Skip to main content
Loading video...

Boonlake Review - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 22:49

hey everybody today i'm talking about boone lake which is a board game designed by alexander fister and published by dlp games this one takes around 90 to 120 minutes to play and accommodates one to four players so this is a pretty involved euro strategy game which you might expect from a designer like alexander vista who's known for making games such as a great western trail maracaibo a cloud age blackout hong kong a lot of very successful games and i'll say probably weight wise at least you know in terms of its complexity this is probably comparable to a game like great western trail but let's get on and show you how boon lake plays so the board in boone lake is going to look like this where you've basically got this map made up of all these hexes and divided into four separate towns so you've got at the top here you've got this unknown town you've got boone lake down here then you've got southern down here and then you've got new hope down here and the idea of this game is that we're trying to basically develop these different regions by placing these tiles um kind of putting settlers there developing them into houses and then settlements etc trying to get points in the process i'm at the bottom of the board here you've got these different objective strips which you're trying to achieve throughout the game so the game is fundamentally broken into four rounds two of those rounds being intermittent ones and then the kind of halfway point and then the final point up here and whenever your boat which starts at the top of the lake here crosses pass past one of these thresholds here then you're going to go into a scoring and you're going to get points depending on the things you've done in your current board situation but also when you pass

those scoring points you're going to have a look at one of these objectives here and try to see if you've achieved it or not so in the first round you want to be reaching this first point here the second round here here and here but you can only ever score one of these tiles once so you're going to be scoring them all but at all different points in the game now each player is also going to have their own personal play ball that looks like this and we have a bunch of these again these kind of people here you've got your houses you've got your settlements and you've got your cows and as you're placing these onto the board you're kind of uh unlocking different bonuses and things you can get throughout the game such as getting points when it comes to scoring money and all that good stuff to the right of your board here you've got these different lever areas which will give you bonuses when you choose to use them but you have to invest in doing them first and when you do that you're going to be putting one of these different things on it that look like this and then when you want to use that particular ability you can slide it down and take that benefit and they'll refresh in the intermittent scoring phase and this part up here on the board is your basically your resource management area and as you can see all these different points here are related to a different resource you've got your words you've got your your stone etc um and depending on where your boats are your little kind of canoe things here um it's going to be showing which resources you currently have so you don't actually collect the resources in this game you are kind of working on which resources you have based on where your boats are so at the moment i'm saying i had it like this i've got one word because i'm here and i've got two of whatever this resource is because i've got one here and one for this additional symbol here and as the game goes on you can choose to kind of upgrade these and get maybe two of those

and get all the different types of resources as well you're going to have a bunch of tiles and cars that are going to come into play throughout the game and you've got all your normal resources here such as your money you've got those lever doors which i remember which i mentioned earlier and you've got these vases as well which are kind of a rare resource additionally um as you might expect for the fist again this is very card driven you're going to have cards that you can get in your hand and play throughout the game to not only get victory points but to get ongoing engine building benefits and the anatomy is going to look like this where you've got your benefit of the um of the card here which can either be ongoing it could be immediate or it could be at the end of the game based on these symbols here and these are the resources you need to build that card you know three money one word and two whatever that resource is again so if i did mention before the idea of this game is to try and get as many victory points as you can and the way you're going to do that is by taking actions based on this little board here and with these action strips on these different areas and the higher you up are on on this little track here means your boat is going to move up to more spaces so you can see here if i took this particular action strip i'm related to four here which means i can move up to four spaces down this um this lake track and potentially land on these different bonus spots getting me more cards more money i'm kind of um with these vases newer these different settlers here more resources um kind of opportunities etc so that's what you're trying to do in terms of going down the go down the lake and as i said when you cross these points then you're going to go to intermediate scoring um but also you can see here that all

these different strips have different actions associated to them and also have different kind of um different seasons associated to them as well so some of them are very simple like this which means that when you take this action you're going to get money and you're going to get to play a card or draw two cards but you can also see here on the right hand side of these strips that you might have these symbols that look like this which means all the other players and yourself included will get to take a follow-up action such as again drawing either playing a card or discarding a card for two coins and this applies to all the different areas here as well so you can see here this one here says you can play one of these different um different fill tiles that look like this onto the board um and then everybody else can either play a cow or play or discard a card and that's basically how the game is going to work he's going to keep taking these strips you're going to resolve the action you're going to take that strip and move it to the bottom of the row and then slide everything back up meaning that if you want to take these actions again you know to kind of deter people taking the same action they're going to actually end up losing points you want to be waiting until go to the top to not only not suffer those penalties but also being able to have more kind of flexibility on where you want to move down the lake now you can also see on the majority of these strips here you've got this first symbol here which relates to playing cards and this is important because you can only ever play cards if you take um the matching card types action strip so you can see here that this card this some cattle supplies is one of these daylight cards here which means that i'd have to take one of these light

