Skip to main content
Loading video...

Casual Friday - MAPP to the future (Pilot Episode)

Transcript 33:10

hey everyone I'm Jack and I'm Robert and we recorded a thing thing that we're about to put up this is the preamble to the thing this is the preamble to the thing I guess a prologue there we go the thing before the thing yeah so anyway this is like our attempt at a kind of long-form discussion show where we pick a topic and then we talk about it we may come up with answers or we may come up with nothing but hopefully it's an interesting discussion that we've done I don't know you sounded a lot smarter I dragged you off on tangents several times to get my point across rather than actually having the discussion but we're working on it yeah anyway we just wanted to let you know that this was definitely the pilot and there were a lot of things that we just wanted to try and go for it and a lot of things that we notice and went like let's not do that again yeah don't screw it up two cameras the three yeah not bad well well you know it's a lot of technical work and something that we've never done before and we're getting all crazy with multi cameras and you know we have to you know learn learn these are learning opportunities that's what leadership courses have taught me so leadership courses and father learning opportunities so you know you're going to see some fuzzy cameras but I well the the overall camera not terribly good of an angle and not terribly well focused but it's it's probably going to be on your cell phone so it doesn't really matter it's fine look if you really want

to stare at our faces for a half an hour anyway yeah well the camera us close-up face shots mwah chefs kiss they're beautiful the curtain hanging in the background that's like a temporary curtain to cover up the oh god there's going to be a bunch of cars driving by all the time not so great but you know it's fine it's fine just fine okay well without further ado here's her untitled oh yeah let us know a title for the show we need that too yeah we well this show is titled map to the future but the series yeah essentials yes this episode title is mapped to the future which is very clever and very esoteric all right please do enjoy map to the future from our entitled series casual Friday I'm fighting for casual Friday sure bye hey everyone this is Jack and Robert from the cardboard Herald and we need to talk this is a show where we're experimenting with just talking about a certain topic and our name of today's show is map to the future and Robert came up with that name why don't you tell us what this is all about Robert I'm very proud of this terrible pun map to the future is a reference to a news some news that came out recently you might have heard about it on this game are this a new show called off the table nice plug okay I like it yeah about Jeff

Bergeron from the gaming goat which is I'll admit a story I hadn't heard of but I guess I just linked 20 stories I don't know what they're all name the gaming goat but this dude has like I guess the biggest retail gaming chain in the United States like it's a deal for something I have never heard of right and a lot of people in the comments reading through this we're saying that he has aspirations and becoming the Walmart of board games which oh I don't know that's really the what you want to be known as but okay I mean I guess if your goal is lots of volume and that seems to be his goal then sure but anyway he put a post on reddit about basically calling out stone Meyer games and saying hey these guys claim to be pro friendly local game store and they're totally not here my wiesen hawai and Jamie kind of passively aggressively responded and some threads on bgg and yeah you don't swear he has a tendency to do that Jamie tends to react emotionally to things and I think that's one of the things that people latch onto with him is that he seems very authentic like he does carry an overall kind of like I am welcoming business person but if something is going a miss he has no problem with going in there and saying exactly what's on his mind and then apologizing profusely for what he said shortly thereafter yeah so anyway the one of the

central themes that this guy came back to you was that Jamie for a while and from his post I thought this was recently I'm finding out now this is actually last year around this time so almost a year ago now he implemented something called a map a minimum advertised price policy specifically for Amazon only and I actually was just reading his post that he made back in January of this year which will hopefully have a link to down below talking about why he implemented that and what he hoped to get out of it but that probably comes back after the drama right right so we were talking about this before the concept of this show actually came into existence and we've thought about having some sort of discussion based video show that isn't quite what our podcast features have been up until this point where were more having a tight focus on one individual subject and while the the map agreement and the ensuing fallout between the gaming boat Oh things are happening between the gaming go and so mired games was definitely something that I wanted to talk about I thought the broader implication of this is whose responsibility it is to support a friendly local game store you know the FL GS okay well pause for

technical difficulties pause for technical difficulties okay back from technical difficulties here so what I was saying is that I think that the the broader implications of this the thing that it most made me think about is what responsibilities do consumers and also publishers have of supporting friendly local game stores because the post that Jeff maid came from a position that felt kind of entitled to me and that there's an expectation that friendly local game stores need to be supported in order to thrive and that may be true Emma definitely was the pervasive thought maybe 10 or 15 years ago but that was 10 or 15 years ago and I thought we could maybe hash out some of that in this video yeah sure do you want to talk about a little bit about the post I mean my impetus for this was Alan made a lot of it was somebody is wrong on the internet and I want to set the record straight let's hear it I want to hear about how someone is wrong on the internet in a video on the internet yeah kind of complaining about somebody else having hubris by having my own hubris but I mean it just I I don't have dinner I have never had an interaction with Jamie I know a lot of people have I know a lot of people love him so I kind of questioned whether it was like I was reflexively defending him when I was reading this post but I don't think I

have any real reason to I mean I like wingspan I like data culture but I don't like it's not like they're my favorite games ever I don't play them all the time I don't have any dog in this fight as they say but from the beginning of Jeff's post it just didn't seem right and I was on my phone when I was reading it and so for whatever reason the pictures he posted they loaded as three pixels when you opened him up on a phone but when I looked at him later and could actually read what he posted none of it was really the evidence that he was claiming he put out there he had a bunch of email screen caps but they were all from his side and it was him just saying what was me he showed very few of Jamie's responses I the only one I specifically remember was the one that he kept posting again and again which was Jamie saying stop contacting me I will not respond to you email again and overall I just got the impression and I've kind of got the impression from eating other stuff that Jeff has posted that he likes picking fights he is a very abrasive personality and is very convinced that he's right and so it ultimately seemed like he just kept harping on the same points Jamie would say no I don't agree with that and he would just keep badgering him and eventually Jamie felt the need to just say stop right right let's talk about the content of the post itself because his main issues were with the map agreement and then also there were some issues with the the scarcity he was saying that there's a false scarcity of stone Meier Games products and that that

is controlled in order to make them seem like they are rare things and people will buy them at premium prices and then there was also the the overall I guess the the thing that it concluded with was saying I wouldn't have such a problem with this stuff if it weren't that so minor games presented themselves as being very pro retail when these are distinctively in my eyes Jeff saying list that so Meyer games is very anti retail right also in order the map agreement and again I kind of had the impression that this was more of a recent thing but it apparently it must have taken place last year because Jamie said he ended the map agreement in October he Jeff by his own admission ordered a thousand copies of my little sites for I don't know what all of his stores I guess because according to him in his post it was presented to retailers as being a rare thing and so my question about that is so if you think it's rare and you order a thousand copies your expectation is that you're gonna sell almost all those copies of that game so that doesn't mean to me it's like okay so you were trying to corner the market you didn't there turned out to be a lot more copies than you expected so you're a thousand was a drop in the bucket sucks to be you you know there's more copies and also less demand so my little

side I think what happened is that stone Meyer viewed it as hey this is kind of a novelty we're going to print these and we think that people are going to buy them like hotcakes but we don't know if this is going to be something that we print in perpetuity and we're not certainly not going to have it and side the numbers or anything so if you want some I don't know how soon we're going to have anymore yeah and I mean he didn't present any proof he had no screenshots of email saying hey this is gonna be rare it was kind of unclear from his post whether it even came from Jamie Jamie may not have said anything of this sort it might have just been the distributor saying hey we don't think we're gonna have very many copies of this and he ordered a thousand maybe he was the only one who ordered anything and so he got them all and anyway it led to he didn't think he could sell them in his brick-and-mortar stores so he decided I'm gonna dump him onto Amazon which is ironic later and so he put him on Amazon and ran into a problem that Amazon themselves were undercutting his price and Jamie had instituted this minimum advertised price agreement when she said you can't sell for less than 20% under MSRP on Amazon or rather you can't advertise that price and then they had this big argument about what advertising meant right and Jamie basically said you can't list it for less than 20% under and their argument seems to be well if we use this

feature on Amazon that hides the price from you until you add it to your cart then that's not advertising it and therefore we can list it for whatever price we want because we're not advertising it and Jamie said well no because if you're logged in you still see that price you don't have to add it to your cart or anything I don't know I didn't go down into the weeds Jeff claimed that he did and that the Internet agrees with him that if you do this it's not funny how angry people on the internet tend to say and everyone agrees with me on this right so I don't know I'm not a I'm not a lawyer it sounds kind of vaguely interesting in a sad sort of way to go research all of it and decide who actually is right but ultimately whether he was whoever was legally in the right he was obviously subverting the intent and and I had this post from Jamie where he explained his map experiment he said that his intention was to keep people from driving the price down in just a runaway race to the on Amazon because everybody was always gonna be trying to undercut everybody else and he said I'm just gonna put a floor on it you can't go below 20% and then you're and the irony here is he did it at least according to him to keep people from undercutting brick-and-mortar stores right right the that people would not be as tempted to go to Amazon because the brick-and-mortar stores could still be competitive with the price and that's the that's the theory but you know Stowe

