First Martians Review - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
Diana cannibalized my playstation 4 just fix our blown-up part in that lab Jeffrey went out in the rover we haven't seen a Berber a day yeah all the oxygen ages are on the blink I can barely breathe the plants won't grow everything's to blow it up and not working around here and it's stressful can't even get a moment to myself and yet I feel something's out there something's staring at me through the windows I know it's there it's watching it's watching me every day greetings everyone another program equal review here i'm luke hector and today we're talking about everybody's favorite board gaming related topic mars yeah there seem to be a thing going around in 2016 through to the early 17 where everything was just all about mars i don't know what caused it it's not like it suddenly became mainstream i don't know whether it was the martian film that did it the Matt Damon one which I have to confess I've still not watched I'm not sure if I would like it
or not but I'll give it a watch sometime it's on my it's on my ever growing list of movies I need to check out but I don't know whether that caused it or resurgence in this thing but some at some point every publisher and designer was like Mars game Mars game Mars game Mars game is just like no other planet no all Mars I'm get it we've had some really obscure ones from my indie publishers and some light you know ones across the waters yeah we've had terraforming Mars which as much as I don't like it you know is as popular as all get-out to the point where I'm starting to do get and or even seen it on Twitter every five minutes but you know it's just something about it why it's the Red Planet up in the sky is it really that interesting I don't know but you know there's all sorts of stuff you can do in space why Mars and even mission Red Planet on my shelf over there yeah again Mars what is it about Mars anyway I digress today though I'm taking a look at yet another Mars game first Martians this from a nasty drum check and oil games is basically kind of like a sequel a pseudo sequel to Robinson Crusoe which I do have my show here it's all good it's heavy in it's cool second edition perform I've had it since the first edition great you're a co-op game one of my favorites incredibly formatic it just suffered from a being extremely hard because it's like very hard to win this game even the tutorial mission and it suffered from not being the best with mass players I always found it better as a solo game
maybe to player and I started I played it more so than anything else and the other thing was that the rulebook was not particularly great it was long it was illogical it wasn't written very well and it made learning the game after you put it down for a while extremely difficult this addition vastly improved the rulebook to where I can get out a bit more often so there we go first Martians again a sequel you're now on Mars you are running a base it's very science driven you're in this base you've got the vehicles to go out and scout the landscape you've got all these systems everywhere I lit up by green cubes and all these systems will fail don't malfunction things will go wrong and in each at the various scenarios you are doing everything from trying to get your plants to grow to wondering where the rover has gone this scene actually landing on the planet and setting up base fixing all sorts of problems yet there's all sorts of very varied scenarios in this and the idea with how this differs from Robinson Crusoe is more that there is an app integration the app helps you set up the game and also dictates the story and events that will happen you're basically key in whether you do story driven events with your workers it's very much a worker placement game and it will also through each turn bring up random events that will affect the game so it kind of replaces needing the deck of card do that and you can also in the Box play through a couple of campaign modes one of them which is actually legacy driven you know so once
you've played for it you can't play through it again and these will incorporate like changes to your character throughout each game changes to how the game plays I won't go into too much more detail on that suffice to say I don't want to spoil any of them but you've got quite a bit of content to get through the idea is is that in a traditional work of placement style you have your two pawns and you'll place them out on the various locations to do actions if you only use one pawn to do it then you end up having a risk of a lot wounding yourself failing the task or having certain events happen which again are driven by the app if you send as many pawns as is required like two pawns usually but it can be more then you Auto succeed the task and basically the game just carries on through usually anything between say about six to ten rounds depending on the scenario and you'll basically go through until you meet the objectives or you lose outright each scenario is given by essentially a tour sheet like this double-sided with the scenario on it tells you all the rules tells you everything you need to know and basically each one is however you want to do it you want to just do a standalone scenario or do you want to do a campaign mode so first up let's stick with something easy the component quality actually I think it's pretty solid but this actually you know Robinson Crusoe was pretty well produced as well but here you've got you know really cool so pong discs you've got lots of cool looking sort of luminescent dye stuff wrote the board is a mixture of tiles with you know grab one here
