Skip to main content
Loading video...

Undaunted: Normandy - Discussion

Transcript 27:55

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome to the discussion for undaunted specifically normandy uh even though brad has the reinforcements box uh it's just to i guess hold everything uh which is nice um so uh uh so we've played this game multiple times uh with both a with with different types of objectives mainly uh the main one was controlling uh objective points and another one was like a goal i think you had yeah you had to like i just had to get you to get to to the end yeah this game is significantly better when you are playing scenarios with objective points that is the heart of this game because the other one like i just with the deck building element i don't think that you can efficiently like one side like has an advantage over the other um at least in the ones with the objective points i feel still one side has an advantage over the other but it's not so obvious uh at least in my mind i still do not care for this game like my opinion actually really hasn't changed uh so much uh from whenever we we last played this and i thought it might because i i liked it whenever we did like the first game with the objectives and then i really didn't

like it whenever you just had to run and i'm like okay i can't stop you uh and uh and then this one it's like all right yeah like lucky lucky me i kept i had the gunners to keep suppressing you and you had to try and get to areas that i already could control um there's just for me too much luck in in a skirmish game uh like this like especially in a competitive one like dice are what they are like you you it's it's even then like when attacking let's just rifleman even if they're in your exact same spot like it's still like almost a 50 50 shot like there's nothing it's like how is how is that i mean i guess it's obviously supposed to thematically represent mind cover and running and they're not just standing there shooting each other but the dice are too random and then your deck is too random uh for it to be enjoyable for me so uh that's kind of my immediate two cents uh what what what are your thoughts i think so i mean i agree like it's such a it's the scenarios place so much into like depending on the scenario we'll decide on who's going to enjoy the game and who's not yeah really i mean i know you're right you know i mean because like this one yeah the the numbers are out in the middle but you already had places on

three or four of them yeah you know where all you had to do was just play a control card and take them and then i had to somehow force my way through all that stuff and i wasn't getting enough cards to be able to move or if i was going to be like that that's that like i know there's bolster and you're getting your cards to do all that stuff but then because that's why i was trying just to load up because i was wanting to just make a push and just become mince meat and just get totally short you're going there yeah but then i couldn't but then it's like okay are you going to play those cards to move are you going to play those cards to try to bend as you're approaching me because then i cut you know yeah it's like i but then there's certain scenarios that work better for the other side you know so it's just um yeah because all i had to do for this one was my mortar yeah i really didn't move i already had the areas i just had a scout i didn't start with any scouts what i do is have one bolster and then just wait for it to come up your deck you know and then and that's like the first card i had i'm like okay now i'm gonna get some scouts you know then i'll be able to get those uh and i never moved my mortar because i'm like okay well i get to attack each individual one i mean the first one i actually i think i only hit once with my mortar out of what 10 dies 10 die rolls like i know i need a 10 so it's a 1 in 10 chance like i understand that but it's i i did say in the run through if i if i lose however the game happens i'm happy

i rolled 110. so i did kill one guy with one mortar but because it was just more me turtling up and you had to be the push i'm just like okay i'm gonna get machine gunners out i'm gonna suppress you so you have to burn your your advancement cards um and the way my cards were coming out it was definitely in my favor like i'm just like okay i'm gonna you know suppress with my with a machine gunner then i'm gonna attack yeah with um how many cards that i kill of yours two yeah with your pile which is probably what this is supposed to be you are supposed to you know fill up your deck and then run in like what your theme was um but that doesn't work inherently because it's still luck of the draw you could have all your rifleman's like in in your deck but if you're only drawing one and then i suppress them oh okay i guess that's that well and then like also how the board was set up initially i can't remember the initial setup but like if i was going to move i had to load my deck up i had three different hands throughout this game that out the four cards three of them were were fogging the fog of wars yeah and then i was using the other card down in the press you know yeah like so my turns were like or nothing you know and whereas you didn't have to do hardly much fog of war because you already had the areas more or less there so this one this falls into the same issue i have with memoir 44. it's if this was

