Does the Rule of Cool make Chainsaw a good card? (Arkham Card of the Week)
Transcript
Hello everybody and welcome to Card of the Week, the show on the playing board games channel where I talk about a different Arkham card every week. If you don't know how it works, I roll a card and I'm only going to reroll them if it's a card I've already talked about. Uh otherwise, we just take that card and we talk about it for 10 to 15 minutes depending on how fiery it makes me. I'm going to be here on my third favorite website, Arkham Build, and we're going to see what card we go and then we're going to get started. Chainsaw. Wow, this is a fun one. This is a four cost, four experience survivor card that takes up two hand slots. It uses three supplies. As an action, spend one supply, fight, you get plus two fist, and deal plus two damage for this attack. If this attack fails, either place one supply on chainsaw or deal one damage to the attacked enemy.
So, I think that like in terms of the weapons that exist in real life, this is probably the flashiest weapon in the entirety of Arkham Horror, right? There's also like a lot of tropes involving the chainsaw where it's like, you know, like Ash from Evil Dead with his chainsaw arm. There's, I believe, a chainsaw in Doom or in one of the games that are like Doom adjacent, and you just get to run around and cut up monsters with a chainsaw. It's a very fun like tropey fantasy to have in these kind of like pulpy action games. And it was really cool to see this actually come into Arkham Horror, the card game, because this existed in things like Arkham Horror Second Edition and Eldrich Horror, where you were able to use a chainsaw to cut up enemies. And like in those games in Arkham Horror, the chainsaw is a very very powerful and flashy effect. It also works best as this in the survivor class because the survivors are known as the class that just uses the weapons that they have available to them to quote unquote survive. That's where the survivor names from. Their name comes from. They're just slapping together what they have to make work. A big thing as well, you probably know this, but I'm going to tell you just in case you don't. The survivor class for the longest time had a very interesting quirk for how their player cards were designed. Uh, if you know what it is, let me know. Say it right now. But if you don't, they only had cards that were level zero, level one, level two, and level three for the
majority of this early game's lifetime. So, this was in the Stella Clark deck, which I believe came out either before Inmouth or before Dream Eaters. I actually don't remember the exact date, but I think it's sometime within that window. So, that means we got at least Dunich, at least Carcosa, at least the Forgotten Age, and I'm pretty sure at least the Circle Undone of four sets where every other class was getting experience cards in level four and five, but survivors were capping out at three. This was an inherent design choice from the designers to have it so that survivors were kind of like making use with what they had and like they were kind of like lower to the ground in terms of class identity. This of course came with its own baggage problems that we are not talking about in this video because we're talking specifically about Chainsaw. But Stella Clark saw Chainsaw a level four card and then also Quick Learner a level f a level four card as The level five card I think didn't come out until uh Darkhorse and Feast of Hemlock Veil. I could be wrong on that.
Don't sue me if I am, please. I don't have a lot of money. It's not worth your time. But this was an exciting time and a very notable time for Survivor players to be like, "Ooh, we have a big big flashy card." And if you look at the design of Chainsaw, you can actually see that there is this really big kind of follow through with the design survivor class. And then also the um Stella Clark box set which was like the idea is you are failing and like you're failing forward. So we also saw like the daringer the gun that reloads itself and that carries through into the chainsaw here where if you fail you get to either deal one damage to the attacked enemy. So you're basically still just like getting the hit in. It's kind of like following the oops, lucky, dumb luck, um the look what I found kind of train where it's like no matter what this hits. Uh or you get to place the supply back on. This means that you as a player, if you fail against an enemy with only one health left, it's like you pass the test and the enemy is just dead. The supply is still spent, the enemy is gone, you don't really care how you trigger it. But what's really fun is when you're able to combine this with cards like live and learn that let you retry tests. So you could fail with live and learn, put the supply back on, probably do that over pinging the enemy, but you could still ping the enemy and then you play live and learn to take that shot again. You don't need to spend the additional supply. So you actually could also potentially come up one supply from the attack and still hit and
then you could deal the damage to that enemy. And three damage turns out is a lot of damage. Uh it will nullify like most enemies. And what's really nice is it's great at killing two health enemies because three damage is greater than two health. It's incredible at killing three health enemies because three health equals three damage. But chainsaw is also very good at taking out four, five, and six health enemies in a way that a lot of weapons aren't. Right? So, if you have the the if you're going up against a four health enemy, you hit on the first attack, no matter what on the second attack, hit or miss, the enemy is dead, which is something that doesn't sound particularly powerful, but you have to trust me that having that assurance in that sort of attack is very good for you as a player to be able to fine-tune and make the correct decisions in that moment. For a five health enemy, it's like the it's like hitting a four- health enemy with a two damage weapon.
It's dead in two. Six health, same sort of thing. Chainsaw is a very efficient killer. it does carry some slight baggage where in the survivor class supplies um it's like the limited uses can really kind of add up in the way that they can't in like the guardian class with weapons because for example it's a lot easier to replace like an upgraded 45 automatic or an upgraded 41 daringer. These are just cards that are on the screen, so that's why I'm saying them. In the rogue and the guardian class compared to a four cost, four experience chainsaw in the survivor class. Uh, this is kind of um nullified slightly by the fact that this uses supplies instead of ammo, which means that anything that refills supplies, which admittedly is limited, I think, to mostly just things like emergency cash 3 and a few other like story assets. I think there's some that can do it and maybe a few other random cards I'm I'm um forgetting. But the thing that makes up for it is that emergency cash 3. I think it fills up four supplies. So that's like a really good thing where if you don't need the supplies, it's still three money. But if you do need the supplies, you can reload this to a chainsaw and then like a little bit extra, a little bit of an extra kiss. Now again, this three supplies kind of go a little bit longer in the long run because of the fact that um the if you do fail, they're on there.
So like you're essentially in theory guaranteeing nine damage with the chainsaw over a number of attacks. It's the same sort of thing with the daringer. The daringer level zero is guaranteeing four damage. The daringer level two is guaranteeing six damage. The chainsaw is guaranteeing nine damage. These sort of effects again should not be like underestimated to just like guarantee you play the chainsaw and assuming you don't lose it, you use all the supplies, you know that the chainsaw dealt nine damage. Now all of this nice good stuff about chainsaw is carrying a slight little bit of baggage. And the thing for that is that ultimately chainsaw was kind of just outclassed in the survivor class when it came to them getting the upgraded fire extinguisher.
Before chainsaw, survivors never really had like a good weapon to fight with, right? They were kind of just like making it you making it by with baseball bat uh for a time and then Dunage Legacy brought the fire axe and they were able to like start using that. Fire axe had the problem where it used all their resources so they were kind of just forced into like spending their resources which kind of then put them directly into Darkhorse. So they were kind of trapped into a box. Uh and then uh Forgotten Age came out and timewn brand actually became the weapon of choice for the survivor class. There were a lot of silus decks early on that would actually lean more on chainsaw than sorry lean more on time wararm brand than chainsaw. So like you can see kind of the issue here that I talked about with the supplies right where in this game because enemies are relentless and in Drown City they are literally relentless. Um, you have to kind of always have an answer to enemies. And while chainsaw can recommend, like sorry, can can guarantee nine damage, it doesn't guarantee 12 damage. It doesn't guarantee 15 damage because you either need to replace the chainsaw or reload it. But Timeworn brand doesn't guarantee that damage, but ensures that over a longer number of turns, it's more likely to hit a higher damage threshold than chainsaw for just a oneaction play, and you don't need to worry about anything else. Not to mention that Timeworm Brand also has the
supercharged magic paddle attack that also is very good because it draws cards. Now, this then hit like the crescendo as I mentioned with like um survivor getting the fire extinguisher because the new upgraded fire extinguisher is actually just like a melee weapon that's like on par with machete without like the the rider of having the um the extra like only one enemy engaged with you. And like it might sound like for a survivor class paying three experience for just a melee weapon that gives you plus one fist and plus one damage is too much, but survivors can look at that and be like, I can now play this weapon. I do not need anything else because I've been jumping through hoops for years to just ensure that my damage is consistent. And the fire extinguisher now says I don't need to do that. I can just hit. We look at all the other survivor fighters and they lean on their off classes like Will York is going to lean on his his guardian weapons. He's probably using machete. Will York can use chainsaw.
We've seen Will York decks use active desperation on their chainsaw to then replay the chainsaw. And those loops are really good. So chainsaw ultimately will always have a home. But because because fighters demand consistent fighting, especially at lower player counts, chainsaw ultimately, while impressive and flashy and has a lot of upsides, is just kind of like most firearms, cuz this technically kind of is a firearm, it has limited uses, it's outclassed by just general melee weapons. I'd be very curious to see a chainsaw designed with today's sentiment because the the philosophy on the design for limited uses has changed quite a bit from the time of Stella Clark's release. I'd love to see a new chainsaw. I think it would be pretty cool. Uh Chainsaw is a fun card. I've I know someone uh a certain someone watching as I'm recording this is thinking, "Hey, were didn't you say you were going to play a Silus deck with Chainsaw and the uh um the Gastly Possession?" And you know what? I did say that, but then I realized with Silus, it's kind of still just better to just play a fire extinguisher. That's what always happens with me. There's a lot of cool ideas that just get like replaced with the most efficient ones.
And that's kind of what I see when I look at chainsaw. Thanks for watching everybody. I hope you enjoyed this card of the week. I can't wait to see you for the next one. It's always a little bit fun and a little bit scary when I roll the card to see what I'm going to be talking about. But in the meantime, thank you so much for watching. Have a good one. And as always, the GG's.