Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 1:03:03

some viewers may find the following video disturbing viewer discretion is advised hey everyone welcome back to war Dames and lock and Zack and are doing a discussion over War of the ring with all expansions including the newest one Kings of Middle Earth uh that was announced like 5 years ago and then just for some reason never came out yeah it took them a long time to get out um yeah so of the Ring I think is sitting in like the BGG top 100 or top definit 100 I think it's top 10 um which it's not it's top 20 uh war war if the Ring of the Ring second edition it is number eight okay that is insane cuz this game came out in the second edition came out in 2011 yeah it's old um still getting an expansion that's just released this year so uh if you're uh fans of the channel for a long time I had a run through and a discussion years like six years ago or something uh so this discussion is basically going to replace that we'll talk about the game and then kind of throw go to each expansion uh Lords of Middle Earth Warriors of middlee and out Kings of Middle Earth um and kind of our overall thoughts um but I will say I usually do not like IP games because they're either a lot of them I mean I feel like you get away with IPS more with shows right um versus video games you know video game IP it's like why would I play this when I can play the video game um but a lot of games with an IP just

feel very gimmicky and again only for f hardcore fans of that um it's like I never really saw the appeal uh War of the ring is one of the best games ever made yeah and it's so good it feels like L of the Rings yes um like it's l of the Rings what if like a lot of you do stuff just to be like what if this happened like one of the very first things I did was like bring the Bal Rog out cuz it's like yeah he was in Moria and he stayed there or like I separated Companions and I was like oh I'm just going to move Mary and PPP into fome forest and it's like I really should bring Strider with because there are tactical decisions I need to make in this game versus the memes that realistically if it was if I was trying not to win this game I would just move Mar and Pippen because that would have been fun right and if there's people around everybody would have enjoyed that exactly there's a lot of stuff that you do that is like I mean in many cases it's like okay well what if uh you know the spiders or the um Hillman actually came and attacked Rivendell uh just a lot of that that is not quirky you know it's not like oh man this make this game funny it's if you love Lord of the Rings kind of like Star Wars rebellion this is Lord of the Rings in a box except this is surprisingly still getting supported whereas Star Wars rebellion Fantasy Flight was like well they did the one expansion but this will be the last expansion that's what they stayed at Le so uh they were doing

before they Third Edition yeah I mean if they do a third edition um but it's basically it's now done it's complete um which again just the base game is a lot it is um yeah you're living with the expansions with so many reference sheets constantly like we were actually going to do a run through for it um because I did a run through originally it's like I'll replace that one with a new one um but we were basically living in the in the [ __ ] yeah I've never played this game without going through the rule books during the game yeah just constant nuances I will say the rules are not written all that well um and there is a uh there is a I mean you really like the how to play video um I think it's well done I just think it's kind of more just told at you more than like can you I mean it it's it's pretty good it's better than a lot that are out there and there are honestly this game has a lot of people who are not main uh stage rule explainers teachers out there who do this game yeah like I think harsh does one it's really good but it's forever like if is gritty details yeah and this game is one of those that I I mean I again I haven't played this in so long that what you do is actually not that difficult everything you do is based off the dice right which is all C

right here yep and nice little play the references are there when you are looking through the rules you can go to the index even though it's like the tiniest text imaginable but you're able to quickly find it I will say um I still love this game and the best part is even though this game I I I just lost um it was all I can look back and be like that's where I messed up right um but there's also things that it's like it's a you're gonna have a lot of little stuff like that first fight in Helms Deep I forgot a lot of rolls and it's like that could have made a difference cuz you didn't have a lot of people there therefore you wouldn't have been able to come and attack or think just things like that you forgot two D two rounds with an extra die which in this game again CU your action e is all dice mhm not having a die for two rounds is a big deal especially as the Free People you're conly um down dice although I really feel like I don't know I think if you throw in all expansions which we just did I really think they tilted the favor in the free people's they did for some things so like um mainly the dice economy the dice economy definitely gotten better uh but one things they I would call they helped stop that so like realistically you should have Gan off the white by round two same as you should have zon by round two no later and because of the dice economy because now I could lose dice by having gandal the way out permanently it did encourage me not to push him as fast yeah that's

true um cuz realistically by round two I would have had extra die anyway for a lot of them and like I didn't so realistically for like the extra die ones other than Gandalf which actually helped you because it forced me to do the fellowship which is what you wanted to do anyway I just kind of stopped that because I realized that wasn't helping me that much and so he lost a die and so all I had was Lady for a while yeah got Elon he lasted one turn with his die because it starred on the next one which me I lost it and those dice I mean yeah I I I think they improved a lot but the the feeling could be just I mean we haven't played with every expansion all the time we're not playing this weekly uh that would be crazy they they have the the removal which I also have I have Di have the star on it if I have the mouth of SAR on out no witch King witch king um but your icons also have an eye on them which is interesting um so that that was one thing and I will say it feels very dated uh it could be a lot worse but one of my big things is I don't I really don't like the dice resolution for combat it it's it clearly is like this came out in 2011 again they have a lot of ways to mitigate that with the dualed card so it doesn't it could be worse it could just be whatever they are roll and hope you get fives or sixes there's a lot of stuff you play a card that's like hey you add one or your opponent rolls less or ignore rolls or do away with rolls to get special

