Board Game Arena Awards for 2024 – Who REALLY Deserved to Win?!
Transcript
board game arena just held his 2025 games of the Year Awards these games were selected and voted on by users to be the best board games released on the platform in 2024 So today we're going to go over each category of the nominations to not only reveal who won and what those games are about but also who should have won games were rewarded bronze silver and gold in their respective categories but really this is just a fun way to discuss some games we might not talk a lot about on this channel so get ready to jump in the comment section and tell me how wrong I am and then challenge me to a game in BGA like an old timey duel to the board game death so we start today's competition with the best two-player game on board game arena released in 2024 the nominees are Splender duel altered pocket cats and battle spirit Saga and the winner went a Splender Duel By popular user vote okay first of all let's get this out of the way how battle spirits Saga made into this list just blows my mind like it's Dreadful I quickly went through the rules and played it a couple times it just felt like the most derivative card battler I've ever played also it's really ugly like it's super ugly the game went by way too quickly to do any proper planning and since the monsters were all attacking on the same turn they enter you can't really like formulate a response which only increased the luck of the cards I felt so let's remove that nomination entirely and instead replace it with the fox and the forest which is a much better two player game so instead we're going to start the match today with altered altered is a two-player trading card game in which each player
brings a deck led by a hero card in Altered you'll lead two Expeditions as they discover and explore the land now altered unlike Saga is a good trading card game and its nomination kind of makes sense it's sort of this game that sits between Magic and and lorana in complexity there's there's no direct attacking which which I don't like but there's a lot of opportunities for you know good clean passive aggressive fun since it's more of a race than it is a fight it uses a sort of Lane system like something you'd see in Star Wars or or Flesh and Blood I actually enjoyed this much more overboard game arena than I did in person primarily because BGA handles all the region totals for me it's a good game but I I don't think it deserves a medal for this year sorry alter I I know you trained hard for this but you you be better luck next year so instead for our first medalist we have fox in the forest my the entry that I put in there that nobody voted for Fox in the forest these players doing the typical trick-taking stuff but also using various characters to utilize their abilities you'll score points Point by winning more than your opponent but if you get too greedy and win too many tricks you'll be punished like the naughty Fox you are fox in the forest is a great trick tricking game that even I enjoy playing and I genuinely hate most trick-taking games I like that every card feels valuable and I love the odd number cards having these like cool abilities it made the decision space much more interesting and added a lot more depth to every card beyond their you know their respective numbers plus there are some wonderful opportunities to mess with your opponents and get into their head every time I gave K a win of
a trick when she who didn't want to win I was like just cackling like a like a just a joyous so it's just a solid card game and I'm happy I gave it a chance despite the hatred I have for the genre a well-deserved bronze so next we have a board game nobody is talking about because if you go to the board game geek page it's just it's empty we're just pocket cats pocket cats is a super light TI moving game we on your turn you flip a tile and then reform it's power and when you're attempting to do is to get your cats next to pray for points but dogs can take out your cats so be careful so in Pocket cats you get this like really fun little back and forth between you and your opponent where you're sort of like jockeying for position but also trying to negate your opponent's cats with with dogs because whatever they point to is what they negate it's fairly clever and I was surprised by how much I enjoyed playing it on BGA yes there is a lot of luck in this game but you can sort of navigate that luck by making sure you understand that the position of the tiles you flip May more important than what is actually underneath that tile the game is hitting much harder than what it has any right to to do given how Bloody light it is I encourage you all to check it out and just play a single round you can learn the game in like 2 minutes Baka cats deserves the second place silver now of course that leaves Splender duel Splender duel is a race to Victory where players draft gems from the Common Board and use the gems to purchase cards that will grant them bonuses Royal favors Prestige and even more gems full
