Eric's Silas Marsh Innsmouth Conspiracy Deck Retrospective | ARKHAM HORROR: THE CARD GAME
Transcript
Hello everybody and welcome to the deck retrospective for Eric and Eric's blind run through the ends of the conspiracy. We're going to be talking about Salis Marsh and also Ursula downs here kind of talking about the deck, what worked, what didn't work. Um, and we're going to also be careful not to spoil because we um just finished the final uh scenario here,
but this video is coming out before the final scenario. So, we're going to not talk about how they did in the last scenario, but we're going to kind of talk about the decks as a whole, what how we feel they did. Just a classic little retrospective here. And we'll start with your Silus deck. Eric, I'll let you take it away. So, with Silus, uh, one thing I discovered was that Silus is very much just a strong, good value character. Uh, I really enjoyed playing him. This was my first time also just kind of being like, mythos deck, okay,
and just soaking it. And it actually worked uncomfortably well. Like you just suffer and it's fine.
Yeah. You just you just have a little bit of hardship, but then you get through it and you're like, "Wait a minute. Should I have just always been having that hardship?"
Yeah.
Like, is that the right way?
Yeah, 100%. Um, so I thought Silus was really Silus was a really good character. I really enjoyed playing him. Um, I I definitely felt like he was uh if if I was to make a comparison, I prefer playing mono black, but this definitely felt like a red deck wins where you're just like, I'm just going to keep doing stuff and as long as I keep doing stuff, I'm going to keep winning and I'm just going to outtempo everyone else cuz I just don't stop.
Can I ask you a question? Yes. from previous discussions that we've had on this channel, you often say that you find the most comfort in both in magic, but then also it translates to Arkham when you can have like you can relate it to like a mono colored strategy or alternatively you prefer mono color in magic. Yes. You often say for example like when you watch me play a rogue deck, it's watching like like a blue black combo deck or like a band combo deck and you're like I can't freick with that.
Yeah. Would you say that Silus worked for you because you felt that he was just basically like you knew what to do with his resources and you didn't have to think that hard about it?
Yeah, 100% 100%. He's just he's just outvalue everything. And if you can't outv value everything, you die. But don't worry, you just have more value.
Yeah,
it's it was really really good. So, the first thing I did to do that was based on Silus's net and sea chain and harpoon, I put in anchor chain and I put in hand hook. And I have to say, all the way till the end of the game, I never felt like it was necessary to get rid of either of these.
They always felt good. It felt like what I like what I had was I had three of Silus's net and three of um Silus's harpoon
in worse versions, significantly worse versions,
but because they were only three bucks, because I was very cheap as a deck. Yeah.
I never felt bad throwing them out. I never felt bad using them from hand. I never felt bad throwing one out to replace it with the actual net or the actual harpoon and it just got me there and that's all I wanted to do with it.
Yeah. Just it did the job enough while you waited for the real things.
Yes.
The real thing being sledgehammer level three.
Yeah.
So I I do see the argument that sledgehammer without the upgrade is sometimes better. The two action versus the three action is good. Mhm.
But I actually found that the one action was good enough in the Silus deck to get me where I needed to go.
Yeah, the top actions. Yeah, you you sacrifice a bit of that like utility and versatility of the bottom action and Silus probably could with skills get through it,
but just having that top action to just work it is really nice. which was also why I enjoyed having the hook and the anchor chain because you can just discard them from hand
to basically have a hidden third hand if you need it.
So, I was like, I'm actually feeling really comfortable with running this this very slow sledgehammer because it doesn't feels like it's slowing me down. It feels like it's actually winning the action economy.
So, that was really interesting for me. And those were my entire weapon suite. That was everything I needed.
Yeah. So you uh for context at home there was uh these were how you killed. So 1 2 3 4 five cards in the deck killed and then there was three that was like enemy management in the form of evasion. So pretty good spread like eight cards in your deck, right? Eight of the 30 cards. Well 33 cards. So technically 34 cuz Silus has two signatures.
Um but like yeah it's like a good spread and you found one and you were able to make it work. And of course, we also know stylus can just work with skill cards as well, which I'm sure you're going to talk about once you get to your skill cards as we get through here as well.
Absolutely. So, the next thing I put in relatively late, but I was really happy with it every time it showed up was the black cat.
Uh, black hat is just good soak. It's also a two wild icon if you want to throw it away after you've got one already in play. And I love that its ability is basically a form of token fixing that doesn't play with bless or
curse.
And that it's just there to help smooth out any problems you might be able to have.
