Isla Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everyone today I'm taking a look at ISA which is a one to four player role and right Style game that according to the Box takes 45 to 60 Minutes to play but from my experience it is actually uh quicker than that now before I get started this is a prototype copy of the game so of course all the components here are not final and this game will be coming up on Kickstarter I believe in February um but before I get started on my review of Isa I want to give a shout out to the show sponsor ker.com retailer and if you use the link in my show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order okay so Isa is going to look like this when it is set up where each player will have their own um player sheet which you can see is made up of all these different terrain types as well as these tokens which have been randomly distributed on the map and placed on these kind of highlighted spaces here uh you have your own explorer that starts in the bottom left hand corner of the board where your little boat is as well as these dice exhaustion tokens which is kind of one of the key elements uh to the game you have five different dice here that come in the different um in the different denominations from a a D4 all the way up to a d10 um I believe as well as a couple of decks of cards where you have these kind of um research cards where you're trying to cash in the relevant tokens which are distributed on your map for the relevant amount of points so you
can see here that if I cashed in one of these Leaf cards a parrot card and a skull card then I would get 11 points at the end of the game you also have a big deck of these threat cards that can come into play so before we get into the mechanisms let's take a look at how the game actually scores and of course the player with the most points here will be uh the winner so first off if you are the first player to get out of the island by escaping through this top right hand corner here then you'll get a bonus five points and if you're second place you'll get three points you'll get any points based on the research cards you collect throughout the game you'll get any points based on the threat cards that you collect throughout the game and they can be positive or negative and we'll take a look at some of those cards later any unused dice points so as I said if any of these um tokens remain um kind of unexhausted at the end of the game you'll get the points that's depicted on those exact tiles the Escape Track where if you kind of push beyond that Escape Route any kind of over spill will start generating you points all the way to a maximum of 10 and finally you will lose points based on every unexplored space on the map so ideally you want to be covering as much of the map as you can or you really start racking up those negative points so how does the game actually work so first off each player is going to decide what they want to do for the round and you have one of three options the first of which is to actually explore for um the map which is what you'll be doing more than
often the second of which is again researching one of these cards or the third of which is to use the rest action which you have one option to do that throughout the game or another one should you collect this bonus rest token and if you take that rest action you are going to unexhausted dice token um on your player sheet um again the research it um action is going to let you buy one of these and of course the explore action will let you Traverse the board so once each player has chosen which action they wish to take then you are going to as the first player roll the five dice like so and if you roll a one so let's just say I rolled um a one here and doesn't matter how many you roll as long as you roll at least one you are going to reveal and collect the top threat um card from that deck and put it onto your little um little next to your board essentially or next to your sheet and you can see here this one has given me a bit of a challenge that says you add these victory points in these six victory points at the end of the game if you have explored all of the beach spaces so this is going to be a bit of an objective for me to go around and visit all of these Beach spaces scattered amongst the map and some of these cards again are challenges like that some of them are punishments like this one here says you know you got minus one movement this turn um as duplicates there and so on again we'll talk about some of these a bit later you you've got some quite nasty ones like this out of breath card this says you exhaust your triangle
die okay so let's um assume I've taken the explore action and I've already resolved any threats I rolled um I am going to choose one of these dice that have been rolled so in this in this example I'm going to choose this green four just to show you how one of the mechanisms works so because I've rolled a four I'm going to and I chose the green Dy first of all I'm going to exhaust my green Dy token like so meaning that I cannot choose that die again until this is unexhausted and the way you unexhausted um the dice tokens is by passing through or touching one of the matching dice symbols on the map here so because I moved four I could go 1 2 3 4 and because I've touched again this triangle I'm going to un exhaust that die token meaning that I can use it again in the future and of course I would be actually marking this on my player sheet showing the direction I've moved like so just to recall which um which direction I've moved and so on because you can never Backtrack on yourself or pass through an area that you've already explored and that's essentially how the game works as you can imagine you trying to um Traverse the board as much as you can by keeping your dice tokens unexhausted so you can keep moving and have more options you're trying to collect the tokens you're trying to take research actions in order to cash in for these contracts you're trying to overcome the threats you're getting um and so on and of course
