Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 246: Mark Diaz Truman on RPG vs. Board Game Design

Transcript 1:08:13

And now for a quick word from our sponsor. I am proud to announce that the Beyond Solitire podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through Games and Simulations. Their upcoming project, Line by Line, will crowdfund on Backer Kit this October, and you can find my interview with the designer, Tilac Vias, in the show notes. CJS's most recent project, The Blue Way by Jason Morning Star, is also currently up for pre-order. It's an amazing RPG about oppression and identity, and you should check it out. For now, though, let's get on with the show. Hey gamers, this is Liz Davidson from Beyond Solitire. And this week on the pot, I have a very special guest. Uh this is Mark Diaz Truman. He is a co-owner of Magpie Games and he is also an RPG and tabletop game designer. How you doing, Mark?

I'm good. I'm good. Thanks for having me here.

I'm um I'm super happy to have you on because our lives meet in a very important place and that is the root RPG.

Yeah, that's true. Like sometimes I go on podcasts or or vlogs and it's called vlogs. Am I too old? If I think they're vlogs. Um, the better go. And I was like, "Hey, person I've never met before who's played our games or something, but uh yeah, you and I are are tied up in this funny little woodland called Root."

Indeed. So, I'm not a huge tabletop RPG player, although I would enjoy changing that given the opportunity. Um, so I feel like I'll be asking you questions from a perspective of somebody who doesn't know what they're talking about, but that's what you're here for.

That's great. Yeah. No, that's awesome. I mean, I'll tell you like things have changed a lot. When I started in this industry 15 years ago, I literally would tell people I made board games because it was too much work to explain to new people what RPGs were. And thankfully, because of Critical Role, you know, uh, Stranger Things, whatever. I can actually say the words, I make tabletop RPGs, and they say like Dn D, and then I say yes, like Dn D. And then we can have an actual conversation.

Hey, that's better than like Monopoly.

Right. Exactly. Yeah. Right. Do you make Monopoly? like no not even close. So,

so what inspired you? You know, this is before my time at Leader. So, what what led to I guess the idea of a root RPG?

I I actually think that the root RPG in many ways is like like a platonic ideal of how a license starts because a lot of times with licenses, you look at something and you say, you know, well, this is it's so popular. It's so huge. Wouldn't it be cool to do an RPG in that? if you want to play in that world. But there was something really pure about the start of the root RPG which was sitting in our conference room, me, Brendan who's the co-designer for the for Root, Marissa who's been, you know, co-founder of Magpie and I think our friend Katherine and we were playing the root board game for like the sixth time in about two weeks. So we get came home from Gen Con and we were just playing the game over and over and over and like with this kind of odd fascination. We weren't we we didn't really I think fully understand why it was like hitting us so hard. We were like, "This is really interesting." And I was playing the vagabond and I had this moment where I was like, "I really wish I could do like more here, like get deeper. I don't know, get to know these clearings, get to know this space." You know what? That would make a really cool role playing.

That's the thing role playing games do is go deeper, right? To like dig in deeper with this thing. And so I just messaged Patrick on Twitter back when, you know, before Twitter was

was X or whatever it is now. Yeah. successful pool. I messaged him on Twitter and said, "Hey, we have basically the same all the same friends. We all know the same people. Do you want to make an RPG of of this game, Ruth, that you guys publish?" And Root had just started, I think, to kind of pick up. And he was like, "I love RPGs. Let's talk." And we walked into that first meeting basically. So, it's about a bunch of vagabons. Yeah, it's about a bunch of vagabots. Okay, cool. And that was it, right? And then everything went from there.

Yeah. Honestly, for Patrick's taste, that couldn't have been a better pitch. He loves the vagabond and he he does love RPGs.

Yeah. Like

Yeah.

A lot.

I I was I mean Yeah. When we talk with licensers, you know, like we look at someone like like like Paramount where we do the license with Avatar the Last Airbender and they still don't really understand what an RPG is. Like they even we've run it for them. We It's just like you don't have that years and years of deep understanding. Patrick was like, "I'm running this. I'm running that. I'm running this thing. I ran this other thing you sent me." like there was a lot of like really deep interesting kind of conversations and then Cole who was our main like sort of point of contact he's running games for his kids he's running games every other week for Drew like this there's a lot of stuff there that I see as like the leader games team very early on was invested in making a great RPG and that made our job a lot easier

that's awesome so for those of you who have not seen the the root RPG out there you essentially take on the role of a vagabond and you can have multiple vagabonds who are doing vagabond Um uh so Mark, what what made you choose that role as a way to enter the Root world as a character and how did you build an RPG kind of like what concepts are you building that RPG around for for interacting with Root as in this way?

It's such a great question. I think it's one of the I think it's like there's a really interesting thing about talking with with people who play role playing games and people who like tabletop RPG designers versus tabletop board game designers. I think board game designers really focus a lot on constraints. Like you like the board game kind of space requires you to really think about what is the box that I'm drawing around this space. What's inside? What's outside? And what's challenging about tabletop RPG design is it is actually very difficult to put anything outside because people want to enter the space and say I'm a vagabond and I'm choosing anything I want to do in this story. Right? And so like we don't get to say sorry you have to play one of the cards in your hand. Like that's just not an option. We have to accept that people are going to do whatever it is they're going to do except really like the design is about constraining them without looking like you're constraining them. So when we say you have to play a woodland creature, then somebody comes in and says, "Well, I want to be a human." And you're like, "Sorry, it's not an option. You can't do that. Sorry, it's not an option." Right?

It's a constraint. Right? So really a lot for tabletop RPGs players and a lot of designers don't think enough in terms of those constraints. They just sort of say, "Yeah, you could do whatever you want." And then the question is like, "Whatever you want means what?"

Yeah.

Like what?

Tell me what you want. Right. Like like, "Oh, you've sent me a board game. It's a it's a a two two dice and a bunch of wooden pieces. What do I do with them?" I don't know. Whatever you want. Whatever you want to do with them. Right. And so so like there's this thing where the very first and most central idea that I think magpie puts at the forefront of every game we make and this is I think probably our biggest contribution to RPG theory is the idea of a holding environment. And this really comes from um the adaptive leadership stuff that I did at the Harvard Kennedy School um when I was there doing my masters in public policy which is about the idea that like groups systems have this sort of container in which all the conflict happens within that container. So this is easy if you think about like working in a business. The business is kind of the holding environment and there's a sense here of whether the holding environment is strong. It can take a lot of conflict.

It has the ability to kind of keep people inside or it's weak. And weak holding environments can look actually like no conflict because people know that if they have any conflict, the holding environment is going to explode and it's all going to it's all going to break apart. One of the reasons that we have such intense conflicts with our family is because we kind of intuitively understand that like they kind of have to still love us when it's all done. So me and my brother can like get in a fist fight while we're 13 and in the you know outside our house and we we're still brothers the next day. But we kind of understand that somebody you just met, somebody that just came to work at a business, a church you just joined, the holding environment is not maybe there yet, right? So yeah, but when we think about an RPG, what we're really think about is what is the holding environment for this? And Dn D has one of the sort of oldest, most time-tested solid holding environments, which is do you want to keep playing a game with your friends?

The problem with that is it's not a fictional holding environment. Meaning, yeah.