disclosure I have never been a big fan of Splendor I bought it like everyone else when it was like crazy popular but the game the game always left me feeling a little bored and a little unfulfilled I I think Splender duel is a better version uh of Splendor and it may be simply because it adds a fun little spatial puzzle in the game since on your turn you can select three gems in a row to add to your collection and you get these like wonderful moments where I'm playing paying extra attention to my opponent and seeing what they want and then making sure I take it from them because again I'm a I'm a joyous also they added new ways to win the game which makes the entire experience a lot more enjoyable since it creates a bit more a bit more tension and adds versatility and strategy I don't know if this is one I want to own physically uh but I do enjoy playing on BGA I think this is a great choice for the best two-player game Splender duel takes the gold in a well-deserved fight now before we move on the next category we need to have a brief Ranch segment I've always hated how a lot of people classify two-player games it always seems to go to games that exclusively play two players but if I want to know the best two-player game right as a as a user I I don't care if it plays more than two players the best two-player games in our hobby are honestly the ones that just happen to play more than two players like like five tribes uh War of the ring uh castles of burgundy you know I can't be Lo this let me know in the comment section if you agree or disagree
with that because I want to make a list of the best two-player games and I want to know if I should be limiting it by the play range to be exclusively for two so let me know in the comment section Now we move on to the best casual game the nominees for this category are castle combo Captain flip Super Mega lucky box and flowers for the winner BGA users voted on castle combo so let's start with super mega Lucky Box super mega lucky box is a light-hearted bingo style card game where players flip numbered cards uh mark them on their boards and unlock exciting chain reactions of bonuses I I really I I just like this game so much so that I'd love to just boot it from the competition entirely but I don't want to do that twice in a row because it it it casts a negative light on the Integrity of this very sacred board game tournament super mega Lucky Box these players Crossing off numbers off their own personal cards based on revealed cards it was like this like really brain dead and boring version of Bingo but without the beautiful ambiance of like cigarette smoke and just depression lofting through the air I didn't really care for the added lightning bolts which let you change a card number despite the fact that they do provide something they they provide something to ponder over it felt like it felt like a party game without the actual party you know like because there was no interaction between players you know I didn't have fun with this in person at a buddy's house and it and it just played like crap when I played it on BGA so you don't get a medal so let's go to an actual game now oh I'll be a one that also is flame flowers in
flowers you select from Two Face up cards and what you're trying to do is make sure by end of game that you have you know four fours next to one another three threes Etc and you have five of a single color next to one another it's a it's a mildly clever game that plays very quickly flowers requires a lot of careful planning and Forward Thinking which I admit is enjoyable and if these sort of spatial puzzles interest you it's certainly worth checking out on BGA the worst part is that you're going to make mistakes and end up blocking a number before you completed it um but I but I suppose that's part of the fun as much as I'm not the biggest fan I I do see this as a worthy third place because I can see a lot of people having you know a quick little bit of fun with this between you know breaks or on a lunch break so you you get a bronze you absolutely get a bronze next we have Captain flip in Captain flip players take a tile from the bag and they decide if they want to play it as it is or flip it over to see what's on the other side they place the tile onto their board and then gain coins depending on the powers of the characters they played finish four columns and the game ends and who has the most coins is the winner Captain flip is a game it sounds strange but I'm not sure I want to own but I do love playing it on BGA because it just it plays so damn fast and it's filled with these like tiny little adrenaline hits and and moments of tension it's a really light and and really reward and gay with some great Pusher luck moments like when you have when you have two cannons and you know the third one will kill you uh but you're behind in points and so you take that risk and Flip It Anyway only to get another Cannon and then stop
playing for the day because your sanity D you just can't take it anymore and you're going to go back to work very angry and although it's a very low interaction game you are racing people sometimes to fulfill some columns and you are checking to see what they have it's miter interaction but at least it's something for something that's so quick all in all it's just really good silly fun and I think this is one that everyone has to play like right now I am not joking okay pause the video and and just go play a match if you haven't already okay you done now good did you like it because I think this is a well-deserved silver medalist and finally this of course leaves our Gold Medal winner castle combo in castle combo players draft cards to build a 3X3 Tableau to trigger instant effects and endgame bonuses all to get the most victory points by the end of the game Castle Cobble just took me by complete surprise like I knew nothing about it but I wanted to play every new game released on BGA for 2024 uh for my tier list video and after the first game of castle combo I just I fell in love I fell in love considering the ease of the game there is a good amount here to keep me invested on every single turn and more importantly aware of what my opponent is doing because there is this a good amount of interaction with people at the table in a roundabout way which I find fairly rare in these relatively simple card games hate drafting is so incredibly satisfying here and there is some great positioning possibilities to make your opponent sort of waste keys to get what they want cuz they can only draft from one of the two levels and so you just kind of make sure you put it on a level that they don't want it to be at
also there are really good variety of scoring methods which again for a simple card game it's impressive I love how each card has its own abilities that have to you kind of have to be aware of which also keeping in mind its scoring objectives and placement a and its Shield type and its cost there's a lot to follow that makes the game really engaging and interesting you know I think this is one that is punching well above its weight class so this to me is an easy Gold Medal winner well deserved Now we move on to what BGA refers to as regular games whatever whatever that means and hero nominations are harmonies cartographers Middle Ages and loot and users gave the win to harmonies now looking at these nominations for Best regular game I'm starting to think if maybe my view on a game's weight are are somewhat skewed because I view games like photographers and Middle Ages as relatively light and I'm assuming regular sort of means midweight but we'll stick to their system and not remove any of them because they're they're all they're all pretty decent games so first we have cartographers cartographers is a fliping right board game where players take on the role of map makers drawing terrain Types on a personal grid based on cards revealed each round while aiming to fulfill scoring objectives this is a game Kim really loves although honestly I think it's just the the drawing portion that she really likes it's a game where a bunch of people can all play at once drawing on their map uh a choice of shapes that the flip card reveals it's just sort of like cute little puzzle game that adds a bit of mean spite here and there through its monsters since you can draw in other people's kingdoms it's
going to mess them up it's certainly gimmicky but it's but it's fun for what it is I will say however uh that while we do enjoy this one and we own it it's not particularly a good game on BGA and I think a big part of that fun is it's drawing your personal fantasy map like physically drawing at least that's how I feel so sadly despite being a good game I I don't think photographers is going to make the cut this year next we have our first medalist Middle Ages in Middle Ages you are the head of a Thom in your future lands developing new prosperous buildings assaulting neighboring foms and just placing loads of tiles this game feels like really similar to King Domino but with some extra meanness tossed in which which I enjoy since you can attack the tiles of your opponents it's a very simple game with a good amount of interesting maneuvering for future turns that can leave you feeling pretty Satisfied by the end of the game I I think it deserves a well earned bronze uh it's a good little throwaway game to play when you don't have much time in your day for anything else I wouldn't call this a regular game but it is a good game so next we have the game that users sled to win harmonies harmonies is an abstract strategy game that sees players drafting a set of three discs at the start of their turn which they'll use to place on their board to complete various patterns required by anal cards they've drafted this is a game Kim and I really liked uh if you want our full review you can check it out on our channel for more information on the game it's just a really good abstract game that that really gets the brain burning and it's almost it's almost perfect playing on BGA because just so damn fast when you
play it virtually and given that there is almost no interaction anyway in the physical copy of the game you you don't really lose anything in this experience I think this is a well-deserved silver finally we have loot in loot players control a horde of Vikings raiding the mainland capturing buildings stealing the englishman's cute little sheep and just racking up as much riches as possible while getting your opponent's way at every turn till you crown yl of the Vikings it was really tough choosing between harmonies and loot because I really enjoy both of them like harmonies we have a full review of this game on our channel it's a fairly abstract game that sees you placing Vikings on a shared board to take control of tiles uh which you then place on your own personal board to surround Victory tiles uh that act as a sort of like contract that you have to fulfill but the most fun part of this game is finding ways to block your opponents off on that public board and take what they need and really just be a true true Viking or at least what I imagine to be a true Viking because knowing exactly when to use the three onetime powers in this game provides you is just it's a really fun tactical exercise where you're sort of agonizing whether you should use the double placement so soon even though you know it will snag you that much needed Tower but doing so will mean that you'll have no countermeasure for if your opponent attempts to block you from that castle tile you've been eyeing loot is a much deeper game that it lets on and I encourage everyone to check it out I think this is a really good Gold Medal winner our next C category is the best animal theme game yes that's right this category is very dumb and it does not interest me at all I'm not I'm not really sure why it's even here uh I