Meyer ended up stopping the mat policy because it I think in a post that was earlier this year or even end of last year where he was talking about how it was kind of like a failed policy yeah it was just too much management and too much micromanagement of retailers and distributors and it sounds like this is very much the kind of thing that stone Mayer ended up not wanting to have to deal with right and the other thing that he said that was interesting was that he had hoped that because Amazon seemed to set their price based on the lowest price that was advertised on Amazon that if nobody was advertising low 20% under than Amazon would sell at 20% under MSRP right that worked for a little while but after a while he said it looked like they were looking web wide and if anybody advertised it below 20 20 percent under then they would match that and undercut it by a little bit and so at that point like he had no control over it there was no way he was gonna be able to keep people and he said you know what all right go back to doing what you're doing I think it's you know bad for you but I can't control it I can't police you let's talk about the false scarcity thing because wingspan is obviously the biggest game to come out this year and I don't think anyone really anticipated that maybe snow Meyer games did you know that that's the conspiracy theory right is that they knew that it was going to be this big of a game and they put a stranglehold on the manufacturing or at least the

distribution of the game and stone wire games is making some money off of that including the reprints where it's like yo you pay air freight shipping then we will get you at copies in order to fulfill this but I think the initial speculation and stove Meyer made several posts about this was that they thought that this was going to be a good selling game and they decided to order based off of that but they had no idea that this would be the massive hit with such incredible broad appeal that it has right I mean if Jamie had said in his kind of well I think even Jeff and his posts referred to it as Jamie's Mia culpa that wasn't - Mia culpa but I mean that's kind of the whole debate here in in March on the date of the official release date for wingspan Jamie said look I I asked around and and I forget if he said he asked I think he asked distributors and he said hey I've got this euro-style game it's about birds how many copies should I print and the distributor's all said ten thousand now I don't know how that number shakes out I don't know how many things how many units most games would sell like seith for instance how much was their first print run I don't know so 10,000 might be high might be low sounds like quite a few games he didn't really think that that was out of the ordinary it's a euro game unsure how much people might like that and you know part of this thing was saying well maybe I should have offered some more details because it's so much more than just a

euro style game about birds but anyway he he bordered 10,000 he ordered those back in fall of 2018 so right September last year about the time this whole map thing was going down it takes apparently four or five months to get them printed shipped I mean especially shipped cuz they throw them on a boat it gets here when it gets slow boat from China right and he expected them to get here around January they got here he started taking pre-orders he planned on doing a week of pre-orders mmm he had 50-100 pre-orders for this game right right you know the demand was bonkers and I I think just the initial reviews and then I think the story building up surrounding wingspan I mean it almost has a mythos a cult around it is kind of separate from the game at this point and we're still in the early days of its release I mean this is May that we're recording this video and the official release was only two months ago and I imagine that so Meyer is going to be keeping up with demand for quite some time and the the thing about this is is that snow Meyer started as a Kickstarter company they were they historically utilized Kickstarter up through side and then after that their games that came out were they had my little side which we already talked about did not sell to the numbers that were apparently expected and then there was also between

two castles of Mad King Ludwig which I love that game but it definitely didn't seem like it really stuck in the public conscience consciousness conscience I say words on podcast and on videos and maybe they work out then then there was wingspan and I think this is the first like slam dunk that they've had and it could be that they were being a little bit cautious about rolling out a game about birds in a hobby that just wants sexy elves and spaceships I mean that might be a little over simplistic but I guess you know your audience better than I do I know my watch yeah I mean I think that would that was really the tone of Jamie's post was like I don't have any way of knowing like it's so hard for me to know and and in some ways that was the tone of Jeff's post too was a lot of what he was saying about wingspan was you should have known and and his evidence for that was oh well I ordered i pre-ordered 3000 of these through four different distributors well his evidence of that was as people pointed out in the comments basically a screenshot of what looked like his internal inventory system and it looked like it was an aspirational pre-order of I hope I have these and his 3,000 number was on the line that was marked to sell through Amazon so really he order he was hoping to order 400 copies to sell in

