Skip to main content
Loading video...

Unfathomable Review: A Wild, Chaotic Experience

Transcript 16:42

hello board of it here i am farrell this is tally and now that tally has recovered from covid we are able to get back to what's important board games and today we're bringing you a review of unfathomable a game that is currently at the top of the board game geek hotness ranking and the reason this game is currently in vogue is because it is a long awaited reprint or rather reskin of the incredibly popular game battlestar galactica the board game battlestar galactica is famous for its hidden role systems and mechanics however due to licensing issues fell out of print and now copies go for the big bucks on the second hand market fantasy flight games have addressed the clamor of fans by releasing unfallenable changing the setting to their lovecraftian universe of games and the map to a 20th century ocean liner while keeping the core gameplay mechanics intact and in unfathomable you and your friends will be passengers and crew aboard the ss atlantica some will be human others decidedly not so human and the game begins with a murder and deep ones storming the ship and to be honest things only get much worse from there the passengers who are human well well sorry the humans will want to get to boston and survive whereas the traitors will want to sink the ship who amongst your fellow passengers and crew can you trust

you'll begin unfathomable by picking a unique character to play us and you'll be dealt a secret hidden role card which will either be human hybrid or cultist if you're human you want the ss atlantica to reach boston this is done by getting to the end of the travel track repeatedly and when you get to the end of the travel track you'll obtain a waypoint card which has a value on it between two and four when the value of all your waypoint cards adds up to 12 or more you have one final time to get to the end of the travel track and the humans will reach boston when the value of the waypoint cards is six or more everyone is dealt a second hidden role card if you're a hybrid you do not want the ship to reach boston and ideally you want it to sink and the quicker the better and there are a few ways to go about this you can get so many deep ones on the ship that essentially the passengers and crew are overwhelmed you could reduce any of these dials to zero which will represent a critical loss of something important like food or fuel you could murder all the passengers which are represented by these tokens or you could just damage every interior space of the ship meaning that it's essentially sunk what's interesting is that there's another type of traitor called a cultist and the cultist is actually human just a naughty human and what they want is the ship to get within sight of boston so they can swim to shore but then they want the ship to sink so they want the cards of the waypoint deck to get to 12 or more but not that final

time to boston and then they want the ship sink in this very very small window each term will begin by drawing skill cards which can either be used for their action or their value then you'll take two actions with your character which will usually be moving around the ship and dealing with the problems that pop up then you'll draw a mythos card which will have a crisis on it for the players to solve these will usually have a skill check and all players can contribute to the skill check by adding as many cards as they like and then two cards are added from the chaos deck the cards that match the skill check add to the overall value of that skill check and those that do not are negative we never played battlestar galactica the board game but we were pretty delighted by unfathomable when you first read the rules it seems quite fiddly but in practice it's pretty simple and intuitive we played our first game with two non-gamers and after explaining and getting down to it they had really no issues and no questions and we barely had to check the rules reference we've got some pretty good role play going with the characters and the crisis situations and it was generally a terrifically fun gaming experience and what's excellent is this huge deck of mythos cards and the variety of different crises that come on it combined with the item deck the spell deck the skill cards and the actions they can do your character actions means that there's going to be a very wide range of experiences available within this kind of sandbox

and it means that every time you play you have multiple different ways to solve the many problems that have thrown at you and another kind of great thing about this replayability in variety is that because each of the characters are unique and hopefully you'll play different characters most of the times you play different games are going to feel different in how they play due to the actions of your characters it's very much a game where you'll be faced with a problem and everyone will kind of scan their cards and their characters and then somebody will go hey guys i can do x y and z and everyone just be like noice because it's just a really sweet way to solve that problem really like clever little twist one really excellent mechanic is the traitor system adding a second set of roll cards halfway through the game is genius because it adds such an unknowable element to the gameplay you could literally spend the first half of the game suspecting everyone when no one is a traitor then halfway through everything shifts and you know there are traitors but just how many we also like the inclusion of the cultist card which will have you wanting the ship to get most of the way to boston but you still need to sync it so it adds a wonderful dash of chaos and the who is the traitor drama wouldn't be there without the excellent skill check system this is where when you do skill check all players can add as many cards as they want from their hand to the middle face down but you'll always add two from the chaos deck and this deck is just

comprised of two of each type of skill and this is crucial for allowing deniability for the traitors when they want to tank a skill check because you can always point to the random cards added there's nothing better than being a traitor seeing a skill check tanked when you added some cards in but then finding out that actually both the chaos cards were good and that means that everything adds up no obsex or thing and you just get away with it so another great thing is that you have constant skill checks and this means that rather being pushed to always be bad and then you know deny it you can pick and choose when to strike as a traitor and it just means that you can lay suspicions for longer point them on other people point them on chaos deck it's just a nice touch and it's the intricate combination of systems in this game such as the skill checks and the hidden roles that really allow you to have these great dramatic experiences one thing we do worry about is balance because this game is so chaotic and random and a lot of bad stuff will be happening all it takes is a little bit of bad luck for the game to be almost unwinnable for the humans as an example in our second game essentially every card we drew from the mythos deck moved the ritual track rather than the travel track which meant that the humans were never getting any closer to winning or the end of the game and this combined