Yeah.
So just having this in there with Silus just felt really good. Every time I drew the black cat, I was like, "Okay, I'm safe."
Yeah. And the nice thing about your deck and black cat as well is that I don't think it ever happened where you exchanged your elder sign for this one cuz Silus's elder sign is so good.
So good. But it means that like you have the draw in theory that if the first one dies, you have the resources and the action available to just play the second one.
100%. Yeah,
I do see why it's a five experience card, but being able to just declare that two of the big dangerous tokens.
Yeah. Or just just minus ones. Yeah,
we actually played so hard. Spoilers. We actually played so hard that some of this stopped mattering as much.
Yes, it's true. Y
but it still felt great to have. Yes.
And a three three soak. I'm happy to pay 10 experience for it by the time I get there.
Yeah. Yeah.
Uh so the next one I played was Grizzled. We're getting into my skills now. And so Grizzled um is a very interesting card. Felt incredibly strong.
You love you loved this card.
I loved this card. I committed it to everything I could. Uh despite what it says, I chose humanoids, not humans.
Um terror and monster. So I immediately went to try and get three. um uh traits.
Yeah. I think what you did is you put the monster on as penance for your sins. Yes. Like penitence for your sins of just being like I think I committed this to something that wasn't a humanoid and you're like I want to fix that. So you just put the XP in right away.
Yeah, 100%. Cuz I did accidentally mess it up. I will say it's very much a tech that you should know what your what what the the pool is going to be like. And so in a very mixed pool, I think this would be a lot weaker.
Yeah. So that one's very interesting for Grizzle. The choices that are usually the default good ones are humanoid or monster. Those are like in every campaign. And then terror and like hex are usually pretty good ones as well.
Yeah. I I ended up choosing scheme. I don't think it ever came up. But
no. So I think a funny thing is cuz you bought the always prepared um to return them to your hand.
But I actually think once you put that XP in your deck, you never ran into the grizzleds needing to be necessary again. Just like it's like 5 XP to just like rise above the mythos deck. like just as a person. Yeah.
Yeah, 100%. But I really really enjoyed it. I especially enjoyed it with Silus. Silus makes it feel really good to always be gambling with a card, just be putting it out there to see what happens.
I was going to say that I think that you played that part of Silus really well where you weren't worried about like the concept of losing the card. Like you were just like, I'm going to just throw this out here. Even like one where it only like put you up two. you were like, "Yeah, I'm gonna still put this out here because I either pass the test and get rid of it or I fail the test and I can like keep it, right?" So, it worked really well for that.
Yeah, exactly. I think Silus really plays well when you are Yeah. when you're in that mindset of just try it.
Yep. Just try it.
What's the harm?
Yep.
So, yeah, Grizzle did really well. I pumped it full of experience. Barely got any value out of it, but I loved it. Uh, I put in Unrelenting. Uh, Unrelenting is a hard card for me to understand. Um, I only used it a few times to good effect. Uh, but I really enjoyed it when I did. And being able to pull it back with Silus was kind of silly.
Yeah. So, this is like one of the weird like advanced stylus cards where you have to like go all in and like Silus has like he's kind of like Luke where he levels up once you learn like timing windows, right? And like how certain cards work. less about timing windows for Silus, but more but still kind of the same because how it works is like when is the effect on the card active and when is it not active and it's a very interesting kind of thing to learn with Unrelenting and Silus.
Yeah. And it was and it was really really good when I needed card draw, but there were very few times I needed card draw. So I often didn't feel like I needed to do weird plays with it. And so I could also occasionally just play it straight with just locking in the tokens I didn't want to see.
Yeah. Which was really cool. We'll see. I will say that this one got through the gates a lot. I think it was like two scenarios back to back where got through the gates.
True.
I I also think that uh the nature of your Silus deck, which was relying more on the sledgehammer as your weapon,
um me meant that you weren't as hardressed on the resources in your hand because like you could just hit with the sledgehammer and be able to beat most things where a lot of silos decks like Unrelenting because it lets them draw back up after spending out their whole hand to kill like a big boss monster. Makes perfect sense to me.
Yeah. And I could see unrelenting was great. Uh the next one I put in was Daring.
Uh another card I absolutely loved. Committed to everything I could all the time, anytime.
Yep.
Um
Eric's not lying there.
Yeah. I It's just It's It's three good cards. If you fail the shot, you're already wasting a skill card. Like here's here's my point on on on daring.
Mhm.
You're already wasting the shot. Um, you want to draw one card?
