Skip to main content
Loading video...

No Pun Included's Board Game of the Year 2022

Transcript 19:56

hi my name is efka and this is my co-host and we're here to present no pun included Game of the Year yes much like the Michael Mann awards for restaurants the MPI g-o-t-y is the Pinnacle of board game Excellence the creme de La Creme of crams the big cheese in the sky basting you in cardboard Brilliance Elaine there's some Red Hot cardboard under these red hot curtains that I bought for a previous video and they were so expensive we had to use them again but today we have not one but two games of the year because we couldn't agree on which one was better why don't you reveal yours

oh look it's undaunted Stalingrad thankfully we have already reviewed it and we don't need you for this video anymore because people can go and watch that one oh yeah my game is here that's this is II gods of Atlantis and if it's not better than every other game published last year then it's at least better than gods of Atlantis you see II gods of Atlantis is a curiously titled sequel to a game we've reviewed all the way back when our videos look like when your dad got a camera to record your 12th birthday and you know what this is pretty much the same game as the last one except now there's more stuff in it and also much like liberace's piano the box is white and that's how you know it's classy so why am I talking about it well because it's brilliant that's why and you should know about this game gods of Atlantis is here to do one thing and the thing is to say remember mobas you know the video game thing forget about it it's basically like that but a board game which is cool okay each player takes on a character like a sky pirate or a gladiator Doberman and most of these characters are very good at one thing and rubbish and everything else as the game progresses your job is simple win by killing your opponents sort of and if

you're good at that you'll level up which is where you get to either be average at the things you wear rubbish at or really lean into that one thing you could already do well and let me tell you there is no way that that will go wrong at the heart of Gardens of Atlantis is the map divided into multiple zones on each team's side did I mention this as a team game never mind don't think about that right now we'll talk about it later on each team's side is your throne and that over there where the camera cuts it off is your opponent's Throne destroy your opponent's throne and that's another way that you can win here is where it gets really tricky the rest of the map is filled with battle zones at any given point there's only one active Battle Zone much like England's High streets that is where it is going down right now and that's also where all the Minions are if at any point you kill all the enemy team minions you winions that Battle Zone meaning that the active Battle Zone moves One Step Closer towards your opponent's throne and all the Minions reset to there if you do that one more time you will destroy the enemy from and win which is the central conflict of II gods of Atlantis you have ruthless Cutthroat fight spitting Your Heroes against enemy here Rose but then you also have to maintain your focus on killing enemy minions because if you ignore that then the enemy will kill

your minions push the lane and then suddenly you have to run all the way back and defend your base before it's too late minions even fight themselves at the end of each round if you have less minions than your opponent in the Battle Zone you'll lose more minions equal to the difference meaning that if you don't kill any of the minions all your opponent has to do is kill one minion and then you're on a cascading path towards bananas it's a minions joke for the young people all good and the balance between these two tension points is pitched so tight you can literally hear a pin drop anytime anyone plays a card talking off step aside Dr canitzia there's a new card game in town pew pew this system just slaps no really like you play a card in this game and then gods of Atlantis is so tightly wound there's a small nation of mistakes in baked into the complex so each time you do play a card you'll find yourself making about five of them coincidentally you start the game with five cards and whilst you do get new cards as you level up and your abilities do get better you're still at the mercy of that number because each card you get replaces an existing one you can never have more than five the five cards that's a problem each round you are forced forced

to play four of them each person picks a card and team members can discuss what they want to play but only out loud so that others at the table can hear them and then everyone simultaneously reveals their selection meaning that it's not just your options the dwindle as the round goes on but so does your defense the real trick of II is that each card is loaded did with options one card can let you move attack defend or do a special ability and all of these elements have different values based on which card you've chosen and it also determines your turn order which in a game this precise can be the difference between losing and losing a little less embarrassingly let's say that I'm four spaces away from an enemy hero that I'd love to get closer to and then own the next turn attack before the other enemy hero which is right next to me and I love to get away from attacks me and forces me to defend my highest initiative card is dread razor and if I play it there is a good chance I will get to go first but it's also one of my only two Attack cards on top of that it only has a movement of one my other option is to play Shield of Decay which has a movement of three nice but slightly lower initiative low enough to make me doubt my timely escape and on top of that it is also my highest defense count so if I do play it and don't go first in turn order then I'm stuffed suddenly this choice to play

