Scythe: Expeditions - can the sequel match the original?
Transcript
let's talk about the sequel to Scythe one of my favorite games of all time welcome to brains on games I'm Dr Brian McDonald in this episode we are going to talk about the sequel to Scythe which you've seen behind me in every single episode of the show Scythe is one of my favorite games of all time and I pre-ordered the follow-up to scythe and it just arrived just recently so this giant box this thing is so big I'm gonna have to take a lot of pictures and show you some pictures you're not going to see even probably this whole box on the camera but this is Scythe Expeditions from stonemeyer games now Scythe Expeditions is a game for between one and five players of course they have a solo version of this game you can play it with teenagers kids age 14 and up shouldn't have too much trouble with this one although it is on the a slightly heavier side than some of the games I've talked about recently and games play in an hour to an hour and a half let's take a deeper look at Scythe expeditions Scythe is a game that's medium in terms of its complexity and it really is sort of an exploration action selection game where you're trying to earn victory points the winner of the game is going to be the player who has the most victory points at the end and those are earned by completing quests and upgrading your Mech of course
there's mechs in a scythe game uh by earning coins there's there's multiple ways that you can earn some victory points in this game we'll talk about some of those it does of course have that great artwork that's that any fan of Scythe will be familiar with but we're laying out a modular board here so there are three groups of these big hexagonal tiles and you're going to shuffle each group Up and Deal them out in rows across the the base camp down here shows how to arrange things there are going to be some face up cards in between that you can collect on along the way those might include items or quests that you can do now the story here it takes place after the rise of Fenris expansion for the old scythe and the idea is that a meteorite has crash landed in Siberia and two Expeditions have gone to investigate and nothing has been heard from them since so the game is about players taking exploration mechs into the Siberian Wilderness to find out what's going on and you'll see that the cards are very thematic you'll see those things in the quests and the cards you'll be finding some scientists you'll be interviewing eyewitnesses there's all kinds of quests that you can do in the game but uh what's going to to happen at the beginning here is that each player is going to be dealt at random a Mech and a hero with that
Hero's companion so the heroes in this case are cards in the original site you had separate Miniatures the only Minis that you're going to be moving around the board are your max now this is the Ironclad Edition because I couldn't resist that it's got metal Max these are quite heavy and the game comes with these plastic rings so that you can identify the player color and remember Who's Who The Lumberjack was my favorite of these mechs with the big buzz saws on both of his hands so there are five different mechs each Mech has a unique ability and then of course there are heroes and Companions and they have unique abilities as well you're only seeing part of the board here like I said I'm going to put lots of pictures this game is huge it's such a table hog that I couldn't put everything out so that you could see everything all at once but you'll see those in in the graphics players start the game at the bottom of the board at base camp and then they can they can choose typically on your turn you're going to be able to choose two out of three actions and as you build up your engine as you gather cards from the board multiple things are going to start to happen and you can create these big combos where you're earning might and guile and and victory points and all kinds of things happen just by playing a single card or placing a worker or moving to a certain space so the three actions that you have to choose from are to move your Mech to play a card or to gather from the space that your Mech is on and like I said on
the first turn you get to do all three of those things but I'm going to move the board out of the way so that you can see what the player board looks like and how those actions are chosen eventually your mechs are going to move into spaces that have not yet been explored and then you're going to get one of these little Maps which is on the on the top of each of the face down locations and when you move on to it you flip that space over so now I've moved from an isolated settlement into a weird forest and I've earned a map token for that and like I said I'm going to show you how you earn victory points and map tokens are a part of that equation of course when you flip over one of these hidden locations there is going to be some corruption related to the meteorite that has crash landed I don't want to give too much away but of course the radiation from the meteorite is affecting lots of things and that's why you have this weird forest and and there are some unusual things that are going on that you'll see as you play through the cards so when you flip over one of these locations you're going to add some corruption to it because the location's closer to the meteorite are corrupted there's a number here on each of these tiles that tell you how much corruption it has to have the minimum amount that it has to have and then you draw these corruption tiles from a bag so if I happen to draw a 5 it says five plus on that tile then I'm done but if I
