4 Game Reviews - Floriferous, Game of 49, Grog Island, Pick Picknic
Transcript
hey everybody today I'll be taking a look at four board games in quick succession and sharing my thoughts on each of them I'm doing the model in one video just to help me catch up through my backlog of games because I'm starting to fall behind again so the four games I'm taking a look at are Grog Island we have the game of 49 we have hick hack in gako whack and finally we're going to finish off with fluoriferous but before I start my reviews on these games I want to give shout out to the show sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so let's start off with Grog Island by Michael renick this one is a bidding Style game that takes 60 Minutes to play on average um accommodates two to four players now the game is gonna look like this when it's set up essentially you have all these peninsulas at the top here where you're trying to get some Arrow control down because at the start of the game you're going to get given a bunch of secret objectives and these objectives can be things such as have the majority on the yellow Peninsula or it could say if every one of these uh hand buildings you're in you'll get x amount of points or for every one of these um you know coffin buildings you've got in you're gonna get x amount of points and so on and there is going to be some cross-contamination there so I could be sharing objectives with other players got your money track here you've got
your score track here and more importantly you have this part of the map which is where the gameplay takes place and this is a really cool mechanism actually that I've never seen before and I would actually like to be seen again so essentially at the start of each round you're going to be rolling all these dice so you're going to put them on their matching colors like so then on your turn you are going to use these dice to bid to get presents down on these peninsulas and when you do that you are going to choose some of these dice but they have to go in a certain order so let's just say I chose this one here I put it in the top box now everyone following it has to be equal or lower than the existing one so I could do this I could do this if I wanted to I picked the four there hell I could even do this and bid three of them now once I've got my bid locked in it's going to go to the next player who is either going to raise that bid they can completely reorganize it as long as the total pit value goes higher than the existing one or they can pass now if they pass they're going to take a number of tokens equal to these exposed spots here so you can see here that if the if the if the next play would pass they'd get a coconut one to get a fish one and they'd get this map token and the idea is then you would come to the bottom part of the board and use those tokens to trade in to get different bonuses which can be things such as money it could be these treasure cars which has a kind of a random number of money on the reverse side you get more money there you can get you can interchange your um objective cards and you can even get
these parrot cards which will let you manipulate the dice and even bid the same as somebody else um in turn order which is a little rules break there and then essentially once everybody's passed I mean you are or the person with the highest bid is going to pay coins equal to their bidding amount like so reduce their money potentially spend some treasure cards if they didn't have the funds and then they are going to start allocating um their control pieces on the peninsulas now the trick to this game is though that the color of the colors of the dice are important because they match the building spots here so for example I would have to use um a or to put a worker down on a Green Building because the green is next to the Green Building there and then I'd have to do a blue building on this one and the more dice you used means that you can potentially get victory points and even get these padlock tokens which can lock players out of taking other buildings and once that's done you are going to rotate these around to mean that all the um different tokens are going to be worth or useful for different things and so on and then as soon as somebody's got all their workers down which is going to vary on the Play account like I think in a in a three player game you're gonna have nine workers each in a four player game I think you have seven each which is going to pretty much fill up most of the map here um and then the player with the most particular points based on what you've acquired during the game and the ones of your secret objectives are you know it's going to be the winner and these objectives aren't only going to relate to the majorities or the building types they could be things such as you know for each treasure card you have you're going to get x-matter points or for each parrot card you have left in your hand
you'll get x amount of points or for each token you have you'll get more points and something I didn't mention as well is that not only can you cash your markers in for the upper bonus you can also cash them for the lower bonus which means you have to trade four in at a time but you can jump straight in and get a building down which is a nice little shortcut there but yeah this game is football for me to be honest it all boils down to this one mechanism of how the dice are used that manipulating things even using those parrot cards to you know vary things in your favor um and obviously managing your money as well because you're going to have to set out quite a lot of the auctions because if you do then you're going to have the option to trade the tokens in to get more money in your supply and to keep you going but you have to be quite careful not to be too chilled out or to sit back too far because if you do you're going to fall behind on deploying your people on the peninsulas and uh inevitably that's going to catch wolf guard and you know you'll be caught off guard by The Rush strategy if that makes sense but yeah I actually do chronic um of this part here this idea of yes I'm using these dice which is going to cost me quite a lot of money um if I use more Dyson we're going to get more bonuses but I'm leaving more opportunities for my opponents because they're going to get more of the tokens which can be used for you know great um great benefit so yeah that for me is where the game shines the rest of it is okay I'm not the biggest fan of kind of hidden objectives anyway especially when there is potential for a couple of the