Meaning like the problems come when you want to keep playing games with your friends, but the thief and the paladin are now at odds with each other because in the fiction they're they're not friends, but you are friends outside and there's a disconnect. And so we spent a lot of time, if you look at something like um our game Masks, which is a teenage superhero game like Teen Titans or Young Justice. Brendan designed Masks with the idea that you're all on the same superhero team. So, if you get in a big fight, then you know, of course, Super Boy and Robin get in a big fight on Teen Titans. What happens at the end of the episode?

They figure it out.

They make up, right? And they get back together. So, we know how superhero teams work. You get in a fight, Cap Cap and Iron Man get in a fight and then the team is broken apart for a while and then the super villain wins and so the team has to like that sense of the team coming back together. It's a really strong holding environment, right? Root needed a strongholding environment because if we do something where we say, "Okay, my character works for the Marcusat and your character is with the Eerie Dynasties and my character the other character is a lizard cultist. What are we doing together?" Like what what what would we possibly do together in the woodland? Right? Any one of those could kind of work, but then not all of them can work. So we have to find some way of looking at the woodland where everybody could kind of be on the same page or at least argue about the same things. And that for us very early on was having everybody play a vagabond and that you're a band of vagabond. So you don't agree, you don't necessarily get along. You don't have the same ideas, but you do have the same perspective.

You can't, for example, decide, well, I'm just going to work my way up the ranks of the Eerie dynasty,

right?

That's that's my character's journey. It's like, well, every other character is like, well, we're not we're not doing that. we're not interested in working with the Yuri. So the vagabons really give us the ability to say as long as you can stay a band of vagabons, as long as you can stay friendsish, then you're gonna be able to keep having adventures. And that's something we also trust you out of character to manage as like your players are going to decide to stay together and play together.

Interesting. Did you consider any other paths? Because like the story of working your way up through the eerie dynasties is inherently like an interesting potential.

Oh my god, it's so good, right? like the idea of like just doing it within the arena. So the first thing is the vagabonds are great. We joke sometimes that Root is really the Fast and the Furious role playing game because there's no no cats, no masters. Like you do what you want. Everybody every single vagabond is like a superhero is able to do amazing incredible things beyond what every other you know Dennis of the Woodland can do. But you can still do the story with the working your way up the Eerie ranks if you ally yourself with the Eerie and kind of convince your group to do that. and the vagabonds are flexible enough that that's not that's not 100% outside. It's just not necessarily where we're going to start, right? Um, but we have definitely designed games like Urban Shadows, which is an urban urban fantasy role playing game in which somebody can say, "I'm a vampire who is in this sort of vampire organization dealing with vampire problems, and you are an immortal who kind of looks down on the city from above, who's mixed up in business in my territory."

And so we're not really friends. It's not like we're not we're not like we don't like hang out on the weekends, right? But we're like both mixed up in the same story. And the reason that works is again this holding environment idea. What's the holding environment for a different fantasy game? The city,

right? So there's like a pot to put everybody in.

Yes.

That makes sense regardless of their roles like within the game.

Yeah. So if we were to limit ourselves to a single clearing, right, then like sure that makes it a lot easier. There's an eerie post here and you're playing an eerie soldier and I'm playing a blacksmith who's kind of with the dead asins but secretly working for the Marcusat and you know our other you know Patrick's playing a Woodland Alliance founder who's trying to get this whole clearing to that sounds great but if we're in three different clearings at three different times I don't know how that would work.

Yeah, that's a really good that is a very good point. Um, so I guess like as you work on this RPG and on, you know, I mean there have been expansions for it and everything. How do you choose where to expand a world like R?

Well, so this is an interesting thing with licenses is that like a lot of times we decide cuz you guys decided. So [clears throat] like for example, why are there four new factions? Well, you made the crows, the lizards, the otter, and the and the moles. So cool. Guess what? We got to bring those to the game. Um, but part of that is also trusting that like what you all bring into the game is interesting and dynamic and doing something. So, I mean, I will tell you that we we gave out a bunch of cool little badges at Gen Con. You guys have them at your

Yeah, we love them. Thank you so much.

Yeah, they're they just have the the sort of like the name of the faction with a little symbol and the color and stuff. Do you remember what was popular at your booth? [snorts]

Oh god. Um, it was a mix. I gave it a lot of different ones which made me really happy. Yeah. I feel like being just a straight up cats or keepers person is a base choice.

Yes.

Um there were a lot of lizard cultists. I am one.

That's what I was gonna say

that one. So many lizard cultists, right? Like people instantly gravitate towards the lizards, right? And I I see it in everything we do. Like the dice we sell, the the gribbons and everything. You're right. Like I don't know how many people really are excited about playing kitty colonizers. I mean the cats are cute, but like the lizards. I don't know. Do you know why? Do you have a some sense of why people are so drawn to it?

I think people just find cults and religion inherently interesting, especially because the lizard cults beliefs are not defined, which means that you can have all the fun of being in a culty little group without actually having to think about the belief consequences of it, which makes it fun. I'm just one by family loyalty because I have a bearded dragon and she comes to the office with me and she has like a lizard cult background on her tape.

That's amazing. Yes. Yeah. Well, there's something I mean I think there's something really beautifully like and I say this without judgment like without without trying to other them, but like there's something alien about the lizards. It's not the otter cult, right? The otter cult sounds kind of silly and and like I don't know, not real, but the lizard cult feels like these people from far away who bring something different to the woodland. And you know, we did spend I mean there there is some belief systems that we had to define to give people some direction. But like you said, there's so much open room in what the lizards actually believe and how they work. And I think people just feel this really incredible draw to them as others and them as religious figures and the complications of that. And so like when we think about what to add, it's like we are definitely following in the sort of leader games like wake of here's the stuff you guys are giving us and how exciting and interesting is it? We also give away a lot of Corvid conspiracy stuff, but that's because we're magpie. So I think people are excited. They feel like it's kind of an alignment.

Oh, I love I love the Corvids. I I like the mischief they bring to the game, too. I think a lot of people when they play, they want that sense of playfulness. I think the crowds are attractive because they are inherently, in my opinion, the most playful

faction. Um there's an unseriousness to all the traps and the guessing and stuff that

makes them a blast.

But it's actually they were very hard to implement in the game because remember each faction has to sort of have a win condition for us like a fictional win condition. It can't just be you scored the most points. There has to be some way almost like a coin game of us looking and saying, "What does it mean for the eerie to win?" Okay, well, they control the woodland. They return to the top. What does it mean for the lizard cult to win? Well, maybe nobody controls the woodland, but the religious movement succeeds at converting enough woodland denisens to be real. What does it look like for the corvids to win? And that was a really difficult conversation. And finally, we landed on a kind of what we jokingly call the Tony Sopran Crow model, which is that the their sort of corruption is so serious that whoever is in charge, maybe the cats are in charge, but the crows are pulling all the strings because they actually have corrupted every meaningful institution.

And so, like thinking through what you guys do is like 90% of our work with root. It's like how do we figure out how to implement these amazing board game factions into a thing that is an RPG you can actually engage with at a fictional level? And we talk a lot about the fiction and diagus, right? Like what actually shows up in the fiction because things have to appear in the fiction. They can't just exist at the level of mechanics because fiction is a mechanic in RPGs.