won't card becomes an impossibility Minefield which is exactly what you want in a good card game you want your decisions to ask questions if I do this what will happen to me and then what you want is about four or five plausible scenarios that you can gamble on to complicate matters further I did mention you get new cards when you level up each time you gain a level you can select one of your defense skill or Attack cards and then you get a new one that you have to choose from too one will be a slightly better version of the one you had before and the other one is totally different with a bunch of new values you have to evaluate and the one you don't pick permanently increases a stat that's at the bottom of the card which is yet another thing to consider by this point you're probably thinking Ah that's too much and sort of yeah if you break it down like that it is indeed a lot but I I want you to make mistakes because mistakes create interesting game States and this isn't my observation this is literally what the designer is saying try things fail enjoy the terrible consequences and really losing is so easy like I mentioned before the two win conditions are to either destroy your opponent's Throne or kill enemy Heroes if you do kill one they don't immediately disappear they just reset at their own throne but this is funny because it's like

video games from the 80s if your hero gets killed you lose a life and if you run out of lives you lose very Charming finally the real meat of III how do you kill a hero well you have to attack them and if you attack they just die no really let's say I play a card that lets me attack for five then the person who controls the hero that I am targeting has to discard a card with at least an equal defense value if they haven't got one then they immediately kill over if they do have one the card that they discount they obviously can no longer use and if you discard two cards in a round on your fourth turn you'll be doing nothing and if you have no cards and someone attacks you you just die no questions asked which choose this game to the rhythm of hubris and downfall your best attack cards are your best defense cards only two of your cards attack and they often have a Litany of conditions you must fulfill before you can even try and hit your opponent such as being in precise positions and also once again they are your best movement cards so to get to a place where you can attack you have to spend the card that lets you attack and whilst you can talk shop with your teammates before you play the card once you reveal it all the tactics have to be done inside your brain without conferring I mean you can confer but only with your brain and your brain is too busy to work out how these cards actually work like this one for example blink strike says before the

attack move two spaces in a straight line for an enemy unit Target that unit and you're like ah great I can move to the attack no no no no no you already have to be next to the person that you want to attack and then if you're next to the person and there's something in front of that person you can't move through it so the card does nothing brain game I did say that not a lot has changed between the first and second editions of the game and I wasn't lying about that I was just omitting all the things that did change this somewhat obviously more box here with a frankly astounding 22 playable characters new play mods and chunky inserts to not hold all your cards in dedicated slots because instead of having a lid for the cards they live inside the lid and obviously tip this box sideways and the cards are everywhere but you don't even need to do that just taking this box up the stairs to the calyx makes the cards magically teleport in their seats what has changed is ethos III wants to be more approachable than its predecessor previously when your character died not only did they have to charge back all the way from the throne to where the action is but they also lost the turn which tactically made sense but on an emotional level it was a punishment that was hard to recover from same goes for the five cards before you had a card that just said hold on it and much like with an nft you felt swizzed because the card did nothing in 2017 Africa must

have been a really easy mark because I was all like oh but having a hold card creates interesting tactical implications like when do you deploy a card that does nothing yeah real fun gameplay there now instead of a hold card you get a card that is incredibly circumstantial but hey isn't that a lot more fun like if you can figure out a great time to use your terrible card for an advantage that's a golden Source feeling I would be remiss to mention that whilst III is an intricate and complex game the manual and also the included Tome of Mastery really tries to ease you into the experience for example it strongly encourages you to start with a truncated version of the game each module and is really lot of them is given a number of stars to indicate the complexity level and there's a nice chart that says don't play with X Stars until you have Y games under your belt each hero is also given a complexity rating from one to three stars and that isn't just nice that's pretty much a necessity because if you start with a freestyle character you'll be like ah my cards they do nothing because the text I don't understand too much but also each character has a summary card that explains what their strengths and weaknesses are and crucially explains how the role Works within the context of MOBA games for example this card tells me the Dodger the Warlock is an excellent Pusher and if I've never played MOBA games I might start thinking I wanted

