Skip to main content
Loading video...

Historical Game Chat: Votes for Women w/ Jason Perez

Transcript 43:38

thank you hey Gamers this is Davidson from Beyond Solitaire and I'm doing something I haven't got to do in a long time which is record with Jason Perez from what's up Co-op shop and shelf stories how you doing Jason yo my peoples what's up it's been too long uh I mean it's been months which is like too long I know like we usually record more often this it's just been like a crazy gear yeah I mean well I think our our content lives heading in a different direction than just like a lot of reviews so we used to get together and like review a lot of games but I personally am not playing a ton of new stuff it's a lot of Designing yay actually been thinking thinking about I wonder what my output's gonna look like in five years from now because I don't want to stop designing I'm really enjoying it as a process and also I think as you and I both get more interested in kind of talking about the historical elements of games or the cultural elements of games it just kind of changes the kinds of things you make yep absolutely so uh not as many just pure just let's just get a game on the table and talk about it but every once in a while it's good to kind of get back to the roots and refresh the tree and whatever you know old saw that you want to put in indeed indeed uh and so in that vein we're gonna today no it's for women from Fort Circle games uh desire to Tory Lynn so um up front we're the like wall of disclosures oh yeah I gotta make several holy moly uh I mean we're both I mean well Liz is actually contracted designer I am a

contract the cultural consultant on one of the other products uh and we like Kevin like just bottom line uh when we like having these Compton's for ball games and conventions and these very friendly guy uh so and I mean Fort circle is a a special thing for us because there's such into the historical gaming which we are into but just in general I find that for this episode and the next one we're doing we're all like a circle of friends at this point like we all kind of we're like a tribe the historical gaming not like War gaming specifically That's Not My Tribe believe me that's more years but games that are trying to Grapple with history in an intelligent way make arguments uh set up multiple sides and get people to think as well as have fun with these you know Euro modern mechanisms like we're all friends now and we're all rooting for each other to uh you know to do their thing so disclosures all over the place but this isn't going to be a traditional review in any kind of sense what we want to do is we want to just lay out the game uh talk about it like invite people to check it out for themselves and see if it's uh the right fit for you and then after that we're going to get into a discussion that kind of blew up on boarding geek recently yeah during the golden Geeks uh multi women was categorized as a war game what Liz has thoughts oh no yes uh one more disclosure which is it one of the reasons I've not done a traditional review of what's Romans because I was paid to do the tutorials so if you go to the Fort circle Youtube channel um you can be taught by me how to play

uh I do recommend it as a thing I actually do like the game uh otherwise I wouldn't have spent this much time talking about it okay so you did a tutorial so you could probably give us a brief rundown a verbal rundown for this podcast yeah what's going on so what's wrong with is what's called a car driven game and you have a deck and the opponent has a deck so it could be with two players you could split the two sides into two so for up to four players or you could play solo against a bot but the essential breakdown is that the suffragists are playing against the opposition and the suffrage is what's the setting just in case I mean we have some non-american listeners so they might not know exactly what the setting is so just leading up to the passage of the 19th Amendment which allows women to vote in the United States and so suffragists are people who want the vote for women the opposition are traditional patriarchal forces who do not want women to have the vote so if you are the opposition you're just trying to oppose everything you want to make sure that Congress doesn't ever pass the amendment and sent to the states at all if he can and if they do you want to make sure the state's foot against it if you are on the suffragist side you are trying to Lobby Congress to pass the amendment and send it to the states for a vote and then you also want to build up enough influence in enough States for the amendment to pass and so there's partially the game of you kind of spewing your little influence cubes all over the map of the United States trying to get strong enough control of every state possible to make sure that you're getting votes in your favor um there's also lobbying Congress there

is a bit of an economy of buttons that like you can get these cool little campaign buttons that are modeled on actual you know ones at the time the Ford Circle treatment the fort Circle treatment just did a podcast about that I heard it indeed uh where you know basically you can um you know accumulate these buttons to either bid on strategy cards between your normal card play rounds um or you can use them to re-roll if things are going well because there are a bunch of die rolls in the game and you can campaign and you can play your different cards for events there's basically a lot of stuff going on but I will say if you're not somebody who games a lot or you mostly play light games so far this is a pretty doable game because really what it boils down to is you have a hand of cards you play one of your cards in one of the specified ways and then your opponent plays one of their cards in one of the specified ways so you need to go back and forth so there's a lot you can do but on any one turn it's not that complicated just a little bit right so I taught this game at the library and and more you've been to the library uh at Manchester so um I volunteer once a month uh and it's the kind of games that are mostly receptive at the library are these kind of you know light to Middle Euro games and I'm more and more appreciating when when games are very intentional about okay simple turns right a lot there could be a lot going on there's you know mechanisms and you didn't you didn't even describe most of what's going on I mean it's there's a fair amount but you

got to the main thing which is play a card and choose what you want to do based on that card play so it's like you could play the card for the event you could play the card for this campaigning action which is spreading all the cubes uh Etc so like that that I appreciated that in terms of how teachable this game is and what kind of audience this game is going to uh reach out to and you know it's been a positively reviewed in like polygon and vulture and like as a game you can play with people you know and it isn't just like this kind of Niche thing uh so that's definitely uh speaking to it um okay so we have you know again not a traditional review We're Not Gonna um you know give some kind of ultimate assessment um what I will say though is the game precedes a kind of three acts right there's three moments in the game at the beginning of the game you start with not a lot of campaigners out on the big board and the game incentivizes you to kind of spread out with these cards so you go into the state different states and if you get majority in a state four cubes or whatever then you get the card and the card's a good thing so it's like gives you a really concrete thing to go for right and then there's this middle part where you're kind of jockeying for stuff and the middle part ends when you ratify the 19th amendment in the that Congress track so the the suffragists are trying to push that Congress track the opposition either the bot or the player is trying to stop that progress because one of the late conditions is the knights never passes so it's like okay here you don't pass it like anything um and then you get to this third act which I think is the most exciting part

of all where it's like okay turning the the cubes into checks and X's that that part is exciting and so like I think the and this this all right this came from me when I was playing at the library the first part was fun and easy like okay there you go go get the states the climax was also cool it's like okay yay check X check X that middle part of like you know jockeying for the the Congress track and everything uh that was encountered by the people that I was teaching with it's like okay um you know I play a card I move the thing up uh my opponent plays a card they move the thing down move up and down move up and down and then in the individual states like I play I play cubes I put them there and then the other opponent plays this place you take my cubes away back and forth back and forth back and forth so I guess my on my only thing is for what this game and you know is that middle I wonder how people are experiencing that middle of like the back and forth and maybe that's just like an area control thing I'm not an area control person so I don't love the the you know I did something that my opponent undoes it at the very next turn the baby as a more of a war game background you kind of have more to say about that but that's where that's my my thing that I want people to know of like yeah are you cool with that on your gaming experience of like the back and forth foot cube steak cubes put kill put cones take cones Etc

there are I think there's some truth to what you're saying for sure that it's you know there's a bit of a push pull there that can go on if you're feeling antsy about it right um at the same time I do actually like that there are other things to concentrate on that can give you a little bit of a guide to what's the most important to you right now so I really like the strategy cards because thinking about them and what you can do with them can inform the the next course of your game um and I also love the state cards because they help me figure out which states I want to go for so for those of you who not played there are some extra kind of cards sitting up there that you can acquire for yourself but you'd have to be the first one to get control in the state or there's like a bidding war using your buttons between turns when you're trying to get strategy cards and so thinking long term not just about like okay am I gonna get this one state but what areas of the country can I make trouble in so that it doesn't just go back and forth over one state so that I actually have like a multi-faceted multi-front strategy that's gonna frustrate my opponent and then also you know how do I get these cards first so that I have some advantages here over them and they don't get those advantages over me so I think that it's possible to get tunnel vision in the game but I also think that if you are like you know I think this is true for war games too like I get tunnel vision and War games and I always lose when I do it because if I get too obsessed with one part of one front right I mess up and and so I think the game is training you right to think

broad because if you're like well if this person's just so determined to have a South skirt let them have it I'm just gonna go drop a bunch of keeps in the Midwest and watch them look baffled to and this is actually something I do want to really talk about with this game is the game really I think tries to capture a lot of how this political process felt sure and I suspect that that back and forth is very authentic to the way that people fighting about this issue felt historically like I certainly watch our issues du jour go back and forth and I feel like we make progress and we lose progress we make progress and we lose progress we make progress and then suddenly we lose some more progress and sometimes it feels like two steps forward and then either one step back or three depending on how bad whatever's happened it is and you know I I wonder if that frustration is something that's just baked into being part of a political process too um and that's a tough thing because like you you want to evoke that as a feeling at to you know in to get people in the theme right that back and forth but then straddling that line between like a theme experience and a game experience so and and so this is what happened and when I was playing with it in the library with one group and I felt really bad so speaking exactly what you said they focusing on kind of like one part of the game and a very attractive part of the game to focus on which is the Congress track so it's it's different than all the states right I mean there's 50 states there's 50 sets of Cubes okay we'll pick which were the one but the

Congress track that one is like okay the past the 19th Amendment so that you can get to that exciting end game right and so it's like okay play this card and you know make progress It's like a um a track of six right you got to get six cones on there or cylinders there you go uh so what the group ended up doing was like really focusing on that okay I'm gonna try to get that but the game is constructed such that okay what one group gets it and then the opposition can very easily just undo it with one card play it's not that hard it's like you know Zoom as a matter of fact the other um the the bot player the opposition player was like they got the man which was they didn't want it but like they were last so you got stuck playing the man but and they weren't um they weren't that much of a gamer they just like okay um they want that I'm taking that away so like every card they got boom took it away and what ended up happening was they they well they they passed it like the the second to last you know turn of the game yes 1900 which is not that's not you that's not gonna win any of the game so focusing on that track and I can see how attractive that is just like basically broke the experience for them you know watching it go back and forth so easily and I I get your point it's like almost like a learn to play moment yeah you know so to speaks like you know you gotta you can't just like focus on the track you know and blah blah um but I guess like from the perspective of the kind of person who would pick this up which isn't a person that's gonna be seasoned in more games or whatever it is it's kind of like just like a flag for people that like this game isn't exactly

going to act like you might expect you know easy go for the Congress thing and then move on to the next thing you might have to kind of change up a little bit so kind of like just letting people know that that's what that's in there yeah to avoid a frustration Point yeah because like want to do is you want the other person to panic and feel like they need to play their cards for something other than that event that's going to take the cylinder away but if you don't know that you can end up in kind of a spiral right and that's always tough um that said this game has a lot of what I appreciate the most in games these days which is a lot of thought going into historical accuracy theme so let's talk about the themes with all those mechanisms let's talk about our experience of being indeed indeed so I think the thing I liked the best was that the game doesn't give suffragists a break in terms of just presenting them all as saintly good people who want something good right and instead the game tries to reflect kind of conflict between different groups so like intersectionality is not a guarantee um and uh far from it and then you also have to make some really nasty choices about whether for example you want to sacrifice um civil rights for black people at the expense of you know in order to try to get a boost for for the staffordius movement which was a real argument from this time period and it was because it was like uh it wasn't like a polite debate like there were schisms in the movement because of the question of whether to admit black women into uh you

know the area so I forget the national and the American like the two factions I get them confused all the time I call them like the Susan B Anthony Lucy don't faction so Susie Anthony was a white supremacist just like like straight up which I was distressed to learn because I grew up with the Susan B Anthony coins I'm like oh I have a Susie coin it's like oh have a suit uh I guess let's get away let's get something on somebody else on there um anyway so like that was that it's it's not like highlighted it's like you can't like truly Schism in the game as esophage is like you can't like you know because you can get those kind of semi Co-op experience which we're going to talk about in The Next Episode the semi Co-op experience so like the game didn't go that way they could have but it didn't you're still Co-op but at least in the like the the distinction of the pieces and the the text of the cards and the way that the cards kind of follow on one another so like if this card is in play this other strategy is in play then this other card you can play that one or you can't play certain cards so they they lay it in that way uh which was a good choice because I don't there's enough friction in the game you don't need kind of that other extra layer um but yeah no no it was it was really well done and on the man's side uh you know having this other strategy and having you know I learned about the um I didn't learn about it I knew about it but like I learned more uh about the um the alcohol the temperance movement and how the temperance movement was Pro suffragette and like the Bars were all like no women stay home said the men can keep on drinking type thing right yeah and like little touches like that are all kind of in there and they're there to be seen if you know what to look for yeah I mean I think that any more

complexity added would have taken away from the game's obvious goal being accessible right right but I like that the hints of problems are there and I do like also that some of these events have long-term consequences so if you go for the southern strategy it sits there on the board like a turd and bites you later yeah what you did and so like so like you have to sit there and live with what you chose to do and I it's the one card in the game that does that but it's what a card yeah but it should you know I mean because it's the one that has the most modern resonance I think it's so funny um not I mean and of course a reality is very serious right but within the game context I like that you can choose to like we've talked about things like doing bad things in games um I like that it kind of you can do it it has a momentary advantage and then you have to like look at it okay with it yep look what you did um and the opposition cards are also really interesting because you know I don't really I will admit this is not a period of history that I know a lot of details about and so I really liked that the cards were really based on people who actually did stuff and had something to do with this movement with like real images and with real flavor text with like good descriptions I feel like I learned a lot every time I pull this game out because I actually get a sense of who the key players are and in a way I find the game comforting because I feel like we're in a political time where people ask for rights and then have them

denied or taken and it is encouraging to me to play something like this for women and get a sense of how heated and uncertain it all really was um because it gives me some grounds for optimism that we can get through this I mean just the simple Act of like all the Senators right the the dour white guys yeah and the idea that like you know it could be so abstract when you're reading it when you're going into classroom and you know and learning about it and everything but like when you have the card in front of you that's like okay I can't have the Women's Suffrage because these thou are white guys yeah they're all downward I don't know why they do it must be the formal portrait pose at the time but every nobody's smiling everybody looks like somebody just died yeah or like everybody's about to misbehave steal an apple from a tree or something's like new better do not do that yeah

like could you say it livens up and it actually invites a little bit a little bit of role play because like you know when I was would I be playing this with the library people they play that card it's like I'm looking at you now and yeah yeah because this is what you're doing and mechanically this is what you're doing and the feeling that it evokes off of the play I mean that's where that's where you're really kind of getting it as a game designer and that's what we're thinking about right we're thinking about like okay our mechanisms and for a historical game in particular you really want people to kind of feel what they felt like to get to your earlier point and I think ultimately this game kind of really leads into that space and once again we have we're biased so it's like we want to root for this game so we're like okay this thing could you know the Temptation might be so like this game does a great job but what I really want to land is this is what the game is going for and if you want to check it out which yeah please check it out then that's what you're that's what you want to explore is like how does this game make you feel does this game make you feel like an historical actor in the game and then once you're in that space then you can absorb all sorts of stuff the game's doing yes yes I agree and So speaking of sort of like openness to the game and what it offers um we've been seeing some discussion in our community about like where it belongs in terms of how we categorize it who it's for transition does that we only have between like about 700 pieces of content between us you'd think