Okay, this is a just a hot take that I'm just going to have. Um, but I think you might be right. Tell me what you think. Um, do you think that the Corvids and the lizards are also attractive to players, especially in the RPG world, because even on the board, I feel like they're easier to roleplay. like my table talk increases

when I'm playing one of those factions because you know you take over it's like I'm innocently building a garden how dare you martyr me oh no like if you're the lizards or you know if you're the crow it's like you got to guess you going to guess you know like there's something there's like a certain behavior that it brings out of me that's different from like okay well I'm going to program my cards and and I have to battle on these clearings like there's it's almost like those are storyheavy factions in a story heavy game [snorts]

there is something so true about that from from and this is interesting to me having done more board game design recently and and sort of like crossing those streams of where where is where is something an RPG and where is it a board game. I think we're at this point in the industry where there's a lot of back and forth between those two things. Yes.

I think the irony is that of course RPGs came out of wargaming. So, like there was always a sort of tabletop game to RPG pipeline, but there was a long time, I think, especially when you think about like the Vampire the Masquerade years where like Vampire the Masquerade does not have very many board gamey elements. In fact, the mechanical elements of Vampire are sort of legendarily sort of uncooked or like undercooked, right? They don't they don't really work. The ideas of Vampire are so powerful and so interesting. But the irony of the of the many many vampire board games of today is that the vampire RPG really was about having big feelings. like big feelings, kind of disconnected from the mechanics of the game. Um, but yeah, I think it's really interesting to see that there are certain factions that people embody, right? Like that we talk a lot about embodiment in RPG RPGs. Embodiment is the moment at which you are playing your character. I think of it kind of like an actor, right? So, you can play your character in an RPG very distantly. You can say things like, um, okay, Liz, you're running the game. Um, I tell these people that if they don't do what I want, I'm going to kill them. And then I tell my fellow PC, look, I need you to get on board with this. Uh, what is, and you might say, well, Mark, is that what you said? And I said, I don't know, something more persuasive. Like I I would say something more persuasive. We have to accept that because you're not

if you're character's charisma is a million, then I can't say, well, Liz, I'm sorry that wasn't you. You need to do a better job of persuading me out of character.

That's really funny. You know, sometimes I don't, you know, this is fair enough in all solo games, right? Like a lot of solo RPGs involve dice or cards to kind of determine results of things, but if I know I did a good job and I'm playing one like an aspect of roleplay, I'm like, "No, I'm just going to give myself this. I know I nailed that explanation." Like even in my own personal mind, right, like I know whether I've like really played something up or not.

Yes. Yes. Well, this is this is a this is a thing because the whole thing you're like sort of lifting up the right rocks here to talk about some really difficult RPG stuff, which is what do you do if we're playing a game in which there's a persuasion rule. Not all games have persuasion rules, right? Right. Um like let's we're playing a game with a persuasion rule and you come to the table and you say, "Okay, uh you know, king that's that's holding my friend hostage. I have this gem that you've been looking for for the last 50 years. I will give it to you if you release my friend." And there's a part for me as the GM is like, am I making am I making Liz make a persuasion role here? Like this seems this seems like it's done.

Really good trade. Like

a really good trade like done, right? You know, so am I the GM authorized to say, "Yeah, like you just just done [clears throat] or do I have to say no, you need to roll and if I'm asking you to roll, what am I asking you to do?" Right? These are sort of fundamental questions to RPGs. And I think when it comes to why people are so excited about things like the lizard cult or corid conspiracy, it's a little bit because I think it authorizes them to do an embodiment to to have a body to their sort of talk of their work. The wiz the woodland alliance does this a little bit where people get a little sassy when they're playing the woodland alliance, right? But like it's hard as the cats to be like, "Aha, I the colonizer have taken back the clearing you liberated." Like it's not it's not as fun.

When I'm them, I always focus on the buildings. Like, oh, look at this beautiful thing I made. Like, don't you just want more? I have to I have to make sure everybody has this beautiful

Yeah. Yeah. And and one of our challenges with the RPG is actually that we have to make every faction reasonably sympathetic because if if we create a world in which we say, "Okay, here are the cats and they're just the worst and here are the birds. They're just the second worst." and the only reasonable political stance for you to have is woodland alliance or nothing, then we've created a very boring game because you basically just like everything you do is just like, well, I I work against the cats and I work against the birds and then I side with the woodlands.

RPGs work way better when they problematize things. And what I mean by that is if you come into an RPG thinking, well, I'm definitely going to support the Woodland Alliance, and then the Woodland Alliance does, I don't know, an atrocity or two because they're insurgents. They're not actually like, you know, Robin Hoodesque fairy tale, you know, like rebels. They're like a real insurgency. Then you have to ask yourself like, am I really allied with these people? Some of which maybe don't even believe in the insurgency, but just want to do the violence, right? Like, how do I feel about that? And now we've problematized your experience in a way that's very productive for a role playing game, maybe not so productive for a board game because there's no mechanisms in the board game to engage and resolve that. Right? The RPG gives us the space to do that. And so I think all of this is when you go back to the original vagabond is I'd like to be a vagabond and deal with the problems of a vagabond. You can't actually do that in the board game.

Yeah. Although I do think board games have also taken some really interesting leaps into having more emotionally resonant mechanisms and theming uh in ways that aren't quite role-playing, but sometimes offering those structures and those choices, it's like, okay, well, if you want to win, you have to be a Yes.

You're going to have to do something bad.

Um I think that forcing somebody into that track,

I mean, obviously we're choosing to play. It's but like if if you offer what you offer players in a board game is its own statement about what that world is like and as you choose to enter that world you are agreeing to play by certain sets of rules where certain things bring you success even if they are bad people things to do.

I mean this is I think the the best and and easiest way to access this is thinking about a coin game like Fire in the Lake or Distant Plane where if you're playing the Taliban in Distant Plane you're like okay so you're going to do some terror attacks. I'm not saying I'm not saying you might do some terror attacks. I'm saying you're not going to win the game if you do not understand how to leverage this terror mechanism. And every one of those terror attacks you do, you have to kind of in your head be like, "So, I'm doing a terror again." Right? There we go.

But also, the act of doing it and then seeing the consequences and doing it on purpose to get a board effect is an intellectually interesting thing to do because it tells you how does Vulco, who worked with the CIA, like understand the effects of things like this. Yep. And so it's depersonalized. You abstractly understand that you've done a terrible thing. But what's interesting in the board game version of something like this is that you get to see how it impacts the world in a large as opposed to the individual lives you just wrecked.

There's a set of like incentives. You know, I remember when we first played a Distant Plane, we decided to play the long game. We set aside a whole day for it. We played for 14 hours because like one of our first coin games. We're also figuring out how it works. And at the end we were all mad and maybe didn't know who won. So I was like, "Afghanistan, we did it. We didn't Afghanistan." Um, but we we had these moments where I was playing the Americans and I had a moment of saying like, "Guys, I can't believe I'm about to say this, but I think I need to surge in here and win this war." And like I had this like terrifying moment of like me, you know, anarchist socialist liberal over here being like, I think I understand the US military in a way that makes me uncomfortable. Like that I Yes. I see the board and I see the incentives. And yeah, that's the kind of thing I think that board games can do so powerfully is to lay out incentives and have you intellectually sort of thoughts versus feelings, intellectually see it and then have feelings from those thoughts, right? But then within like the RPG world, it's sort of like you have these big feelings and then you're like where do those take me, right?