players to share some objectives like for example I played this game the other day me and one of my opponents had the exact same objective therefore we were diluting our scoring and the other players had some objectives that did not contaminate with anybody else therefore they scored the full amount of those objectives and I'm there for one now I understand you can try and predict what the other players are going for therefore you can try and sabotage their plans by going for the padlocks Etc but you're probably not going to do that because you're going to be focused on your own stuff but yeah this is definitely a lighter you know a game on the lighter end of the Spectrum which is fine but it might just be a little bit light for me that being said I would love to see this be used in something else this is super cool and you know I have a lot of bidding games in my collection and none of them do this so yeah I like this part but the rest of it is okay at best and yeah that's pretty much my thoughts on this one a kind of a a great mechanism in a in an okay game so that is grog Island and I rate that one probably a five and a half to a six out of ten the next game we're talking about is the game of 49 this is another auction and bidding Style game this is a two to five player game that takes around 30 minutes to play on average and the board is going to look like this which is essentially a seven by seven grid hence the name of the game of 49. and the idea is that we are trying to win control of these different numbers with the aim of trying to get four of your pieces or your counters in a row column or diagonal and as soon as you get your
fourth in a row column or diagonal then you are going to be the winner of the game and you're going to do this by revealing a new card which will show the number that comes up for auction during the round so for example this will be the 25 other auction um which you know might not be a great number but it could be a good number because this player wants it for this vertical here and then in a simple auction fashion you're going to go around in turn order trying to raise the bid or dropping out of course the last player standing is going to play all that money to the bank and put their control marker on the matching spots now this guy does have some cool little twists to it for example some of the cards in the deck will say things like this where you've got the 49 in the middle that will come up to auction more than once in the game so you can actually control Power or change power um of who owns the 49 spot and also only a few of the cards have this payoff part of the card here at the bottom which means that you have to pace yourself quite carefully because you can quickly run out of money so you can actually go through quite a few cars before your supply is topped back up with with money and the money that you get back is based on your control and influence on the board because you can see here you're going to get seven dollars per control marker you have on the board so having presence down is just important in the first place because if you don't have enough presence and you're being a bit too you know being a bit too standoffish then you're not going to have any money coming back to you and also there's some cards that look like this where you can see it's a lot more
flexible where this card is actually going to be quite valuable because it could you can actually win any of the 41 to 48 markers here which of course are going to be important important to some players and that's what even applies to some of the outer rims or the the kind of middle Rim here as well and that's essentially how the game is going to play out you're going to keep going until somebody has that four in a row and the game is going to end immediately when that happens now I actually do really like the concept of this game I like the way that some spots are worth more to other players you have to kind of hate bit sometimes just to stop people in their tracks and block their their rows and columns which is quite cool however there are some flaws with the game um for example often you'll find yourself that somebody will have three in a row they just need their final piece like for example this red player here needs the Final Four and when that happens of course that player is going to bid every single penny they have to win it because why wouldn't they why wouldn't wouldn't you bid everything you have and that really does play a big part in the turn order structure because if you know that the player whose last intern order has more money than this player then you can just sit back pass and let the last player spend all of their money just to stop the other person from winning and of course when that happens they're going to run out of all their money as well and then the person who hasn't bid anything is going to be in a much stronger position so there are some turn order issues I have with this game and I think it's actually somewhat fixable um and we whenever we played this game we always household it by using a blind
