Skip to main content
Loading video...

A Masterclass in Priority & The Stack | The Command Zone 649 | MTG EDH Magic Gathering

Transcript 1:22:30

greetings humans you have entered the command Zone your destination for all aspects of Elder Dragon Highlander enjoy your stay hello everybody and welcome back to another episode of the command Zone podcast I'm your host Rachel weeks how's it it's Josh leai and today we are doing something a little special we're bringing back a past episode that we think is still relevant has some really great information and it's one of been one of my favorites to recommend to people for years to really uh level up their magic playing skills it's uh the power of priority in the stack is what it was forly called and it's like it's a throwback episode but it's not none of that information is bad all of it's still going to make you a much much better magic player and I felt like we could cover it again but we'd be saying exactly what was in this episode already so yeah I'm glad you you uh suggested this and it's one of my favorite episodes that we've ever done there's a lot of cool like rules hacks and tricks uh to learn here and even when I watched rewatched it like I was like oh yeah like even I sometimes you need to be reminded more than you need to to learn it for the first time you know what I mean yeah plus a couple of the rules that we talked about in this episode have changed so we're going to amend a couple of those things and bring it all the way up to date and uh hence the remastered part the REM Bard part all right but first before we get into that episode if you want to pick up any cards if you're building around the holidays if you're giving a deck away go to

cardkingdom.com commmand Card Kingdom has a huge amount of singles sealed product if you got a little bit of uh spare change for Christmas this year some holiday money the best the gift card for anything spend it on what you really want is Magic cards and supporting the command Zone they've got a huge selection of all of the cards that you're looking for if you're trying to upgrade one of your old decks now that you've got a little bit of extra money to put into that deck if you're trying to upgrade one of the printings if you're trying to get a fancy new version or maybe a fancy old version if you're like us and want to find a throwback Card Kingdom has so many of those cards all in one place plus they're going to package it safely and all in one package so you're only waiting on one thing to show up on your doorstep Plus if anything goes wrong in shipping they've got a great team that'll take care of you because they know cards they know you want them perfect and we trust them so hopefully you do too car Kingdom's got a ton of the best thing in our lives magic cards credit card kingdom.com commmand and you'll be supporting the show while you shop speaking of uh what to do with some extra holiday spending money ultrapro.com commmand is another place to go if you're trying to figure out how to like spice up your Battlefield you know I've got decks where it's like yeah the deck's good like I don't really have any cards I want to slot in or out but another way to sort of upgrade it and maybe the final way that you don't always think of is like oh I can get the sleeves the deck box the playmat that all match you know for my favorite mono Blue Deck I

can get the Mana eight you know line covering everything and then then I can do that sort of final finesse polish on my deck to just you know indicate this is my favorite one that I've ever built or one of my favorites or whatever and a lot of people don't take that final step but it really is fun and Ultra BR has the best game accessories in the business the ones we trust our own collections to here command zone so again ultrapro.com commmand is the place to go to pick up all that stuff and also they always have all kinds of discounts and almost guaranteed after the holidays there's going to be a bunch of extra inventory that they're looking to move and they often Mark that stuff down by quite a bit so it's a good time to pick up binders and other things like that so one final time ultrapro.com commmand the final way to support us is directly over at patreon.com command Zone all of our patrons get access to game nights and extra turns a day early without ads plus you get access to exclusive content like turn talk which is one of my favorite of our series to watch after a game of extra turns you get to watch everybody sort of break down how that game went for their deck what they loved what they didn't like what they'll change about their deck what mistakes maybe they think they made they had in their hands yeah that's one of my favorite parts of people were going oh I did this but I think I probably should have thought about it this way I learn yeah it's a cool way to like reflect on the on the game and see what the what the players had up their sleeves yeah plus you get to join our community on Discord and talk with us every everybody on the staff and all of our fans talk about new precons as they come out or spoilers that kind of thing uh it's a great Community to be a part of uh especially if you don't have a playgroup that's

particularly engaged ours is a promise again patreon.com commmand Zone and uh we also call out one lucky Patron every single episode this episode is dedicated to jenor Jen you rock you definitely Rock okay let's get into this remastered episode which was called The Power of priority and the stack I don't think we were as good at naming episodes back then yeah we we've it's remastered yeah um so I just wanted to talk about this like bring this episode back because unlocking the stack and understanding how things are resolve or when you can even cast spells or activate abilities is a big part of unlocking your magic potential absolutely because it can completely like if somebody something that gets mentioned in the episode if if somebody has a complicated uh combo going or if they have a very specific Synergy it's hard to know when you can interrupt that and understanding the stack and priority really helps you interact and really helps you build your or execute your own combos when you know you can be interacted with so um and plus it allows you to do super cool things that I don't think uh a lot of players imagine is possible I remember before I watched the command Zone uh or before I was part of the command Zone excuse me I was watching the command Zone and there was a game nights and it was the modern Horizon's game nights there was a lot that happened in the the bare force one episode where you cast a a smothering

tithe and you hold priority and then cast a taries protection on top of the smothering TI oh yes I remember this and you phased out so to Fair's protection resolves phases out all of his board protects his life total and himself and then there's Justice mothering TI the on your board because the smothering tithe hasn't resolved yet which means that you can still get all the benefit from all of the card draw happening on the other turns and you're protected which I think it was in response to somebody like removing some of your things you definitely had a balinor play at the time yeah but it's cool it was a cool play and I remember watching it and just being like wow I didn't even I would never have thought of that yeah I think that's one of the great things about understanding the rules around just magic in general but how the sack Works in priority and everything like that because you'll see lines that you just didn't know were possible absolutely so yeah there's that sort of two-pronged reason to kind of watch this episode and pay attention um which is like what I can do and then how what my opponent is doing how it's working and how I might be able to throw a wrench in the gears of that but without understanding all that stuff it can be like you said hard but as soon as you understand the stack and priority and everything then you can find the moment MH and you know Magic's not a game where how quickly you react as far as like your fast twitched muscles matters a lot of times you can be like okay let's just walk through it what's the stack look like where is it where are you what resolved okay now at this point then I want to do this right and just understanding how to walk through that can really change the

outcome of games and the stack itself is a relatively like simple idea and they'll explain that in a moment but it's a simple idea but there's a lot of corner cases and there's a lot of weird things that don't use the stack and to discuss it in this episode you brought in a judge there was a there was a third host it was Danny samard yep and Danny was one of our original sort of rules experts judge people that would uh sit with us during our gameplay videos game nights for for a number of years and you know make sure that we weren't messing up rules while we were playing and Danny's a level two judge and very knowledgeable uh was playing the game for years and years ever since like 1997 and you know had judged events and and done all kinds of things and uh Danny doesn't work with this anymore in that uh in that capacity has gone on to other careers and like that but uh super knowledgeable and definitely in this episode really lays out uh you know how things work in a really interesting way and I think it'll be engaging you're going to learn stuff like I said I even you know do do count as learning if you kind of forgot or I said that yeah but even I was like oh yeah you can do that that's cool yeah yeah no it's this is a very cool episode and hopefully it will help you master uh your magic moves uh plus there's been some rules updates so pay attention and you can find out where things have changed this episode starts with the very fundamentals of the stack all right so let's move into our main topic here a lot of you know the basics of how the stack and priority work but we're going to go over them really quick

just so everybody's on the same page for those who don't so the basics of the stack it really is just this first in last out system right like things happen and they technically happen at instant speed all on top of each other but the first thing that gets cast actually happens after the last thing that gets cast uh and that's why we call it the stack actually because somebody cast something somebody in response cast something else and that gets stacked on top of it then maybe somebody in response cast something else and that gets stacked on top of the previous two things and then everybody activates an ability does something in response and so then everybody goes okay is anybody else going to do anything no let's resolve everything and we go thing on top the last thing that was cast or ability that was activated that happens now the next thing happens and then the first thing happens and sometimes the things on the stack will affect the other things like counter spells and whatnot mhm um I think sort of the earliest recollection I have of the stacken in the old days we didn't call it that but the way a very simple thing that would happen is like somebody says I'm going to lightning bolt your creature in response I'm going to Giant growth my creature so that's pretty intuitive right like it's a one- one it makes it into a 44 the lightning bolt won't kill it anymore but the way this happens in game is that lightning bolt Goes On The Stack giant growth Goes On The Stack there's an implicit is anybody going to do anything else no me neither okay giant growth actually resolves first because it was cast last that turns the creature into a 44 now lightning bolt resolves and that hits it

for three damage not enough to kill it lot of people also do this as the dishwashing system you put dishes and you stack them up and you wash the dishes from the top to the bottom aka the last dish you put in is the first dish you're going to wash there you go so that's the stack in its most simple form it can get crazy because the way the stack also works is that as the Stack's getting resolved you can stop at certain points and add things again MH so like let's imagine that lightning bolt giant growth another player in the game goes oh I'm going to counter spell I don't know the lightning the lightning bolt you could go okay let the counter spell re resolve the lightning bolt is not on the stack anymore I'm going to misdirect that giant growth over to something else now yeah cuz you can wait until the counter spell resolved and now go wait before the giant growth resolves I'm going to do this other thing so that's the type of move that the stack allows you to make which really makes it super complicated yeah and actually we've had the stack we explained the stack pretty well in a game night's episode but we've had it be pretty intense and I won't spoil anything but the last game night's episode we had with the stack was so complicated we were just just like well let's just move to the end result because trying to explain it in this scenario would just not be fun I think for people involved and it would actually bog down the game and but but we're here to clarify the power of what the stack is and of course how you as Commander players can utilize it the best yeah I think actually we in the

