Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 11:20

Hello, ladies and gentlemen, and welcome to the discriminating gamer. You know, my wife told me that she'd leave me if I kept bringing kitchen utensils to the office. But, it was a whisk I was willing to take. Ladies and gentlemen, today we're going to go ahead and take a look at Suds and Malone from Crosscut Games.

In Suds and Malone from Crosscut Games, two to four players take on the roles of anthropomorphic mice as they attempt to solve crimes. Yes, these are mice detectives. It's an old trope, and it is adorable. All right, ladies and gentlemen, I'm not going to take a deep dive into the rules here. I'm just going to tell you the basics of gameplay and then tell you what I think. All right, there's a lot going on in the game board. You've got eight locations, you've got a calendar that's going to go ahead and and and be important in certain phases of the game. You have got the conspiracy area where the suspects are going to go. That's right, there's three moles, three frogs, and three rats. And you're also going to have to put some stoolies in there, but before you do that, you're going to put those those moles, rats, and frogs down four of them in the conspiracy, but nobody knows who is where. Now, this is important because this is going to be how you're going to score during the game, and it is going to behoove you over the course of the game to try to figure out who's there. But, you're going to mix in the stoolies, you're going to go ahead, you're going to put them out in the various locations, in the eight locations. You're going to have flimflam cards, and you're going to put those face down in the various locations as well.

Now, on the backs of the flimflam cards, you'll have various currencies in the game. You'll have things like telephones, notebooks, drinks, uh different things that you'll be able to use during the game in order to uh solve crimes and advance. Now, each player is going to get a player board, various tracks on it, and cubes at the bottom, and these are different actions that you can take, and you'll be able to enhance those actions. And you're also going to get a file cabinet, which is just kind of a cardboard strip that you're going to want to have space above and below for cards. Now, what the first player is going to do every round is he's going to roll a pool of dice. You've got black, white, and gray dice, enough for everybody, but then everybody also has a dice in a die in their color. So, you're going to go ahead and roll all of those together, and then you're going to take turns taking a dice action. You can take a die from that die pool and do it. Now, every player can only do one white, one black, and one gray, and then the die of their color. And the die you take, the actions, of course, are represented on your player board with those cubes. Now, the first thing you can do is you can take an office action. When you take an office action, you can move your cube up on any of the different actions. And what that means is as you take those actions in the future, they will become more powerful.

Now, you can take a calendar action. Essentially, you can move your token along the calendar several days toward the end of the week, and whenever you uh go over these uh spaces, you can take all sorts of actions. They will let you do all sorts of interesting things on the board as you are moving forward. They're up to and including gaining points. Now, you can investigate, meaning you have little badge tokens, you can move them around the board. Now, as part of calendar actions, you can put kind of the the little in kind of informants, I think they're called out there. Uh if you land on one that belongs to somebody else, you can pay them a dollar to flip it over and gain whatever token that comes from. If you land on a space that has one of yours, you can just take it. But as you're moving through these card locations, you can take the items that are on the back of those flimflam cards. You can also go ahead and kind of manipulate the flimflam cards onto the conspiracy board.

Now for your fourth action, you can do a flimflam action. So all those flimflam cards that that were kind of transferred to the conspiracy phase, you can actually go ahead, pay the cost for those, and take those and gain whatever reward is printed on them. Now with six, you can do moxie. You can take bullets, which are another currency in the game, and you can roll the die again to take another action. Now if you don't want to do any of those things, you can you can read the news. Essentially, you pay one die, whatever it's faces, and you can get kind of a dollar, you can get a bullet, and you can take one resource. Now once you've taken all your actions, you can actually close a case. So you've got your case cards. Your case cards have kind of various resources you have to spend in order to claim claim them and gain a resource. Now once you close a case, you put it on the top of your file, you put it above your file cabinet. But if you've got one from each of the A, B, or C tabs, so you've got A, B, and C, some cards maybe have two of them. If you've got A, B, and C, you can put it at the bottom and take a hunch card. And these hunch cards are important cuz they're going to help you score at the end of the game. Now generally when you're drawing cards in the game, you're not just drawing a card, you're drawing three cards, and you're looking at the bottom, there may be opportunities to draw more cards if you're willing to pay for resources.