his brick-and-mortar store those 20 stores that you mentioned earlier and then he was hoping to make a bunch of money by selling the others three Amazon totally so let's talk about the other part of this is you know like what is our responsibility in the community of supporting the friendly local game store the FL GS and you hear this in all kinds of hobbies because I'm really big into cycling as well and it's support your f lbs your friendly local bike shop but you know the the boardgame hobby has been so evangelical for a long time and adamant that you have to support the community you have to do things to support the community even when you're a designer or publisher you're getting into the game a lot of the advice you'll get is start a podcast start a blog do something for the community first to establish yourself you know give back to the community before asking for something and I think that's born out of the necessity to have someone else to play these games with and for a long time board game shops friendly local game stores were the places where you could organically go into and meet other people who are interested in these things and also it could be a public face for people who aren't aware of games to go and to be exposed to all these to me probably the biggest value now for a game store is having the environment to play and support like tournaments and community events and

then it's also the exposure to a breadth of games that you wouldn't necessarily seek out on the Internet right so for a small publisher to have a game in a game show into a game store then it can be sitting there right next to wingspan and it might catch someone's attention that it might not otherwise and Amazon or something but I mean is it my job or is it still my er Games's job in order to make sure that these are thriving businesses is that a necessity for the hobby or is it the responsibility of the retailer themselves in order to make sure that they providing something that brings someone in you see what I'm saying yeah I don't know that you gave me a whole lot to a riff off of there I mean one of the things and it is interesting to think about it you know it's Jeff was definitely on the side of Jamie is not supporting the brick and mortar story right there are why yeah I mean there are two reasons why I think I would disagree two main reasons why I think I would disagree with that one is I don't know that I would consider Jeff to be a brick and mortar store or like a friendly at least a friendly local game store yeah obviously given his own evidence your friendly local Walmart yeah but even given like his own evidence of why he was ordering these games 90% of his his planned sales are online through Amazon he's just trying

to compete well not really trying to compete with Amazon but you know he's knowing that most of his sales are coming through there too now his argument is he turns around and plows all those profits back into the brick-and-mortar stores but he's not exactly the person that's you know he's doing both I guess right at best the other reason I say that is it's very obvious that Jamie is involved in the community and is trying to give back in his own way I mean he's he's trying to make a buck - and and it's not purely altruistic but he is very responsive as he says all the time he responds to every comment on his forums and also on bgg and apparently also on reddit even if on bgg in a passive-aggressive thread of oh I'm not going to respond to that I can possibly be bothered and he he writes that on a blog post he shoots a bunch of videos all about I mean he even though he got out of the Kickstarter game he still does how to's of how to do your Kickstarter he takes a look at it every so often in his blog and I mean ultimately he's looking for good games to get out there and you know would Elizabeth Hargrave have picked up with another publisher maybe maybe not it's definitely a niche topic but it caught on and you know maybe maybe Jamie had something to do with that maybe something nobody else would have I don't know but I don't think and I don't have any reason to disbelieve him when he says I actually am for these game stores

and I'm trying to do my best it may not always seem that way and it may not always work out the way he intended but you know his this policy that that Jeff from the gaming goat is complaining about if we believe what Jamie said and Jeff doesn't right he was intending it to keep this price cutting this rampant price cutting that I think people are afraid that's it's the same thing that happened to book stores is gonna happen to the game stores and Jamie was trying to prevent that by not allowing Amazon to undercut everybody so severely right and you know like Stowe Meyer games like you said it's not entirely altruistic like Stowe Meyer games wants a thriving gaming hobby because that's going to hopefully create more gamers who they can sell to but also at the same time you know even just based off of facts whether it's altruistic or not you know stole my are games supports tournaments provides materials to conventions you know there are examples of where so mer is and many other companies as well are providing to local hobby points of community I guess whether it's the game store or its you know local tournaments at conventions that kind of stuff and I guess the the thing that I'm I'm most thinking about here is that it is extremely difficult