you're going to keep on going until you've exited the island getting those extra points by being there first as well as um traveling further down this track and um of course trying to avoid getting trapped on the island because if you run out of these dice tokens by having them all exhausted and even using your rest action then um your game is going to be pretty much over and you're going to be um just stuck on the island and have to settle with the points um you already have and that is how how Isa works so let's take a look at a few more of these threat cards just to give you an idea about what's in that deck so you have this rushed cards here that says you get minus um two points but if you discard the threat if another player escapes the island so um you know that's a bit of a gamble that one you're going to get minus two points um but there's a good chance you'll lose those or not have to suffer those minus two points as long as somebody else escapes you got the hallucination cards here that says the opponent to your left will choose which die you use this turn and as you can imagine they're going to want to you force you to use a very inefficient dice uh you got the poisoned one here that says you get minus three movement the wasted effort card you get minus one point per unused species token um at the end of the game so you want to be making sure that you cash in those species tokens for these um research contracts the deja vu this says you play this card um next to the dice B on the next round the dice are not rerolled so you're stuck with the original role and the sprain one here that says you exhaust your Square die um and then discard this
card okay so let's share some thoughts on Isa and for me kind of the biggest thing about this game that I liked the most was this dice exhaustion um system here I think this is a really novel idea and it's quite cool after seeing so many rooll and right style games a concept that I personally haven't seen before I can't say for sure if it's been done before or not but I haven't seen it um on a personal level and it actually adds a a a cool system to the game where you're trying to keep on ticking along as much as you can knowing when to reach further to collect one of these tokens maybe as well as keeping all you know as many of your dice um unexhausted because you know before you know it if you do not bear this in mind your tokens to get quickly um exhausted and you're going to leave yourself out of options so you always want to be making sure you reach that next checkpoint and think ahead and even kind of un exhaust several tokens at once once you start using these higher um rolls you know if you get used as 12 like this um then you can imagine you can travel the board quite a lot but to refresh that particular um die the refresh tokens are right towards the exit therefore you're not going to be able to keep on using that one again and again so it's quite nice how it spreads from the you know the D4 to the D6 to the d8 um and so on so it's really nice kind of a pacing to the game when it kind of almost lures you to um reach further at times and take a gamble on whether you go to roll a high number the next time to reach that next check checkpoint the remainder of the game is fairly simple stuff you know you got some simple contract and fulfillment
here collecting these tokens and cashing them in um against these contracts but there is somewhat of a sense of urgency if you and your opponents are looking for the same things um and I think they seem to be weighted pretty accurately you know the some of the tokens are quite common you got four of these but you've only got you know two of these therefore the um the contracts with these on are worth more points you know naturally um and there's some extra touches that I did appreciate like for example I do like the idea of when you over spill to escape um you start generating more points that's a mechanism I generally like in games um you know when you are rewarded um for your overcompensation um as well as you know that that push and pull of wanting to stay on the map to explore as much as possible but getting some bonus points by escaping um the board now a part of the game I do not feel is going to be for everybody is the way that these threat cards are balanced as way as well as the way they are resoled because you know as the first player if you roll a one on any of these five dice which is quite likely then you're going to have to take and resolve one of these cards and they do range from pretty benign to pretty um awful in terms of how punishing uh they are because you know if you leave yourself um say with completely relying on one of these dice exhaustion tokens and then you just by bad luck draw a card that exhausts that particular token then that could be you completely out of the game if you not have if you have not used um your rest token so they can be pretty punishing some of them I think are actually quite cool like I actually like this sunnday
the one that says you know you add these victory points if you explore all of a certain region or a certain terrain type and by the end of the game because that kind of gives you this this Devil's temptation of you know do I really Gamble and try to go through all those Beach spaces knowing that going for them is going to potentially you leave me with not enough fuel in my tank to uh to keep going and reach these new dice spots so I actually think more cars like this would have been a better idea and I think there could have been a a less random way to resolve getting the threats because know just by sheare good luck or bad luck you can keep on avoiding these threats or you can um get hit by one every single time um which can definitely be a Difference Maker in who wins or loses the game through again no fault of your own I also feel the game could have benefited from a bit more streamlining when it comes to which action you choose because again the rules state that kind of before the round even begins you choose whether you want to explore by again moving around your board whether you want to rest up or whether you want to research and take one of these cards and I kind of understand why they've done it because that's happens before you roll the dice so if you commit to taking a contract and then the dice are rolled and they're all great numbers you might think ah maybe I should have taken that Gamble and explore so I understand what they're going for there but I think the game gamep playay experience would have been enhanced if every round you just roll the dice and then if you want to you can rest um then you do everybody does the
explore action and then in player order should you wish to you can cash in your tokens again everybody's on the same same level then everyone singing from the same Hy sheet rather than people doing different phases at different times because it's not like it makes a huge difference because you're going to have to factor in turn order anyway and turn order is past in the standard order by going from you know player to your left so um it kind of seems like it's over convoluted the turn system more than it needed to be whereas they could have just kept it very standardized and have just made everybody do the same thing the player interaction is somewhat of a mixed bag yes you do have the competition of um you know fighting for the contracts um and some of the um threats do interact with the other players in a little bit of a take that way nothing major um I suppose the biggest issue I have is is that there is a somewhat pseudo player elimination thing going on here um because if your opponent runs out of steam and um you don't then they're going to have to just sit there and watch you play out the remainder of your game which kind of seems pointless if you know you've already beaten your opponent because they're probably going to have so many unexplored places and that's so many negative points so you know the incentive to continue once your opponents have been elimination is pretty much non-existent which is a bit of a shame I also feel the replayability could be a bit of an issue um with this game because again I'm not sure if this is going to be with a final copy but the Prototype that I've been given is all of the same sheet there's no variability
but I do feel like this game actually has a lot of potential through this system to create a ton of different maps and even using that core system to add little wrinkles and little tricks and bells and whistles into that system by you know creating additional mechanisms which certainly isn't going to be too much of a rules overhaul so yeah I think the actual system itself is nice and pure and can lend itself to lots of replayability but if this is what you're getting in the final box which I doubt it will be um it's not going to be quite enough to keep you coming back and also feel the time investment is actually quite good with this game now I'm not quite sure why the box says 45 to 60 minutes again this is a prototype version so please take that with a grain of salt um but yeah this you can get it played in 20 to 30 minutes which is quite a nice little time investment um should you get a good you know a good game out of it so yeah I think this investment is pretty pretty good and what you'd expect with a roll and right Style game okay so let's share some final thoughts on Isa and again I want to stress this is a prototype copy um of the game there could be huge differences between this and what the final product is um so yeah please do bear that in mind but I think the game system here is a lot of fun and I do love this dice exhaustion system of trying to reach that next checkpoint to refresh your dice just so you can continue a little bit more check a few more boxes off and reach for that next contract and it even has this little pushy luck thing going on at times because you do not know what you're going to be able to move you might leave yourself with one of the High um die available still unexhausted
but if you roll a low value you're still only moving one space so you're always kind of um you know gambling on how far you can travel and if you're going to reach out that next checkpoint I do like how some of the little things have been considered here you know that over spill I really like the a refresh token I like um you know very simple contract fulfillment stuff which is never going to be a bad thing you know simple stuff and again the urgency to reach those tokens before your opponents get to them I'm not quite sure why the deck's so big because you could have just done a a standardized bunch of different ones and make people reach for them rather than doing this kind of refresh system um but that's very very nitpicky um again the the threat system I think is a little bit too swingy for my taste because again you can get absolutely battered by this through no fault of your own or you can get completely scot-free and not have to worry about it at all so again I think that's a little bit too lucky and people should get the same kind of set amount or they should affect all players or something like that just to make sure that nobody's going to get rubbed the wrong way yes it is a light and silly roll and right game and but I think some people aren't going to like that just just at face value really but you know for for the time investment it's it's a nice rolling right I don't think it's up there with the best of them but I think if you like games like maybe something like the trails of tuana um this is something that's somewhat in the same vein and you're going to get somewhat um similar feelings um and an experience out of it so yeah it's a it's a pleasant game and you do have to weigh up quite a lot there know different decisions you need to weigh up here you know how far do you want to jump past the the exit
how many spaces are you leaving um kind of ticked off or exposed to start generating you those negative points um and so on so if it appeals to you be sure to check out the um the kickstarter campaign I'm coming up for Isa