Okay, I guess maybe I don't want to support every insurgency. Some insurgencies could be bad actually and that really arises from the feelings that come out of these engagements with an actual like a lived insurgency, not an abstracted insurgency. Um, and so part of what's really interesting is sort of on the role playing game side, how much can we push this idea of incentives in a in a positive way, like giving you real incentives to do things and making them meaningful and binding. And on the board game side, how can we push the feeling side and give you feelings about the things that you are grappling with that then will lead you to make different decisions because of those feelings?

Yeah. Do you find Okay, so obviously every role playing group is different. Um people respond differently to options, but in a role playing game where you could be anything and be any kind of person.

I feel like most people have a hard time actually choosing to fully embody someone evil. Um whereas a board game can like let you fake it from a distance. It's like I mean what do you when you when you're incentivizing different behaviors like do you feel weird about what you might be incentivizing in a role playing game because people choose so much more of it and invent so much more of the path for themselves and also do you see differences in who players are willing to be because in a board game you can say well I'm just following the rules so I'm not

choosing this like you know I guess what kind of weird quandaries do you find on your end of the business?

Oh my god. Yeah. I mean, I think there's a game design quandry in general. You know, we we did a a longtime program for the Harvard Kennedy School and the Harvard Executive Ed program where we did a zombie simulation where people would come in and create a country and then have a zombie apocalypse happen. And of course, everything goes wrong. And the whole exercise was about learning to manage loss. And so, we'd have these discussions of how did you manage the losses that you encountered? Um, and again, this is sort of some adaptive leadership stuff around um, thinking about your capacity for loss and when did you when did you stop making good decisions because you were overwhelmed by loss and you didn't know what to do next. Um, and so we really worried in designing that that the right answer is round up everybody who's infected, execute them, and then lock down everything. What message does that send as a game designer that you think the right way to respond to a crisis, the right way, the way that works mechanically, right? Um, and and as we saw people try different things, I was reminded that RPGs are really great at problematizing, meaning the second that you do that, you now have solved quotequote solved the the zombie crisis, but you have not solved any of your internal political crisis that really the best thing to do would be to somehow balance getting consensus about how to deal with the zombies while dealing with them. So, it's this impossible line to walk.

But I think it would be fair for somebody to walk away and say, "Y'all are telling me that fascist governments would do a better job than non-fascist governments at dealing with zombie apocalypse." And I'm like, I don't know, man. There's no zombie apocalypses. But sure, I it does seem to look like fascist governments are good at dealing with crisis. And that's not really true. It's complicated. I think that there are times where, you know, we give incentives. we we try to pay very close attention to not just the text of the game but the subtext and I think that's a difficult thing to kind of address which is if you say for example in Urban Shadows that there are many many different kinds of supernatural creatures and they don't get along particularly well and the game is often about their problematic relationships with each other have you just written a game that's anti multiculturalism like it's tough Right. This is a really tough question. So, so I think that what we really try to focus on, I think this is a thing that's the reason people keep coming to RPGs even when I think on average RPGs yield more unsatisfying sessions than board games do because they're just more chaotic.

They're more open. They're more they're less constrained, right? They have a lot more ways to go wrong. It's hard to just get five adults in a room on a regular basis anyway, right? Like there's lots of problems with RPGs, but I think the reason that they are so incredible is that they problematize things

very productively. Meaning that if somebody says, "I'm gonna play an evil person." I'm like, "Okay, that's cool." Like, "What what do you mean by evil? I'm really really selfish." Like, "Okay, and now I'm going to give you like a like a like a 10-year-old child." And this 10-year-old child doesn't have anybody else in the whole world. And they remind you a lot of you. Do you want to do anything with them? It's like, "No, I don't care about them at all." He's like, "Okay, cool. I will move on to the next thing to problematize your evil, problematize your position, and something because you're also a human being is gonna is going to catch you and then you're going to have to deal with that sense of your selfishness is now being undermined by your own actions, by your actions.

Yeah. Oh, that's fun. Um, so, um, Root is not the only IP that you have worked with. Um, I would, uh, you know, most notably y'all have an Avatar RPG. Um, but how do y'all how do you what is your take on IP versus not for role playing games because y'all have done a variety of projects?

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I mean, our first project I I'm looking out this little window of my office here because we actually have in our lobby everything we've ever printed, one copy of everything we've ever printed here in our lobby. And I have it here in part so I don't, you know, like throw myself to the floor and wail and weep when things are hard because I look out my window. I think every one of those things was also late and difficult and hard. So like we'll make it right. Um, but our first book was like a 6 by9, you know, little GMless role playinging game like that that that we, you know, not first, I guess, our second book, but like was was I it took me, you know, a couple months to write and we got it laid out and printed and the whole process probably took less than six months from start to finish. And now we do these giant IP books that take five years to get approved and through the process like it's so different. I think that licensing I have two thoughts. One is kind of a product based thought. So, I'll do the product thought and then the game thought first. We make I think those two lenses are really productive for thinking in a professional way about the tabletop RPG industry is what's the product doing and what's the game doing.

On a product level, licenses are incredible because they give you a floor. They say that there is going to be this many people at a minimum interested in this thing because you're giving them something they've probably already always wanted, which is the ability to spend more time in that space. And so I think for example there is some floor where just the fact that there are so many root fans and so many people excited about Root means there's some number of people who just are excited about the root RPG that they just want to play more Root. Even if they never play it, even if they just buy it and put it on their shelves, they are very happy that they have the access to more Root. Um there's also in many cases though a ceiling. Meaning, if I tell you, you know, Liz, we're we're doing an Avatar the Last Airbender role playing game, and you've never seen Avatar the Last Airbender, you might actually have a negative reaction. You might, I'm good, thanks. I don't really want to participate with that. Um, and so there's a way that it it kind of puts you in a band of interest of like what people are willing to do. Um, and one of the reasons I think Root is so successful, for example, is because its ceiling is very weak. Meaning if somebody comes to you and says, "Hey, I've got this cute animal game where you we're gonna play adventurers who are animals who go around this forest having you know different adventures and and you know deciding whether we're heroes or villains or rogues or whatever and you're like well I've never played the board game." The very first thing somebody's going to say is wait it doesn't matter. You don't need to. It's you know I I'll teach you everything you need to know in five minutes. I don't think it's realistic for me to say you don't need to watch Avatar the Last Air Better. I'll just tell you everything. I don't think that would resonate with you

in the same way.

No, I think that's probably correct.

You You would not believe me if I said, "Don't worry, I'll sum up both shows, all the movies, all the novels for you. Don't worry about it." I think that would not that would not seem correct to you. So, so there's a difference where I think there are some licenses like Alien for example where I think you can get across the main ideas of Alien in about five minutes and everybody kind of is seeped into the popular culture and I think people kind of know what you're talking about and then there's things like Fall in London which is one of our licenses where you probably should have played this browserbased game for an extended period of time to have any real sense of what this game is about or what it's doing. I think on the game side, licenses are challenging because they require you to be in constraints that you would never have selected.

