Skip to main content
Loading video...

Black Forest - Board Game Review - Glass Road 2.0

Transcript 32:25

God not that guy he always comes bearing really inconvenient gifts brought you some saltwater tropical fish now you got to feed him every two hours and I fed him an hour ago son of a hi everyone I'm Luke hear and this is the broken me a show where I rant and Rave about board games but let's be honest it's more about the ranty part we'll get on with the show in just a second but it's been a while since I've talked about them and they are my sponsor after all so just give them a minute of your time as Gamers we find it hard to deal with empty shelves some worse than others you therefore want the supplier that has what you need at affordable prices and delivers on time for me that supplier is Kender they offer a discount on bulk purchases as well as a point scheme for future Acquisitions down the line if there's a hot title you're after chances are kender's got it Wings manman mine Arc no mine eclipse actually I hate that game it's terrible but you might like it if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get 5% discount on your first order over £60 so let's make gaps in your collection a ft of the past get down to Kender and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so we're talking about one of the most popular games that came out at Essen yes I already talked about setti and that was certainly one of the hyped games for the convention and this is definitely up there if not possibly more so than setti I mean I mean it was pretty popular

everybody wanted to try and grab this one you know the only place you're likely to get it for a while is from Essen God knows when this will get a UK release or a US release but the fact that furland Spiel when it comes to their games tend to basically have a boofer Essen and then run out of copies quite quick you know they have a Q system for a reason if you don't get there soon chances are that Q is going to fill up and everybody is desperate to get like the English copies of these particular games fair play to them they make some pretty popular games well this one was on my list because I actually played this site cheat back in the UK games Expo uh the I forget it was the designer I think it was more one of the Publishers uh one of the agents and the Publishers brought a prototype a final prototype of the game down it was essentially finished just quality of components and we played a full free player game at the time at the Expo and I gave my thoughts on those review videos by all means check them out if you want even more detail but this one now find is in my hands a full-fledged copy it's essentially a sequel to Glass Road this is a game that I had to warm up to yeah originally I wasn't a fan of glass Road a card system I found a little bit chaotic especially at four players now I actually quite like glass road though I will admit I do prefer it with less players rather than rather than more so I would play it with two and three probably wouldn't play it with four but I did warm up to that and a lot of it is well we'll get on to certain reasons why later this is the sequel to it so it takes one of the mechanics the resource wheels and

basically doubles that in terms of scope but it replaces that card system with a map system with little like trades people that you can move around and stuff and of course there's buildings that you can build and victory points to be earned and a lot of resource Gathering so question is is this a wordy sequel does it eclipse the original can it run side by side it's not exactly um making its title welln with a tiny little tagline for Black Forest but I mean I guess if you're from Germany you'll actually the Black Forest personally I've never actually been there but it looks very pretty I'd like to give it a look but the question is is the game good let's get on with it what are you waiting for a kiss goodbye so black forest at its core is a resource management game everybody has control of their own estate with various different terrain pieces already set up like forests and corn fields and lakes and so forth but everybody mainly has control of these two resource stles so if you're familiar with glass Road you already know what this is but now instead of one you have two double the trouble you basically have resource markers on these and they operate a little bit like clocks in the sense that your resources are tracked by the numbers on the internal spin wheels there and you know you've got quite a lot of these markers so you know I'm not going to put them in exactly the right place but yeah all of these markers are on your wheels and you are tracking these things and the idea is is that as you go through the game you are collecting resources and spending it to do various things like building up your estate or making glass or you know producing other resources but your resource Wheels work on this system where basically as you spend

resources or gain them your wheel will continue to move if there is scope for it to do so like there's no marker bucking its path so if you get yourself a bunch of charcoal sand and you know water and what's the other thing that needs wood then you you'll have space between the spokes of your wheel and where those resources are it will automatically move along and produce one of the secondary resources glass whether you're like it or not yes you have a situation where some times you produce resources only for them to get sucked away because it wants to make the secondary resource of glass or in the other Wheels case Provisions so this is essentially a cool sort of juggling match that you've got to play with these resources bricks get to live on the side on the track so they can get off scotf free but what exactly are you doing with these resources on your turn well this board is littered with all these different Trad people this is just a fraction of how many are in the game but you use them all they're just set up in a specific way and each one has a specific on it sometimes you got to spend resources to do it sometimes it just gives you stuff and there's one in particular a traveling Merchant who you can pay your resource to swap it round with other trades people on the map so they don't necessarily remain in the same place at setup but if I just take this Village here for example everybody has a meeple start at their turn they choose whether to mess around with this Merchant but afterwards on the first turn they can go where they like but on subsequent turns you move along the map via these roads and in order to do so you have to spend Provisions each Road has a provision cost you spend them from your wheel it's one of the secondary

