Hollow Pact: Midhall's ambitious followup to Beast - TCbH Review
Transcript
Social elements have long been experimented with in strategy board games and for good reasons. You can heighten immersion, increase suspense, add unpredictability, or just even a playing field. And you got everything from deduction to hidden movement to negotiation and secret traders. But no platform is as precarious as semi-ooperative victory conditions. See, in fully cooperative games, or victories at least, players know where they stand, can coach one another, support one another, and ideally everyone is working to press the game forward to the same outcome. Semi-ooperative victories where one or many players can win but all in theory should be working together to avoid losing is great in concept but for that whole social thing. What's to say that the other player is going to be pulling their weight and your victory may be dependent upon their efforts but not necessarily their outcomes? And who's to say that they're going to see this as a cooperative thing that they need to help you? Never mind the prevailing game theory inherent to the prisoner's dilemma that says that it's just always strategically better to betray the other person. The point that I'm making is that it's fun when it works, but it requires an extra level of dedication and mutual understanding of all players at the table to prop up the institution. Otherwise, it can quickly devolve. So, now that we got the lecture
out of the way, let's talk about Hollow Packed. Did I say precarious social elements like deduction, hidden traders, negotiation, and semi-ooperative victories? Cuz Hollowacted, the new game set in the world of and from the makers of Beast, one of my favorite recent hidden movement games, has all of these. One player is the beast working to fulfill their personal objective and to find a cool totem of power randomly and secretly assigned then carried by one of the two smugglers in their matching cargo box. Meanwhile, said smugglers both have their own secret victory conditions, which may or may not require them to suffer so much stress from a variety of means that they go insane, flipping their board and making themselves more vulnerable to the beast's curses and general high jinks and teetering close to a stress related, though not the only means of death.
Turns themselves are pretty straightforward. Players have action points to spend on default actions on their character mat or cards in their hand to move about a semi-randomized board across three tiers of spaces. Completing randomized or preset scenarios assigned to their tier. Generally, it's some thematic objective setting up how to break into the next level, like getting map pieces or the keys or explosives into the barrerow to shove into the gate to bust open a hole or even presenting opportunities to absolve you from needing to complete one or more of your objectives. All the while the beast player chasing, damaging, and cursing you in much the same fashion. As a big fan of Beast, there's something actually kind of shocking about how straightforward this game is.
Spend stamina to move, draw cards, or if you're the beast, you can attack, dealing straightforward damage to these couriers, possibly revealing if they have the precious McGuffin and use more stamina to draw into more shared player cards or your personal unique curses. Meanwhile, the humans, like in a lot of cooperative games, are spending their actions to predominantly move and interact. Or otherwise, like the beast, they can spend actions to draw cards for more specific actions that you can take off of the shared pool of cards or their own unique relics, which can be scavenged for in different locations. This echoes back to Beast, where there are shared cards that you both use and separate faction only cards. Though since the shared deck of cards isn't dealt then drafted, this is more practical than meaningful. But it is nice that a lot of the operations for the two definitely asymmetric sides function largely the same, giving a familiarity with capabilities. The rub and why I started this whole damn review the way that I did is that there's different tiers of victory for the humans and beast alike. The humans, well, only one of them can have a true victory if they manage to complete both of their goals and escape in their favored escape route based off of the highest priority number on their completed goals and escape with the magical egg mcguffin in their possession. But either human or both
humans can have a partial victory if they just manage to escape. Period. Goals be damned. Whereas the beast has a true victory if they manage to kill the player in possession of the tasty taco, which means that they then obtain it. But yet still, even if a player manages to escape with the magical egg, then you as the beast can still have a partial victory if you just get to eat another human. Or there's even another type of victory which is the coolest and the one where the most sense of ambiguity and mystery and delight uh and betrayal seems to hinge upon. And that's where you as the beast can curse one of the players often based off of certain context, which might be that they've made themselves vulnerable to the essence of this dark world by going into their insane state. And you play a curse on them. And a type of curse that you can place on them is a dark pact, which gives them the option of winning with the beast so long as they fulfill the conditions of the dark pact or otherwise they can just not do it. And like any curse, the dark pact itself and all the opportunities that it presents can go away so long as other conditions are met on the card. For my group, this did actually work pretty much as intended,
but it adds a layer of squishiness that players are going to have to muddle through that both gives the game its identity, but also its biggest hurdles, which is undoubtedly going to make or break how this game works for you. Even in the limited scenario I had to play, Hallact had a ton of cinematic elements. Man or monster alike, running across a bridge causes it to collapse, decreasing mobility, but also putting some distance between you and the beast or otherwise trapping you in together. One of my favorite systems are the rituals set up to the side of the board where players claim start of turn benefits so long as they have the most spirit, a powerful resource that comes at the cost of cards and actions, but serves as a contentious area control element with tangible consequences to the rest of the game. And as you climb through the city and discover the schematics for each new section, it enforces new strategic considerations.
Where Holact falters is the anticlimactic conclusion largely driven by the semi-ooperative nature. I found that the humans wanted to work together, caring less about their personal victory than denying the beast their prey. But completing personal goals can require interfering with or even injuring their partner. Similarly, there's a ganging up feeling that can happen for the lone uncursed human where the only incentive to not defect is pity and spiting the beast. It's a powerful incentive, but not an enforcable one. And then there's player elimination. Like beast, damage is pretty matterof fact and packed. If you attack, you just deal a damage, and there's little aside from a sprinkling of relic cards that can do much about it. Since humans can't hurt the beast, if the beast manages to kill a hero and even claim their fashion nugget, there could still be a significant time until the fate of the remaining player is decided. even if the best they can achieve is a hollow survival and not a true win. Midhall Games informed me as part of this review that they're still doing some development work on this game, including an alternating action system that could go a long way to mitigating the worst impacts of a particularly nasty beast turn.
Personally, I hope they take a look at the victory conditions and the levers associated with these shifting alliances to make a more codified light or dark victory where either humans or the singular beast or the beast and a human with an act of dark pact win as one. Though that might be distancing itself too much from what the game intends to be. As it stands, it's fun, adventurous, dynamic, it's singular, where I haven't played a game quite treading in the same waters as this when it comes to The Prisoner's Dilemma. And it is absolutely gorgeous in illustrations. And the production of the prototype that I received is the best pre-production production that I think I've ever covered on this channel. So, I'm pretty confident that the end result is just going to be damn gorgeous. And this is a world that I just want to be in. I mean, not actually be in because that sounds pretty terrifying and miserable, but you know what I mean. It oozes with dark folklore and murky gray occult. And that setting sets it up for those sorts of shifting alliances and moral ambiguity. But this is definitely the type of game where players are going to want to know the ins and outs before going in. And I think there is some polishing to do to get it to the final state. Taking it from a good game into a great one. But as it is, Hollow Pacted is ambitious and definitely worth looking into, especially if you are
interested in social layers being added onto strategy games. And that's our review. But let me know what do you think about this in comparison to Beast as a followup to what is one of my favorite games period. and definitely one of my favorite hidden movement games to have come out in the last several years. Put it in the comments below. And as always, thanks for watching, thanks for supporting, thanks for being such an awesome community. You know that I've been Jack for the Cardboard Herald.