Skip to main content
Loading video...

Windmill Valley First Impressions

Transcript 19:46

hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor my name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today in this video I'm going to give you my first impressions of windmill Valley now this was voted on by the community on Board Game Geek for me to play and review so thank you for all of those who participated whether you are watching this video or not thank you for your input to helping me uh be motivated to look at this game and play it I was motivated already this is one of the games that caught my eye during Gen Con and it is being talked about during essent as well and so in preparation for that I wanted to play this game and see what I thought so the way that I structure this is I go through uh the mechanisms and the aspects of the game that make it feel unique and then I during that I'm also going to make some game comparisons I'm going going to combine both of those aspects of my review and first impressions into one I then will go over the thoughts and impressions of others who have made their comments known on Board Game Geek specifically and then wrap it up with concluding thoughts on how I feel about this game so in windmill Valley this is a game by Danny Garcia where it is a mediumweight game where you are uh taking actions on a Rondell and doing various and and a multitude of things including planting

tulips onto your Tableau uh Gathering cards to make your Tableau feel unique and have interesting and special powers in addition to that you can also customize your wheel to to make those actions more unique and Powerful as you take them uh all the while uh you in addition to planting out tulips you are placing out windmills onto a board to gain benefits along the way you can purchase and take part in actions based off of this mini rondelle in the market on the middle of the board and whoever has the most points at the end of the game will win so breaking some of these different mechanisms down first the TBL low it's it feels very standard uh to most mediumweight Euro games where you are keeping track of different icons placing certain tokens down gaining benefits as you progress along the either a track or uh as you try to spatially arrange these tokens so you can score points at the end of the game I won't get into all the rules in this review but uh I I feel like one game that I could compare this to if if you know if it's not only all-encompassing with a lot of typical Euro games nowadays I will compare this first to Barcelona which is one of Dan Danny Garcia's other games the way that your Tableau worked in seemingly in both

games if I remember correctly and I reviewed this game last year is that there are a lot of opportunities to Cascade the actions that you take more on how that Cascades a little bit later but the the fact that you are able to plant a lot of different tulips here uh in a spatial puzzle U wanting to keep the same type of tulip in each row is most important to getting a lot of points out of this system but you know placing them on top of spaces to gain Bon uh benefits which may include other actions or even Straight Up victory points to be able to Cascade certain actions as you go along one designer of note that does a lot of this is V lasa but this game is not at the same complexity as lda's games uh this definitely falls into a uh more streamlined or less uh convoluted uh pathway that is often found in Danny Garcia's games so it's a little bit easier to handle if you're not so used to those types of mechanisms in gameplay or don't enjoy them in uh if you don't enjoy the high complexity type of games and so it's fairly easy in my opinion to manage this Tableau and it feels a lot like uh Garcia's other games which often have cascading actions taking place now let's move on to the Rondell so two games remind me of this

Rondell system one for taking actions and the other part about customizing the action the uh actions that you can place into your Tableau and those games are uh praga kaput regy and dice Forge so praga is a Vladimir sui game where you are able to take actions based off of a shared Rondell and this game they are combin or they are separated per player but in prog a lot of the decisions each turn revolve around a Rondell of choosing actions that are beneficial to you but also giving you an opportunity to move farther or not as far on that rondelle track to be able to take actions that you need to take to be the most efficient so a lot of decision spaces uh the decision space is the same I feel from turn to turn when you compared praga to kapo regy and then dice Forge has as the name implies uh an opportunity to roll dice but also to customize those dice to give you better and more powerful actions as well as more resources when you do roll those dice during the game play and so that aspect is seen here in windmill Valley as you are able to customize your Rondell system and it was fun to try to match up a certain pairing of different rondelle pieces to make them align so that you can take a super action once

your Rondell uh circles back to that certain action at a at a point um and so that was that was a lot of fun there are ways to mitigate it as well with these tools and more on that later or maybe more on it right now because the last aspect that I wanted to touch on was this Dyke system so each turn before you rotate your wheel you have to decide how far you're going to rotate it and you do so by essentially choosing one of these three actions uh or you know major you know uh branching actions to take and so it tells you how many times you can move that wheel on your turn at a price if you do choose to move it uh as you know fast as you can with by three spaces you do gain victory points by moving it faster as well but you also have to move the Dyke uh representation of the Dyke flooding onto the land by uh moving this tracker up and down this uh particular track there are actions on your Rondell which allow you to move the space uh to the this marker to the left which not only gains you benefits as shown but also allows you to in the future be able to move the Dyke farther or your your uh pardon your wheel farther because if this marker is all the way at the end you can't go farther than than one space you would have to uh it represents the Dy could be way too uh open and allowing for too much water flow and so you would have to

take one action and reduce the flow of the Dyke and so that immediately reminded me of Lan Loland not only shares thematic uh setting as both games I believe are taking place uh you know closer to the Netherlands or or Denmark you know in that area where the the lands are low and and the uh uh there is a push and pull system in low lens where it's somewhat semi-cooperative where you can contribute to the Dyke building in the proc the process of building a dyke if you do so you can change the future of the game and how it's scored um and if you don't participate in it there are other ways to benefit from it but at the risk of losing a lot of points if not everyone else you know contributes to the Dyke itself and so there's a lot of social interaction in this game via the choices that you make to build or not to build the Dyke uh more on this on my separate review on the channel but in a somewhat similar fashion the way that you interact with this not only tells you how you can interact with your own rondelle but also it may affect the decisions of other players as well as yours if you decide to take a lot of actions and push this marker all the way to the top preventing other players and potentially yourself from advancing very far on the track itself now I had the opportunity to skim through some of the comments made by

folks who have played this game candidly uh without any review material online I haven't really dived into any of the online reviews myself or the video reviews on YouTube rather but a lot of people commented on this game in comparison to some of other Danny Garcia's Garcia games this game is definitely lighter than games such as Barcelona and so some people enjoy that some people didn't you know it's easier to to teach to those who aren't you know as familiar or as willing to play more complex or even longer games I will comment this game felt shorter to play uh and in addition to that though at the cost seemingly of the the weight and the complexity of the game the game this game for a lot of folks made it uh a little too Breezy uh it was too streamlined and not enough uh tough and Meaty decisions to make throughout the game and so I I I found that comment uh multiple times that it it just didn't seem as interesting or as replayable uh to some folks because of how light this game felt now in my opinion I agree that this game was easier to learn than say games like Barcelona I did really enjoy the different aspects of this game and how they kind of come together some people did not like the water track I did I I liked this aspect of the game despite

the fact in the caveat that I I would rather play lowland than this but but in in regards to this I I do enjoy this mechanism for the fact that there is an opportunity for some interaction to potentially Advance your own agenda forward at potentially the expense of someone else or to sacrifice your agenda to prevent someone else from progressing as far as as you can uh the other thing that I did not mention yet is how this game ends and I suppose there is a fifth game that I should mention here that I don't have a picture which is tapestry and so it this reminded me of tapestry and other games where the ending of the game is somewhat asymmetrical not in the sense like in tapestry or everdell where everyone can be on a or or I should say uh the game ultimately ends with everyone taking this the I guess the uh same amount of Seasons uh in this game uh that is not the case there is a a an a trigger at the end of the game that is not static meaning that someone could race ahead and finish the game before anyone else has reached that fourth season everyone takes the same amount of turns but the amount of spins that you apply to your will will determine how fast you progress through this calendar which is what this is and so just as a side note too I I played this game against myself but I used some

dice to just randomize some of the choices that were made by this uh OTA person that I played against uh scoring wise it this probably is uh artificially low because in this particular game that I played the way that the dice rolls went was that this otoma player really progressed fast through throughout the the game itself and really spun that wheel making the game go by faster and giving me less turns to take I didn't uh keep track of how many turns I took overall but it was probably insignificantly less than you would see on an average game if you were playing against a regular person who would be uh strategizing a little bit more from turn to turn and so but the aspect of of this game having a non static ending uh meaning not having a set number of turns or rounds to play this game in made it feel more interactive and has the potential to be more socially interactive when you are uh playing this game and looking potentially looking at once you really understand this game you can look at someone else's Tau and board and plan ahead accordingly to either speed up the game or reduce the speed as necessary to be able to beat out your opponents to certain uh events whether they are bonuses on this calendar track if you progress first uh you can have you have more options to choose from to