abilties so it is a lot better but still a lot of times if you're not drawing those good combat cards and it's like okay yeah I rolled us I still rolled a two and three ones and you rolled all sixes yeah not really I can do much about that cuz one Tipping Point which again you can make it all super thematic right was cuz I don't think you were even looking at Moria until you took orank and then 100% wasn't uh and that roll against Helm I think you were no attacking orth think no it was attacking Helm's de roll like three sixes and it's like there's nothing I can do the way I was going to do that is you didn't have enough to prolong The Siege so I thought I could Outlast and I thought then I might be able to take it I had a car to actually move the dead army into Helm steep oh really really yep over the impassible terrain yes e One card all do so they're ghost and there is a pass technically cuz that's how Aron gets there uh not through Helms Deep where it's from well he it's from Ed from the Edis location yeah same principle of it um and so I had a card and that's why I actually like when you when you attack there if I didn't roll well that's why I was moving Aragon all the way over there to make that dead army it was to then come back and counter but yeah know I wasn't going and then realistically so you have the army that was here and because I moved the ends basically forcing it cuz here was the thing the ends couldn't take this location they could kill everything in that location so um by moving the Army there

it did free up but what I was going to do is use the ends to kill there and kill there and then move my Army yeah it definitely um cuz for the free peoples to win they have to get four yeah points which a lot lot of expansions basically fix the quick attacks yeah uh from the free people just be like I'm going to go take more I'm going to go take Mount gundabad and that's four um yeah cuz there's a point there there's two points there there's two points there and there's two points there that aren't terrible to go pick right I if you decide to just go war path and you just muster I mean that is the the main reason is that you have to basically do a lot of stuff to get them activated a lot of people I remember loved Battle of 5 arm I don't like Battle of armies I think it's very just kind of one note and but a lot of people hate the political track yeah I love the political track I think it adds intrigue and Nuance to the game and theme of like hey why would the dwarves all the way up in the north come all the way down to help it it also slow like for me some of it is it Paces the shadow Army so you have at least one turn because otherwise what happens to me in my opinion is if you didn't have to move any of your stuff down M like you just take everything on round one or two there's no way for me to build up fast enough because I don't have enough dice yeah but that's also a strategy if I roll a bunch of muster I just move CU they all they all start active right so all you got to do is start moving them yeah I think it's what two uh there you started one starts there no two start on

the low end and then one starts at the top right um one start the South run and easterling start there um and then Sauron oh and there they are um yeah so it takes what four musters four musters to get everyone ready and a lot of cards can be like hey if they're all at War to swarm with people um so yeah they but yeah whenever you're playing the game it's like yep that's where I [ __ ] up that sucks uh but at least it's better than being like I don't know what I did wrong yeah um so one thing that's also kind of strange so the other way that the shadow player Wis is by corrupting and there's no basically a lot of what the shadow player does is just kind of like gridlock you almost where it's like I got you up to what six corruption at one point which is halfway and it's like that basically for my end made it feel like that you were like okay I'm not winning that way cuz I was like are you ever going to move them again well part of my problem with why I didn't move them is I didn't get very many character Dice and they kept getting revealed and so it then takes two character dice just to move it m and at that point I was like but if I don't start doing other things to defend locations like honestly I was going to continue moving them but I needed to consolidate a little bit everywhere else cuz I was moving pretty aggressively for a while there and then it was like well

you keep revealing it mhm it's not helping me and then you did the one attack and then honestly that's what flipped the switch from I'm playing this defensively cuz that I'll put this was my original strategy I was going to go for this yeah and I was trying to corrupt you that was my original strategy and I was like okay but then when I won Helm Ste it flipped and I was like okay I think now I can finish this turn and take two points and hold it and I think in the next one to two rounds I'll get two more faster than you can get so here here's my here's my my question after having played this again because I have basically an unlimited number of units that's just limited to the plastic and the 10 on a spot this game doesn't have like a timer on it and I think looking back on playing Star Wars rebellion Star Wars rebellion does have a timer I almost feel like this does need one because if you refuse to move the the fellowship let's just say I keep pumping into the bag and all that and I'm just like okay you keep slowly gaining corruption every time you move and it gets higher than you thought you know cards that I was like oh a Spider goes in there and then boom you know you know like if if you're hesitant to move them so you never move them and I just fortify all my strongholds with 10 units yeah but eventually the thing is you could for file your units and still have enough to go just hit one city at a time and you take two points and again every troop I lose I never get back right

every troop you lose is just a timer before it comes back fighting another War so realistically the long game you will win every long game yeah and that and that's why this to me is the timer so if I can't win like if I don't win the helm steep fight like that or it goes to a stalemate where I don't have any troops but you don't have any troops my only wind is still this now I just have to figure out do I have enough time to fory and move and again some of the problem is yeah you had a lot like so I you would put two like two in and then you would roll two to three more well for me to move that's five like you're going to get corrupt like realistically no I know yeah um I will say though that this because of that very reason though like if like let's just say I did do that like an or thing I just do Saron thing bring them all in and just fortify every place that gives uh to cuz where do do I have anything that you could just not do strongholds and win I don't think so no it's all strong well there's Angar up there that's one point there must be one more vus moral to uh what is that that's Moran and is two Beador is two one below there this one's gorgoth no and this is nor so no oh yeah far far har so I have to go take so you you could take these and then one more right but if I just defended that like realistically I could just be like I am not moving I'm going to let you know that right now I'm not moving and it's like okay uh again I

don't I'm not saying a timer to benefit the shadow player or but it's like you would think that there would be a timer that as if the game is prolonged that the ring wears on him so it's like sure almost you gain a corruption every round but that would be the game would last 12 rounds for that reason it would last cuz you never want to move all that's exactly all that's basically to say the game is long yeah yeah the game is super long it is again Aries does war gaming mhm and so this is a war game so this is um so the people I know who really love this outside of us are people who play like 40K um and play War like real war games not um where like where accent allies is considered a light war game oh yeah you're talking the ones with just cardboard chits everywhere and that's it and I'm like yep that makes sense that's all this game is yeah uh sieges are long and drawn out they're rough yeah sieges suck cuz it's like like all right like basically I moved in there there's no reason why you're not going to cancel that and basically Retreat into your Str strong which is thematic right like it's like okay now I'm going to attack again it's hard to take it but again they limited like cuz like I had more guys in Miss here then could go into the stronghold uh right yeah and then also the fact that it's like okay hey you're

limited on units they're stuck in Helms Deep or they're stuck in Rivendell so you cannot Retreat or you cannot escape and no one can enter like in fact it's like if I just keep people there I can bring more units to keep the fight going I will say one of the things that this expansion did and this is probably more for me I would have used these Elven Rings way earlier in the base game but because they have these cool kind of powers it's like H do I use it now oh yeah the Lord of Middle Earth yeah uh yeah the lord of the Middle Earth expansion it's like do I use the Rings now no should use yeah right but but why should I like well I probably should but it's not the right moment yet and so then I never used it until the very last round to basically win the game but yeah I was like cuz how how many I mean we probably played six seven rounds totality something like that there is no way I've ever played a game where in round three I had used all Rings yeah I'm really trying to figure out like I feel like the expansions all benefited the free people's way more the Warriors definitely did by far warriors did Lords of middle uh earth like with the extra D and like it's like they gave me the balog who was I mean he's cool but it's like okay he's basically going to come out and fight once and that's it well cuz all it takes is for because I have to keep him there so it's like basically what I do is I bring him out and just keep him there yeah so I think I think

the answer for the bog was yes you could move it out you're not supposed to to so it's like why is he even there you because he's super very powerful but that's kind of lame I guess I mean you have gader or what she has to stay in laan I think um I think uh elron does too elron has stay in Rivendell I think so um yeah he has a stay in Rivendell okay uh so like yeah so like they have a St I guess theoretically I could just build up a huge Army in Moran then just boop boop into lauan and Tackle lauran with the with the batt Rog so honestly that's well yeah with b roog um that would have been super useful I mean the only I mean yeah it would have been super useful to do that yeah but I did it cuz I was like oh that'd be cool if the batt Rock attacked Rivendell oh yeah I thought that I mean thematically it was great yeah um but it is very like cuz he can come out and then it's like I'm just going to use this die to get rid of him it's like oh okay yeah I have to use a will of the West which again it's a wild die right um so there's always take but I almost feel like they they should have done it where it's like will of the West to make him inactive and then another die that's why I thought and that's why I looked at the rules cuz I thought okay because that would make sense but it's no it's nope if he's inact if you use a will of West to make him inactive is if he's inactive outside of more Moria then he's gone it's like that's kind of really he's this ancient basically Lesser God being that's just like oh okay and I will say like so yeah the

faction D is fine realistically it's to activate other factions and then draw more faction cards more play faction cards okay it's fine uh yes there are eyes and stars which can get permanently um the other ring bearers die gone they also have the most crappy um Panther card which is just draw one of your event cards isn't that draw oh yeah it was draw yeah cuz there's another one that's draw or play so so it's this it's draw or play which is super useful cuz all the cards can just be played with it but just to draw one like by turn three I have full hand cars continuously cuz a lot of them are situational if they're at the top and then the rest are combat which are sometimes situational right uh mine had a tendency to be very situational most of my cards required a companion mine needed minions to Forfeit leadership a lot and then the fights that were happening I didn't have leadership right um but at the same time kind of like what you said people this is a war game I get notes of um I haven't played access and allies but definitely Twilight Struggle where it's like it benefits you to know what your opponent can do right um and if you play with all expansions that's a lot to keep track of there just a lot it's basically like once you were getting characters out I I was like I don't know what they do and I don't want I'm I'm not going to retain it yeah honestly cuz like if I again a good example I mean the promo cards I'm not counting cuz they're promos and those are [ __ ] so I'll put this way um

honestly getting out uh Theoden was so Theoden was good uh theand honestly wasn't super useful mhm um cu the leadership die really doesn't do you any good because it's replaces one of your other die right that's it and it's fine like what it does it's basically no better than any of your other dieses and I never used his power which was basically if you had three dice in the hunt box you'd only get to roll two dice instead of three by using his one time ability and that's it other than he was a leader so if you attacked a location he counts as another leader Chie oh damn it what I was supposed to have a shadow ruler die whenever I bring out a dark Chieftain that's what this one is no that's what this one is yeah what the [ __ ] is this one oh maybe it's another characters die that's a leader as well I think I was forg getting some dice oh well it doesn't matter uh cuz I'm trying to remember what this poopy one is this one is one of them is for the so so the for the kings of Middle Earth that's this one yep and then the black one which would replac one of your red dice yes um oh you have the you all the rule books uh which one do you need both of them cuz I just wait I just want to know what the the black Dy

is um yeah so that's the shadow one so would it came from this one oh it's a gothmog it's another I have the bow roog and gothmog um anyway so what I was saying is like for example if you're playing with Warriors you moving Aragorn down to like Rush this way it's like oh I bet you that's what he's doing he's trying to get them activated so he can bring them into the fight uh and so a lot of stuff like that is tied into the IP and the lore um but from a game mechanic standpoint if you play this game a lot you're going to have those nuances of like oh I bet you that's why he's doing that which is why I don't know if you notice it in the rules of kings the very last page has competitive play for this rul I saw that I skipped that immediately like who plays this for competitive levels uh yeah competitive tournament rules and I was like okay like I'm never going to play this game enough for that no um yeah so the dead men and the ants play very similar um the dead men basically there's a card that again The Ant and the dead men have have a card for you to basically move them at all they can't just be moved with any action but then like so the ends you remove one from their um more but they basically make these chains and you can go kill anything in around their chains fairly well the dead men every time they move you remove a dead man every time they attack they move a dead

man from the entire thing but for if you as long as you have one in there you get a roll three dice at four do you instant win with them with something no no I just thought they were super powerful if they came in well did something because like let's say you take Manus tith and I have four of them at man tith I get attacked four times rolling three dice at four better for every single time I have one I just keep removing so basically I can clean off a castle or a stronghold yeah um now pretty much at that point you're probably done with them cuz they're getting eliminated that's true but so yes so them and the Ant are kind of these one things now what the ants do is if I use the ant to attack um Al gillath or um uh or think orth think if they killed everything that was there it just Auto dies it becomes mine instantly I don't need troops there like normal gotcha um yeah my my next plan was cuz I I completely forgot about Moria um I was eventually going to start sweeping this way and I was like okay well he he's not going to be able to get enough units um to be able to deal with this um and honestly like corrupting um couple of my leaders like in both locations cuz you had armies basically at the doorsteps like well those cities are now done and that's exactly yeah so now we can talk about Kings of Middle Earth um I don't really like it it was fine yeah it it's

like which is a shame because it took so long to come out I really think Warriors is the best one yeah Warriors definitely changed the game the most yeah it yeah it really did uh Lords is is good just to get extra like unique characters to come out uh very situational but Kings adds this like Sovereign uh yeah The Sovereign corruption board and basically five Kings of all the different nations so you have brand which is the Northman Dane for dwarves denior for Gondor uh Theoden for Rohan and Thell for the elves right and the shadow player can basically use eyes from his hunt box to be able to try and corrupt them and you just draw us from the bag and they all have like a threshold um if he does that and he hits her threshold they become corrupted which means you they're mine now but pretty much all they do is um they limit your ability to increase your main city strongholds uh your Capital Cities yeah you just can't well you just um you can't recruit there anymore you just can't recruit in those regions I think um well I guess specifically where they're at like thru for example you just can't recruit in the Woodland realm right um and if I go to attack it uh then I can get rid of regular units to keep the siege going instead of Elites so it's like you do that once per turn um so it's like okay I attack Woodland

realm in this case with a bunch of regular units and you know a couple Elites it's like I mean you're going it's it's a lot easier to win those fights yeah which again those are some of the harder fights to win right especially because I have I mean the shadow player has to get 10 points to win so he has to take strongholds yeah now I think feel like they were incredibly strong on my side Theoden was definitely the strongest with the first round combat his leadership went up to three Yeah so basically getting three roll on that that's pretty solid honestly yeah um especially if you're rolling five dice just having one person that's like three rolls that's really good right um now beyond that again they're probably all again it's it's very situation most of the power hour in this game sometimes are a little bit like oh man that's a little over the top yeah but situational like so I had a card in my hand that allowed me to roll three dice uh five or better I take back all my rings that I've spent oh gotcha I'm like okay if you roll three dice the the chances are you're going to get and you have to have them all spent to roll three so you get one roll for every ring you've spent so if you spent them all realistically you might get one ring back yeah and if I haven't spent them cuz and you haven't spent them right so in this game a lot of powers can be great but they're situational mhm yeah a

lot of ones that I had were like oh hey if um like I weirdly got a lot that said if smeagle was your guide yeah and he basically came out immediately and then died which I think is supposed to like the chances are pretty slim cuz it's two tiles off of like 15 16 tiles you can I think you can add two more yeah I discarded that card I drew it and I was like oh I need to discard cuz if he's your guide he's basically a buffer yes he's pretty strong buff with that but then I actually just read one that was like if he's your guide um this gets played on the table oh man where was it and basically each smeagle tile adds to corruption yeah so again it's those type of things where it's like okay now we're talking just bad like it it's this mixture of really good and really bad mhm getting smigle early on kind of is terrible because like I want to use the fellowship to remove corruption and separate but getting smeagle right away meant I had to have him always as my guide and I'm like if he had been the second to the last or third to last one I'd be like oh that's awesome yeah that's the greatest CH you know thing to do yeah cuz I would have just split them all mhm but at that point I was like but none of them got to suck up corruption at this point yeah yeah they uh it does feel like that they did with all the expansions they did everything in their power to remove a meta yeah you know because this game definitely had a meta it's like almost basically follow the movies yeah or

follow the the books whichever one uh and now with all the expansions that is it it turned a lot more into what if you a lot more options uh but yeah I like the kings of Middle Earth just kind of for how much it came it came out or how long it took to come out didn't really care it basically allowed me to stall more not having to use all my dice just to pull it out and pull from the bag but at the same time if I really want to corrupt them it's like if I draw a three it's like oh well that's going to get Theoden or denior or brand right um but then that's going to go be discarded and that's not a three that's going to hit you right to me it's it's that idea that oh you as the shadow player are not going to go for a ring corruption Victory you're going to go for I'm gonna go take five strongholds that are now going to be easy to take yeah and that's it and let's do it that per because again to me what is is now as me as the fellowship if I'm going to go for a ring Victory I have to like I want you to pull those and you don't want to pull those until I've played all my movement I want you to pull those and corrupt people so I can then get cheaper movement M but you're waiting and then you have a stall yeah cuz before what was is the ship always had like free people had stall for a lot of it because you normally would have more dice you just kep rolling enough eyes just like it's like oh we have the same number it's like yeah I just put three in the

hunt box yeah and that's that's actually the part that kind of sucks at some point it's like well you're not moving right so and I actually kind of find this you know this is probably a negative on my end the fact that I don't have an active way to hunt you right if I don't get cards that just allow me to drop tiles on you um then it's like okay like there goes that uh but again if I if you're not moving and I let's say I allocate two in the hunt for the ring and then I roll four eyes it's like there's six dice in there that are now dead right and that's like okay well I had no control over that um so now you're definitely not moving so again some of the things why this game for me is always a struggle because it has so much so like you attacked Helm I could have even made it worse for you I could have played this so for the entire fight you couldn't play any cards oh yeah yeah I mean I really feel like a lot of my cards I got this round were not amazing see so this is where I do actually feel like this game always every time I play I felt like all your cards were great oh that's funny and i' that's what I've always felt with this game it always feels like always the losing playing this game and every it doesn't matter which side I play is the shadow I'm always feeling like oh so far with the ring and then he's like I'm at

[ __ ] five corruption already like how am I going to survive this yeah uh no I mean I'm definitely not saying this game is unbalanced I'm just saying there there are slight nitpicks that I have um about both sides and that's just because the game's dated and in large and complex and yeah like if you're going to play this game like just make a day out of it especi like like cuz you can play The Hunt for the ring game which is basically a hidden movement game until the fellowship gets into rivendel and they have rules like if you did shitty in that game you start with corruption right like as the fellowship if I if you did great you get like benefits from the the draw bag and stuff because it's like oh I have no idea where the Ring's at right uh I think that's a really awesome cuz AR's made that game as well so that's really cool that they tied it in but do a whole [ __ ] Lord of the Rings day like I mean look up Lord of the Rings recipes and drinks and then play hunt for the ring on a taable Topper pull that up and then boom you have War of the Rings set up and just do a whole Lord of the Rings event cuz it is going to be epic and you can actually do that even with five armies too it change there oh did they tie tie it into this I it changes how the north ends up oh interesting like how this whole region up here at the top up and it does change it depend on who wins so there you go you do Battle of Five Armies hunt for the ring and the ring and that is your entire day right um so I mean to be fair

I think a lot of my more like there like there are negatives like I don't like just rolling dice be like okay cuz there's no control even if you play cards to modify it um yeah you don't that's pretty much it I mean I didn't really like the kings of the Middle Earth expansion I I probably would always play with Lords of Middle Earth and Warriors of Middle Earth Kings probably not so I'm probably going to include Kings because it didn't add nor subtract almost anything to me and so then why burdens some with extra rules you know because the people I want who I'm going to play this game with are going to be the type that want to play with everything gotcha yeah I think I'm I'm definitely at this point where it's like yeah yeah this game took forever to set up forever to learn again yeah setup is brutal so it was like and then it just added like more stuff that I was trying to keep track of and I'm like yeah but that kind of didn't that was like kind of a nothing expansion yeah so like I mean I guess it's better than being [ __ ] right but they were just kind of there you know like whenever I corrupted you know uh uh denior and Dane I'm like I guess I did that yeah the denor for me was more critical cuz it's like cuz normally I can hold Miss Earth for a long time yeah but then like the minute you did that cuz like I had a lot of elit that was going to start pumping into there and I was like well that's

done and I had like two cars that allowed me to drop stuff in and it's like but one required Bor Mir to be there oh yeah and I was like well that's just not happening yeah and maybe I mean to be fair like we haven't played Kings of Middle Earth a lot that easily like and that's the great thing about this game is you look back and you can be like oh if I do this next time like it's like boom I'm going to try and get denior ahead of time and then start sweeping because now you're limited on how you're getting units in there so Min tith Falls yeah which if Min tith Falls that means pelar and Dole alth are basically falling and what it really does is now sauron's Army can now move much more freely again like the books in the movies m tith is the problem right once they took m tith it was done yeah and like I've known that like if the shadow player can take M to Earth early mhm you are now fulltime REM mode yeah well yeah exactly especially because it's like okay boom you had I don't remember how many units start in there but like let's say you take Min T that's two points great well he's still corrupted so the the only reason to get the only way to get rid of him is getting a free people's Nation or barir right to basically run down there and get rid of him so then it's like okay you can't recruit in there anymore but now it's easier to take because I can just put a bunch of Elites in there and regulars and just pop a regular out to keep the siege going yep and now all your Gondor people are dead right and then that's 2 three four five I don't think there's anything I don't think there's anything yeah so that's already half the points you need just from this

alone right and so it's definitely fighting a war on two fronts and I and I think Kings of Middle Earth probably has the it has a higher chance of going up from me liking it than it being it going down I just feel like it didn't feel as impactful as warriors did for sure oh yeah Warriors definitely felt most impactful but I think what for me the Warriors felt impactful because it made the free people have a potential for an offense 100% yeah the Eagles are like can the Eagles ANS and the um I mean I will say the Warriors for the like the factions that the Warriors brought in for the free are way [ __ ] cooler oh than the the Sauron or the The Shadow player I get I mean the spiders are cool like but then it's like okay the the skanks the dunland people right um and I kept here's the funny enough I kept want to bring the corsairs in yeah because oh the super movement yes and last time I played this I did that I focused on them cuz I took the boats up the and then that's how I attacked oh the north I was super scared like I kept waiting for you to do it and I was like cuz otherwise there's nothing I can do over there no exactly well the problem that I was facing was again with all expansions trying to manage um cuz you kept blocking a lot of stuff trying to you know make sure you didn't get all them and all their benefits and they need the South runs and easterlings to be at War and they're actually the furthest to I mean again it's not hard it's four musters to get everyone at War

for me I mean it's two must but I also never rolled musters I know and so I was whenever I was doing it it was like okay shobs and the D the duning d The Dun lings uh they were easier to do and I was trying to take Helms Deep and Rivendell uh and have all the dunlins kind of split right to help that but then I would have taken Rivendell but then you're like oh I'm just going to use this die to get rid of the B roog it's like okay that's [ __ ] stupid so that and that's why I did it because I was like okay if the balog's there I'm probably going to lose rendale yeah and I was like my gut reaction was if I could get rid of the balro you weren't going to attack riend no I'm no and I I Absolut I might I'd like to know I'd like I'd probably house rule that like like because as the battle roog player to even use him I have to roll that result um which is 33% of the time right so then it'd be nice with this demigod kind of being that it's like okay you use a will of the West to inactivate it because he doesn't do anything like he he literally cannot do anything if he's at a zero right um so then it's like okay then I have to roll this to activate him again and that's only one die you could theoretically have two will of the West could um so it's like if you have one you inactivate him then you get rid of him it's like okay yeah they use two of yours even if he's inactive and I spend that to reactivate him I have to wait a whole another turn and hopefully roll him to then activate him which you always get to go first right so then you

could use so I like that tug of warar with him um I don't think he's as powerful as like as just getting using a die to pop him out I don't know yet though this is I'm just I I'm just I know I mean to me again I think the principle for him was his value is holding Moria and that could be entirely the case but then that kind of goes against the whole what if sure it's like what if the balog wasn't Moria what do you mean what if he [ __ ] was right and then again the only way to get rid of him at that point is that's likeand that's like the ends go through fangorn they start there but it's like you can have them sweep all the way down they didn't attack Helms Deep right they so you still have a lot more nuance and I can't really do much with the the ants or the the dead people or the Eagles whereas all you have to do is spend a die to get rid of one them I'm just saying well only be out cuz like again that's like Elon and gadriel they don't move at all so I mean you also get three of them and extra dice well two of them Gandalf I mean you always had Gandalf um but but he didn't give you a die yeah but it it does encourage you to do the hunt true because that because I don't get the die if I don't move the fellowship yeah I'm just more curious if people have I highly doubt it but if people have played well I guess uh the battle Ro is not even Kings of Middle Earth that's Lords of Middle Earth um so

people would have played that I'm just curious if people have ever tweaked with the idea of the batt roog not being so easy to get rid of um and I don't know about gothmog I didn't bring him out uh yeah so so I mean it could be one of those things where I play a game of this and try it be like hey that um house ruling it takes two you have to you have to make him inactive um and then do it again and maybe it's like no that's too much work and you just swept the entire door just power that could easily be the case I don't know maybe someone has tried that uh but this game absolutely has a lot of tug and War it does my perfect element of random um Randomness where it's like because Randomness to me like imagine if you wanted to do something you're like I want to move hope I roll the move die oh I didn't get it so I guess I can't do that yeah you roll at the beginning and then you can start making a plan for what you have like you're hoping for stuff like I'm really hoping like I really want to get the Southerns South sou South Southerns South RS and Easter it's like I really want to get them activated [ __ ] I only got one mustard damn okay or hey I got I got that wild right do I use that on a muster just to get them active h but that's decision making that is still random but I never feel like the game is thrown one way or the other because of the action dice yeah I can kind of sometimes feel the game could lean uh based off combat

but I've played this game I have played this game quite a bit and I have won evenly both sides yeah I probably I played this fair amount and I will say always now it's always just been base game this the first time with an expansion and I always felt the shadow had the slight Advantage okay um I would love to know that data this game is definitely old enough I'd love to know if cuz people do that with like uh summon rewards it's like hey actually these factions together like win pretty evenly I'd love to know the data of like which side actually wins more of all the tnow player WIS of time that fings or and or hell even like base game like Shadow player wins 70% time you add in Lords of Middle Earth drops to 65 sure that data would be really cool um and it's just epic like I was actually really hoping you'd get to Mount uh Mountain Doom just to cuz I like that takes you basically it takes you five rounds to get there or five movement and then you just have to take corruption the entire time and it's like oh I mean that's that's a nasty one and draw that one and it's like oh okay you're taking well in that case two corruption but could be six and you're at six not with the way you were rolling no I was rolling like ass this whole [ __ ] game dude it was bad I'm throwing those dice away well I mean you shouldn't cuz I rolled them and they rolled fantastic that's right they were

just on the side of good today that's fair that's fair I mean can't can't be mad I mean the the free people's did win in in all of it um what would you so let's see talk about Kings of Middle Earth it it's okay you and I like Warriors the best yeah of the expansion been my first Lords I think was the yeah it was the first one that came out it was kind of more of a modular hey and well I mean you actually got to experience more Lords came with all the alternate yeah characters what do you think of those um I remember you were looking through and you're like oh my God this is hard again it was one of those things where it's like oh these would be so good situationally like so Mary and Pippen I was trying to remember so like if they're the guide the new ones they get eliminated out of the game completely they don't separate when they take corruption but they get remove all the corruption it's like okay that's cool because they only normally have one leadership so theoretically if you draw three I can just get rid of all three corruption but they're now gone yeah versus in the old one I subtract one from whatever you pulled but now they're out and they move and they can go help an army somewhere because realistically that's where I was like when I play base game like again round two I'm pretty much sping most of the fellowship out because leaders and leaving Rivendell and was like what the f because leadership is so important in fights like just being able to roll like in companion normally had something else

that helped them like legal and gimle were super like once they gave like a plus W to stuff when they were fighting it's like okay I don't care if these people die they're going to help hold lauran for that full extra round or two rounds and that might make it or break the game yeah here it was like well these companions are kind cool but there's just so much variables that like I don't know that this will ever come into effect yeah I just don't know and those situational ones like are usually really powerful which again is very cool cuz War of the ring is what if uh all that which is why I don't know like for something and I'm not a huge Star Wars fan so like Star Wars rebellion never really gave me that same what if feeling um and this one always did and that could just be because I love L of the Rings and I don't really like Star Wars so I wasn't getting into it as much but yeah there's just so much like so I felt that with um um the Star Wars I'm sure most people did it was like oh this is full what if what if you froze Darth th and carbonite and took them hostage right what if nobody got the Death Star plans like and what if you know you put the plans on all that on and nobody went and search right next to it right next to the core cuz like I've done that like where I'm like oh you can put right there right next in the mid and nobody PL nobody goes to the middle one they

all like oh it's definitely one of these Corner ones they start it's like or it's like y that's that's right right next to where you start yeah yeah uh and the cool thing about this game is it also it does feel like that both players are still playing the same game but just I wouldn't call the super asymmetric um but it uh it does still feel like that we that we're doing different things like the the action cards and stuff feel like hey this is all for me like it's also massive so it just takes a long time to do stuff that is in Rebellion it doesn't take that long for you to start accomplishing goals here or searching planets and here you take an entire round just to build the Army then you take an entire round just to move it halfway across the field then you take an entire turn just to get at the door and you take an entire round just to start The Siege no you that is a very good point you get the [ __ ] South runs and easterlings it's like cuz I had a card that was like cuz I was going to start sweeping them up like attack Min tith and then have have my the South runs come in the card I had um was basically like I could summon them but they had to come from over here yeah and I'm like well that's way too far and that to me is where this game does feel because lther needs to said medieval warfare mhm Medieval Warfare is fairly slow right and so you do get to have this I call this experience of like just kind of watching it's like huh that arm is just

marching and there's nothing I can do about it yeah cuz the Free People you can't go meet them on the field of combat you could and it's going to be like the movie and you're just going to get slaughtered and then you're going to bring back whatever you have left to hold the city for a little while and because you did that it's going to be even worse that is true that's true I mean I guess you could send a couple people out cuz then you you just stall like you're like hey I'm going to send two people out that's going to block your whole movement just to walk in there and I mean you can you only rolled one Army die sorry bro you have to use it to attack these two [ __ ] right uh with your entire massive Army right and so so like you could do that but there is such a cost and there's a known cost value in that again if you're actually relying only on dice which is why these action cards are awesome and this the action cards are what give me that Twilight Struggle feel of like now not in the same way of like if I play this this is a really good benefit but it's going to give you a [ __ ] ton of action points or whatever yeah um there's none of that but there is a lot of stuff play on the table right and again that's more play on the table stuff that's like if you have all expansions included that's like I [ __ ] forgot that was over there like the one I remembered was you can't attack lauran rivendel or and I'm like oh right I'm like cool I wasn't never going to go after lauran but it was definitely Rivendell and then uh grey Havens was so far over there I'm like that's never happening yeah um but they have all those on the table and they explicitly say it on the cards of how to get rid of it right so the information

is there it's just up to the player to remember attention and remember and which if you don't play this game for years on end you're just trying to retain how to play the game if you again for the people who are playing this game a lot a lot of these aren't going to be a problem like you're just going to know or you're going to have notebooks of basically kind of overarching strategies like oh if he doesn't put X number of dice into the hunt box then I definitely move with as many swords as I can and I mitigate with this stuff yeah and this game which has the benefit because a lot of games that have this kind of rule set are new so it's like okay no one's making anything 100 bucks there's Forums on BGG that are condensed right um either rules or it's instead of looking through oh which one had that die with oh my God it's Allon one yeah things like that I don't know that for sure but I would be very very surprised if there was not something that made cuz I mean um battar galac something like that like a condensed colored uh rule set um a on trespass obviously has that so people will make do everything in their power to make great games like this easier manageable yeah uh one thing I do think that is absolute dog [ __ ] like and this is actually probably my biggest negative I [ __ ] hate the the Miniatures oh yeah they are awful and not only in that in one because they you have a cap limit of 10 um

they look so identical yeah like it's like which ones the Rohan units they're the ones with the horse on The Shield is that a horse and I will say so the base game versus the expansions the expansion used a way better plastic mhm than the originals the originals are super soft yeah um so everyone's Spears are like limp dicks yep um now I have Hur and I'm just never going to pay the money to get collector's edition that gu not fixing the collector's edition they're all painted they're all painted they're higher grade Plastics they're L like uh the board's larger MH um everything's just a little nicer but you're talking stupid money what is it like two grand or something I've seen it for Grand and 1500 I almost still years ago like I'm talking years ago whenever I had a lot more Expendable income someone was selling a collector's tion and I almost talked him into let having him let me make payments on it and he like yeah but I'm not shipping until it's paid for I'm like that's fine but he had someone who bought it out right like that's fair yeah I mean this would definitely be a game that I would love the Collector's Edition for um but yeah I'm not dropping $1,000 on it it's not going to get played enough for me and it's not it doesn't look good enough sitting on a shelf for a grand I got other things I'll spend a grand on that sit on my shelf yeah nope I completely agree so other than that in fact I even like the fact that the the expansion came with better like cuz it's a darker

thing so they're easily recognizable um I don't know if there's like a cheaper alternative to fixing that because it's like people paint the bases so you I was actually going to okay so you take the colors of the Nations and you paint the Bas idea yeah uh the problem is the plastic is again of a bad quality that you have to do some stuff to get the paint to really stick well got it but and my other problem is there are multiple factions that are absolutely Ely so close in color that it's still hard to understand which one was which if you just do it by paint uh yeah yeah you really have to make sure that what you're getting cuz it's like I mean cuz technically you can merge units in this game uh of the same of different factions however like for example I think one of the reasons I didn't attack minth early on was because I had South run and easterlings in there and they weren't at War so they can't actually fight so I'd have to leave them behind but they look so identical I bet you money if I did attack we wouldn't have noticed yeah except you had an elite and I noticed the oh yeah I guess the elephant is there um but yeah otherwise I probably wouldn't have noticed um yeah uh you paint the bases and that's a good idea and you just paint the bases so and you can literally basically just dip um yeah I guess that's true and you leave the top so it's all the same red and blue cuz Sauron is yellow or not Sauron sauron's red the South runs are orange and think is iard is yellow okay yep

you're right and then you have light blue brown and then it's the greens that are the problem so you have this light green for the elves and then you have a dark green somewhere else I guess you don't really have to match exactly what this color is you just do a dark green and a light green sure but still like again why on Earth do you have the two factions that are super close to each other with the same color that's true the elves and ran both of the same color like don't do green like you could have yeah that's true and two Blues you have a light blue and you have a dark blue and I'm like there are more colors on the wheel everybody not in 2011 there weren't there were no there were only two genders in 2011 now there's eight no it's like make this like super political out of nowhere it's like whoa that didn't add up but yeah other than that yeah it's a great game but I mean yeah spend it Grand and then you won't have to deal with that problem um but it also muddies up the board like it gets really like okay I'm going to move I'm going to move these into oh my God that's the other complaint is there's so many cars that just give you a name if you are not familiar with the Realms of midle Earth yeah super hard like so I had a card that that moved the ant more to the Old Forest and I was like looking all around there for I like well it's not there it's like oh but they had their wives in the sh so I started looking around the sh and there it was like that's it right yeah yep there's not a whole lot which nowadays if this game came out there' probably a picture on the C um even at the time they could picture

on the true that that's true but it's Aries and they're somehow still a company blows my mind that they're still around but yeah so other than that I mean this game's [ __ ] fantastic yep it's fantastic so on scale of 1 to 10 Let's uh let's do the game okay and then we'll do the three expansions yeah so on scale 1 to 10 what are you just giving War of the Ring no I me half that's exactly where I meant too I was like I can't I can't give it a 10 anymore because I gave quite a few nitpicks that and negatives that it's like they they do kind of annoy me a little bit um so yeah N9 and a half uh that's that's a perfect perfect one so then we go to Lords of Middle Earth uh just by itself uh eight I'm GNA go probably I might go a six no I really hate how they [ __ ] over the balro uh it's I mean because again I think you're right he's just supposed to sit in Moria but then that goes kind of against the whole whole shiel so um well you don't have to it's just a risk it is a risk but yeah the reward isn't as big right so yeah um I do still think I'd always have it um because I do also like how much extra stuff they gave I'll give it a seven I I think I think I don't really

like it as much as the shadow people but overall it really gave a lot of cool stuff to the free peoples yeah uh warriors uh 10 yeah I agree I I really like yeah Warriors expansion um it frees up so much of this game for both sides too sides they gave yeah they gave the free peoples the offense and then they gave the Shadow People Mobility utility stuffff it's like which is what both sides were lacking pretty much like it'll just speed up your because that's the thing it's like I still need 10 to win but it takes me forever to get over there except men tith which is just so it's like now oh man these corsairs can right like oh the dunland they're right in the middle so they they have they're attack they're close to a lot of stuff yeah um no Warriors just definitely a 10 if you're looking for an expansion that is the that's the one to get I think and then the newest one Kings of Middle Earth for me it's probably a seven really okay yeah um I'm at a five right now I think it's like right there uh it didn't really feel like it did much for you didn't do much for me um so the the reason why I'm giving a seven is Theoden honestly felt like Theoden yeah um and for me that's what the and honestly uh denior felt like the corrupted denior weakening yeah what he do for you if you had him um uh you may use a muster action die to replace one of your gond during regular

army with an elite unit from then on so basically I could just start converting my regulars into elites in that location got it with just any muster die so instead of placing you know taking one from my reinforcements or losing a guy basically I could just make five Elites in that one spot and then start Ping leaders that's pretty gross yep and so that again I'm like okay that's pretty good yeah it's not bad yeah so again like I'm putting Kings right as a at a five but I could see it going up the more it gets played the more strategies and nuances you see but I mean all of them are still adding a [ __ ] ton of variety yeah like which is great because like I said war the ring at first feels like it definitely has a meta yeah and even if it's a slight one like even if it's like a oh turn two you have this character out or you're always going to attack whatever laurian I like even just a slight meta is still annoying to me it's like well okay like let's just skip all that and let's just say we did that and start the game from there now that is not the case it's like oh man what am I going to do right so yep that's it that's you got anything else no cool well that's our thoughts on war of the Ring Lord Lords of Middle Earth uh Warriors of Middle Earth and the newest expansion Kings of Middle Earth um let us know what you think of the game in the comments below other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time upd it is for

you hey everyone thank you for watching and I really hope that you enjoyed the video if you would like to see more of my content go ahead and click that subscribe button and the bell to be notified whenever I upload any new content if you feel like supporting the channel you can go ahead and click that patreon link to be taken to my patreon and any help is truly appreciated other than that stick around for any any other run throughs or reviews or cool top 10 or whatever I feel like putting on other than that like comment share and subscribe and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you

Progress saved