Up or Down Review: Either Direction is Fine, I'm Here For The Music
Transcript
Hey everybody, I'm Joey Evans.
And I'm Chris Yay.
And we are going up or down.
Yeah. You take them high, I'll hit them low and together we'll commit a tackling penalty in the NFL.
25 yards. Is that it? 25 yards. I don't know. We don't watch the sports teams. Um, so pretty much up or down. This is one that I circled mainly because of the artwork.
Okay. I I like the designers. It's Kramer and Keysley. I think they
Kramer and Keyling. Yep.
Doing a little card game.
Yes. Yeah. So, pretty much we're going to go to what we thought about it. But first, let's see how it plays.
Okay. So, we are set up for a game of up or down. Now, we're set up for four players. And the reason that matters is the numbers that you use differ depending on the player count. So, what you're going to have is you're going to have these cards around the outside. These are ascending or descending order. They're all in order there. And in the center, you're going to have two discard piles, one face down and one face up. What you're going to try to do is on your in your tableau, you're going to make three columns representing elevators that are going up or down. See, there's the name. So, here's how you play. First off, everyone gets a hand of three cards. And then you're going to play a card into this display. And as you do, wherever you play it, it has to go in the order it goes into. And then you're going to be able to take one of those cards and put them into your elevator, but only one of the cards that is on either side. For example, let's say I've got this 14 here. I want to play, let's see here. I will play it right here. All right. Now, because that goes between these, I can choose either the 34 or the 11. What I'm going to do is I'm going to choose, of course, the 11. And I then place that right here.
So, there I've got my the start of one of my three elevators. And then after that, I am then going to draw a card. I can draw either the face down or face up card. So maybe I'll choose to take the face up card just like this. Now let's go on how these elevators work real quick. When you do play cards here again, if I were to start a new elevator, say I pulled this from the display and I set it over here, I could then start a new elevator just like that. Now, these cards as they sit out are either going up or down. So if I were to play, say later, I was going to go ahead and play, let's see here. There we go. I was going to play this eight here on my next turn. Then I'll take this 14 here. Now I then set it on top and that has decided that this elevator is now going up. So I can no longer play any cards below it. Like later I couldn't grab a six or seven or something and put it underneath because this elevator is going up. So every card has to be above 14 going up. And over here I could then have another elevator that is going say I play a 77 here and then a 28. This elevator is now going down. So anything I grab over here would have to then be going down below 28.
Obviously that's pretty bad. You're skipping like 50 cards in that. But that's just an example. Okay. So now also this is going to arise later. Say these are my three columns or three elevators here. Notice the 56 is going down. So here I have to play something lower than five. Here I have to play something higher than 69. And here I have to play high something higher than 75. If it ever comes the time to if I look at my hand just like this and I've got these three cards. Let's see if I can get those into focus. Just like this. See I've got these 6, 16, and 32. I can then I then pretty much can only place these in between here. But if you look the eight right here and the 34, neither one will fit here into my tableau. So, what I would have to do is I would have to then ditch one of these and then start a new elevator. So, if I were to go ahead and just play this 16 right here. Now, also, you don't only do this when you're forced to. There are times when you can choose to close down an elevator and start a new one. So, let's see here. If I take this one, place it here. Tell you what, I will take this eight and I will then I will close this elevator down.
and then place those in my discard. At the end of the game, these in my discard will give me one point per card in my discard, whatever I've closed down. And then I'll take the eight I pulled from there. And now I'm starting a new elevator. Hopefully going up. That would make the most sense. Okay. So, you're going to keep going around. You're going to play until both draw piles are depleted. And you're going to continue until all the cards in the player's hands have been played as well. These six cards will still be remaining out there. And that's when you go into scoring. Now, scoring, how does scoring work? Well, pretty much it's like I said before, any of those that you discarded, those columns you took away and put in your discard, those are worth one point per. But these right here are going to use the colors you see there. You're going to take the color the colors that have the most multiply by how many cards there are. For example, this has two blues and it is three cards. So, it is 2 * 3 meaning six. And this, of course, is one. And this right here would be 2 * 4.
So that would give you eight points. You're going to add up your points. Everyone does. And whoever has the most points wins. And that is how you play up or down. Okay. So that's pretty much it. Um I would usually say not all the rules, but that's pretty much most the rules for up or down. It's a fairly simple game. It is. I think it's it's not deceivingly simple, right? It's pretty accurately simple, right? But as you as you play a card, I think the biggest thing people have to remember is when you're excited about a card in hand, you're like, "Yeah, oh, I don't get it yet. I'm gonna play it.
Take something next to it.
That's mindbending. Go ahead.
Yeah. Well, and you just like have that hope and a prayer that like maybe that 60 yellow will still be there on my turn.
Yes.
It won't be.
Yeah. The cards in your hand are never going to get played your tableau.
Not directly, right? But maybe through that indirect thing. And I like that. I like that little flow to it.
I do too. And I also hate it because it's like one of those is like, man, if that gap's really big, I could drop an eight down there and end up with like a 70. You know, one thing I did not mention in the overview, but if you can't place it anywhere, it'll go kind of towards the, you know, in the middle. Like if your highest number is a 50, it's going to go between the 50 and the eight. It's going to go in there like you have a 70 or whatever. So, it kind of circles back around that whole grid out there.
