In Defense of UNFATHOMABLE and FROM THE ABYSS
Transcript
I was wrong about unfathomable I fell for the meme and became the fool a buffoon of my own making like those dudes in Plato's Cave I stared at what I thought was real and was convinced that unfathomable was a hollowed out version of the alltime classic board game battl Star Galactica unfathomable was the rebranded knockoff like offbrand cereals and teu electronics to the Glorious original and this sentiment was everywhere and all discourse really just came down to it's just a worst Battle Star so why even bother but a very recent expansion from the abyss came out and I thought it might be a neat idea to try it all together and see if this ship was salvageable at its core unfathomable is a game about trusting people to do the right thing so what's the game in unfathomable three to six players will set sail to Boston on the SS Atlantica and throughout the 3ish hour Journey you'll be able to help or hinder the cruise you'll start the game off by picking a unique character grab an item have your ultimate feed ability go to your staring room and really just hope for the best now the twist of this cruise ship is that instead of being Infested by Boomers and norovirus you've got to deal with fish people these little buddies are the Deep ones and their father deeon and mother Hydra all invade and attack the ship but they have also infiltrated traded Humanity with
secret hybrid players yes that's right there are Traders on board and just like a top 10 anime betrayal list the game encourages you to lie to your Naka each player will be handed a loyalty card either human or fish hybrid and that determines your goal for the game your loyalty isn't inherently set in stone cuz at the halfway point of the game you'll receive an additional loyalty card that could flip you from Human to hybrid for example in a five-player game there would be a deck of 10 Loyalty cards eight of them would be humans and two would be Fishman hybrids who would want to syn the ship what this means is that at the very start of the game there is a 22% chance to have zero hybrids 55% to have one hybrid and 22% to have both hybrids in play at the very start in other words some games You'll Play half the game and there won't even be an evil team and other games you'll find two fifths of the players are already sabotage from the very beginning this first draw results in an incredibly different experience and different strategies that end up being employed by everyone involved and the reason why I love this is that even if no one is a hybrid there is still a ton of accusations that get thrown about and on the flip side there's always a way for a hybrid player to hide this doubt of whether they exist or not like a raw chicken nugget the illusion of tastiness can often be covered by a batter of Deceit then at about the halfway point
to our journey to Boston there is more certainty of what the exact competition of loyalties are there's still always a tinge of uncertainty though because what if someone got the hybrid card twice it adds a few layers into the reveal itself because whatever that mystery card someone else just received just adds to the drama of it all now some people may say well what about four players or six player games I heard Battle Star is only playable at five players and thankfully unfathomed liable has implemented a massive improvement over battar with the addition of the cultist the cultist is kind of a third faction in a way they're human who desperately wants to become a fish person but this transformation takes time so the cultist does their absolute best to keep the ship afloat until the very end stage where they finally Sprout their gills and become a hybrid player the reason why this works so well is that it really helps with the balance to make human players get to that final stretch but then that final stretch is even harder since the cultist has now flipped into a Fishman hybrid it creates an increasing flow of tension because the other hybrid players know their best bet is to wait and sink at the very end and humans know that that final stretch is going to be a very tough struggle unfathomable breeds in murky suspicion between players even a player who is an evil fish hybrid isn't too sure if they're alone or have Secret supporters at the start of the game it
is truly a Traer game that makes all the Hybrids feel isolated since they're all hiding from each other and other players and this sense of suspense escalates as more problems occur just like any terrible workplace someone needs to be blamed for all the problems aboard and this all culminates in a grand betrayal like how Judas betrayed Christ for 30 pieces of silver the hybrids will reveal themselves for the sweet sweet Embrace of mother Hydra these reveals are often hilarious and some of the most memorable moments of all board games after 3 hours of a long journey to Boston having the captain reveal himself as a hybrid and the crew just loses some more sanity is just fun memorable and cuts deep into the psyche from all those times we trusted him the constant fear and suspicion of one another is so tangible and it's so deliciously clever and look I won't lie unfathomable is a long and sometimes complex game running at between 2 to 4 hours at any player count and with dozens of interlocking mechanics character abilities loyalties and a ton of decks unique skill decks an item deck a spell deck a waypoint deck a damage deck a chaos deck and the one and only big chunky Mythos deck it's a lot of decks and I didn't even mention the deck board spaces all of this can be overwhelming to any player but I find that as long as one player is familiar with the game even even casual gamers can wrap their head around the game in the same way