I'm a professional at this you don't think so all right let's talk about it what is a war game what is a war game so you know what's very interesting is that since I started talking about this I have gotten so many little um messages about it um and like including like these very certain comments on my uh on my all the videos about it like most Roman is not a war game it is a conflict simulation however or like I think it's a very obvious what a war game is I think it's a very obvious that a war game is you know like it's very very interesting how certain people are about their definitions and I especially find this interesting because I don't think that definitions are very certain at all like basically ever right and so you know to me this is always like a bit of a surprise so basically where this is coming from is that vets for women was nominated for the burgundy golden geek Award for best war game for best thematic game which I thought was also a good fit and uh it's also up for a Charlie and I am on the nomcon for the Charlie's I won't say anything about what anybody else said I supported this game what is it trolley so Charlie is the Charles S Roberts Awards um they are a long-standing but with a checkered history uh war game award um but technically it's a conflict simulation game award that's the mission

and so this has also led to a lot of discussions about what should be eligible for one of these Awards um and if you look back in the past like so to be real this is Awards and definitions are a mess things that have won Charlie's in the past include Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective oh my God so I'm just I'm just gonna for you Purity police come on there's always something I'm just gonna I'm just gonna leave that there oh my God we're doing our best now okay in this modern era but discussion of what is a war game is very live and when it comes to books for women in particular there's been a ton of moaning and groaning about how it doesn't belong it's not a war game it shouldn't be considered under working words and I can see some of that argument but I also personally believe that opening up the definition even if it means changing it to historical game I think that we need to have more flexibility and the reason I think that is because so you and I were talking you know we were both at Circle DC you and I are game designers now kind of working in the same space as traditional war game designers as historical game designers you know Dan Bullock is on the fence about whether his games campus war games he did um no motherland without about North Korea uh 1979 revolution in Ron he's got a game coming out about um you know weapons contracts in Afghanistan so is it a war game is it not a war game no if he would say no

but our categorizations I think once we're running into is the idea that so you and I were talking about our kind of people right like our crew and I think that there's also an R kind of games yes these days but it includes both traditional war games with like pew pew and some hexes and some boats and some guns soldiers it has to have toy soldiers basically like whenever I hear a war game and I hear people saying that's not a war game I think there's a um a yearning for the toy soldier and all this stuff but I would agree yeah I would absolutely agree with that um and so you know what makes this hard right is that I understand the desire on both ends to kind of protect and to expand and to make sure that the kinds of games that you care about still have space to win an award I really think it's the only place where this matters to be real right um yeah I mean okay so we're entering Hobbies changing we that's all we do is talk about the hobby changing and diversifying and expanding inclusive all that kind of stuff and you know that like War gaming has traditionally been straight up the province of white guys who like to sit in the back of the store and play with their toy soldiers to be honest with you and yeah I mean that's certainly the percent things are changing now but they're changing now things are changing in terms of the the where are we coming from right and uh and I'm being a little bit reductive there I mean there I think there was a a sense of you know these people are you go to their houses and there's like their bookshelves are full of World War

II books and they're full of you know uh accoutrement and all that kind of thing like like War BB like this is this is what this is all about is war and because it's the long-standing thing all the awards are kind of through that prison and you know when you want to when you win and win award you want to win something with some pedigree you wanna like it's almost like a status thing that's that's what we're arguing about we're arguing about the status thing so it's like okay uh if we were to make a consume award it'd be newer it'd be less understood it wouldn't have as much status so by saying votes of women is a war game what we're saying is what we're saying is we want this to win an award with the same status as what was what came before right and so yes you know so I so it's like okay so that's what we're jostling about we're dressing about this world war and we're trying to and so like one side is trying to kind of restrict it and like keep the status it within what traditional you know X encounter work uh you know toy soldiers and then you have another one who wants to expand the definition precisely because we don't want to be in the ghetto of like okay the accommodation inclusive area we want to be in the middle and we want an expanded yeah I want to sit on the JV team Forever This is a varsity game yes no yeah the Jade we're not winning the JV historicon Sim award we're winning the give us the good stuff right right so and so that's a live issue so like maybe you know I mean I've heard discussion that like okay maybe we should rename it and all that kind of stuff I'm like okay good so maybe that's ultimately what has

to happen is this broadening and like a realignment where like the toy soldiers become the JV and that's like the worst outcome ever isn't it for some people it's like oh my God we're gonna get demoted into the JV and so there's so much so like there's the conceptual kind of like um argument and then there's like the sociological stuff yes and we confuse those things and we don't like we don't mean know what we're talking about in terms of those things for a million this is a total sociology beef I think you're absolutely right this is very much a status issue and it may be an intellectual Supremacy issue yeah uh because okay so let's be real people who play like if you look at old Avalon Hill advertisements even right it's like you know oh do you know thinking men who are going to be able to handle these war games let's be real like words they're perceived as intimidating they're perceived as stinky they're perceived as like for a specific kind of person who likes history who likes to read and who likes and you know I mean for me that was part of the attraction obviously um but I also think that when you're comfortable when you want to call something a war game it's not I want to tell you that you know your ppus aren't good enough anymore or something like that right it's I want you to take this game seriously in the same way like votes for women is one of those games that belongs in the same competitive pool as any other serious War historical game and it doesn't make sense for it to

be competing in a different pool that contains Fantasy games or like games about quilts or like I actually pretty sure any of these could be very heated right like I'm not direct and it's not that those themes are not as good right but it's that votes for women belongs in the category of games that are really trying to say something right and I think that that is the difference right and that's where we're having a hard time I think try and describe what we want and what we mean and that the something that we're saying involves human conflict yes at the end of the day you know we're talking about games history where we're highlighting moments of high conflict I mean there was huge Stakes involved in the in the vote for women there was some people who were arrested and the you know organizations people gave their lives to these causes and all that kind of stuff and so you know the the people who are part of the suffrage movement they perceive themselves as soldiers there's cards of that of like you know the women would go into you know battlegrounds uh or uh there was one thing about the San Francisco earthquake and like to have that kind of suspended uh you know it's like I could just kind of put myself in the mindspace like I'm in organizing in San Francisco and I can't do that anymore uh there's a big been a big earthquake the city's shut down my cause right my car and all that and that so that that emotional investment of being that's what a soldier is really that they do more than pew pew there's an emotional investment right so yeah anytime you have that on the ground level anytime you have like you know powerful people jockeying for a power

you know what do they say like Wars politics by other means like why why if so if that's true and I think people would just kind of like take that as a saw if war is politics by other means then why can't we expand the definition of what is a war game right it's just a war by any means type yeah well the thing is that um you know I think our language is also very slippery like think about how many people describe themselves as culture Warriors talking about culture War um or you know we talk about oh man that was uh you know even um even if you listen to goofy club music right we're gonna fight till we see something no you're actually just gonna try to stay up and have a good time sometimes worse fun um oh you know the black Ariel I mean there's also I think you can kind of like get our our uh bees in a bunch about yo yeah but professional War Gamers have already very much explained to the term war game I mean you can literally talk about wargaming a pandemic now and have that make sense at the Department of Defense or at a federal agency who's commissioned a war game about an issue so at the professional level where people are using games to save lives and train leaders war game really just means let's look at a conflict or a situation game it out and see what we can learn about it so martial societal response I think that's a big thing you know so like this is not a debate over uh you know as Daft Punk or whatever it is this isn't like a fandom thing this is like the the activation of Nations to get things objectives done that are in the National

interest yes so I think that there are already sectors where you know and I would say that you know what we do is nothing on what the pros are doing um in terms of games being important and needing to say the right things and give the right options um but war game is already taken on a different meaning further up the chain um the other thing is that we're also dealing with the difference between what is a war game and what's a conflict simulation and we haven't actually totally finished like separating that out so one of the nom-com issues for the Charlie's was that the charter specifically says that they acknowledge that not all conflict simulations have to actually involve war and so political or historical events can be candidates for conflict simulation and so like Charter like section 2.3 or something like that says this um but the categories as they're currently defined and like of course this is something that we're gonna be talking about in future years like Gary ardwolf the current director has already been really open about this in public so I don't feel weird saying it um you know we talked about what do we do about the categories because you look at the categories they still have the word board game in them and they're very striated according to to the periods of history that war Gamers traditionally have favored so there's like best Napoleonic best Civil War best ancients but yeah and so you know those categories don't always fit games that are about something other than a specific war from a specific time period and so we had to figure out how to reward games that are coming out in

those areas because we should but also how to make seats at the table for games that are doing really important things in the space but linguistically we are not yet accommodating them and and that's in terms of like getting back to the whole thing what is a war game I mean a war game is has been traditionally this kind of narrow thing and if we want to do this whole inclusion thing uh so much of it is just our language and the way we the words we use and the way we talk about them and it's that seems so silly but you know that's how humans work like the words we use and the the priors when something gets baked in as a prior that really kind of shapes our vision of what's out there and what's possible so you know I you um the Zenobia thing you know um what is a rebellion Haiti which I'm so looking forward to I hope that that game gets signed um tandaya which I have over here which was about this the Canary Islands I love that game and you know there's conflict there and there's that that is a you know even just like games you know the native resistance games and I think like something like Navajo War has got um and comancheria that got that gets acknowledged as a war game because it's very intentionally focused on like the struggles of those peoples as a whole but like every conflict with the natives should have some war game elements and it's like okay where are we making space for all that you know and so yeah yeah and and so I think um I love that votes are women and I love that BGG kudos to them how do you open Money be like okay no more game

discuss because it really challenges a conversation like this but it's like wow okay I need to step back and just and get out of the toy soldier mindset get out of Napoleonic mindset and rethink this category and then Liz and I are partisans we we want this to happen I do yeah I will say I'm absolutely biasing of opening up definitions this is also partially and I mentioned this I actually wrote a blog post about this like awesome I am very skeptical of the idea that any definition is going to hold on everything because even if you say oh War has to have some kind of conflict well what about a game that's about logistics because I would say that the logistics of getting your men their ammo is just as important as modeling the actual shooting part for example um or you know if it's politics and wartime and you're convincing people weather to engage in a war to continue or to sign a treaty and you get news from the front does that suddenly not become a war game even though it's about a war but it didn't have any actual kinetic conflict in it I just think it's so messy um if you're really thinking about what conflict can Encompass um but I also you know as somebody with a PhD in religious studies the first thing that we had to do in one of my early graduate seminars was Define religion and the once you start trying to do that it's a mess it's a mess it's a mess like oh belief in a higher power but like okay but what about the people who are spiritual but not religious it's that fully encompassed religion um oh it's a set of activities that you all do together

um to show your devotion okay well I was at a brave game last night yeah and we had a liturgy you know well that would be civil religion I I I can tell you talk ahead off about civil religion but anyway yeah way far afield right but if we're trying to find religion there are a lot of things like I mean especially because of sports game for example also has lots of superstitious practices around it typically among people who are very devoted to the sport who you know like Gamers players who have their lucky stuff or like you know people who think that you know certain chance or certain things you know what I mean like there's there's definitely only like a high level right of almost superstition about a lot of sports activities and so like think about like the curse of the billy goat you know the Cubs for like 100 years and and so I um I just really I I'm very skeptical that you can actually Define something cleanly and the more confident you are about how clean your definition is the less likely I am to buy it right sure because it means you weren't thinking about the slip and slide in the nuance and that's where I live as a person who is I mean my boyfriend can't stand the fact that I can't answer a yes or no question half the time because I'll be like well it's more complicated than yes or no okay pancakes are waffles

and so I mean on my end I always try to look at it from the other perspective and what what is so okay if it isn't just like a gatekeeper thing right unless because there's definitely some people where it's like it's just straight up gatekeeper thing but there are some people who want to be able to preserve something right you know I was like okay if you know if if war is being expanded is it going to be ex you know if I buy a war game I wanna I'm coming out of a certain set of expectations that I'm gonna be buying organ so like if I'm like the most reasonable thing in the world like I'm I'm a war I'm a war gamer I want to buy a war game but I haven't played in a little while I'm gonna go down the BG list and I'm gonna you know buy whatever's on there boats for women what and there's going to be that kind of record scratch moment so I think on some level like there's gonna be people who think like in that category of like what is war and they're trying to want to preserve something right and so it's like okay I get I get what's by trying to be preserved yes but at the at the same time it's like that usually those restricted definitions real are really exclude some important things right the other thing though is that this works two ways so for example I think endurance from hansfield was a fantastic historical game this year calling it a war game is such a stretch that I can't even imagine it does that make sense because it's not even about really conflict it's just about surviving in the Antarctic um but it's an incredible game and it deserves to be recognized in its own way so that causes issues you know Dan Bullock and I've had this conversation this channel recently and he had a good point about how he wants there also be

room for games about you know High fashion in different periods of time and you know all of a sudden so you know war game can't really cover all of that right there should be between Oregon historical game no question yes the question is like where do we draw that line and how do we make sure that we're adequately rewarding both categories because for me the issue is that I don't want games that are about something special and that are really making interesting historical commentary in that are you know doing something a little different from you know like for example I'm looking over at my and end expansion that just came in hello vanzin um I'm becoming more of a historical gamer now right so like my interest in what I want to play is changing but I don't think that a game about historical fashion or about the Antarctic the shackles and Expedition belong necessarily the same Awards category as something like Anson or even Hopple Marcus which yeah I love those games but they're not historical games they're not trying to say anything they're just trying to be fun like and there's room for all that too but I just don't want to see games that are really doing something get lost because they're not doing something in the right way according to part of our community right and ultimately I think the answer is like okay I just did like maintain the idea of War uh kind of broaden the idea of War to Encompass politics because that's what this is a politics game yeah and trying to educate the masses to either accept that as an expand the definition or you know with a

historical conflict game now or whatever it is so and ultimately some kind of like change has to happen but at least the chain is happening along tracks and if there's there are some guard rails and that's what these conversations are all about is like establishing those tracks and those guardrails and let Evolution happen yeah change is not bad oh yeah because negotiation will also always happen over these over these conversations like there's no like we said it and now we're done and we've solved the problem for eternity like that I wish good luck the game was all wished oh yeah these three these things should be settled we understand it's a thematic game no wingspan is a strategic game there's not a rule book where we can go settle this guy it's like um and so I don't know I'm trying to take the more flexible approach going forward because I think that that leaves the most room to do something good and not exclude something that shouldn't be excluded I know other people have different opinions but Jason I think you and I are roughly on the same page about this one we always very often are that's why we have done our like 27th podcast together and it's amazing all right so with that I think we'll draw this one to an end but uh this will be a video on my channel it's going to be a podcast on the One Stop cup shop so hello to everyone out there um I'm everywhere it's beyond Solitaire Jason top stories GB uh like games like shelf stories GBL on Twitter uh and on YouTube shelf stories uh One Stop Co-op shop we are rolling on hit all as this

uh as this hits we are barreling towards episode 400 of the Pod and also 40 000 subscribers on the YouTube channel so we are thriving so come on in and join the party congrats to y'all for that that's a big milestone I'm sitting pretty it not that but I mean some stories that like I have 3 000 for like a year

but uh um the other thing I guess I want to emphasize is that I feel like among solo creators too and and Co-op you know the alliances are there so just as there's like a war in historical gaming crew there's also a solo Co-op gaming crew and um yeah we're all we're all buds we're part of this like same Circle people who are encouraging what we love and hoping that you hop into so hop in with us let's do it all right thank you so much everybody please go try that scary war game if you haven't yet I promise it won't be so bad um but please like subscribe comment ask questions and happy gaming everybody later everybody um

Progress saved