Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 14:31

Miniature Market has thousands of board games at discounted prices. Click the direct link below to see all those discounted games. Hello my friends. Today it's all about the instruments. We're going to be building and crafting and repairing instruments and performing with those instruments in the orchestra, trying to get first cheer, trying to make patrons happy. Today we're taking a look at Luier. This is a mediumheavyweight Euro game. Let me show you how it's played. I'll see you on the other side. Now, Luier has amazing production, amazing vintage tray art, and amazing components. But my favorite component is the first player token, which is the conductor's wand, which is probably one of the coolest first player tokens I've seen in any game, and it's massive.

Scale-wise, that's my hand. This thing is huge. Now, everyone's going to start by drafting one of two families that they get. And each of these, not only do they have nice artwork and they are historically accurate, but they're also going to show you what your starting resources are and what a special ability that you have that no one else has. Now, one of the main goals in the game is to satisfy patrons. And you're going to be getting all sorts of different patrons that want different things, different types of music, different instruments. Sometimes they want the instruments themselves. Sometimes they just want you to repair instruments. Sometimes they want you to perform specific types of music. And they're going to give you bonuses and ongoing abilities. sometimes endgame goals once you have satisfied them. So sometimes you'll be going to the repair shop where you're going to be repairing certain instruments of different types like percussion or wind instruments or string instruments to make those patrons happy. And you can be turning in resources like animal like horsehair for example or wood or metal to get points and to then place that out into the orchestra in a little battle of area control trying to get first chair in order to get the most points at the end and the best bonuses. But you're also going to be crafting instruments for these patrons like percussion instruments like the harpacord or string instruments like the cello or wind instruments like the clarinet.

Or maybe you're performing different types of music like classical, baroque, or even romantic style music. And this one has a little bit of luck that can be mitigated with some dice rolls. This is all facilitated over six rounds of gameplay where players are going to have certain workers that going to place on the board and they're each going to have different strengths. And you'll be placing these workers secretly in turn order. If they're in a planning phase, other players might be going to the same spot, too. And during the resolution phase, players are going to take turn taking actions and activating any space that has not been done yet that has one of their pieces with the highest value player going first. And likewise, if they're tied, whoever got there first. So, you might be able to do actions even when other players are selecting something to do on their turn. And hopefully completing things like repairing this woodwin instrument using two wood, getting two points and being able to go out into the orchestra, but it's also going to fulfill a requirement of Mozart, which is great because not only does this reset, allowing you to get more abilities each round and because if this ever gets to the end, well, he gets mad and leaves and you're losing points and you're not able to satisfy him. So, it's a race to try to figure out how to satisfy him. Once you fully satisfied him, you'll be getting points, moving up your streets, tracks, and getting lifetime ongoing benefits or even endgame scoring goals. Might even be going to your own bench to rough different instruments like the ones that some of your patrons might want. And you'll be able to spend things like animal and wood in order to get it to your finishing bench, which again would take another action for you to spend certain resources to finish it. and again possibly fulfill a patron with

that and go to the orchestra and be able to get first chair because you're going to be getting good bonuses for building that clarinet. But the more you have in first chair, the more points you get at the end of the game. And this is a battle of area control. But you also get to go there for repairing and even performing certain types of music as well. Sometimes you'll be trying to perform music by rolling dice. The higher you move up on this track, the better dice you get to try to fulfill some of these, move your way up on the performance track on those and hopefully satisfy patrons as well. In addition to all that, you will be selecting specific private goals at the beginning of the game. Two of them to focus on that will give you some focus from the beginning of the game. But there's also going to be some public goals that you're going to be fighting over for trying to have a certain amount of certain types of requirements in order to get more prestige as well. The game lasts six rounds, but over the course of the game, you're actually going to be getting more and more workers, so you actually have a bigger arc and more actions that you can take towards the end of the game. You're also able to go to a fluctuating market that changes each round whether you're buying or selling the different goods but also getting assist apprentices which help you bolster the strength on some of your actions. Uh but you can also move up tracks with this as well.