um bidding system rather than the standard you know round robin bidding system which I think makes the game a lot more fun and it stops it from being so drawn out and tedious by just constantly I'm you know bidding one more than a previous player if everybody does one bid secretly in the hand reveals it it means that some people are going to be overpaying some people are going to be under spending and that kind of thing so that makes it a lot more enjoyable but it still is difficult to come or to counteract that that final spot mechanism where somebody's going to always bid every single penny they have and it almost always leads to a anticlimactic finish because you can either stop it or you can't but I actually do like the rest of the game I particularly love the pacing of the money I think this is awesome you can also you can often find yourself just spending all your money having nothing to compete with and go through several cars before you get your money back and I also do think it's quite an obvious strategy in this game just to get your markers down on the borders quickly as possible because if there is a payoff card early then you're going to be in a much stronger position than every other player and it's hard for the other players to counteract that and come back from that deficit so I think this game has a lot of potential but it also I think it has a lot of rough edges um and I think because my um bidding and auction games you know part of my collection is so saturated now I don't think this one is going to stand out quite enough but I do like it we've played it quite a few times we've had some fun with it but I think we're just about done with it but yeah I'd love to see this one be reworked remastered with a few of these little issues that I have being you know ironed out and sorted because I think it could
be easily done yeah that is the game of 49. something I should mention as well is that the production of this game is absolutely terrible and really cheap pieces um you know paper money which is horrible to play with um so yeah bear that in mind as well but if you can pick up a cheap copy then I would say give it a go because it definitely is some fun to be had here but ultimately I'd always lean towards some of my favorite auction games over this one and I'd probably rate it around a six out of ten with the blind bidding mechanism maybe a 5 out of 10 with a standard round robin the next game I'm looking at here is hick hack in gakawak also known as pick picnic this is a Stefan Dora design takes around 20 minutes to play and accommodates two to six players now the game is gonna look like this when it's set up where you have these six different tiles here and every round there's going to be one of these cubes distributed on each of the tiles and these cubes come in three different colors you've got the green ones the blue ones and the yellow ones and they're going to be worth one two and three points respectively at the end of the game so everybody is going to get given a hand of cards and these are going to be you know randomly distributed and these cards are going to come in two different types they're going to be either the actual poultry cards that look like this or they are going to be uh Fox cards that look like this and this is a simultaneous selection game so everybody is going to choose one of the cards in their hand and then they are going to reveal them at the same time and then certain things are going
to happen depending on what people choose so if everybody I somebody chooses the card and nobody else has chosen it then you're going to get all of the cubes on that card like so on that tile so for example if I played The only green card I would be the one who gets all of the cards from the green towel now if a number of poultry cards are played of the same color then there's going to be a bit of a jewel where you're going to roll a die and add that to your strength here and whoever kind of wins the jaw is going to get the cubes or you can be a bit diplomatic and share them out as you see fit you have the option to take or to play one of these kind of quicker birds like this now these kind of do a quick grab and you can run and grab a green Tube before anybody else gets their hand on it and that relates to the fox cards that look like this now the fox cards are interesting because if somebody goes to a region and you have a matching Fox card so let's just say um I don't think I have the colors here but let's say I played a fox card I revealed it and somebody else went for the yellow one and it was a poultry card that I would actually end up taking the poultry card and eating that and getting that for end game points based on the strength here so that's a really cool little twist there so it's kind of like bluffing double bluffing now if there's several um Fox cards and a poetry card go to the same spot then the fox cards will have a jewel just as if you were the poultry cards before and that's pretty much how the game works you're going to keep on going until all the cubes have been taken and then add up your points based on you know the
cubes you've collected and the um and the poultry cards that you've eaten with your foxes and then the play with the most points is going to be the winner so as you can tell this is a very silly simple chaotic game but it is fun in its nature you could definitely play this one with absolutely anybody and to be honest kind of a simultaneous selection style games I do enjoy them in general you know I like a lot of them and some of my favorite games use this mechanism now I don't think this is the strongest example of simultaneous selection and the reason for that is because it you know because you're doing it so often you know time and time again and repeating yourself it makes the decisions feel less consequential so I for example I love games like for sale because you actually only do the simultaneous reveal so many times which makes each each selection feel more important this one you know is so chaotic that you're not quite sure what you're going to get and you know you're just basing it on you know bluffing and double bluffing yes if there's a spot here with um a bunch of uh breadcrumbs on it you've got a good idea that there's going to be a bunch of poultry that are going to go there because they're going to want their fair share and you might play a fox card to do it um but of course other people are going to know that so they might hold off on that tile and I'm therefore you're going to waste your Fox cards Etc but you know I don't want to make this sound negative because I do enjoy this game I've had a lot of fun with it but I think it does have a bit of a glass ceiling on how many times you can play this game and have the most fun from it so yeah I like it again just a little bit take too chaotic for me um a little bit too light maybe the
