Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 7:23

I'm Adam in Wales and this is Bard game Wales recommends and today we're looking at a tile placement game first I want you to imagine that you're playing caras on that Classic Tile laying game but instead of having a communal grid of tiles you have your own personal grid your own personal Tableau and you're connecting up those roads and those fields and those cities and then at the end of the game you score your points and see who did the best it sounds dull doesn't it it really does but not so because most games that use this mechanism this personal Tableau of tile laying what they do is have a great Central sort of mechanism for How We Gather those tiles and so it is in games like Glen Mo uh and games like quadropolis so the players do have their personal Tableau uh but but we have a great mechanism M there for How We Gather the tiles now this game that we're looking at today Isle of sky from Lookout Spiel or Mayfair games has one of the best mechanisms for doing that that I've seen in is of Sky each player is Chieftain ruling over a small area of territory on the Scottish Island throughout the game players Place tiles into their own personal interconnected grid and score points by fulfilling objectives the scoring criteria are variable so in one game you might score for the shape of your grid of tiles or another game you might be gathering sheep or ships or trying to enclose areas of mountain or water or fields in any single game there

are four scoring criteria in play the first phase of each round sees players gather income based on the number of whiskey barrels on their landscape the second phase involves each player drawing three tiles from a bag and assigning prices to two of the tiles and discarding the third they need to be careful when ass signing the prices because if other players don't buy the tile then they're going to have to buy it them themselves the next phase sees players select a tile to purchase from one of their opponents and then they add it to their own landscape finally the tiles are scored at the end of each round according to the variable scoring criteria and after a set number of rounds the player with the most points wins now that tile pricing sort of mechanism that I mentioned in the in the overview there um it works brilliantly it's it's really it's a really difficult decision how much is this tile Worth to me how much is this tole worth to the other players if I price it too high then they're not going to buy it and I'm going to have to end up spending the money on it how much can I afford to spend on it it works fantastically and you can see that the whole game has been built around this one thing but when you throw in those variable scoring conditions as well now we have a load of replay value and every turn every round of the game different scoring criteria apply so they don't all apply in every round which means you've got to constantly change your strategies not to mention there is a significant and visible catchup mechanism in this game the players who are trailing get a big leg up particularly in the later stages

of the game as they gather more and more income they're given more income just for being behind now lots of players will throw the hands up and say well that's outrageous why are we rewarding players for doing badly why are we punishing the leaders but what it actually does is gives you uh an an additional strategy if you know that from the outset then you need to be aware that just because you've got a a good run ahead at the beginning doesn't mean that you're going to win the game and in fact you need to focus on the later scoring opportunities not the early ones um that said if you don't like catchup mechanisms this is one of the most visible catch-up mechanisms that I've seen in a game you're not going to like this game if you don't like those sort of things and if you feel that the leader should be rewarded and that the other people should just get on and accept their losses um you're not going to like is of sky in that case personally I've seen everyone enjoy that it's nice to see people coming back later in the game it's nice to see the tight finishes the close games and and the sort of frustration as the as the winner faces that sort of that that that headwind as they as they're not quite making the same progress that the other players are because they're in the lead um so it's a game where you might even want to hang back a little bit like in power grid I've made a whole video about this recently about catch up mechanisms so go and have a look at that in fact I've also made a video about tile laying games so you could have a look at that one as well um I mentioned previously the game Glen Moore now Glen Moore is a game that has exactly the same theme I mean exactly the same right down to the whiskey barrels on the tiles but Glen

Moore doesn't have the beautiful Clemens France artwork Clemens France is the illustrator who did Agricola and many many other games I've placed a lot of them behind me on the on the shelves here so that you can see um and is of Sky really uh captures that feel as well albeit the images here are much smaller than in many of his games you have to sort of re really have a close look to see those little cows and sheep and lighthouses and what have you but they're done in his style and so it fits very well into that family and has that atmosphere of Countryside and farming which feature in so many of his games that said I call it an atmosphere because there is no story here there is no theme I mean no theme it makes no sense what we're doing here why are we paying for these tiles who are we paying why do I receive income for them why do I set the value for them what do these Scar and criteria mean why why am I scoring points for this and that you have to ignore all of that and get into the mechanisms and the puzzle of it all and just let the atmosphere sort of wash over you but don't look for story here you won't find any this is a simple game okay it won the kenis field as yarz which is the game for uh connoisseurs The Gamers Choice um and it is a step up from things like um caraz on uh and and and the like but but not a big step a good next step I would say um so this is by no means complex it's not going to take you a long time to play although there is room for a little bit of analysis paralysis with uh more players a lot of that is simultaneous though

when we're setting the values of our tiles um people are doing that simultaneously but when also also when choosing to purchase tiles you might find that players spend a long time looking around at all the other tiles that players have laid out particularly in a four or five player game so it might be a game that's better played at three players Maybe four the two-player game works very well actually um I was quite impressed with the two-player game so all in all I thought it was a worthy winner of the kenis speld as yarz I think it's well worth anyone picking up it's a nice package it's nicely produced the components are good the artworks lovely and the mechanics are ingenious um if Glenn Moore I think Glen Moore is Du a Revival at some point um if it comes back with beautiful Graphics like this then the two of them will sit comfortably alongside each other as two of the best TI laying games around and they just happen to have exactly the same theme so uh that's Isle of Sky by Lookout games and Mayfair I'm Adam in Wales thank you very much for watching my video if you want to subscribe to my channel it's board game Wales Adams board game Wales or you can follow me on Twitter at boardgame Wales on Board Game Geek I'm adam78 thanks very much for watching all the best

Progress saved