So there's a lot of different options to manage the different resources that you have. But you also be going to the balcony to influence turn order possibly get apprentices money or claiming goals but also moving up a reputation track giving you a lot of different uh special abilities as well. And you're trying to have the most prestige at the end of the sixth round. Okay, let me tell you my uh my sort of my biases and where I stand on certain things before I get into this review is generally speaking my wheelhouse and my favorite types of games or ones that are like 60ish minutes, maybe 75 with streamlined mechanisms but tons of depth in the decision-m. I do like heavy games from time to time. Uh the the heavier longer the game is, the better it needs to stand out for me to want to continue playing it. I was interested in this game because I am a saxophone player. I love music uh and the theme and I Vince Dutra is my favorite artist in board gaming. So all those things together I like I like worker placement. I like hidden stuff. I like lots of interaction in my Euros. So that's why I want to give this longer game a chance. So let me tell you what I like about it.

Obviously I just sort of mentioned uh Vray knocked it out of the park. This this might be as a whole the most one of the most if not the most gorgeous game I've ever seen. I mean, and the best of his work. I It's just unbelievable how just the board and everything looks so nice and the cards and man, it just looks so good. Secret worker placement. I love this. Uh there's another game that did this a while back called like a lockup, I think, from uh from Thunderworks games. And I love that. I I like worker placement. I like the intrigue about that. I love that you don't know what people are, you know, you're not getting bumped, but you're it's about who's going there first. I love that aspect of this because I like a lot of interaction in my Euro games. They don't like necessarily just solo playing Euro games. Uh I like that the the whole aspect of the patience of the patrons. So you're trying to fulfill them before they get mad and leave and you lose three points for every for each requirement that you didn't fulfill and they're gone and that really hurts.

But you're trying to fulfill them at different times to reset. And a lot of times you're trying to decide, okay, this round I'm only going to be able to reset one of these people. Which one do I reset? Which one do I have a better chance of fulfilling? Which one do this? When do I do this? You know what? I could fulfill this one this round, but I'm going to wait till next round because it's going to give me one more good ability next round and then I can he'll reset and then I'll do it again then. So, the idea of who who to reset, when to reset, and who to do that to is is is a great aspect of this game. I like that you have bonuses for better workers. So, you can get the uh the different aspects of of the specialty workers that makes you do all sorts of special things. That was really cool, too. uh the alternate actions as I I'm going to talk about a little bit later how punishing the game can be. The fact that when things don't go your way that there is at least something you can get, at least some resources, at least something. So, if you do get hosed at a certain spots, there's that alternative action to allow you to get something and that's that's good. They they they needed to have that there. I like that the game ramps up the arc with more workers. So, after the second round, after the fourth round, you get an additional worker. So by the end of the game you you know you've got five workers going off and you're getting a much more done and so at the beginning it's like how am I going to get anything done and towards the end like whoa I got so much I can do here. I like boost bolstering things or boosting things with the apprentices. That's great where you could boost things up and you know having the higher higher levels of things give you an additional bonus when you go places. That's cool. The public and private goals public the private ones you're sort of selecting at the beginning. The public ones a little bit of game of chicken where you're trying to say hey I've already got this many.

Do I want to go to the balcony and claim this now or do I think I'm going to be able to get more later and is anyone else going to possibly get that before me? So I've always liked that aspect. when you get a goal, you can claim it now or you can wait and try to claim a better version of that. I've always liked that mechanism. You know, Kanagawa had it. Uh Rise of Augustus had it and it works really, really well here. I like the first chair area control where you're rushing to get there. You know, the fact that you can get there with uh you know, by doing performances or doing uh repairing, but if someone comes there later with an instrument, you know, it trumps you out of there. Like I kind of like that aspect and of of the area control overall. Uh, I enjoyed the game. It has a lot of things that I like. So, what are things that I didn't like as much or what others might not like? Well, you need to know going into this.

It's a medium heavy game, right? So, it's going to, as normal, it's going to have lots of setup and it's going to be a long game. I think the game said 90 to 150 minutes. That's that's probably lying. That's if everybody has played the game before and no one there generally has analysis paralysis. More on that later. uh it's it's definitely going to be long game, but usually with this type of game, you kind of know what you're getting into. One thing that people definitely need to know is your plans are going to get screwed up in this game. If you're the type of player that likes to plan things out and follow your plan and do the plan that you set and not let anything mess with it, if you don't like people messing with your plans, this isn't going to be the game for you. Uh I have a few friends that are like that, and they're not going to like this game. You've got to be able to go into it knowing that you got to get your plans done, but they're probably not going to happen. It gets worse with higher player counts. Uh which is why two players is going to be the most forgiving, the most planning essential, the most where you can just look at one player and go, "H, they're not going to go repair that instrument. They don't even have a patron for that." Like, I can go there pretty good. I'll put my lowest worker there, you know? But when there's three other people there and you got all this stuff, you're not going to look at everything everybody else is doing. There's too much to think about on your own board. Um, so your plans will and can get screwed up if you don't like being able to maybe have a whole round go haywire. Like, hey, I need to get this performance uh this this repair done. I need to go to the market first in order to do this one activate act act this buying or selling in order to get the right things to to get here, right?

