We changed our mind so many times! - Papyria Board Game Review
Transcript
Hello everyone. This is Johannes
and this is Cinema
and you are watching Board Gaming Ramblings
and today we are taking a look at Paperia.
We are taking a look at this game right here. It was sent to us from the publisher. So, thank you so much for that. Today we're doing a review of this game as we usually do. And as always, subscribe because you can. It's free. Help us get to a million subscribers because that would be awesome.
Going to happen so close. Very, very close. only like 980,000.
It's the closest we've ever been.
It is. We're closer than ever. Without that out of the way, the subscriber stuff, let's talk about the game. As always, brief little overview. This is the game. This is only a third of the game board because of space. You will see in the pictures.
This is the game. This is not the game.
It's the game, but it's not the complete game board. This is a Rondell based game. So, on your turn, you're going to move one of your pieces around the Rondell. So, let's just pretend that this is the whole randell. I will be able to move my piece one or two spaces. When I get to a space where somebody else is, I can skip it. Or I could also bump them out of that space and give them a resource to be able to take that action space. When I land on an action space, for example, over here, I will be able to do two actions. And what actions are available depends if you're moving your wanderer or your ships. So, if I'm moving this little dude over here, I will be able to take those two actions that are on this location. And if I move my ship, I will be able to take this tile, which is a multiplier, and then choose one of the two actions that I want to do. And that is basically what you're doing. There's a couple of spaces where you move past like the halfway spots where you can pay Papyrus to either move on a knowledge track that we're going to talk about soon or to do an extra scoring. This game is kind of like you're building your own scoring and you're doing some scorings. So let's say I for example would take this scoring right here that says a tree knowledge. I would move my tile up or my my token up trees based on the knowledge track and then I would score mountains.
So right now I would have three mountains adjacent to each other. If I had a mine I will start with a mine over here. Let's say I built another mine over there and those would count as two and this mountain would be one. So that would be two, three, four, five. This one over here doesn't count because it's not adjacent to the others. If I got a tile over here with also a mountain, I would connect these. So let's say now that's 2, 3, 4, 5. I would score that multiplied by three, which would be 15 points, but only if I have 15 or more knowledge. So the scoring is going to be higher than the knowledge. You're trying to keep them moving to score the most points. You have something you're you're racing for, trying to do that before the other players. you're building out your board and at the end of the game there's a couple of final scorings but most of the scoring is going to come from these key tiles that gives an extra scoring at the end and the scorings you do throughout the game and that is basically the gist of what you're doing in this board game.
Let's talk about the main like mechanism in this game. First the way you play the game is moving on the rondelle. And I like the rondelle because it has like a double uh rondelle. It has the inner one with the ship and also the outer one with the wanderer.
Wonderer.
And if you play with two players, you get an extra one of each.
Um, so you have more like spaces that you can take like move from. So you have more opportunities there. But also with more players, you can like as you said, you can if you encounter another player or yourself, you can skip that space. So you can move further. There's also different abilities that you can build on your um um tiles. Yes. That could help you move your ships or your wanderer further.
Mhm. I think like the two-player game has the or it has the same amount of pieces than that as the four player game. So, I think that with two, if you hadn't have doubled up, you would have too few opportunities to move you. It would be very hard to be able to do things.
This is a very interesting game. This game has made us do two things that we haven't done in a while.
Yeah.
It has made us sit after a game and talk after half an hour about the experience
and discuss what we like and what we don't like. Very often we play a game a couple of times or more like but when we play the game we're like okay this is how we feel about it.
H and sometimes you play it the third or fourth or fifth time and we we change that but we very very early on understand what kind of game this is. And this was a game. I read the rules and I was like, "Oh, this is this kind of game where you get to do these things and these things." And then we played it once and I still felt that. Then we played it again and I kind of changed a little bit. Then we played it a third time and it changed very much. And then we spoke about it for a long long time. Then we played it again because we felt like we just had to play it and play it and play it and play it and we were in a position like, "Oh, is this the only thing you can do?" But then we played it again. I was like, "Oh, but you can also do this thing to be able to counter that thing." Yeah.
