Skip to main content
Loading video...

Arkham Horror 2nd Edition Board Game Review - Still Worth It?

Transcript 14:17

Hello. Welcome back to the channel, and this is a channel where we give you reviews, playthroughs, unboxings, and we generally like to talk a lot of bollocks about tabletop gaming in general. And in this video, we're going to be talking about a classic Ameritrash game. We're going to be talking about Arkham Horror second edition. And in this game, you'll be wandering around the city of Arkham. You'll be gathering clues. You'll be gathering items that will boost your chances of defeating the old one at the end of the game. So, in this video, we're going to be giving you a very, very brief overview of this quite rules fiddly game. We'll be telling you what we do like, we don't like. We'll come back and we'll tell you whether or not Arkham Horror second edition is still worth playing. And when was kind of it, 2005? We'll say 17 years after it was first released in, I don't know, 2005. So, remember, if you're new here, then please consider subscribing to this channel. Leave a comment in that section down below, where you hit the like button and all that YouTube We'll see you after this.

Bollocks. So, Arkham Horror second edition. How to play this game. So, Arkham Horror second edition is an Ameritrash game, which is highly dependent on the roll of a dice. There's a mechanism in this game called skill checks, and you'll be rolling a certain amount of dice dependent on the skill that you're using. And if you roll a five or six, it's considered a success. There's also modifiers that will enhance your chances or will decrease your chances of getting those coveted successes. So, each player is going to pick an investigator. There's quite a few investigators in the core set. You might want to pick Carolyn Fern. She is the psychologist. She's got a six sanity, which is the stat if it's depleted down to zero, will send you off your nut. And she's got four stamina, which represents how much damage you can take. Each character has got a special ability. In the case of Carolyn Fern, she's got the psychology ability, and it says, "In the upkeep phase, Dr. Fern may restore one sanity to herself or another character in her location, right? Or you might want to pick the in the hat, Dexter Drake. He is a magician. He's got five sanity, five stamina, and he's got a magical gift that he wants to give you. And it says, "In any phase, whenever the great Drake draws one or more cards from the spell deck, he draws one extra card and discards the other."

So, this geezer is a bit of a magician. Clearly, he benefits from drawing cards from the spell deck, right? Or you might want to give a lift to Ashcan Pete. He's a drifter, he's got four sanity, six stamina. Not only does he draw universal credit, but when Pete draws from the common item, unique item, or spell deck, he may draw from either the top or the bottom of that deck. So, there is a wealth of characters in the core set alone. And it gives you a lot of variety when you are playing this game, right? So, you'll notice that on your character sheet, there's also these like slidery things, and there's six different skills that you have got. In the first phase of the game, in the upkeep phase, you look at your focus score, and this tells you that the amount of spaces you can move each one of these sliders up or down to the skills of the characters. Then not static, they are dynamic. So, setting a game up is quite simple. You'll stick all the cards out onto the table, you stick the board on the table, you stick some starting clues on the board, you will open one gate, you put a token on a location, and a monster will appear. And this will start off the cascading level of doom that you are going to face. So, like we said, the first phase of the game is the upkeep phase. This is where you refresh any cards that you tapped, and you'll be able to use your focus to move your sliders up and down. And then you're going to the movement phase. Each character has a speed score. They are going to move one space for each speed point that you've got. All the investigators will do this first before you move onto the next phase, which is encounter phase. So, this is where it gets a little bit fiddly. There's a few little things you got to remember, right? So, each investigator is going to have an encounter on space that they land, right? If there's no gate on the space that you land, you will draw a card from the location deck, and you'll

look at where you are, and then you'll read and resolve the encounter that's on the card, right? If you're are spot where there's a gate, you'll be sucked into another world. You'll move your investigator into the other world space. You resolve an other world encounter. You'll draw a card from the other world deck and you'll do what it says based on the place where you are. When you're in the other world on your next turn, you have to follow the arrow on the other world space and you'll move to next space. And then on the subsequent turn after that, if you resolve the encounter correctly, you'll be able to go back to the space in Arkham and you'll be able to put an explored marker on it and this will later close the gate. You have to do a skill check to do this. And if you close the gate, you'll take the gate marker as a trophy and these can be used for different things later on in the game, right? So, there's also a way to seal different gates. You'll be able to spend five clue tokens to stick an elder sign on it. This means that no more monsters can come through that gate, right? They ain't going to come through.

