Skip to main content
Loading video...

My Three FAVORITE Wargames Rules Mechanics

Transcript 13:23

in this video I talk about three well three and a half of my favorite game mechanics in tabletop wargaming rules I'm a strong believer that rules are more important to a war game than story or art or lore or Vibes certainly those things will get you in the door you know cool art and models and fluff can kind of get Butts in seats as they say but if the rules are bad then I won't be sticking around at best I might take the models if they're cool and we'll work in other rule sets and maybe I'll take like the idea of the story from a game with bad rules and use it in a game with rules that I like better your mileage may vary but for me rules make or break a war game now it's not a zero sum game either sometimes a rule set can have mostly good rules and maybe like one of them is janky that happens in lots of games and you either just kind of deal with the bad rule among the good ones or you and your play group decide to modify that bad Rule and make it something more to your liking this is one of the many great things about tabletop War gaming unlike video gaming you can very easily change the way the game is played without needing to know like how to code or make mods or whatever speaking of bad game mechanics

I made a video earlier this year about three wargaming rules mechanics that need to go pachow and again this is all my opinion you may have differing ideas also if a game has like one of these mechanics in it that's in that video it's not instantly a bad game you just generally have to decide if you want to bother changing it or not when you play with your friends if a game has two or maybe three of these bad mechanics in it well then you might have to think a bit more about whether it's something you still want to play it's totally up to you but now I want to focus on some good war game mechanics types of rules that I love to see in wargaming rule sets again these are my opinion and if I missed a mechanic that you think should be something that people look for you know in their games then drop them down in the comments below so we can all check them out and as I said just before if a game doesn't have all of these rules in them that doesn't make it a bad game one of my favorite games space weirdos only has one of these mechanics in it but again it's the sum of the parts to begin we'll start where many wargaming rule sets begin a game turn with initiative a great thing that I love to see in war games are interesting initiative and activation schemes rather than the normal kind of we roll off to see who goes first and then we alternate back and forth type of setup many games use like this point of the beginning of each turn to help tell the story of the

battle a little bit more while rolling to see who goes first and then alternating back and forth is you know fast and pretty easy to remember doing something a bit more interesting can really add to the feel now take the game bolt action for example I can't find anywhere online that mentions whether this changed in the newest edition which just came out earlier this year so I'm going to assume that it didn't but if it changed sorry in bolt action normally uh you and your opponent each put a number of colorcoded dice into the same dice bag at the beginning of each turn equal to the number of units you each still have in the game right so if I got five units I put in five dice you've got six units you put in six dice that kind of thing then you shake that bag up and and and then you one of you reaches in and pulls out a die if it's your color then you activate any one of your units if your opponent O's color shows up well then they get to activate any one of theirs now this might seem kind of weird but what this does is it simulates the fog of War being a World War II game there's going to be smoke and explosions and all kinds of factors obscuring the battlefield during a battle so it's harder to plan on what you're going to do with your forces because you can't really see everything that's going on this you know what we're trying to simulate here so pulling the dice out of the bag simulates this whole whole not knowing thing however it's not totally

random as there are a known quantity of dice in the bag if you get to activate a bunch of your units in a row you know due to Lucky pulls from the bag then eventually your opponent will start seeing their dice coming out of the bag later rain in Hell a game by me and YouTube's Vince venturella uses a different initiative scheme and it's I think kind of brilliant Vince did an amazing job on it since it's mostly you know kind of a hand to hand and Demon combat game and there's not explosions and fog of war and all that kind of stuff going on then each player rolls a number of d12's at the beginning of each turn equal to the number of demons that they still have in the game then they each order them on their play sheets to show which of the corresponding 12 initiative steps from 12 to 1 they rolled starting with 12 whichever play a roll to 12 gets to activate a demon then 11s then 10s and and so on what this simulates is the kind of everchanging flow of a big hand toand scrum since these roles of the 12 Siders aren't hidden from either player each player can look at their opponent's play sheet and see how the overall initiative order will go over the course of the turn it informs how you as the leader of your demons decides how your demons will act during this turn it still gives each player agency right but but there's still a little bit of Randomness in each turn you know with the rolling of the

d12's and all that however it's Randomness that you can learn of at the beginning of the turn and then react to as you go initiative schemes don't need to even be as detailed as the two that I just mentioned I've been going through the rules for the new game trench Crusade which I just talked about last week pachow and in that the activation order is the sort of standard alternating activation style where one person activates a model or unit and then the opponent does one and then back and forth and so on the interesting difference though is this the first person to activate at the beginning of each turn is the person with the fewest units still on the table rather than rolling off you know d6s to see who goes first it's kind of a Mario Kart sort of blue shell mechanic and I appreciate its simplicity so that first mechanic interesting initiatives is one of my very favorites and I kind of went deep on it but we have a few more to get through so I'll move on this next mechanic is one that I see in many games so it gets used pretty frequently but you really notice it when it's not there a set number of rounds is a game mechanic that ends the game at the end of a certain number of rounds or turns or whatever the game system likes to call them you don't just keep playing until you finally kill off the other team or finally finish the objective or finally get bored or whatever you've got to deadline this deadline helps to add urgency to the decisions that you make

as the commander of your troops you can't just kind of Simply sit back and wait to see what your opponent is going to do you have to take action because the game ends on turn four or five or whatever the rules say and you have to get stuff done as does your opponent now in many games the game can kind of End early as well of course if you destroy you know all of your opponent's units then you'll generally win but I've won games before because I still had you know a couple of models left at the end of the last round and they were standing on an objective and my nearly unharmed opponent wasn't I also have some fond memories of playing fifth edition 40K back when you generally rolled at the end of turn five to see if the game ends or or if it doesn't if it didn't then you rolled again at the end of turn six if it didn't end there then it would end no matter what at the end of turn seven it was quite rare that I ever wanted the game to go longer I usually was standing on the objectives I needed at the end of turn five and if the game went longer du to the dice roll and went into into turn six then I usually wouldn't be able to survive the next turn and would lose but those dice rolls were always thrilling campaign play is another mechanic I look for in most of my Miniatures games that I'm considering playing rather than just playing like a single game winning or losing and then starting over and playing another one again these games are designed to be played in a sequence

as each model or unit gains experience from doing things killing other people that kind of stuff you know and also takes injuries during games from you know trying to be killed themselves they generally have to roll on charts between games to see if they get you know new skills or better weapons from doing well or perhaps get long-term injuries or just totally die from taking damage this makes the Miniatures game seem a little more like a roleplaying game but more like kind of a video game version of a role playing game right you know like gaining experience allows you to like level up your units and maybe get new weapons and items and stuff like that whereas being knocked out in a battle like out of action could end up with the unit recovering fully right or maybe damaging the unit long term or potentially even killing the unit requiring them to be replaced with something else like a newer unit that doesn't have as much experience you as the player generally get much more invested in the kind of tiny lives of your minis in your War band when you're playing a campaign game and that's really fun well at least it is to me your mileage again may vary and this postgame process where you determine what happens to your War band you know between games can be something very detailed like the old game morheim where your you know models gained experience and injuries as you progressed you could upgrade your equipment as you went you know by finding money or making money

that kind of stuff right you could uh add new members to your War band as you wanted it to grow and as you built your things out and sometimes rolling on the charts between games there was lots of charts was nearly as memorable as the games themselves however campaign play can also be very simple just checking to see if the models that get kind of taken out in the last game come back in the next or not lastly this one is not exactly a rules mechanic but it does have very much to do with the rules themselves I love to see a game where everything you need is in one book not something like you need to buy the rule book and then the Army book for the Army or potentially armies that you'd like to play instead you buy one book and that's what you need to play the game it's better for the players both because it's cheaper and also because it's fewer things to you know lug around to the game at at the shop or over your friend's house or whatever there are exceptions of course if the Rules book is something that you need to buy but then all the information for the armies for example is generally free downloads you know something like onepage rules you buy Grim dark future for five bucks or Grim dark future firefighter age fantasy or any one of those things and then all the Army lists and all the stats and all that jazz is free online this is acceptable to me personally uh but a lot of War games out there can make it so that you just need to buy the one book and that's really all you need

rules-wise how to play and the Army stats or you know like whatever are they're all there in that one book however there are other companies though that believe more books is better and I just usually can't get on board with a game system that works like that so there's my three and a half I suppose uh good mechanics that I love to see in war games rules what do you think of my list do you agree with any of them am I nuts or did I miss some that you really enjoy let us all know in the comments section down below if you liked this video it would be great if you hit the like button which is also down there below it really helps out the video the channel and by extension uh me if you'd like to see more videos like this every single Friday hit the Subscribe button down there as well it's free maybe ding the bell I guess I don't know that might be something thanks for watching

Progress saved