Skip to main content
Loading video...

Nova Luna: Review by AYCB (2020 Spiel des Jahres Nominee)

Transcript 9:16

hey everyone Carlo here with a ycb and today I'm going to be reviewing Nova Luna which is a 1 to 4 player abstract tile laying game it has simple rules and very few components but a surprising amount of depth and complexity to each turn and decision if you don't know how to play yet check out our how to play video before going any further otherwise stick around let me tell you what I think about Nova Luna first off I have to say noble Luna really surprised me it sounds a bit crazy to say that because it's a newbie Rosenberg game and I expect the very best remove a Rosenberg he's one of my favorite designers but I have to say when I first saw this on BoardGameGeek a few months back I took a look at just the way the game played and everything I didn't have the highest expectations for it or I maybe wasn't the most interested in it maybe because I have quite a few of these kind of light to light medium gateway style kind of abstract games that accommodate you know two to four players so to me at first it felt like I have a lot of games kind of like this so I've dismissed it a bit then I was lucky enough to see it for about 30 bucks before this whole pandemic started I managed to get in a four player game and lately I've been playing at a ton of two-player games with my wife and we absolutely love it we're surprised by how good it is how quick it plays and how much we're compelled to come back to it even though we feel like we've kind of figured out what's going on in the game and seen all there is to see to an extent but it still keeps pulling us in

a couple other quick things I'd like to mention before I get into what I do and don't like about the game the first thing is this was just recently nominated for the spiel des jahres award the other thing I'd like to mention is that ube Rosenberg right in the rulebook he credits Corden a van more cell for the idea for the game basically corn a van more cell released a game in 2016 called habitats and this kind of plays off that idea so and corn even more so was nice enough to let veer Rosenberg kind of play off this idea in his own design now since there's a lot I like about this game I'm gonna start with what I don't like as much the first thing it's not that I hate it but I would say the art working components is sort of just average personally again if I saw this on you know I went to a game store and there were games all over the shelves this might not catch my eye right away the quality of the components is pretty good I mean the tiles are thick enough cardboard and whatnot the colors are nice enough but it's it's all fairly simple fairly stripped down the one thing I specifically don't like about the components is these player discs they're a little bit too small I finally get knocked around pretty easily and even just when you're tracking them on the moon wheel and you like sometimes they slip out of your fingers or if you're trying to stack you know three or four on the same spot the stack and tip over easily other than that not really any serious complaints about the artwork and components another complaint I have though is just the theme I mean this is the case with a lot of abstract games some do it better than others but it's basically just a very loose kind of moon

theme without really feeling like you're doing a whole lot involving the moon I guess they've kind of incorporated the whole new moon thing with the wheel and the cycles and you know the way that the tiles get refreshed and it's kind of like a new moon but it still just kind of feels tacked on it's tacked on well enough and it doesn't really draw away from the game for me but if you're the tired person who's looking for some sort of thematic ties it's going to be very very minimal here my last criticism of the game is comes down to basically the box size and the price of the game so as I said before I was lucky enough to pick this up it wasn't even on sale is just regular price about three four months ago for I think it was like 30 32 bucks Canadian then it went out of stock a lot of places for a while I just checked today and everywhere now is between 45 and 50 Canadian I've seen it for upwards of 50 bucks u.s. and I mean this is a tiny box very few components I can basically hold everything in my hands you could fit this all into a pouch basically for a travel game aside from you know the Moon wheel which is also kind of unnecessarily big if I was rating this as like a $30 game or $25 game $20 game it's amazing I would never pay 45 or 50 dollars for this and it's a shame because I think some people are gonna see the price tag and they're gonna take a pass on it because not many people want to spend upwards of 45 50 bucks on a fairly light kind of abstract game with not much theme when you open the box you're gonna be surprised there's all the components and everything take

up maybe about a quarter of the box and you know I've read some speculation online that they might have done this on purpose to allow for expansions in the future for more variability so you can have it all in one box and if that's the case then you know you might be actually happy about that if you plan on getting the expansions but it also feels kind of odd that it by a game and I don't want to get the expansion's that you know 75% of the box is empty and it's taking up spot on my shelf and obviously I say this is someone who loves to own a lot of games so this might not be a problem for everyone I don't think it's fair to call it a criticism but just be aware that you could fit all the components for this aside from this giant Moon wheel which doesn't really need to be this big you could fit this in a much smaller package so it just seems like a bit of wasted space now let's get to what I do like which I like a lot about this game actually there's quite a few similarities to patchwork which you might have noticed if you're familiar with patchwork the whole aspect of the you know the player who's furthest back on the track getting to go I really like how that mixes up the turn order there are times where you take a turn and you might grab a tile with a six or a seven on it that moves you way far up the board and depending how many players there are you might not get a turn for six seven turns you might watch the same players going back and forth taking turns as you're way far ahead on the track waiting for them to catch up so it adds a layer of sort of unpredictability and and also variability of the game I'd also have to praise the accessibility of the game not only is it super easy to teach only takes a couple minutes really it plays really quickly and it's different like a truly different game at all player counts with two players it's a lot more strategic because every time

the Moon wheel is filled you get to see those eleven tiles and have an idea of you know you might be able to see that you're probably gonna get four or five of those tiles or six of those tiles out of those eleven before it gets refilled so you can kind of plan and see what what you want a bit more let's say on the extreme of four players you might only get you know two of those tiles on the Moon wheel and you might not even know when you take the first one what's even going to be available to you next time it comes around so I find at hire players it's more tactical you're having to sort of change what you're doing on the fly and adapt to the the constantly changing state and there's a lot longer between your turns so you just kind of have to take what the best option is for you each time rather than planning ahead there's also a pretty neat solo mode which kind of plays the game in two phases I won't get into it too much but basically it's a good way it seems to kind of you know learn that learn the basics of the game and improve your efficiency of you know how many goals you're completing versus how much you're advancing on on the time track I really like how there is no score this and it's kind of a race but it's a race of efficiency who's doing the better job of optimizing their choices on the moon wheel as well as completing goals and leaving openings to add on other tiles to complete more goals there's again for a game that really just has these tiles and these disks that show you to complete your goals there's a surprising amount to think about on your turn it's not often that I feel so compelled to come back to a game so soon after I feel like I've kind of seen everything there is to see you know after two or three plays it's

not like you're gonna unlock some new game breaking strategy the fact that I've played this five six seven times and I still want to keep playing it is a good sign that I think it really does have some some serious lasting power another thing that makes these choices so difficult is that you a lot of the time feel like you're encouraged to you know prioritize tiles of the same color if you have a bunch of let's say red tiles all lined up then you know that any tile you take that requires let's say two or three red tiles you can place it next there and you might have these goals already completed so sometimes you feel like oh I'm just gonna get a lot of reds but usually when you have a tile of a certain color the goal requirements are often telling you to get tiles of different colors so if you you know try and be too picky about just going for one or two colors you're gonna have a lot of unresolved goals so there's that kind of balance of do you want to sort of prioritize one a little more to have one easy chain or do you want to go kind of spread yourself out in all the colors and again it really depends because you might refill the moon wheel and suddenly there's only one yellow tile and you banked on getting a whole bunch and now you got to completely switch things up and start grabbing tiles of different colors that's pretty much all I've got to say about Nova Luna I highly recommend you check this one out if you're into these abstract kind of games if you're looking for another kind of gateway style game to add to your collection this is a great choice you can't go wrong with it thanks for watching if you like what you see please hit the subscribe button you can check out our website at all you can board comm for any more info or follow us on social yeah thanks and see you again next time

Progress saved