it's all set up I was playing a game this earlier yeah you've got a towel here with the various light in that's there for all the cubes there is a like cubes and there is a bit of a setup you know that these cubes there you've got to set up all the tiles put green cubes into everything to say like it's working or red cubes to say it's malfunctioning setup can take a little bit of a while with that but the app tells you what to do every scenario will say right app tells you put these things out as per the rulebook put these things out specifically these cubes specifically these locations you know so it's very easy to get sort pick it up and go with your first game once you've got the rule books we'll get into that later but you've got some you know decent looking cubes you've got you know fairly not necessary but you're cool miniatures for things like the rover and your base the board itself looks pretty no nice and it it's not like busy or anything it's just more that it looks like a big control panel almost in front of you think best example I fought off was do you remember in the old days there was that mech warrior game that came out with this huge control panel is your joystick and you had like the two joysticks and all these buttons you had the press you remember that but this kind of gave me that same look yeah you feel like the board you're looking at is a giant control panel with a map on one side and all the buttons and everything on the other and it just I don't know it looks pretty sweet from that point of view for my sake anyway the cards a pretty good linen finished quality you know it's very colorful you know there's all sorts of different colors all over the shop so
although I was pretty satisfied with the component quality I didn't find anything to miss nothing was considered to be bad and as for the app I pretty like I like the app I know it had a few bugs and issues when it first came out but I had no issues with it it taught me that the setups easily it ran through each scenario without a problems you know installing it was not an issue and the campaign mode was easy enough to you know run through and I like the way that the app handled a lot of the bookkeeping an aspect goes in Robinson Crusoe you had a deck of cards you had to put stuff in shuffle the marks see when it came up or ever and you know what people are like when you shuffle stuff in the decks it's like Oh conveniently that card just happened to hit the bottom in it well you can't do that with this the app is dictating your story so you ain't getting past that and yeah frozen a nice little bit of ambient music to create some atmosphere and it has the sound effects I think it's a pretty decent app and I'm all for you know I think the grating in games you've heard me rave on about XCOM and the few of the other white mansions a madness second edition saying how good their apps are this is another example of what I think is a decent app integration as well and I wish more games would take this stuff on board I think this is the future for board games to integrate apps into them they don't have to replace all the components but just have the app handle some of the bookkeeping because who here doesn't have a smartphone or a tablet somewhere come on most people who are gonna buy games like this have got that kind of technology to use this so that's
no excuse anymore I know it's not the easiest thing to do or the cheapest thing to do but I think we could get into more games people in terms of content and variety well you've gather a lot here you've got six scenarios as I mentioned with these you know these sheets and each one has got you know two sides you've got six scenarios you've got a campaign mode that will run through several of them in one go you've got one of them that's a legacy one so you know you have envelopes in the box that you only tear up when instructed to do so so that they're quite cool to open and you can get more content for this as the game goes on in fact already recently I think in the last month McNasty himself released another scenario called epidemic you print it off the internet looks exactly like one of these you just print it off laminate it and you're good to go and there you go one bonus scenario that came for free on the app an entire new scenario I've yet to try it but the game didn't originally come with it so I'm not gonna like you know incorporate that for the review but hey now I've got seven scenarios instead of six and you know that over time they could easily just come up with an eighth or a ninth and not and whether they charge for it I don't mind I mean if it's DLC and it's like maybe like a couple of quid or something you a few quid for a new scenario I'll take it you know Robinson Crusoe had the King Kong one you know that was pretty sweet so
you know I can't knock designer forgiving freed or but these cheap downloadable content for a game so you've got plenty enough to keep you going all the missions are very different you know that one of them will have you exploring more the other one has you researching more and they've all worked fanatically very well however this might put off a few people because I think some people who are playing a Martian game are looking more for that kind of exploring all of Mars checking out a ton of landscape maybe even finding aliens you know all sorts of that that proper out there sigh finest for going around Mars this is not like that the exploration part is basically one part of a map and it's mainly flipping over tiles and seeing water resources come available to you it's not quite a massive exploration game but there's very more science based you can tell a lot of effort went into these scenarios I mean they are complex in the way that they work and you know you'll have one that is collecting specific minerals from the like the planet and forming like binding agents and doing all this scientific stuff another one the plants one that I've actually just done actually was finding nutrients like potassium calcium magnesium and all that lot from the planet's surface and then you know doing you know extracting the nutrients of them in order feed your plants there's a lot of science mumbo-jumbo that goes into this and science was probably my weakest GCSE so it took me a little bit to understand it but I like the fact that such effort went into them but if