blue strips in order to play it because again i think whenever you take one of these strips you have the option to either discard a card of the matching type for two coins you know if you don't want to play that card or play that card of course paying the resources and then getting the benefits and they let you do lots of cool things such as climb down these tracks um which you can see in the top left-hand side of the board here the um you've got this track here when you go further down you're taking more income when it comes to scoring phases or drawing more cards when it comes to scoring phases and you've got ones like this where you when you reach certain points on the lake you get kind of money or it's from here where you can discard cards to get more of your settlers which are quite you know quite a difficult resource to manage and this one here lets you kind of move down the card track or get points in lots of different ways at the end of the game managing those resources to play those cars is quite difficult in the first place because you have this kind of river system where if you um if you want a certain amount of resources then you can obviously play them based on where your canoes are and you can also move them down as you see fit so you know if i needed two of these and one of these then that's fine but if i wanted to start going back to wood then i actually have to start paying money to move my canoes back up the river so this symbol here means that you get to play tiles from the stack here and you're going to draw as many as the number there and you're going to start placing these wherever you see fit and obviously connecting to existing regions so if i want to play it here like this then i would get those two coins that i'm covering up and these will give more opportunities to for people to build on and you can do that as you see fair again crossing crossing the bridges if you need to and again taking those bonuses so very simple stuff

this one here means that you can either place one of your settlers onto one of these building spots either taking the bonus on these earlier tiles or even starting to pay money to get other bonuses um in order to you know in order to do that but when you do that you're going to put them on one of these spots here some of them have just one icon on them some of them have two building sites and that's basically it claiming that claiming that tile for yourself uh the when you see this hour going up the arrow going up like this it means you actually get to upgrade that particular um wooden piece to another one so for example the settlers will upgrade to a house like this and when you do that you're going to have to discard another settler from your player board so again managing those settlers is quite difficult um additionally when you um when you really want to you can upgrade these these houses into these settlements that look like this um by discarding two of those settlers but when you do that you need to have at least um i think it's three other um three other what they call like um i don't know what the terminology is the three other pieces surrounding it um basically to show that that's built up so because this has got a cow another settler and a house surrounding that that settlement then i'm actually allowed to do that but if i didn't i couldn't do that and as you can see whenever you're building anything from your play board you start to unlock income like there's these two coins and start to unlock points as well when it comes to scoring phases this symbol here means that you can play

one of these field tiles just as you would a normal tile again placing it next to another uh another tile existing on the board and getting the bonus and then you can see here you've got this cowl symbol which you can choose to place cows onto the board and based on how many cows are on that field is the resources you're going to pay for it so if i had an empty field like this it's going to be very simple you're going to pay are you going to discard just one of these um one of these settlers but the more cows you build on the same field let's say i did this you're going to have to start keep discarding more and more of those settlers to make it more and more expensive so that's very simple these cows are a good really good way of scoring because they end up scoring points each scoring phase depending on how many settlements they are next to additionally when you build these cows and they're next to houses then you actually get two coins for each house you're next to and i'm only using one player piece here but normally everything works for no matter whose player piece is on the board so it's a very interactive game this this um strip here basically means that you can choose to cover up one of these um town bonuses and get it so that will get you for money this one gets you three points this one gets you cards and this one gets you uh where is it this one gets you more money um and then basically every other region because it's going to get covered up every other region is going to score you i think it's a coin for each of these different wooden pieces that are on the board of your color and that happens to all the other players as well this one here can just let you upgrade or place new settlers on the board this one here is where you choose to build these um these levers

and when you do that you're gonna basically pay the fee that's on the board here and put it on that matching spot so let's say i i covered up this one here by paying that five that means whenever i want almost as a free action i get to use that benefit from that particular lever as i mentioned earlier each time you take one of these action strips you're going to start moving your boat down the lake here and when you cross these points on the board these kind of blue barriers then you're going to go into a scoring which is going to follow this little phase here where you can play up to two cards or upgrade and any kind of combination of those you're going to claim one of those objectives if you can which are down here again get cows down um how many how many levers you've got i mean your kind of places on the track i'm trading in resources for additional points and there's a whole ton of variation depending on the you know setup you want to choose um then you're going to take your income based on the tracks here again getting more money or even points as you go on and of course the income from your individual player board here and also you can see when you start building things and creating these strips you can unlock more of these um settlers and potentially start getting victory points depending on how how low you get um on your own resource board um after that you're gonna start getting victory points based on how many um levers you haven't pulled so again the more you don't use those those levers you're going to start getting points and then all the different regions are going to be set to be able to take that action again okay so let's start by sharing my thoughts on some of the key concepts of the game so let's start with the action