that blood on the clock tower has a disproportionate knowledge requirement for the Storyteller unfathomable needs one player to manage the enemies manage the movement of the ship to make players aware of potential actions or triggers and to keep track of all the tracks you need a person to be the glue otherwise everything will fall apart into disarray and mismatched decks of confusion that said the game Loop is fairly simple all all a human player needs to do is draw skill cards do two actions draw the bad news Mythos card and then discard to 10 cards that's really only four main steps of each turn and two of those steps only take a few seconds the hard part is deciding what actions to take and the long part is going over the Mythos card and solving that crisis when it comes to actions this is usually involving the ship itself you might speed up the ship by using the boiler real or use the chapel and get on your knees to prry the monsters away or move and fight some deep ones rescue passengers or use one of your action cards or a unique character ability there's a ton of variety but the actual actions are very fast and easy to complete often just requiring a dice roll the fact that there are ton of potential actions but you're limited to only two actions per turn creates an interesting puzzle for both the human and hybrid players maximize an action economy like your playing brass is the meat of the individual ual strategy on the flip side the Mythos cards can often be the
longest part of anyone's turn Mythos cards are the problems that you encounter on the ship at the end of every single turn these cards might be helping lost kittens first class passengers or a call from an unimaginable whor who wants to destroy your fragile psyche sometimes a player will need to make a choice and other times you'll need to contribute cards from your hand to do something called a skill check a skill check is kind of like having everyone put in ingredients into a recipe but since you're putting these ingredients in blindly someone could sabotage this recipe for example if they were told to put in salt but they put in Sugar there could be potential to ruin the eventual cook this leads to many opportunities of terrible terrible sabotage from hybrids and cultists by poisoning the success of the human players through subtle manipulation of these checks and key decisions of course after the Mythos card is resolved enemies move as well whether that's going deeper into the ship or attacking from the exterior there's a lot of problems that arise after each and every turn and even for hybrids and cultists they'll be following the same routine as humans but instead they try to keep stumbling over themselves as much as possible failing dice rolls making bad decisions and really just playing as suboptimally as they possibly can without making it obvious it's hilarious because sometimes you'll suspect someone of being a fish person because they're playing poorly but they just angered the RNG gods and
can't help but draw the worst possible Mythos cards or fail the most critical dice roll without any ill intent even when a hybrid or cultist revealed thems as a fish the general gameplay Remains the Same except now you get access to a new treachery deck and you can't use the ship's bases freely but you can attack other humans and get yourself attacked it adds a new Dynamic to the game but does feel weaker than being secretly hidden that said revealing as a hybrid does enable a one-time character specific power to really mess up whatever good thing is going on it can often be used as an opportunistic attack to sink the ship in one Fell Swoop in other words you can go all out and release your Ultra Instinct in onetime Trader abilities but after you've done your master stroke you're an easy target for human players to take down it's all very approachable and Mak sense in the context of the game even with people who are new to board games the concept of the feat in fish enemies rescuing passengers and going to Rooms to activate them is a very tangible and engaging experience you just need that one person to manage the admin of enemy movements and attacks as well as to keep track of all the dials and movements my favorite example of the Ingenuity of this game is when enemies are in the water space and the ship moves forward all the enemies get pushed back one space representing that the ship is physically moving past these sea monsters people's eyes light up and it's obvious that they understand how the movement of the ship connects to the placement of enemies without needing to explain enemy movements from the nuts
