Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hobbit: There and Back Again Board Game Review

Transcript 19:33

Embark on an unexpected journey full of dwarves, spiders, a magic ring, and a dragon in The Hobbit. There, and back again.

And we have a copy we're giving away on today's video. So, keep watching and we'll share with you how you can enter for a chance to win this copy. Thank you for joining us at Tantrum House Studio D. I'm Melissa Dul

and I'm Kevin Dulp the Hobbit. There and back again is a roll and write game for one to four players that's designed by Riner Kenitzia and published by Office Dog. It's a division of Asthma.

Now the publisher sent us this copy to review.

In this video, we're going to give a quick overview of the game and then discuss our opinions. The Hobbit, there and back again consists of eight roll and write adventure maps that each take about 30 minutes to play.

Each adventure gives specific details about where to start and how to score points and what triggers the end of the game. In general, these are some of the things that you'll encounter.

In most adventures, you'll be drafting dice to gain resources or movement paths. You take turns selecting dice until the draft pool is empty, and then the next player rolls. When you select a path die, you have to draw it connected to an approved start space or a path you've already drawn. You can even overlap paths.

Usually, you're trying to enter certain spaces to collect rewards, connect to spaces, or surround spaces.

Some spaces reward the first player to complete a task with extra points.

In some adventures, there will be costs or requirements needed to enter certain spaces or complete tasks. The black d12 can be another hurdle. On some maps, you roll it each round with the regular dice to determine which spaces are negatively affected. Sometimes you can spend a specific resource to ignore the effects.

In two adventures, you use the d12 instead of the regular dice. In these, the die roll determines everyone's option. There's no drafting. Each map has a specific end condition that will immediately trigger the end of the game. Once that condition is met, everyone totals their points. The left page of the book walks you through the scoring. The player with the most points wins.

Now, that was a quick overview. We're going to separate this review portion into our four C's. Our thoughts about the components, our critiques, our accommodations, and finally, our conclusions. So, let's start with the components. So, one of the main components in the game are these player books. There's four of them in the box. Um, overall, I like that they're thick. It is interesting though that ours are bowing a little bit. I don't know how that will do over time. It's not It's not bad right now and they open up fine, but I'm wondering, you know, in a year, what will these look like?

Now, they are dry erase, so it comes with dry erase markers and so far those have been working really well.

Yeah. So, another thing about the boards is that each adventure page has most of the rules on it and the scoring. So, a lot of the information is available to each player. And I really like that the player aids are basically built into the pages that you're using. And, you know, 80 to 90% of what you need is already right there.

And I like the books themselves. They the artwork's cool. It's different. It's Yeah, it's a fun

It's thematic to the uh the book that Bilbo writes.

Correct. And you're going through the story, which is nice, too.

Yeah. Talking more about the rules. I thought that the rule book did a really good job. It has the basic rules up at the front and then it has a two-page spread for each adventure part. So, part one has everything that you need to know for that specific adventure. if you already know the the base mechanics and

and any clarifying stuff that you might

clarifying and it's laid out the same way each time. So, the information is in the same spot. It's very um organized, which I really appreciate that I could look to this one page and very quickly get whatever I needed for that specific adventure.

Uh, another components in the game are the dice. You have a d12, normal d12. I think what is interesting are the custom six-sided dice. Uh three of them are different paths.

Mhm.

And they have, you know, one or two different paths that you can um draw. So yeah, lots of different ways that you can draw the paths, which are cool, of course. Sometimes you want the shorter ones, sometimes you want the longer ones depending on what you're trying to accomplish. The other ones are um hats, swords, and uh the the bread. So, kind of resources.

Yeah, the read there are more resources. Now, it is interesting u for some of the campaigns sometimes you're rolling a certain icon and it actually says, well, use this instead. Like one of them are the pine cones. It's like there's not pine cones on these,

right?

But it's interesting. That's like, okay, well, use the bread when you roll bread, do this instead. So, I think that's fine.

Um, and I think it works really well, easily, um, understandable. and the tokens of the cardboard tokens. You do have the pine cones that you use in one of the stories when you're throwing them at the wolves. Um the wargs, sorry. And uh but the bread and the swords you use a lot in the game. And it's nice that they're nice and thick and it's not like you're in a lot of games when you're doing a dry erase, you're um writing those resources on your board or something like that. It's nice that there are tokens. I like that. So that you're collecting them and you're using them throughout the game.

