Skip to main content
Loading video...

Avalon: The Riven Veil - Board Game Review

Transcript 19:22

Hello everyone, this is Johannes.

And this is Sarah May.

And you are watching Board Gaming Ramblings.

And today we are taking a look at Avalon the Riven Vale.

We are. This is a review copy sent to us from the publisher, so thank you so much for that. If you are going to Spiel, we hope to see you there because we are going to Spiel and we are excited like this.

Yay!

Yay! That is how excited we are. And if you do see us walking around Spiel, you can show us a secret sign. It looks like this. And it will make us happy like this. Yay! If you want to extra effort to find us, you can find us at the Align booth on the Saturday from

[clears throat]

No, Friday from 2:00 to 7:00 and Saturday from 10:00 No, Saturday from 2:00 to 7:00 and Sunday from 10:00 to 2:00. I was correct and then I mistakenly thought I was wrong, but no, I was correct. We hope to see you there. You can come and say hi or test out Time Span, whatever you want to do. Maybe not whatever. You can play other games, I think. Like for example, this one. You can't play there, but you could probably play it other booths at the con, the fair, the messa, the Spiel. I'm excited, but today we are talking about Avalon. This is a area majority game. You are going to fight over these majorities. You're going to fight over these relics that are placed in or the mystical beasts that are coming in and you can get hold of them. Like in other games like this, you are moving into territories, trying to find the best territories that are that ever was. I don't know the theme of the game. It's like an Arthurian Arthurian theme. That is the thing I know because it's called Avalon, which is the place from those myths of of Arthur and the Knights of the Round Table.

Mhm.

And also Knights of the the the people under water.

You can be like the Round Table's Knights are one faction you can be, right?

was thinking of saying you can be the Round Table in this game.

It's so much fun. I love it like, "What's your faction?" "I'm a table."

But I think it's a nice touch that they actually made a round board for this.

Oh.

Uh-huh.

That's Avalon the Riven whale and the round board. But, enough about that. I'm briefly going to explain what you're doing in this game. There's a lot, so I'm not going to go deeply into it. It's a card driven game. Every round you're going to get some new cards. There are four different types of cards. Green cards that you will play mostly to place new deploy new people out not people, characters, units out on the board. There are blue cards that will help you build fortresses out on the board like these ones to help you get more stuff and get your position stay in the position next round because after each round you're going to kind of mix up the whole table and you will lose your presence. But, if you have fortresses there, you start with some units there and you're going to also be able to to move directly from there. You have movement cards that let you

move.

Yes. And then you also have battle plan cards which help you in combat. You're going to play ladies cards. Most of the cards have a card cost, so you have to discard other cards to be able to play them. You will do that three times. After you have done that three times, uh you will be doing battle. And you'll be battling everywhere where there is at least two two players units and two factions out there. And you'll do battles if you have any heroes in the battle which are the champions that are these bigger or your lord which is the biggest one, you will be able to play the battle cards that will help you get more power strength in the combat. For example, let's say we put this in here. This would normally be like a one versus two, but only the one player can play any battle cards if the blue player didn't have any heroes in there. And then you will draw some cards trying to not bust to try to get like some extra bonus like a little bit of push your luck element there.

And then you will score points. And then after you have done that, you will basically reset the board and you will even take out the pieces that are in here, reshuffle them and place them out again. So, you don't even know what is going to be there next round. You're You're to play two or three rounds depending if you playing the short or the long game. And after that, the player who has the most points

Mhm.

and haven't gone home yet because it's a school night, are going to be the winner of Avalon.

Yeah, this is a big production, a beautiful game. It's very overwhelming, I would say. There is many modes you can play with, many choices, and also like the the the share just like information overload the first time is but it's it was like I imagined it to be worse actually than it actually was. I think the iconography of the cards helps you a lot because they I feel like they're very very clear. So, I think that makes it easier to get a hold of the concepts of the game easier.