with a bunch of you know a mythos card making a bunch of passengers go on deck the ritual track moved and then about seven passengers at once got blown off the ship and this made the soul dial go down to two and this was at a point where not even every player had had a second turn and it was already obvious he was gonna win and in that game i was a traitor and i really did not have to do anything because i don't think the humans could have won even if there was no traitors and the game does say in the rules that you know if if you're finding it too easy with one side or the other you can adjust the styling resources but i don't find this to be a good idea because the game is so chaotic and unknowable i don't know how you would know which side to balance out unless one side was winning every single time because the first game we played it went down to the wire and either side could have won but i think you have to go into this game with a mindset that you're there to maybe role-play a bit to tell a story to you know experience it rather than as a dry euro to balance out and win by the best route possible because you're just not gonna get that here one really nice touch in unfathomable relates to the characters that you can play as an effort has really been made here to make the characters inclusive and diverse and include but it's not limited to a south pacific islander female captain and a non-binary crew member with they them pronouns it's a small touch that has no effect on gameplay will likely have a

big impact on players who don't usually see themselves represented in board games not to mention that all of the characters are fairly badass and have wonderfully unique powers and well-written backstories it really helps the players embrace the light role-playing element of the game one thing we will mention is the balance of gameplay and admin this game is like 85 admin so if you're looking for an action-filled swashbuckling fast-paced game then this is not it because each player gets only two actions on their turn and these are relatively simple actions your action phase is going to be over in about 30 seconds eg move and roll then each player will resolve the mythos card which requires reading out the crisis adding skill check cards to the skill check counting up those skill check cards enjoying the admin based on the outcome then there'll be some more admin based on the activation and the track symbols which means monster admin and then some more track admin so this means that your action phase is going to last about 30 seconds but then the mythos can't can take minutes to resolve and it's not to say necessarily that this is a bad thing because the crises on the mythos cards are one of the best aspects of the game you know they are thematic narrative engaging often darkly humorous and what they do is they create a lot of debate and discussion when you're picking what option to choose or how much you should contribute or is it important if we do this or succeed or fail

then you always have the tenth skill check and then once a skill check is done you probably have some accusations flying about people yelling at each other however at the end of the day it is still kind of just admin and it's just a little bit anti-climactic to wait 15 minutes to get back to your turn then have your action phase over lightning quick then you draw your mythos card and suddenly the captain gets to read it instead of you so now your turn's over basically it's just that this is a game that every time i've played there's been instances where it gets back to a player's turn and they just go ah finally and it's not just other players turns that can feel long often the entire game will drag because this is a two to four hour game and in our opinion it does not need to be that long you know there's a lot of variety what can happen there's a lot of things to do but the majority of your returns are going to play out the same the on the board gameplay is fairly repetitive you know often you'll be moving and you'll be rescuing a passenger or fighting a monster or repairing a damaged space because these are the most important things to do it's just that the dynamic of the game does not change from hour one to hour four unless a hidden traitor reveals themselves and it's not to be overtly negative about the length uh you know it it will still feel engaging and it will still be tense as long as it's not obvious who's going to

win because if it is obvious who's going to win then it's an exercise in frustration but it just an example is that you know you can have games where within the first hour the humans can get about a value of six on the waypoint cards and so they're halfway to boston then in the second hour they only get two and because of this sudden slow down the game just feels really longed out and what's interesting is that the problem becomes getting it to the table it just makes it more difficult because of the length of time needed and you could fairly argue that it's maybe an event game something best played you know with a lot of people saturday night with some beers not something to be broken out on the regular but what's interesting is that it's very easy to learn it also doesn't take too long to set up so there's really no barrier to getting onto the table and teaching it to people the real barrier is finding four hours spare and this is what makes it hard to get to the table and we just wonder and what we'd like to see is is there a way to kind of half it you know half the waypoint cards half the resources half the requirements for the traitors to win and not break the game because that would be the ideal scenario of just having this game that much shorter the culmination of these issues converges in the brig which is where players can be sent either by a mythos

card or if they're suspected of being untrustworthy players can escape the brig by doing a skill check but they can only add one card so you have to rely on other players to help you escape or get insanely lucky with the chaos deck the problem though is that players in the brig can't really do anything the only action they can really do is try to escape and they don't even get to resolve the crisis on their mythos card and in the game where it can take a while to get back around your turn having a player be able to do even less does not sit well with anyone honestly it can just get a bit awkward to have a player grow increasingly frustrated about not being able to even participate in the game and we've even seen human players bail out a highly suspected traitor just so the friend can engage and not have a completely miserable time there is a mechanic where if you're the traitor you can reveal this to help you escape the brig easier but this doesn't really help if you're a human who has been centered by a mythos card or just wrongly suspected if a game mechanic has players actively hurting their chances of winning just so their friend can participate and not have a completely miserable time then it probably needs rethinking so in terms of our final thoughts unfathomable has us in a strange place it has some strongly thematic intelligent mechanisms is a great story and drama generator and has some very interesting and diverse characters but that aside it can go on longer than it should

suffers from chaotic randomness that can have the game feeling like it's over before it's even begun and has mechanisms that actively hurt the enjoyment of the group now after the first game i was ready to wax lyrical about unfathomable but after the fourth game i was wondering if i could help house rule it without breaking it so i guess the tagline from fadenball would be that it is a wild chaotic experience you know it you can play this and you can have a game that is incredibly tense extremely fun and will leave a lasting impression on your gaming group or you could have a real slug of an experience that everyone just wishes was over and if this is a risk you want to take well that's decision that's up to you and your money bag but that is our review of unfathomable and we appreciate you watching if it was helpful we'd really love it if you could subscribe if you have any questions please ask us down below and just yeah thank you for watching and the dogs are happy that you came to join us

Progress saved