and bolts perspective each individual mechanic is approachable and unfathomable layers them in a way to create a very logical and flavorful sandwich of themes and decisions okay so that's the quick and dirty summary of what to expect from the base game so why then did I think I was so wrong about this game well everything in the base game was good it was fine but the Battle Star Galactica people had a point point it's a rethe of game that already existed but I loved my time with battar and I wanted to capture the same feelings of betrayal and Triumph without spending 500 plus for the game and all its expansions so while the base game of unfathomable feels like a best of collection for battar Galactica from the abyss takes unfathomable into its own thing and brings new ideas into the mix and while the base game is definitely a complete game but I really think the expansion rounds the sometimes rough edges and makes the game feel truly full in other words the expansion doesn't really aim to change the fundamentals but wants to add a glycin Sheen and polish that changes a passable experience into a fantastic one so starting off from the abyss provides a bunch of start of game modifiers in the form of preludes some good ones bad ones neutral ones and each type has five different cards what you do is draw one of each type and modify the initial state of the game and I'm a total fan of these and I use all three for each game in the base game the initial board state
is the same each time so having these slight modifications to add new problems and new solutions to the very start keeps the game fresh some players also use these preludes to adjust the balance if the hybrid team has been crushing it you would only draw the Day card for example truthfully I wish there were more of these added because while five of each is fine M seeing repeats and I would have liked 10 to 15 of each just to keep things surprising in each game still good stuff overall eight new characters of course what's an expansion without new characters and from the abyss almost doubles the base 10 to 18 each character is very flavorful unique and most importantly fun most people just play off Vibes so it's important that they added the iy dead people kid hardworking fisher woman and The Fez wearing Turkish detective I feel like the rooster of 18 is really enough to work with any group and while 10 characters was sufficient 18 feels full and Polished furthermore the strategy of each character really does meld with their character's lore and items for example Avery the boat Swain is just an really outwardly likable and popular dude so his ability is that you can use allies on the boat without paying a cost and he also has the onetime ability to spawn more allies and also take over as the captain or Keeper of the to from all the popular support he has gilaman is also centered around that same mechanic of allies but instead of gaining their
support through popularity is a spiritualist who can speak to them in death so instead of interacting with them on the ship L collects their souls and uses their abilities after they are dead and a lot of characters share the same design philosophy some enable other players reduce RNG or cheat out extra actions but each character takes a substantially different way in approaching a mechanic that really dramatically changes the overarch in strategy which of course also changes depending if you are a hybrid or human player as well which just further adds layers into this Feast of decisions I very much appreciate the design of the characters from a gameplay perspective they each feel unique but since they aren't limited to potential roles like in BSG team composition is less important for the success of the ship you don't necessarily need a well-rounded team to have a great game which often felt like a requirement in BSG and the unique abilities starting items and Feats are very in levels of complexity and wackiness again it's it's all good stuff allies now speaking of allies allies are another new mechanic that represent other crew members or passengers on the ship with active abilities they spawn when you save a group of passengers and in order to use them you need to be in their space and discard a certain amount of skill card value now I should mention that allies do exist in ballar as well and while the idea is the same their functionality is very different overall the Allies in
unfathomable let you cheat out powerful extra abilities every turn for a cost if you need to fix a space but don't want to move that space well you got the mechanic if you want to Stack the Mythos deck there's a fortune teller if you want to rescue a passenger you got the able seam I find that using allies as a human player is almost always worth it if they are already in a convenience in space with that player not to mention they're just a fun idea you get to do more actions per turn and they Scurry away afterwards and if they happen to get caught in the ritual spell they just all die from either getting deleted or get put on the spiritualist board as a soul it's fun thematic and adds a layer of emergent storytelling that keeps the flavor going Boons another addition is always the positive Boon cards which are the yin to the Yang of the treachery cards Boon cards have powerful ability as well as are always positive for skill checks but they are rare to be drawn with the Boon cards the chaos deck is now modified to have seven possible skill cards Boon really round out the skill decks into something that feels fairer and just more interesting even though not the flashiest Edition I find all this under the hood improvements as very meaningful because the game is now a bit more wild and there is more possibility for human players to fight back what sometimes feels like insurmountable odds hor Horrors if you just take a look on the box the biggest selling point of this expansion are the three additional enemy types the horrors these three types spawn a little