historically accurate then cool uh i don't want to play that because i can read the little blurb and be like oh the germans won this cool okay we can just pretend let's say we spent an hour and oh hey the germans won like i want it to be i would almost prefer like a what if scenario like where it's even it's like hey historically the germans won this but we're not it's it's balanced on both sides and then you can be like oh man well what if this happened and then the americans did this instead and then they took in and took the bridge or whatever and then that changed the course of whatever it's like that that to me is more fascinating than it being historically accurate like it's the same kind of with uh movies like historically accurate movies it's like well i could just read the wiki article and not spend the money to watch the movie um but like for this one i i figured out early on oh i want to control initiative right because if i attack like your rifleman and hit well that burns from your hand first so that means they're not getting to go and i just need enough time to scout and then get riflemen and control it and i mean by what turn two i had three points out of the seven you needed right it's like that's not fair or fun like i didn't i i don't like if i if i win i wouldn't feel like i earned i didn't i feel like the scenario just gave it to me well and i did do as kind of a stupid maneuver

early and that was bringing my scout up here oh because i wasn't able to because i i could have gotten that those two points yeah i didn't have any scouts around there that could have moved because i had already because i couldn't move my riflemen into there sure because it wasn't scouted right which you know yeah so that's true so i mean i i went up here because i was i thought the mortars were going to cause more damage than they were theoretically they should but i mean it's like you have three mortar fires on the same location theoretically that should uh that should hit but and because mortars have to go three or three or further it's just like like this scenario didn't call for that i mean it would have theoretically had you actually been able to move forward but having gunners out that roll four dice to suppress is huge like especially when all this is open field so you're running in and it's just like oh okay i'm just gonna you know attack them and then just make you waste your cards but in this particular scenario and in most scenarios i would say initiative is huge like if you can constantly control that you going first to potentially damage or like take an area like if you if you did scout that but then i had an initiative i could move in okay now you can't take it because i'm there um it's i just i don't really like anything about it like i said during the run through you can theoretically kind of get into the

theme like whenever you have a sniper you know shoot i mean he gets to shoot three which is which is really good and they can stalk so they don't need to be scouted but they can't control so it just makes their shot a little bit easier it's interesting but i don't know it's just it's too slow to rely on your on your deck like it'd be cool if your rifling could move and attack like that would make it a lot more fast paced which i think that's what the whole inspire deal is for you need to try to time it where you can but your inspires are very situational if you have to have right you know those types of units in your in your hand with your inspire to get to use them multiple times and if you flood your deck with all different types chances are your inspire is not doing anything so this game just doesn't really do anything for me like the attacking isn't fun it's literally rolling d10s and hoping you roll high it's a subpar deck builder with no unique twist you just have cards in your deck uh i will say um that the the solo mode from what i've watched i haven't played the solo yet obviously

um but uh with it being the whole dave david turksey stuff and everything the solo mode is great from from what i've seen so far and and so it makes it is it is are there solo scenarios specifically or can you play these scenarios so you play all those scenarios oh okay but they had he created an ai to control that so stuff so osprey games did um was the other game imperium yeah which also has an amazing solo mode so maybe they should just make solo games only but but um so that's what i want to try because because on a game like this and you know just like what you said you know like in a 1v1 game this even more so than memoir like like this one is more deterministic uh 1v1 in the scenarios even more than memoir do you think that's fun well you've probably played more more than i am and it's because there is the randomness of the dice and the decks right memoir has the the sugar and the deal but it also has where the offense can get or the the defenders can get screwed over and not be able to do retaliate because they don't have those cards you know i'm saying like i mean i know that's not a mechanic you like or whatever but no yeah but i mean like like right then like i knew if i moved into zone you had cards in your debt your deck was where that i was going to take

damage you can risk it memoir 44 where you move in and be like okay if they don't have a command card for that sector then i'm i can push my luck and try to true that you know so like in a 1v1 game where this one you just know what i mean you can pretty much predict what's going to happen minus the die rolls i know yeah but but uh i think this game for me is going to be a a solo game no then and that's fair if if everyone is clamoring for this game as a solo game that's that's perfectly fine uh and if people are ranking this high because they're they'll only play it solo you know great uh i never consider solo variance uh to be the main point like the only time i do is for games that are solo only like final girl hostess negotiator and stuff like that um because i typically i'm not a solo gamer um but i can see that i can definitely see this being a lot more fun because it's just you versus the ai and it's not as personal i guess whenever it's another player like screwing you over or rolling higher or whatever it's the computer and that feels better i guess in some video games huh it's like playing a video exactly anyway so uh and it's it is kind of interesting how because we played imperium together and which was a pretty solid one uh