And there is a solid player aid which explains different symbols as well. So, if you see like, "Oh, what does this symbol mean?" You can easily look at the player aid and see it. I have to say like I This isn't our favorite genre of games. I always am happy to play a game like this. I like them more than you. And my favorite, I'm pretty sure, is Blood Rage.

And of course, I played Blood Rage a lot, but it feels smoother. Like it feels like it's

This or Blood Rage?

No, no, Blood Rage feels like it's smoother. This one is complex in a way that I do enjoy, but it have its downsides that we're going to talk about later. Mostly, it takes a lot of time. That's like the biggest downside of it. But I I said I was going to talk about it later and then I just said it because like it's like I I look like you and Laura are going to talk about later. It's long. Okay. So, I like the card play.

Yeah, me too.

the card play mechanism it is the core mechanism. It is what you're going to do. And like the economy there, like the resource management basically, because you will get two more cards at the end of the each turn which is three of them and you can choose the cards then. Of course, at the end of the round you're just going to choose the red cards because that's what you can use in combat. So, if I do one of these, which costs basically discarding four cards, that's crazy. Because then I will be able to I will lose four cards, five cards basically. Uh there is a way to be able to to not play one of them. Uh but then I will get two backs. If I don't have other ways to get new cards, I will have a very few cards when I come later out in the game. I really like this um what do you call it? The um the the numbers, which are initiative numbers. Initiative, that's the word I was losing. I was like, I don't know know what that word is. Initiative numbers are really cool because most of the time in this game, because you only have three actions,

Yeah.

going last is very good.

Yeah, I was thinking like, oh, I want to be first. And it's just like, no, I don't want to be first. I want to be last, especially the last round. Being the last player to act, to move or deploy something can change up how like the state of the board because I don't know if you said that, you probably did and I didn't listen.

Uh your like you're doing these like planning actions, that's when you're playing the cards. And then when you're done that three times, then you're going to actually resolving the battles.

Yeah, so it's very much like you're preparing for battle. Uh and then I feel like the preparation phase is kind of a weird name for it because it feels like an action phase. Like But if you think like that the the goal is war, then you are preparing for war. Then there are also these different actions you can do on your player boards. And this is the basic player board that I really recommend you're playing with the first time you do. We did that. I was like, sometimes I jump into like the deep end the first time I played. But then I looked at the back of this board and I did not want to do that because there was so much stuff going on. But I have to say,

Yeah.

we played it once

Yeah.

with this basic setup. And then I was setting up for us playing with the factions and I just read through it and I understood everything.

Yes.

Like it was there is a lot of information because then you have everything on this. There is we we haven't played with all the factions, but we have we have played with with less than all the factions. I don't know what the that sentence was. We haven't played with all the factions, but we have played with some of them. We haven't played with zero of them, but I felt like they were very clear.

Yeah, and they are different. And they they they have like different play styles, but you are trying to achieve the same thing. So, it's a little asymmetric, but not like Root for example.

Yeah, it's not an asymmetric game. It just has asymmetric factions basically. What did you think about the comeback mechanisms?

Oh, I'm just going to stick with the cards a little bit because

Stick with the cards.

I don't know if you showed the divider.

Oh, no, I didn't.

No.

This is the divider. Boom.

I thought that was a nice way of doing that because when you have decided, oh, I want to play that card. I want to pay these two cards for it for example. Yes, because the the the yes, and then you're placing your faction divider. It will looks like any other card, so your opponent doesn't see where in your hand it is to make it clear that you're not cheating.

And then you place it all down like this, so you know this is what they planned. This is the other things, so you can you can easily see them plan the things that you want to do without it being any clear how many cards you're using basically.

Yes.

And now, do you want to talk about the combat? No.

on something else as well.

Do it.

That is that when you're discovering these different areas, you will be flipping these cards over and these can be what do you call it? Relics or they can be like these mythical beasts. So, we can show one here.