So, for example, I think the Lizard cult is very attractive to people,

but really hard on us on the RPG side because we have to give you enough to play it, which means we need to tell you something about their beliefs. So, we've written down a pretty serious amount about the Lizard Cult's beliefs, but then we're we're maybe that's not what we would have done if we were just creating an RPG version. Um, and I think this is most obvious with the Avatar game where there wasn't a lot of information about one of the eras. So, there's five eras of the game and four of those eras were pretty well documented in the shows and movies and stuff. One of them, the Roku era, was not. And so, we [clears throat] got to write it. And if you read through those eras, the Roku era has a lot more hooks and a lot more unsolved problems and a lot more places for the PCs to make a difference because it's written for an RPG, not written for a game or not written for a show and then turned into an RPG.

Yeah. Yes.

So, where do board games come into all of this? Because I also know that's something that you have been dabbling in. and I played a board game of yours at Jen Con.

Yeah.

Um and so uh what's uh what's the plan for integrating all those things together?

I we are super interested. I mean we we have been board game fans for a long time. It's it we we do RPGs in part because that was something that we loved very early like as kids but especially over the last 20 years. I mean, the board game industry has so like it's it's transformed, I think, from those like sort of late 90s Euro games that I saw a lot of to, as you just said, like a really rich variety of games that are exploring narrative and the form of narrative and sort of even the whole idea of like playing board games not to win is like just such a a rich and exciting space, right? You're you're playing to win in the moment, but nobody at the end of Andy and Abyss is like, "Gh, I didn't win." Like, you're like, "That's not the point, man." like you're here in this space doing these things and that starts to feel a lot like an RPG, right? Like we're not here to win.

I had somebody ask me the other day, well, how does somebody win an RPG? And I was like, you have a great time with your friends. That's how you win. It's like that's not really an answer, right? Um I think that what we are excited about because we're also doing some new game design stuff on the RPG side is exploring different levels of stories. So, for example, the game that you played is an urban fantasy game sort of based on Urban Shadows has some ideas from that RPG, but it's at the level of factions, not people. And I think that's a thing that I have always wanted to kind of have some tools for telling stories about factions, but like RPGs are not the right tool to tell stories about factions, as we've been discussing, because you can't be from 17 different factions all in the same game. And I'm I'm sort of struck by the beauty of being able to tell stories at a level that wouldn't work for an RPG that's like outside what an RPG does well.

Yeah. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense. Uh so, you know, as somebody who's now designed in both spaces, um how like what is the difference for you in terms of like iterating and you know, bringing a board game to life versus a tabletop RPG? Well, I think uh first of all, I would say that that you know, we did Wizard Kittens, which is a casual family-friendly card game back in like 2019. And like, you know, making casual games is hard because they're so small, but also they're small. So, there's some sort of like manageableness to them. And we also knew that for wizard kittens, a big part of the attraction is you get to play kittens who are wizards. And so, the arts mattered probably more than the game mechanics in some ways. working on a serious midweight tabletop strategy game is very humbling. Like like it's it's a good reminder that like I spent a lot of time making RPGs and the the board games I've I've played and critiqued and had thoughts about man you all have to work hard to build something from small pieces if that makes sense. I feel like one of the big differences for RPGs, like I'm saying, the big the big picture questions matter so much and then we build from down from those big picture questions. And as long as every piece is kind of in service of that big picture question, I feel like we're good. Like we make it work, right?

But you all have like this card and this card have to go together and produce interesting things without producing destructive things. And you can't tell me when they're both going to show up. And that is like really challenging to make sure that you build from that ground up to create the thing that you're trying to do.

Yeah. This also makes me think of play testing. Like how do you I know how you play test a board game. You just make people play it and watch it a million times and do it yourself a million times. But what about like how are RPGs actually tested and you know what are some like I guess differences in that part of the experience?

Oh my god. Yes. Like I mean so first of all I think like people talk about blind play tests a lot like you could pack up a game you're working on send it to me I can play test it based on the rules you've given me and you will probably have a good sense that I've run it correctly right

that is really hard to there's a reason we write 150,000word books to to tell you how to run a game. It's really really hard in RPGs for you to run it correctly. So, a lot more of the time we're running it because we have internalized all the things need to be internalized and we're looking for whether or not that resonance emerges, whether we have one of those moments where, you know, your lizard cult member has to make a choice that's really hard between honoring the cult and honoring their friends and whether that was a productive conflict. And if instead you end up yelling at the other players because of how this went, I'm like, not so much a productive conflict, right? But then I also have to filter out well everybody knows that Liz is an out of she like Liz Liz that's the kind of character Liz plays like you know so I' I've got to like also work that in. There's a lot more like uh art than science I think to play testing RPGs and making them work. But I also think that Magpie does a lot of work before we get to the table thinking through incentives. So, like I think a lot of RPGs play testing doesn't do much because the incentives aren't in line and they're counting on players to like play to the genre instead of the incentives.

Yeah. I

if that makes sense. They're like, "Well, you're heroes, so you're going to do hero stuff." And I'm like, "Yeah, but like why? But what if the rules are telling me not to do hero stuff then?"

Right.

Right. That's so like we try to work a lot of those bugs out early so that what we're looking for at the table are these like moments of resonance and beauty and how often am I getting to them. I don't think that's how board games work. I don't think you have moments of resonance and beauty that you can kind of work towards. I think you're looking for whether the system as a whole is producing sort of the right tensions and conflicts for the players and whether at the end you [clears throat] can look back and say did we experience what I was looking for here in this narrative and the competition right and so one moment of resonant beauty in RPG that's really good well like your the session was fantastic like the rest of it was a mess we didn't know what we were doing but this one moment that really clicked is sometimes enough to make the story feel extremely solid

I don't think that's enough for a board game I think you als also need to have some sense of more. I'm cur I'm curious for you like what what makes a great play test for you when you're when you're working on something?

Well, actually a lot of what you said, what makes a great play test for me is am I watching players struggle with the exact types of decisions I wanted to watch them struggle with? Yes. Are they doing the kinds of things that I wanted to incentivize them to do? And are they having the emotional responses I was hoping that they would have to those things? And is there anything that's getting in the way of them doing that or that seems to accidentally be incentivizing them in directions that are bad? Like in board games, like one thing I always think about is don't offer someone a tool that doesn't actually do anything. Like having a power that's just a stupid one that's a whole lot weaker than all the other ones. Just don't even put it in the game. Don't because if it's there, people assume they can use it. If it's shining in a video game, people assume they can click it. Um, I actually think this may be true for RPGs too. A lot of game design, this is a weird way to put this, but it is about manipulating the player to inhabit the decision space that you want them to have. And all those rules and guard rails and stuff in board games are supposed to keep you

Yeah.

in the state the designer wants to keep you in. So, first of all, like it's so funny that on on the surface A+ cosigned, all that is true for RPGs, but I think there's one interesting difference that actually captures why it's so hard. So, you know, Luke Crane at Burning Wells talked a long time about, you know, uh game design is mind control, right? Like creating a space where players are making the decisions you want them to make. They're not choosing the outcomes you want them to choose. They're making the decisions you want them to make. They're grappling with the things you want them to grapple with. Right? I think that's true across all games. I think that's what games are about in a lot of ways. But within RPGs, players want to make any decision they can they want to make. So in Urban Shadows, for example, we do have like a faction turn where time advances and people like the characters like do they work their normal jobs? Do they go try to do something in downtime? And one of the options you could choose in downtime is just worse.