resources but then when you go to a village you get to access the two trades people to the side of the spot you go on and then you get to do those actions in any order you like if another player happens to be there you have to give them one of your basic resources it feels a little bit like stardew Valley in that way you know every time you go out visiting you have to take something along with you to pass by because you're gifting it to everybody to get friendship it feels like a very friendly village where everybody gifts stuff back and forth it pretty much is stard you black forest but the that is a consideration to make is you might not want to give them too many resources because obviously it's hindering you and possibly boosting them once you've done the true trades people and you finished all the actions that's it next player takes their ter but on top of that you also have jobs that you can fulfill which are basically little contracts that come out on the board and these are essentially sort of souped up versions of these you know you pay a lot of stuff but then you get a lot of stuff in return but as well as obviously it's not just simply resources I mean the resources you can get will help you get cows and pigs which can live on your board and get you points for you know putting them in Stables or you can just um shall we say use them to get certain other resources um thinking much more of the meaty variety U but then also you'll have several sideboards which I haven't populated at the moment but one will have special buildings on them which are essentially dictated at the start of the game this is not all of them there's a whole bag full of these things and they're basically big buildings that you build for a lot of resources but they

get you a lot of points end game scoring but then much like the game kerer you'll have these two side boards populated with buildings and like to say this is not all of them this is just a fraction of them there are 36 buildings in the game that populate these all of which are double-sided so yeah you have got 72 different buildings effectively from the small buildings that can be in the game and they're all set up from the start so your resources are basically used to build up your estate how do you want to do it get a bunch of ponds get a bunch of corn fields and use use them in that way do you want to you know get a bunch of animals and use them or just put them on your estate and stables for points or do you want to build a bunch of these buildings some let you convert X resource to another some are endgame scoring some are instant bonuses and they worth victory points as well the game continues until somebody gets their SLE clock to basically move so far around that their Provisions pass by a certain spot on their board it's marked with a little hourglass once that once one of their markers does that it triggers the end of the game everybody gets one more turn and then the game ends and you total up your victory points that's easy so that's to production first wow you're getting a lot of pieces in this game this is kind of a thing with a lot of furland spi and Rosenberg games there's a lot of stuff here I mean this is littering my table and all I've taken out is is basically one player's components the sideboards the main board one set of resource dos and a few of each of the trades people and buildings

there's a lot more in this thing I mean could blind me you you litter your box with I know these are like bagged up to an extent but there's job tiles in here there's you know the Stables there's loads of these boards you know with these expansion elements that you can put onto your estate you've got the you know the cows and the pigs all the rest of the buildings all the rest of the corn fields all the rest of the big buildings you're getting a lot of stuff in here it takes a while to punch everything out and it's lited with the typical style of artwork you expect from uie Rosenberg games it's not going to win Awards but it's colorful it's cute and if you look around the board you'll see occasional Easter eggs like you know people have spotted weird looking Huts like a maybe a gingerbread Hut somewhere I saw a Little Red Devil in one of mine somewhere you I don't know why he's there you we kept Googling Black Forest devil to see if there was some like like old wife's tale about some devil in the black forest yes the number I was thinking of was the letter M and it looks colorful and striking on the on the table that being said it's a table hog yeah I mean this board is already pretty big as you can see you have then got to have these on the side of the table so you need to have this big board you need to have this big board and this big big board you know in full show of everybody then you need to have your estate which can potentially have somewhere like about two to three of these things along the side by the time the game is over then you need room for this thing so imagine doing that with four players please

excuse the crudity of this model I didn't have time to build it to scale or to paint it now yes okay these are not necessarily the most stur of boards you know they can warp to an extent but they do have little divots in the back so that you won't have it sort of like you know constantly like this but yeah it's cardboard it can warp but all it takes is a little bit of bending back in place and they fit I've never had a problem where markers have slid off this or the wheels have turned unnecessarily I mean these wheels are pretty sturdy once you put them in they should you know turn you know at their own pace like they won't just slip and go all over the shop so these are fine they do the job okay yes you could have some triple layered board at solid concrete but you know can you imagine what the price point for that would be these work just fine it all looks nice I love the color green it's all over the table great a nugget of purest green now you would have heard me in my seti review mention that one thing I kind of like is when a game that is fairly thinky for what it is doesn't require big teach I don't really have a name for this ratio that we could call it but it's essentially like how much effort does it take to get into the game learn it and get the rules down versus the amount of think that you actually do you play a Lura game you play something like funny enough unconscious mind for example that's underneath the slot you know and you expect a massive ton of rules overhead and then you expect a massive ton of rules complexity this game certainly is going to make you think it's going to make you plan ahead and consider what you're doing with your

resources but this does not require a long teach at all I am pretty damn impressed this rule book has got the full appendix for every building and that in here so you should never have an FAQ moment you know certainly I don't think I've had one specifically but there's not a lot of rules in the game I mean you've got this this basically explains some Core Concepts here and honestly this is only needed if you've never played glass road but it's easy enough to tell what's what it's a little text heavy but there are some pictorial examples but really the game play is not that much I mean there's two pages for the game play and then there's the rewards that you can get with things and then end of the game this is two-player mode and solo play and the solo play is basically mostly just a beat your own score with some character that runs around and occasionally gets in the way that's pretty much what solo mode is but teaching this game especially if you've played glass road before is an absolute cinch because the iconography is very clear nothing is difficult once you know how the buildings work you know blue ones or conversions beige ones or one-off bonuses it's easy to tell what they do the trades people all makes sense not one of the trades people has an ambiguous icon iconography on it it's all really easy even your like spindle board is clear to follow where the markers start what resources you have and where things go it's all nice and clear but teaching it is a cinch because what's the what's the turn sequence I mean you take your guy you move it to a different place pay the provisions do

the two actions on the trade person next person's go that's all it is I mean it's a very easy thing to teach so for the amount of thinkness that you are going to do more than that in a minute it really isn't a difficult teach it's not difficult to teach this from the rule book honestly uh and you know yes there will be video tutorials out there I think even grogan's done one but you don't desperately need one it's you know midweight level in terms of its rules complexity and even easier if you've already had experience with glass Road We're Not So Different you and I the amount of variety in this game is off the fraking chain I mean I mentioned the buildings all of these are available at the start so think Cerna remember I mean that's kind of what black forest is it's kind of a glass Road and CNA had a baby and this is what it is Cera had all those buildings laid out at the start of the game and you got all the options and there was a lot of them in the game well 36 buildings you basically lay this board out well two boards with all the different buildings flip a bunch of them randomly to side B if you want to mix up or you just do all A's or B's whatever you want to do and there's your building combinations I mean there are 36 buildings in the game all of which are double-sided the amount of combinations of buildings that you can have in this setup is insane and that's not even including the special buildings the more expensive ones because you only put out about four or five of these Maxs in G game I think it's about four or five let's have a look at the board yeah four five yeah that's it four or five of these and the bag in the box has got at least about 15 of these things so there is definitely a good amount of variety

there the only thing that doesn't adjust from a variety perspective is the trades people now they'll be in different locations on the map so you are going to get different combinations of you know like some Villages being good for one thing and and the like but because the traveling Merchant swaps the tiles around that will quickly go out the window after the first few turns but yeah you don't have like extra trades people that are in the box or left out you will use every single one I'm kind of cool with that because these do need to be balanced with the game if you had and let's face it there's enough variety elsewhere that I think if you also added variety for all these Trad people I think it would just go a little bit ridiculous you know there is such a thing as too much Variety in the game I can certainly think of several on my shelves that fall into that kind of category it is just that the luxury edition has so much more Eagle you're going to have a different experience each time yes the resource Gathering is the same but how you go about doing it is always going to be different you know with the trades people combos that you see with the buildings that are out there you'll look at them in the start and think hm we're a bit short on charcoal so that could be something that's hard to get but hang on if I grab some if I'm good at food if I can get meat right I can get some animals get some meat I can take that building turn that into that which with that building can turn that into that that lets me get more of those you know that' be pretty sweet you know and then with the jobs that come out they give you little tactical opportunities as well there's just a different way to go about the resource setup and how you're going to progress through the game and people will play with different styles I'll have a game where I focus a ton on animals somebody else will focus a lot on ponds they'll get all the ponds and