differently than the matriarchs and the Deep ones and use an activation track to spawn one of them you got the tentacles the drowned Spirit dude and The strog Goth and each one of these is a little different for example the grasp and tendril these tentacles will go into the water and pull passengers from the ship into water to eventually drown them and die the shogo spawns on the outer deck of the ship and will defeat players destroy interiors and eat items from the item deck and the drowned Spirit spawns directly inside of the interior of the ship and starts damaging the insides while destroying cards found in the toome all three of these whes are a middle ground between the easily defeated deep ones and the Untouchable matriarchs while these three types can be defeated in combat they don't die they just move further away and in a way there are quite sticky and a persistent threat on the board that said as a human player I don't find them too overbearing as they are a bit slow to spawn and their effects aren't necessarily worse than a bad set of deep ones rampaging throughout the ship when playing the horrors add a nice element of anxiety because they can be a little tricky to destroy through the spell track or having the ship move beyond their reach they provide another opening for a hybrid or cultist to create chaos also now with six different enemy types the the overall variety of each game is dramatically improved and each game feels fresh and challenging in a different way the horrors are a massive success in my opinion as they increased enemy variety without ever feeling
unfair or skewed in the favor of the hybrid players partly because human players have added tools with the Allies but also partly because these Horrors do feel a bit like a slow threat relative to the blitz of the deep ones or the Unstoppable attacks from mother Hydra it's just good game design another new threat that moves slow but is hard to remove just fills in the blanks that have been previously missing and rounds out the enemies in a meaningful way additional items spells Waypoint and skill cards of course what's an expansion without filling out every Deck with more stuff from the abyss adds more of everything from unique and Powerful items to some of the best spells in the game as well as two new skill cards for each Deck with new mechanics such as the zero value skill cards that enable and effect after the skill check is done or these Ultra powerful six value ones every deck is bigger better and the variety is just significantly improved I can't think of a single complaint or negative to any of these additions likewise minor rule amendments like saving all passengers and one deck space and one action or drawn three spells instead of two all improve the game in subtle ways that I appreciate the Mythos deck of all of the additions the one I appreciate the most is the addition of the Mythos most Deck cards you know all the stuff I mentioned previously represents about half of the game because the other half is in all of this the Mythos deck this deck is so core to the flow of the game so having a good deck is necessary for unfathomable being
a good game and thankfully from the abyss almost doubles the size of this deck with fun and interesting cards these decisions can be very tough sometimes and the skill checks feel fair and Powerful when passed but brutal when failed It's a Wonderful deck of problems to solve and I very much appreciate the extra heft to it all it's a meaty pack of cards from the wacky inconsequential squabbles of the first class passengers to the calls of the deep to the personal dramas that need to be dealt with this Mythos deck feels well crafted and sets the pace of the entire game and just look how thick this deck is there's so much variety and just so much that keeps happening each game still feels fresh having this thick and refined deck is very very welcome considering it's almost half of the game look when you put all of unfathomable and from the abyss together there is a feeling of responsibility to one another because the game can be so Unforgiven at times human players really do need to trust one another to do the right thing to push the right button and to have trust in one another this part of the game is genius because as a hybrid it is very easy to be willing to help human players outwardly but to sabotage from the shadows and what I mean by this is the game encourages outward support and friendliness against what seems to be impossible odds how many times will a shog goth attack us how many deep ones are on board now we