now for a game store to be a thriving business like you have to innovate it's 2019 and everything is available on Amazon even brick-and-mortar game stores are selling things on Amazon and while I do want to support the community aspect of that game store I also have to like respect my own wallet and my own family's needs and if you know going to a Amazon or a different online retailer is going to get me a game for 40 or 50 percent less than going to a brick-and-mortar store is it my fault or a problem with me that I'm not the one who's you know actually going and spending that to keep that money local and there there are a ton of reasons why you should consider at least buying local you know you're supporting local business you're keeping money in your own community it's providing jobs in your own community but at the same time you know we live in a capitalist society and like I have to take into consideration is there a better way for a publisher to get games to my door and provide me the games that they wouldn't otherwise be able to do if they couldn't do that and Stowe Meyer is in a position where they at least could experiment with this map policy or other hobby focused or I guess

brick-and-mortar focused initiatives to maybe make the the the whole playground a little bit more fair so I tend to give them a bit of the benefit of the doubt but also I do have a wall of Steel Meyer games behind me so maybe that clouds my judgment a little bit yeah I mean I think the other thing that they that Jamie says that they do is he did say they don't while they do sell to me was flat River is the distributor that then sells to Amazon he he well I don't want to say shorts but he gives them a lower percentage of the games that go out to all distributors for the early print runs so that they can go to the tribute errs that are getting them to the brick-and-mortar stores with the idea that they get in front of people to get in front of people that might not have heard of it they can see it they can maybe see it played or play it in the store if there's you know if this store has a demo copy or whatever or somebody else buys it and wants to play with people and I mean again it's not entirely altruistic the more people to play it be able to see it the more people like it the more they're gonna want to buy it but you know his idea is if we gave it to Amazon in the normal percentage you know with whether that's 50 percent or whatever everybody's gonna buy through Amazon you know and especially in something like this where there is an inventory shortage if Amazon had all of them they're gonna get all the sales you know and if everybody did that then brick-and-mortar stores were shut down

the idea behind that is you know the brick-and-mortar store is the place where people go to congregate and I think as you said earlier maybe that has changed now and and I think there are a couple of reasons for that one gaming conventions like packs unplugged another plug back to yeah we're going be there maybe recording one of these we will be there but you know people show up there it it I did not expect it when we went but literally half the floor there is just people showing up playing games with each other that that's a big part of it and for a lot of people that's the entire purpose of packs they don't care that there are publishers and distributors and what designers they're in booths right and there's other conveniences I mean the you can have the community aspect through forums right like bgg our board games on reddit I mean the those provide access to strong healthy communities with tons of discussion and exposure to all kinds of stuff Facebook groups I mean the the idea that I added earlier about getting exposure to certain games that might not otherwise be seen you find all kinds of stuff if you're engaged in any number of these different groups online so there that community can be facilitated in a somewhat legitimate facsimile on right but you know I don't know like the the point of this discussion I think was just to kind of hash out and think about the different perspectives in this and

what I'd like this show to be going forward is not being the guys on the internet who have the answers for you where we are not having all of our hot takes where we definitively know exactly how you should proceed we wanted to be able to just talk about this stuff and think about different perspectives and have some you know thoughtful discourse and I think we've had some of that what do you think Robert yeah I mean if nothing else this is kind of in spite of itself this whole thing has made me think about where I buy my games and and maybe considering buying them somewhere else in the future you know I think most of the games that I have have come from Amazon or direct from the publisher at PAX or elsewhere and so but then again we may be in unique situation because we're in Juno Alaska where we don't have access to the gaming goat but if the gaming goat decides to open their Walmart to board games up here maybe we'll have another discussion I think I would rather support something like say Alaska robotics than the gaming goat but that's just me yeah yeah we do have some good game stores here they're not exactly the the mega stores that you see around but we do have quite a few local businesses that are trying to bring games to gamers all over Southeast Alaska which is pretty great now for all of those of you who are watching if you

have any thoughts about anything that we've talked about today if you have any insider information about stilt mire games or the gaming goat you have some beef that you want to pick with us or them then go ahead and put it in the comments below and if you want to hear us talk about any other topics we'd love to see this series continue if you have a suggestion for a name I mean I'd love to hear that too because we're really not sure what we're doing with this pilot right now but it'll morph into something I think I hope does that mean you're shooting down the Robert's rants idea Robert's rants there we go but is it exclusively going to be Robert and a rotating chair of guests that are always Jack Eddie on it we'll see to be determined let us know what we should do thanks everyone for watching thanks Robert if you enjoyed this video we have all kinds of other reviews interviews and recommendations via writing podcasts and video here on our Channel and website cardboard Harold calm our content is the audience supported so if you want to show your support please visit our patreon thank you so much for watching this has been the cardboard Harold

Progress saved