get their stuff that way now some person might get all the ponds but churing them for different effects on the buildings you know which is still different from the person that's harvesting ponds and trying to keep hold of them the buildings that you take are going to change your little strategies a bit it's definitely got enough like legs to keep going for a considerable amount of time and I have played this multiple times in a row in fact last Friday I took it to a friend's house we played it they Rosenberg fans and we literally played two free player games in a row and each of us did something very different from one game to the next even though the main thing that changes is just some of the buildings flip over and you just rearrange the trades people nice and easy to go from one game to the next barely an inconvenience now if you hated the cards from the original glass road which to be honest when I talk to people about glass Road that's the one I tend to hear the most you either love glass Road or you hate it because of those cards and I know cuz I used to be that person well the cards aren't in this game there is none of that pre-selection thing of what you do it is a case of right I need to go to a particular Village you know where the tiles are they could swap around a couple of them and obviously somebody might be there and it's like do I really have to give you a basic resource all right fine I'll go there it's surprising which groups are more willing to do that and which people are so stingy they refuse to give gifts to anybody ever at all costs but but that's kind of like the Crux of the planning part of it you haven't got that unknown chaos with the cards that bid is gone in fact honestly other than what affects other players do there isn't really any random luck factor in this

game you know the the jobs that come out have got different effects which ones come out at which times is going to be random yes but that's the same for everybody you know it can affect everybody both good and bad and they're not exactly a staple to win the game they're just more options that you can do but everything else is laid out no F no future buildings come out at random no extra mechanics suddenly unveil themselves at random which might benefit one person over another everything is there you can see what's what so in terms of the luck factor it's very very low incredibly low for this game dare say pretty much negligible which is a great thing when you are playing a thingy game with strategy and tactics involved but if the reason you like glass Road was because of these resource Wheels you are going to have a whale of a time and I'm not going to lie this is my favorite thing out of glass Road I think these resource wheels are brilliant as a concept I like resource Gathering games in general but I think this is one of the best ways to do it as much as I love getting a bunch of wooden pieces and saying oh yeah look at my corn I've got all these like wooden corn pieces you know and stuff like that or like you know I'm doing all the I've got all the donkeys look at all the little donkey meeples I love that through and through but the thinkness and the cool planning you do with this resource wheel is such a good system I love the fact that you just track them on here and yes you might push one out of alignment or something but just be careful your board you'll be all right and but I love the idea that when you this wheel will move of its own free will you know if it can the amount of times that I am laughing

my head up because somebody at the other end of like around the table says oh but it's making this why you know is it's always a thing you my mate will have a plan he was like right I can get this wood that would be great right I'll get this bunch of wood and this allows me to get some charcoal I'll now go to Glass I've I cried out loud I what in the wood you know it's it constantly it can trip you up but that's a part of the game it's part of the thinkness and the planning forward but it's still hilarious the amount of times that me myself included get caught out because I think I've got a bunch of stuff and then I realized ah D I got to Auto make Provisions that's a problem it's like I don't want to you might deliberately hinder one of your resource markers so that you can get lots of something else and not make glass which is kind of weird in the game where you're supposed to make glass cuz a lot of the buildings that are really good require it but it's just a clever system of resource management and it causes laugh it causes you to really get your brain cells work and try to like think oh how can I manipulate this and get some of that and can get some of that I need to make some glass but that means I need water where the hell do I get water well he's done it but I'm on the other side of the map where can I get water at this end Merchant and you swap those two around that'd be pretty good it really is getting your brain cells firing on all cylinders to think about the best way to be efficient with your resource management and it's just such a clever cool system now you might think that it's a little bit tricky to know we hangover which building do I need for stuff but to Aid with the aid with this fact and I hope that fural land is

watching and they do this for Cera if you do this for cavera I will buy these guaranteed but these boards have symbols down the left that tell you what the buildings on the road do so if you're looking for something that produces sand for example you know to look at this row because all of these buildings will have something to do with collecting sand if you make boards like this for Cerna as a side thing like an add-on promo or something I will buy them off you without question Shut Up And Take My Money and for the solo Gamers you get the solo mode in here as well it is beat your own score unfortunately which is a bit of a downer because I do get a little bit bored with that type of like that style of solo mode but it is a very easy solo mode to do basically you just flip over the board to a side where the player counting is different it's basically got a little track that's it but instead of having one Pawn that you move around the Villages you effectively take all Five Pawns and then as you play you are time constrained so you have to play five rounds with five turns each and you place the porn out on onto a location for each time so you don't actually move around the Villages but you not only are you time constraint you only have so many turns in the game but when you place a porn out fine if you place the white one which is the neutral one you don't pay any cost but any porn that you place after the last one you did that's in a different village you've got to pay the provision cost to move there and if you put a porn down somewhere where there's already a porn somewhere then you've got to pay a basic resource to the bank other than that most of the other elements of the game

get some minor changes for solo play but that's kind of it you still do what you do in a multiplayer game you get to have fun with all these buildings you get to have fun with your resource you your resource Wheels you get to all the cool Resource Management shenanigames that you had before do I like the fact that it's time constrained yes and no cuz it does add a bit of a challenge to the game to try and get everything you want done in a shorter space of time but when you're playing the main game you're probably taking more turns than 25 turns as you know before the game ends so you you know you definitely feel like you've got more scope to achieve stuff compared to the solo mode but that being said it's a very easy solo mode to do I've played it it's good fun I do wish that there was more than just beat your own score there a small blemish particularly when you're just having so much fun messing around with all the stuff that's in here this is why Superman works alone certainly a lot of love for this game so far but let's talk about the elephant in the room there is one floor with the game and I accept that this floor is generated by the game but it's also a person thing but you need to be aware there is a certain type of player that needs to stay the hell away from this game like crazy the AP player the analysis paralysis player the person who can't stand looking at a bunch of options in front of them and can't process them quick enough to take their turn within say 2 hours well we're waiting yeah those people exist this game gives you a bucket load

of options on every turn which I love the game doesn't take that long to play I mean you will wrap this up in about 90 minutes 2 hours at the absolute Max with four players that are going slow but typically you will get this done in a 90-minute time frame fantastic but the downtime can be a bit long if you get the wrong people in here I mean I can play this with people who have played Rosenberg games to death and they can still be thinking hard about their turns because especially on the first turn where your guy can go anywhere on the map you know some of these spaces are a bit more limited when you run out of provisions and you know you can only go to the next Village but especially that first turn where you can go anywhere your brain is overwhelmed with the amount of options cuz you're looking at all all these buildings and deciding which buildings do I want and what do I need well that means I need to go there would I need to get that where do I get this well I'll go there but then I'm trapped in that Village cuz the guy is over there can I swap it over later and you are trying to process all this in your head that takes time it's something you really want to be doing before it's your turn so this problem can be mitigated with the right group but be warned this game is capable of creating some of the most DieHard analysis paralysis I have seen in players you know I have played this with a mly crew of people some of which I know are prone to AP and believe me those people can drag this game out quite a bit to the point where I'm biting my nails Beyond where they normally are bitten through cuz I'm probably going into bone and bone marrow at this point because I'm just biting them so hard waiting for them to take their turn get on with it

yes get on with it yeah and I can be built guilty of AP in this it's just a game that gener a lot of it all those buildings all these trades people your resources how they're going to manipulate once you move them and whether they'll produce Provisions or glass or something there'll be some people maybe take back sees on a turn like they'll go for a process get to the end realize that they've mucked it up with their resource wheels and then have to go back and try something else you can get some slowdown elements with this but this is not that unusual from other games that are big you know and heavy and this one granted is not quite as you know big and heavy as a lerta game or a mind Clash game or something but the advantage this one has over those is that this one gives you a decent amount of thinkness compared to those games but doesn't over complicate you with a bunch of mechanics but people are still going to freeze over the options be warned everybody got that oui Rosenberg Tito the ren my God have you created a hit here this game is a ton of fun I like Resource Management games in general and I Rosenberg tends to be the guy I go for for resource management but this takes some of the best elements I like from several games and shoves it into one you know you've got the typical Resource Management that he's known for but you don't have to feed your people all the time did I once

mention feeding my people no cuz you don't do that in this thank God we got rid of that mechanic okay cool you then have the ridiculous choice of the buildings out a CER one of my favorite things about CER is all those different buildings you can use well here they are and you know you get them in glass Road as well but you didn't have anywhere near as many as this in glass Road you've got a lot more here and then on top of that you've got those resource Wheels which was the best thing out of glass Road you've taken away the cards which is probably the weaker aspect of glass Road and certainly the divisive one for a lot of people and you're left with the best element of glass road so you've essentially taken a lot of these cool elements shoved it into one game and you've created basically a resource management fans wet dream it's a solid game all around it's not difficult to teach even if you've never played glass road before this one is one that you can easily teach to most mid-heavy Gamers if you've never played a nor Rosenberg game before maybe you might want to put them on something a little bit simpler than this one it's probably a bit much but you know for most people I can teach this in no time at all and if you've played aie Rosenberg games before particularly class Road I can teach this to you in minutes it really is that fast now it's not entirely Flawless because you do have that big problem of the AP Factor but that is just a a a part of the game and yes it's still a flaw you know the game generates a lot of AP because of the nature of the Beast and games can drag with four players if you have those AP players in although to be honest the game could drag with three

players if you've got one person that won't hurry up and take their turn you've got to plan your turns ahead of time you need a plan B and you need to know what you're doing so as I say this is not particularly newbie gamer friendly you know or even newe URI Rosenberg gamer friendly but for those who like his works for those who like these resource wheels and the choice of buildings and just resource management in general this game is fantastic and I've already you know buzzed over you know seti when I did that review but I think when all things considered this one is better than set this is easily I think my favorite game I've played this year it is just such a blast I will play this over and over again in quick succession you know I love changing up what buildings I'm going to use I've got all the variety in the world I've got a solo mode if I want it I've got you know you know different ways to approach the trade to people in all the different buildings and it it really gets those brain cells firing with a lot of forward planning and a lot of tactical and strategic opportunities in the game it is just so much fun is is a 10 out of 10 easily the last time I gave a 10 for setti I said it was a low 10 You could argue it was a high n this is a comfortable 10 this is a benchmark for rui Rosenberg and Resource Management games it's just it gives you a lot of that thinkness and all those options which I do love in games when a game gives you a lot of cool options and each one feels quite cool but it's you know and it gives you a lot of thinkness but it doesn't then you know offset that

with over complicated rules over fiddly elements and stuff that grinds the gears which is you know kind of good on the basis that you are effectively grinding two gears all the time but uh you it it doesn't get clunky it's still silky smooth with the only Hiccup being how well can you plan your turn before it's your turn you know there is that aspect but I just get on with it have fun see what I create at the end the scores are low they're usually below 50 points or so which means that they're pretty tight in terms of the scoring I mean you might have a game where you barely score about 30 or so points you know games can be tight and down to the why I've had turn I've had games end on a tiebreaker or one point apart I can't say much else good about this it's just fantastic 10 out of 10 Benchmark favorite game of the year on route to be the best of the year you know at this rate it just it it already impressed me at the game's Expo it's now been great to get this back to the table and play it some more and I just enjoy it every single time the man suddenly skyrocketed you all saw it so that's it for me on this episode of the broken me if you like what you see then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb it up on borang gate when it goes live on the page check out the rest of my Essen content you can check out seti which I reviewed recently in a big format you know also gave it a very positive review see how it compares to this they're very different games but yeah it's not often I give a 10 and I've already found two games at Essen that I have which you know is that assign at 2024 might be a big Benchmark for gaming

now or if I just got lucky and found two games that really sing to me who knows but uh there's more Essen content coming so check out what I've done so far and be on the lookout for what's to come in the next month or two until next time remember regardless of whether you really desire to make glass or not it's still only a game so get it have fun get frustrated with the wheels and have a good time bye for now

Progress saved