And it is to do nothing. If you choose to do nothing, it's just worse. And players will sometimes be like, I don't get it. I if I just sit in my house and don't engage the city politically, bad things happen to me. I'm like, yes, right, but I have to provide that option because if I don't provide that option, then the player's like, well, I don't understand. I don't want to do anything political, but Mark's game is making me do a political thing. I don't want to do that. That breaks my immersion in the game. So, what I have to do instead is say, "Okay, yeah, you know, that makes sense. You want to sit at your house and do nothing and let the city's politics happen to you? Fair enough. Enjoy."

Right?

I don't think that's an option in a board game. I think you need to make sure every available door that you're giving your players is leading somewhere productive. You can't give them doors that are unproductive because you're not teaching them anything. thing. I don't know if that makes I don't know if that makes sense. It does also I mean board games in a way that RPGs don't. They tell you who you are. Like you are taking the role of the insurgents. You know you are all you know monks making alcohol. You know like you know who you are.

It's not up for debate. It's not up for debate. You can't say halfway through I know we were making alcohol but I'd like to stop making alcohol and instead reform this entire institution. It's like that's not really an option. Right. You can't Yeah. We have to make room for that option,

right? Like you in a board game, you're choosing the role.

It has some flexibility, especially as the the hobby and the craft of doing board games evolves. Yeah.

But it will never be free the way an RPG is free.

Right. And I think that's actually the big difference, right? Is like you cross over into an RPG when things are truly free. And the goal of an RPG designer is to create the systems that give you as much freedom as can be managed within the story you're trying to tell. I can't give you infinite freedom because then we're not doing anything. There has to be the right amount. Um, but I think there's something interesting when I think about being a board game designer. I'm having to really learn and internalize and really prioritize telling people much more who they are. And and being willing to say, I don't care that your versions of wizards would look this way. This is how the wizards are in this game. And you just need to grapple with those tensions. Um, because my instinct, I think this is true a lot of RPG designers who would make board games, my instinct is to be like, well, I what do you guys want? what you guys want to do. And so really being bold with those choices has made the game design much easier and much more compelling is to be bold with those choices and then let players sort out the like you said the decisions, the emotions, the things that come with inhabiting that role really fully.

Yeah. So okay, this actually leads to another set of questions that is a little bit more capitalistic but I think related. So when you um when you're making board games the the versus RPGs, you know, I feel like board games are things that currently in the way that people play now, most people want novel board game experiences. So if you're making board games, you have to produce more of them,

more quickly. Yeah.

With different mechanical conceits so that people can have the variety and the novelty and the ability to always chase something new that they want. Uh, in an RPG, you theoretically could just take an RPG and make a very broad variety of human experiences within one system if that was what you and your players wanted to do, which is why D and D, of course, is so dominant because it's an easy access system that you can do a lot of different stuff in. So, how do you how does that change the market, I guess, for RPGs and offering different ones and trying to kind of hit different specifics of the market? you know, what's the crossover between RPGs as well? I'm just very like curious about how that aspect of it works.

Such a great such a great question again about about what for me the core of that question is sort of like what does it mean to engage an audience over time, right? So like so like there's a thing where at some level you know leader games is going to sell root till the sun extinguishes. Like there's just so it has hit in such a way that there's so many people engaged with it that other people who don't know anything about it then become engaged with it because other people are engaged with it. And that's a thing where like you're going to sell copies of that forever. That's cool. But that's not you keep just make keep making root expansions and be artistically satisfied or continue to have any sort of movement in the industry. So that novelty, that desire for something new, but I would also say solid, right? They don't board game fans don't just want new junk. They want new, when you say novel, you mean genuinely novel, something really actually different and new. I mean, one of the reasons that I think that we are excited to make board games is we're excited to approach board games from the perspective of an RPG RPG designer. I want to push that idea of like what does narrative storytelling look like? What does asymmetric emergence look like?

Those are places where like I think we have some unique perspectives as magpie to bring to the table and produce some novel stuff. On the RPG side, I think we face almost the opposite problem. Every single book that we've ever made contains enough stories in it to last the rest of your life. Why would you ever buy another game from us? If you bought Root, you've got 25 years of play in that book. Enjoy. Like like you're done. You don't ever need to buy a book from us again. You don't even need don't buy the supplements, don't buy anything, and you're g you're still going to have an amazing experience. Um, one of the reasons that I played a lot of role playing games as a kid is I'm from Albuquerque, New Mexico, and there's not a lot going on in Albuquerque, New Mexico, and it's not particularly a very wealthy place, but if you picked up a copy of Vampire for 40 bucks, that was infinite play, right, forever, as much as you wanted. Um, and that sometimes creates some weird incentives. Like, I think that there's a point for RPG creators where there's just too many RPGs. nobody can try new things because they're still trying to get through the old things. And I think that's true for board games, but you all are very heterodox as as a community. Um, when I'm in my board game mindset, you know, when I'm being a board gamer, like tonight, I think I'm going to play a board game with some friends and I'm looking over my collection thinking like, what haven't I tried yet? What what's new? What's the thing I just got in the mail? Like, how do I bring that to the table? I don't run RPGs like that, man. That's not I don't I don't say like, "Hey, everybody's coming over.

I know we're in the middle of a mouse guard campaign, but that. let's throw that away and try whatever I got last week. That's not the mindset, right? So, yeah, I think that you really as an RPG designer have to grapple with um you know, the weight of history. Like people are playing a lot of D and D. They're playing a lot of vampire. They're playing a lot of things they've played for a long time. What do you possibly have to offer them that's worth them trying something new? And the board game side, it's almost the opposite. It's like, how are you going to get people to play your game twice, right? Is like the the challenge. What do you what are your thoughts on that? Like how do you actually think about like what makes a game worth playing twice, three times, 10 times?

You know, it's also interesting um because you talked about sort of tolerance among RPG players for having a bad play session.

Yeah. Yeah.

Uh board gamers do not have that mercy.

You must make sure that the game is engaging.

I mean, I'm willing to try like I play a lot of heavy historical stuff and will try things a couple times before I make sure I understand the game.

Yeah. But when you go into those, that's what you you understand that if somebody buys the game at Target and takes it home or somebody like, you know, is a light gamer and they go to the board game cafe and they're looking for something to play, you've got to figure out how to make it so that even if the game is hard to learn, there's enough appealing about it that people want to give it another spin and see if they can get it right this time. Or you want there to be enough of a, oh well, I could have done this and I wonder what would have happened for them to try it again. and the actual act of play has to feel good enough that you want to scratch that itch again. Um, and it's really really hard to do. Uh, but among RPGs, it feels to me like people are very willing to chalk up because so much of it is dependent on the player. Like how do you decide whether you blame the game or the players that a session didn't go great?

And I feel like it actually makes it maybe harder to determine whether I would think an RPG is good or bad versus a board game. I'll play a board game once or twice and I know if I play an RPG I I don't I don't play them on so maybe I don't know this but I don't know I don't know how to assess it.

Yeah. I think that the first the first and most important thing is that the board game is externalized.

The board game is an experience separate from you and you can look at the rule book and you can say this rule creates this situation. It's right here in black and white. Doesn't really work. Kind of undermines the whole experience. Or you can say, "I've moved all the pieces around the board and I didn't feel anything and I don't think I'm going to feel anything." Right? I think there's a thing when people play root and it goes disastrously wrong because it's so asymmetric and they don't really understand what they're getting into and the cute animals are cute and the game is not cute that they're like, "What the just happened?" But they're not like, "I didn't care." They're like, "Oh my god, that was wild. I need to do it again." Because they understand that something was happening. something meaningful and they need another shot at it, right? But like that sense of like the board game is doing that thing and you're there for it is so different than as you put it, I the player am now part of the game with the RPG. Did we have a bad time because Liz did this thing and it upset me out of character like and and Yeah. Right.

Right. Or did we have a great time because Liz and I have a great time going to the DMV. So like we had it was a great time. We had a great time. I waited for my license. We told some jokes. We had some fun and yay roleplay games. It takes, I think, a lot of critical analysis and time spent in critical spaces to refine and understand what what RPGs look like. Um, I think the indie game reading club, which is run by Paul Beley, is one of the smartest critics for for RPGs because Paul plays and has played a lot of different games and thought very critically about them for years. But yeah, if we play a game and you have one of the first things I told Brendan when he came to work for us was all the way back when he first got started was that fun is irrelevant. Fun doesn't mean anything to an RPG.

Productive problematized conflicts that lead to motion moments of emotional resonance. That one.

Yeah.

Even sometimes those moments of emotional resonance are misery, tragedy, heartbreak. That's what makes a good RPG. Fun is something you can have with your friends anywhere, right? So, so how do we do that? How do we balance the need for fun with the need for the real game doing the thing it's going to do? And if ultimately the cult of the GM tells you, well, whether you had fun or not is whether you had a good GM or not, then who cares what game you buy, what pro what system you play. When we say the system matters, which is a big sort of debate in the RPG community. What we're saying is that the tool you pick up to build the house is going to shape the house. We're not saying that the tool is going to make the house all by itself without you being involved. It's saying that you can't really get away from the fact that the tool is shaping you too.

The hammer makes everything look like a nail. It's because it's shaping you as as part of the tool. You and the tool sort of work together. So D and D is a tool that tells particular kinds of stories well and it's going to struggle to tell other stories and you may not even notice that those things are happening,

right? You might just naturally feel like certain stories just didn't make sense to you at the time.

Yeah.

Never thought to do it. Yeah.

Yeah. One of the things we hear a lot from people is like, "Oh yeah, don't have any intraarty conflict." Like, "That just doesn't work." I'm like, "That's correct. It does not work in Dungeons and Dragons. Cartel as a game about Mexican narcoiction is 100% about PvP conflict. That's all it is is you fighting with each other in the middle of this awful situation. And therefore, I built a tool that does that thing well, that makes that fun." And that is so far outside what most people's imagination is for RPGs. They don't even know what that would look like. They're like, I don't I can't even tell you what what that game would do. And I'm like, yeah, that's why I made it. So, like, you can you can try it. You can see, but you have to give yourself over to it and allow it to kind of change what you think games can do. And that's I think a big thing that board gamers do really well. I think board gamers are much more willing to turn themselves over to the game and say, "Okay, this is what this game is asking me to do. Let's give it a shot and let's see where it takes me."

Yeah. I mean, there are limits. So, one thing I find very interesting about board gaming as it becomes artsier as a form um is, you know, you got lots of people who are really pushing the boundaries, too. Like, there are now games that don't have victory conditions. There are cozy games that go on forever. There are games where, you know, they they resolve, but maybe more than one person can win. You can choose whether to be cooperative or not, right? you know, there's a whole lot of interesting, you know, game systems and things that are coming into being that, you know, if you're looking for story in your game, like, you know, one thing that also makes me interested in talking about RPGs is that people talk a lot about narrative in board games. What is immersion narrative? How do board games tell stories? And like that's a longunning question. But I think that as board games work to be better storytellers, it also means introducing more fluidity into board game systems and how board games resolve.

And then people don't always know how to respond because they wanted rules.

Yeah. Yeah. I I think there's there's a really big change. I played a a game called Die by Kieran Gillan Gillian who who he's known for the comic book Die. And the game is basically sort of version of that comic book. You are playing people who are thrust back into a fantasy world you played in as kids. And so you're sort of looking at yourself through the eyes of you're like you're looking at your 17-year-old self's version of what was cool through your 40-year-old self's version of of being a person. [gasps] That's so powerful, man. That's so powerful to be like to be like, you know, what what is 17-year-old Mark want? What what would what kind of character would I make? And now what would 40-year-old Mark think of that character? It's like brutal. It's like so emotionally activating, right? Um, and then like as you get through the game, it's sort of like where there are rules and where there aren't rules. I, you know, when we ran, I ran a bunch of sessions of it. It was super super engaging. And we had a really productive last session where they sort of realized that they didn't want to be in this world and they wanted to go back to their real world, but there weren't a lot of rules for that. And then at the same time, I'm like, well, should there be a lot of rules for that? Maybe that is just a group therapy session and we just need to get through it together. I don't know. It's complicated. But I think that you're right that that one of the things that we believe at Magpie is that we think of rules as support for the experience that you're going to have. So whether that's at a board game level, it's maybe they challenge you to put you in places you wouldn't otherwise be or at an RPG level of giving you the tools to resolve what happens if you don't want to do anything and that has

to be a legitimate choice within the game. I think we think a lot about how do we build rules that support the experience that Magpie wants you to have. And

I think one of the challenges in the RPG industry is and I'm sure this is true in board games too with the co like cozy games that that don't really push players but just sort of exist as a sort of joint solitary exercise. I think there's a question of like how much do players want to be pushed? How much they want to be pushed to have experiences they didn't know that they wanted to have.

Yeah. And it's definitely a choice. So kind of on that range. I feel like one thing that you and I have in common um other than Root, but what we have in common is people is that we both love historical games because you and I met at SD His North and you'd come to like do the nerd stuff with all the history people. So,

it's so good.

How how do you feel that your interest in the history games into the hobby informs your interaction with other parts of it as an RPG and board game design center? cuz I feel like, you know, there there are some people who only play historical war stuff, but you and I are both people who love that grounding and then also want to play out in like the main areas of the hobby. Um, but how does how does grounding things in history impact you as a designer for non-historical games?

I mean, the first thing is like I didn't really think about this until I signed up to go to this S SD History Con North and which is like the just everything about it was just beautiful. like it's like 50 people or whatever, 60 people. We're all playing the nerdiest games you could possibly imagine with such intensity, but also like a lot of kindness. I think everybody who's there understands like these games are hard, they're heavy, they take a lot of work, right? Just so like it was a really great environment. I was very glad to have gone. Um, and not just because I mean also you and Cole and other people I get to see there. It's like it's a great community. Um, but I think that I didn't really think about this before, but like in a lot of ways that's what Cartel is. Cartel is a historical game. It's not actually meant to be a fun, cheeky, magic-filled role playinging experience. It's it's a it's a very challenging asymmetric view of Mexican drug cartels from 2007.

