City of the Great Machine Review: Every Move You Make, Every Step You Take, I'll Be Watching You
Transcript
hello everyone I'm tally this is Farrell and we are board of it and today we're going to be reviewing city of the great machine a one versus many kinda hidden movement kind of deduction game that's been receiving a fair bit of buzz in the last few months now this was a Kickstarter that funded back in late 2021 so it's just making its way into the hands of the backers and also the reviewers you can play this Solo cooperatively or competitively so if you're playing offensive one player will take the role of the titular great machine who is obsessed with creating the perfect City however it has gained control of the city essentially through human laziness as always and has now found that humans are annoyingly unpredictable and don't follow the rules so it has to do something about making a city while run however there are some revolutionaries which take issue of this who the other players will play as and they are trying to make the populace rise up and overthrow the great machine because they don't really appreciate having a complete lack of free will or right or anything like that please note before we get to how the game works that we were provided this copy by the publisher as a review copy
city of the great machine is for one to four players if you play in the solo or cooperative mode then all of the players play against the great machine otherwise in the main competitive mode which will be the focus of our review one player takes on the role of the great machine whilst all the other players take on the role of the revolutionaries there are always three revolutionaries in play out of a possible six each having a unique special power the goal of the great machine is to activate the master plan which happens when this track reaches 12 and the goal of the revolutionaries is to incite three riots or incite two riots and have the discontent track maxed out every round begins with an event card being flipped and these will alter one of the rules for this round perhaps reducing the cost of something or hampering either side in some kind of way they also offer the great machine a way to advance the master plan which might be in the control of the great machine or in the control of the revolutionaries for example it might be something like if the revolutionaries visit a major District this round then Advance the master plan by one then the revolutionaries will decide which districts they want to go to that round and pick the relevant access card and play it face down or they might just choose the access card for the district they're already in any discussion must be done in front of the great machine so to communicate with your fellow
revolutionaries you have to be a bit cryptic and clever before moving the great machine will take their term they have three Servants of which they can move to different districts and then each one can take one action the most important action is probably raid where they can attempt a raid on a district but they can also rearrange the city or pass new laws in order to make life more difficult for the revolutionaries then the revolutionaries would take their turn by revealing their access cards and they must move to that District that matches their access card and then they can take one action however if they move to a district where the great machine has tried to raid then they're going to get captured and then the great machine will get to decide whether they are allowed to continue their turn but the master plan will advance by one or cancel their turn and take away their resources and their access cards the revolutionaries also have a number of actions available to them but in general what they're trying to do is run around and incite citizens to write after finding out who they are this is because there are six different types of citizens and the higher the level of discontent the more of these types of citizens will be ready to rise up and start a riot at the beginning of the game you don't know what level anyone's assigned to so you're going to take action where you can peek at who they are and then you know their level and you can also take an action to raise discontent to make it
more likely a world riot to actually do it right you take the right action and what you need is to have more citizens who are ready to write then citizens who won't Riot and guards in that District now as a general overview the revolutionaries are going to try and run around raise discontent and incite citizens to Riot while the great machine is going to try and hamper them try to capture them through raids and to try and complete these goals on the event cards every round the first thing to note about city of the great machine is that despite it being referred to a lot as a hidden movement game it actually isn't really that it deals with this mechanism quite differently to other hidden movement games which mean players aren't usually a fan of this type of genre might quite enjoy this typically with hidden movement games the non-hidden players are spending their time trying to deduce the location of the Hidden player leading to a lot of brain work another issue can also be that if a player gets a rule wrong it can torpedo the whole game due to the amount of secrecy that's involved in city of the greatest team the only thing that's hidden is where the revolutionaries are going to move to and it's not hidden for very long on top of that playing is a great machine if when you're trying to guess where they're going it often feels more like gambling than being deductive or puzzle solving because revolutionaries often
have so many options available to them and passive action you can't 100 know where they will go and it means that you're going to almost every round at least when you're playing raid tokens you're going to get tension you're going to get drama you're going to get payoff and you're going to have catharsis and there's going to be elements of tension for both sides which is pretty fun on top of all that even better is the way the game works with this kind of hidden information there isn't anything that the players can mess up so bad that it will ruin the entire game and experience like can happen with many of these other hidden movement games leading on from this one thing the game does really well is offer players interesting decisions the event cards which occur every round are a particular highlight here as often they'll incite the revolutionaries to act in a more predictable manner or have them hamper their own plans in order to prevent the great machine from scoring a point not to mention they also change up a rule every round which further shakes out the decision space creates a wonderful dilemma for both sides and adds new angles and considerations to the gameplay every round in particular playing as a revolutionaries is a Non-Stop option Buffet not only are they provided with a variety of clever ways to go about the long-term goal of starting riots they can also take advantage of the special powers that are different depending on which revolutionaries they choose to play as in each of our games it's always
felt like the revolutionaries could come up with some kind of unique way of inciting the city to Riot in one of our games they came out all guns are blazing bashing every guard in sight until the great machine had hardly any guards left to prevent the riots and in another game they quietly went about identifying the citizens biding the time and then striking just at the right moment and trying to incite three riots in one round unfortunately we found playing as a great machine a little bit drier you feel so much more limited in what you can do which is a bit antithetical to the theme of the game where the great machine is supposed to be in complete control of the city your servants don't have unique powers and you have fewer actions available to you worse revolutionaries can undo almost everything that you can do on a drawer directive they can just bin it you pass the directive they can cancel it you repair a guard they can just break it frustratingly the revolutionaries always feel as though they're in control of their goal and have their fate in their hands whereas it doesn't feel like that with a great machine because the points you get to advance the master plan you get two ways one event cards two from capturing revolutionaries in raids but as we said before the event cards will either refer to one party or the other so about half the time getting that point is not within your own hands
then you'll say okay well you've got to capture the revolutionaries well the issue is because they have so many more options available to them there is a lot they can potentially do and you do end up more or less just guessing where they're going to go and we don't mean that in a reductive way it's just that if they have six potentially equally good options how are you going to decide where they're going to go besides kind of luck you're going to have a lot of experiences of being should I put it here or should I put it there and then you reveal and you've literally got that 50 50 wrong worst of all is the fact that you're going to have to decide between advancing the master plan by one and letting the revolutionaries take their turn if you capture them in a raid or canceling their turn and taking something away from them now in the early mid game this is a really interesting fun and fanatic decision it's one of these great decisions that we've been talking about previously but when you get to the late game it ceases to be a decision at all because you're likely going to need a situation where if you let the Revolutionary take their turn they can start a right or they could be so close to winning that you just can't risk letting them take that turn and we feel that it was a strange decision to be able to start a riot even once you've been detained whether you have the turn or not because what this then means is that the game late stage will end up becoming a holding pattern and being longed out as the great machine will consistently stop them from
having a turn if they can continue to catch them in raids and the players won't be getting a turn now it seems as I've been very negative on playing Instagram machine and it's not exactly true it's still fun and interesting and thematic and you get real Joy when you capture the revolutionaries and it's really fun to step down as they talk amongst themselves and pretend that you can understand what they're going to do it's just that means how you both felt that the great machine was more limiting and much harder to play as if you're interested in city of the great machine one thing you should know is that there is quite a lot of Randomness for what is essentially a deductive tactical experience you're rolling dice to see if you break a guard or evade capture you're drawing event cards out of a deck that are situational and could be useless or could be game breaking your randomly assigning citizens at setup that can have a big effect on how the game plays out you know it is possible for the gray machine to draw an event card that just because of the situation in the game it's impossible for them to get a point from or a revolutionary you could spend three rounds in a row trying to break a guard and fail every time because of a dice roll and we're not saying that it's on balance necessarily just that I think the game could be quite swingy based on all these elements of luck coming together you know as an example in one of our games we have on multiple occasions have
the card come out that essentially says the great machine gets a point if they don't raid this round but it's come out at essentially the depth of the game where if they don't raid then they're just laying the revolutionaries win so it's worthless to them that said all of this culminates in making each game feel pretty unique you're going to have different city setups different event cards each game different directives and different Heroes with different powers being chosen it creates some special narratives and some stories to be told don't grab this game if you want a perfectly balanced experience but grab it because you want an experience some drama and some intrigue and this game is also really replayable and what it does particularly well via the event cards that come out each round is keep each round feeling unique so all together this culminates in a game that feels really interactive really engaging which also has a pretty nice Cadence to its round structures it's worth noting that the game will feel a little different depending on which player count you play that and this is because you always have three revolutionaries in play no matter how many players there are so in a two-play game you're going to have a 10th test head experience where both players are directly opposite and going straight at each other with full force up four you're going to have a funny collaborative experience where you're going to have to find interesting ways to communicate because a great machine can see and hear everything you're doing
three is probably the worst way to play just because then either one player will have to control two revolutionaries and the other gets one or you're going to split that third revolutionary between you which can be a little difficult considering your limited communication final thoughts city of the great machine is an interesting experiment that does hidden movement differently than anything else in the drama that's come before in fact it provides such an engaging experience that it might be something that even people who don't usually like hidden movement might enjoy it's interactive it's dramatic and it's thematic that said it's not going to be for everyone randomness of certain elements can have a big impact on the experience which some people might not enjoy we also found it less interesting to play as the great machine and it's harder than the revolutionaries but perhaps that's best considering only one player will take on that role overall we really enjoyed our time with the great machine city of the great machine and we do look forward to exploring it even further if we very distracted by the chaos if you enjoyed this review we'd really appreciate it if you could give us a thumbs up subscribe to our Channel if you're not already definitely do and please feel free to ask us anything about city of the great machine in the comments or let us know what you thought of it if you've played um
goodbye bye