Guild of ravnik game nights episode we had a pretty impressive stack and we explained it and I think we'll just play that clip right now now the game keeps track of the order that cards are played in and then it starts to stack them up like a a bunch of Pancakes so we have an Elish noorn a dictative arabos a marari wake we'll get rid of that one because we allowed it to resolve a taper's protection and then a Citywide bus the thing is then the Spells will resolve in reverse order so city-wide bus is actually going to happen first and ellish noorn won't come into the battlefield until the very end and then Citywide bust is going to resolve in response I'm going to sacrifice this alra Zion to to yeni so he gets indestructible so they won't die so they won't die okay and Orton is still not on the battlefield the next thing is the taper's protection so I phase out my stuff I'm not here I'm gone I'm gone so can you stay that way so deal yeah you disappeared it and now the dictate has landed so it's in play and then the elar comes in so I think that gives some measure of how the stack works and and we're going to go through this more as we go um originally this episode was going to just be about the stack and as we started to lay it out we realized oh the real thing here is actually player priority that's the that's actually the the part that I think there's the most misconceptions about that players I think players kind of understand the stack but when you start getting into

player priority in multiplayer that is the part where people start to get lost or confused or start to misunderstand when things are happening or why or who's allowed to do stuff when is that something that happens in 1 V one a lot Danny or is it like I'm assuming multiplayer just makes it that much more complicated uh I mean yeah of course it's more complicated in multiplayer but you pretty much hit the nail on the head um the main thing is uh most most of us know that if you want to respond to a spell you have to wait your turn more or less and that's the structure of the stack and it helps uh us organize so only one thing happens at any given time um however like you also said you can interrupt it and any time before and after something is resolving but the important thing to understand is yeah like when do I have a chance to say tap my lands for mana and add Mana to my Mana pool or what if I have a um like a card that I think about is Leon and arbiter which has a special action which we're going to talk about as well that doesn't use the stack at all like when can I do that these are these are the kinds of questions that are more nuanced and require like a more granular break down The rules yeah so we're going to get into a lot of the little side nooks and crannies of you know things that come up you know quite often honestly these will come up a few times a game of these Corner cases um but let's talk about Priority First so priority is basically the ability or under the rules you're the player that's allowed to act so if you have priority you're the only one that can do stuff mhm that's what that that's basically what that means you can cast spells or activate abilities um so a player with

priority cast a spell or activates an ability and I think people don't actually even know this part a lot of players don't you can do as many of those as you want while you've got priority right we call it holding priority and you'll hear us I think we've said it on game nights before where you go I'm going to do this I'm going to hold priority because the default uh in Magic generally is when you do something you immediately pass priority that's just what people assume but that's not necessarily what happens that's a shortcut and we're going to we're going to be talking about a lot of things that are often shortcut today but what we're going to be saying is here's the shortcut if you don't even know that's a shortcut you don't know what's the long cut what's the actual way right that it's supposed to work so I cast lightning bolt on your one one creature you say in response and I'm like well hold on I'm going to hold priority I want to do something else first because I still have the priority I didn't give it to you yet passing a priority is something that you you know you do so I'm going to lightning bolt this I'm going to hold priority I'm going to Fork my lightning bolt at this other thing now I'm done you can have priority and now you'd be in a sticky situation where you're like okay well I only have one giant growth which creature do I save right that is something that you can do when you have priority so the way that priority Works in multiplayer because it's not 1 V one is that when you pass priority when you're done you say I do a thing or I do a number of things whatever it is okay those are on the stack I pass priority

it goes in turn order around the table to the next person so it would go to Danny here and I'd say you have any effects I have no effects I pass priority and that's what implied when we just do nothing right exactly then it would go to Jimmy I would say yeah I would like to do something uh in response to the fork the second spell you cast cuz you held priority I'm going to counter or do whatever it is or maybe I'm a maniac I just lightly mold something else cuz I also love that card and then it would go to Mel and Mel would say you know she would do something or not and then it would come back to me now here's something important to understand about priority is that if you only get another chance to respond in there if somebody else responded when you pass priority you're saying I'm not going to do anything else and if everybody else says neither am I the stuff happens yeah it's like hting the last thing on the stack happens it's like hitting a tennis ball right to someone across the court and if they don't do anything to hit it back then the ball is gone you can't be like hold on now that you guys all said you're not going to do something I'm going to do something else because that would give you a strategic Advantage as well right you're you're trying to bait out a counter spell say or whatever and and by their reply it makes you think that they didn't have one you know the fork is going to resolve now the fork resolving now the lightning Bolt's on the stack and we'd all get to pass priority again right yes so that you would have yeah but if it's just lightning bolt if I go I'm the lightning bolt your thing pass priority Danny goes nothing Jimmy says nothing Mel says nothing I don't have a chance now to be like wait I want to Fork it the lightning bolt goes off does that make sense to everybody I

hope it does okay we just going to assume that it does and if it doesn't of course we'll give you all of our social details you can just pound us with messages later again is often shortcut and the shortcuts are totally fine but knowing how the passing of priority works is important because we'll see this type of scenario happen in a lot of multiplayer games where like I do something Jimmy's two seats away and he's he like responds to it before Danny has a chance which can be great for Danny or it could be bad for Danny but a lot of times and we do this all the time in our games we're like hold on hold on hold on let's walk through this just because it's getting complicated Danny did you do anything no nothing pass okay Jimmy now he does the thing yeah you know where a lot of times somebody will be like I I I take an action you know when it's not their turn and and a lot of times that's fine but sometimes it's not and you need to rewind and make sure that each person gets a chance to you know have a a response yeah um okay let's walk through two scenarios I think that get people in trouble with priority also you want to toss the paper Danny it's very exciting part of the show boom bam nailed it oh just throw it away great yeah all right this this page one there you go oh one one important thing to note about priority that I didn't mention earlier is that priority always uh it always comes back to the active player which is the player whose turn it is when it's done being passed so the active player is the default person that has priority so when an action is taken nobody does anything or even if they do by the time all that stuff's resolved Boom the priority is going to land in the lap of the player whose turn it is

right exactly one thing I want to say too is uh just to be Crystal Clear let's say for example Josh it's your turn you cast a spell we do a handful of different things and then um Jimmy had responded with something Jimmy's thing responds like you just said it goes back to you you the active player it's your turn you get priority and then we start the cycle again not back to Jimmy even though his thing responded you get priority okay so the active player is always the default person even amidst the stuff happening in the middle of the stack basically even after somebody else's thing has just resolved off the stack gotcha got that's that's really because you started it I guess yeah and you were the active player that started it interesting okay so this comes up with a situation where like let's say Jimmy plays a creature let's say like a death right Shaman and I don't really want him to have that creature for whatever reason and I have a swords to plow shares in my hand but it's Jimmy's turn obviously because he cast a creature I guess unless he had valkin ory we won't get into that it's his turn he casts his creature I have swords to plow shares when can I swords to plow shares Jimmy's creature can I do it immediately as I cast it yeah let's say he has something that gives the death right Shaman haste right yeah so uh the short answer is no um because again it's Jimmy's turn he just cast a creature that's something you can only usually do on your main phase so he's the active player so as soon as the death right Shaman spell resolves because you chose not to counter it no one else did and right sword supp doesn't kill it while it's on the stack it has to on the battlefield correct yeah it's not there yet so uh we all let death R Shaman as a spell resolve it enters the battlefield and then priority goes back to Jimmy now