When I started writing it in 2012, it wasn't a historical game, but then it turned into one. I I [clears throat] joke that I I think that a game written last year could be a historical game in the sense that it is trying to mimic and sort of explore the tensions of a particular moment in time, not just a particular story, not just fantasy or root as being like the woodland, right? Where I think the woodland has a lot of similarities to Vietnam uh the Vietnam War, uh but but like actually grapple with like 2007, what are the tensions of being in a Mexican drug cartel in 2007? Um, one of the one of the cool things that came out of the con was I started working with a fellow conor, Steve, on um, a Mexican Revolution game because I've really wanted to see the Mexican Revolution be presented in a serious historical way. Um, and so we started talking about some of the games we were playing and both realized that this is this is a thing we're both interested in and and sort of like I think of it as I want you to deal with the actual Mexican Revolution, right? Not with just some metaphor for the Mexican Revolution, but for the thing itself. And that's what I think happened with Cartel. The reason Cartel is not popular is because I think people love metaphors. They love those sort of distance from the thing itself.

And so when you're doing Night Witches, I know you probably there are times where you're like, well, yeah, but this is how it was. There's not I can't design differently because this is true.

Yeah. Although I do think that it also makes so I as a as somebody who reviewed board games, I loved historical games because you can it's more easy to assess whether the game is on point or like reaching its goal because it has a historical grounding and you can check the relationship between the game and the history and actually look at what the game is doing in relation to something that is real. And then as a designer, one thing I've noticed is, you know, not all the games I work on are historical, but if I can work on anything that has like a political element or an economic element or any of that, I like looking at history about those topics while I'm making that game because to me, it helps me ground the mechanisms in ways that feel real.

Yes. Because even if it's not about this history, it's like, okay, well, this this is something that people have really done.

So, I can use this as like inspiration or grounding when I'm trying to make something that has that feeling of reality when you're playing in the world.

Yeah, I think that's a really good really good way to talk about it is does it feel real? And I think it's possible to make a wizard council feel real and be be binding, right? But there's something about like being like no man Ponchovilla this he's a friend to everybody and an enemy of everyone and he kept betraying people and and like I want you to play Ponchovilla and I want you to like understand why he did that and have at the end some sense of like oh yeah I guess that he was trying to sort of like become a legend. You can't become a legend by following the rules but you also can't become a legend by not having any friends. So like how do I become a legend? It must be some form of picking my moments to betray. picking my moments to make that name for myself and like that's real, right? It's like and so yeah, I think the historical games are beautiful in their rawness. It's a weird thing to say because they sound kind of like boring like like oh it's the Nicaraguan war like oh it's so it's so it doesn't have any of the sexiness of elves and dwarves and magic and dragons. But like I think that it's much more raw to play something like Fire in the Lake and be like I the Vietkong am as scared of the North Vietnamese army as in some ways I am of the South Vietnamese army. because I am going to get wiped out by both, right? And that rawness feels very, like you said, very real in a way that I think a lot of people who play board games don't actually want and a lot of people who play role playing games don't want either. That they want the metaphor to kind of give them an access point. And I understand that makes sense. The metaphor makes it fun, right? And I think that we're kind of constantly

balancing not fun, not fun, but rawness, right? Fun and raw, right? is this comfortable to explore versus is this so close is the shaving so close to the bone that I'm like getting anxious about it. So like one thing I also you know I'm an ancient historian right like Rome is my my specialty. Um, but like I think that it's easier to talk about ancient Rome because you don't know any ancient Romans and you can't and there is no news footage of ancient Romans and you know so you can kind of talk about them in the abstract because

you know you you're talking you can talk about your whenever you're talking about history you're talking about what happened but you're also talking about yourselves because it's always the way it is right you're interpreting and then you're also as the person who interprets telling a tale of your time and of yourself and of your world and So looking at distant worlds makes it easier, I think, to talk about your world because it doesn't feel like you're talking about your world. So you can chew on like, well, is this the right thing to do? Like, you know, how do I treat people? But you don't have to look at actual people when you're doing it. I think that distance creates a space that feels safer to play in. [snorts]

Yeah. Yeah, I mean I would say that the the the main thing that I encountered when working on cartel in terms of in terms of like how people had had an experience of it was that they were scared about misrepresenting Mexico or they were scared about saying something offensive. And it was interesting to me obviously white people were considerably more square scared than non-white people but like I think there was some sense like you said of this is too close right and it reminds me I put this in the book reminds me of a Judo Diaz quote where he said will read a book that's one-third Elvish but put two sentences in Spanish and they think we're taking over which is like this sense of like of like the Elvishness is so distant that it just feels like a pleasant distraction from the from the realness of the Spanish right and I kind of think it's like two ways, two paths to the real, not to get too xjeki in here, but like there's sort of two paths to the real, right? One is this sort of metaphoric path where we follow Lord of the Rings and it's this pleasant distraction, this tale of these little hobbits and then there's this moment where Sam throws Froto over his shoulder and says, "I can't carry the ring, but I can carry you." And my heart just shatters into a million pieces and it's so real it hurts. And then there's a realness that is looking at the real history of this thing and getting a sense of it and getting a sense of the terrible choices people had to make. And my heart shatters for the realness of it. And and not because it's so perfectly constructed, but because it's just so true. And I think those two are

sort of like getting to the same place through two very different vectors.

Yes. Honestly, we could talk about truth and games for an entire other hour that I will never go to work.

Yeah, I always say I'll just say the last thing is like I always say that like what I want is I want to make things that are like the wire and I want to make things that are like Wakanda. I think Latinos, for example, deserve both. We deserve to be able to have something that's brutally truthful and we deserve to have something that is a fantasy that gets at a different kind of truth. And if you only have one, it's a it's terrible, but if you don't have both, then it's terrible in a different way, right?

Yeah. Amen to that. So, your softy questions. Uh the first one is always what are games you've played recently that brought you some joy?

First of all, all these games in the historical I got to play Here I Stand for like a first like full six hours or whatever. That was fantastic. I played Gorilla Generation. That was fantastic. Um I uh I got to uh let's see what else was I I think those were the two big ones that stood out to me for the for the con. Um, obviously I've been playing John Company and still shocked at how many times it ends up as a radically different game uh when I've been when I've been playing it. Um, and then we played what's that Alice in Wonderland War was

Yeah, Wonderland way more interesting than I thought. I was like, I'm kind of into this. It's got a cool components, but we played it again the other day and it was way more different than I thought it would be the second time through. So, I I just would have been really surprised by all these great games. So that's that's probably those are the ones I've been playing that I've been thinking a lot about.

That's fantastic. And then uh the easiest question of all uh because I do know you have an online presence. Uh if people want to find you online and follow your work, where do you like to be found?

Yeah, for now I think probably magpygames.com. I know we're going to be doing some more stuff with some design diary updates and things. That's a thing that in the RPG world, design diaries are not as popular. But we're really excited to share some we've been working on with this urban fantasy game and some other things we're doing. But for now, you have magpames.com. I mean, come sign up for the list. Everything we're doing is going to go out on our email list and and we'd love to have people who are interested come sign up and check out what we're doing.

Sounds great, Mark. Thank you so much for taking the time to come on. It's been awesome to talk to you.

Yeah, it's great. Thanks.

All right, everybody. If you're looking for me, I can be found everywhere beyond solitire. Please like, subscribe, comment, ask questions, and most of all, happy gaming.

Progress saved