Why are you worried about uh retaliate?
Just go.
Just go.
Just go for it.
Yep.
Also, enemies can't get double retaliate. So, if they already have it, this is just plus three and draw a card.
Exactly. Yeah.
So, just do it
cuz if you miss it, things already suck. Yep.
So, just just hit. Just hit. Especially with sledgehammer. This was really really fun to throw in to just be like up eight.
Yes.
For no reason. Um, overpower always just a good card.
Yeah, these kind of live in the same space for your deck. Yeah, they're kind of like the same
the better version of Daring.
Yeah.
Uh, Dauntless Spirit was a late ad and I wish I had chosen it from the very beginning. Dauntless Spirit was so much fun. It was the only bit of protection against the mythos that I had and I mostly played it against you.
Yeah. Well, no, you also have the um the grizzled.
Oh, right. But it shows that like for keeping yourself safe, four of those is really nice.
That's all you needed. And the best part was that these kept you safe as well.
Yes. You were able to commit them to me.
That was huge.
Which was uh very relevant during the course of that campaign.
Brute force I nearly cut several times and I'm so glad I didn't because brute force came in handy so often. It was such a good It's not, in my opinion, a standard Silus card because you never want to pull it back, but oh, is it good to just deal three damage for one action and to go up uh three to hit?
It's so good.
Can I offer an an interesting perspective that you might not have thought about for Salos and brute force of why Salos is probably one of the best users of it?
Oh,
it's because he ensures that it triggers.
True.
Other people you could potentially miss with it. like you could like not succeed by three, but if that happens with Silus, you say, "You know what? I'm just gonna run it back. I'm just gonna take it back and then try for it again."
Yeah, actually that's a really good point. Yeah.
But yeah, no, it is it is uh very strong punch.
Yeah. And I mean, it does have to be, as you mentioned, higher than two. Yeah.
But with so much of what else Silus is doing, it often feels like this plus daring.
Yeah. You're five. You're five. Sorry, you're six actually. So like that's that's a huge number to get to.
Huge. Huge. Uh oh, Strongarmed. I loved Strong Armed.
I'm sure it's just a good card overall,
but it's so good. The second half clause is good, but it doesn't even matter compared to how the first half clause is.
A card that just says if you're using a weapon, add one damage and one fist.
Mhm.
For no cost.
Yeah. It's like vicious blow. And Silus, the thing that Silus was really missing was a vicious blow type card to get him to really just have that extra little damage hump to beat with weapons. Yeah.
So, Strong Arm is very nice in him for that reason.
Absolutely. I think it's such a good card.
No complaints. Uh, Stunning Blow was funny. I didn't use it very often, but when I did,
Yeah. it was very good as well. Yeah.
Yeah. Uh, the fact that it doesn't target, it doesn't specify uh a non- elite enemy.
Yep. So, you can use it to lock down bosses on the attack. Yep.
Huge. very good for that.
Yeah. Most important part of it in my opinion.
Yeah. Oh, 100%.
Yeah. Um I put in resourceful. Uh it was good. It's just a good card. Um I basically only used it for the purpose of recurring when I was already pretty sure I was going to be up. But again, with Silus, if you're only going up one or two, try
Yep.
Just try it out. Try and get a good card back.
Yep.
And so that was my entire skill pool.
Yeah. So yeah, actually a good thing to always look at is how much were in each of these. Um, and I think also it was really cool to see what you prioritized in bringing back with resourceful because it kind of shifted as the game went, right? In the early game, you would bring back Grizzled all the time, which I think was the right choice. And then later in the game, you would start bringing back like brute force or uh even like unrelenting depending on what you needed at the time. So it was like cool to see that shift as the game changed and got even like a stunning blow bringing that back at the right time.
Mhm.
Man, yeah, you do have a lot of your silos deck. So you have 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 16 18.
Yeah.
Yeah. 18 skills, which is So then of our 34 cards, we have then eight assets to kill with. So we're looking at the last little bit here. But really good um balance of skills that we see in this Silus deck here. Yeah. And I will say also that Silus was able to get off the ground really effectively with very little experience. Y
which is like I I put in some cherish keep shakes sakes. I only had them blow up once.
I did at one point throw one away just so that it didn't get exiled.
Very smart move
which is very fun. Uh just a good card to have cuz it kind of rounds out your it puts you as a 99. Yeah.
Which is you know with flying and death touch is just
Yeah. pretty pretty strong.
