Tumble Town Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about tumbletown which is a 2020 board game uh designed by kevin russ and um published by weird giraffe games um this was actually a kickstarter from earlier in the year and it actually delivered quite a bit earlier than expected which is quite a rare thing um it's a dice driven i suppose family weight game where you are building your own little town or west you know wild western town um of these dice um i said it's a fan weight game so it's not overly complicated or complex but it has quite a lot of interesting things going on in it i suppose on the premise is a card drafting game where you have these three rows of cards and those cards are made up of these different formations of buildings and those buildings are constructed using dice so you are going to choose one of those cars based on the rows and that is not only going to take you're going to take the card and kind of unbuilt pile of buildings but it's also going to allow you to take a bunch of resources and those resources are the dice themselves so you've got brown dyes which i suppose represents like wood you've got your gray dice you've got black dyes and you've also got the golden dice as well which are kind of a wild resource or a more kind of lucrative resource and whenever you take dice you're going to roll them and kind of add them to your pool of resources ready for the next phase where you're going to construct those buildings based on the criteria of the buildings you've just drafted and those cards are ranged from very simple things such as only having kind of uh you know a couple of squares or a cup of dice next to each other
um or can be quite extravagant in terms of taking five or five dice or so in order to build them but not only are you restricted restricted in terms of the um the colored dice you need to build those buildings but they can have further restrictions too so they could have things such as you know all the dyes used in this building must be equal or ored or they all must be different pip values or they have to be pairs of dice or have to come above a certain value or below a certain value so you've got lots of restrictions you need to take into consideration when you draft these draft these buildings in order to build them but when you build them you actually physically build them with the dice you've um uh accrued throughout the game and then you are going to place them on your own player board and your own player board is kind of represent your little your little town your little high street and there's a bunch of different squares which kind of provide further restrictions or opportunities to score in for example it might say you know if you place a brown dice on this on this spot you'll get an extra point at the end of the game or if you have a stack of at least two here you'll get an extra point or if you have a stack of three here you'll get an extra point so not only are you trying to draft the dice based on the all the cards based on the dice you have you're also trying to build the buildings based on your formation of your town as well in order to get as many points as you can and you know once you build them you are going to place the buildings that you've constructed onto your built side of the of your town um which not only gets you points at the end of the game but will also give you lots of mitigation um tools
at your kind of you know that you can use at your whim really such as you know re-rolling the dice or changing the pit values up and down or you know up and down a few or um you know getting new dice into your pool or trans or transmuting one dyson to another couple of dice so as the game goes on and you're building more and more buildings you've got the opportunity or an engine to really mitigate what you want with those guys to let you build the more expensive buildings which is really cool and that's pretty much the flow of the game and you know at the end of the game you can get points based on how many buildings you built um you've got a secret objective at the start of the game which gets you bonus points you've got to the additional points based on the actual physicality of your town you know based on how many of those restrictions you're adhering to so yeah lots of points you can um you could focus on and you know the the game is not overly long it it's you know you're only going to get say you know seven or eight buildings built um and the game basically ends when um a couple of those dice colors are kind of gone down to a couple of couple in the pool so um yeah it's not overly long it doesn't take too long and you've got to weigh up you know are you going to really focus on those getting lots of cheap buildings out to try and you know get as many bonuses as you can and and kind of trigger off your secret objective or are you going to go for those really expensive buildings that use all those gold dice and you know not only are they worth more points but they also give you more um more end game scoring options as well
such as you know get um you know might say get a couple of points for every pair of cactuses and um i don't know bushes on your um on your cars combined so yeah you've got all that different set collection methods going on as well as the um you know dice or taking a dice resource and taking your cards so there's quite a lot of decisions that go on that tick along quite nicely in terms of constantly mitigating your dice to plan forward and draft the dice or draft the cards you want to fit that and the that that's basically for the game it's very very simple but it ticks along nicely and it's it's fast it's it's satisfying in terms of the you know ultimately it's a game where you're rolling a bunch and a bunch of dice throughout but i love the extra element of being able to mitigate to quite a quite a good degree so it's very fun to do that it feels quite satisfying when you are you know really tailoring the dice you've um you've taken to your needs and you've also got to bear in mind as well you can only ever carry six dice through from from round to round um so you know you've got to be quite you know wary of the fact that you don't want to waste resources by not building something every round because you could be just throwing dice away for the sake of it so yeah meaningful decision-wise there is quite a lot to um to bear in mind while still being quite breezy and simple to um to play um the balance of the game seems pretty good as well i mean you know are you gonna you know as i said go for these lots of cheap buildings so are you gonna go for these more powerful ones um you know are you gonna really focus
on getting your own buildings down are you gonna um maybe go for one of those more expensive buildings and then try and get as many set collection bonuses as you can off the back of that um so yeah mechanically and rules wise extremely digestible so simple um but the the actual you know mechanisms themselves are broken down just to two very simple phases you know take a card from one of those rows and get your resources um rolling the dice that is and then building any buildings you've collected beforehand um obviously using all those mitigation tools at your at your behest ready and then go straight to the next round the um the time investment as i said is great i mean it takes about half an hour to play this one um you know just as you feel like you're getting an engine going and getting loads of loads of capacity to smash those buildings out then the game comes to an end which is always good because it leaves you wanting more uptime fantastic you know a lot of the phases in the game can can be played at the same time she's not waiting for someone to do their time the only thing is is the actual card raffling order but that's actually a good thing because the actual turn angst of getting the buildings you want is quite palpable um because you know turn order is great because if you have a certain bunch of dice that fit a building you know really well and that building is just sitting there ready for the taking but someone's before you and they take that building off you then very frustrating so yeah it's got a good um that card drafting mechanism comes through nicely and um obviously turn audit is important
