Skip to main content
Loading video...

Orichalcum - Board Game Review - A Full Table Hog Roast

Transcript 15:47

thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences so with the assistance of zatoo games we'll be sponsored this video I'm taking a look at Ori calcum this is not the newest game ever it came out last year I believe but it's been released by catch-up games here and by pandasaurus I believe over in the States and it's had a decent amount of birds there's been some very positive reviews for it it's co-designed with Bruno kafana as well as Johannes goopy I'm not sure if that's how you pronounce it but I mean it's g-o-u-p-y how would you pronounce it and it's meant to be a fairly short fairly simple game with a kind of a not quite a sib feel but the idea of building up pure terrain little map and racing to five victory points rather than having to score them at the end it's just get there immediately win which is a nice change of pace question is was it actually deserving of all those reviews or is just this one pretty forgettable generally what happens is actually all have your board and more on these a little bit later but this is where you will build your Mac tile so these matte tiles come in for sizes of three two and one and you'll place them on here and they represent different terrain types these will enable you to gain control of Titans which are essentially like powerful God characters that can give you a special ability but also so that you have room to build temples and mine for more or a calcum although just call it gold who the hell covers it or in calcum and you know recruit more hop

lights which are kind of like both are like currencies in the game that allow you to do stuff but the Crux of the game revolves around an action selection board so this board will have a bunch of action cards which correspond to multiple things firstly they dictate the size of terrain tile that will go on it they also have an action that you'll be able to do and if a volcano happens to turn up on one of the terrain towels they may also come with one of these one of these a lovely delightful monsters to make life a little bit harder for you because you have to get to five victory points and be clear of monsters to win the games and the Monsters can get you a bonus for killing them but they are a hindrance to you actually winning you essentially take it in turns to choose one of the action cards from the row paying a cost if it's further up and you take the title you put it on your board and resolve any effects of claiming Titans if you've put three or more of the same terrain type together but then you also get to do the action which could get more Hot Lights get more gold actually fight off the creatures or construct buildings of which there are Motley Crew of buildings that come in another bag here we go nice little buildings here that can either give you uh more training camps more mines there for hop lights and gold but also a bunch of buildings with special abilities that can be built on your terrain tiles in order to basically improve your standing now when you've finished around you reset everything you put more buildings out you refresh the card row and you keep going rinse repeat until somebody gets to that five Victory Point limit

and as soon as that happens that's it no scoring no finished around no bonus turns that's why first player markers are pretty important in this game if you get the 5vp you win well done so in terms of components and artwork you know they are pretty good nothing Stellar but pretty good these Dixit size cards are cool for the action cards because they've got to hold the tiles on there and they've also got to have creatures on there so it's nice that everything is there and all you do is take the card with all the stuff on it and you get to do your turn that in itself is pretty cool the terrain tiles themselves have got nicer artwork on them they're pretty colorful and they're sturdy enough you know not the biggest cardboard in the world but they're not going to break the Titans are you know just basically a tower with another cool picture on them and of course there's a lot of boards I mean in terms of how many they can be I mean a player board is like this a double-sided with two slightly different maps and then you got the building board and then you've got the action row board itself so there's a decent amount of construction quality in here you know plastic components of wooden hop lights and of course two bags that are big enough to hold the buildings and even the monsters on those bases as you saw which is pretty good going so there's definitely a decent amount of money thrown into this but all these components come at a price and it's surprisingly not the price of the game the game itself is actually reasonably priced but you are talking about a game here that takes about 45 minutes to 75 minutes to play depending on whether you play with two to four players that's pretty accurate and it's not a particularly long game Enders will get on too soon it's a pretty simple game so this is a lightish affair this