into some illegal activity here but one flip of the uh Tome of Mastery and I can learn that a pusher is someone who is good at pushing Elaine meaning they can effectively protect their own minions and Destroy enemy ones ensuring that the battle moves closer to your opponent's Throne pushing it this is then further segmented into ability icons that describe the very specific things that a hero can do and what those mean within the context of the system making gods of Atlantis not just a high complexity game but a high complexity game that wants you to be good at it and understand its strategies I sincerely wish more games would do that and then from there we go into like a mid-review turnaround except we're not calling it a mid-review turn around because it's not a joke and it's been played out like half a decade ago and then you say sounds very exciting now tell the good viewers watching that you lied and that this isn't actually your game of the year and I'm like wait what what what you know and like koi pretending that I don't know what's going on but I actually do know what's going on and then you're like what is the caption on the thumbnail of the video and I'm like uh

and then you're like really hammering it in what is the caption on the thumbnail of the video and I'm like the best game you will never play all right from the top okay okay okay this isn't my game of the year even though I really like it you know like genuinely I love this game so much in theory in practice it's virtually unplayable actually it's the opposite of that it's virtually playable as in you're more likely to find online players to play on a virtual tabletop rather than convince your friends in the real world to give it a spin so first up it's a team game which is a big No-No for about 50 of people watching because team games are really frustrating for people who really like to win and if they're paired up with someone with a more Lassie Fair attitude they'll end up eating the table next it's a MOBA game which the remaining 80 percent of the 50 generally don't care about and you really have to care about this genre to enjoy it because it's a remarkably elegant yet faithful emulation everything you love and hate about mobas is here there's still 10 of you left so let's get rid of you now this game is available only through crowdfunding crowdfunding that has already happened hence it being here now on our table so if you missed that

you can't have it unless the launch a reprint Campaign which actually I think they are doing literally all of that would be fine and in no way disqualify guards of Atlantis from being my game of the year if anything a game that's specifically great for a niche is what games of the year are all about something that excels exactly and what it is doing and the people who want it well they'll love it but ah we have reached the one percent the very cream and to you I say are you not embarrassed by some of the artistic choices that publish a wolf designer opted for here I get that some people can get past the sexist depiction of women that is as tired as the man children Gathering to find in the comments section right now don't worry they'll be removed but there's also some other choices here that are as cumbersome is trying to teach a dog how to whistle dog whistle what does that remind me of so this is a playable character in a fantasy setting but this uniform here um does it remind you of something you could say that Sabina that is the character's name and the provided lore calls her a condotier giving her overall Italian cultural Vibes it's just a dashing fashionista just someone who likes to look bossy and it's not meant to evoke any real world imagery but then what about this pasty buff man literally called Aryan okay dog whistle Jokes Aside this probably isn't

intentional right Aryan the tide Master gonna take a wild stab and guess that it's a pun on Ariel so like Disney but with some more accidental Uber man Aryan is also one of tolkien's Maya and also the adjective to describe someone under the Aries star sign so overall not really bad but you put this artwork this uniform this name together what do you get you get cringe tired sad cringe it doesn't make the game look good and that's the problem because if I have to get three friends together and say to them hey this is a team game and very intricate and brittle and unusual and unforgiving but just give it a chance okay I promise I might want to do that but then if I have to say to them oh there's also this male gays infantile artwork and potentially some patchy characters they're going to tell me to stop my game and go back to the basement and I don't want to go back to the basement that's where incels live I know that the designer of II watches our channel so to our Dom and any gods of Atlantis fans which I am very much one of I know that you care about the setting of this game as much as I care about Downton Abbey it exists because it has to and so you tolerate it but until you at least shape up your artwork I can't give this the game of the year award and I really really really really really wish I could yes Elaine that is

indeed what I am doing disqualifying my winner right at the Finish Line I mean why not what better way to make a point and say hey we had enough of this totally approach to artwork and inclusivity and if you don't step up your game you won't get the biscuit biscuit being the game of the year award so what is that what is my actual biscuit of the here well I'll default to your choice and say it's undaunted Stalingrad which is an excellent game and also if we weren't compromised then prostate would be appearing somewhere in this video reviews for these games will be now covering up Elaine's face including a link to our Patron where if you enjoyed this video for some reason or maybe our other videos you can go there and give us money so that we can eat you still need to eat right I think she does

Progress saved