The Kings Dilemma review
Transcript
this video is brought to you by the three-minute board game patrons keep us Independent by supporting us on patreon Kiara Coto and Welcome to our review of The King's dilemma the more astute among you will notice that this is a more traditional style review than you're accustomed to on the 3-minute board games Channel and the reason for that is well some games just don't fit our format very well either due to being too complex not complex enough having too much dick it or realtime elements to them or in the nature of the king's dilemma not really being much of a game and mostly being a storytelling experience now before we get into the nitty-gritty of the review let's cover off the basics it has no solo mode it's a game for three to five players each individual Reign within the game lasts about an hour and the game can go for 15 odd Reigns and it's a pretty simple game now let's blast through the mechanics of the game cuz ultimately they're not that important the core idea is that you are a noble house that advises the king and you are one of many noble housers within the kingdom the noble housers of you and the other players are the ones selected to be part of the king's Council and the core gameplay revolves around event cards so what'll happen is one player will draw one of these event cards and it will have a set of consequences on them you'll Mark those consequences on the board clearly showing what voting I will do and what nay will do and the results of those votes will influence these tracks in the middle of the board now these five tracks represent the military might of the Kingdom the wealth of the Kingdom the morale of the people
the Health and Welfare of the people and the strength of your scholarship and Ingenuity various votes will cause these to rise and fall and along with them the popularity of the king themselves so you see that's tracked using the scales at the side and if that ever gets to either end the king will abdicate well how do these votes go down you have a finite amount of influence tokens and when it is your turn to vote you may choose to put that influence on either I or nay if you have the most influence on any any of those categories you become the council leader and that means voting will end with the player to your left you can also choose to abstain which allows you to either collect a coin which can be used for scoring and bribing other players or you can collect the gabble which acts as a tiebreaker the game includes this little cardboard thing as a gabble but I went out and secured a much more fun one so you go around and you do a bunch of talking and then you count up the votes and that determines which outcome is selected and therefore what things on the chart move a huge part of your reasoning behind that is each of you will have a scoring card and it will show where you want at the end of that King's Reign uh these tracks to end up so for example in this position we have the moderate card and the moderate wants everything to be in the middle of the table so at the moment they would score really big because they have four things sitting in the middle of the table and there isn't there's only one resource in the extremes different results also give you laws that can be passed into effect that end up being place at the top of the board and also allow you to open up
envelopes and these envelopes which are all individually numbered come with extra cards and extra events so this is what drives the story now at the end of each Reign based on how many points you scored you'll get Prestige and crave and you'll also Mark off achievements based on your house the goal of the game is to score the most prestige or crave depending on you know whether you want to undermine the kingdom or whether you want to prop it up But ultimately none of that actually matters the the whole scoring system of this game the whole resolution thing it's just it's kind of busy work it's fun busy work but really all the king's dilemma is when you get down to Brass tax is a pick and path book and I mean I love pick a path books this is the entire fighting fantasy collection up here uh fighting fantasy is kind of what got me into the wider gaming hobby so when I say something as a pick aath book that is not a knock on it but it is just describing it and saying what it actually is because what really happens in the king's dilemma is you kind of get into character about what your house is so the vote will come up and you'll come up with blithering reasons and sort of roleplay reasons for why you want uh a number on this track to move up a certain number of steps uh so say the vote is oh no um someone insulted the king what should we do shall we let it slide um because they're a rich person and that will like increase the economy or or make us less popular but if we
lock that guy up it'll ruin the economy you know it's those kind of decisions and ultimately you're just moving these numbers around on the board in order to get good numbers at the end to mark down better numbers on your chart here mechanically the king's dilemma is it's all about distraction it's all about busy work to get you to the point where you're reading about the decisions and those decisions are resolved but it's not much of a game it's kind of like a DM storytelling game but one that's you know heavily on Rails but it is a good story well it's kind of six stories without getting into too many spoilers there's six main story paths and each of them goes their own way depending on the decisions you've made tied up in an overall story structure but there's really six major subplots and each of those by itself are quite compelling and we got quite into them and as I say the story was the really good part what we're really enjoying the arguing about it and moving the plot along and seeing what happened to this wacky horrible horrible terrible terrible Kingdom ruled by absolutely terrible people like we we were Shockers we did Despicable horrible things during our