It's very hard because the designer has some intention.
Yes.
On how he wants the game to be, how they want the experience to be, what kind of strategies are there and all of that. And it's our like we get to explore that and understand that. I feel this game gave me not like misconceptions but I was like I thought this is this kind of game and now I think it's a very different kind of game.
Yes, it absolutely challenged my view on this game because when we played it the first couple of times I was just like okay I I thought I knew what what kind of game it was. Now I have to look at it differently for me to do well in it and also to enjoy myself with the experience with it because this is a very quick game. It is when we played it with two two players it takes like 30 to 45 minutes.
It was the quickest game we played in 30 minutes. That was a very racy game. It's a very racy game and also the the longest has been with four players which took us like 75 to 90 minutes
which is a very quick.
Yes. And it also like the play time is fairly short but also the game feels very quick because this is an engine builder game. You're building up your scoring in the beginning. You can take like a scoring that gives you six or eight points or something and you feel like ah this is cool. And then you can get scorings up to 50 points if the game hasn't been ended long before that though. Um so so you're building up building up building up and you don't want the game to end before you reach like
the thing that you want to achieve or maybe you want the end to game to end because you don't want the other players to reach what they're trying to achieve.
Yeah. So let's talk a bit about what we what the evolution of our thinking of this game because when I saw this game I saw all these uh multipliers all of these you're building up you're you're trying to build up scoring in the beginning you maybe score a little bit here and there and then you try to build up to get a lot of points and it felt to me like it was going to be like a sandboxing game. Not sandbox is the wrong word. It's not like you can do whatever you want because the choice like the the decision space isn't that big. There's only like this amount of things only like this amount of things to go for.
But they thought you were going to have some leeway.
Yeah. But in this game, we had a game where we played and I think this won't happen again if you play four players who played before. We played two players who hadn't played. You had played before and I played a couple of times before. Uh four player game. The last player lost place, I won't say who it was.
Uh but it wasn't me. Uh got 164 points.
Yeah. And the winner, which was me, yes, got 595 points.
Uh, and that is a big big
Yeah, that's got what got us talking a lot in the first place because how did this happen? How could this happen?
And this game from going to because that's when I had I had lost very badly the two first time I played and then I went into it and something happened in the beginning. I was like okay but if I try to raise for these things and maybe that is the thing to do and it was and that was the race for these because these are two things happen when you get one of them let's say I get this I have built three cities I get this tile so it does two things for me it gives me a final scoring of cities which means I can boost that very highly up and know let's say I have 50 or 60 points at the end of the game but it also gives me two extra multipliers to use the whole game so what happened that game and also the next time you play two players is that I got three of these first and then I basically won the game.
Okay. Not three of these.
No, no, three of three of the tiles
because they get worse. So in a two-player game, it's two multipliers and zero multipliers. So you get the scoring which could be good if you build that up, but you won't get the multipliers. So basically two multipliers like this is two free ship actions.
Yeah. And also what you are doing to achieve those like get those is building up your scoring itself. So it's basically what you're good at you will be better at. So you're trying to like Yeah. It's not like a one trick pony game. Not at all. But you're
you could do that at Sergey as well. Like there's there is different things to do.
Yes. But you will not lay your eggs in all of the baskets in the game either. I think it the thing about this game and and it's hard to like we have talked about this for hours and trying to concise it into this review for a couple of games there. We thought that you had to and I think you kind of do because if if you let one person race for all of these and don't try to get any of them, I don't think you're going to win the game. But I the thing and you talked about this a lot like you felt like the game then was forcing you down a road. Yeah,
like forcing you that you had to build up the river for example and try to race for that because a couple of them like the inventions, the river and the sanctuaries, those are the ones that you just get while building.
Yes. And we kind of agree disagree on this one is that for me it doesn't take away from the game that the game is forcing me to do one of those three things because that's how I win because that's what I'm I'm trying to do to if I see somebody else trying to rush three scorings, I should probably try to stop them because this is an interactive game. Yeah.