only have two fuel and three sandity left it's a constant set of problems and constant stress so human players will need to turn to anyone to help them and a smart hybrid player will help outwardly while secretly ruining the skill checks or pretending not to have any Buffs or just by picking the most suboptimal path forward unfathomable is completely unlike other social deduction games or survival games because brilliantly the game isn't always guaranteed to have someone who's on the evil team at the start like I mentioned before in a five player game about 22% of all games won't even start with someone evil but there's always some suspicion the game adds just enough room for error that even if everyone is human you can still accuse of someone of being a fish person yes by the end of the game there will always be at least one guaranteed hybrid player but even then the previous Acquisitions carry from the early stages of the game which provide further room for Bluffin for the true hybrid player and this leads me to a very common complaint which is the brg this prison space locks up players and a lot of criticism is levied that if you go into the brag all the fun is suck drve from your turns and I really don't see it that way going to the brg isn't like a death sentence like dying in Nemesis or Mafia I especially found that because the game is so oppressive at what is going to be attacking human players putting another human player in the brig is often enough to guarantee a
loss players are smart enough to know this and using the brig is often just a last resort or used against a player who is obviously a hybrid but hasn't revealed themselves from The Game's perspective these soft revealed players actively demonstrate that they have no interest in helping humans but don't want to reveal as a hybrid yet and at least in my group's meta the brg is reserved for these players and then they reveal and they get out B discard and skill cards and in fact I find the brig a very very mild form of player elimination that has more than enough counterplay to be a healthy addition to the game another common complaint is the games are too long and too complicated and have too much admin busy work first on the game length unfathomable runs between 2.5 to 4 hours depending on how fast people play player count doesn't really matter either because the endgame objective of either sinking the ship or reaching Boston requires the same total resource depletion damage or distance traveled which isn't shortened by having fewer players you can expect to play around 30 turns per game so with four players that's about eight turns each and with six players that's about five turns per player in other words the total amount of turns doesn't change but individual impact is reduced because you'll have fewer turns per player it's not really to say that one player count is best though five feels the most standard but the cultist is a very
healthy addition to the game and having four players would create a stronger sense of individual player agency the truth of it is that the actual time you're moving your characters around and acting is fairly minimal there are not a lot of actions available for a 3-hour game which can make people feel like they lack agency I think this is a fair point but I don't think it's much of a critique and the reason for this is the actions are not the entire game a ton of the game is in the Mythos deck and resolving these Mythos cards discussing the options joining in for the skill check revealing the value of the cards themselves this is all also part of the collective game everyone is playing just because you aren't reading the Mythos card doesn't mean it doesn't matter to you or that you can't interact with it and you're going to resolve a lot of these cards what's on the board and the actions you take on the board itself isn't the full game the game is also a little story book of little problems and little Choose Your Own Adventure style consequences that is all communally discussed and weighed and analyzed not to mention the whole social deduction aspect of the game that fall follows after each and every turn and that's why I was so glad to see that the Mythos deck got a hefty upgrade in the expansion because seeing a never seen before Mythos card is fun and is a large part of what keeps this game together even though you have fairly limited actions and yes it can take some time to come back to you doesn't mean that you don't have direct input in the
trajectory of the game as a whole and like a social deduction game a lot of the fun is played between players and between reading the lines of each other's decisions multiplayer solitire fans just won't get it and on the admin nah the enemy management is super easy and follows a very simple logic it should only take 30 seconds to resolve a large swath of attacks and damage to the ship same with spawning them and moving them you just really need one person to read the rules ahead of time and understand how everything interacts and I really just don't see this as an issue it's impossible not to recognize the big old Battle Star that looms over the SS Atlantica people love BSG the characters and the theme are blended into the game that only a few other games can rival but and I know this is a little sacriligious to say I don't really play BSG after I've played unfathomable with its expansion unfathomable and from the abyss take everything that worked well in BSG and refined it into a more thoughtful smooth and just funner experience components like the sylon fleet board are revamp stamped in a new and much more improved bordon of deep ones and Horrors the miracle cards of Daybreak are so much worse than the feed cards that each character gets in unfathomable the addition of the cultist over the human or sylon sympathizer role and the sylon leader role is just so much better and easier to play with it actually makes the four and six player games rival