and but even then everyone's like oh it's better solo it's like all right well what maybe they should make solo i think the reason they say that one is better solos because it's just the length like that game would be so long if you don't play it if you play it with any more than two that is true because the game doesn't really change yeah you're right it's just the length of game that is true but also the um at least the two we played uh the the yeah i was gonna say factions but civilizations uh they didn't feel a hundred percent different right uh so it didn't really matter i wasn't like oh my god you can do that like it's still all about like what i was trying to do um i mean in terms of skirmish games this isn't it's like it's like what's worse a really bad game or like a a um a painfully average game you know it's like because i get i get nothing out of this i like the only sense like i succeeded on almost every die roll like and if you miss like i would i would understand like because there's no mitigation right for rolling i understand missing every now and then that would increase like but you already have the fog of war like aspects that can just really screw you over if you really need to make a push and you happen to draw four fog of wars you can't i mean yeah you can technically um

was it conceal to take them out of europe but it's like okay yeah let me just waste one of my cards to get rid of one fog over right and if you happen to draw three fog of wars in your hand it's like great while your opponent happens to draw four really good units like i had one where the machine gunner a rifleman and two mortars it's like that's a awesome hand um but what's also really annoying is you draw four cards and really you're only going to play three of them and then if you have any fogs that just lowers it yeah and then if you don't have initiative then since i knew you had a lot of fog of wars i wasn't as like scared to play mine to try and be initiative because i'd break ties like i i would the game would be a lot more action-packed and fun potentially probably not but if you do five and you could use four you get through your deck a lot quicker chances of you drawing five fog of wars is very low yeah no you made that comment earlier in the play through that uh about getting the gunners and when one person goes all in on gunners not all land you you had quite a few gunners yeah out there and you were you were using a suppression what beca what it turns into is i'm suppressing you you're suppressing me we're just wasting cards to reset up and we're suppressing each other expressing it just turns the game into a longer that is true you know so it's like i'm just gonna go and just see what happens yeah i mean like technically i don't know if you ever used your gunners i moved them

oh yeah you move them i mean maybe the only thing with like is maybe use your because you knew i was suppressing your rifleman used your gunners to suppress by gunners and then that frees up your rifleman to move i i don't know yeah it was just prolonging the inevitable yeah and that's the other thing is yeah whenever you're trying to control that's kind of the negative to the objectives is if someone just it happens to be in there no matter if i have all my units in one area and you have one scout i can't control it it's like why i have i have my entire army i can't control this one house no granted theoretically i just attack until i wipe your but that's even kind of annoying because initially i liked the multi-cards because i was like that represented like a squad like oh okay i hit one i hate your rifle and b that's one of your guys down out of the five in your in your deck um but in a game like this since everything is kind of so slow it's i have to roll high and then i have to waste my entire hand theoretically me drawing well just to kill one squad to then wait for my deck to cycle to then control to get one point right you know it's like i just don't want to do the game wasn't long necessarily but i think it it easily could have been it could have if i even if i would have been trying to push more hell even if you've been fighting for stuff more right or if you i mean because you you attacked quite a bit and just rolled low

yeah and it's like okay well that's that think i'm glad i wasted one of my three cards to miss yeah and that was my uh because there was a one point where i moved my rifleman b in there and then i was like oh [ __ ] he's my only one like so i have to wait if i want to uh to try and control that yeah i'm interested to see what the africa one does i mean i'm not holding on anything because that's a vegan change it has tanks and armored vehicles and stuff and it's probably just more the same probably um well there are people that like that that like the africa better than normandy's been kind of the consensus i can see if the vehicles have like a carry like something yeah which obviously makes sense well that would make it move a lot faster um and uh i would i wonder if the boards would have to be bigger than not sure like i said i haven't gotten if i had to guess yeah i i don't know anything about the north africa if i had to guess the vehicles can't move as far but they since they can carry like they can move maybe one area or two and then carry people uh yeah having having vehicles i mean this one it's weird that normandy doesn't it's not like this is whatever war where they only had foot soldiers it's like there were planes and there were at least that was the benefit of memoir you had tanks and you had aerial support

like this reinforcements expansion adds uh air oh it does aircraft and stuff too gotcha it just adds some more stuff you know i mean more different kinds of units and and mine layers yeah and late you get delayed mines and stuff and everything too and this i like what they're trying to do with it i just i'm still kind of surprised you know we've played this a few times i've played it uh with some of the other guys a few times and i'm i'm just kind of surprised that it gets the super hype that it has you know like yeah like i'm very excited to try the solo because i trust turksey and his solo modes it looks really cool when looking at the stuff in the box and plus being able to play every scenario solo that's come out plus the scenario book from the reinforcements expansion a lot of scenarios yeah there's a lot of solo play that definitely sounds like the the goal yeah but uh i'm kind of i'm i almost would just rather play memoir like like if i had to compare it like if i had to play one world war two game memoir i mean how many were exciting that that's i guess so yeah it's more exciting like moving these chips around on the board is kind of but you have a little tank you know you have more visual yeah there's like sandbags so you have more visual appeal with memoir and yeah it's been a long time since i played memoir but that one was because you could you had grenades and stuff but you had to roll the grenade symbol on the dot yeah there were