you're thinking that you want that full-on exploration of Mars you're not gonna get that here this is more about the science and the like that you know the the intellectual side of being on Mars this is much more a realistic approach thing I suppose maybe the Martian film I don't know I haven't watched it but you know forget all those sci-fi films where everybody's on Mars 200 years in the future and it can do all sorts with the surface and that yeah this is very much like almost kind of like a tiny bit into the future or even modern-day really I don't know but by being on Mars you've got your basic base and you're just doing the basic stuff I suppose I'm no doctor who's done a few things like that waters of Mars you remember that episode you know that's yeah that's sort of a basic base you're barely surviving you've gotta make do but you're there to basically sieve you can have been having it later it's it's a sweet theme I've got to give it credit you know I when I play this I feel like I am doing the whole Marcin I feel like the aquifer and all this stuff at me and as the systems go on and off as things break this has an impact on your game yo if the certain areas don't get enough oxygen or power they shut down you've got to repair them if plants start wilting away and you lack of food and you've got automated assistance for the you know they've got their own pulling car if you're playing with less than four players you can use those as drones for actions you've got the buggies to go out onto the planet's surface it does feel very rich in theme and that was a
big draw for me and a big plus we do have to talk a bit about that rule book though because yet again I said this was alien artifacts I said this with the original robinson crusoe the rulebook is not great and I know from other reviewers this put them off as well yeah the fact that it was very difficult to learn the game from the rulebook it had a lot of issues with my FAQ and stuff like that and as I read it it's got some weird designs for the pictorial examples with the font it's like it shows a pictorial example and then the font is like massive it's kind of weird it's not done particularly well and like I say this that does negatively affect this game however in recent months an almanac of the rules has been printed for free online on the portal website by aghhh nasty and his team and this Almanac is a much better rule book you can play the game from that almanac itself however if that's not helped then you can have the rule book as a supplement although to be honest the best way I learned this game was simply there you go he's on there go find Bradley Smith watch his video with the Almanac as a printed out supplement if you do that then playing this game is fine I've had no trouble now I can pick it up I can teach it to players without any issues whatsoever all because I've basically read through that Almanac and watch this video and they weren't great granted yes the Almanac is not part of this package so I granted if you bought
this game a long time ago it would have given you a bit of a you know a headache trying to learn it but nowadays rest assured if you get this now there is hope there is a way for you to learn this game very easily the almanac is good it's laid out in a much more logical fashion that pictorial examples are better it's not a hundred percent perfect I mean you've got to get used to the game overall but it's a lot better it's so much better to do that and of course what beats me if he does a great job at this video so again that helps in the way the game length is actually pretty good if you're playing with less or so players this is the same thing I happened Robinson Crusoe I never felt that Robinson Crusoe worked with three or four players occasionally would free but before I originally called Robinson Crusoe overrated because the first few games I played of it were for play when I eventually decided you know I'm gonna get the game and play as solo and two-player and they and see what happens I had to literally I apologize on nearly every other video where I talk about the game now because I have to accept that yeah Robinson Crusoe it's a great game but I now pretty much only play its solo or two-player occasionally free this one has that same issue this is not a game I feel like I want to play with three or four players certainly if they have no idea about Robinson Crusoe or anything like that that might go against that rule if they're big Mars fans and they would understand the science stuff more but again this feels so much better as a solo game or two players two players
works quite well but in solo mode I get to make all the decisions myself I get the drones that you know I can use to every round so I don't feel like I'm too restricting on actions just because I've got less astronauts it's I mean it does work with free or for players but again I just feel like this is a go to solo game but I can get a game wrapped up in about an hour yeah an hour for a solo game you know you know if I'm doing particularly well the absolute max the game should take you really is about 90 or so minutes and that's what like more players obviously but it just takes you a little bit of a learning curve to get to that stage but yeah I wish it was a bit better with more players because this is something I would like to show to more people but I feel like the game is not at its best when that happens with the exception of the campaign mode I don't think this game works with more players for standalone scenarios but I could see the potential for this with the campaign mode because when I've played this standard I haven't played the campaign mode with multiplayer I'll stress that now I've played it with solo mode and I really enjoyed it with multiplayer but the standalone scenarios I feel like maybe the game goes on a little bit too long and you don't get enough of that interaction with all your astronaut friends in terms of their characters changing but with the campaign mode I feel the multiplayer aspect is increased because then each person is having changes and skill levels for their particular astronaut and they feel more different from