Pretty strong. Um, and then this is why I bring up the Silus has so much XP. So, if you've noticed, I had I I mentioned at least three cards that I sunk about 20 XP into and barely used.
And this is one of them. I bought this and never ever played it or drew it.
Yeah. So, some slight spoilers for the final scenario. This is what Eric put in leading into the final scenario and they just didn't show up. So, it's not like they were there early and just never came to be, but it was just like this was going to the final scenario just the way the deck did. Uh, these never came into play there. But yeah, Sal is very low to the ground and uh the ex I mean survivors in general are so that's the nice thing about them is they can make it work with little but then they scale they don't really like the idea is they don't scale up as much but because Silus has the ability to recur things it kind of makes him able to scale up
and it did feel that way like if you'll notice I ran no economy
y
I never felt a need to I was low to the ground for cost I was low to the ground for XP cost
and so it just felt like halfway through the campaign I was like, "Okay, Silus is done. Like everything else is gravy, and all I need to do now is focus on core gameplay loops to be able to just win consecutively."
Yeah. And uh I think also this is the first of these deck retrospectives where there's not some cards that you were like, "Yeah, I put these in. They just didn't like Yeah. They never did anything." So I feel like this was a very uh I think this is like the first deck that you took and you were just like you made it work completely without like any weaknesses. I see no weaknesses in that Silus deck.
Yeah, it felt really good.
All right. And coming with Silus was Ursula DS, who I brought in with the perspective of not joking around because we talked about this when we were doing our Hemlock Veil re uh retrospective for our decks where it was very much of a I think I'm letting Eric down with some of the decks that I'm bringing. So, I said, I'm just going to bring a tryh hard deck for the next scenario, for the next campaign rather, and this deck tried very hard and it succeeded very well. Uh, I believe that Ursula is very good in two-player because her ability effect like practically empties half a location for most of the locations in the game. I think she loses some of her sauce when she goes up to higher like levels for that, but at two-player, she's smooth like butter. Uh, and then I also brought into Ursula my favorite archetype, which is the steadyhanded precision archetype for the seeker class. This is something that I think I might actually have a problem because chemistry set and steady-handed have just been going into like the majority of my decks because what do I love more than anything else in Arkham? Value. I just like it when you can turn something that is there every turn into value. And as you can attest to, Eric, I did do that in this campaign where I would take an action and like get two clues, draw a
card, get a resource, like just every every turn.
Spoilers, I won't say which one it's for, but at one point Justin drew seven cards. Got two clues and at least $2.
Yeah. And I moved across the map.
And moved across the map.
In one turn. Yeah.
In one turn. And moved four squares minimum.
Yeah. Oh, and and push the objective forward.
Yes. And I Yeah, I did push the objective. Yeah.
Uh so, uh this the precision archetype uh got some support in Drown City. So, these are both from Hemlock, but they got further support in Drown City in the form of artistic inspiration, which is kind of like an alternative version of steadyhanded, but also the Antiitha, which is I I before I played it, uh Daniel from Quick Learner told me the card was very strong, and I believed him. I believed him. But if it's somehow possible, I now double believe him that it's very strong because this card was just insane. Like it's just so much value for one card to turn everything you do into either a free clue or a free upkeep or a free action. The the what's the wildest part about this card for how good it is is the fact that the bottom action where you get a free action is the one that I was least excited to trigger. Like that's how you know the card is good when these ones are like the first two which is just get it up, keep guard card in a resource or get a clue. Turing those every turn is just nuts. With that said though, I don't think the anti is busted. I think for 5 XP that's a pretty good effect for what it does. Um but the card's absolutely wild. Well, I think what's interesting about this card, too, is that it absolutely plays into a particular archetype,
and that it passively gains value, which is great, but it passively gains value while taking up a slot. There's nothing you can do with the antitherror to activate it.
Y,
unless you are playing a bunch of support, so I think that helps control it. Yeah, you can try to like just hope you get something. And you're probably it's probably okay to just play the antiro without any of this stuff. But this allowed me to trigger what I wanted when I wanted to, which was made it better than just like as you said, it takes a slot. It It's just value and that's good. But if you're building around something else in that accessory slot, you could probably do better.
Yeah.
But if you're doing this, it's very good.
Oh, yeah. And consistent.
