Lewis and Clark - Boardgames4K Review - Still Worth It?
Transcript
hello welcome back to the ball games 4k youtube channel and this is a channel where we give you reviews play throughs unboxings and we generally like to talk a load of bugs about tabletop gaming in general and in this video i'm going to be talking about a hybrid game that was released quite a while ago we're going to be talking about lewis and clark the expedition and this is a game which sees you play cards from your hand place a few workers out to the board in an attempt to move your camp through the american wilderness and to get to the final destination first or as quickly as possible so in this video we're going to be giving you a very brief overview of the rules we'll be telling you what we do like we don't like then we'll come back we'll tell you whether or not lewis and clark is still worth playing today and in the future maybe because it's got a second edition has just been released so remember if you knew it then please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we will see you after
this board games 4k so lewis and clark how to play this game so first things first right we are talking about the first edition i think it's the second printing maybe it's the first printing this is the first edition anyway we're not talking about second edition we haven't seen the second edition so maybe there's been a few rules changes i got clue so if you want to know about the second edition then go and watch another bloody video in there so lewis and clark is a bit of a hybrid game it's got a bit of everything it's got to be a racing bit of dick building it's got a worker placement a bit of card management all that sort of stuff right so once you set the game up got a choice of doing two things on your turn you've got a mandatory thing you've got to do you've got to perform an action don't get away from that you can't hide in the fridge or anything you're going to have to do an action the second option you got is that you've got the option of setting up camp and or you've got the option of buying a character from one of them characters that's on the display so the actions you can take you can take a character action in which case you will select one of the cards from your starting end and you'll play it and you'll do what it says or you can use some indians that you've acquired and place them on a relevant spot on a game board like a sort of a worker placement thing bit like stone age you know so if you select a character card from your hand you'll play the card face up and you'll notice that there's certain indian markers on one side of the board and this indicates to you that the card has to be activated right so there's
three ways to activate the card you can select another card in your round you flip it over and you'll place it underneath the card right and that'll give you at least one indian to activated card you can take a card from your and flip it over and place some extra indians on the empty spots on the card or you could just load the card up itself with some indian meeples and then that will activate the card without having to flip one over right so everybody starts with the same cards right you're going to be acquiring more cards by buying them from the display on the ball but we're going to talk about the starting cards very very briefly we're not going to spend eon talk about this in fact i'm wasting enough time as shut up so the first cards that you could talk about are the primary resource collection cards that you've got you're going to play the cards and then you're going to look at who's got what next year for every symbol that matches the card you played you're going to take that many resources and put it on your player board and you've got to be careful with this because you've only got a certain amount of slots that you can put resources on to if you get to head around with too many resources this is going to cost you a lot of time you've got to be very mindful of that but we're going to get into that in a little bit right so the next action you can take is you can take the action that lets you take indians from the board right and what you'll do any indians are already on the board you'll move them to the center of the board called the pow wow area and then you'll get the option of taking as many of them as you want and placing them on your relevant spot on your player board yeah then you'll discard the character card that's at the bottom of the display and then finally place an indian meeple on the newcomer area of the board right and this is the primary way of getting your indians peoples onto a player board that will allow you to take subsequent actions on later times you
know so the next action you can do from your starting hand is the commander action which allows you to move forward on the route you'll have to pass a certain number of resources that will allow you to move on land all through the mountains if you notice on the board you've got sort of a mountain segment there's always a pain in the backside to move through and then you'll move your scout that number of spaces up the river you won't move a camp yet you'll do that later but you'll move your scalp marker that many spaces on the river all through the mountains or whatever you want to do right those are the basic starting card actions and now we're going to turn our attention to the actions on the board right and for this you're going to need to pick up some indian meeples and chuck them onto the board and this will allow you to take actions so you've got the basic actions that's going to allow you to take food or different types of resources like fur wood equipment and all that sort of thing or food you've got the farewell space that will allow you to discard zero to three character cards from your hand a way of dumping out all the shape that you got your hand and then you'll be able to discard all the cards in the journal which is the display and then you'll be able to really fill them up right you've got horse trade action where you'll be able to discard three different resources and then you'll be able to take a horse cube you've got the same principle when you're talking about a canoe manufacturing you'll discard those those resources and you'll take a canoe cube got the expedition upgrade you'll pay free wood and then you'll be able to take one of the upgrade tiles and add it to your player board this will basically expand your ability to carry more gear then you've got a shamanism action you'll be able to activate a character card that's already on the table so that's all the actions you can take on the player board now we're going to quickly talk about the other two
optional things you can do basically you can recruit a character from the display you'll pay the cost in equipment and also be a cost of maybe furs or something so you have to pay the cost and then what you do you'll add that character to your hand and then slide everything down and reveal a new card so the final thing that you can do in this game is you can take the encampment action right so when you set up camp you'll place all the indians that you played on your cards back into the boats on your player board then you'll calculate how much time you've spent about time is the equal sum of the character cars are still in your hand at this moment so be one time for every character card in your hand and then the possible time costs of the boats in your expedition right so the first space is free the second space will cost you one time no matter what the third space will cost you one time for every space that is taken up and then the last one will be one time per indian right so what you do you move your scout backwards by the same number of spaces as the time your expedition spends as in camp and then what you do you bring your camp up to the space where your scout finished right so keep doing this you'll keep going backwards and forwards backwards and forwards across the map and the first player to bring their camp marker up to full class up financially will be the winner of lewis and clark so what do we like about lewis and clark so the first thing that we really really like about lewis and clark is the fact