So cool. Well, why don't we move on to our critiques? Okay, so my main critique is that all of the chapters basically have an immediate end trigger. So in essence, it makes each chapter a race. And my wonderful husband here, when he is playing a race game, that's his goal to finish first. even though I want to it is a competitive game but I want to you know keep gaining things and collecting things and I'm usually playing the long game and a little too late I realize that Kevin is five steps away from the end and I go oh no I need to speed up so there's a race element that I have to think about in each of the games

I mean there's a start and there's a finish to what what are you supposed to finish. I will say I think the game mechanics lend more towards my game style.

I appreciate that because I on average probably have won more games than have lost games on these.

So Kevin can finish first and still lose depending on how things

Melissa has won games that I have finished first.

It has happened not that often. No, I'm we and it is interesting. I think there was one game where I finished

first and you were like really close to winning. If I hadn't ended,

then you probably would have won. So, you know, I was planning on that.

Kevin's a good racer.

I'm a good eraser. Um, I will say since it is this race mechanic, the there's a start and there's a finish. A lot of the um chapters feel maybe if you want to say syy, it might be a word to use. Very similar in what you're doing. You're drafting dice and you're basically drawing paths from one end to the other. You they all have different themes for different chapters, but it's like, oh, in essence, what are you doing? You're going from start to finish. Now, two of the chapters, four and six, just use a D12 that does sort of throw, you know, a little bit difference, and I like that with the more Tetrisy feel to it. But even those two,

right, I felt that those two chapters felt different than the others, but they were similar to each other.

Mhm. Yeah. So, I would say just be aware even though it is 12 different eight different chapters, there is very similar things going on. Um, another slight critique, not not a big issue or deal, is that the drafting chapters, there's five dice and you're playing one to four players. So, it's not an even draft, but you do draft all the dice. So,

different people have a different number of dice during that round.

And then,

one or two you normally,

right? And it can be a little confusing as to who is supposed to roll the dice for the next round because you're kind of, you know, if you're just not thinking, you're like, "Oh, I rolled last time. The player to my left rolls the next time." But that's not how it works. It's whoever was supposed to draft next and there's no dye for that person. That's the person who rolls. That way, people are getting the right amount of dice as the game goes around. It was a small hiccup in one of the games and I think it's it was like sixth, seventh, eighth game we had played. We just weren't thinking and realized halfway through, oh, we've just been doing it

or like turnise instead of the correct person rolling because we

weren't thinking about it properly. We were a little distracted. So, that's just a minor critique of something that you have to be careful of and pay attention to of who is actually supposed to be rolling for the next round.

Um, our last critique before we get to the things we like our combinations. The name of the game is The Hobbit and back again.

This is not a real critique. At least not for me.

Well, your critique was about erasing, so I get to have my own critique and you can have your own critiques. Totally fine. Uh so there and back again it is based off of the story. The I will say the climax of the story is you know in Dale when they defeat Smog which you get in this but the name is there and back again. You get there but you never get back again in this uh in the game. Ke Kevin needs an additional ninth chapter where you are boringly just walking back to the sh

to finish.

All you have to do is go from Dale back to the the shire.

Collect your gold from the troll.

I could actually see it working a little day. You know, you just got a little. It's It's not the climax, which is okay. Every story has to have a climax, but it doesn't have to be the end. So, I'm saying a ninth chapter, maybe an expansion. There you go, office dog. Just a small expansion that's like here's the ninth chapter so that it completes there and back again.

All right, so let's move into our commendations. One of the things that I really like about this game is that it is not a campaign. It has eight different chapters, eight different games, but you don't have to play them in order. you can sit down and just play your favorite uh adventure maps. So, there's no locking you in to have to play it with the same people eight times or have to play one to unlock something in number two. They are completely standalone options for your gameplay. So, I really enjoyed that out of the game.

Um I like the flexibility in the game. So, you are drafting dice and sometimes you may not get exactly what you want or maybe the path that you're collecting is too long and you're like, I just really want to get to this spot. Well, the game in the rules allows you to actually draw over lines that you've already made so that the die that you're or the path die that you're using is actually the right shape,

right? Because you do have to draw the full shape.

Yeah. Yeah. You can't be like, I'm just taking the one spot. I don't want to do the other spot. you actually have to draw it all correctly. But that flexibility of drawing the path over what you've already drawn, I think that gives that, you know, a little bit more flexibility. And there on the uh in the books, there's more flexibility in the way you can use wizard hats. So, you're collecting wizard hats throughout the game. And most I think most of the game, most of the chapters, you can use wizard hats by um crossing them off and they will give you different path tiles, maybe bread, um swords, depending on the chapter, what you need. And that gives you more flexibility on what exactly you need. And there's also the burglar um option because of you know the hobbit.