those of five players the removal of junk mechanics like risking Raptors or having to be a pilot to fight syon ships are all gone and benef official to the flow of the game even the character abilities both normal and Trader abilities are more useful and create a better balance than the often thematic but poorly implemented character abilities in BSG everything in infath themable just works without the admittedly Charming clunkiness of ESG there is no doubt that Battlestar forged itself into a classic and yes Battlestar and its three expansions still has more content and modules than unfathomable and from the abyss but a lot of that content and alternative game modules are bloat that dilute what makes this type of game fun the emergent storytelling is better thanks to the streamlining and improvements to the gameplay in unfathomable the truth is unfathomable and from the abyss is a beefy full game but keeps everything in work in order because of smart decisions and adaptations from its progator the mechanics all work together make sense and there is more more than enough variety with its large cast new enemies and various gameplay improvements it sails its own path and succeeds in improving a classic game in tangible ways yes it lacks a recognizable theme but I find that a lot of people are polarized over the BSG theme to begin with fans of the show love it and people who don't watch it are mostly
indifferent or even slightly apprehensive unfathomable is a very approachable well executed but generic theme that is entice enough for almost anyone but look just hold on for one minute most games have a generic theme fantasy historical sci-fi nature and even yes lovecraftian it's nearly impossible for a board game to complete with a wellestablished franchise to create an IP that's as strong as four seasons of a TV show it just isn't fair to say well I just couldn't relate to William BG in the same that I could with President Roslin when you've seen like 75 episodes of TV compared to a short four paragraph backstory and the Counterpoint is that you've already created a personality based off the IP therefore in a way the generic theme in in unfathomable creates room for role play that's wouldn't be possible with those who are familiar with characters in BSG anyways a lot of people say it's a onetoone adaptation with a slapped on cthulu theme and that just isn't the case fathomable is more akin to a successor than it is to a the Clone yes it doesn't have a licensed recognizable theme to lean on but the characters the set in the gameplay all melt together into creating something that's worth getting a bunch of people together for an evening of mishaps and suspense there's another common complaint and that is the game is fundamentally unbalanced the truth is yeah the game is kind of all over the place I think the
biggest problem people have is that after a few games you'll realize that the hybrid players tend to win more often than not I'd say it's about a 7030 win loss for hybrids which can really break the mind of those sweats out there who really like to optimize and treat each game as a competitive Endeavor and what really annoys me is that whenever I read discourse online about this balance it's all over the place some people complain about how an early revealed Trader is too powerful with their new treachery cards other people complain that the soft revealed hybrid in the galley is too powerful other people think that the game itself is too hard and the trader can just remain hidden and Crush all hopes over one or two key skill checks it really reminds me of when a brand new game comes out and there's threads about how X character is broken or y character is useless or the most OP Strat but when you compile all these conversations everything is broken and everything is underpowered simultaneously it's been a conversation since BSG first came out and I recommend just to Zone it out zone out the noise and enjoy your own game with your own groups meta and the thing is I know why this is a problem unfathomable invites a paradox it's a 3ish hour long game with dozens of interlocking mechanics it has a ton of depth and variance but if it's played like a hyperco competitive game you're going to have a bad time so it invites people who really like complex and long and detailed high conflict games but at the same time it isn't
viable as a competitive game and to me this really isn't a problem it's just best played as a vehicle to have fun and have an emergent story not competition if you go in with that mindset the win loss ratio of what team wins doesn't really matter and secondly I don't think this game is balanced around each team but instead balanced around the goal to have a very close squeaker of a game the game is designed to make those final few turns matter and to always feel like you're at the very edge of success and it is a success because the game consists instantly reaches that very final round where making it home to Boston is so close but you only have one or two of a key resource left this balance this tension is far more important than the actual win loss ratios because the story has a climax and the tension Rises to a peak the game works amazingly for the goal it has and I find this far more important than the actual balance and the trick of this is that this buildup this climax it all feels well deserved and is unique every game it's not an exercise in predestination like Candyland or secret Hitler unfathomable and from the abyss is both deep and vast when you make it to those final rounds you've actually done the work you've made the decisions and the journey feels unique it is rewarding whether you win or lose because the story you and your buddies went on is memorable and the strategies either paid off or crippled the ship Beyond repair it's a joy to experience an unfathomable recognizes that
providing the decision space and depth and Str strategy to create these unique experiences is what really matters if you go into unfathomable and from the abyss with the intent to min max as a soft revealed hybrid and start counting skill cards like a deranged poker player looking to steal any chance of Victory against people who've played maybe once or twice before yeah you're probably going to win the competitive aspect of the game at least but if the point of the game is to have a fun emerging story did you really win anything unfathomable is not that kind of competitive sweaty game to play it as a vehicle for your competitiveness needs every other person on board to share the same mentality and at that point you'll be overcome by the frustrations of RNG and the intended innate imbalance of the game and it wouldn't even work as a competitive game so why bother gajin aeta when you could just enjoy the ride as a more emerging story with high conflict and high interaction it's just wrong of course there's a lot of strategy planning and play style expression and you should always try to win but trying to argue that the game isn't perfectly balanced between characters or loyalties is a moot point in my opinion you definitely have player agency and a ton of it but the game can really change on a dime at any given moment heck in about a quarter of your five player games you won't even start with a hybrid player on the board and these games are much easier to win than the ones where you start with two
hybrids on board but that's that's why it's fun it's suspense and it's story and it's supposed to make your buddies laugh of course the balance is out of whack and if you're on a lost streak there's house rules or even recommended Prelude cards to adjust the game balance but I believe it wasn't the goal to make a perfectly balanced game it was a goal to create a lengthy fun deep tense game of suspicions and betrayals which unfathomable ultimately succeeds in there is nothing wrong with a juicy meaty game that isn't designed as a competitive game and in this way I applaud the design I get it I felt the same way too How could a game that just slaps on a generic cthulu IP overtake one of the titans of all a board gaming but unfathomable has won me over the rebalancing of the game the new mechanics the streamlining of Core Concepts have all pushed the game from what might have seen like a knockoff into its own thing worthy of existing and worthy of time and money then you add on from the abyss with the very helpful allies the new characters the new enemy types and the giant sack of Mythos cards and the game is pushed into a new better Direction than anything that battl star did it feels shockingly fresh and the gameplay is just smoother than ever and Nostalgia is a hell of a drug and when we look back at all those old memories and hilarious reveals or being tossed in the brig as a sylon we
can still look at those moments and recognize that battar can still be a bit of a messy game unfathomable is approachable teachable and an improved version for a generation of players who have probably never even seen a single episode of battl Star Galactica truthfully a lot of people who played really felt like the cthulu theme was cohesive and engaging throughout the 3-hour play time and when I mentioned it was based off an older BSG game there was a visible confusion on what Battlestar Galactica was and how relates to fish people PSG is not as notable as a franchise as it was in 2009 so playing a game based on it isn't inherently a positive for all people that said there is definitely a saturation of cthulu on the market but there is obvious care in the models the character the boat itself everything is made with the theme in mind it just might not be your preferred theme because of this I have to concede unfathomable with from the abyss is my favorite hidden Trader game games like Nemesis or dead of winter would be in the same family of games but unfathomable smartly avoids the pitfalls of these games and has a stronger core gameplay Loop than the great ancestor of the genre BSG and I have to give unfathomable with from the abyss a solid 9 out of 10 it's just a very good time and if you go in with the right mindset and aren't tripped up by Nostalgia I think you'll find an excellent journey to share laughs and make memorable
moments with friends thank you for watching