Now at the end of your turn, you discard down to four cards, and you go around. You go till the end of the round when all of the dice are spent. When that happens, there is some bookkeeping, some things get replaced on the board, and then you do it again. In total, you'll be doing these things uh these phases four times. There will be four rounds in the game. Now when the cases solved they go to the bottom of your file cabinet uh they may give you an immediate reward or they may give you a matchbook and the more matchbooks you collect may give you score may help you score at the end of the game. So after the fourth game round you go to scoring. You're going to score whatever tokens you've got left. You're going to score any of those matchbooks that you've got left and you're going to score those hunch cards cuz those hunch cards are going to have points for either the rat, the frog, or the mole. You're going to look at who the suspects were. You're going to score off those cards and whoever has the most points wins.

Suds and Malone. We'll get back to the review in just a moment. I want to take a minute to ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, books on history, military history. I even post some of my lectures for my classes on there. Please check that out. Please subscribe to that channel and now back to the review. All right ladies and gentlemen, Suds and Malone. There's a lot more going on here. I'm just kind of kind of scratching the surface of the game. Now I'll tell you right off the bat there was a bit of a learning curve here. It's not too bad but there were a few things I think our first round we were kind of screwing up on and then once we kind of realized what was going on it it works great. So just just be aware of that. You really want to give a deep reading to the rules before you get into it. There's a lot of stuff there.

Now the game is interesting. At the end of the day it is a mystery game. Essentially you're trying to find out what those suspects are and different game effects at different times may allow you to peek at some of these cards. So if you know what the cards are down here you will kind of know what hunches you want to grab because again you're going to score the hunches based off of who is there. But there's a lot of other ways to score. You're trying to solve those cases. You're going to score for that. You may get points off the calendar. There's a lot of different ways that you're going to score and of course for the resources you have at the end of the game. Um the game itself you know I'm not a huge fan of anthropomorphic animals just generally. I mean I like Robin Hood when I was a kid, the Disney Robin Hood, but it's just kind of I always kind of found it a little creepy. Uh but that being said, I did find the theme here to be kind of fun and appropriate. Um well, when I say appropriate, it's weird because you know, I I don't know if this is really a kids game cuz you've got drinking in it, you've got bullets in it, you know. Uh but at the same time, there's nothing, you know, terribly graphic or or or you know, bad about the game in terms of the theme. It's but it's but it's kind of weird to know exactly who this was geared toward. But the game has a lot of uh interesting choices in it. Uh you're kind of limited to the die, but you're deciding each round, well, which die do I want to take? Uh but you can only do the black die, the gray die, or the white die, and then your colored die during the game.

And so that is that it's very interesting when those choices come up about which one you're going to take and when and when can I defer an action or, you know, do I want to go now or do I want to try to beat someone on the calendar? Um you know, do I do I want to play that action now or do I want to wait for that action later? So it's So it's very it's interesting, and I like games that have this kind of die manipulation and and and what have you. I I I think I think that aspect of the game, the way you're using the die for to to to to to make the decisions is really good. I also really like the player board, how depending on the action you take can be improved during the game. And you're never going to be able to improve everything in one game. So you really from game to game have to decide which actions do you want to maximize cuz they're all important in one way or another, and it's just how do you want, you know, what is your strategy? What do you What kind of points do you want to chase during the game? So I thought that was pretty good as well. Now, overall, uh we all really enjoyed it. We all had a lot of fun with Suds and Malone. It's It's a game that I'll tell you is kind of unusual. It's one of those games that I don't know that I have a lot of games like this in my collection. I don't have a lot of kind of mystery games that that do what this does. I mean at at its heart trying to figure out what those cards are just to score off of the closest thing I can think of is Clue, but even that's very different. But it's it's just kind of fun and every game you play is a little bit different. So I'm going to go ahead I'm going to give Suds and Malone a seven on a seven out of 10 on the Cody scale. I think it is a very fun game. I think if you like the theme you'll really like the mechanisms here.

It's a lot of fun. Thank you once again ladies and gentlemen for joining us today on the discriminating gamer. As always we'd ask you to please leave a comment here on YouTube on BoardGameGeek on our Facebook page on X. We'd love to hear back from you. I'd love to hear what you have to say about these games or anything else you want to comment on. Please like this video and subscribe to our YouTube channel. And if you do really like what we do here on the discriminating gamer I would humbly ask you to check out my other channel that is Cody Carlson PhD where we talk about history, military history, books on history, fun things like that. I even post some of my lectures on that channel. Please check that out and subscribe. It would mean the world to me. And if you do really like what you see here I would humbly ask you to click on the super thanks button and leave a tip. You know, I'm thinking of switching all of my shoelaces to Velcro.

I mean, why not?

[screaming]

So this time I'm like didn't really mix it up any more than I messed it up for myself. Wow, there's a lot of sixes on there.

Progress saved