Then I also had a one of lab coat, which kind of fits into this archetype, but it never actually really did anything. Um, and I kind of regret putting it in, but I was like, I'm going to wear this L. This is So, this was me making the mistake of being like, I could be a little bit silly. I could be a little bit silly. I've played this card in lots of decks, and it's always been awful. And I think I just need to accept that I should stop playing it and trying it out, but what can you do? All right, so that's the precision archetype that we had in this deck here. But I also had uh some Ursula things in the form of free movement uh when I was putting this deck together. So this is actually kind of funny how um little there is here for the free movement, but how much I was moving freely in the campaign when we were when we were doing our putting our decks in the order we wanted to talk about them. Um having like this, oh, I this is it. This is all I had. This is all I had here. but for how much it actually felt the impact uh for what they did.
Well, and part of the craziness of that was it was because of how well you fixed your deck. You just drew till you found what you wanted, and that was often Pathfinder.
Yes. Yeah. Oh, speaking of going back to the last ones, I had a relic hunter to deal with having both the uh chemistry set and the antither in play. Okay.
Which was just a little bit extra gravy. Not necessarily needed. Like you could just turn the chemistry sets into the antitherra, but I wanted both. God damn it. Um, additionally to follow up with this Ursula thing, we had some abilities to investigate with the because it's just taking investigate action. So, it could be a basic or you could do a burning the midnight oil oil or a seeking answers too, which I've actually been playing a lot of this card uh more uh and it's actually pretty impressive. Um, it's it's gone up in my uh how I rate cards.
Every time I saw it, it was generally uh it was like, "Oh, okay. We're going to get ahead of the camp of the of the scenario now." Yep. Yep. All right. Uh, next up, we're going to call the tryhard pile. The things that just made my decks super consistent and super good while also being maybe a little bit boring, but I said tier, if you will,
but or D tier on your tier list.
Uh, two copies of Studius to make sure so my hand was loaded with what I wanted at the start of each scenario.
Two copies of magnifying glass just to make myself good at investigating. So just to confirm this, the way Studioius works is you start with one additional card, but then you still get to mulligan, right?
Yes. So you're mulling with seven cards as opposed to five. So you can see 14 cards of your deck as opposed to 10.
So you can touch half your deck.
Yes, pretty much.
To decide what you need.
Yeah, it's pretty good.
That's busted.
Yep. Uh we got two Dr. Blondon Christophers, just ally of choice to just get the job done. Uh we had two upgraded perceptions because I'm a Justin deck, so I'm going to have two upgraded perceptions. That's a rule. I have to follow it. Um, and then I had two copies of Cryptic Research to just draw cards fast. I gave them to Eric sometimes, but I took them for myself a lot, too. But this is just the pile of boring stuff. And like, so you might be saying, "Where's the fun stuff?" And it was the broken stuff I was doing with all this stuff. So there, that's where the fun's going to stop.
The fun stops at value, kids.
Yes. Uh, my one economy card.
Yeah. I mean, I had the burning the midnight oils as well.
You had the burning midnight, but the reality is once things got settled, this was giving me a lot of juice to make sure I was able to buy what I wanted to buy when I wanted to buy it. Uh, we had two deductions to just get more clues. And this is what we're going to call the weird pile, which was like some interesting choices that I think they all impacted the game. Um, Eye of Truth was put in for the last scenario, so we only saw it there. just cuz I had five experience and didn't know what to put in. I had an existential riddle. I added that to replace the transmogriphies. Um, as again as part of my forward drive to just make sure these decks won, I went hard in the first scenario uh for also enemy management to deal with the deep one bulls. The transmogriphies left, but the existential riddle was upgraded out of one of them. And then I had this extensive research uh to something to you for me to spend my resources on just to get some clues. I played this uh pretty much every scenario. I had it in the my hand for some of them that never never saw a play, but because that's a sign that you didn't need it if it was just in your hand because you were just getting enough clues with all your other tricks.
But overall, I think this is one of the strongest decks I've played in a while. And it was very fun because it was just fun to take a test and then turn five cards sideways
and draw five more cards.
Like it was just uh that's kind of what it's all about.
Yeah.
All right. Let me cut off your head again. All right. Well, thanks for watching everybody. I hope you enjoyed this. Uh the final scenario should be coming out this week and then next week we're going to be doing Eric's Inmith uh thoughts on the Inmouth campaign. So, look forward to that. But in the meantime, thank you so much for watching. I want to do a huge shout out to all of our patrons. There we go. Eric's back. Uh, you guys all rock. Uh, our next campaign that we're going to be doing is Edge of the Earth. I don't know when that campaign is going to start on the channel, but keep your eyes for it. Uh, and we're going to have a great time playing that one, too. So, thanks for watching everybody. Have a good one. And as always, the GG's.