But if somebody activates that before I've gone to the market, I'm screwed. I'm just gonna have to take that alternate action and then that really stinks because I was planning on that specific thing to satisfy this patron and now he's going to go away at the end of the round, right? You can really get totally hosed in this game and if you don't like that, it might not be the game for you. If you like lots of interaction, you're going to like that. This game is definitely analysis paralysis prone AP. There are so many crunchy things to think about. Mechanism wise, I think the game sort of medium crunchiness and cognitive overload. Uh it's at least mediumheavy. I mean, you're thinking, "Oh my goodness, this round I need to get this person fulfilled. I need to rough this. I need to also finish this. I need to have all these resources this round. I also need Oh, you know which worker I put where?

Well, I've gone on this track, so you know, I can rough two things at once. Well, I can go over here and I can uh oh, I I can use one less resource over here. Here, my worker is plus one, but I have this other bonus here that also gives me a plus one. So now I only really need to put a three there to get the five to get like these are the types of things that you are minmaxing in order to get things done in this game. And you have pretty much during the planning phase to figure that out. And you're like okay I'm going to go here then I can go here and get this and that will give me a bonus and I'll take that that added with this. Like you're doing mathematical formulas like you don't do in most games when you're playing this. Uh and that's what makes the game good and that's the crux of the game and that's why the game is so thinky and so crunchy. But even myself who doesn't tend to have AP, I tend to shoot from the hip and move very fast. Even I was like stuck like a deer in headlights at times, like trying to math everything out to get things done. Uh if you play with someone that has AP, this game's going to take forever. Just just know that. But it is part of what makes the game what it is. U the game can be punishing for sure. Like I just mentioned, the way of someone getting there, screwing up your whole round, and now your hose, and now your patron goes away. Sure, you should have planned for that, but the game could be punishing.

Uh, the mitigation method. Well, you you need something and there's not a card out there for you. Well, you could pay the 10 money. You could spend the the inspiration to take the top card of the deck of that type. Yeah. You know what? If you're going for an instrument, uh, and you're taking the top one of the type, chances are it might be even harder to get than the one that you already have on your board that you could rough and then finish, right? That could happen. and it likely will happen if you're if you got like a medium weight card there. So, the mitigation method's there, but a it's costly and b it doesn't really do I would have rather seen the cost be higher and then you'd be like take any card you want out of there. Of course, I realize why they didn't do that because then people are going to AP that to death and they're going to be sitting there for an hour figure out which card they want to take. I'd be like no, I want a brass. I want a woodwwind and I want one that that that's the easiest one. I could rifle through that, do that. I don't know. The mitigation's there, but it's not usually worth the cost. So, it's like, why do it? You know, I'm gonna spend all this and maybe get something that's worse. I didn't like that aspect. Um, the I I had the regular edition of the game, which is by most means is usually a deluxe game, right? The one thing I wish they would have done is the dual- layered boards. It is pretty easy to bump those cubes on the on the patrons.

I would have rather have seen them cut a corner somewhere else possibly to make that a dual layered board. Dual layer boards are kind of standard these days. They're not necessarily just in deluxe games. The game feels deluxe except for that. I wish I wish that it was a dual layered board. Uh that's pretty much it for the negatives. Uh I think from this you should be able to tell if this game is for you. It's been a game boy geek breaking down barriers growing relationship board games by helping you find the next one you love. Game Toppers upgrades every game you play, being the one table to rule them all with game toppers, leg kits, dining covers, premium game mats, and more. In their 5.0 Kickstarter, they found a way to deflate prices to prepandemic levels without sacrificing their quality brand and in some cases by $200, plus dropping the shipping price as much as 50%, saving another $100. Go to gamettopperslc.com to late pledge now.

Progress saved