Saint Petersburg Board Game Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
welcome back to the ball games 4k YouTube channel and this is a channel where we do reviews playthroughs unboxings where sort of thing in glorious 4k resolution and we generally talk a line of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general and in this video we're going to be talking about the claim it's about ten years old now so this would talk about a second edition but the first edition in the second edition box we're gonna be talking about a euro game card draft in Euro going to st. Petersburg designed by some German gazer and the bloke who done demarco which we reviewed earlier car high school so in this video we're going to be giving you a very very brief overview of the rules because there are not many rules in this game and we'll be telling you what we do like what we don't like and then we'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not st. Petersburg is still worth playing in 2019 and beyond so if you know anything please consider subscribing to the channel leave a comment in the box down below and we'll see you after this so some petersburg add you play this game this is a basically like a card draft in ancient building set collecting sore game it's a
bit of a hybrid of all sorts of things and in this game there's going to be four different phases you've got the Walker phase you got the building's phase you've got the nobles phase and then you've got the exchange phase and each phase corresponds to a separate decker car so you obviously you've got a worker card you've got a building carts you've got the noble carts and then you've got the exchange cards and what you'll be doing in the first round is a little bit different you'll reveal twice the number of cars per player off the worker deck you'll put them in the top row of the board and then everybody has to buy at least two cards right and this is where we get into the actions of the game so it's a very very very very slim amount of action contain you come by a card for the cost it depicted on the card you can take the card into your hand for free and that means that you can keep in your hand it may be stop other people from getting it and then pay the cost later when you take the play the card action and that means that you take a cut that you've taken from your hand for free and then you put it in front and then you will pay the cost there and then the final thing you can do is you can pass and once everybody's passed in succession why it mean even if you pass you can come back in in the next round but once everybody's passed then the round is over and then you score and then why this works is the score in this is that workers or only give you money buildings generally only give you victory points notebooks give you a bit both an exchange cards work a little bit differently so if you're gonna be playing an exchange card taking one off
the board and playing into your tableau you'll have to take them while it displaces and put it back on the board right so they they're generally sort of like that the exchange cards are more like power-ups here they they give you more powerful versions of cards that you already own and there's a different ways of reducing the cost of the car that you buy so it ended around you'll move all the cars of in the top row you move them down into the bottom row and that makes any card in the bottom row one ruble cheaper right and also if you double up cards to say if you've got to lumberjack cards here then you get to ruble discount on the third lumberjack card so the more cards you've got the same type the cheaper they become and there's other types of castle on the carpet of them giving you this counsel certain colors of cars that you got and then you got a say like the the fake building card building card yeah that will pay for itself at but it will become cheaper if you turn it turn it face down right so there's always different the cards that do different things it's very very simple game the way the game ends is that once one of the decks of cards becomes depleted then you've finished the whole round you get to exchange that you you score the exchange there and then the game is over you taught up how many nobles only points you got with nobles so nobles the way that the noble scoring works very very simple you get points for every person sets of different local city core so Jupitus don't count for anything so you look on the chart at Bob or count up how many different levels you got I guess yourself Richard puts every ten rubles gives you another victory point and
whoever's got the most points is the winner of some petersburg so what do we like about some petersburg so the first thing that we really like about this game is the way that the decks are used in a strict sequential order right and that allows you to kind of plan ahead not not not in in the sense that you know what's coming out of the deck right because that's completely rounded but you know that the workers are going to come out first and then you know that buildings are going to follow that so it allows you to sort of plan that you're gonna get your money then you can maybe trade you up a trade show cash in furniture points then you might be able to get some locals and then you might be able to swap out the cars you no longer need with the exchange that way sir give us you sort of a as a nice mixture between forward planning and China trying to negate the the randomness of this game so the second thing that we really like about this one is there's some really good choices in this it's import simple honest choices that units it might do you invest in Walker carts to give you more cash to to bot builders that give you victory points or or nobles or do you save up your cash throughout the game just sort of building out your bank reserves incrementally see that's splurge your money on the really lucrative nobles or do you try and wait for the exchange cars to come out that really help you loose the efficiency of you engine there's all these really simple but really tasty choices in this guy and that makes this game pretty good fine so referred thing that we really enjoy about this is there is no complex in the
