Castles of Burgundy Review - Not Actually About Castles
Transcript
20 quid that's all this game costs 20 quid now considering it's from the acclaimed design of Stephen Feld you can see right here it's written in tiny letters and up until very recently castles of burgundy was in board game geks top 10 games of all time until it got bumped by Gloom Haven that should be enough of an endorsement for you to just go out and get it why you why are you still watching this just go and buy castles of B and it's 20 quid seriously you can do one month without a pedicure it's fine God knows some people some people spend more money on scratches and this Lottery has a much better chance at actually giving you something that will make you happy all right Don that was easy took me like 10 minutes I should review famous games more often why you're still here I bet you can't get enough of this mug actually it's probably this mug you're more curious about and that's perfectly fine look in all seriousness £20 isn't a lot for an acclaimed game but castles of burgundy isn't perfect and I bet you are wondering to yourself right now just where does this low price tag hit the threshold of maybe I'm not so sure I want to get this game boys and girls let's get down and dirty this game looks pants nothing about castles of burgundy's tactility is particularly appealing in any way the box is drab the cardboard in ins side is thinner than
your grandma's grasp on reality the dice are well the dice so you can't really complain too much but they're rather plain and the artwork I actually quite like the artwork on the main board it is plain and understated but I do enjoy the aesthetic so I guess it's like the old adage goes you get what you can reasonably afford because not everybody's income is equal and some people have to buy subar products to you know not become homeless and such on top of that castles of burgundy is a major offender in one of the most overused themes in board games castles not only are there more intelling games about castles out there but I don't think this game is actually about castles or burgundy in castles of burgundy you'll be acquiring hexagonal tiles and then placing them on your personal player board to get things these tiles might be castles but they're much more likely to be things like boats rocks houses chick and philosophically Abstract skills the game calls them knowledge and just because your game is burgundy it doesn't mean it's about burgundy but I hear you I hear you I have already received all your letters of complains and I will address them right now here's one that reads dear EA you know better than anyone else that theme doesn't really matter as long as the gaml is good frankly I am disappointed in you I thought I loved you but not So Much
Anymore in fact I have to stop watching you sleep at night ah what the hell is this look I get your point I can understand that some people will buy a 20 game with a bad theme I get it some people will buy a 20 game with terrible components but there is no way in a million years that anyone would ever buy a 20 game with a terrible theme bad components and absolutely ghastly garbage gameplay much less a 25b one that was that was Cards Against Humanity flashing by the way in case you didn't didn't quite see it I thought I'd make it a little bit less subtle that was our official review by the way not that it really needs an official review because everybody knows I'm just preaching to the choir here I don't want to harp on this particular subject for much longer but yes game play is important perhaps the most important thing but we live in an age of board game opulence there's dozens of new games released every week and in the space it takes you to change your socks there's another game on Kickstarter that's made like 200 million dollars or whatever it is and there are games that take you hundreds of hours to play there are games that look like they're the love child of Brad bit and Aphrodite there are games that you control a submarine with an erasable Mark and Shout at your friend friends and there are games that let you swap out die faces and at the same time there
are a lot of games with really good game play so when we are so spoiled for Choice why not choose games that have both thankfully castles of burgundy is a pretty good game gameplay-wise certainly better than the other game that we just reviewed a couple of scenes ago much like in all Euro games in castles of burgundy you will try to be the the person with the most points and you go ahead Brucey and tell them why points make prizes what do points make in fact castles of burgundy doesn't just give you points it positively showers you with points like a Jed stream of efficient tile placement at the start of each round you will roll your dice you will roll exactly two dice and every player will roll dice simultaneously so you can eyeball what your opponent has rled and what the possible actions for them are each of those dice represents an action and there are four different actions in the game you can take although honestly you will be mostly taking two of them the first action that you can take is you can reserve one of these tiles from the main player board and putting them on your personal player board and one of these free spaces right here and the reason you only have fre spaces is that you can't infinitely just hoard all the good tiles and then do something else later with them but the trick is the tile that you can take is dictated by the D you have just spent so if you're done die is number two you can only take tires from the region two on the player
board alternatively you can spend one of your dice to place one of your reserve tiles onto your personal player board except that the dice that you are spending corresponds to the type of space you can put a tile on except that I can't actually do this you see the problem is that not only do I have to match the numbers on the die and the tile space but I can also only players tiles onto spaces that are adjacent to tiles I've already placed meaning out of these free tiles and all these dice that I've rolled I can only place this mine because it's a four and it's adjacent to this castle that I already have and then I will get things and the things I get depends on the type of tile I place mines will give you rocks because why wouldn't they boats will let you advance an initiative and become first for the next round potentially houses will give you various different things in an ironic Twist of F points don't make pets pets make points and that's a very very very Niche joke that very few people will get consoles will let you take an extra turn as if you have spent a die of any facing and finally knowledge tiles will give you skills that are unique to you and that is the gist of castles of burgundy two simple actions but there is a lot going on here yes there are four actions in total but those two make up the core of the game you're either reserving a tile from the the main board or you're taking a reserve tile from your personal player board and placing it on one of the appropriate spots but
no matter what you're doing you're always getting rewarded you're e either snatching something from your opponents they can no longer have or you're taking a reserve tile and placing it here and you always get a bonus some sort of bonus when you do so and I have to say I've gone on record on saying that I haven't played many Stephen Feld games and that's because I didn't connect to aquasphere the first game that I've played and Oracle of Deli didn't wow me either but here the mechanisms are so elegant and simple and easy to teach and easy to explain but there's so much depth going in and enjoyment because no matter what you're doing there's always something there for doing so stefen Feld gets what makes games fun but there is the deception in castles of burgundy's assume Simplicity because actually there's quite a lot going on under the hood as you would spec it would be easy to assume that all you need to do is pick a strategy of what hexes you're going to place and how you're going to chain bonuses into points and all of that stuff and that's great except that castles of burgundy frows a wrench into that plan and the wrench is is that there are different clusters of same colors of hexes on your personal player board and they're called areas fill in one area and you're going to get a bonus number of points what is that number number well it depends on what phase you are in there are five phases in castles of burgundy and each of them is kind of like an Uber round complete one area in
its entirety in phase one and you'll get a bonus of 10 points but complete that same area in Phase five you're only getting two points on top of that if you're the first person around the table to complete a certain color then you get a bonus number of seven points meaning that casts of burgundy suddenly becomes a race filled to the brim with tension on every single turn it's phase one round one the very start of the game you won the dice off meaning you are first in the world is your cardb oyster you can do whatever you like you scan your player board and the main board and you notice that you have a free here that's a single town area meaning it takes a single tile to complete it and score the F first face bonus of 10 points for completing an entire area you spend your two to pick up a town tile and put it in your reserved area and then you spend the free to place it right here and great you've just scored those 10 points plus you scored an extra seven points for the round because you are the first person to complete a town area in the game and no one else can have that anymore that is yours permanently the trade-off is that now it's your opponent's turn and that means that they get to pick up these boat tiles now whilst they're still in their Reserve they they're not doing anything those tiles are no longer available and these bat tiles determine initiative and there's a limited supply of them on the board signaling to in my imaginary game of four players to the third and fourth
player that hey you should probably pick up both tiles as well because initiative is going to be important because there's not many of them meaning I have just been relegated to going last for a long while and that's the thing about castles of burty there are no bad turns there are only good turns and better turns and it is up to you to figure out which is which remember that constant barrage of points I mentioned well it turns out that that barrage of points is Just an Illusion because everyone is getting them it's very likely that at the end of the game you'll find that your scores are pretty close meaning that these big powerful plays of shooting ahead and points aren't as important what's important is figuring out a continuous supply of points that every turn gives you something and that is harder than it sounds but that is also the attraction of the game it is a lot more subtle than it initially presents itself to be and I'm fascinated by games that wear a mask and seem to be something else at the start of it and then you get to learn and figure out what the game is actually trying to get you to do well wouldn't it be easy to just math the whole thing out you know figure out the optimal tiles you need to take for maximum points and just win at that point you might as well pick the person at the table who's best at maths and declare them the winner because why bother anyway which is what I'm sure people do when they play power grid yes but you are forgetting about dyes and D severely restrict you in terms of what tiles you can take and
what tiles you can place but you do have workers that let you adjust them each worker you spend will adjust the die by plus one or minus one not a significant difference but it still gives you some flexibility except that workers are a very hard resource to acquire one of the ways you can reliably get work is by spending a die you can spend a die of any facing and just get two workers which throws a spanner into your plans let's say you have the last four turns of a phase left and you know exactly what you want to do on those four turns to achieve what you want to achieve that's great but if it takes you all four turns to do it you're going to have to roll your dice twice and unless you are incredibly lucky you won't get the exact faces you need meaning you need to account all your plans for spending extra actions just to ensure that you can do the thing that you want to do which can sometimes get frustrating because you sometimes just will roll dice that don't let you do anything you want to do no matter how many workers you have but it's just the reality of castles of burgundy you have about 50 actions 50 dice rolls it's very likely that through the course of the game things will even out all of this makes castles of burgundy an incredibly cut frro experience the last time I saw someone fight so hard over free chickens and a boat I had to call medieval police cuz it was medieval times and police was medieval and everything is fine in the world now people don't fight over food
and there's no poverty and everything's okay regardless of its plain aesthetic and drab looks and boring looks castles of p is a ruthless game it's unforgiving and the only saving grace for people who don't like ruthless and forgiving games is that well you can still play a non ruthless game you can you can kind of lay off the tactics if you want to and you'll still do fine because you are still constantly smattered with points you're just not likely to win because no matter how poorly the dice roll you know the person who has more of an understanding of this game and more experience with it is going to win unless you roll the same number every single time you roll a total of 50 dice this game and if if all of them land on then I mean when has that ever happened so then the answer is yes yes a thousand times yes it's 20 quid you should go out and get castles of burgundy because the game play is good the design is elegant and everything is fine ironically when I asked the lion if she would pay 50 Quid for this game if it had Swank components she said no she wouldn't but she would happily pay £20 for this which I think says something about castles of burgundy I think what that says about is that it's fine as it is it's not a game admittedly that wowed me but I suspect expectations were said high and there is something to be said about Stephen feld's designs that feel somewhat
lifeless and that is not really a criticism of the game because I don't think it was designed for an evening of rock as fun it's designed for people who like to meet each other on the battlefield of wits and and if you are one of them boy there's a lot to enjoy in castles of burgundy if you can hear anything over the spattering of water you should click the Subscribe button there's a few things we haven't quite covered in castles of quy like silverlings or the trade actions but they're not important we try to get the feel of the game across and and and if anything else this is incredibly unpleasant and you should feel sorry for me and hit the Subscribe button and then I'll be happy this is funny somehow I don't I don't know how