game demands a tablespace though that is bigger than what most households have it is insane I mean if four of you are playing okay you need to have four people with boards big enough for this this is big I mean look at it you know box size for scale here this is a pretty sizable board imagine four of these Keys around the table okay right for starters then you need to have the building board here which has these little sort of Medallion tokens on the edge there as well as these tokens here okay so you need to have that somewhere you need to have space to lay out these Titan tiles you need to have space above your board it's not just the board itself you need to have space above it to hold the victory Point things because that's how you track how well you're doing so you need that space and then you need this board long somewhere with the cards placed on it it's a little insane and that's and then you need to have the bags and the tiles like face down in piles nearby and that and it's wow uh the amount of table space I've been to board game clubs with this game and actually not brought it out because I know the tables can't fit the game even the rule books aren't exactly small although thankfully they're only big because they're just big size with Big Font and lots of pictures the rules of this game is really straightforward I mean I had no trouble learning this from the rule book it's got pictorial representation everything's laid out pretty easily there's maybe a little bit of ambiguity with regards to laying tiles and how you get the terrain uh sorry the Titan favor is there a little bit ambiguous but a bigger sorry but

everything else is easy to read easy to decipher and you know once you're done with it you know you have this player turn summary which annoyingly I would have liked a small card for every player but if you've got this out you pretty much have all the rules to the game at your disposal because most of it is on here and if you just need the memory jogger it's absolutely perfect and then flip it over you've got the iconography as well as what every single building does what every single creature does for its benefit but then you have to go through this long upkeep you have to refresh the buildings you have to refresh this action row of cards sliding any down and refreshing them and then if any of them and then when you get the cards out you need to populate them with the relevant size terrain token and if any of them are volcanoes you need to get them out of the bag and put them on there it's a little bit of a palava to set up each round and you're having quite a lot of rounds in the game so you get to a point where you almost feel like the Roundup keeps taking longer than the turns themselves now to a crazy extent but certainly you're going to want to divide that up amongst the players because if one person's doing it they're going to lose the will to live by the end of the game and so it's it's kind of weird that the game progresses at a nice even smooth pace for your turns it's like oh that was quick that was quick that was quick hang on reset right right that this is good this is good right reset it's a it's it's kind of like constantly you're watching a good movie but you're constantly having to press the pause button every 10 minutes it's kind of just a little bit annoying and I wish that it was just a little bit easier to

do that being said your gameplay turns are still fulfilling even if they are pretty short I mean you've got decent you know scope for deciding where you want to put the terrain tiles and you've got to think well I need to put them in a diamond the four different terrains if I want to build these for victory points but then maybe I want to tighten in which case I need to get if I want this Titan I need free desert together I need free Mountain together and then if you can construct buildings well which building do I go for they're based on terrain type but then if you cover up a Terrain piece it no longer counts for building temples or getting Titans so you've got to think well I'm using up that terrain for this building don't want the building you should have built it somewhere else you know I don't know and then even just you know whether you go first is a consideration this goes to the character who sorry the player who has the most hop lights so you might be thinking well if I can go first in the next turn then that'll be cool yes the player to your right gets a bonus Hop light as part of this but because the game ends immediately on 5vp it's cool when in the late game you actually consider the fact that you might want to have a big army of units just to get the first player markers that you can be the first one to hit the 5vp line when somebody else is possibly your rival for it it's some cool tactical decisions to make and they're not brain burning there's not many action cards though I wish there were a bit more you know you literally do only have this many action cards in the game now there's only so many actions I guess there's not too much variety but yeah you do find yourself shuffling through this deck of cards quite often which is certainly saying something and replay value is limited because you are basically doing

temples medallions or and Titans all three of them in a kind of mix you are likely to get one Titan as one of your five victory points that's just gonna happen I think generally but then you're gonna have the thing of deciding whether you're spending gold or building temples and you're probably going to do a mix of all three of these things so no he feels that different among all the players and honestly I don't see why you even need the players in the game frankly because this game is mostly multiplayer Solitaire and that again is a bit of a letdown when you play this with two players you've done in about 45 minutes and it goes at a pretty Swift pace and you've got the ability to discard an extra card from the row at the end of the turn so I find that two player is probably the best way to play this in fact because you've got tension for the cards the first player marker means more and it just goes along at a quicker pace and it takes up less space on the table but when you add the third and fourth player you add no further interaction the only interaction there's two aspects one the choosing of a card did you choose the card I want that is not really player interaction that's just standard in Euro games the only other interaction is the Titans the Titans themselves don't hit other players but because somebody only has to expand their area of the same Terrain in all to Nick it off you this is the victory point that basically bounces around the other players that's it other than that the fact that the third and fourth player here is doing no nothing but elongating the time and this is a game that really shines more when it is in its 45 minute to an hour mark But when you've got four players there's a bit of a down time and there's certainly a little bit of like oh this is getting on

to 75 minutes maybe 90 if you've got slow players this could be a problem on top of that the downtime can be even worse with this first player marker because let's say this is let's say player one two three four right so one player one I have around one two three four we then evaluate where this first player marker goes and it goes to the player to my left yes I get a bonus hotline but that means I've basically had my term and then I have to wait one two three four five six turns before it gets back around to mine now the game does come with a solo mode sort of and this is uh something I'm not a fan of and normally I wouldn't even talk about this sort of thing but the solo mode is not in the box it's only two to four players in the box but there is an official print and play solo mode and I hate the fact that it's print and play seriously you knew there was going to be a solo mode in this game why didn't you put it in the back so why didn't you think about it before you sent it off for printing I hate print and play you essentially have a solo AI it goes through the motions it picks a card based on a die roll does the action based on some criteria rules like priority and then gets rid of a card at the end again based on a die roll it has a slightly easier time dealing with uh creatures and it's mainly just going for the 5vp just like you are it's a decent mode it's not amazing that you have to go through the hassle of print and playing the board and the rules and then sort of learning it in order to play essentially a two-player game uh I'd rather just play the two player game

honestly but the solo mode is there but then it exasperates the problem of that Roundup key because I'm then having to do all the buildings all the cards all the terrain pieces all the creatures I have to do all that round set up myself I can take my turn in a matter of seconds like less than a minute and I am done with my turn the AI will probably take half of that time even to do their turn and then I gotta go through the upkeep I'm pressing that pause button pretty frequently when I'm playing a solo game and by the time you get to the end you're kind of losing the will to live and continue with the game it's just kind of annoying that that Roundup keep takes up a decent chunk of your play time sorry calcum is a fine game it's decent but I don't think it's quite deserving of some of the really high ratings I've been seeing for this I've seen some people give very high eight very good nines you know nine out of tens for this and I'm like hmm I don't know maybe typically your expectations down a little bit because they don't tend to mention a lot of the things like the table space and the downtime and other aspects like that so what I'm saying here is that already calcium is still a good game I enjoy the gameplay I enjoy the choosing of the cards and setting up my little board and trying to go for that race to 5vp there's a lot of tension when you've got fares on four VP three four VP and you you think all right come on I need to go ah they're going first no don't do it don't do it ah still got some time still got some time right do this quick I'm still not there come on one more turn and that tension is really cool I love the fact that the rules are dead simple it's

really easy to learn this although strangely the QR code on here doesn't work but honestly you don't need a rules video for this don't bother watching one you can learn this game in a matter of minutes don't worry about watching a video because it's unnecessary the summary Aid will do you for every subsequent game you play because it's an excellent memory jogger and the graphic design on here is pretty straightforward so again it's an easy game to get to the table and play providing you have the table space for it and that is a bit of a pain having to sort of go and I can't play this game because there's four of us and it's gonna take a bit longer and the table's barely big enough to fit all the boards on it really did need to be scaled down a little bit but overall it's relatively short it's not difficult to learn and teach it's still good fun to play but it just has those niggling flaws that stop it being great and certainly I think the replay value is going to suffer because you don't have many of these action cards you've only got these three ways to score points and every game is going to play out in a very similar manner so I do worry about this game's long life but overall I'm giving it a 7 out of 10. I know I've been giving out a lot of sevens lately but that just seems to be the way the cookie crumbles at the moment you know a lot of these games I'm playing are good but not great so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple if you like what you see please remember thumbing up on YouTube and on Board Game Geek and get it into the Hat review section leave your comments down below you're probably gonna do so because of the competition anyway but even if that's a lapsed then by all means you know let me know your thoughts on the video and the game itself and share it

on social media until next time you can check out more content on the show including reviews I am doing for various wonderwork titles an expansion for living forest and also my top 10 two-player game series that I have done so take care and remember regardless of whether you have a table physically big enough to house this game or not it's still only a game so bye for now

foreign

Progress saved