game score and I mean you look at mr. Smith's other going what do maca it the scoring mechanism that game obviously it's a bit more grandiose in it but there's all these weird ways to score and by the end of this one all you do is you count up the amount of different Nobles that you've got and then you trade in your cash with victory points and that's it and basically it's all staring you in the face there's none of this sort of like a farmer type thing in Carcassonne were you thinking well it does this being this there's a spinner its banks arrow and a board you know what you're getting at you know everyone's got and then that's it was gonna go so yeah that's really that's really good so what don't we like about some PS bow so the first thing that we don't like about it is it takes eons to get this they get this engine kinda when we when we play this the other day and it seemed like wow I ain't got no money yes well we kept ourselves I think I'm I can't do this can't do it I'm gonna have to pass why the fact that the cards are only available twice in the game so they're the Welker cards appear on the top rider goes a bottom row and then they're gone so it's very difficult to get the cards you you need it's quickly enough in the beginning of the game because you do you haven't really got any resources you're trying to sort of sling it your honor you're trying to buy a four-bedroom house washed your own benefits you know how many that's what it feels like way so it's very difficult to get that in this case quite frustrating that's why I think that's one choice that's quite frustrating in the beginning of the game to get where you want because the games keeps moving keeps moving and you can't keep partner yeah yeah so that's just one thing so the second thing that is
quite frustrating about this game is the fact that the duplicate Nobles aren't worth a thing so in that sense what's the point in evidence so you might draw a car to draw eight nobles and then you get for the same one you've already got one in your tableau you would've played one so that's four cards got that taken up sauce that you you ain't even going to consider right so it seems a little bit weird the duplicate levels aren't worth anything I understand the fact that they're not worth as much right but it would make more sense to me is if duplicate notebooks are worth like half a point or summat or something like that I don't know but it just seems like there's a lot of wastage on the board when you're talking about duplicate Nobles so a third thing that we find frustrating is the two-player game is cardem this seems a little bit lackluster I know that certain people who like this game have said that is best at two players I'm not convinced about that because it seems to me that like we said in the previous point that with a two-player game you still draw a cart on so the part of the board so there's a lot of wastage going on because because you can't really do everything you wanted that you can't get water culture what seems like these cars are going through this that this slipped away from you though some people are throwing cards into a river and you're like I think that card is fly so it's floating down a river away from you and all these cards have been wasted because you can only afford one maybe two so it's like if it's quite frustrating to two players so I'm not sounds a bad guy with super highs but I think it's probably better maybe free
maybe for pyres maybe because there's more competition for cards or a lot of the cards are getting just discarded because you can't afford them so to summarize is some petersburg worth playing today and in the future so we're going to say maybe maybe it's maybe it's all right there all depends what sort games you like done I mean this is solid solid some cards roughly an engine builder it's very very solid we enjoyed it is a good game it's nice and colorful
second edition at that marketplace element which we're not talking about here because we're talking about that the original type of game based there if you want to play it thinking about games it's like is it to us it felt like a cross I mean that's my sound a bit with you but it's the truth oh it seems like a cross between century spice route and Marvel legendary did that building came because you've got there worker cars that give you cash right and then you've got other cars to give you victory points and you also if you look at a board the way the bulwarks and the way centrist boss won't work so you're putting cards out to this this line take them off the board and then they move tonight so it seems like it's a sort of a mix and that last sounds a bit weird be essentially has a bit they've built involved as well no because you you're not building out your debt you just build on this tableau it may as well be a deck right so that's the sort games it's so similar so if you like sensory spice Road and if you feel like you saw very like that building games like Marvel legendary this might be our B Street I think it's out of print which leads me to another criticism which off but it's not really Icarus it's just that the the English rules gonna think this is only available in German at the moment and the English rules aren't available on the hams hands own hands in aren't available when a publisher website so we had to download the old edition rules and try and make sense of that in the new edition so they just be aware that if you do pick this up in German something you can get Amazon doctor so it'd just be fi to be aware that the English rules for the second edition are currently unavailable anywhere so we couldn't find them anywhere
yeah it's I'm going to give this one may be free stars which means it's a good game but there are better games out there if you look for the ones we mentioned and yeah so that's an OK game it's alright it's a good solid euro it takes about 60 minutes to place so uh like I said if you're Noel and please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment about some Pittsburgh and whatever you want to talk about in the comments below and we'll see you next time