Critter Kitchen: Discussion
Transcript
some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to board games on like and today I'm doing a discussion over Critter kitchen the newest game by cardboard Alchemy which is the same company that did flamecraft now flamecraft wasn't an interesting game because it for some reason had this weird um stigma against it that the art was what made the game good and I'm not going to lie that the art helped the um the game but I always thought that flamecraft was solid so it was interesting whenever Critter kitchen was coming out to kind of see if that was still going to be the consensus around it because the same artist of flamecraft did the same art for this one and I gotta say cardboard Alchemy and um like this company is certainly one to keep an eye on because I think Critter kitchen is also an extremely solid game the art and production quality of this insanely huge deluxe edition do elevate it a little bit I would say but the gameplay of Critter kitchen I think is still really good I don't think there's many restaurant style games out there not really in the sense that this one does where you are going to various locations to get a different quality of ingredients to fulfill challenges and then also have like this final big seven course meal that's going to give you
even more victory points um at least yeah most of them the the restaurant games that I'm kind of aware of is usually either managing a restaurant or kind of this weird I wouldn't necessarily say like played up but like rival restaurants for I think is what it's called Uh is a lot more almost Cutthroat Kitchen style this one is still going to locations and hopefully sending your faster uh worker to that spot to NAB an ingredient that you might want uh there's still kind of that element of player interaction but for the most part it's really just trying to present the best ingredient at a or present the best meal for these challenges to get you more victory points but I would honestly say at the base level of this game it's fine because depending on player count which in my opinion you're actually going to want higher player counts because that's going to one give more locations but two means that there's going to be a different variety of workers at any given location that means there's going to be a little bit more player interaction and more thought on your locations uh where you're assigning your workers because it's like hm okay who might want that level five meat can I send my slower worker to grab it and maybe get a little bit more ingredients or do I just ensure that I get it inste my fast one oh but wait I'm like third
in turn order so if someone else sends their fast one I'm going to go last in that picking if they also go there you get that in a higher player count game versus a lower player count where lower player counts yeah there's less locations but you're kind of always going to get where you're wanting but like like I was saying at the base level of this game it's fine you're you're generally going to get your points and because the challenge meals have a wide range of victory points it's easy to get 12 you know cuz you need 12 or higher to get victory points uh to to get two victory points and that's pretty easy especially whenever you can accommodate soup soup is kind of like a wild resource and there's an unlimited amount of it so you can apply that if oh hey I need to do this this Coastal Fusion which needs fish cheese and carrots you need at least you need all of them but let's say you have fish and cheese you can actually use soup as a substitute for that and generally it's easy to get to the the 12 value at the very least and if everyone is doing that if everyone's able to do that then that means everyone's getting two points so no one's ever really gaining a leg up now I will say in this game getting an extra point here and there can absolutely make a difference whether that's from a challenge meal whether it's from your character special power
or whether it's from the critic during the game because this game is not necessarily like a high swingy point game where it's like I got 30 points uh it's nickel and Diamond victory points every every now and then and uh in the games of this that I have played I've actually seen more than my fair share of ties which is kind of interesting whether it's like final scoring I get a point because I got my seven course meal and uh some others didn't but they had the most soup so they got a point so you're kind of getting that uh you know tug of war aspect of oh I got a point more and now you you've made it up so that's all well and good because it's it's a basic worker placement not really worker placement worker assignment thing uh which I do like like I do like that element of having all the locations in your hand but you can only send one worker to one location I love the chef Academy location that has a ton of different uh extra workers that have a special ability but they can only be used on the very next round and some of them might be really good so you're going to be competing for that one but that means you're not going to another location to get maybe some ingredients you might really want um plus it also gives you an extra worker so I think that that element helps a lot but where this game really shines is in the all a card expansion where it kind of makes it module and to be fair the base game will
have its uh different challenges that you're going to go through it also will have different critics which will change the way the game works uh because they're going to kind of have an overall rule like the base game one that they recommend you start with is like hey in the final course you can have as much cheese as you want cuz normally you can only assign one to each location or each uh ingredient but you can have as much cheese as you want and whoever has the most cheese will get an extra two points and all the critics will change the rules in some way so that that alone does help the variety and then they have two different types of rumors that will either be for final scoring purposes or kind of like an overall goal for the final course which is extremely nice so there is is some variety within the base game but then the allart expansion one adds more Cutthroat uh Zoo chefs I think is what they're called instead of suf it's there's a bunch of a bunch of puns on the um in in the game which is definitely well uh well received I think uh because it makes the game extremely Charming like all of the player Powers individual player powers are based off of real chefs and I was surprised to know that I knew a lot of them and I'm not like into the culinary world at all but I was like these I kind of know all these um but so that that adds more Cutthroat uh elements there are some
characters like one uh that pulled up in the last game was all Mouse uh all Mouse workers at that character's location actually go last so that will also add some more decision- making whenever you are choosing your locations where it's like hm where do I send him where do I think everyone's going to send their fast workers and can I you know snipe them and and get to go before all of them uh so there's some clever reading of the other players whenever you have those particular Zoo chefs in and then there's the carts which in the deluxe edition will have like this whole vacuum sealed tray of pieces that are completely unused unless you are playing with the cart expansion and what's really cool about that is there's a ton of different cards that all have unique rules to the game and those carts are assigned to some of the uh specific locations cuz you're going to have a super truck you're going to have the midnight Merchant and the chef Academy but then the individual locations will have carts put with them that will have their own rules whether that will be for various ingredients to get extra victory points to completely change the way way that you're interacting with that location that I think is a really really awesome expansion because like I said the base game is fine but yeah you have different critics that's cool then you have the different rumors uh the two different
types that's kind of neat but the cards really blow this game wide open that and it's a modular expansion so you could either throw in the Cutthroat Zoo chefs or you can have the regular ones and then throw in the carts and that is really what is giving this game legs in my opinion um so yeah like I think that this game surprisingly with all even with all like the the modularity and the variety is extremely clean of a game I would say comparing the two between flamecraft and Critter kitchen this one has I think more a little bit more going for it base game to base game uh they're pretty comparable I'd say but this one has the extra step of where you can kind of add more and more and get a fresh take every time you are playing whereas flamecraft I feel like if you played flamecraft over and over it would kind of be like okay this is this is what this game is which doesn't take anything away from it but if you're wanting something that is similar in theme even though yeah this is all about cooking and and restaurants and ingredients I'm talking about kind of like the cute uh peaceful kind of comfort style this one is going to have a lot more legs to it uh I mean in terms of like negatives the it's not really like
hard negatives where I'm like I don't like this it's more of you're going to want more people because in the lower count games that I've had of this it's fine like I'm not sitting you're like this game is bad at two but it it is a lot less interactive it is kind of like oh no going to the same location again and okay good yeah you didn't want the fish that I wanted you took the other two things that's fine I got what I wanted um so there's again less indirect player interaction because there's not again there's not a lot of like I'm stealing this from you or I'm stopping you from doing this there are Zoo chefs that have abilities like that but that's from the expansion and but whenever you have more players it just it feels like your decisions make have a lot more weight when you're looking and you're like I have my three workers who do I want to send my big worker to cuz he can take three more ingredients or you can take three ingredients but God there's really good ingredients at the Garden Top Shop do I want do I risk it or do I if I send him there but then two other you know two other people go there then he's not going to have anything left so it it adds an element of like risk reward even though what's nice is if you go to a location and there's nothing there that you want or uh there's nothing there for you to take at all you at least get soup like something
um but what's also kind of neat about this game is ingredients are never lost so whenever you're done at various locations any leftover ingredients go to the chef Academy which in the theme of this game is the area that you know new chefs are being taught the chef Academy so there's an extra step for you to go there and get something but then everything that's from the chef Academy goes to the soup truck so and that's where they'll stay so it kind of allows for lower ingredients which still have their value um to still be go sought after they never get like removed which means that if higher value um increas are taken those are obviously going to be used in the challenges but then those will go back into the bag later on so I I do really enjoy this game more so than I thought I would but I was excited whenever I was setting it up because because I do I do think flamecraft is a extremely solid game and I assume this was going to be of a similar Vibe but I was very excited for the God my dog just oh my dog just like push against my door it freaked me out um I was very excited for the restaurant theme that this game was going to bring and it I mean in terms of like what you're doing on your turn you are really just doing kind of set collection with different numbers but the art and oh God
the art looks so good on the food challenge cards um it has a an aura of that culinary scene uh which I think does a really good job of kind of helping as you're playing through this game so yeah like not many not many negatives um I would probably play this game again with more people and and throw in the the allart expansion because it really isn't going to over complicate it I don't think and that would that would keep me around if the game came out just as the base game I'd be like H yeah this is fine um but I don't know if I want to keep it around but I think because for me I have the deluxe edition so that helps a lot uh that will that will want me to keep coming back and that's pretty much it um on a scale of of 1 to 10 um I think I'm at like a 7.5 like I think this game is good leaning a little bit into into great but at the same time like I think I think this one would Pro like if this one saw a little bit more play because I haven't played it with multiple people that many uh that many times um I've primarily played this at two but the games that I have played with more people it was like ah Yep this is probably better so it'll depend on how this game actually is you know how
it sees over time if I'm able to consistently get it to the table with more people um could bump that up into an 8 maybe an 85 uh but yeah this one if you honestly I could say if you like flamecraft but you were like I want a little bit more this is probably the game to go out and get honestly so I really like this company so far I think they're two for two and yeah that's my thoughts on Critter kitchen so let me know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day is for you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you