Do it.

Uh it has

is Tempest.

It has some points and it has a strength and like an ability and

Yes.

because you're talking about the cards, you also want cards to bid for these, but it's going to be like a what do you call it? Blind

Blind bid. And then you also show it with a divider what you're going to bid.

four now. Maybe you bid five. You get it.

that's the thing that I when we play this game I'm just like oh I have full control. I'm going to play this card. I'm going to spend this card on this card. I'm just like oh no, I want this magical beast. Now I need to spend the cards on this too.

I really enjoyed the beast I give you like a little bit of a different strategy a different vibe for it. So now do you want to talk about the combat?

Yes, I can talk about the combat. The combat is fun. The combat is tense. It's a very simple. You can play with a like a deterministic combat without the push your luck.

Mhm. And even as a player who doesn't like luck, that sounded extremely boring.

Yeah, we actually were just like no we want the push your luck guys.

It sounded It sounded horrible. Basically what you do instead like you have these combat cards battle cards that says like this is my two strength limit, but I can add bonus cards to it. So let's say I add this. I play this. This is now a max of four. I'm going to draw card. So I will draw this. Oh it's a one. Oh I know I can only get a three. Oh I got a three. I will stop there. If I got a three first, oh I can get up to four. I will push it. And then I didn't get it. Another player doesn't know. So you draw that and I say I'm going to stop there. And then when everybody has drawn the cards you're going to show it. So I get zero strength or I get actually half of the strength, but that is a fun thing. If you play with a deterministic one, I would just get four.

Yeah, I think that is more boring and I think like I think it's cool that if you have a lot of more power than me when we're going into battle I can see I have the upper hand. It's It's like most likely that I will win, but you're not totally sure. And some of those cards you don't want to play it because you will win or because but they have some abilities also that if you lose or if you win, you get this. So, you want to try to choose something that that is good either way.

We played this game two players. I had heard this game [clears throat] was long. So, the some of the games we play now before Spiel, we just have to decide that this is we're just going to be able to play this with two players and we decided for that with this one. I have to say it works very well with two players. I enjoyed playing it with two players. Like the area majority stuff plays with two players. It can play up to five with the one expansion we got, which sounds like the worst idea I know about. But of course some people enjoy games lasting eight hours and being downtime aroma. Uh with two players who hadn't played it or who had played once before, it still took took about two hours to play the two season game. And that means a three hour game to play like the full game.

With three seasons.

With two players, which means if you play with four players, let's say you can shave it down a bit. It's still like five to six hours of game.

A long game.

And [clears throat] because nothing nothing really happens throughout the preparation phase that I can interact with from the other players except for like, "Oh no, there's a bidding phase going on." I will do something. Other than that, I can just I can see you going into the place where I am. I can't really do anything with it, which means that if there's four players in the game. This is of course just like on the way it felt like playing with two players and then adding one or two or even three more players. I'm not a fan of downtime when I don't have any engaging interesting things to do in it because also the board state will change. So, I can't really Oh, my plan is maybe I know and you also you know your plan. You can't change your plan too much because you've played your card. So, I know that okay, I'm lost. I want to build my fortress. I don't know where I can build it at the end of this round because things might have changed or even I want to build it there. I'm going to build it there, but I just have to wait 15 minutes. So, the it is a long game.

It is. Uh you said that it's like this changes. Um

[clears throat]

I feel like the the different areas are not that different that I really care about them changing though. Um it will be new cards. Uh so you're like saying, "Okay, will I trigger a a bid for this this creature right now?" Because I'm low on cards, maybe I don't want to do that. But um discovering new areas gives you like uh discovering bonus.

Yes.

So that's probably something you want to do anyways.

I just want to say like when you build a fortress there, the the the area will stay there in the game, which also means still needs to be explored like some leader a lord has to go in to be able to flip it. He's the only one that can explore there. But the scoring changes throughout the game. So that was like when you knew oh next round this is going to be 10 points last it was four, then it's more important to go in there. I enjoyed that part.