draw a 4 first that's not enough because it says I need five plus I draw a second one and then I get a five and now there's an 9 corruption on there that has to be cleared before you can use the action that's underneath so here is the player board for the marsh Strider this fella right here with the long legs each of the mech has a unique ability and in the marsh strider's case he can move one to four hexes on the map instead of one to three all the other mechs can only move three The Lumberjack here gets a bonus when he's clearing corruption off those corrupted tiles and then the action selection I think is quite clever like I said on the first turn you can do all three of these actions it says move play and gather here and then on your next turn you've got this Cube that moves up and it starts to cover things up you can play and gather or move and gather or you can move and play a card so you're playing a card from your hand and getting some benefit from playing that card as you play those cards you're going to earn guile that's the little round brain on here my son kept calling it brains he said I'm earning brains and he called the mic games just because of the show but you're going to earn might and you're going to earn guile and now if I've got five dial here I can play a card that allows me to a clear corruption from this space Vanquish the corruption and then I would spend five might once I've played that card and take that corruption off if I also had four guile I could spend those four you
can Vanquish on one Vanquish action you can spend as much as you want to Vanquish as many of these little tokens as you want to so I could have spent everything and then managed to get everything cleared from the card and now there's a second ability on here that anyone can use if they happen to come onto the space other Macs can walk across walk through the tile that you're on but they can't finish their turn on the same tile that's occupied by a Mac so you're moving if you play currents there's all kinds of things that happen when you play cards each card has uh has some bonus that you're going to get at the top some core values so in this case when you play a Kiko you're going to get one might for playing her once you've got some stars on the on the base camp we'll I'll explain how you do that then you get some additional bonuses as well as you go through the game you may have seen there's some pictures let me move this out of the way there's some pictures of workers so you can collect workers when you play a card you can add a worker to the bottom here this one needs it a Kiko needs a yellow worker to take whatever extra bonus action there is down here at the bottom of her card so moving playing you play a card to Vanquish like I said you can also gather so each of these hexes has some some bonus some resource that you're going to get if you gather there you might get to collect a card you might get some workers that you'll be able to play later on you might get to rescue a card take it out of your
active your active row of cards so that you can play it again and get those bonuses all over again and and you do definitely need to do that and that is important once you've played a card it sits there you don't you you do get some ongoing bonuses from items that you might have in your active row but there are all these abilities that you need to use for example there are very few cards that allow you to Vanquish corruption there are very few currents that allow you to solve a quest uh you know you know the main one is going to be your hero and the companion the companion allows you to Vanquish corruption the hero is the one who solves quests typically there are some other cards and items that have some of those effects as well but but primarily you're going to be using those two cards once they're played they're gone and their workers are stuck on there you don't get to take the workers off until you refresh that active row of cards and you refresh by moving your little Cube down here so each turn you're going to be taking those two actions you can move your Cube to cover up one of them you can change it every time if you want to but eventually you're going to want to refresh meaning you take all the cards that that are in your active row and you put them back in your hand you put all the workers back on your on your Mech mat here so that you can use them when you play cards later on so you're losing a turn to refresh your cards but then on the next turn you get to do all three actions again because your Cube moves over you see there's little arrows here that explain what to do and and that's
basically the game there are certain abilities that you can't do until you clear corruption later later on on some of the Hidden tiles you can't get purple workers until you get up to those tiles that are corrupted you you can't meld meteorites to your Mech and build up your Mech in that way uh and and that's one way that you can earn some victory points you can't upgrade your Mech until so you get up here and start clearing corruption off of these spaces so you do have to start to explore and although you're not battling against one another the two mechs aren't battling one another you are spending these things to start to clear the corruption from the space that your Mech is on and eventually you're going to start boasting about your accomplishments and that is a very important way to earn victory points now if you upgrade your Mech if you take an item and play it you you're going to find yourself tucking cards underneath your Mech here then this is an ongoing benefit that I'm going to get every turn I don't need to play the card I don't need to play I don't need to play a worker on it it's going to give me three victory points it says down there at the bottom so item cards are what you upgrade your when you meld meteorites like I said this is a meteorite card actually it just so happened that I had a meteorite card out the meteorite cards get tucked under as well and in this case you're going to get one Victory point for each adjacent face up card when you activate that and you get the bonus from each of the