again Jimmy still has priority so you do not yet have the opportunity to cast any spells including your swords he has to pass priority for some reason for me to cast swords but if death right Shaman had haste for some reason he would always be able to activate it right then without me being able to swords it first Y A lot of people uh compare this to Plaines Walkers people Cass the Plaines Walkers someone's like I kill your Plaines Walker like no no because I'm the one that cast it and it's my turn I can use one of its abilities and when I use the Ability you can them respond right I'm always get activation off though yes right because in unless you countered it it's got to hit the battlefield and once it's on the battlefield the active player got priority back and until they pass it now if he played the death right Shaman even though it had Hast and he goes okay I'm going to go to combat ah now he would be passing priorities because when you move through steps and phases you have to give all the other players a chance to respond before you move on to the next phase yeah exactly that those are implied priority passes shortcuts we can also talk about that's why we say I'm going to go to combat and we look at everybody expectantly like are you going to do anything which means I'm going to go to combat would you like to take any moves before I do these are like we said Cuts but what a player's actually saying is I'm going to pass I'm going to go to combat I'm going to pass priority do you want to take any actions before we're in the combat phase like tapping down a creature removing a threat and this happens a lot un limited too with tappers so you'll see uh the going to combat phase a lot of people get confused because they will often wait too long and it's like well I'm in combat I can tap and attack you now and then you're going to get priority so you need to do things that affect the creatures for instance in combat before

they enter combat right mhm uh just to take a quick step back um I think it's it's also important to understand that while we humans are playing this game if you think about the fact that Arena and Magic Online exist software has been written to that reflect the comprehensive rules to make it work so just again taking a step back the way we actually do move to the next step of the game is when both players or all players involved pass priority and the stack is empty and whenever that happens you automatically move to the next step of the game mhm so that that would be the going to combat no response you're saying I have nothing on the stack and I'm passing prer to you do you do nothing great also now we're moving on right it's implied that you would move on and not just stay in the same face CU you've already said I have nothing to do here yeah okay so let's talk about some effects here that do and do not use the stack because as you uh sort of alluded to earlier there are things that don't use the stack and there are things that do and you it's really important to know the difference between the two sometimes because you can give away information on accent you know a lot of times this happens in games where something happens somebody goes I'm going to do this H you can't do that because this is a special case and so giving away information could be bad for you in that moment just because you just didn't know this stuff so hopefully we can clear up some things so let's start with stuff that does use the stack um every spell that you're going to cast out of your hand uh basically there's a few there's a few exceptions but cards instant sorceries artifacts are going to use the stack even like Split Second uses the stack it just it just has some rules

modifications to how the Stack's going to work now that you've cast it right yep exactly um triggered abilities use the stack these are abilities that say when or whenever basically or at so like if something happens it it causes a trigger it's really but trigger is a really good word for it right it's like a it's like a thing that got flipped that you don't even necessarily have control of uh that happens um activated abilities almost always use the stack there is exception that we're going to talk about here um so an example of all these things solemn simac MH when you cast that spell that uses the stack because that's a spell you cast out your hand also when it enters the battlefield it triggers and says go find a land out of your library that is a triggered ability that uses the stack that goes on the stack so somebody could go before you find that land I want to do something MH um elth Sun's Champion a a plaines Walker loyalty abilities use the stack so the Loyalty ability doesn't just happen you get a chance to respond so if you go I'm going to minus l Beth and I'm going to clear the board of all creatures with power four or greater okay well that's going to go on the stack and I can and all the other players get a chance to respond to it so maybe Jimmy goes I'm going to sacrifice my creature to some effect that lets me to greater good just because it's going to die anyway or whatever he has a chance to act before that loyalty ability goes off um or you can for instance oh it's power four or greater I'm going to do something to shrink a creature or I'm going to bounce a creature Because by the time that effect resolves then the next thing on the stack would be the minus ability of elth

it wouldn't see the creature it would be safe that be so sick you like toxic Deluge with v alinor out just to get your creatures underneath the four power just slightly but but hopefully all your opponent's creatures do not make it they would kill their small creatures because they're like Tut right um Tim prodigal sorcerer that's another one that uses the stack again just Taps to do one point of damage to something the you tap it the one point of damage Goes On The Stack people can respond they could giant grow their creature so it doesn't die that kind of thing it's very important too if you're looking at older cards that have different templating and wording and if you don't understand oh is this an activate ability or not go to gatherer they have updated the rules text in the text version of all of the cards there so you can see oh this card in the past used to say do this this and this but it didn't have a colon to indicate that it was an activate ability you can tell what it is and what it isn't thanks to gatherer yeah as a quick aside here um and this is something that's easy to miss we do it all the time in like set reviews and stuff when you're getting excited about a card oh yeah activ activated abilities have a cost and that cost is all sort of Encompass before the colon so everything you see before the colon is part of the cost of doing the thing and then what happens after the colon is what the effect is so for instance Prime speaker vanar you tap it and you sacrifice a creature and then you search your library for a creature with power one or greater no CMC one equal to one plus a creature CMC yes sorry birthing pod yeah you birthing pod on a stick on the stick instant speed so sacrificing the creature in that instance to vanar is

part of the cost of doing the ability you can't respond to the cost right so they can't go I'm going to tap my Prime speaker vanar and I'm going to sacrifice my seedborn muse and you can't go I'm going to path to Exile your seedborn Muse before you sacrifice it right right because at that point you've already you while you have priority and you go through the steps to Casting a spell you figure out the cost you pay the cost and then it goes on the stack and then you get priority so yeah no point in the middle of that does anyone have their chance to respond to that right so that's I think that's a thing that newer players get wrong and I remember in of your me thinking that I could get rid of the creature going to sacrifice before they sacrifice it and then you're like ha you have nothing to sacrifice you can't do the thing that's not how it works even with rules back then right the rules were different and they had like interrupt cards again like if you see something says interrupt It's actually an instant so ignore that look at the gather text like Jimmy said but yeah the rules used to work this way and so when sixth edition came out and the stack was built right the game got a lot more sort of structured and stabiliz streamlined another thing that uh part of the cost is loyalty abilities so part of paying the cost is the loyalty ability so you can't like when ELP plus Goes On The Stack you can't like respond while it still has the Loyalty it had before got plused to like kill it at that it's part of the cost to play it also misspoke vanar is not at instant speed you can only activate anytime you could activate this use do sorcerer yes good to know yeah good to know okay so those are the abilities and and cards and effects that use the stack the more interesting part of this discussion is stuff that does not use the stack so yeah this is where things get real tricky so we said there were some activated abilities that don't use the

stack and the primary ones are Mana abilities mhm this is to prevent somebody from going like and by manab biles we mean birds of paradise if you tap that to add man your Mana pool or Mountain if you tap a mountain to add your Mana pool or ashnod's alter is actually a really weird one but that's a mana ability this is to prevent somebody from Jimmy uh says I tap five mana and you go in response before your that mana's in your Mana pool I'm going to do something the game doesn't want that to happen because it would just create times to like sort of mess with people between when the mana's in their Mana pool so they just said nope Mana just goes in the pool that doesn't use the stack you can you can just sort of do that at any time otherwise I think the game would kind of fall apart so okay so let's talk about ashnod's alter in forian alter specifically I think it makes sense right that you can tap your lands and stuff ashnod and fian are interesting because you could technically sacrifice a creature like if somebody goes to cro and grip your Ash Knot's alter you can still sack creatures to the Ash's alter to create Mana in that moment yes and I think the big reason why you're pulling this up is because it doesn't seem intuitive because you're like wait gross and grip it says Split Second no one can do anything well no one can activate abilities or cast spells but you can still do special actions which Mana abilities are special actions because it it would totally make sense if somebody says I'm going to cro and grip whatever and you go before that resolves I'm going to tap five lands and add five Mana to my Mana pool I don't think anybody would think that's weird exactly but ashnod's alter it's because it's an artifact even though because fexi and Ash noods are man abilties you could you could totally do it so sudden spoiling