A bit like locking yourself in a downstairs bog. So, once all the characters have had their encounter, you'll move into the mythos phase. You will draw a mythos card and you will resolve it. First thing you'll do is you'll add a doom token to the doom track. If the doom track ever gets filled up, then the old one will awaken and they will probably kill you. Then you'll draw a random you'll stick it on the board in the space that it tells you to. You'll draw a monster from the monster cup and you'll stick it on the spot. There's an open gate at a location, then there's going to be a monster surge and this is where you're literally going to your pants, yeah. You'll stick a clue token on the board in the space that it tells you to. Remember, if you get five of these, you can close a gate and you can also spend clue tokens to re-roll dice that you up. Then you'll move monsters. You look at the boxes on the cards and depending on the symbol on the monster, you'll be able to move them following the black arrow or the arrow. Then you'll activate the mythos ability. This could be either good or it could be really bad. So, if you're on a space of a monster, you get the opportunity to evade it. You'll have to do a sneak skill check and you will move away from the monster. But, if you don't want to evade the monster or you bugger it up, then you can fight the monster. First thing you're going to have to do is you're going to have to do a horror check. If you pass it, nothing happens.

But, if you fail it, then you'll lose sanity equal to what's on the monster tile, yeah? And then what you do, you'll look at your fight ability. you'll be able to add some weapons or skills to this to boost your score. And then you roll a number of dice equal to that and you'll need to get a certain number of successes equal to the monster's toughness. If you pass, then you'll take the monster token as a trophy. But if you fail, then you're going to get up royally, right? So there's also a terror track. This will be increased through various things. If it gets to the third level, then the general store will close. Then the curiosity shop will close at level six and at level nine, then the magic shop. So if you really, really want the Ark of Dildo, you better run down a shop quick, right? You'll keep doing this until the ancient one awakens. There's a couple of ways for the ancient one to awaken. If the doom track is full up, then they will get out of their bed. If there's too many gates open, then the old one will come downstairs and give you a slap. If there's no gate markers left on board, then the ancient one will awaken.

And if there's no monsters left, then you're probably also going to die. But the chances of that happening is probably slim to none. So what you do, you have a final battle. You'll look at the ancient one card and you'll follow the instructions. If you do over the ancient one, you win the game. If you don't, then you won't, right? So what do we like about Arkham Horror, second edition? So first thing that we really like about this is it tells a pretty bloody good story. Okay, it is random and disjointed. Sometimes you're looking at the encounter cards thinking, "What the is it talking about? How did I get here?" But that's part of the game. You've just got to accept that stupid is going to happen. Sort of reminds us of the Tales of the Arabian Nights where it's just haphazard, anything can happen. But you know that going in, right? It's not like you're going to go into a haunted house expecting to see Zippy and Bungle in there. Maybe you are, actually. And whilst there isn't that many encounter cards for the actual locations, you have got quite a big stack of these other world encounters.

So just to give you a little taste of what you can expect to find in the other worlds, you might find the City of the Great Race. It says this conical entity tries to teach you some magic. Pass a lore check to draw two spells. That's quite good, right? Or you might end up going to the plateau of Leng. This says you're taken to a prehistoric monastery where a high priest in a yellow silken mask questions you. Pass a lore check to answer him to his satisfaction. You'll gain your freedom. It's nice of him, isn't it? And one spell. Otherwise, you're lost in time and space. Which is probably a little bit scary, isn't it? Or you might want to go to the abyss and it says the caverns split. Make a luck check and consult the chart below. If you get one success, you move to the black cave. If you get two successes, you move to the dreamlands. And if you get three, you'll enter a dark sample. Pass a luck check to draw a unique cotton cutter. These location encounters are good or bad. You never know what you're going to get. It might be a little bit too random for some, but it. We like it. So, the next thing that we like about this game is there is a good variety of monsters, characters, and ancient ones just in the core set. I mean, for instance, like the amount of characters you get, you get 1 2 4 5 6 7 8 10. There's 12 characters in this game. It's like I said at the beginning, they've all got different special abilities. They've all got different stats. So, this is going to keep you going for quite a long time. Likewise, there is 1 2 3 4 5 6 7. There's eight different ancient ones. Actually, I just found some more characters. So, there is actually 16 characters and eight different ancient ones, right?