strip mechanism and i'm going to come out straight away and say this is absolutely fantastic so very recently i reviewed a game called arc nova which is another pretty heavy involved euro strategy game and i praised that game so much because it managed to almost engross a very involved game complex game but into a very simple core kind of user interface and system to operate that game this one does something very similar to that where you know at the end of the day at the end of the day all you're doing is taking one of these action strips and resolving it and then pushing them back together and when you do that yeah they're going to be obviously i have an umbrella of actions that come under that such as playing the cards and taking the follow-up actions but all the actions in their own right are very simple you know place tiles down on the board and expand the the towns and either place or upgrade your your settlers draw cards play cards play cows all that kind of simple stuff maybe even upgrade your player board and i personally didn't ever find any confusion in what what the symbology did what the kind of fallout of these actions were there really wasn't anything totally hidden in my opinion and it was all pretty um apparent what you had to do and the best thing to do at face value so i thought that was really well implemented and i love this idea of you're incentivized to wait for it to come back to the top because then you've got more flexibility on where you can go down the lake because you might want a cash injection you might want more cards you might want one of these vases and more importantly you might want some of these resources to start playing more juicy cards in the first place so yeah i thought that was really well done and i also like the tension

here on the on the lake which i didn't cover before where some people might really want say a settler here you're on that spot but you can't actually share a spot with somebody else unless they're one of these wider ones here so that again that's got that kind of passive player interaction where you're blocking spots and covering up the um the late positions and how far you want to go and like this like most vista games this one or at least the more involved this game this the pace of this game is dictated by the players so with something like great western trail maracaibo they have very similar concepts where again you can kind of travel down it's almost like a rondelle or a path and when you reach certain points in that path then things are going to trigger you're going to trigger scoring etcetera and this one uses that same thing and you've got to be very careful on how you use that because you might want to jump forward and get a particular bonus but you might not be ready for that scoring to activate yet and i like the way that that kind of embeds tension into the game because you might think you know my opponent is going slow down at the lake therefore i can afford to go slow as well and maybe we'll get more turns but then all of a sudden your opponent takes one of the top strips and then they're going past that score and when you weren't quite ready to do it and you weren't quite ready to fulfill one of these objectives another concept of this game that i absolutely adore is the actual resource management system so i i can't actually recall any game using this before normally you just go to a sport or do something and actually collect physical resources and spend them when you want this one is a very temporary thing and you can only get resources based on your current position and that's really cool and particularly you know when you want to take a sound action um you also got kind of further restrictions what you can play at any time anyway and you might need to

you know i might need one of these in one of these um and that means i'm gonna have to go down here and maybe go down here and get this card played but then in order to play a future card i might have to spend that money to move my boat right back up to the wood which is gonna be very expensive so it kind of adds this kind of string of strategy into the game where you want to be playing these cards in a certain order to be more efficient and not waste money in order to move your boat back up and maybe potentially get this unlocked here so that you can you flick that switch and move your boat right back to the uh the start without paying anything at all and on top of that the cards themselves are really interesting and worth having you know not only for the victory points because obviously victory points is the aim of the game but for what they actually do so you can see things like this you know when your levers you all your leaves are going to be too cheap throughout the game so if you get that one played early it's going to be fantastic or instantly refresh one of your levers to use it again and exploit that so yeah there's a lot to be had here a lot to and sink your teeth into create really cool engines and just a nice tableau of cars that's going to help you um throughout the game and on top of everything we covered of course you've got the actual current board state that you need to manage as well and this is where all the interaction comes into the game in quite an interesting and dynamic way because of course you want to create more coverage on the board because you want these really cool bonuses from under these hexes which are all really worth having but additionally when you do something you're kind of always creating opportunities for other players because you might have really good tiles that you lay down that other people can build on first and get really cool