meteorites each time you add a new one under there now you can only add four in total but you're going to get bigger bonuses each time once I've got four upgrades under my player mat I can place a star there so here's the quest maybe uh uh one of the things that we often did because we explored we'd get lots of these map tokens very quickly you can place another one here at the end as once you've got five map tokens you can only do that when you gather from a space that has that star token that star image on it because that means you're boasting about those accomplishments when a player has placed their fourth star here on the board this one indicates that you're going to be able to place a star once you've got seven of these corruption tokens that you've vanquished from the board then that signifies the final round of the game each player gets another turn including the player that initiated that end game status by placing the fourth star so the player who's finishing the game really does kind of get one extra turn in the end and everybody else is going to be scrambling to earn as many victory points as possible before that last that last player gets to play once that player who's placed the fourth star has finished their final turn it's time to count up victory points now you will have I mean the victory points in this game are coins so you'll see one dollar one coin really and and the Scythe metal coins are the ones that I use uh the game comes with cardboard ones but you
can upgrade it if you want to these are from the original site but they're the same coins for each one so first you count up your coins there are even some places where you can gather and get some coins on the map but you're gonna count up your coins first each one is worth one Victory Point there's the victory Point symbol the number of coins in the bottom of your upgrade card like I mentioned earlier so you can count up your upgrades you're going to get two victory points for each corruption token that you've collected along the way and then you get victory points for the stars that you've placed now in the original Scythe you were using your rep reputation as a multiplier you get many more points if your reputation was high in Scythe Expeditions it's the number of quests becomes a multiplier and if you finish three or more quests you're going to get 10 points for each of the stars that are on here and one of the things that happened in in one of the games that we played was that I only had two stars I was set to place a third one on my last turn but the player who had placed his fourth star was blocking the only spot I had access to where I could boast and put one of my stars on the board I wound up losing the game by two points I was the only player with a ton of upgrades on the map and I've been clearing corruption because I I had the buzz saw guy who could clear corruption more easily than anyone else so The Lumberjack was able to help me with the corruption I lost only by two points the
the I I only had two of these Stars placed so I I was only able to get eight victory points for each one and Meanwhile my opponent the one who finished the game was getting 40 points for the stars that he had placed and then he had a few other points along the way so I lost by two in the first game I won by 11 in the second one once I had figured out the impact of these stars now what skills are you working on when you play a game like Scythe Expeditions well this is a game where you are tracking a lot of information you're looking at what are your opponents doing what cards are they trying to collect how are they trying to earn those victory points what are they doing to place the stars on the board how many stars have been placed how close are you to the end game you know there's a lot of things to keep track of so you're juggling a lot of information and when you're playing with experienced players of these kinds of games you're going to start to recognize that it's a race everyone is racing to get as many victory points as possible before the any of the players get to place that fourth star and what that means is that you're trying very hard to be efficient with those actions we never have enough actions in this game to do all the things that we want to do on our turn I always wanted like a third or a fourth one but most of the time I only had two every so often I could get that third one but I usually had to Forfeit a turn in order to do that you never have enough turns enough actions to do all the things that you want to do and so