I agree. But other than that, I didn't feel like oh it's a totally different game now because this is there and that is uh the other way. But but um I felt like sometimes when we play like a shorter version of a game, uh I feel like that experience is lacking. I didn't feel like that in you might disagree if you played a bunch of times. Um and sometimes your your like character's ability doesn't really like like take the full form until like mid um game like round two.

Because when you play with the advanced ones there's like a mission you need to do to be able to unlock your super duper dude.

So for example, uh then you will find it more exciting to play all three rounds because it's like you're building kind of a little up. But since the board like kind of resets, you basically doing like the same thing three times. So I feel like that's a good thing that you can easily play a shorter version of this game and it's still a good experience. But also it's a long game and you're repeating Um like I didn't feel like

of change.

Yeah, a little bit of change, but not like

No.

Yeah.

I agree. Do you want to do some final thoughts?

Yeah.

Yes, let's do it. You can begin because that's how we usually do it is that you begin, then I am, then I say like that's the end of the video and stuff like that and then the video ends and then people can watch other videos for example from us, but if you want to make sure to watch our videos you can.

Subscribe.

And now final thoughts.

You all know what I'm going to say. This is not my genre of games. You know I don't like Blood Rage too much. Well, I okay, don't don't hate on me. I like it. I just like I'd rather play something else.

Yes.

Um and and this game I was I was thinking this is absolutely no game for me. Why did we even like

Because I wanted to play it.

Yes. Um but when we played it I was just like I like this card playing mechanic. Yeah. I I I enjoy that and even though um I sometimes I don't know. I get like attached to these little plastic dudes. I'm just like why are you dying on me? I want you to survive. Um I I felt like there is something here that I do enjoy that I like I could see myself actually playing this.

Yeah.

Um but I'm I'm I'm more inclined to play other games because I have more fun with those kind of games, but like in this genre if I'm if I'm choosing now I'm going to play a area majority game that is only that I think this is a good contender for like one of the ones I would think about. And and mostly also be yeah, because of those asymmetric faction powers and those the card playing, but but like it's it's too yeah, I don't know. It's good with two players though, but it feels very long. I I I know if I would be like I could either play these three cool games on a game night or we can play this one game.

hours.

Yeah, but I think you will know if you would like that or not. Uh, I might not, but I still appreciate a good design when I see one and that is this. So, I'm going to give this a seven. I appreciate the way it's done. I think it's a good way of doing it, but it's not my style game.

I think that for you to enjoy this game, you need to have a group of friends who first of all like to play one game a lot of times because then you will play it smoother. Most gamers maybe play a game two to five times and I don't think this game is going to shine for you then, especially if you play with many players because it it it takes a lot of time. I do enjoy most of the mechanisms. I do enjoy almost all of the mechanisms. There is a We didn't talk about this, but there's like there's like this catch-up mechanism where it's like, "Oh, if you have few points, you just get three points." I don't like that at all. Uh, but there is like you can build up the way you want to use this game yourself. It is It is fine. I think that the game I think that the game is enjoyable. I I enjoyed myself playing it. I don't see myself going back to playing it again, but I am happy It's It's It's for me one of those games where I'm like, "This was a fun time. Let's never play it again."

Mhm.

Uh, which is with a lot of games that I en- enjoy. I didn't love this game. I think it is a I think it's a decent game. I'm going to land on a 6.5. I think it is a a good game, but not just good enough for for my taste or what I want to play more of, but happy to have played it.

Mhm.

Does that make sense?

Yeah.

Good because sense is good. And that's going to be the end of the video. I just I said it earlier at the after I did my final thoughts.

Oh, so they know that already.

It's not like a shock that's coming. It's coming now. This is the end of the video. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes.

I'm Johannes.

I'm No Board Gaming Ramblings. Subscribe and bye-bye.

Progress saved