guess they just felt it was cute on a positive note though I am pleased that none of the nominations feature anthropomorphic animals this is a trend I am not enjoying in gaming and if you're a developer or you're a publisher and you're encouraging these obnoxious creatures just stop it just just stop it get some help the nominees for this category are cat and the mountain goats New York zoo and the wolves with the winner going to the wolves from the users so the big loser of the bunch in my opinion is mountain goats mountain goats is a quick and competitive dice rolling game where players race to climb mountain peaks control scoring spots and knock opponents down to secure the highest points if you haven't played it it's really similar to can't stop you're using dice combinations on your turn to move your goat up various numbered columns uh you have no way to mitigate these dice so you'll lose due to random luck most of the time anyway and when you roll multiple ones you can change the die results on all but one of the rolled ones which which always felt really really strong and really annoying when it wasn't you that was doing it I I hate this game despite the great opportunity for meanness the game provides where you can sort of like position yourself so that your opponent is stuck at the top of the columns as you're as you're sort of purposely and slowly crawling up and leaving them with like absolutely nothing to do in their turn um but if you're on the receiving in the of that though it really sucks but despite that no metal for you mountain goats go away so next is Cat in the Box cat the box is a mind-bending trick ticking game where players assign colors to their played cards in real time creating a shringer cat inspired
challenge a deduction and strategy so you get your cards discard one then try and predict how many tricks you'll win and the neat thing is that the person playing decides what color they have because all the cards themselves are black as I've mentioned I I hate trick kicking games for the most part uh Kim's family plays a few with a standard de cards and I I want to die by about the second or third hour of playing with them the norest them I love them it's just those trick taking games I don't remember what they're called but I hate them cat in the Box however it is clever though it provides a good amount of strategy and creativity for a genre that is kind of oversaturated um and that's that's a pretty good accomplishment it's not a game for me but it's worth checking out and I do think it deserves the bronze here The Animal theme competition this year I it's not it's not really Stellar sadly next we have New York Zoo New York zoo is a to placement in anual park building game where players strategically fit enclosures breed animals and optimize their Zoo layout to be the first to complete their board so this is yet another tile Lane game by Rosenberg I I'll say it again this is this is a really boring category because like cat in a box I I I don't I barely even like this game I know most board games are in fact a form of a puzzle um but typically a lot of of that is sort of hidden behind mechanics and theme but here that that that puzzle is just laid bare I just find this like Tetris style Pol nominal crap tedious most of the time
like especially when it's playing front and center in the game like it's just it's really boring and the replay value of this game especially a line where you'll go through a lot of games it's just really bad every game felt the same and there was there was it didn't feel like there was anything new to discover the spatial puzzle is certainly challenging it gets you thinking but but it's not an enjoyable process to me and the breeding portion of the game is pretty straightforward and obvious and doesn't seem to add depth that would be nice and what is otherwise a fairly simple game listen to me this is a this is a medalist I'm just trashing on the game uh a silver I guess I I told you I told you I don't like this category and I don't like most of the games in it finally we have the Wolves the Wolves is a Pack building area control game with players attempt to claim as much territory as possible recruiting low wolves to their pack hunting prey and just trying their best to De with the cards you have the Wolves is a is a pretty good Game it it's super easy to learn and it adds a good amount of strategy here and there you do have to think well ahead on any given term because maneuvering in this game is pretty much everything and that can be that can be an enjoyable process it also has a pretty good Pace to the game which is fitting and I like the player controlled ending because you're constantly thinking about you know if you should slow down or accelerate the game should you sprout out your pack or keep them concentrated and there's a lot of interaction here Beyond Simply Having more wolves surrounding an objective because you can take control of other people's wolves uh which is which is always fun when you do it because well it's just fun to be mean sometimes it's a pretty Dynamic game and I I think it