decisions aren't quite there and it ends up just you know you can probably do just as well by playing random cards as you can by trying to think your turns through but you know it's silly fun it looks cool and it's a bit of a throwback really and I think you can definitely get a few plays out of this and um you know play with anybody and you can all have a good time so that is Hiccup and gakawak again also known as pick picnic and I rate this one about a six out of 10. and the final game I'm talking about today is fluoriferous by Dr Steve Finn Eduardo baraf and Clementine campadoo this is a small box fella game takes around 20 minutes to play and accommodates one to four players now this is a set collection drafting Style game as you have this Tableau of cards which are a bunch of different types so at the top here you have these public objectives that you're trying to aim towards so for example at the end of the first round if you have um any of these symbols or any combination of these symbols then you're going to put one of your control markers down and get the maximum amount of points but the longer you take you're going to score fewer and fewer points but there is some crossover between the two so you can be working on several at once but the main structure of the game is by moving your player piece onto one of the cards in the next column and you're going to do that based on turn order on who's the highest from the previous round but this is of course the starting order so for example this player might really want this Daisy card and then put it on there like that and collect the card now you can also see that some of these cards have these Stones allocated to them and they play it within most stones at the end of
the game we'll get this little tier card which is worth another couple of points but once you've moved your piece and you collect the card and potential stones on them you're going to add them to to your tableau and that piece is going to remain in place and then it will go to the next player so let's just say the uh the green player here wants to take this card like so they'll add it to their collection now some of these cards are going to have to score on a sliding scale like this and you can also see that a bunch of these cards have um different symbology on them so they have a flower type they have a shape surrounding that flower which is important and some of them also have these bugs on them and you can also see that depending on the player count some of these cards are going to be flipped face down now you can also see at the bottom row here you have these different shaped cards which are going to score you points based on different criteria and let's just say the yellow players chose to take that card this round like so and in this case this card is going to say I'm going to get two points per every little one Pentagon that I've got there so hopefully I'm going to be collecting those as the game goes on now I suppose the biggest Twist on this game is the turn order structure because whoever has taken the highest card from the previous turn as in the green one here taking that one furthest to the top is going to be first in the next round so it has this kind of trade-off thinking yes I really want to get this card perhaps I really want this scoring criteria because I've got a bunch of you know ladybugs here it does mean if I go that deep I'm going to be last in the next turn and it's all about pacing yourself
you know when you're willing to sit back and sacrifice going first or when do you really need to guarantee yourself first place and um you know take the top card regardless because you need to secure that spot and no on top of that this is just a simple set collection game you're going to play through three rounds by going left to right right to left and then left to right again and of course the play with the most points at the end of the game based on those public objectives your personal objectives is going to be the winner so yeah this is a pretty much picked by number Style game there are a ton of these games out there however I do think this is a particularly strong example of this type of game it's very Breezy it's Charming you can certainly see it has a stunning visual look here with these watercolored um flowers and it's a true filler you know this isn't going to be too taxing on the brain but it's not brain dead either you know you do have to think through you know again especially regarding that turn order and I do like to get the crossover of the objectives there and because you can be working on several thing at once you know maybe I do want this the ladybug criteria because that is not only going to allow me to start collecting ladybugs that way but it's also going to let me start aiming towards these two objective cards which can be you know kind of compounding when you're scoring and getting lots of bang for your buck there so yeah it's a clever little game again it doesn't do anything terribly Innovative or it's not going to be you know it's not going to have a standout impression in your mind but it's I think it's going to be one that you're going to come back to because it is so Breezy it does take 20 minutes and again it fits that nice bracket of being a filler but not being a brain dead filler so yeah this one I do enjoy quite a bit I would give it a soft recommendation I think it's amongst
defense better games I do think he's a designer who's either hit or missed for me generally more missed and hit to be honest but this one is you know I would I would lean towards that hit side of things so yeah I think this one's going to stick around for a little bit longer in my collection I want to play it a few more times just to see how I feel about it um you know am I going to Tire a bit quicker than that I'd like really because again it doesn't do anything terribly inspiring but it still manages to put a smile on my face so that is fluoriferous all right this one probably uh maybe a six and a half out of ten um if I'm lean you know if I'm feeling generous I suppose but I would I would recommend it to the right game group and that's it really that is all the games I'm talking about this episode um so that's for reference um it's hick hacking gakka work in the game of 49 and grog Island so apologies if you wanted a full review of these games I'm just a bit backlogged at the moment and I don't really have the time or capacity to do that but regardless I hope you've enjoyed the video if you have please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye