There is plenty of sand in the desert! Sand - Board Game Review
Transcript
hello everyone this is s and this is Johannes and you're watching board gaming ramblings and today we are taking a look at sand this is the newest game from devier games designed by Ariel D costanso and Javier pelisor it plays from one to four players in 120 minutes yay before we go into it I'm going to say that this is a review copy so you know that before we go into the whole thing sand is a game where you are a kind of traiter not traitor but Traer those two words are kind of hard to say differently you're a traitor that's going to be a very different game but you are a Traer and you are moving around on this board it's bigger we just made it so so you can see the player board as well and you are moving around on your little worm that looks like this and you're moving to this city there you might pick up some goods and then you will move to another to this camp for example and you can deliver the goods and then you might get some coins for it and and that is basically what you're going to do the game is based on dice these dice are going to be rolled and it's kind of a dice action game it's like an action selection dice game but instead of me having my own dice everybody has the same dice so for example if I use the white di now for an action this turn it's going to be a six and if I use the red one it's going to be a four and you get the the picture I don't have to explain also that the blue is a three and the black is a one you would understand that by yourself and
then you can then do use this to do different actions like I said moving around uh which costs you then water and food and health for your worm you can heal up these things you can get blessings which then lets you mitigate like choose to different to do to change the Pips on die you can also use coins but those are victory points and you can get this reputation which is going to give you more coins when you deliver things that is basically what you're going to do you're going to move around these this map the best you possibly can deliver trying to deliver combos of things that gives you more advanced Goods so that you can then deliver those and get better abilities when you deliver you're going to get a base sum you're also going to try to get different bonuses like upgrading your little worm so it gets bigger and bigger and better and better you will get these helpers that will help you do different special actions or make actions better and you're trying to also score these kind of contract cards that you will get at the end of each round of you have played I think it's five or six or four or five rounds depending on number of players you're playing rounds five or six four or five something like that depending on number of players and the most important thing is the player has the most coins at the end of the game is going to be the winner of this game let's start talking about things that you see with your eyes yes and that is the artwork and components and there are great components in this game you have these double layer player boards which makes the resources really easy to keep in the place you also have a really nice
artwork set I love all the artwork in this game both on the the characters here but also the map is pretty easy to have have an overview over you have these different roads that leads to the different places that's the most important thing to to notice I think about where you're going uh to deliver the things that you have yeah I had to say one thing which I think is kind of just a fun little quirky thing is that this game kind of has to have cubes for the different kind of deliveries different kind I I'm going to call it in my play I'm calling it white and red and blue and black I'm not calling it what they're actually called but they're drawn from a bag so they couldn't be like shapes or something so what they have done then is to call them boxes of resources is kind of cute so it's the first game I played where they made like a reason for it to be cubes like it's a little box that you get to deliver to get to take with you as always I have to say that the rear makes great small box games yes I love the box size for this game and they're so good at putting together like a lot of game in small boxes so Props for Vi for always being good at that from a good thing to a bad thing this game has a rule book yeah that is usually good that's usually good but not in this case and it's kind of weird because I we also played we also played the the last game from the gam sou on SE had a great rule book yes and I'm wondering how do you manage to go from that and get this like I I would
have thought that in I don't know how big a div as company or maybe like there's completely different people who did this if that's the case let the people who did the salon C rule book do the next one because this has to this is one of the worst Rule books I have read in a long time I read a rule book and I couldn't play the game I I I read many rule books and I I don't usually have a problem with it I read this and I had to go and watch um me University shout out go and check if you want to play this game just show the rule book and and and watch that video because that's going to explain how to play the actually play the game because this game has many game r book doses nowadays and I don't like it with all of the explanation of stuff first and then the game play but here it's just out in another level I'm not going to go into details but it's like you are playing you're you're telling me the available action the game turns and then like you have a huge thing about the upkeep phase which I don't know what is I don't know how this works and then the end the game on page 12 I don't know anything about how this game works but I know how to end the game I have no idea and then you have like lists of things let's see here you go to the part where you talk about like the player board as I said I don't know anything about how this game play works and you could say I could just skip ahead and read what I needed to read but I read Rule books from the start to the end because except for some games that tells me skip to this page I would guess that this is the way they want me to read the rule book so here you have like just like 14 different points of sentences up of sentences of what things are and they