Oh, this. Yeah. Yeah. And it's cool because Yeah. when you when you have like the when you have a small gap on that like loop around, right? You have 110 out there and the one
and then all of a sudden the one gets taken and the lowest number is a 30 and then the highest gets taken and the highest number is a 70. You're like
I have a lot of flexibility to play in between those numbers now. So yeah, it's every card feels at times useless. You're like gh this is not going to help me.
I agree.
And then at other times so critical. So it's a nice little balance for that.
It does. and also makes you want to go ahead the choices in there because a lot of times you can't look ahead because they're going to you're going to get frustrated. But um you do kind of you're going to try to balance those those elevators that get you the most points and then close down the ones that do not because later I mean at you're wanting to I'm just going to go eight then I'm going to go nine then I'm going to go 10 and then I'm going to go 58 you know because you're like whoops.
Yes. And then
oh that happened
and people forget to look at the colors a lot. Is that how your people are or like when you played it?
Yeah. Yeah. The the scoring is one of those things I kind of remind people a few times throughout be like, "Yeah, a lot of cards is good." Remember that the other multiplier is a lot of cards the same color.
Yes.
And so as I think as you're teaching it to people, you give that little reminder. They're like, "Oh yeah, three greens is really good on this one. Got it. I should add a fourth one."
Uh and I think that that scoring is what kind of elevates it because the card play loop is super simple. It is. And I think that some people would say like it's not enough control. But I think it is fun that it is you're just kind of along for the ride a little bit kind of like an elevator. But that scoring is where you do have more control. You do have more of an option to say like I think I'm going to prioritize this one right now.
Uh and so I think that that's what elevates the game a little bit more in my eyes.
Ouch. Ah, no. But pretty much every turn can be joy or agony,
which is one of those I will say, um, it wasn't that way, but for me it was very divisive on who likes a game and who doesn't, but my wife, she did not. We played with another couple and my wife and his wife hated it because it's just like it's so mind-melting when it gets there, which it seems very simple, but it does have some good decision- making in there. And I think some people I think if it's that flow that cycle of the game if you catch on to it I had a table of people
six people a six person
I did not play six
and everyone caught on to it really quick it was a smooth fast game but yeah if people have those hiccups because of the whole like play a card out it becomes this and it feels like a lot of steps if you if you're not getting it
if you are getting it have a whole table that gets it's going to feel like an incredibly smooth card game. So yeah, divisive might be a good way to
it is and one of those things too that one frustration in there a negative in there. I love the cards first off. They're just gorgeously made with the emboss everything on that. But I will say when you go those different player counts, you're going to need to get like one through I think it's like 72 for one, one through 45. So you do have to kind of it takes some time to divide those cards and that could be frustrating,
right?
You know, it does take a bit bit of time. So anyway, um any final thoughts before we go into the final what you think of it?
I just you call out the art. I also find it hilarious that the lower numbers uh are well I should say it this way. The higher numbers are really elegant and beautiful and when you go to the lower numbers they're jank you know it's the same picture of the elevator right like all the greens all the blues the same elevator but you go to the lower levels and there's like spray paint and like broken boxes on like floors one through eight. So
wow I did not know that seems very pointed.
Yeah.
It's it's a fun little visual touch that you kind like as you play a card out.
That's interesting. All right. So, um I'll go first because this card, this game is one of those that when I heard it, I saw at Gen Con being demo. I'm like, "Wow, this sounds really great." But I play it and I think it's just for me it's fine. I I'll go back to it. I don't love it. I think other ones I'd play with it, but I do I found myself playing it a couple times because it is easy to teach. I'm coming in at a six on this one because I I like it. I don't love it. I don't know how often I'd go back to it. I don't think your brain melts as much as some people say it does, but it does kind of I think it's a quick, elegant, elegant game.
I am coming in quite a bit higher. I'm giving this one a 7.5. I think that this is a very slick game. The whole cycle of it is fun and and yeah, if you have tables that get it then even at six players, it feels like it moves at a good brisk pace. Uh, I love the tension, especially near the end of the game because you've had all that time to choose what cards are out and you see what's out. Playing the last three cards out of your hand is certainly most stressful.
Yes,
you have three huge
you have three good elevators like don't mess this up, don't mess this up. But you do have a bit of control in what will be your last few cards. So, I like that touch. I think that uh like I said, that and the nice clever scoring make it a fun, charming game for me. So great production, great artwork and everything and it's just always been a fun time
and so many great decisions in such a small box in a small simple game.
Mhm.
So anyway, that is up or down. Where would you like to live? Where is your floor? Are you one of the lower ones that apparently have crushed up boxes on their elevator or the higher ones that just sip wine with pinkies out?
That's me.
With the beer flows like wine.
Yes. I'm Joey Evans.
And I'm Chris Yay.
And we're on an elevator. Hey folks, thanks for joining us for that video. If you haven't yet, like the video, subscribe to the channel, and hey, make sure you check out what's happening where I'll cover an app on an iOS or a Switch device and you can check it out along with me. Thanks very much. You've been watching the Dice Tower.
Is it on there?
Is it Is it there?
It's It's going. Okay, let's do this.
Oh, I lost it. Do you mind? I'm doing something wrong. I work with children and