game you look at the mechanic again and you have all these laws get passed into effect and ultimately having these laws in effect didn't really mean Jack uh it meant that there were opportunities for people to start off with a couple less resources or they might lose some victory points if say you'd passed them to effect three negative laws for wealth well you had to try and K wealth out of the bottom or else you were going to score even even fewer points but coming last kind of had its own reward anyway so there's so much mechanical busy work here that I think ultimately takes away from the experience of the storytelling game and I think I would rather play again something a bit simpler a bit more straightforward like the quiet year for the
queen or this other one that had a Jinger Tower in it that I will Ed it in later once I remember what the hell it is you see those games did a similar sort of thing of exploring a kingdom and having a shared role playing experience uh it just didn't have remotely as much uh busy work uh down here on this board and with all these tracking icons and all this other bits and Bobs and that brings me to I think the last issue I have with the king's dilemma and that is that ultimately it is a giant waste and the reason for that is ultimately every single thing in this box you throw out there's nothing worth keeping like there is zero replayability this game all of this all of this crap here oh and the Box insert all of these cards everything all of this crap it just goes in the tip like I really don't know how to feel about that I mean it seems excessive and I kind of knew that going into it that it was a legacy game and it was disposable but I don't know it's it's one of those things to think that before playing one and it's actually the case to get to the end of it and realize there's nothing here worth
keeping at all like big chunky roll book all of these stickers things you didn't use all of the envelopes uh the tokens aren't even particularly useful for anything uh it's just it's just going to go to the tip and yeah I don't think I don't think I can do this again I don't think I can get another um Legacy game like this that's just this wasteful in the end um because you know Ticket to Ride uh Legacy for example there's still a game there to play at the end um it might not be everyone's cup of tea but there's something I King's dmma there's there's nothing I mean you could possibly if you were incredibly fastidious um play it in a way that you could reuse it by I don't know putting the stickers down a certain way so that you could unstick them later or photocopying it I I don't know um but the game is clearly not designed to be in any way shape or form salvageable and I think I think that's just not for me I think while I enjoyed the overall story and idea of the king's dilemma as a concept I don't think I enjoyed it enough to to deal with this especially not when there are alternatives like as I say the quiet year uh which you can
play with just Post-it notes uh and the deck of cards that comes with it and if you're done with that um you you can just pass it on to someone else there's another game I've got here as well uh the Sherlock Holmes Consulting detective games they're one and done they're a big box set game and there's like 10 or so scenarios in each one or cases and once you're done solving them there's not much point in revisiting them but you haven't trashed um the game you can sell it on to someone else who can have just as much fun with the cas and then there's like escape room games but they're so much smaller um and I'm going to have a look at a couple of those that got sent to me and see just how iffy they are but yeah I pandemic Legacy even there was a pandemic board in that and you can salvage some of the pieces and do stuff with them this like the the tokens aren't really useful for anything the coins I mean they're just hardboard coins it's not like you can't can't get those in 10,000 other games uh the cards really I mean they're good card stock but they're kind of awkward size so yeah uh that's my final say on the king's dilemma it is a kind of neat experience I think it would be kind of fun to play if it was a app and I believe they've done one of those and I think that might be a fun way to do it where you virtualize everything you digitize uh all of this instead of
having it being paper uh because ultimately this just ain't it this is not this is not great I actually feel kind of shitty having to put all this in the tip after playing that game so yeah that's my review of The King's deliver and if you enjoyed this video hitting the notification button like share and subscribe to the
channel the one thing I am going to keep from the king's dilemma is one of these tokens and uh one of his double-sided tokens and the reason for that is there's a coin toss at some point during the game and I did the coin toss and it landed on that top bar up there and it didn't come back down it just flicked it up and it just landed up there it was like a one in a gazillion chance so I've left the token that I did that up on that bar that's the one thing I'll
keep