you need to be efficient and when you're budgeting actions and your budgeting resources to clear that corruption and I mean and you're juggling lots of information in your mind we are talking about executive functioning skills the skills and behaviors that you need to work towards a goal planning and budgeting are among those being able to attend to multiple kinds of information and being flexible in your approach you know I I was all set to place that last star for myself in that first game that we played but my opponent blocked me from being able to do that and then I had to on the Fly come up with some other strategy to earn as many points as possible and I was this close but I didn't I wasn't quite able to do it so you are working on those executive functioning skills when you when you play this game there's this you know visual spatial problem solving to it as well you're trying to get to certain locations but we're primarily talking about executive functioning skills here final thoughts about Scythe Expeditions well this is a gorgeous game with amazing components I mean like all of the stonemeyer games I don't think I've played anything by them uh that I haven't played all of their games I'll be honest with you but I mean viticulture is a beautiful one Scythe of course wingspan like these are folks who know what they're doing in terms of component quality uh I love these mechs these giant metal things and of course the artwork and the theme I find really interesting as well you know it's it's
they've got these big giant robots but you know we're we're looking at Farmers uh with all these machines around them it looks a little bit like Tails from the loop sometimes when you see the graphics on the on these tiles and on the cards uh this one is faster I think than the original Scythe it's easier to teach because it's fairly straightforward with those actions and then the things that you do are printed on the cards and the same way that um Concordia has those cards that you play in there that what you're doing is printed exactly on them that's something that you're doing here in Scythe Expeditions as well there's no combat and I kind of liked that there was no compound I always found the combat in the original site to be kind of the stressful part there's no combat there's still player interactions in terms of of trap drafting the cards that the other players want or blocking the spaces that they want to have access to you can kind of box people in to prevent them even though they can jump over you uh if you're on a space that they needed to get to they can't use that space so you can limit their options so I do find it's a game that's that's still strategic but faster and easier maybe to play than the original scythe and definitely I think easier to teach and you've got that removal of the combat and nobody can steal from you your might or your guile which I know sometimes my resources would get stolen
in scythe and oh was that ever frustrating when that happened it is still a recognizable game in the Scythe universe and there are some shared elements including those beautiful mechs like we talked about and uh the artwork uh is is fantastic so it retains the feel of Scythe um the Box organizer even is excellent but it is like if we're going to talk about downsides it is a table hog I couldn't even show you the entire board here on my table this thing is huge the box is huge I've I've been trying to figure out how am I going to fit that box on the Shelf I don't know where I'm going to put this game once I pack it up and put it away until the next time we play uh so it's it's a table hog uh there's less player interaction maybe than there is in sight like I said you can box people in but without that combat some people want that kind of Mech versus Mech or hero versus hero combat um I I think that that's definitely a change that is very noticeable here in this game and of course I mean this is brand new there are no expansions for it yet hopefully there will be because I think that it lends itself to that but there are no expansions for it yet and so it's um you know I I it's in my mind right now but Scythe has kind of sucked me in uh and it is one of my favorite games of all time I don't think Scythe
Expeditions replaces it for me yet but like I said it's faster it's easier to teach you it gives you a lot of the feel of Scythe uh without as much of the overhead that Scythe maybe has so um this is a game that I'm going to be pulling out again there's no question about it I this is another one that I think uh that fans of the original are still going to enjoy um and you know it's got a great box organizer two maybe the downside is that sometimes the it is kind of hard to get that box organizer open without destroying the Box um but look still Meyer games this is another great one this is one that I'm going to be pulling out I think to show my friends and and even with these uh big heavy mechs uh I you know you know it's got a great it's a table hog but it has a great table presence uh so it's a winner for us I've already only came in a few days ago and I've already played a bunch of games of this thing I was excited about it enthusiastic about it I love Scythe uh you know and I've Loved many of stonemeyer's other games as well so it's a winner for us if you have any questions about Scythe Expeditions or suggestions for brains on games you can leave them in the comment section below the video or you can email me at Bryant brainsongames.ca brainsongames.ca is the website that's where future episodes ago the previous ones are up there already brains on games is the Twitter handle and the Facebook page and the Instagram feed so we're all over the place if you
enjoyed this video and you want to be notified of future ones you can head on over to YouTube and click that subscribe button thanks for joining me and hopefully I'll see you next time foreign