command and color system is what i loved about that game i mean i know the shared deck was which i mean i know a lot of people mentioned that memoir gets fixed if you i mean you have to buy a second copy but then you get everyone gets their own deck right it's like it's still luck of the draw but at least it's not you took that before i could it's like oh you got an air support okay i know i have one in my deck yeah and that's how i would almost prefer to play it um worthy was it the overlord so it's called were you the big overlord is playing d-day okay it's like the whole beach yeah yeah yeah i mean that would just be that would just be cool like to get immersed in that but also for me this theme doesn't do a whole lot uh like theoretically i like it like i could kind of get into like the sniper just the crack of the bullet hitting the ground and i can i can hear all that but this game just eh yeah like the dice the deck and then the scenarios the they're it's this game's just kind of blah for me so i got nothing else i don't know what else to say so on a scale of one to ten uh what would what would you give it conditionally i'm going to give this a conditional because not taking the solenoid account obviously because i haven't played that yeah um i don't think i could go above a five

yeah that's that's i think of five is about it for the 1v1 experience um and then obvious i know the solo is gonna be higher just because being a solo gamer you know work better if you like world war ii and you're a solo person um i even i want to say it even adds co-op in this like we can play teams like 2v2 i think i did see that kind of stuff like that so that way that'd be another way but it's pretty much still playing the same damn game decisions yeah um so if you're a solo gamer i would say if you have the opportunity to try it do so um uh and maybe on a future solo list you'll know my opinion of if it's a good solo or not yeah yeah or in your top 100 if you play it solo jump on there um no i completely agree like there's nothing inherently wrong i can't necessarily justify a four um i mean the the last scenario we did what was that one oh my god that was just it was pretty much where i was just i was running away and you were i was withdrawing and i had to get to an exit yeah yeah i actually opened up right to it yeah you i had i had rifleman and uh and uh i had to bring out the freaking mortars and snipers and i just had to because you had to scout all the way ahead but i had to um

pin you so i had to kill all your riflemen well that's [ __ ] impossible when you can just i'm gonna bolster and pull all my riflemen in and it's like okay so i have to hit you five times with luck of the dice and then just burn that it yeah that scenario was [ __ ] garbage and then that's my point like the the scenarios are so swingy with this yeah there isn't i we haven't played i guess the initial practice one was the most even because we were sitting there bouncing back and forth yes but everything else we've played so far has been so uh boot on you know like boot on the head or you know where you had to which i know is probably what the war was actually like but no i and i and i get that but yeah like yeah that one was because no one initially controlled the area no that's not true sorry um the german and the initial set of larae was the germans controlled three points but that was it they had to scout all the way out to the other ones and then you had a few scouts and then you could get two yeah that one just because yeah we were going back and forth trying to get it and i think that's the spirit of the game i think the whole battling for those areas yeah no i agree but uh so the the the weird one of running like that would have been like a four that was extremely frustrating but this one going back and taking the other one the

victory point conditions i'm just gonna give it a five this is such a whatever game uh for me but maybe north africa would be would be cool vehicles sound neat but yeah i think you i think you're right memoir is more exciting it's just as luck driven yeah like with drawing cards like yeah it's not it's this is your own decks or how you built it but you can't necessarily filter it to really be like all right i need my rifleman a's out to come out so i'm going to burn some cards because that would mean you're theoretically killing your own soldiers well it's just hard for me like like this is hard for me to picture being a soldier right you know like and i know it's cost because this is this is not an expensive game yeah is memoir 44 still super expensive i felt like it's about 50 bucks for the base game okay um i know they had a bunch of expansions and i thought i remember those expansions being hard to get at one point but i feel like i see them yeah i think they got reprinted i thought so too um but yeah so i mean it's visually you know it memoirs it's better version yeah i agree all right so that's our thoughts on undaunted normandy specifically uh let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and i really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that

subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever i upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run-throughs or reviews or cool top tens or whatever i feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved