Skip to main content
Loading video...

Rival Cities Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 7:42

At number two, I have Rival Cities. So, this is the newest design by Andrea Steding, who is most known for Hanza Tutonica and Forenz. So, made some really good games. Now, this is a bit different to his normal fair because this is a twoplayer only kind of sudden death style games. There are actually five different fronts that you and your opponent are fighting on. Now, four of them are sudden death conditions and one of them is simply victory points if none of those sudden death conditions are are met basically. So, the game is a kind of a rondelle style game as you have the board with a bunch of cards spread around. You you can do it randomly if you like or there is suggested setups as well as some special cards mixed in there as well. and you can simply move your player piece one or two spaces around the rondelle uh for free or if you want to go more than that then you are going to have to start paying resources. Now the different fronts you're fighting on are kind of several tugofwar tracks as well as some set collection and there is kind of a strong thread of resource management going on behind the scenes to get those cards that you need. So, I suppose we'll start with the the different ways to win. So, first of which, there's this big tugof-war track like this prestige track on the main board where if you collect these hearts, you could pull the little marker in your direction. And if you pull it far enough, you'll instantly win. But if it's on your side of the the

table, then you will get some passive income at the end of the round, which can be really helpful and help you with the different fronts you're fighting on. Uh you can collect these ships that will give you instant or ongoing benefits. And if you ever have three more ships or maybe more than three ships, I can't remember than your opponent, then you'll instantly win. The ships of course cost resources. Uh you've got these kind of affiliation cards that there's four of them available at any game or any time. Um and as long as you are in control of these cards, you'll get quite a powerful benefit. Um, but every time you go around the Rondell, you do need to pay resources to keep hold of them, and you can even snatch them off your opponent. And these will do things such as increasing your yield of resources or giving you discounts on other parts of the game. And you also have these lawsuits, which are kind of multiple little tugof-war games, um, where when you go to the lawsuit places, you will pay resources to move your little market in your direction, um, and try and get beat your opponent. But unlike the main tugof-war board, these um these ones are resolved at the end of every round. So even if you are slightly ahead of your opponent, you will win that lawsuit and get the benefit from it. And if you ever collect, I think it's three lawsuits, you'll instantly win the game. But there are lots of ways to manipulate the state of play by shifting those lawsuits around so that maybe the ones you're struggling on will be pushed back into a couple of rounds time and you can focus on the other ones and use that time to catch back up. Now, despite having so many moving parts, the game is pretty

easy to digest and there is some good synergies between those different facets of the game. You know, for example, you know, you might buy the ship, which will be one of the ones that you need. Um, and that ship might let you move down the tug of war track. So, you're constantly looking over your shoulder here because there are so many things you need to manage and you're spinning so many plates. the game just forces you to feel paranoid and which I think the is what the game is trying to do and the feeling the game is trying to get across. So if you want a game that as soon as you set it up you need to be looking over your shoulder and being aware of all the options that not only you can take but try and block your opponent from taking actions that they want to. Uh the the game system itself is pretty simple. Again just move around the rondelle use one of the basic abilities if you want to. You can use these more powerful abilities, but they will take you an extra turn because you spend a turn picking them up and then a future turn playing them. And those are normally really really good and much more powerful than the the basic abilities. But you even do have this um additional option to spend these envelopes that you can collect to do both those actions, which can be a good got you moment uh for your opponent. So this one again on paper is everything I like. It's very mechanically sound. kind of m runs like a welloiled machine. Very well put together um and realized uh production on a on the whole is is pretty decent. I mean it looks it looks relatively you know like a traditional Euro maybe pretty boring looking to some

players. I personally like the way it looks. Um there are some major um minor issues I'd say with some of the components especially when it comes to these law tracks. where you have these little kind of cardboard pieces where you're moving the little marker up and down. They kind of slide around easily on the board. Um, and they're not too they're a little bit too fiddly and chintzy. I think they could have been a bit more robust cuz you can quite easily lose your place on those lore tracks. So, I do like most things about this game. In fact, I kind of feel like I'm nitpicking on it because I can't actually put my thumb on why exactly the game or why I didn't love the game. So, I did like it a lot and I think it's going to be very popular and highly well reviewed, but the game did feel a little bit soulless to me. Um, and I didn't really connect with it, if that makes sense. I kind of felt like I was looking at the game from a from a bird's eye view and I could appreciate it, but I didn't really feel like I was not enjoying it, but I didn't really feel like this is a game I want to keep coming back to. It kind of felt like, yeah, I played it. I enjoyed how all the different parts mesh with each other, but I wasn't really invested in keep on coming back and seeing how the game what other things the game had to offer. Um, I think maybe a big part of that was because I have games like Seven Wonders Jewel in my collection. I think Seven Wonders Jewel has a slightly elevated fun factor as compared to Rival Cities.

But I do think if you like one, you'll like the other. And if there's room in your collection for for two games that are I'm not gonna say they're similar, but they do have some crossover, then you will probably um have space in your collection for both of them. And you you won't you won't regret having both of them in your collection. Now, I'm kind of at a spa a place now where I want a game in my collection or a single game in my collection for each occasion. And I think for my tense two-player tugof-war style game, I'm probably always going to choose seven jewel over this one. Hence why I probably won't be keeping hold of it. But if you do very regularly play all your games and you regularly hit the game game table with two players only, then this is a very credible choice for your collection and I think you're going to have a good time with it. Um, as well as making good decisions because there is a good degree of resource management. Um, knowing what to do at any time is highly important because again, you are always looking over your shoulder um about what your opponent could do and you don't want to be caught off guard and lose when you least expect it. So again, nice game. I think maybe it's not going to be to everyone's taste when it comes to the visual appeal. I think just because it's not like, you know, we're in this age now where everything's animal themed or nature themed and it has that cutesy feel. This one has a kind of more traditional early 2000s look to it. um which doesn't seem to be the you know the thing in trend at the moment. So that might work against it. But gameplay it is rock solid. That is rival cities

at number

Progress saved