Yeah, Bilbo has the burglar option. And they're basically almost wilds in a sense. They um there's only a couple two or three of them in a in a given chapter, but um it's basically any die you can pick and you cross it off and like I want to use it for this thing, whatever that thing is,

right? So, if it's a resource I don't want or a path that I really don't want to draw, I can use the limited Yeah.

kind of slot.

But I'm glad it has it.

Mhm. Yeah. Mitigation is always good in these types of games. So, I am a big Lord of the Rings and Hobbit fan. So, the theme, I would say, is one of the things that I enjoy about the game. And I do think that the different maps play into the theme of that adventure and chapter. There are quotes from the book. There's like the riddles that Gollum gives.

Yes. Can you read one of those riddles there?

Um, alive without breath, as cold as death, never thirsty, never drinking, all in male, never clinking.

So, it's kind of fun. It has some of the thematic elements to it in the game. So, I I enjoyed that aspect of the game to play through the book and the different adventures. So, I thought the theme was integrated well into what you were doing in the different chapters.

Yeah. And the artwork, like I think we mentioned during the component section, I think it's a cool design, cool artwork, and I I think it works great for what you're doing in the game. The other thing I like in the game, I actually like the two chapters that just use the D12. They're unique. Um, I like the um what you're doing in that game where everyone has to basically use that number and they're basically using it to the best of their ability. Now, there's a little bit of even mitigation in that. Whereas, like say someone rolls an eight, not everyone has to use the eight shape. You can actually go lower, which is kind of fun because you're like, "Oh, should I do the lower one?" Sometimes you're trying to complete columns of the different Tetris um shapes in order to complete things. So, there's a there's that puzzly nature to it and strategy.

Or are you always going to use the highest one because usually the higher the number, the more spaces you're able to do, which means you get to finish faster

for that race aspect of Kevin. Um yeah, I I really enjoyed those chapters as well. Another thing that I wanted to mention is that the game is quick. Part of that is the race. And if you're playing with Kevin, it is going to be a quick game.

Definitely be 20 30 minutes.

But it's it's a nice I think weight and time length for a roll and write game. It doesn't overstay its welcome. I think it's just about the right length.

Cool. Well, let's move on to our conclusions.

Okay, so conclusions. I usually enjoy roll and write games. It's a game mechanic that it I us like most of them. It's usually going to be a thumbs up for me. And so I was already inclined to like the game because of the mechanic and the theme, two things that I like. And I am very glad that I did enjoy it. I

And the mechanic and the theme, not not just the mechanic and the theme, but the theme and the mechanic actually marry well together.

Right. Right. the uh different things that you're doing on the adventures feel like it goes with that part of the story. Kevin already mentioned the ones where you're rolling the D12. I enjoyed those chapters, everyone kind of doing the same thing. I also thought the chapter, I think it was five, it has the wargs and the eagles and the pine cones was interesting and threw in some new mechanics that you had to think about cuz the eagles are coming this way and you're trying to get the dwarfs into the tree. So, you're trying to balance both sides of your board to kind of meet.

Yeah. And then the last chapter when you're fighting smog I thought was interesting where if you can save the house or if he actually burns down the house

and then you have to fight smog too,

right? And if you roll that die number again on the black dye, then you actually fight him on that space. So it was interesting trying to figure out how to get the correct hits on smog. So I agree. Those were a few of my favorite chapters in the book. I I think it's pretty welcoming. It starts out easy with the first uh chapter, very basic, and then ramps up some of the difficulty, but never super difficult.

Yeah, I would put this on a medium weight.

Yeah, medium weight, maybe a little

light, like top level of light.

Yeah. Yeah. For a roll and right game, easy to get into. There's a lot packed into this box. So, I think you're going to have a lot of replayability. We mentioned that a little bit. So, solid rolling right game. If you like the the Lord of the Rings Hobbit theme, I think you should definitely try this one out.

Oh, is it time?

People have been waiting.

So, this is a sealed sealed copy

that we would like to give away.

So, what threshold do we need to to meet, Kevin?

Let's do if this video reaches a hundred likes.

All right. 100 likes, we will give away the game to someone who comments on the video answering one of these two questions.

So, either

what is your favorite Tolken Hobbit Lord of the Rings themed game.

Okay.

Or if you don't have one or haven't played any, what type of game? What mechanics would you like to see?

Yeah. So, we have a roll and right here.

Yeah, there's roll and right. There's Trick Taker. There's the pandemic style co-op which we've seen.

There's adventure games. What would What's the next thing that you would like to see with a Lord of the Rings or Hobbit theme? What What would excite you in that area?

Well, definitely click that like button now so we can get to 100 likes quickly. And thank you so much for watching. Be sure to continue seeing lots of other videos coming out from Tantrum House soon.

Progress saved