another player in the standalone any kind of field same and that puts a few people off so it kind of depends what I'm doing I could see myself doing a multiplayer campaign mode with this game but I'd have to find people to do it regularly and you know who would understand the game although unlike most legacy games that have come out lately at least you only need to play I think five games I think there's about five games that you play for a campaign mode so it's it's nowhere near as long to do it you know when you take you months and weeks like things like Chara stone or pandemic legacy could do on top of the rulebook in the Almanac and everything you do have to accept that there is a fair amount to absorb with this you need to understand the iconography you need to understand what each cards do and things like that but also you kind of have to accept that these can be a little bit overwhelming when you read them I'm fine with them they give you like a little introduction so if I can point out on this one so gives you a bit of an introduction like a little bit blurb like the monitor text communication between Earth and Mars it then gives you like a timer track the title gives you some specific actions are unique some special like the tokens what are they what do they do when you go exploring the planet but there's a lot of text it is quite text heavy you can see just from these that there's a fair amount of text on there so it will take you a while to get used to a scenario and I can see that being a little overwhelming for people but I think that those who were gonna get into this game are probably gonna be used to reading a fair
amount of text on you know like a help reference sheet cuz this is definitely not a gateway game no way ever will I introduce this to new players not even the next step this is a gamer game you know a gamers co-op I could not see new players getting into this you know be a lot of rules a lot of stuff going on unless they were big on the Mars theme then maybe you can try it but not something I'm going to attempt put it that way so all in all I really do actually like first Martians it didn't quite meet my top ten of 2017 but it came close it was definitely in the 11 to 15 range the rule book being pretty bad is a negative the Almanac is decent it allows you to do it but course you have to get the Almanac print it off it doesn't come with the game it should really be packaged up it you know if they reprint this that Almanac needs to be a proper rulebook in the box that's how they need to do it and of course I had to go watch Rodney Rogers played in order to understand it better bad rule books are a negative got a factor that in there's definitely a lot of text to get through without the reference sheets and the theme is definitely not going to appeal to everybody it depends what you want from a Mars for you do you want the science aspect of it or do you want a bit more sci-fi kind of excitement exploration aspect if it's the latter you're probably not gonna get it in this game but if it's the former then you'll probably get a kick out of this one I certainly I think prefer it from a science aspect I learned a few things it
feels very much more realistic a realistic approach to it the app integration I think is solid I didn't have a problem with it I think it's really good that you can just add more scenarios over time so this has got a lot of content in the box you'll get your money's worth easily and more stuff will come out like I've got a whole new standalone scenario to try out now and I can try an easy medium hard difficulty I can add it to the campaign mode and try that again there's plenty of scope for this to grow and I understand that this has had a bit of a bad upbringing you know with the delays and the pre-order system and the fact that there was buggy when it first came out but I think now it's a solid title that is definitely worth checking out I know some reviewers have sort of hated on it a bit more I don't I can see why some people wouldn't like it though but personally I think I think this worked with me because I like fanatic coops and this is definitely that this is a very rich formatic game good component quality app integration takes a lot of effort out of it is text-heavy rule books not great I'll admit but conquer that first hurdle and you're well away to a very enjoyable co-op so for me to take everything into account I think my personal reading buddies I think is a pretty high eight it's it's got some issues like I say the robot can quite text of it it's a bit of a learning to get through but when you get round to it I wish you know it's a solid game I
just wish it was a bit bare with more players three or four is not my favorite way to play this but solo fantastic I love this as a solo game and two players worked pretty well as well I just think four is not great it takes a bit too long I think we'd four but maybe other people think differently that's the whole beauty of this hobby so that's it for me first Martians adventures on the Red Planet this one is my fate is it a mission Red Planet would probably still mean my favourite Mars game but the theme of that one is not necessarily tied to Mars specifically I mean you could replace mission bred fight it could be called mission green planet for all that matters really you just have Venus with the moon you know what difference would it make really I think penis hasn't learned I'm not sure my straw man he's not great so no mission prep is probably my favorite Mars related game this definitely comes second I really enjoyed this one for what it is and yeah if you're wondering where terraforming Mars came troll anyway so that's it for me see you on the next broken meatball review take care and enjoy
you