could have been like the food the the health and the water could just be these are resources used to move your worm that's all I need I don't need hydration this tracks what you use to pay your worm's hydration cost when taking the travel action C page23 you can advance the position of your marker with a care for your worm hydration action C page 27 I don't need that that is too much and it's it's just and then you get to the actions on page 23 so that's where you actually learn the game and yeah it's not good I could have spoken about it for a long time but I'm not going to do it more than I already did it's not good that's the Baseline you have a play raate at least I think there's a lot of text on this play raate I would have liked it to be bigger or with symbols or something because this is a little bit text heavy but I'm glad to have it it was really nice to not have to open the rule book and also it references to the pages where the it is explained in detail so I like the play rate I'm happy that they did that the problem I think is that this game isn't super complicated but the rule book makes it seem like a super complicated game and it's not it's what you do is pretty straightforward and that is kind of the main problem it feel like this is a convoluted hard game you have to explain this and this no you didn't have to do that do better we did play the game game yes we have played it with two three and four players and it has taken us 70 minutes to 2 and 1/ half hourish that is a long time yeah it is I
think it's too long for this game not with two I think two like an hour that's bit more than an hour with two that was fine with that I had the most fun when I played it with two because of that and the other place was long I think that if you play it you could get it down yes but there is some because of the tightness of this game you could get potentially a lot of AP um so so yeah you could get it down I think what the box says 2 hours each is realistic yes I think that's a good on the box it doesn't say like 60 minutes and take two and a half hours the game play we're going to I'm going to basically start by saying this this is a pickup and deliver game yeah and after playing this when I got this I was like oh we don't have many pickup and deliver games and then when I play this a few times I was thinking oh this is why we don't have many pickup and deliver games so before going into the rest of the the review know that pickup and deliver isn't kind of my favorite thing if you love pick up and deliver games you might like this a lot better than we did spoiler alert the dice is good yeah the dice is good I like dice in games that isn't like you just roll it and you get ones and other people get sixes and you I thought you really loved rolling move as a mechanism like top 10 mechanism my number one game but uh I I like in for example this game I think it's a clever use of dice for example on my turn I choose three in this case three of the dice that I want to do an
action with and then I can use them for different things for example the red one I can use for healing and blue one I can use for getting hydrated and whatever color but just the right number I can use to remove my Worm for example I love that and I also love that these are the same for every player and after Tre turn you roll them again and you sometimes you get get a really low number when you really needed a high one for the black d for example I think that this is the part of the game that's going to take less time the more you play it because this is the bottleneck basically when it's my turn I'm going to be I could have thought about it but think might change especially in a three or four player game two player games are more predictable because if you are over here and I'm over here I know you're not going to in the beginning at least speed over here and take my resources so it is this okay so now I need to do this one but then I want to do that and then I want to pick up this because when you pick up a resource let's say I'm here and I'm picking up the red resource I am then placing it down here so now I have less space to do actions and that is kind of clever really it's kind of thematic as well like the more stuff is on your worm I'm guessing these boxes are bigger than this like and it's going to be harder for the worm to to do things but other than that as you might have seen I flip this over to show a box which means that as long as I have a red resource there I cannot do any actions with a red die so you need to plan
because let's say now I didn't have enough food now to move I would be stuck and I would have to throw away this into the garbage to get back my my my dice so I can then do that action again so the planning is what makes it AP prone yeah but also what makes it fun because they're planning here and managing to do it in the right order is what is enjoyable about this game for me I think I agree I think this is a game which I know because I played it this is a game which is extremely tight at least at the beginning in the beginning it move your worm cost a ton of resources before you have upgraded it you have um you have one less like space for doing actions and if you want to pick up things which you have to do to upgrade your worm um which is essential in this game feels like it is the game yeah you have to pick up these resources and then you get to do fewer actions so it really is a hurdle in the beginning to get the resources that you want get to a place where you can deliver them you have to at least deliver to to get to upgrade your worm and you also have to manage that beside the other players who might take the resource before you yeah I feel like this game wanted to make a game or the deciders want to make a game where you're escalating so you're like getting to do a little bit and then doing a bit but it ends up feeling a bit artificial
because the beginning is kind of very forced like there of course the whole game is about picking up the resources and and doing them but the players who manag to pick up two basic resources and deliver them in the beginning of the game I'm not going to say they're going to win because but it's going to feel that way and we going to talk about that soon because that's kind of interesting but to deliver two of them and upgrade this to the other side that is basically changing the game you now have four spaces you get five of each resource and it's way cheaper to to move now and when you get to the other one it's basically free to move you can basically do whatever you want in but that's going to take longer to the game so that beginning it feels kind of unnecessary it feels so slow and punishing and it's not fun in the beginning and especially being the player that doesn't get to upgrade at the same Pace as the other you feel like you're lagging behind for the entire game I I not saying that you don't have a chance but it feels that way and the thing is it's kind of because we love tight games so you might have SE like oh you don't like tight games we love them but this feels like as I said it feels artificial it feels like it's there in the beginning just so you get a feeling of getting to do more and then get a feeling of doing more yeah for example let's compar it to L boa which is a really weird um compar but that is a game where I feel like it's really tight in the beginning I spend four resources I get one back but there is different branches I can choose which path I want to go on here it's one path I want to upgrade my worm that is
essential I need to do that and I think that especially a two or three player game like because these uh cities or these camps here they have like a specific they want to have for example this one it's best to deliver the black and the white and if you deliver both of them at the same time you're going to get a purple so if a player get to do that and get two resources and get the points and everything upgrade of war and get the resource back that's going to be a huge huge like benefit in the beginning as I said one thing that is important to note is that if somebody gets ahead in the beginning that might also because if they get to deliver more stuff in the beginning they might get like some bonuses but those bonuses are going to be there for you as well when you get them later yeah so it has felt very hopeless for some people who people who get left behind in the beginning and they have gotten almost back again they haven't won no so the player or players who managed to get the two matching resources that they wanted to and and get the bone that the ball rolling because then if I get the purple and I go to a city where I can pick up more resources I also have something to deliver so it's not just to pick it up it's to deliver as well and then I maybe get to go here and here to pick up two that matches this place and go there and I can go there and deliver it so getting those bonuses feels kind of essential I agree there is this other thing where you deliver this bad resources like not bad but they want them less and you get a token that say either two or one on it
and the player who gets the most of them gets 12 I never did that because it didn't feel very good no I tried doing it uh some of the plays that we played but I agree in 12 points in this game isn't that much and also they're not secured points because somebody might take them from you and get more yeah yeah and also um but I like that even like no matter what you deliver you're placing them here and getting the bonuses for example when you deliver third resource you can place this uh what you call it Outpost Outpost which you can store resources and also send resources to it if you have some special ability yeah which might be really helpful and also so you can get these helpers which is really I feel like those are really powerful oh yeah and and all of them are powerful which is cool because it's not like oh you have to do this one you have to do this one this is where you kind of be even though like this is a pretty straightforward game you're picking up stuff delivering it you can do different kind of strategies you can go for because if you play two players and I I think it works better with more but then it's slower but the thing with two people is that if you end up being on your side of the board I could basically if I'm lucky enough with the resource I can basically just do this yeah and that also isn't that interesting and if you get the shaman which then can you can pay coins to you have these acolytes of different colors
and if they match let's say this for example is the red I and I have this and a shaman I can pay a coin and do a a red action to just transport this into my Outpost so you can then end up even easier doing the thing let's say I had here the red so then I can just go here pick up the black I come there deliver this then I can use that red another place to put it in there so in the beginning the movement is so crucial but after a while it feels like it's less important and also when you get like the uh you can have a double movement so I can move on one dice I can move over here and if you these are going to be very very expensive in the beginning the shortcuts but if you upgrade to your big worm you can move very fast so it it get that feeling of the acceleration that you're doing more and more but for me it doesn't get more fun well it get more more fun because it's in the beginning it's boring so you get to a place where you think that you can accomplish something with which I think is nice and the shaman also has another ability which you can um when when you have things in your um what you the out poost yeah the artifacts when you have them there you can upgrade them from being an artifact to being like a stone yes it's a magical stone and that is a super cool resource that you get a lot of money for it's 13 and you also have this better track which gets you more points but to deliver them you have to go up to to Harbor there's nothing else to do in a