those any of those effects you could still use your Ash noods uh to get Mana in that instance now you couldn't probably use the Mana to cast anything because Split Second would stop that but you could just add a to your pool let it get destroyed and then use the Mana if you want right well if it was your turn you could continue with your main phase and the Mana would not have left your Mana pool so you would have access to that but yeah it does seem very weird because it's like hold on nothing else can happen well you could tap lands you can also sack creatures to generate Mana because sacrificing creatures are part of the cost you couldn't like sacrifice a creature to like high Market or something or or things like that right because again that's an effect playing a land does not use the stack so you can't I'm trying to think of a situation like some situation where maybe you've seen your opponent's hand and you know like oh they need double blue to cast a certain spell they say I play an Islands you can't be like before that Island hits the battlefield I'm going to do something now becauseand your other land whatever yeah so it's just nope the land is in play you can't do anything about it you don't get priority they're going to be able to add that blue to their Mana pool before you can do anything um the if if something had landfall though the landfall trigger would go on the stack is that correct uh yeah still so th those are still normal triggered abilities like sort of irrespective of the special action that's playing a land and we're going to talk about how triggered abilities work a little later too I think so yeah MH but that's a way that you could create a moment where you could respond to some stuff in that instance obviously they'd still be able to tap the land for the blue Mana you couldn't you can't sort of mess with that but um this is a weird one I didn't know before we started doing this but suspend does not use the stack that is correct so basically the timing

restrictions of the card still matter so sorcery means only during your main phase but you don't actually cast a spell you put it into Exile as a spectal action and um that's it now when it comes off of a suspend that's the moment you're casting it and using the stack right exactly yeah and you have to meet all the same like uh rules criteria for the spell resolving going on stack choosing targets all these things so you could you know depending on what's going on out there and if you had you know the dacin ories and things in play you could maybe spend greater garget on and Sack things at a moment where it would be difficult for you to do so is that true yes yeah so I did not know suspend didn't use a stack it's pretty interesting I don't know how to abuse it but yeah I don't know if there's too many ways to abuse it yeah if some is there is there like Split Second speed discard or anything like that I don't think so don't think so no okay Split Second will come up a lot in this episode because it is a way to circumnavigate the stack and so there's a very special thing in Magic's history to have the the tech that Split Second does it's very unique and it's a great way to demonstrate when abnormal things can happen because that normally puts the cap on those things happening um okay yeah we talked about triggered abilities versus Mana abilities here's a really interesting one so auras that enchant lands are considered there's some old ones like wild growth that says whenever you tap the enchanted land for Mana add an additional Mana to your Mana pool if a triggered ability is triggered by a man by a mana ability then it does not use the stack yeah like so that's a

way to explain it so here's the thing let's just here's I just got a headache now okay so let's break this down into two simple steps cor whenever you see when whenever and at I that was circular you see that uh it's a triggered ability right but not all triggered abilities are created equal if a triggered ability a would create Mana doesn't have a Target isn't a Plains Walker loyalty ability or anything like that um and it would yeah when it it would generate Mana when it would res then it's a triggered mana ability and then it's just like everything else we just talked about it resolves automatically and that's it it can't be responded to I see it comes into play mostly with the ores than enchant like so if you look at yeah wild growth is the classic example when you tap it even though it's now says whenever you tap Enchanted land for Mana add green uh it's just it just adds to your Mana pool like your Forest is doubled basically or whatever the land you put it on they've templated those differently in recent years I think because of this where now it says it gives the enchanted land an ability to tap for two Mana of any true yeah and that can have like narrow implications for things that turn off activated abilities but that's that's another topic but but yeah you're right okay so all right so hopefully you got all that um the next thing that doesn't use the stack uh and we've referred to this many times on the show so this is known is unmorph MH so this is to prevent things like people go I unmorph my creature and you're like before you do I'm going to lightning bolt it while it's still a 2 two you if you paid the unmorph costs it's flipping up there's really nothing in that moment that'll stop it right it also gives the ability to do things like counter croen grips because if you have

say k spell snatcher un morphing doesn't use the stack so cro and grip Goes On The Stack says nothing else can be added no other cards and effects can be played or whatever and you go okay but I'm going to unmorph my thing it's a Kos spell snatcher and it says when it's turned face up you know I can counter a spell well that trigger goes on the stack and cro and grip can't stop that basically yep that's true so something else that's interesting about how when we have multiple triggers and this of comes up in y'all's context because you play multiplayer a lot um is uh many many of times I've already seen in commander games multiple triggers happen all at the same time and from different people right like uh let's say three people have some kind of effect that says when the creature when creature dies exactly very very common thing right so what do you do they appear to just from like a heris or a simple observation it's like oh they happen kind of all at the same time but that's not how the rules work right they have to be stacked exactly right so how do you put them on the stack well you put them on the stack in we say app Anda order for short which means active player non-active player and like you already talked about um that means if you have multiple triggers you put them on the stack in any order of you're choosing you being the player this turn it is you being the person who is the active player so your turn yes so you put all your Triggers on the stack in any order of your choicing choosing excuse me then the next person in turn orders in this case me I would take all my triggers let's say I have three I can go oh a b and then C then pass on to Jimmy then pass on to whomever else right so my triggers as the active player would be on the bottom on the bottom of the stack when it's all said and done yes okay mm I would just concede at that point yeah one last thing to say here uh often

times with these complicated Stacks especially in multiplayer people may want to respond at a certain point in the stack to create a certain outcome after it's all said and done right one triggers go on the stack uh they I don't want to use the word priority but they they go first triggers have to go on the stack before players can activate abilities and cast spells so if after it's all said and done and you put all the Triggers on the stack then you can put something on stack like cast a spell or activate your own ability but it must go on top of the stack and if you want to put it on the middle you have to wait for each thing to resolve to for that thing to be on top to get there right right now it's obviously a lot easier in games like Arena and online where you can see the stack literally pop up as little icons and things that you can highlight over them in Magic it is a lot more difficult to keep track of yeah in Commander for sure and and we have a lot more to keep track of uh but we're going to take a quick mid roll break from our sponsors and when we get back we're going to go through an entire turn of Magic the Gathering and that's exciting this show is sponsored by liquid IV season greetings Cool Cats this year I jetmir Nexus of rebels will throw the most perfect holiday party this whole crime family will come together as the Halo Fountain well look we may have used up all of our Angel juice at my meowo masquerade but fear not I found a new source of hydration to keep everyone fully pumped liquid IV it's the best way to stay hydrated through the holidays with eight vitamins and nutrients plus three times the electrolytes of the leading Sports stram one stick of liquid IV with 16 ounces of water hydrates better than water alone so you can tear pour and live more never let a party

leave you parched again whether you need to stay vigilant on Commander Knights trample the dance floor or double strike a pose on the runway proper hydration is a must Halo was good but this P colada flavorer is simply Divine hey how do they make this stuff no Angels were harmed in the making of liquid IV stay hydrated through the holidays with liquid IV get 20% off your first order of liquid IV when you go to liquid iv.com and use code command at checkout that's 20% off your first order when you shop better hydration today using promo code command at liquid i.com and our new merch selection is live ah that is a good feeling man Jimmy remember how long we just had no merch at all oh yeah I mean for years if we even wanted to sell a t-shirt I'd have to enter every order and address in manually and who's got that kind of time seriously we would not have had time to do the podcast much less game nights but now we've got command own shirts hats wall srels and even our own custom sleeves all thanks to Shopify nobody does selling better than Shopify they give you everything you need to get your product in the hands of your fans no matter where you are as a business whether you're a fledgling YouTube channel or a global brand like alirts Shopify is there with the best converting checkout system on the planet turning more browsers into buyers while leaving you free to focus on your product businesses that sell more sell on Shopify exactly okay I'm going to buy a t-shirt uh Jimmy you're a host you could just have a shirt yeah but like getting packages upgrade your business and get the same checkout we use sign up for your $1 per month trial period at shopify.com tcz all lowercase go to shopify.com tcz to upgrade your selling

today again shopify.com tcz sorry I just discovered that I've been paying for two Netflix accounts I'm Kean and I maybe and have a corrupted memory but with all the services and subscriptions these days how can anyone remember it all thankfully I have rocket money to ease my burden rocket money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel your unwanted subscriptions monitors your spending and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings it's hard enough keeping track of whether my power is odd or even I can't be constantly checking on my accounts but rocket money's dashboard lets me see all of my subscriptions in one place so I know exactly where my money keeps disappearing too rocket money has over 5 million users and has saved a total of 500 million in canceled subscriptions saving members up to $740 a year when using all of the apps features they even alert me if a bill increases in price or if an unexplained charge appears out of nowhere stop wasting money on things you don't use cancel your unwanted subscriptions by going to Rocket money.com commmand Zone that's rocket money.com commmand Zone again rocket money.com command Zone I think it might need more card draw who are you talking to or is that just something you say oh no I'm on a call with Jimmy we're uh building a chatter Fang deck ooh I just added toi that should help right wa the card just showed up yeah with architect you can