choose a benefit um or you know to take as much time as you can to really reap the benefits that you have set up as you have developed your cogs and and uh your windmill Rondell essentially on your own board so I like that and that Al also all Tye into how you uh meddle with this track and making sure that if you you know take as many spins as you can and can't afford you potentially could stop someone else from progressing as fast as they would like to on that game and so I like the potential that that provides all in a package that is easily more I should say more easily understandable than your average medium heavy heavy you know medium to heavy weight Euro game that is often seen by Garcia and others uh nowadays essentially does this game have replayability for me uh so this this game does offer a little bit of variety in terms of these cards I should mention that these uh cards are helper cards that you can either play to the top of your Tableau for asymmetric benefits ongoing benefits that you can uh take advantage of or for objectives that you can try to fulfill by the end of the game for extra points and you also have a public objective that people are racing towards as well and so there is setup variability in this game as well as randomization of

the different uh upgrades that you can apply to your own rondells and so there is you know physical variation in this game but does it feel like it will be variable from game to game I don't I don't know I I I would be very happy to play this game again if it was offered on a uh like a digital format like board game arena I think I would be interested in doing so it I there are other mediumweight games that I would prefer whether they are because they have more social interaction or more variety in gameplay and tougher decisions to make despite the streamlined rule scent uh you know I I've been playing a lot of glass Road recently which is I think it falls in the same weight as this if not it probably is a little bit less in terms of rules complexity compared to Windmill Valley or it's about the same I should say I would rather play that game because there's more social interaction than uh the potential that this game has windmill Valley I think there's a lot more potential in this game rather than upfront interaction that you will see in games like glass Road as well as The Upfront interaction that you would see in a game like Lan I would definitely play this game uh windmill Valley over dice Forge uh just because dice Forge is a little too light in complexity for my tastes there's uh more complexity in decisions to be made in this game I think I would rather play this game over praga as well I felt like

praga was just a bit too overwhelming of a game for me to really want to sink my teeth into and understand the nuances of that game and I feel like praga is a touch more static in how you approach it because of how expansive Ra's board is which is very similar to this windmill uh uh you know field board that you are playing your windmills to in windmill Valley and so I think I would go for windmill Valley over praga Barcelona I haven't touched and thought about since I played it last and so it's about the same for me I I think windmill Valley would be easier to remember and play again and so I might give the nod towards windmill Valley if I were to compare this to Barcelona but there are I I guess this is all to say that I really enjoyed my play of woodmill Valley and I would play it again but it didn't leave me thinking about the decisions and the the nooks and crannies that I could potentially explore in this game I do appreciate that there are a lot of different ways to accumulate points and I think this game would really shine at a higher player count because I didn't even touch in this first impressions video on the uh this uh trade board or not as much on the market as well and so there are plenty of opportunities to gain different benefits and bonuses throughout the game that could really Propel your engine and uh and points forward in this game that I did not get to see on first blush but I don't think

there are as many Nooks for me to explore in this game as there are in other games and some of that is because of just what is presented here mechanically but also with the social interactive aspect of this game um yeah so a lot of people didn't enjoy how simple or how I guess negligent it this uh potential social interaction was it didn't really feel like it played a big role in their enjoyment and the tension that the game could have provided and I I think I'm in agreement mostly with what what other people say that this game didn't have that much uh tension or or as much interaction as I I think it would provide but that is yet to be seen and I would have to confirm that at a higher player count and playing with uh real folks rather than against an AI just to really feel out the mechanism so so enjoyable game and if if uh what I am saying and the mechanisms that are discussed in this video and the you know the board game comparisons that I've made uh speak to you and have intrigued you then you're more than welcome of course to try this game out this is a free module on tabletop pop simulator that you can check out for yourself and uh so yeah so feel free to do so and those are my thoughts on Windmill Valley thank you for Consulting with me today and hope that you schedule an appointment with your board gaming doctor real soon take care

Progress saved