bonuses such as going climbing tracks getting money getting cars all that good stuff but additionally you want to be putting houses down because houses start generating your income but when you put houses down people might start about it building fields and they're putting cows on those fields because they're gonna get money for doing so and then building settlements because they're gonna get points for the cows next to settlements but you wanna do you wanna definitely get your settlements down because settlements is going to be your what are your main ways to generate points and it might even be one of the objectives you're working towards so again whatever you do in this game there's some kind of give and take and i love the way that interacts with it you know with each other it's nothing you know blazing or in your face it's just about kind of who's who's going to get the net gain out of this and the game does a really good job of kind of enticing you to do things so from a mechanical standpoint and from the actual decisions you get to make in the game there's really not much i can criticize this about this at all i love the way everything works together in a very well blended fashion um one of the big issues of the game that were potential big issues of the game is how long the game can take so i said at the beginning this takes 90 to 120 minutes to play and i think that's right if you're playing with two or three players who are pretty seasoned and don't really suffer from analysis paralysis or anything like that i think if you're starting to reach that four player account or maybe have three players who aren't used to playing games with this weight then you are probably looking to that two to maybe three hour time frame which is sometimes venturing into that kind of no-go area which people just don't like to spend that much time playing one game which is perfectly acceptable but i definitely do think that once you've got your head around this pretty

simple system and how everything works together then i don't think it's alien to say that you could easily get this done in two hours every time you play it additionally the game does a great job of keeping players engaged throughout the game because when people take actions you pretty much always get some kind of full up action which will keep all the players engaged at all times and really mitigate that idea of just being sat out and twiddling your thumbs while other people take their turns the replayability of boom lake is also pretty excellent i mean you've got a ton of cars here that you can play with and of course you're not going to go through all those each game to create new synergies new combos et cetera and we've got a bunch of these different tiles that are going to be different each time that come out um you've got the actual different objectives as well if you've got a whole bag here of different objectives you can play with so again that modularity and the variability of the game is going to feel fresh each time you play it from a production standpoint the game is wonderfully produced um all the components are high quality you know we've got your traditional wooden euro pieces that look great nice chunky boats and stuff the actual meeples look great um all a lot of the pieces are kind of dual layered so you've got this action strip board here where things aren't going to slide around and the personal player balls are excellent i love the way these work everything sits together in place and brilliantly cardboard stock is a wonderful i got no issues at all with iconography i didn't even have to look once i'm in the rulebook to see what anything does it's all very obvious and generally it's a very pleasant looking game you know i like this nature theme or the nature visuals um but i would say there's a little bit of

a disconnect with some of the card art and i suppose the theme in general i mean i'm not a themed man but it just feels a bit weird that you've got this nice nature theme and all of a sudden you've got these like metal buildings that just seem a bit out of place and i think this is a bit of a waste opportunity really because for me fista is really known for his gritty um cool themes you know you've got great great games like mombasa even like great western trail and maracaiba they've got edgy cool themes about pirates and you know colonizing africa all this really cool stuff then all of a sudden you've got this which doesn't really mean anything it's a bit it just feels like it's a bit castrated compared to some of those other games and i don't quite know why that is okay so final thoughts on boone lake so if you can't tell by now i think this game is fantastic um i will say that generally um vista games are good one or two ways to me um normally i think they're either a bit too fiddly and a bit a bit convoluted or they're utterly brilliant so games like um maracaibo i think is one of my favorite games of all time and to be honest i had a bit of apprehension to see is he ever going to make a game as good as maracaibo again and i think he has here this game is absolutely brilliant it's almost like his rendition of a game like terra mystica that weird level of player interaction the upgrading your player board unlocking things and scoring opportunities as you go i absolutely love this style of thing and this game does that fantastically i love the opportunities that are created without the game and the way that the board develops and spreads out it feels organic but there's some still some juicy interaction you've got that classic um vista hand management of you

know are you going to actually what cards you got to play and manage your resources to actually play those cards in the first place um and also which cards can you afford to discard and get money for because money again is a tight resource in the game this action strip mechanism does a brilliant game brilliant job of making the rules manageable and i will say biggest props for this game um in terms of not really being any exceptions to rules any kind of need to go check the rule book and see anything like that it's all very clear in what you have to do i think once you've learned the rules here you're not going to forget them any time soon um i still like the familiarity of some of the fister traits here like go down the lake um you know as a timer throughout the game that's brilliant i get the hand management and card play constant engine building it's pretty much got everything you'd like if you do enjoy um alexander vista games and this one for me might not quite hit the heights of a game like maracaibo because not many games will forever but this one for me i think is pretty strongly my second favorite game um he's ever made i think this is absolutely brilliant a strong recommendation for me and it's a shame that the theme was a bit bland um but the rest of it the actual game mechanisms the interaction the kind of progression throughout the game the satisfaction on building your little tableau it's all there and it all is brilliantly fun so yeah i really do recommend um boom lake very excited that this game's come out and i think it's fantastic so this one is going to get my elite shield confident to give it that because i

think this game is going to be a staple of my collection for a long time to come

Progress saved