harbor no uh so I felt like the one time I tried to go for that it felt like too many steps for the points it was worth and it didn't end up being worth it so I think that it seemed really cool to be able to do that but you actually won doing regular stuff because you didn't have to go trips up to the harbor and especially because when you choose when you get the first stone you have discard all of your contracts so you're not going to score any points for that as well and they're not that much better like if you end up going to the harbor with these artifacts they're going to be 11 yeah and then they going to be 11 + 3 5 5 6 7 10 but these are 13 + 5 6 so it's not even that big a difference so they felt like I don't see a game then I had to have like the stars be align and as I said you had to have you had to to fill like up three of them and then have the double movement to be able to move up there and leave a tree at the same time that you can have like two of the same color on one space so I see that you can make it happen but it's a lot of work going into getting those points and the thing about as you said moving read resources if you have a lot of resources you have to move so slow so if you want to deliver a lot of things at the same time it's going to take a while so yeah let's talk about about the weight yeah and who do you think this is for I will say that if you take away the horrible rule book if you watch the video instead the game is pretty straightforward like the game isn't complicated but the rule book makes it
feel complicated even though it's it's not it's very straightforward you do the actions there's not that many actions you do use the die you fill up the spaces you can't use that anymore you try to deliver them and that's basically it like of course there's more rules than that but it isn't a complicated game so for me it's like a medium game IE who do you think would like this game I would say if you are looking for a pickup and delivery game this game delivers and it picks up tight stuff probably and if you like a game that really escalates because it does it does Accelerate from being extremely slow too slow in the beginning and um much much more what you call it like giving no yes yes you get to do stuff you get to do stuff that's nice yeah I think so I think like if you if you see it as like oh this is going to be for me then you you're probably going to like it that is a very boring thing to say if you think you will like it this is for you but yeah for me it's just to to everything let's do the final thoughts if you like this video and you are here on our Channel and you felt like this video gave you something that we used to call Value it's a great word and if we gave it to you then we are happy but we're going to be even happier if you give us a victory point and we you get victory points when you click that subscribe button you can also click the Bell to get notifications every time we post a new video okay finally thoughts time for sand I really wish that I like
this game more because I think it has some great things going for it for example this game uh mechanism which we've seen kind of before in Lorenzo in magnifico I think that is clever I also think like the the blocking of the SPAC is here clever the I really like the thematics in the resources you need to move your worm you could be like it cost 10 coins no you need water and food and it has to have enough Health to go on this journey really enjoy that I like the the really cool upgrades that really is a game changer when you get them I just feel like it's it's a drag before you get them because when you have these and the graded worm then the game is kind of fun but then again I'm it's a pickup done deliver game and now we know that that is not a genre because it's not that I thought it was more fun with four players yes um because uh or treat but I thought like having one side of the board to yourself that wasn't that interesting it's more interesting when you're just like oh I need to get there before you so you don't take the red that I so desperately need that is a big part of this game for me I think this is landing on being like an average game so I'm going to give it a 5.5 oh yeah I I I I I love like the theme I basically what you said but the start of reading your rule book but then I watched the video and I was like oh this looks fun and I played it and it is fun but it is only
as you said it's kind of fun and I would love it if you have like a pickup a delivery game you think we would like let us know um and I think like I I said it's from the beginning it feels scripted it feels so so tight in the beginning and then again even though there are different ways to go it's more of what are you doing let's try to move another place than you are and try to snag out these resources trying to get the shaman so I can warp these resources around and doing the best I can of course I agree that more players is better because the interaction makes the game better but it also makes it longer I enjoy very much the dice mechanisms but I just don't enjoy the game that much I am going to give it A5 I think it's an average game I for me it's yeah I'm never going to stick it out to play and I might not play it if somebody really wants to play it I might do something else instead like scroll on Facebook or something but yeah that's going to be the end yes if you enjoy the video I already said that stuff but you can also give us a point if you didn't do it earlier but now you get a second chance now it's not it's not locked but now the end of the video is here and I'm going to say thank you so much for watching it means a lot I'm Johannes I'm s and you have been watching board gaming ramblings and byebye