collaborate in real time from anywhere in the world changes show up immediately you don't even have to reload the page so it's perfect for brewing with a friend this is cool but isn't Jimmy just upstairs yeah but I'm I'm downstairs right now I ain't coming downstairs archade is the best place to browse brew and play test Commander decks just go to arc.com commmand Zone to get started that's Arc ht.com command Zone okay we are back with Danny talking about the complexities of well Magic the Gathering priority using the stack how it works and more importantly how you can use a Tor Advantage as a commander player um so I guess let's just move right back into it yeah we're going to start here with the parts of a turn uh we're going to go through turn order because it's important to know within each of that when priority happens and how all that stuff works so knowing how your turns the steps and phases interact with priority in the stack is going to help you make more effective decisions about you know what to do and when to do your spells and abilities remember that the active player the player whose turn it is they if they want to move to the next phase they have to pass pass priority at that moment so like you know we're going to start with the beginning phase here in a second if I want to move out of my upkeep and go to draw technically I have to give everybody chance to still act during my upkeep again we shortcut this very often where people will go like untap draw and then a lot of times people if you want to do something in upkeep people know to be like hold on I have effects during your upkeep and and we kind of put the onus on the other

player to tell the active player in those moments when they want to act during the upkeep because 90% of the time nobody does so it doesn't make sense to like every time stop so if you have effects during somebody's upkeep you just want to tell them sometime around when they're untapping like just so you know I have effects during your upkeep so don't dve card um let's see uh yep okay so an example of this recently we had the um the war of the spark episode of Game Nights and Cedric wanted to cast to Fair's time twist during Emma's second main phase before she went to the endep so he just because it was implied Emma said I passed the turn that's an implication of I'm going to my endep right Cedric said hold on before your end step so we're still in your second main I'm going to do this thing because T's time twist brings the creature back on the next end step so if they were already in MSM step it would come back on Cedric's endstep which was not when he wanted the creature to come back he wanted it to be able to attack the next turn so he just had to specify you know hold on we're going to we're going to slow down here for a second and I'm going to specify where we're at so I can take this action notably when he does do that he passes again the active player priority back to Emma who is still in her second main phase so if she wanted to cast a sorcery at that point for instance she could she doesn't automatically move to her endep because someone else stopped her before she moved to the end step the the I guess it goes back around it's like okay I'm now it's your second main phase again still yeah she could be like oh well you tapped two blue Mana to do that and now I know you don't have a counter spell so I'm going to do something that I didn't want to do before you did that um Corner

case but that does become very relevant sometimes so let's talk about the beginning phase of the turn so you start and you're in the untap and untap is a special phase where basically nothing can happen yeah how's that work well yeah unless your name is Josh Le in which case all your stuff phases back in all right so there's yes so phasing is a weird thing that happens right before untap right yeah it happens in untap before you untap your stuff we didn't used to have to know much about this but because of tf's protection we do now right allows you to use your mana on your turn that's that's the way that that phasing card works yeah yeah so so the first thing that happens in your turn is if you're phased out or stuff was phased out it phases in um there is stuff with phasing that actually if it was phased in would maybe phase out during this time but that's where the phase part of the phase happens yeah then we untap and any triggered abilities that happen because of something untapping so like the inspired mechanic from Theos M those triggers happen but they get pushed into the upkeep they don't technically happen during the untap step right right and this is unique to the untap step and they just you know rules at Wizards just decided to make this the case so yeah if you have triggers that would occur during the untap step they wait to go to the upkeep step and then again they would go on the stack in active player non-active player order they just don't want people being able to mess with when untapping is happening because it gets really messy I mean how would it even work like oh before you untap these three lands but after you untap those two I'm going to do something like you have their endep to do that right that's

that's normally the time to act so the untap is pretty unique just nothing can even happen triggers even that happen there get pushed till later so to allow the game to literally just function so you can so you're not ever in a awful feel bad moment I don't know we lot of these changes and and stack rules made so that players wouldn't get into unfund scenarios I think that's ultimately the intent of any like rules change or any like big decision that Wizards makes but also part of it is um every time they make rules changes if if it's not for new keywords or something like that or just a big sweeping rules change they're they're trying to make the game rules and the way the technicalities more closely match how the game naturally plays I see okay they want to be intuitive exactly makes sense and fair okay so we're untap we untap our stuff nobody can do anything if any triggers happen they would get pushed to upkeep so the upkeep happens and then at that moment all the beginning of upkeep effects trigger um these can't be preempted so the scenario that we like to toss around because I've seen this happen many times is let's say you have a fxi in Arena and you're at one life there's not a window in you in there for you to do anything to fxi Arena like let's say you have a croing grip in your hand you can't untap and then cast the croing grip it'll still be too late the fxing arena trigger will have happened as soon as your upkeep began correct yeah yeah so there's just not a way really to get around those upkeep Triggers on your turn I would have to cro and grip or do whatever on the end

step before my turn right um could you just play a card that says end the turn clear everything off the stack yeah you could C you could activate your Sund out of the infinite there that that would save you although you'd be in the same position next turn but maybe true so that's one example right effects that say end the turn and they say in parenthesis like empty the stack you know move to the end and everything else um the other thing you could do for example in this narrow situation is you could uh stifle your own FX Arena trigger but of course that's like uh responding to anything else right it goes on the stack you have priority you could say I hold priority I'm going to stifle my trigger right you can yeah so fing Arena does use the stack so you can respond to it everyone will have a chance to respond to it um you we talked about this a little bit just a second ago but just to make it clear if if you have multiple triggers during your upkeep that trigger at the beginning like let's say you have aasa and a forian Arena and you're not at one life you're at a healthy life total it's probably advantageous for you to want to scry first and then draw the card and that'sa lets you scry FX lets you draw since they're both your triggers when they both go on the stack at the same time you can choose which order you want them to happen and the way I usually say it um is just that I'm going to make it so that I'm going to scry first and then draw yeah MH and and that's again a shortcut just to be like look I have two triggers I get to stack them I get to put them in any order I choose so because they're my triggers I'm going to say f subcribe then draw yeah technically you're saying I'm putting the arena foring Arena on the stack and then I'm putting that on the stack right um that's how it works in mtgo very confusing again easier to just say it now how your triggers stack with your opponent's triggers and this is the same

as when multiple triggers all happen at once because they are so your opponent might have like a I don't know what's a shield trigger MH affects that trigger on your opponent's upkeeps what would Happ is let's say I have the thsa the fexi arena somebody else has the shield DD I'm the active player I would put my fexi Arena first then thsa so I'm going to scry first then draw those are my triggers as the active player then it would go to any triggers Danny has nonactive players yep yep and then it would go to any triggers Jimmy has so if Danny didn't have any then it would go to Jimmy he has the shield DD you're going to have to sack the price of the creature before you get to scry and draw the card right is the way the outcome's going to happen your your opponent's triggers are basically always going to happen first M yeah that I think people kind of they want to be able to circumnavigate that system a lot well I'd much rather like you know draw a card or you know maybe you only have one creature and you have a sacrifice effect I want to sacrifice to that first no sorry um okay so remember so we're we're in upkeep and then and then upkeep happens and it's just like anything else it's it's just like the main phase except you can't cast sorcery speed stuff yep and usually we just shortcut it by going I draw my card and the draw step has a spectal action that occurs at the beginning of the draw step and it doesn't use the stack either you draw your card people don't respond once you've gone to your draw step to drawing your card now they do have a chance to do stuff before you draw your card that's what the upkeep is so once you go to the draw step you just draw that happens and now there is a chance for for other things to happen um so like howling mine

would be a trigger that causes you to draw another card to Fair's puzzle box is a big one oh gosh that like so the draw would happen first then you would count how many cards you have for tf's puzzle box counting the one you drew for turn and then you would put all those on the bottom and draw that many cards you don't count first put those on the bottom then draw that card that many cards then one for turn if that makes sense yeah I that's that's definitely a weird one another weird one I was going to bring up um was uh silven Library oh oh yes this one is uh can be an issue at competitive RL we're not talking about that today but I'm just telling telling you about my experiences uh the easiest way to do this is just to draw draw three cards basically pick up the top three cards of your library and don't have them touch your hand yet just be a good sport with all your teammates right or your play group right and then you make your decisions on whether or not you want to keep more than one pay the four life per card Etc and then put that many back so you get your little sort of mini Ponder brainstorm um that happens all at the same time because that's actually a replacement effect and what you talking about a second ago Josh uh you said special action I need to we need to be Crystal it's a turn-based action so it's a thing that happens automatically as a turn or a step of sorry a u yeah step in a turn is happening right so drawing a card for during your draw step that's a turnbas action yeah no one can respond it happens and then the active player get priority yeah let's talk about replacement effects for a minute because there are a number of things and it does tend to happen a lot during the draw step where it says in uh underr Lich was a new one that said instead of drawing you know your one card per turn look at the top three at the top three choose one and then put two in the graveyard

that's not a trigger right that just replaces the draw so nobody can respond to to that that's is that sort of how Sven Library works too uh yes so uh quick thing on replacement effects it's very easy to spot replacement effects all of them or at least almost all of them have the word instead so if you see instead on the correct you know the up-to-date Oracle readings on any particular card then you know it's a replacement effect and it's very simple it's what the English word means like instead of a do B so instead of drawing one card like a normal turn-based action you look at the top three pick one bin two and that replaces your draw notably yeah if you have cards like consecrated Sphinx out you your opponent if they do that they're not drawing a card triggers like that won't for keep an eye out for that for under L it replaces the draw at what point in there can an opponent respond it's not there's not a point right until they've discarded already uh how about this let's role play okay I have under Ro Lich yeah uh it's my upkeep yeah I passed priority to Jimmy okay I have no effects No Effects cool all right so we've all passed priority with an empty stack yeah we now or in my draw st draw phase right I the normal game rules would say draw card but instead I'm going to look at the top three notice neither of you have had chance to PRI have any sort of priority neither have I I'm now going to look at these three pick one and put two in my graveyard I've completed that boom now there's nothing else in the stack there's or sorry there's no other replacement effects it's now my turn in my draw step I get priority right so there's no point in time at which I'm like able to I don't know do anything at all there until you move to your main phase or you do something after

receiving priority in your draw step correct exactly yeah okay okay so again we're done with Danny's draw step and he says do you guys have any effects during my draw step yeah I pass priority Jimmy do you pass priority yep we pass and now we're into Danny's main phase yep main phase one so hopefully main phase is going to be pretty self-explanatory at this point anytime you would cast a spell in ability each other player gets a chance to respond you know if you don't hold hold priority and then they also get a chance to respond before you move to your next step so it basically works like upkeep it's not that much different other than you can cast sorceries speed stuff right yep and play a land which is the one of the special actions we talked about I like playing lands um and then the next phase gets pretty complicated so this is the combat phase right we've had so many different rules questions about this over the years uh it gets pretty confusing so the combat phase obviously is the phase that it's let's see it has five steps or it has five phases within the combat phase how do you uh there steps within a phase right so there's beginning declare attackers declare blockers if there's First Strike or double strike there's First Strike damage and then there's combat damage then there's end of combat okay and then you're back in a main face so that's super simple duhig deal end of the episode it's actually super important to know all the steps within the combat phase because there are things within each step that you can do to affect combat and knowing the best time to do them can honestly be a big difference between whether Annihilator happens to you or not or things like that so we go to the combat phase and

we're in beginning of combat this is before anything's happen and this is the moment where people go I go to combat this is that moment where you're allowed to respond and do stuff yeah think of it as the upkeep for the combat phase yeah oh very nice yes so only instance can be used here uh or instant speed stuff yes and this is where you would want to be like okay I didn't talk Jimmy out of attacking me with his it that betrays so I'm going to tap it down I'm going to use my cryptic command and tap all of Jimmy's creatures so he can't attack that's where you do it is in the beginning of combat phase now technically you could do it earlier in the the main phase but you want to in general and Magic strategically wait till the very last possible moment to do something for the most part so you don't want to open the door to any sorcery speed stuff that Jimmy may have which he could use during his main phase you might as well wait till the beginning of combat where he can only use instant speed stuff yes not that you even know what those may or may not be but it constricts him in some way and it's just to your advantage to do so uh path to Exile is another thing that could happen then because if you say I go to combat we're beginning of combat pH and uh I say that and goes to you guys and you're like I do nothing I do nothing now we're in declare attackers and this is where the first thing similar to drawing the card at the beginning of your draw step the first thing that happens at declare attackers is you declare your attackers yep and at that point it's going to be too late if you haven't already to do things like tap all their creatures down before they attack you'll run into this

on Arena and mtgo a lot more because without verbal communication if you just click one too many times you're now too late to use your those type of effects and you're like crap I meant to tap that down but it's too late now yeah yeah and and also like the reason that you have to do this before you declare attackers just because it's just like okay Josh I go to combat yeah you do nothing I'm like all right I'm Josh I'm swing you with three lra Z and you're like whoa whoa whoa hold on hold on before you swing with me with those jazi now that you've revealed literally what you're going to do I want to do something no it's too late to do that yeah it's too late yeah because you might go beginning of combat do you me who are you going to attack I don't know not sure yeah and he and you're like okay I do nothing I attack you Josh wait I want to tap him down no doesn't work like that yep you can't have the best of both worlds or have you King needed too whatever anecdote you want yeah exactly yeah so that's why you'll see us a lot of times asking that question so we know whether to do things before they declare attackers so we get to declare attackers the player declares their attacks and then that's when priority gets passed so what one thing you can do because as the active player let's say I'm attacking and I say I'm going to attack you know Danny with this creature and Jimmy with this one I declare those attackers I have I have priority at that moment I can say before blockers I'm going to path to Exile this creature Danny so now you have nothing yeah exactly so like you said when we move into declare attackers the first thing you do is the turn based action of declaring your attackers um and then yeah once that's already all said and done the active player you get priority and you pass it and then when everyone passes you go to the next step and then

yeah like once I have priority after I've declared my attacks then I can path to Exile or do whatever else I want and everyone else resp this has saved me on Arena before where I'm like oh crap I need to do this thing I have one last chance my creatures to attack well technically you have it after the next step which is declaring blockers so I attack Josh with two lir elves or one lir it's a one one B very bold make a statement send the signals so another turn-based effect here I'm assuming by declaring blockers something that you cannot be uh you cannot interact with right and you'll see this on Arena in mtgl you turn the card sideways you you ship them and then pass the other player and then they're allowed to choose blockers before anything priority gets passed around well they get priority after declare attackers if they didn't take it then then it assumes we're going to declare blockers right right and then yeah then you say the first thing you do at the beginning of the declare blockers face Danny's double-checking some of our stuff here I hope we're right yeah yeah sorry uh do want to take a pause real quick what I was thinking is um the communication policy changed kind of well like a year ago with a Smuggler copter in standard right uh for saying the word combat or things like that it used to be ambiguous now it's more clear and I just want to find it real quick so I can make sure we an instance where somebody said like I go to combat where somebody said combat yeah and then that was I'm not as worried about it for Commander because like generally we're like people are playing at their kitchen table and and tournament wording I think you got to be more careful with than we do a lot of times we even let somebody rewind where it's like somebody said wait wait wait hold on before you you know as long as no information's been

revealed you know mhm yeah we skipped over the beginning of combat and I wanted to do this right uh so I guess just to just to summarize it very briefly it's just like if you say go to combat and everyone says uh oh sorry let's say you go to combat uh and you have something like a Smuggler copter where you have not yet turned it into a creature you have not crud at this turn right um you basically use contacts to say well if we if I say combat and you all you all don't respond and and there's nothing on the battlefield then we're in declare attackers but if there's something that matters like that you see on the battlefield or you have to explicitly stay I want to go to beginning of combat then you would go to beginning of combat otherwise you just go to declare attackers that's basic because the sack is empty and auto passes to the next thing right right it's because of crew specifically because I can't crew once I'm in declare attackers right it's at that point too late because like we said you do the turn base action of attacking first then you would have priority to well crew it or anything else so just make sure your forces are ready before going into combat or I'm going to go to combat holding priority I will crew this thing mhm right okay so we're back to declare blocker um I've attacked or Jimmy's attacked me with the land off is that the scenario we're in okay you know it and then he passed priority and nobody did anything mhm um this is also interestingly well okay so then it goes to me as a person being attacked and I get to declare blockers and that's the first thing I can do at this point I can't respond with like a lightning buol or anything yet I would have to block or declare blockers first if you have no blockers that's still declaring of blockers right

yeah yeah we still go through the turnbas action of declaring blockers even if you have none or even if you choose to not block at all M right so I say oh I'm going to block with my two two and I declare that as blocker now Jimmy's priority again because he's the active player he has the first um chance to act it's actually it's actually a a a disadvantage in this case this is the defender's Advantage whereas we get to see what Jimmy does if we want to respond as the defender so if Jimmy wants to pump his creature in some way I'll Cast a Giant growth on my land elf at this point making it a 44 killing your tutu or it should kill your tutu however because I did something on the stack it is going to pass the priority around the table so Josh now has a chance to respond I mean i' get you respond even if you didn't cast the giant growth right so let's say I for whatever reason let's say I blocked with the one one just to makeas right you go l or elf I say block with this death right sham one two yeah block with something that's that's un trying to think of something played in Commander sakur tribe Elder that's a two1 that's a one one as well oh yeah okay yeah yeah so I block with my secure Tri Elder and then Jimmy gets priority and he says I'm going to pump my creature in some way yeah now priority goes back to me and this is a really good example because I go oh well in that case I'm going to sacrifice my secure tribe Elder right and go find a land right whereas maybe if I really didn't want Jimmy to have the land War elf and I'm happy with the trade if Jimmy says and this is where we get into some that thing we alluded to earlier if in that same scenario Jimmy says okay I do nothing pass prior to you

Josh if I do nothing here Jimmy can't then say wait no I'm in a giant growth yeah because there's no chance for Jimmy to get priority back before combat damage resolves so I'm it's I'm in the driver's seat as a defender in that moment but if I go I'm going to sacrifice my secur tri tribe Elder Jimmy could respond in some way wouldn't make sense to Giant growth it then though yeah I but there's something else that maybe I could have done where I was like you know what I needed that creature off the board because now I'm going to flash in and edict effect or whatever or because Josh now just has one creature left he has to you know because he got rid of the or whatever it is some way to give it instant speed trample would be good then spicy yeah that one damage coming in hot maybe I'm at one I'm going to died to my own forx oreno we don't know there you go okay now we go to so declare attackers priorities passed declare block blockers priorities passed once priority's been passing no one's everyone's you know said I'm not doing anything else you resolve whatever happened and then you go to combat damage this is where it gets a little interesting because let's talk so at the beginning of the combat damage step the damage happens again turn based turn based action similar to the drawing the card the declaring the attackers the declaring the blockers those are all turnbas actions that like at the beginning of those steps that thing happens and after that priority happens so combat damage happens now the way this gets slightly complicated is with First Strike MH so the way the game deals with first strike is if tell me if I get this right sure if a first Striker

is declared as an attacker mhm in that moment it creates a first strike combat damage step uh correct yes so if a first Striker is if there's no first Striker involved in combat there will not be a first strike combat damage step yeah it's not like something you skip over it's gets it's gets created when the creature attacks mhm yep so if You' got a first Striker and it's involved in combat there's going to be two combat damage steps one for first strike in which case the first strike damage will happen at the beginning of that step and then people will get prior which means you can act between first strike damage and regular damage we see this with like I don't know sort of feas in famine I was going to say um was GT um is really good something like tragic slip or something with morbid you might be able to be like oh my first recer is going to kill their thing and then now that something's died it can tragic slip something else yeah they may have been blocking something yeah in between when the regular damage happens so even burn spells are really good let's say it's a five toughness creature you hit it for with three first strike and then you use a burn spell to kill the last two so it doesn't actually hit you back right you can get rid of the creature before it's even gotten a chance to deal damage so first strike is there's a lot of different ways to play with that priority there yeah so then we we do first strike damage that all resolves then I mean the damage happens and then we do the priority thing Jimmy says you know I'm going to burn the rest this creature the rest of the way down here in between combat so it doesn't hit me back and then we go to regular damage and that damage again at the beginning of that step just happens uh there's no interrupting that at that point mhm and then into pass

priority again and this is where um we get to the end of combat step right before we actually go to this I just remembered something yeah okay we're going to interrupt right here because Danny goes on to explain about uh ordering blockers and how that works but that step in the process no longer exists we brought in murf to explain how it works today yeah so nowadays uh whenever you block with multiple creatures all all of a sudden you don't have to worry about assigning blockers anymore the attacking player just gets to decide how much damage they want to put on each of the blocking creatures pretty simple you don't have to order and pick this one takes the damage first and have to assign lethal to that one it's just these two block and then the attacker decides how much damage they want to dish out the interesting thing here is like how it relates to this episode is uh the priority has changed yes where before you would order blockers and then blocker would know how damage roughly has to be dealt out and could make moves between that and when damage is dealt yeah now you can no longer do that it puts a little bit of the power back in the attacker's favor yeah which is kind of neat also a little simpler yeah so that's the correction here it uh doesn't change much about anything else but now you know back to the show all right so now first strike damage happened combat damage happened we're at the end of combat this is the part where lot of people have problems

with this every time we we utilize this there's a moment at the end of the combat phase where creatures are still involved in combat MH it's called the end of combat they could have already dealt their damage in fact they did because First Strike damage and regular damage happened MH but they're still considered attackers and blockers at this moment and at that moment if you have instances that refer to attackers and blockers you can you can use them you can activate them so um reconnaissance is the big which allows you to untap a creature that's in combat and we saw wedge use it after he swung with a creature dealt the damage and then use ronance to untap and people were saying you can't do that because he's done with combat however he's doing it at the end of combat step ronance also says that creature neither deals or nor receives damage this combat um which doesn't matter after it's already done its thing the game will not sort of time travel back and retroactively take away damage that happened right it's like hey we'll prevent any damage from here but combat damage is already over so we're just going to do the other parts of it yep uh settle the wreckage is another one that like let's say somebody attacked you with a ton of stuff and you didn't want to give them that many lands you had a few free blocks you might block wait till damage happened kill a few of them and then settle the last couple that were left over those kind of things we'll see that in limited more often with like you know destroy target attacking creature or whatever kill the little one do it to the big one that's kill the little one okay woo combat woo combat is crazy yeah so after end of

combat we say okay does anybody have any effects end of combat pass that priority rounds goes to your second main phase which is identical to your first main phase it's just the second one it doesn't it's not called pre-combat main phase it's called post combat science if you didn't play a land you can now play a land and then works just like we've been talking and we go towards the end step and the way that we usually move to the endep is say we talk about something cool outside the World of Magic we usually say just I'm going to pass the turn or whatever if we have uh if we have endep triggers that are happening then a lot of times people say I mve to my endep and this happens right um but we're implicitly sort of stating like I'm going to go to my endep I pass priority and that's where Cedric took advantage of saying like nope we're not in your endep yet and I actually want to do something before we get there right right U but most of the time people just go into the endep and then the endep works a lot like the upkeep in that there's a beginning of endep triggers that will occur at that point Licor was one right yeah T's time twist that we just talked about with Cedric is another one that creates a delayed trigger that just happens there's all kinds of like sneak attacks and things like that that will happen at the endep and murf who was one of the people that helped us put together the the outline for this said you can think of the end step and the cleanup step which are sort of the the ending of phase two things almost like UNT upkeep in reverse order oh very nice that's a good way to think about it

almost there's some differences so just like the upkeep we go to the endep and this is where the end step triggers happen happen and again it's active player non-active player so if if Jimmy had you know flicker whisk or whatever he would stack it after my um my end step triggers happen so right uh we've already covered that and then okay so then again um and sub's not quite over yeah right so there's what's the oh oh we we we tried to come come up with examples for all this stuff so I guess the flip flicker whst example is better than this one we were saying if you had death reap ritual and someone else has Arch fiend of depravity right which kills creatures yeah it says choose to sacrifice the rest is say each player inep it says yeah so that's actually an example where it doesn't work because a creatures died during the inep it's not at the beginning of the inep which again is hearkening back to the tarry's time or that cedra cast right once you have entered into the end step anything that says at the beginning of the end step uh if if the conditions were not met it's not going to trigger until the next endep okay so if it again it's all depending on the card just like the upkeep beginning of EP triggers they happen they get stacked they resolve we respond to them then pass priority I have nothing else in my EP can I go to my cleanup phase MH and then you guys say yes now we go to the cleanup step and this is again we're going to say similar to the untap step but it's not the exact same so damage wears off your

creatures at this point this is the moment where you know if somebody's whatever 88 has taken four damage uh or has taken five damage you can't lightning bolt and finish it off anymore effects that say until end of turn wear off so like your active treason type effects Insurrection would wear off at this point you and then you discard down to the maximum hand size so you discard down to seven cards generally if you have nine cards You' have to discard two the way this is similar to the untap step is that no actions can be willfully taken however unlike the untap step if any triggers occur during the cleanup phase they have to be resolved before the turn moves on to the next player so whereas on the unta step if a trigger happen like inspired MH that gets pushed into upkeep on the cleanup step if a trigger happens there's no place to push it so it has to be resolved within the cleanup phase end of the line buddy so the interesting thing here and it comes up a lot and this is actually one of the reasons we even did this episode is because our buddy Kyle was talking about a a gitrog monster deck that he played against and how in the endep it went to cleanup phase had eight cards discarded a land get Rog triggers there to draw your card whenever a land enters the battle or enters your graveyard from anywhere and then Drew another card well that player is had eight cards discarded another land drew a card discarded the land drew a card and just continued to do that and went through like 20 cards on their turn or whatever and this is totally legal at the moment we were like what the heck and we were Googling it cuz I was like I don't know