is well-deserving of the gold medal here even though I actually don't even love this game I I I kind of like it but not really as I said this is a really weak category so let's just leave this one behind and move on to my favorite category now we have the best expert games which are simply the heavier game section on board game arena and the nominees are Darwin's Journey age of innovation terraforming Mars and river of gold and users gave the win to Darwin's Journey so it's so strange to see terraforming marvs on this list but remember this is based on when the games were released on board game arena and not in general let's start with age of innovation because it feels like the weakest of the bunch despite it being a reimplementation of a great game teror mytica age of innovation is a deep and strategic civilization building game where players customize factions develop Technologies and expand influence across a modular map to achieve dominance I think Innovation is well behind Gaia project and of course teror mystica itself so it's it's it's going to get the runner-up prize it just adds a lot of things that I don't feel make the game any more strategic or the choices on any given turn any more entertaining or engaging the book resource adds a bit more options on a turn which is nice but I really miss the individual races I know the game adds the ability to sort of build your own race and Powers as you progress um but it's not as enjoyable yeah yeah this one to me is a bit of a flop so moving on to our first medalist we have Darwin's Journey which actually won Gold in the original BGA Awards which is which is wild I had no idea this game was so popular Darwin's journey is a strategic exploration and
Adventure game where players take on the role of naturalists conducting research Gathering specimens and advancing Darwin's theory of evolution while navigating the challenges of a scientific Expedition Darwin's Journey definitely feels like one of those like kitchen syn Euro games where you're just sort of bombarded with so many different mechanisms and it just it doesn't really start being enjoyable until the like the third or fourth play it's cuz the game is really combo heavy but you really need to know the game to get yourself in that position and when you are it does become a lot more fun actions are just like constantly chaining other actions which can also make downtime in this game sometimes just a complete drag I actually prefer this one virtually or physically because I I got to tell you watching a person perform a million like cascading actions on their turn after you just did like one little simple like pathetic thing well it's it's agonizing it's agonizing it's an interesting game though because although it feels like you're constantly being rewarded it's actually a very like tight restricting game where you're not going to be able to do everything you want and especially in the early mid game you are super tight on money to do all of the best actions it's just a lot of fun and and clever mechanisms here all sort of working together pretty damn nicely so definitely have a look at this year's bronze medalist next will be complete blasphemy for most people people but it's terraforming Mars terraforming Mars sees players working as corporations to develop and terraform Mars by managing resources building infrastructure and completing projects to increase the planet's habitability all while playing loads and loads of cards listen I I
really like terraforming Mars and all the games that reviewers told me were killing it like like Ark Nova did not did not indeed kill it and I I still own it and play it now and then uh but I have found a new love for it on BGA it's a really good implementation and it handles all the like those fiddly annoying bits pretty really well and it's so infinitely easier to see all your cards sort of laid out in front of you instead of messing around with them in your hand uh but the game itself I mean what more needs to be said about terraforming Mars it's a it's a really really good game with loads of depth fun Combos and variability between games but in my opinion it just couldn't be our next game which is River of gold I love River of gold on BGA I think it's so fun to play virtually in river of gold players use their boat to travel down the river performing various actions such as developing New Ports markets and various other buildings as well as doing their best to grow their wealth and visit nobility all an effort to get as many points as possible there is a good amount of player interaction in how you're able to use other people's buildings it reminds me sort of of Kus both in movement and in Shar building use although this is a much nicer version because Kus is insanely Savage there is also a good amount of varying mechanics here that all sort of work well together to create a fairly relaxed and enjoyable experience that isn't that isn't so simple that it's boring but not too convoluted that it's sort of jarring and overwhelming theor control is pleasurable instead of tedious and you're still rewarded for moving up those influence tracks regardless of whether or not you're in the lead at the end of the game which is nice it's just
a really good game that I would actually classify more as casual than expert but I didn't make the nominations of the categories so riveral gold I think takes the gold and those are this year's true winners of the board game arena Awards BGA is an amazing platform that I'm sure all of you already playing on endlessly and then like myself you probably have like dozens of turn-based games on the go at any given time so that's all for this video let me know in the comments section what you agree with or disagree with or whatever your favorite game is to play on BGA and general I'll see you in the next video bye I