This is not a game where you can do your own thing and hope that somebody else doesn't do better things. Yeah,
you have to look at what they're doing and try to counter it. Also, what we felt very after we played all these plays is that the crucial time is when you pivot.
Yeah.
For example, the sanctuaries, they only count if they're not adjacent.
So, if I had built this up there, I would go from having two to one and not to three. For example, the last time we played, I after I placed two extra tiles in the beginning, uh I was like, "Okay, you already have three sanctuaries. I could place this, which is pretty good for me, but then I get one. Okay, I'm not going to do sanctuaries. Yeah.
And if I had chosen that maybe four times later, I think that would be too late.
Yeah. And it it is interesting because that is a thing in the game in games in general that I'm not very good at. I want to stick to my plan if I if I have one.
That is true.
You're not very good at you. And that is like you you like these solo puzzles.
Yes. Um, and also as we talked about, I I felt like I was forced kind of to do something in the game that
like race for those three very like easy milestones to go for, but I feel like I suffer more from that in a two-player game because then because then I have to do it. There's no one else to do it. If I don't, you will get those because they're like the easiest to get. So, I think that that will be a trouble for me with a two-player game. Um, in a four-player game, I can do a little more what I thought was fun that I do a little of different stuff in the beginning and then kind of find my way. Uh, instead of being like this is the road that I go on, boop.
Yeah. But I think I think I think that that my feeling with this game is that because it's so short.
Yeah.
You have to like and that's the reason also the pivot the crucial timing of that is very important is that you you can't choose late game.
Yeah.
Like if you don't choose something that's going to work or you try to to stop somebody from getting something I don't think you're going to win. Like I think that like the the in the decisions you take in the beginning are very crucial. So I think like going for building up something is very important. Like for me the game feels like this. I build up and maybe I do some scorings here and there or when I move past the halfway I try to have Papyrus so I can do the scoring. I also try to have Papyrus so I can move extra on the knowledge because that will help me score more points.
That's important.
And it's more important than like if you're playing with cutro players. You could also like play this pretty cutthroat with somebody taking a scoring just because somebody else will get a lot of points for it.
Yes. But there is luck involved in this game. Um because I have done that. Yes.
And being like okay I will snag this scoring before you. Another scoring flips and it's even better for you. And I was just like no. And that scoring didn't even give me a lot of points. So I don't think it's the way to go, but I think it might be sometimes it can be what I was trying to say actually is like you will get the knowledge, but the knowledge isn't that high. So you will get more knowledge from other sources in the game. And what I was trying like I'm trying to build up to get one or two of these. Yeah.
Or four if I'm playing uh very well. And then try to build up. So I will try to get points for many different things. And after that, my goal has been to up my knowledge. Yeah.
Because the final scoring, I know I have that one. That's like the only scoring I know like there's all the other scoring somebody can take from me. This one, nobody can take from me.
Yeah. It's very interesting because you have this aspect in a lot of other games too. For example, I'm just going to take a random example. Uh Princess of Florence. Okay. when you in the beginning you get you get get the the choice of taking the thing bonuses that you get in points or money in the beginning you will choose money because that's early game you need that money to build something else up and you want to find the right point in time to start taking points because it's the end game now and I think that is very hard to comprehend for me in this game when does the end game start when should I stop building up and start like capitalizing on what I have built up. And also this is this is a game where when you get the ball rolling, if you if one player gets it rolling pretty fast, it could be difficult to catch up.
Could be.
Yeah, because it very much depends. No, it depends on how you play and also the setup of the game because all of these are different each time, which I really like, but it feels very differently. So this you take out and so next time the actions could look like this instead. So now you have to go there to get their minds. And what I do enjoy and this is a thing that we played very differently the last time we played. Before that everybody kind of played it the same t same way and that is when something is emptied. Let's say I take this mine there's no more mines there and then place a final scoring tile. So this one for example says take two knowledge. I can pay uh three a piece to get 11 points. And there is a lot of different ones of these. You can for example this can never be empty. This one is empty. I get nine knowledge and I get two pay two a piece for four points. So we have been playing the first times we played we've been kind of ignoring them.