exactly how that works uh because again there's no place else to push those triggers to right which is discards your maximum hand size mhm an interesting thing we found when researching this was like if you have necro poens out you have to discard to hand size maybe there the way necro is worded the creature card will actually hit your graveyard and you could instant speed like recurrent before necron would Exile it I believe because necron trigger Goes On The Stack anytime a creature would or a part with the in your graveyard it gets exiled instead it doesn't say instead oh it just gets exiled I believe yes that creates trigger in your cleanup SE if said the word instead you wouldn't be able to respond to it CU that wouldn't be a trigger correct correct that would be a replacement effect so it seize the graveyard for a hot second before necro poent is trigger Exiles it and you go Goro's Vengeance it and then you get it until the next EP of your opponent or whatever that's spicy very spicy okay what a turn wow so that was the turn that was priority that was we did attack with like aanta War elves that was pretty boring man I mean there was a colossal dread Bond oh that's true that yeah 66 gun there um okay so hopefully this was of some interest to you maybe you learned some things I know I did when we were putting this together murf and I were both like really that's how that works we have played magic 4 forever so I'm hopefully there were some interesting things in there uh that kind of gives you an idea of how stuff's supposed to work when you're supposed to act and also when your windows of opportunity are cuz when stuff starts to get complicated you can be looking for that moment you know one of the tricks we used to talk about was that Dead Eye Navigator when the Soul Bond trigger

Goes On The Stack is when you have to go to remove it because if you let that Soul Bond thing happen they're just going to Blink it again in response and those little tricks you can learn about cards often make them at first they seem like unbeatable and then it's like no I just have to know when is my opportunity to strike right yeah when the stack how things are getting stacked and where those things are and a lot of that is just communication with your play group yeah and if you're a player that has learned magic through Arena this is definitely something going to be very unintuitive to you because the game takes a lot of steps for you I would recommend try playing a game just holding down full control the entire time to see when you get an option to do stuff and that's going to give you a better idea of okay this is what it's like if I responded to every single moment when I have an ability to do something take an action to have priority I I want to I want to as a final thought here just say a couple of things which is like all the shortcuts we use right now in Commander are good you should totally keep doing them they help the game Flow and they're ultimately better for everybody and I know a lot lot of times people they get up in arms about even in game nights will shortcut some things but you want the game like you said most of the rules are actually trying to make the game Flow in the way that we actually play it yeah you're a judge do you rules layer uh no I don't at all like like if people ask me questions like yeah that's when we slow it down and go step by step and we're extra granular but yeah like you guys are talking about the point of the rules is to make it so it intuitively makes the game have a normal Tempo M but we have the actual rules to reference if something comes up yeah I mean and if you're going to lightning bu to Giant growth response there's not a lot of Prior passing priority that actually has to happen there lightning Bol J growth okay cool that's you don't need to be like I pass priority I do this where's

the stack look like you don't have to do any of that stuff so we're not advocating for anybody to to rules layer um that's not what this is It's really just a way so that you can know what's happening when so you can understand it because what we don't want to happen is like I said with the dead ey Navigator thing where it just seems like it's unbeatable but actually you oh if you broke it down and understood how it works you'd be like oh well here's the moment in time where I can pick it apart and actually cuz magic is about you know that's the really unique thing about the game being able to respond to almost anything there's a possibility of being able to like thwart almost anything yeah and Josh made a great point in the outline here which is don't try and out rule someone as a way of getting an advantage I see this happen at pre-releases unfortunately a lot where someone just doesn't realize oh that's how the game works and the other person will take advantage of that and that I think leads to the most feel bad moments because instead of winning strategically through you know like a decision you made in the you're winning off of what almost feels like a technicality which is never nice right never feels good no one wants to see that happen all right that was pretty sweet I mean there's it's very helpful to just walk through a whole turn and know exactly how everything breaks down because we tend to shortcut so many of the things so it's it's good to know yeah I I hope people out there uh you know found some cool stuff out there you know that they're going to be able to use in their games and hopefully have a little bit more peace of mind just understanding what's going on sometimes I know you know even you know at this point I don't know if you feel this way but I do even today having played magic and you know have it been my job and my profession for years and years there's still

moments in gam are like hold on what how's that work what's going on and oh yeah okay that makes sense so don't feel bad if you have to do that but also hopefully this gives you some confidence you have a general understanding of how the stack works but it's okay if you're like hey let's just can we just explain this because I'm not really sure that happens to me still yeah and when things get complicated and a lot of people are jumping on top of each other especially in multiplayer it's helpful to slow things all the way down and lay out the cards in the order yeah and it gives everybody A visual representation of how this is going to happen and where we are in what process and it just makes it easier for everybody to understand I know a lot of people were referring this video to their play group they're like I need everybody in my play group to watch this they can get better understanding yeah it does make games better even though it seems complex once everybody knows what's going on yeah hope this episode helped hope you enjoyed the remastered version of it uh to the listeners have you mastered the stack as hopefully this episode has helped what cool moves have you pulled off as a result because I think the holding priority thing is very fun is a very fun trick and uh knowing when to remove creatures in combat when it comes to First Strike and double strike and all of that yeah uh being a rules lawyer it can help yeah rules knowledgeable but you don't have to be like a rules litigator rules librarian there you go if you want to pick up any magic cards uh after this if you're like oh you know what I understand this card much better I'm going to put it in my deck go to

cardkingdom.com commmand Card Kingdom has a huge selection of singles sealed product everything that you need to play Magic if you're really into foundations like we are there's a lot of tools for teaching magic there's a lot of tools for expanding a collection both in singles and in sealed product go to Card Kingdom they're going to have a ton of that stuff all in in one place plus they're going to package it safely and soundly and make sure it shows up on your doorstep in one piece I know I get frustrated when I order a card and it's a specific printing or a specific foiling and when it shows up it's not the one I thought so I love shopping with Card Kingdom because they know cards and they know how to ship them plus they've got a great team to take care of you if something does go wrong it is the mail after all car kingdom.com commmand and you can sport the show and of course once you get those cards you want to keep them protected and in pristine condition ultr pro is the company we trust our own collections to here at the command zone go to ultrapro.com commmand and you can see all kinds of cool items that they have for every single set they've got the licensing agreement with Wizards of the Coast so they often have like your commander or your legendary creature on a playmat on sleeves on deck boxes so you can theme out your stuff that way they also have the awesome Mana eight line which we've been talking about a while you know if you're dreaming of a white Christmas and you know Rachel's the white player the white man eight stuff is perfect for like you know wrapping up the holidays here I was thinking about this it's kind of rule zero conversation if some somebody shows up and they've got like the black playmat and the black sleeves and the black deck like deck box you're like oh well I know what's happening yeah and

also respect right like that's pretty cool you're pretty organized with your Battlefield so yeah and and it is after the holidays and I think there's a really good chance that they're going to have all kinds of discounts they always they have them year year round um not just during the holidays but this is definitely a time where a lot of stores and places are like okay we're done selling for the holidays we've got extra inventory let's discount it so this is a great time to go to ultrapro.com commmand for the show y before we go we want to say thank you to our amazing team here at the command Zone that make episodes like this possible thank you to Rachel Kendra Karina Cruz Sebastian Salazar grav Gatti Jamie block Jordan pigon Jake Boss Eric LM Josh Murphy Manon L Christopher matista we got there Evan limberger Sam walto and Jimmy Wong CH on the newer side we'll get used to it stumbl stumbl right sorry Chris we'll do better next time let a teas yeah this was a good idea I think we should do more of these remastered episodes like I you know we've got some good ones in the bank that I think are still very relevant like this so let us know if you liked it yeah let us know if you liked it if you've got one that you're like oh I always like this one let us know yeah and we're on episode like 600 and uh 49 so there's I'm sure there's a lot buried in there that people just aren't aware we've ever even done so being able to dig those up and be like look this is a cool one I already have one in mind that's my favorite one of my favorites we'll bring it back at some point all right for watching everybody peace

bye thank you for your attention for further inquiries send an email to command cast rocket jump.com or ask us on Twitter at jfwong and at Josh Le see you later alligator greetings humans

Progress saved