Witcher Old World | Solo Review | The Mage Knight Killer?
Transcript
Witcher old world was a pretty substantial Kickstart again earning itself a whopping 5 million 800 Grand plus from a whopping 45 000 backers it's based on The Witcher Universe which was running High two years ago thanks to the full series of the Netflix show bringing the world into the mainstream and prompting loads of folk even myself to give the computer game series a goo yes I'd played Witcher 1 and 2 on PC when they first released but I didn't really finish him and I couldn't get into the combat mechanics in the early tens but I did finally play all three fully or rather slogged through the first two games after the first series dropped and I even read all the short stories fully immersing myself into this great series like many others did so I of course was very interested in the board M when I heard about the kickstarter it was solo from the off which is Boston news to my ears War badly priced for their best game and all but unfortunately they have the money on like a load of other folk as a disabled unemployed bloke so I have to be a bit picky when it comes to getting money available for stuff and I had to sit at the kickstarter on this one uh lucky for me though I heard it was coming to the shops but many day sit
out on this Kickstarter and because of that General consensus seems to be pretty polarizing on this and and from playing just the base retail version I think I sort of understand why as it's a bit of the old Marvel United effect see since this was as I said a huge Kickstarter that got bought by a louder folk on the IP basis alone people saw The Witcher they saw a huge amount of Minis but they're bypassed the actual game or just briefly looked at it and couldn't quite get that this is basically a sort of entry-level Adventure game like Marvel United this attempted to appeal to a wide audience and in doing so made a very simplistic game that's easy to pick up and play out on the box now for me that's perfect but others crunchy or yeah Midway Gamers they are being Satisfied by its Simplicity and they are thoroughly disappointed labeling it a bit of a Kickstarter blower and cards on the table I call deny some of that criticism as whenever I've looked at all the videos with everything tacked on I also feel like those stretch goals make this a bit of a bloated mess see this game don't realistically need minis I personally played 45 quid for this and 50 Quid in total with
powerstage receiving just the base box and tokens and that I feel makes this game almost the perfect entry point for me there's no need for the minis at all outside of the arrows as only the witches move across the board and do stuff the monsters stay completely static in one spot except for the legendary encounters ones from an expansion but if you have got the minis for the best game alone they just end up sitting there doing notebook looking pretty there is no need whatsoever for them to exist other than entice Kickstarter backers in cause whenever there's a whiff of minis available people's eyes light up and they just gotta have them even if they're sitting a box Gathering dust and suit no purpose whatsoever then you'll add on all the extra cards which balloon at the already massive Adventure decks and the monster trail stuff which just gives monsters a weakness that you'll know that forget as soon as combat arrives and extra four cards so the monsters to do when extra fight maneuver that seems a bit pointless looking at it from me and you also add on the mutagens again uh mechanic which just adds more forgetful blow into what is at this core very simplistic system designed for Speed and ease of play in the Alps of
making it seem a bit more complex but realistically like a great magician bamboozling with fancy tricks it's all an allusion to trick you to going all in for nearly 400 quid Jedi Mind tricking you away from what this game actually is an easier more accessible and for me personally a vastly superior Mage Knight so imagine it is a storyless adventure card game it's a puzzle where you'll have to utilize the cards each individual Mage note has to the best of your ability to move around the map uncover tiles level up and deck build with a more complex mechanic for attacking monsters in three towers that's basically solo only and is terrible with multiple players due to slow player turns in downtime Witcher old world is a storyless adventure car game it's a timed puzzle where you'll have to utilize the cards each individual Witcher has to the best year ability to move around the map interact with tans level up and deck build with a very simplistic but fun combat mechanic where you'll hunt down three monsters that's basically solo only as it's apparently terrible with multiple players due to slow player turns and downtime one is complex that takes you three to five hours to play and one is Fisher Price's my first Adventure game
that takes about an hour to play solo and it's in that dichotomy that yo will choose which one you'll enjoy more because this to me is everything I wanted Mage Knight to be originally and I hated Mage Knight because of its needless complexity I love simplistic games I was a Games Workshop only player for 20 sudden years third to fifth edition Were Made bread and butter along with more time and they are known for appealing to a wider audience because of their accessibility but still fun to play games so whenever I play really crunchy stuff I tend not to enjoy it unless the best rules are easy to master because I'm getting a bit forgetful in the middle age I will lie and I like to jump into a game with easier to pick up and play learn and remember rules I don't want to watch three sets of half hour long videos on YouTube telling me how to move a recruit and do combat which I felt Yao had to do with Mage Knight cause for me it was a bit Saft with all the needless details for moving across different terrain types attacking certain monsters with all their conditions and effects and and having wounds basically bloat your deck let alone attacking towers with loads of enemies and all sorts of blocks poisons and damaged cantors which trigger for me