Yeah.
Until like the game we are getting things going, getting things going, getting things going and then starting to do them. But I felt the last time we played that this was kind of a counter strategy for somebody being quicker than you in the game.
Yes. Then you can first off get knowledge. Second, you can get points pretty easily and you will trigger the end of the game quicker. Well, in my defense, the first times I've played this game, I forgot that you could do this for free even though you couldn't afford that. So, that is a crucial crucial part of information that I kind of missed the first times.
So, anything else you want to add or should we jump into the next segment of who is it for? Who do you think is going to like this? Do you think it's better for people or dogs?
I think uh sort of it caught me off guard. Yes. Uh people.
Yes. I agree. I agree.
Yeah.
So that's who's going to like it? People. Who do Do you have like any thinking of who's going to like this?
Well, I think I I'm just talking my personal preference. I would I would prefer this with three or four players. 100%. Um, so if you are playing a lot of two-player games, um, and kind of see the same issues with the games that kind of I tapped into. Yeah. Um, it it depends on you really bothered with that or not. And then I I think you should Yeah, I don't know.
Better be more players. What you're trying to say. So when I'm thinking like the two-player game, I really enjoyed it, but it was very different. like as when you play the two players in half an hour, it's just like bam bam bam bam bam. It almost takes more time to set it up. It doesn't, but there's a lot of setup in this game. I feel like if you enjoy an a race, it needs to be a race. It also is not as solo like multiplayer solar as it might feel the first time you play it. It's very interactive. not like haha in your face interactive, but it's very important to be you have to enjoy looking at what other people are doing and interacting and trying to stop them. There's a couple of kind of mean things you can do like pushing them over the halfway point so they don't get to do the bonus action and stuff like that. And sometimes I really want to go there with my ship and then you bounce me there and I can't go there with my ship now. So, so there's a couple of things like that that you need to be aware of.
But with that said, let's do some final thoughts for this game. Paperia,
I like the game. Um, but it has, yeah, the the journey that it has taken us on have been challenging for me because as you say, sometimes we play a game and we very quickly get like a feeling of it, a good feeling of how well we like it and also what kind of possibilities and what kind of game it is. And then we play it more times and it really just confirms our initial thoughts changes is but this has changed in a lot of ways and it's been a long time since I played a game like this. Uh that said, I think it's a really solid game. I think it's cool that you can play it in such a short time and it has this variable setup and also the interaction between the players makes it really fresh each time. That said, it's kind of the same things you do.
Oh yeah. every time. We played it a lot now. I'm kind of done.
Yes.
Um, but that said, it is a game that makes me really think about how to play it because I don't feel like I'm any good at it. So, that also want me makes me want to play it more.
I'm going to land on the seven. I think it's a good game.
I I really like Paperia. Uh, I also I like it more than you in in many ways. I think that many of the interactions here are very interesting. I this is one like as you said like we are not used to playing games over and over and over and over but I I I could let's say I had fewer games and we didn't have YouTube channel. I would be very happy to play this like five ten more times to see like okay what more is there here and as you said you are doing the same kind of thing but the board setup and especially the interaction the interaction what's is what is going to make the game feel different each time because it's not like you're going into this game and being like this guy I'm not going to build any rivers and then all the ties available will have rivers on them and you're going to be like nope not going to build that you will lose it's strategical but more tactical Yeah,
you will have to look at the available tiles. You have to look at the starting setup. You have to look at what the other players are doing. Always ready to like crucial timing and doing these things and learning that. I've had a great time with this. I really think it's a a a good game. I I think it's a great game. I'm going to give it an eight.
Cool.
So, that's going to be the end of this video review that you watch. I don't know why I said video review. It's not like, oh, it's a video as well. I only listen to the audio. That is the end. We hope you enjoyed it and we hope you subscribe. What more you can do? And we're sorry we're saying this in all the videos. It's just what we have to do. You can click the bell and choose all notifications to get uh the videos every time we place a new video.
Yeah. And also join our Discord.
You can do it. We believe in you. That's the end. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes. I'm And you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings. And bye-bye.