that this game utilizes dual use cards in a really really novel way not only can you use the abilities of the characters as you see fit you know as you see them but you could flip them over to power up other cars and i haven't really seen this much in many games at when this was released back in way back in the day i can't remember 2012 somewhere i didn't really see this very much it was a really novel way of doing something so you got to be thinking am i going to keep the cards in my hand to actually sort of get the resources i need because more often than not you're going to be using the lower powered cars like the dog and the one that gives you wouldn't that to power out the cars but then there might be occasions when you might want to use some of the extra cars that you got from the display to give you that little bit more power when you're trying to augment the really decent cars you know so it's a really nice choice between which way you're going to go with respect to utilizing the abilities of the cars you know i mean so the second thing that we really like about lewis and clark is that this game effectively utilizes a mishmash of other genres you've got deck building in there because you'll be taking cards from the display adding them into your hand playing them and then scooping them all back up again you've got the racing element where it's going to be the first player to set up camp in full clap sop clock clack sack you've got to work a placement element where you'll be placing the indian meeples onto the board ala stone age and then also you've got that hand management as well which we just talked about on previous points so the fact that this game amalgam makes all the probably the most popular genres or
mechanics of previous games and really effectively meshes them into a really coherent package super so the next thing that we really like about lewis and clark is it's really intriguing the way this game tempts you into loading up your player board with all the junk possible only to turn around here at the end of your turn and say hang on a minute mate i think you're carrying too much there you need to offload some of that junk right so in order to win this game you're going to be forced into a position to carry as much stuff as possible but in order to move forward you're going to have to be as light as possible right so the game operates around this sort of balance of how much are you willing to risk carrying up against how quickly do you feel you can move through the wilderness well that is also fantastic that is so the final thing that we really like about lewis and clark is this game looks absolutely amazing it's a beautiful sight to behold on on the table you've got the rich colors of the actual map it looks absolutely fantastic and the detailed artwork on the character cards really brings this game alive and one of the other amazing things about this game whilst everyone starts with the same type of cards each player's got different characters on the same cards that they've got right so there's this wild variety of characters that are anchored in history and you've even got this sort of bibliography sort of thing at the back of the rule book that tells you a little bit of stuff around all the
characters and that's really lovely we do like that about games when they they go the extra mile to anchor the theme down in your head so what don't we like about lewis and clark so the first thing that we don't like about lewis and clark is that when you grab all the indians from the center of the board there's not really any sort of incentive not to grab those indians because more often than not you are going to be using them all up and they're not going to be hanging about on your board either you know what i mean so 99 of the time if it's your turn and you've got the opportunity to grab all them indians who are in the center of board you're going to do it in your and that means that everybody else is gonna basically have no way of performing those worker placement actions okay this ain't too bad and look at maybe a three-player game but when you're talking like a five-player game there's going to be occasions where everybody but one player isn't really going to be able to do much more than half the game right it might be the case that when that opportunity comes around again to grab those indian meeples from the center of the board you're going to miss out because you didn't have the right card or you'd already done something with it and so you might have to sit out and if you missed this once or twice or three times you are stuffed right so just seems a little bit unbalanced if you've got the opportunity to take those indian meeples you're going to gobble them up in yeah so the next thing we don't like about lewis and clark is that whilst it's part of the main game moving your scout marker loads and loads of spaces forward because you played a good round only to see it move back
x amount of spaces it can be a little bit frustrating it's like a tug of war mechanism this is especially even more frustrating when you've built up the means to move through the mountains only to find that you have miscalculated and you have to go back so there's this frustrating element to it where you feel like you're progressing but really you're not you're actually sort of taking a step back every time you know so the final thing that we don't like about lewis and clark is that we found that the equipment the grey cubes you need these to be able to buy characters right the fundamental part of that process but in such short supply that it makes the purchasing of these characters insanely difficult and again it's exacerbated in higher player games when you're talking like five players in that you are going to be banging your head against a brick wall and there have been occasions where somebody has actually threatened to kill me because i've gone to the equipment space twice in a row and they've not been able to get anywhere i know this game shouldn't incite people to murder but it does so to summarise his lewis and clark still worth playing maybe buying a second edition today and maybe next tuesday so we're going to say yes this is a captivating and engaging visual feast that attempts to capture the spirit of multiple genres in board games and pulls it off with spectacular ease it can be frustrating watching your scout barker move forward and your camp marker never quite catching up to
it simply because you didn't get an opportunity to grab those indian meeples or maybe you missed out on the car because you couldn't get any equipment space by the end of the day this is a game that rewards your ability to see balance and the frustration that emerges from this game is usually born out a misguided desire to move forward too quickly or to carry too much clobber when you ain't got the means to do so so we are going to give lewis and clark four out of five like i said this version we've got is our print but it's just been reprinted in a second edition i'm led to believe there's not been that many rule changes there might be a couple of little nuances have been added or taken away if you know what they are then leave a comment down in that section there it's uh it's an intriguing game it's a beautiful looking game and we like this one a lot so there you go that's lewis and clark remember if you're new here please consider subscribing to this channel leave a comment in that section down below and we'll see you next time you