was just pointless bloat that meant you couldn't just set up a game and jump into it with your old world though gives me that easy to play feeling I need set up the game and use cards from your ons to move to locations then interact or fight in and out within an hour and that's exactly what I enjoy the five which are minis are also brilliant little sculpts there's some great details in each one and you can easily tell which school they are from at a glances they all seem individual and each have their own great little pose that matches the artwork on The Witcher boards so much that I wouldn't even think you'd need to use their colorized bear Stoppers that come with a game even if you played with multiple players because the artwork throughout all the game is Just Sublime the card art Witcher art monster art even the art on the back of the cards I feel is Sensational and really shows a lot of time and effort really went into making this a premium product the Monster cards show all of the monsters you have faced in The Witcher games to devastating effect and it really brought back some flashbacks to me when I saw drowners the noon wraith or Strega pop up randomly from my enemy card draw and I really wanted to take them down the art on your witch's decks show off all the sign powers in full effect and the combat cards and the market also don't shy away
from the devastating effects of violence which is can do to monsters as you see many heavy attacks really slicing out and some of the monsters burning things with igne or using your personal Shield Quinn the huge event card deck is another great positive eras depended on choices you make during your tan or art skirt quests you can stumble upon quite a few decent upgrades or help us in the number deck some of which you could inadvertently end up fighting or getting ranged weapons to assist in your fights against the monsters every little Alps after all especially when you go against some of those level sardine threes and I have to say it but those exploration decks being separated between towns and outskirts means you're just never likely to encounter the same ones over and over again seven times I've played this game using all the witches I've used two twice and I'm yet to get the same Quest twice I'm probably near the bottom of the deck for a reshuffle but I'm not there yet and I think that's going to be a great thing even in the best game is you're gonna be playing this all the while you're gonna be taking breaks between plays and so you'll probably forget the result on reshuffles or yeah I'll deliberately choose the alternative and open up a new
quest line or effect that changes your game up and so that's a big positive for me is sometimes you might feel like you have done the right choice for The Witcher and you might have interfered in events that don't concern you just like the game seriously geralt would have killed the bloody cursed Tree in Witcher 3 he would never let that thing steal children and luring and killing villagers it sickens me seeing people even trying to debate that online where it is what it is lastly though my big positive is the quality of all the playing components that cards are tarot sized so are bigger than regular cards yes it's a swine for sleeving could cost a bit more but for a working class bloke who used to work on buses and got his arms crushed and bossed three times they um perfect size for me Moss Evans it's so much easier to shuffle and play the sudden game along with them being easier to read for a bloke who suffers with his eyes the dice are massive and I love myself some big chunky dice but I will say the black ones are the easiest to read from my perspective but it's so satisfying choking big sodium dice across the table the board is all so huge with easy to read players names see traveling lines numbers activities Yale can interact with once you can arrive
and I also love the fact that everything has its place on the board for the best game potions the mark card markets monsters everything goes on air in its own little place and it just makes it easier to speed up the game for you when playing as you'll know what to do where to go and what to collect with all the places of the game being broken down as you go left to right on the board and collect stuff it's a great piece of design with a gorgeous map on top featuring places you'll know from the games and books and The Witcher boards themselves are double thickness with indents cut out for your leveling up skills and levels and also feature card slots for you to slotting extra abilities once you gain them and you kill the monsters I really love the boards also in this game and it shows the crafting care they put into this premium product they're all slots back into the box easy enough when fully sleeved as they also provided an inbox storage system where every piece goes into its own little dedicated compartment without baggies and I feel like I have an art attack these days whenever I see one of those as I'm just sick to death of backing stuff up and just dumping it all back into the box where it just shakes about as you take
it upstairs and put it on your shelf the fact that all cards tokens and witches have their own safe and well thought at compartment is just brilliant and shows our great Kickstarter can be for the design processes it saves you buying an extra 15 quid plus one off another company and giving them sudden money for something the original company should have done in the first place seriously many games could benefit from a great storage in box as it just means set up and tear down time is reduced and you spend more time playing the blooming game that you've bought but I do have a couple of issues with certain components the gold especially as the car board furry is a bit naff and it just don't feel great and you're on so I will admit that I've been spoiled by Iron clay some brass Brum lately or metal coins by Raiders of the North Sea and I do feel the location tokens do need to be put in them little 2p capsules since you have to shuffle them up quite often but that's it really the tokens from the monsters are fine as they just sit there on the board and don't need to be shuffled at all if you use the cards and shuffle them instead to randomly choose your three monsters with the artwork once again looking exceptional and really capturing the monster over a 50p size
token that sits on the board waiting for you to fight it but after all that gushing let's go on to MIDI slugs as being objective this game ain't fully perfect and it definitely a for everyone I've heard in multiplayer there is a load of Dan time between turns where you're sitting around like an anime character in a Shonen Jump waiting for your opponent to stop monologuing and actually do something but on solo only and so that dough really affect me I just want to put it out there along with saying that Simplicity of course has its drawbacks especially in the combat department for the enemies see yoav one 20 card deck to represent all the monsters base game yo will draw between 10 and 18 cards at random and yeah I'll just choose one of the two effects bite or charge or in Solo you roll a D6 and then one of two things open it will be a soft attack or a heart attack and there's no thematic sense or style in the attacks from Individual monsters in the base game it's one effect or the other completely random trigger and you're at the mercy of the dice and card and those cards are the same for every monster the cards are also their health balls along with yours being in your
deck and so Randomness con player hell of a big factor in you getting your great combo cards out and choices during the deck building phase also as a cardio want to always play y'all might never see during any combat due to luck and randomness and the deck building aspect is another part which I feel is a little bit lacking in this game yes every Witcher starts off with their own personal deck and individual cards in them one might have more blues for light quick attacks one more greens for better defense one more Reds for strong attacks with yellows and purples being more cyan and combo cards but yeah of course just focus on one aspect in this game to win if igne spam was your favorite sign of choice in the game you could just pick all the igne cards up and expect to win firstly the main reason is because there are many odd origin cards available and the card deck is so huge the likelihood of Yao seen one in the game outside of your starting deck is very booming slim but it's also because this game is mainly about the combos imagine Tony Hawk's Pro Skater you see a half pipe into a grind rail into a jump that lands you in the bowl you can grind across or hold your board on that game itself was
all about combos to Max your score and here your combos in your deck maximize your combat Pro S as the more cards you out put down the more damage you'll do negating the life of the monster and thus lowering the chances of them dealing tons of damage here but of course your cards are your health ball too and you need to build a balanced deck that gives options for combos damage defense and wounds so always buying the expensive cards well always win you the game as you'll have to spend your cards to buy others and you only get one a turn to buy one card yes you know could wait till summer chipper but that only happens in the last card on the spot and it's only chipper by one and the chip cards are often a bit naff so the deck building for me ends up being a bit of a disappointment when I think of deck building I like to have the option of buying more than one card at a time or I also prefer having more than 10 or so turns to fully build my decal but here with the game not lasting very long you really only have 10 to 12 turns before you're done without really dragging it out and so that's what 10 to 11 cards to add to your deck Max meaning your options are a bit Limited in the same way it is with Mage Knight and you'll really have to plan out your upgraded cards best for Combos and pick
one of the colored paths to get on this means the desk building aspect of this game is where all your tactics are as the cards have dual uses with the movement and all so you don't want to waste your movement across the board whilst being a beast in battle then the shall get to build a decent balanced deck but I'd never consider this a good deck builder because of the limitations of the cards on offer and the fact that solo often tended to just pick up the card in the almost three -1 cost slot due to wanting to bolt my deck out for health with me only just buying three to four great combo cards in the two cost range which just means the deck building is very weak from my personal perspective and it's let down lastly though my other complaint is a severe lack of money on offer you know which again where you're supposed to be a traveling Monster killer who removes threats around towns and Villages but most of the quests you know go on they'll offer much money or at all or even often then so the only real way of earning anything is through dice poker which is only available in certain Tans and then you're totally reliant on the look of the dice once again where you only get one re-roll and need at least three of a coin to earn just one extra coin and when which are
schools need two three four or even five coins to upgrade just one level you suddenly realize you'll need to be constantly earning at least a bit of money to move you up on one specialist level for you to meditate on that wins you the game and so you need to be either trying to consistently earn money that relies on lock or you'll need to get a Crest reward that gives you money which is once again based on luck and that heavy look based element can be a swine in Solo mode when you're hoping to win the game in 69 turns as it basically means you're heavily reliant on everything going your way unless you'll get a big break your upper creek without a sardine paddling there's no way you can compete the game in a quick time frame no matter what you do with that lady look being on your side so as I said this game is going to be decisive simply because it's a very simplistic Adventure game that can be completed within an hour and hour and a half Max at solo it's a race to level up your stats and deck killed Just Three Monsters the Dow change overall in the Solar mode and if you die to one of them it's either game over or they'll just wake up in the next
turn and go again it's the Marvel United of adventure games simple enough to learn quick enough to have fun and play and if you're um after something a bit more meaty yeah we're gonna find it here there's no campaign there's not to do but test out all five witches and go against all the monsters and that's it a full one-off game you can just get on the table on a Sunday after dinner and have some fun and kill an afternoon that's all this is some people will like to buy all the minis and extra stuff that bloats this one out or creates an extra race mechanic with a legendary monsters along with all the bloated decks and monster weaknesses but I hey one of them folks this works for me exactly as it was intended a simplistic adventure game and that might not be for Yao there ain't no wrong with that yeah I'll just need to know that before you go and buy it as this one is on the lighter end and that the fancy models just do now but look pretty so buying the cheapest best version of this would be the best bang for your book to use a Yankee term and if y'all do crave something more meaty in all honesty just buy sodium Mage not for the same price or even a bit cheaper these days they are at the core the same
sodding game and both are great for solo players depending on the weight and complexity you prefer so there we have it I personally love this game it works for me and I love getting it on the table whenever I fancy just going on a bit of a short Adventure like Bilbo so cheers for watching and Tatty boy