Whilst there's not that much variety in the encounters, these things are going to give you a different place to head it in your brain every time you play this game and that is welcome. So, the next thing that we like about this game is the sliders work really well. Well, this is something was omitted in the sequel to this Elder Sign horror, right? Each character just had a set number of abilities that you could get plus or minus tokens, but I actually quite like the fact that you can use the sliders to sort of plan against the random nature of the game. For instance, we played this the other day and a gate appeared in the woods. A monster appeared there. It was a pretty tough monster, so we used the sliders to plan ahead to increase our speed so we could get down there pretty quick and stop off on the way to pick some equipment, right? And then we changed it to up our fight value so that we gave ourselves the best chance of defeating it, right? This is something that couldn't really do in Eldritch Horror and it's just a shame that it was omitted because it is at least some form of mitigation against the random nature of the game, right?

So, what don't we like about Arkham Horror second edition? So, the first thing that we don't like about it is it's disjointed and it is unfair, right? When we played this the other day, we first started out and we drew a monster from the monster cup and it was one of the hardest monsters to defeat. It ripped up your sanity. It had a toughness of three and had a special ability that basically ripped your off and shoved it up your ass. So, just to demonstrate, I'm going to reach into my monster cup now and we'll see what we get, right? We've got the undead, right? Okay, that's not a particularly good example, but that just demonstrates how unfair and uneven the game is. On one occasion, you could draw out the equivalent of a marauding terrorist and on the other, you could pull out the equivalent of a rabbit labradoodle. So, the second thing that we don't like about Arkham Horror second edition is that the rules are still too fiddly after all this time. I played this way back when in about 2012, and 12, but I remember back in 2012 thinking, "My god, these rules are just sort of going to give me an aneurysm." Whilst things have progressed to the point where I don't think that anymore, still found myself struggling to absorb all the little itty-bitty rules about flying monsters, the different restrictions on monsters on board, remembering to take monsters out of the overflow bit on the board, right, and put them on the board. I kept forgetting to do that. When I was rereading the rules, on paper, it didn't look that complicated, but in practice, it is a real pain in the ass just to try and remember all the bits. And you do need a cheat sheet, even then, that's not enough. So, just go down your local chemist, get a box of Nurofen, and don't

eat them all, but maybe have one or two. So, the third and the final thing that we don't like about Arkham Horror second edition is that there's not enough content in the core box, right? I'm not talking about the investigators or the monsters or the ancient ones because that is bountiful. What I'm talking about is the location encounter cards. There's seven or maybe nine. I can't remember the exact number, but there's not that many of them. And on each card there's three different locations, but you're going to burn through these quite a bit. And while you'll be shuffling these cards back into the deck, it might be the case that you might have the same encounter one, two, three, maybe four times during a game, right? The main problem I've got with this is that there's not enough content in the core box, but then this game got accused of being a bloke fest when the last expansion was released. There was eight expansions released for this. And sadly, you can't get any of them anymore unless you're going to pay through the nose or sell your kidney on the black market because even the most common expansions go for about 200 quid, right? So, you can write that off. If you're going to buy this now, you're going to be stuck with the core set. And really, you're going to burn through a lot of these encounters pretty quickly. And that is a little bit disappointing because I want more. So, to summarize, is Arkham Horror second edition still worth your time or bother, I don't know. Let's say 17 years after it was first released date.

So, we're going to say yes, I do enjoy a good romp through Arkham City. But I haven't played this game for about 10 years, but it was just a good feeling to go back in there and have a nose around, fight a few monsters, and get my ass handed to me, right? It's not as complex and epic as I remember. That's probably because it's been superseded and surpassed by games like Gloomhaven, I've sworn, and all those big massive Kickstarter beasts that tell a more cohesive story and don't rely on random die rolls so much, right? The rules do still feel quite fiddly and unintuitive. The lack of content in the core set is still massively problematic as it was when it was first released, right? But there's something permanently charming and curious about this ancient classic, which means it still endures to this day. If you know what you're going to get when you're you into this, you're going to get a random luck fest with a little bit of mitigation. You're just going to have to pull your pants up, dive in, and swim, and have a laugh while you're doing it, and don't take it too seriously, right? Just don't expect to pick up any of the expansions anytime soon, if at all. One idea I did have is if Fantasy Flight could reprint this maybe as a collector's edition or something where they take all of the content, stick it in one box, and then, I don't know, chuck it on Gamefound or Kickstarter for the people that have stolen loads of money from somebody else or the board game in drug dealing cartels or something like that. That would be a good idea, but I don't think it's going to happen because I think they're still invested in the reportedly inferior Arkham Horror third edition, right? There you go, that is Arkham Horror second edition. Remember, if you're new here, then please consider

subscribing to this channel, hit the like button, and all that YouTube And we'll see you next Tuesday.

Progress saved