because of that um replayability is is really decent because there is a ton of different buildings that come with the game and you know quite a lot of them aren't used from games of game so lots of variability there um as i said the different strategies go down themselves um and so on so yeah replayability is good for a game of this weight um interaction as well is is pretty decent in terms of the car draft i mean everything else there's not really much um much interaction but you know you don't really want much more than that in a game like this it's all about that card draft that's where the that's where the player interaction lies um aesthetically is something i'm in in two minds about so obviously this was a kickstarter game um and it almost looks like quite quite obviously that it is i think it's the cards themselves are they're actually quite good quality but the i i'm not too sure on the artwork on them don't get me wrong i think it's it's very clear and it's very simple to see what dicer needed for these buildings but it could have looked a little bit more refined for me it could have looked a little bit more polished and professional as i said it does look a bit like a prototype version um not only the building cars themselves but also the um the player boards they're a bit basic looking it could have been a bit more vibrant and a bit more um you know a bit more cartoony and just just give a bit more feel of the of the game and maybe increase its appeal a bit but it's not a huge issue i i can't really complain about the functionality at all i think
it's they could have gone too far the other way and made it a bit more you know obscure the simplicity of it a bit but i just think it could have been a little bit smarter component wise though the actual quality of the components is very good it actually comes with a little dice tower which is really good um you know it didn't have to do that it's almost like a surplus um you know component but you know you can't complain you know it's always nice to have a dice tower um obviously get a ton of dice for the games and those dice are a really good quality to be honest um so yeah no complaints there at all just just the just the asset it could have been a little bit nicer for me um theme wise as well i mean like i tend to like that kind of wild west theme and it works fine for this one it is very much a skin it could have been it could have been anything but um but it works absolutely fine um and setup and tear down time is is no issue at all you're just taking a bunch of cards out based on the player count and um i'm setting out the the kind of tableau of cards ready to play so yeah no real issue with setup and teardown at all um the progression of the game i think is is um extremely good because as i said when you're building more and more buildings you are taking more mitigation tools to use and additionally when you start kind of filtering through those decks of cards as people draft them and it comes to the bottom card you'll start to take more resources which speeds up the game and brings it to a bit more of an exciting climax as those orange or or the golden dice become easier to
to obtain in order to get those big buildings scalability as well is is really good um it's still quick all play accounts as i said because a lot of it is done you can play the game together um and you're not waiting for other players to take their turns so yeah scalability is done really well and the game comes with quite a few different solo modes as well now i haven't played them um but it looks like you can play against an ar you can try do like a beat your own score and i think there's also scenarios as well so they've put a lot of effort into making um solo gamers happy with this one which is always a nice touch um and i suppose comparison wise um you know it's a dice game it's almost like a pattern building dice game there's quite a lot of those out there but something like sagrada kind of sings to me in terms of this one you know you've got you know restrictions you can choose to ignore or choose to um or i supposed to gladly you've got this kind of harder restrictions but this one you know you're still trying to use those dice to get as many points as you can with what you've got at your behest so i i do like that and yeah overall um this game was a huge surprise for me i mean it didn't get a lot of buzz a lot of fanfare whatsoever and um it was an absolute delight to play i really enjoyed this one so breezy but still really satisfying as you you know as you build these buildings it's almost it has a great table presence as well and it has a nice tactical or um tactile feel to it because you're actually physically building your own little town out with these dice which is really cool um yeah so i really
do like that in terms of family weight gains this is one definitely to check out um the only thing i'm concerned about is that i think this one's flowing a bit a little bit under the radar um i'm not quite sure of the retail availability of it if it if it was you know backed by a lot of retailers or if it is indeed going to retail at all um or if it's just the people who've backed the game are actually going to get to play this one and obviously i'll go into the second secondary market from there but i think it'll be such a shame if this game doesn't actually get the get the attention it deserves because while i said well the aesthetic is you know it's a bit marmite you know you're not too it's not a terribly beautiful game but the gameplay itself is razor sharp it is absolutely um just put together to uh to a great or in a great effort really there's i find with a lot of kickstarter games um especially with you know less experienced designers they um you can see the cracks you know you can you can see the kind of um uh you know they're not as polished or as refined as they could be and i think that's often um you know a sign of an experience but this one the gameplay itself is is faultless so i mean if this is what you're looking for then i cannot complain at all but in the same vein you know the aesthetic might hold it back a bit but yeah overall um yeah this game it was great the the thing that's impressed me most is that this is designed by um kevin russ who recently came out with
calico which was uh quite a big hit and it really did take off and get a lot of attention now i think this one is going to be very much a kind of in the shadow of that but taking that into consideration i think that this this designer has really laid a foundation to get um you know to get my attention at least in terms of these um you know restrictive pattern building games um you know he's really kind of formed him or given himself a nice platform to build off in in terms of getting at least my respect and my eyes on him um in terms of what he's going to bring out next because both those games are very well streamlined um very accessible but still extremely fun and and just just satisfying so yeah definitely a huge surprise for me this one come out of the left field and um just just just a really nice pleasant family weight gain so this one definitely gets my my seal of quality check this one out if you can as i said it's not going to be overly available i think but if you can get a hold on it and you do like that weight of gains then definitely check this one out so that concludes my review of tumbletown and i hope you've enjoyed it if you have please hit like and subscribe to my channel and check out my other videos too for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye