Skip to main content
Loading video...

Forever Home - Board Game Review - Who Doesn't Love Dogs?

Transcript 19:29

catch a cupcake you'll get it

buddy hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and this is the broken me Po a show where I talk and rant about board games usually more the latter we'll get on with the video in just a second but first my sponsor with a quick word as Gamers we find it hard to deal with empty shelves some worse than others you therefore want a supplier that has what you need at affordable prices and delivers on time for me that supplier is Kender they offer a discount on bulk purchases as well as a point scheme for future Acquisitions down the line if there's a hot title you're after chances are kender's got it Wings man mine Arc no mine Eclipse actually I hate that game it's terrible but you might like it if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection a ft of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so we got a very simple one for you today probably a short video as a result this is forever home this is the newest release from birdwood games who some fans might recognize as the creators of dog park this is a game which I have not played yet but it's on my agenda to review in the future along with this expansion dog tricks and you know anything else that it might have but this is the newest one again keeping with that whole dog aesthetic and I mean you know side plot I do love dogs I probably think I'm more of a cat person but I still really love dogs I just like animals in general frankly I will fall in love with your pets as long as they've got less than eight legs and I'm I'm totally down for it but this one is a pattern building game where you're essentially laying out patterns and trying to complete these cards which

will give you points but also let you graduate these dogs into different homes like foster homes the city suburbs Etc to score points in various different ways it's meant to be a very simple game very light it boasts only 45 minutes absolute Tops on the box so I'm totally down for something that's short and sweet and cute so the question is is there enough in this game to actually make it fun or is it going to be forgettable the rules to Forever home are very straightforward you essentially carry on until somebody has completed seven of these training cards which have the different patterns that you're trying to make on there you have two actions per turn you have only three actions to pick from you have a face up display of these training cards along with some of the these actual dogs of different color tiles and basically your two actions are to take a dog that's available and stick it somewhere on your board take one of these cards and keep it basically in front of you or to actually move a dog on your grid that's it that's essentially what you can do in your term but what you're trying to do is you're trying to make the patterns on these cards so for example I've got one here that requires me to make a pattern of three dogs two of which have to be the same type of dog and there's a space in the middle so for example I could take two red here uh let's take the basic side of the board for now we'll go on to the other bit later and so there's a red dog there there's a red dog there there's a space in between so at that point I have completed this card and therefore it's one of the seven that I've done now these cards will give you some points for the end of the game but there's another feature you've got four different locations where these dogs are effectively being essentially you're teaching them tricks and they're getting to go to different homes so you've got City suburbs Countryside and Foster

homes and so these cards will tell you how many dogs you graduate from this training school to the different homes and you choose where they're going to go your incentive for putting them in certain locations though is that you have some scoring cards that are set up before the start of the game like Countryside wants three of the same dog you get six points uh foster home is the safety one one for every dog uh but then a suburbs here might give you six points if you can get three very specific dogs three points if you only get two one if you get one you know there's very easy scoring opportunities here so it's up to you whether you go for the simple ones or try and gun for the big stuff on top of that you've also got some additional scoring opportunity with the dogs where these little meatles are set up before the game starts and essentially it will reward you with more points if for certain things like on your board or in the different homes Etc you've got the most of a particular color dog so you know most rehomed dogs well if the board is set up with a red dog there then I'll get free points if I have the most red dogs rehomed at the end of the game and these will be different every round you'll still have the same free criteria but the colors of dogs will be different which doesn't change up the game dramatically but it just means that there's an incentive not just to Simply grab whatever colors you feel like the colors are not just relevant for some of these and some of the tricks they're also relevant for this board as well and play Just carries on with everyone taking turns until somebody has completed seven of these cards and then you just tally up the points and see who wins that's easy so yeah this game ain't hard at all it really isn't I mean this is the rule book it's a very thin rule book and

that's got to incorporate the solo mode in the index as well so I mean there's your index here's your solo game rules there's one page for the advanced side of the board and then this is setup and then three pages to explain the entirety of the rules of the game and the rule book is pretty sound and I didn't really find it there was really any ambiguity in here though I think one or two questions I had were actually answered relatively quickly by an FAQ at the end of the book so this is by all means a Gateway game this is something that you could teach to just about anybody and because it's got a very good aesthetic with the whole retraining of dogs it's going to appear to a lot of people as well now of course there's no real theme in this game you know the whole thing of oh I'm training dogs with new tricks and graduating them to different homes whatever this is an abstract pattern building game at the end of the day but that being said this is a very well produced product for the P for the money you're paying and if you are going to give me a straight up abstract game then just embrace the fact it's abstract and make it look nice this game is not trying to hide that it's an abstract game it's not trying to say oh yeah check out the Thematic of you know taking your various breeds of dogs and arranging them in weird little squares and stuff it's like it's not trying to lie to your face about it like some games do it knows what it is but if you're going to do it it does it by making it super super pretty this game is gorgeous I mean these tiles yeah they're nothing to speak of like artwise but they are decent thick quality tiles they come in their really nice like

really good custom soft bag you know really good you can get your hand in there nice and easy the cards themselves great they've all got pictures of all these cute little lovely doggies falling around there you cute little lovely doggies and different poses and even the back of the card is immensely detailed I mean youve got like a sort of small family here or like a dog Watcher or something and then you know they're teaching the dog Lassie or whatever it is to you know do the poor it's got detailed foliage grass clothing the dog hair everything is just really good and that's just the back of the card you've then got the board then got these Taro size location cards everything in here just looks so beautiful so you got to give credit to the artist Dominique vassi and Dawn May and some of you might be able to Twig that Dawn may also appears as an artist on dog park so there's definitely some overlap in terms of it I mean dog park I've still not played it fully yet but you know you can't deny it looks gorgeous on the table well this is another thing so it's got the Aesthetics it's got the Simplicity it's definitely going to be a Gateway game that appeals to a lot of people unless you absolutely hate dogs you'll get into the theme of this I mean how much did I go on a rant with everyone saying that dragons were better than birds with worms ban you know and you know if you're one of these people who thinks that dogs are the bane of all existence and you prefer cats to that extent then fine but you know for the most part most people don't hate dogs with a passion and should be able to get into something like this I think not baby puppy so I didn't have to explain a lot of rules you might be thinking there's not a huge amount of

meat to this game and no I don't mean dog meat this one though still has you putting in a decent amount of effort to think about what you're doing because it's not just simply oh I'll just stick these things on randomly and then I'll make a pattern and all is well and good the thing that you have to note is that even if your pattern requires say three dogs or five dogs in order to do you only graduate a certain number of them typically between one and I think it's only between one and three I don't remember ever seen a fourth but that means that not every dog leaves your board so you might have made this really cool pattern with all right I got you know three pink dogs here and two green ones yeah made a nice cross here but then the card only says you graduate three of them so which ones do I graduate two green and the pink three pink you know um you know none of the greens both greens one green and where do I put them do I put one in the city one in the countryside you know you can cherry pick it to your heart's contempt but it means that some of the dogs are still going to be left on your board hopefully to synergize with more other training cards so yes I have completed this one I'm now going to graduate all the pink dogs and because I you know I'm rewarded for having a lot of you know pink dogs in this particular B I'm putting them in the countryside sorted all right what's the next card I've got let's see I need uh H I need let's see I need three in a colum that are all the same type oh look I've already got two green here that are the same but I just need a green dog boom done graduate one dog um okay I'll put this one in the city then I'm still left with more dogs on the board does it synergize with another pattern and this carries on throughout the game it gives you you know because you've got the different incentives for the four different

locations they can go to as well as the extra points you're getting for this board at the end you know the color has become important but also just the fact that the training cards always want you to have usually at least one type of dog at most two types of dogs in the tricks so you can't you know have a you can't have something like this where you have like green yellow pink purple whatever you know all over you you you can't make your board look like a skittles advert it needs to have some kind of formality with it so you know even though the actions are very simple there's enough for you to look at on your turn and plan ah head for up to a point you play this with four players you might find that the display of cards will chop and change a little bit by the time it gets yours but not dreadfully because you've only got two actions a turn and you know you might not necessarily take anything from the display you might just move stuff on your board to get it into a better position so by the time it gets back round to you you should still have a reasonable chance of getting a card or a dog that you were like kind of gunning for and there is enough in the display based on player scaling to account for a little bit of that so yeah you got to accept that sometimes your stuff will get taken but you should be able to plan for some eventualities and at the end of the day there is a decent amount of flexibility with the training cars for you to move on to other options there are two other methods of playing this game I've shown you the basic side of the board there is an advanced side of the board which essentially has a couple of slightly fiddly rules with it but not too bad where essentially if you place a dog on one of these spaces that has arrows on it or a particular icon it allows you to do some Shenanigans like

swap a dog swap a card you know move a dog across the entire field that kind of thing the rules on how they apply in terms of when you place a dog on one and when you like move a dog to one of these spaces and how they trigger is takes a probably a second read in order to get it firmly in your head it's maybe a little bit weird when you read it for the first time but once you've got that down honestly after you've played a game with the basic side you're pretty much just going to play with the advanced side all the time now because the advanced side just introduces a lot of extra you know strategic ways or tactical ways that you can manipulate the dogs on your board and so once I you know if I'm teaching this to like like my family or like really new Gamers then fine stick with the basic side and you'll be fine but any gamer you could pretty much just shove them straight into the advanced mode and they'll be totally fine with working with it and then you'll never look back but at least you've got the two modes and you can easily choose between the two you've also got a solo mode if you just want to have the puzzle of pattern building the solo mode is a nice little feature very straightforward it just basically has a deck that removes uh cards and dogs from it at you know random times you know very easy but it's kind of like a almost like a time trial type thing yes you're trying to get beat your own score which is you know not the best thing ever but what it essentially means is that you now have sorry this side of the board where as you go through the game you've only got so many rounds before you start losing negative points and what you're trying to do is obviously get the highest score by the time you decide I want to end the game you can end the

game at round eight but then if you do it round 9 or 10 you'll have lost points which is quite a significant amount of points I mean you really do not want to end this game on round nine or 10 unless you've got a hell of a good reason to so typically round eight but as you go through each round you have to choose where to put one of these colored dogs on and they get bonus points for like having more green dogs in training than pink dogs but you're deciding how these score throughout the solo game so you can see how you're getting on and then build the scoring condition yourself which is quite a neat little feature other than that that's essentially the solo challenge it's fine I can play it every now and again at least you'll get through it very quickly I mean you'll be done in dusted with it in 20 minutes you know very simple rules and very simple operation you know the AI doesn't really have an AI it's just literally flip a card and remove some stuff now of course being a very simple game with you know an everchanging display in that there's going to be an element of luckiness and this is not a huge negative on the game frankly because this is like a 20 to 40 5 minute time frame and it actually does keep to a 20 to 45 minute time frame this is a super fast game but you have to accept that sometimes particularly with more players and when these you know cards get flipped over into the display that sometimes the right card just turns up for the right person exactly when they need it it's like yeah I've got this stuff all over the board what am I supposed to do with this oh that's nice I've already got like three in a column sweet I'll take this card and I can do this nice and quick it's going to happen but it's a simple like Gateway game it's

not meant to be a serious 3-hour Euro and I know I've harped on you know on games in the past for having too much luck in them it's not that I want every game to have no luck in it at all but there's a difference between a 25 minute game having an element of luck and a 3our Euro having an element of luck you know there's a huge difference there for something like this that's super simple and super light it's not that big a deal but yeah you are just going to have to accept that these things going to happen you know the right cards can just turn up or maybe you've got stuff on your board and just nothing turns up that fits with you but again you're done in dusted in 30 minutes this is a filler game just pack up rinse and go again or just accept that that's what happens in a filler game I mean do you get you know do you give love letter a hard time because you don't draw the right card at the right time not terribly so it's not a huge negative here you just got to Bear it in mind another little minor point is that the player scaling is good to an extent but it's two to five you don't really desperately need to play this with five I mean the the display will be more chaotic and you're just adding more downtime where it starts going into that whole 45 minute sort of time frame I mean it shouldn't even take an hour frankly unless You' got really slow players but yeah you're going to the higher end if you have five of you but the other thing is that the display has a kind of weird scaling thing about it you have the same number of dogs and cards available for two to three players and then a different number for four to five players so you don't have a different count for each player it's not like you say cards plus one for players and dogs plus one for players it has a set of amount so I don't quite get why

it doesn't change between two and three and why it doesn't change between four and five you would think that it should change at every player count now I'm pretty positive you could house rule this in whatever you know if you're not happy with how free player feels a little bit you know tighter than two and how five feels very tight compared to four then kind of bit like ticket to ride in that respect then you could easily house roll it just say that you put in players plus one number of stuff in the middle one and you'll have enough of you know it will fix that problem for you that's not something I say you need to do in this game but it's just one minor niggle I had which I can choose to fix or I can just say you know what it's not a big deal so forever home is not Reinventing the wheel it's not doing anything particularly new or Innovative it's just giving you exactly what it says on the tin a simple pattern building abstract that anybody can play that has a very nice Charming aesthetic that really looks nice on the table and plays in a fither length time frame and I mean typically a filler length time frame you play this with two to three players it will easily be filler length you play it with four could still be filler length maybe just slightly above but we are still talking probably Splendor levels of length here five just maybe going on a bit longer but you know for what it is it's a very Charming little game and it's nice to see another proper Gateway game that I can you know talk about you so many big Euros so many huge kickstarters in that to have a game which is just nice straight up and simple you know well we're waiting for people to turn up we got like 20 30

minutes or so why don't we just play a little bit of pattern building and there are people I know that are dog lovers they'll get into this theme I like dogs I get into this you know theme and aesthetic but even if you're not a massive animal person unless you categorically hate dogs you're still going to look at this artwork and just go it's so gorgeous it's so pretty it's so charming and it will certainly appeal to a lot of players but with very simple rules with a little bit of flexibility in the scoring different options for you to pursue and just a you know not terribly meaty but not autopilot puzzle in front of you it ticks the boxes for what a little Gateway game needs to be do I want to play it over and over again no it's one that I sort of go right I'll bring it to a night we've played it once and I'm kind of good right we can leave it at the bag and now I'll bring it maybe next time but it's a very easy to store very simple little Gateway game that I think deserves a little bit of a you know a little bit of attention cuz we don't have a lot of these Gateway Games and we don't have a lot of G games feed around dogs frankly I mean let's face it this is kind of what uh you know Lotty and Jack are doing as their sort of passion project with this publish with this company you know all about dogs they clearly love them um so you know it's good to actually see a theme being utilized that we don't see very often or at least not very often in good games this one I'm giving a solid seven out of 10 it's a good game you know it's not going to blow your mind it's not going to blow the doors off or anything but it's still a just a very Charming game a little zen-like puzzle game that's going to make any dog lover just go a and you know looking at all the cute Aesthetics and even if you're not

necessarily a dog lover it's still a decent enough abstract that's going to give you what you want from a filler length game so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see them please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on Board Game Geek when it goes live on the page don't forget to check out the other content I've been doing lately I'm fresh back from the UK games Expo and there's a lot to talk about on there so by all means check out the two-part series I did for that whether in podcast or YouTube form and you know listen to my ramblings about various games and let me know your thoughts on there and of course if you want to show any support for the show then b means check out the patreon where you know anything that you chip in to help on the patreon helps me to get review copies to review on this channel and provide content for you so until next time regardless of whether you believe you can teach a dog new tricks it's still only a game so bye for now

Progress saved