The Best & Worst of Arcs by Leder Games | First Impressions
Transcript
hello welcome to quack thank you for being here it is currently 4:30 a.m. on Tuesday night and I just finished going through the arcs rule book for the second time going through the Arata for said rule book and playing two full games of well base game arcs without lore and without leaders included as you the community uh recommended and you were absolutely right I I would not have been prepared equipped or even enjoyed this game if I tried to dive into well lore and leaders let alone the expansion in the big box and my normal instinct is to want to jump directly into a campaign Style Adventure game full of asymetry and lots and lots of building blocks but holy cow arcs is in a world of its own both when it comes to game design the experience of play and the complexity sitting in front of you on the table now this is a first impressions review Style video talking about a game that I've played once four players once two players and I did pull and get feedback from the three other people that I played with just tonight to get a sense of where their rankings are what their highs and lows were and so in this video I'm going to break down five big good
points in arcs five big negative points in arcs the good the bad the beautiful and well honestly the ugly and and don't worry BGG is absolutely going to love this video as well cuz well I guess I've actually played the game this time so maybe now I have a right to talk about it so arcs for those of you that have no idea what this game is I'll give you my little 30 second pitch but I have a lot of content coming out on this game I mean I can sit here right now and tell you that I will absolutely be getting six or so off camera plays done likely this week and then recording a three-part campaign in the full quackalope style that means card overlays and commentary and behind the-scenes cameras and a incredible Studio space to film it in so if you're excited about this game and you're ready for guided content gameplay content the stuff that we make here then go ahead and hit that subscribe button and let us know what you're looking for arcs the 32nd pitch on arcs is that this is going to be a race to win Victory Point driven game that combines area control with trick taking card mechanics now a lot of people won't be familiar with what trick-taking is as a genre the core concept is that you'll have a sequence of cards that'll have some type of number number and some type of color
trick taking involves you playing down a card that matches but then trumps those other cards or that leading card that's been played so if I played the five red you would then want to be able to put down a card that is higher than that card number in the same matching color as that card number many times games iterate on this by having you follow the last person who played or having you take special actions abilities depending on what card you were able to put down in arcs they change the script a little bit with the player who has initiative leading the card setting the parameters for what that round that single set of actions every player will take is going to be like and then every other player has three options they can do they can play a card down that uh has the same color is a higher number than that initiative card that first card that was played and they get the actions they get the number of Pips and the actions associated with the four different types of cards in the game however they could also play down a card of a different color getting one action of their color or play a card face down getting one action of whatever that leading card was so the trick taking here is smart and it's hard in a lot of weird interesting ways cuz the actions that are associated with the tricks that you're taking combine with the resources that you have the special asymmetric abilities that you've been able to draft and whatever positioning is happening here on the board I mean these little cards are
doing a lot let me just show you one of them I keep reaching out there to grab one it's almost as if I should just leave a few here on the table for you to see these cards not only have a range of and I'm looking for one more color these cards not only have a range of abilities there's a blue just destroying the set in front of me they normally have a range of abilities associated with with the color that's been played they also have a power level associated with the number and the number of Pips the lower number cards are going to have more actions that you can take associated with them they have specific abilities tied to them like here the construction card you can build or repair aggression you can battle move or secure Administration you can Tax Repair or influence and mobilization you can move or influence so multiple actions but each one is limited to a specific type of card that you're playing and limited to the amount of actions that you can take on that card the more powerful cards the cards that you can typically play after someone has has led the initiative are going to typically give you less abilities less actions that you can actually take on top of that the bottom of these cards here are going to have the type of scoring they could trigger the Ambitions track I told you that this was a race to win and in many ways that's the case similar to root in a mechanics system you have variable ways of scoring points and you're going to be trying to trigger endgame by crossing a threshold the person at the
end of the game whoever triggers endgame the person at the end of the game who has the most points will be the Victor you're going to be scoring though instead of your own asymmetric player boards off of this Ambitions track and this Ambition track relates pretty much everything you're doing on the game board Tycoon is two different types of resources you want to collect Tyrant is how many units you've captured not from battling but instead from occupying and enslaving I suppose the alien life forms and whatever Planet your compatriots are at warlord is going to be from blowing those alien life forms up keeper is going to be by having these relic icons and empath is going to be having the Scion or the psychic icons either on your cards or on the people that you've recruited and the resources that you have on the table so you have a race to win engine you have an area control Space Opera Happening Here in the center where you're establishing outposts Gathering resources spreading across this map and fighting tooth and nail to try to win all driven by this extremely Innovative extremely interesting uh trick-taking card system I mean you don't have your own unique deck of Tricks either you have this shuffled deck of cards and you're drawing up and so the math and the equation that you get and the abilities that you get get and what everyone else has around the table is this weighty process of trying to deduce and trying to read the room and trying to follow
and grab initiative exactly when you need it the experience of playing arcs is the experience of learning a game when you play this for the first time you're going to spend almost if not the entirety of the game just trying to figure it out in in fact the second time I played it the two-player variation again because of the dynamic between four and two players I was sitting here trying to balance and figure out and read the board I went straight for scoring and that did well for me but there's so much more here that I haven't really been able to sink my teeth into and I don't really quite yet fully comprehend I'm a bit concerned that as I learn this base game more and more it becomes simpler becomes more straightforward yeah of course I'm going to go for scoring objectives or yeah there's cards out here in the marketplace that I want add to my Tableau or I can go rip them out of my enemy's cold dead fingers I will keep an eye on the cards that are being played the tricks and kind of understanding who's played what and what's already popped out here under the board and there'll be a sequential process of how you approach the game one of my concerns with base games Arc arcs right now is that as I get deeper into it the complexity will pull back and the Simplicity of the game design and game engine will actually reveal itself more and more I don't know if if that's good or bad I will say this though leader games has already in my opinion acknowledged and corrected for that very
issue you have leader cards that you can add in that add a wide variety of setup conditions special powers and abilities and starting resources or conditions for scoring that completely change the game not only that but you'll grab the lore cards and you'll be able to draft those as well we have an integrated these into our gameplay yet because base game's confusing enough as it is but as I was reading through these and getting a sense of exactly how they operate I can see how this asymmetry will start transforming the way you approach the game and while the puzzle the core architecture of arcs is going to be fairly straightforward depending on what cards you have you kind of have a order or operation of play that you need to follow and depending on what is being triggered or how you're able to trigger things you sort of go for victory points you focus on that there's not really too much else you need to do but depending on the puzzle I've been given from drafting these cards that's going to really change the way that I have to approach the game and change the way that I'm going to be able to uh acquire victory points on top of that the massive big box expansion that all of you told me don't dive into first that's just going to add an entire new mess to the game engine the game system I I believe it operat similar to how oath did where like the game evolves as you play the story and the architecture and the cards change and transform and then you can reset it back to zero but you play it through three
full years of three to five chapters each so a dedicated 6 to 8 Hour game session and I can only imagine that the narrative progression and the asymmetry only continues to diversify as the game gets deeper and deeper so far despite my apprehensions and my skepticism around arcs I really like this game I think the game design is clean and elegant I think it is chaotic and I can 100% see where some other reviewers are going to like this in a way that I might not relate to I mean the comparisons to Twilight Imperium and Cosmic Encounter have already started echoing through the stratosphere of the board game industry and I think in many ways I have to agree with them I the Twilight Imperium aspects of this are there it's not as complex it's not as overreaching but the fact that you can sit down you can play through a giant narrative campaign the fact that you're sitting here balancing this complex asymetry this craft and resource management and scoring objectives and the thing that I think well some reviewers are going to uh enjoy in a way that I probably won't the fact that this game leaves open the opportunity for tons of above board conversation wheeling and dealing personal debts and players ganging up
against the leader it almost requires it in some ways well this could become more of a social experiential game than a mechanics first driven game and that's where I think a lot of people are actually going to fall off of this the wildness the variance and the randomness in opport in dice rolling in scoring and in the cards that you draw up is pretty steep and if you're not willing and dealing if you're not self-balancing the game as a set of players you're going to run into a situation where the Euros side the gamer that just wants it to be a good perfect math problem the root player in you that wants a asymmetric puzzle but doesn't want too much chaos introduced into their board game uh I don't think ARS is going to work I think it's too wild I think it's too open and I think it requires the players to all have a vast deep experience with the game in a way that I would even argue root doesn't quite require yeah and root you want to be able to play all four or all six or all 12 factions so you understand how they score and how they operate but if you focus on your faction you focus on your faction well you can have a good game by the end of our well both of our games everyone around the table was still for the most part learning how to play Still figuring out the fiddly little details and asking Corrections and nuanced questions around the rules some of which weren't answered in the rule book and were answered here
in the Arata and I I took notes on all of that and I wrote all that down and as I was going back and parsing through things I realized just how open-ended the rule book leaves many aspects of this game to the point where even in the back of the rules it talks about player agency it talks about reworking turns as long as you haven't revealed new information it it opens the door for conversations wheeling and dealing without of course revealing private information or binding ties but it's encouraging the players to take a role in The Narrative and uh experiential aspects of play so let's talk about my two game plays specifically and then the best and the worst elements of arcs and then I've got a few other videos I'm going to film I'm already ready to go on them I've been uh taking notes all evening so I've got a few lists to run through so in our four-player game we took about 30 to 45 minutes to do the initial run through and teach the general setup and breakdown before that I'd spent about an hour reading through the rule book myself setting up the game and getting a sense of how the operational play worked after about 30 minutes of teaching we started running through the game and that first round or two was definitely a teaching round or two too we had crazy thing H things happen where like people zoomed in and destroyed a city right off the bat to see what happens when you Revolt but there was no one on a card over here in order for them to claim so they ended up just penalizing themselves for the duration of the game as opposed to
getting a strong benefit for destroying a city I mean it seems like you should go rip things apart but that first couple rounds was much more of a learning game than than anything else by about Midway through the game we were all pretty well up and running playing cards trying to go for victory points and figuring out the conditions necessary to score but the end points did not align with a balanced well-informed table or well-informed game the scores ended at 32 15 5 and four a very distant and steep contrast between those that were focusing this focusing on this as more of a uh build your Tableau establish your colonies control your space engine as opposed to a ambition driven Victory Point scoring focused game a race to win game engine it definitely incentivized and benefited players who were familiar with trift shaking already and could think a little bit ahead in how they were approaching and how they were playing out cards in order to do multiple actions like taking the most Pips possible but also making sure they had initiative at the right time in order to trigger the ambition that they wanted so that it would score as far as the players everyone across the board gave it a seven out of 10 not a perfect game not their favorite game of all time not a game that they even fully understood but one that they were all interested in playing again and
one that all of them said has a likelihood of improving with multiple plays the deeper they get into it the more likely my group was to enjoy this we did almost no above board wheeling and dealing other than gentle about rolling Dice and attacking our ships we were very focused on learning the game and the gam playay structure I don't know that wheeling and dealing would enhance our personal gaming experience but I'm not opposed to trying it especially when I get the right group of friends around me we all know the game very well and we're doing something like the campaign game or the asymmetric game where wheeling and dealing and cutting Corners in order to benefit other players to balance the game and self-regulate those scores might be essential and might important I mean the fact that our final scores were so steeply different is concerning for me I don't love walking into a game and watching one player blow everyone else out of the water I think for the players that didn't score so well it can be a little bit anticlimactic it can be a little bit discouraging for them coming back to the game table and it shows some type of Disconnect between what the games telling or instructing players to do and what of course the whole point of the game or the whole objective or ambition of the game is now that could have been on me that could have had something to do with the teach and the overview and how much emphasis I put on how things score and the focus on that but I really think we all had a pretty good understanding of the game overall and by the end of it we all had a good
time so keep that in mind most people said they were not ready no everyone across the board said they were not ready for more content that's why I followed up with a two-player still without in introducing leaders or lore I myself wasn't ready for new content I wasn't ready to add in a symmetry I was still figuring out the puzzle of the game and wanted to figure out the balance between two players versus four full players I do like four players quite a lot because it has the ones and the seven cards in the ones of course cannot label Ambitions but they have a lot of resources and the sevens always Trump so you're able to wheel and deal and steal initiative a little bit more effectively the game feels like it was designed for those four players in mind and yet two players functioned really really well I enjoyed two players quite a lot actually and I'm really excited to teach Shir this I'm really excited to sit down with West and have a chance to run through the two-player puzzle of this game more two players felt more tactical more chess-like more strategic where four players Felt Like Anything Could Happen across the board and you're just kind of Holding On by the Reigns and seeing if you can carry yourself across that Finish Line in my two-player game the scores however did not improve I scored 35 points closing the game out in the third chapter by the way game four also closed out in the third chapter as well and my opponent scored two points game took about an hour and a half to run with two players and we had a good time we really did like it was a
fantastic experience playing two players but again the difference in scoring and scoring objectives the difference in how people were approaching this game defin itely shown through I mean that is a wild divide and maybe it was because we weren't self-balancing well enough or it could just be because the game engine of arcs rewards certain play Styles or rewards heavy scoring I was able to get all of my uh cities out onto the board so I was scoring at sometimes in the last round I think I in the in the last round in chapter three I think I ended up choosing the two Ambitions that we scored and scoring a collect 22 points or so for them and so we're in a position where one round one really good round drove endgame and also drove Victory I don't know that I love that I don't know that I hate it it feels very similar to like the corvid conspiracy where you have this engine that if you get it up and running with your hidden tokens across the board you can suddenly score 10 15 points without anyone realizing just how close to Victory you were were cuz you were so far behind I think my opponent underestimated how close I was to winning cuz they weren't so focused on what I would actually end up scoring they were more focused on building their engine for the later stages and the later chapters of the game again things that you can learn stuff that you can refine but if I'm sitting down to play this for the first time or teaching this
to someone who's played it once or twice already I don't want to see those numbers blown out of the water so drastically I want the game to be uh in and of itself in some ways balanced and competitive and both in the four-player game and the two-player game I didn't see that as evident and by the way my opponent in the two-player game had just finished the four-player game as well so we were both just as familiar with the game uh as well anyone else sitting there at the table I can compare this over to other games other Euro style games and games that I've played that rope that score in a little bit tighter have maybe guard rails up a little bit higher it's not necessary but I think for a game that's presenting itself as an accessible addition to this hobby space it does it does present some challenges okay the best the worst our thoughts where we're going from here I mean you already know we're going to produce a ton of content on this I'm very excited about this I'm going to be keeping it in my collection till I've at least played through the expansion once entirely and then we'll read the verdict we'll read the room I'm wondering if this sticks around around as a base game only I'm wondering if this sticks around as something that I play but I play it kind of like Twilight Imperium where I have the right group and I get the I get the three full narrative story arcs out and onto the table I'm not sure where it lands I can't see myself teaching this to many players often like many of the
other games that I have that play in that four-player count range it's competing with too many games there but as a two-player head-to-head puzzle I really can see this hitting the table quite a bit if the other player knows it and enjoys it cuz then it just comes down to the various different strategies you have how you're reading your opponent and the depth in play that you can get uh as you explore the game so the best things the five best things about arcs one wide openen strategies there are a lot of different ways to go for victory here and all of them are kind of open if you get wiped out or annihilated on the board there's other ways to wiggle your way back to score to produce resources really there's not catch-up mechanics necessarily but there's multiple levers and game engines you can pull at any stage in this game in order to try and score as much as possible and I don't think you're ever out of the game however if you can't convince other players to help you along and leave you alone a little bit you can certainly be beat down to the degree that you're not able to get up before the game closes and those barn doors shut but the wide open scoring strategies the way that you can be well ripped off of half the board and still have Pathways back and feel like you have Pathways worth exploring really makes this a standout kind of open World open box experience it's fast playing after the teach we were able to get this up and running fairly quickly and I never felt like I was sitting and
waiting for too long in fact I might have been taking the longest turns at the table granted I am and was on Aderall at the time so I was really thinking through my actions that might have contributed to my win as well you know you get that little add bug out of your head and then suddenly you're expert board gamer however I don't think anyone was getting impatient or feeling like the AP was prolonged there are moments where there's a lot of tokens and a lot of stuff that you can do sure if you have a really AP driven player things can slow down a lot I am sure but it wasn't really an issue for us three broken combos I I love broken combos remember this is still the list of things that I think are really good here and I absolutely enjoyed coming across some of these cards where I was adding them to my Tableau and the combinations were just magical for instance I had one that allowed me to declare an ambition after playing a card if it hadn't already been declared so if I'm not first an initiative I could still use my cards to claim Ambitions which is great because I was driving some scoring and driving the scoring engine is the way that you win arcs but on top of that I had another card that then allowed me to trigger extra benefits depending on what ambition I had declared so one of them allowed me to not cover up my number if I declared that to start with so if I was ever leading a card I had initiative I would utilize that another one was able to give me Kickbacks or something like that depending on what I played out so there was a lot of flexibility oh one
allowed me to look at another player's hand and take or swap a card with them from my own hand after I declared an ambition so pairing that that means every turn I could just choose an ambition I wanted meaning I'm driving the scoring engine and swap a card with another player giving me insight into everything they have in their hand and allowing me to substitute something out giving me another card that could potentially grab me a new ambition scoring modifier it was a broken combo and yeah other people could have beat me up and stolen it from me and there's ways to mitigate that Brokenness in the game but just discovering that just finding those little things that you can press those little buttons that people out enough they want to come after you it's something that I love in board games moving down to number four I think the trick taking in this game and the way that it's combining trick taking with this area control you know this build out your zones grow your Fleet grow your ships fight across the battlefield it feels really Innovative to me please let me know if I'm overlooking some classic games out there that I haven't played I I've played quite a few trick taking games but I'll be honest it's not my favorite genre out there so I'm not always hunting for them but I don't know of a lot of games that utilize trick taking in a bigger box experience like this and specifically utilize trick taking in the way that arcs does it feels extremely fresh it feels extremely different from other area control games that I've played other games that require hand management or have some form of drafting or
asymmetric builds or Tableau building arcs feels different from all of those because the way that you get a hand of cards and you have to weigh and wear out and figure out exactly what order you want to play them in and then you have to respond to other players as they fuddle all your plans and then finally there is so much to explore I'm actually really excited about these leader cards I'm really excited about these lore cards and I'm insanely excited even though I'm completely unprepared completely uh not ready to play it I'm very very excited about the big box expansion I'm hoping I get it to the table sometime in the next week or two I can't wait to see what else they have in store I mean if this turns into this epic Galactic exploration game that I want so desperately I'm in I think I would be absolutely sold is it going to be in my top 10 or top 20 of all time I don't know about that but it certainly might be on a two-player top 10 or top 20 list and it might be hear me out depending on how good that campaign is it might be competitive and unique enough to get on to a larger campaign board game list I'm compelled I'm excited I'm intrigued I am still skeptical I want to see how I feel 10 and 15 plays deep but for now ARS has my attention and like many of the other
content creators and reviewers out there I think it has my attention for a very fair and very good reason even though I think there's going to be a lot of people that buy this based on the hype and bounce off of it hard so let's talk about those five elements those five things that I think are just bad about this game and these were contributed by the other three players I had at the table as well so the thing that two out of four of the players at the table said is that they really didn't like the dice they didn't feel like the dice were balanced they had a little bit of trouble understanding them initially and then when it came to fighting and rolling which is a big critical part of this game they just didn't feel like they were effective they didn't feel like they played a role I get it dice are dice right they can have big wins they can have epic fails and arcs gives you this unique combination of choosing and drafting the type and style of dice that you want to use but I found a lot of our players were de defaulting by the end of the game back to these blue dice cuz they just got tired of losing their own ships and destroying their own fleets in a barrage to try to steal resources and annihilate other players the red dice are heavy hitting but risky you'll able to wipe out other fleets but you also might deal a lot of damage back to yourself the orange or yellowish dice the orange dice are going to be focused on stealing from other players getting their resources getting their recruits and they also have damage associated
with them as well so they're a little bit riskier to play and the blue dice are safe a 50/50 role flip of a coin you might hit them you might not hit them but you're not hurting yourself in the process I don't love the dice I don't hate the dice I think a lot of people are really going to either be thrilled by the introduction of these Dice and the way that you can choose and mix and decide exactly what type and how many you want to integrate Into Your Role how risky you want to make a role and there's going to be a lot of people that find them confusing find them frustrating and default to always using the same sequence or the same comp combination of dice and they'll just completely whiff pass that part of the game because yeah it doesn't always feel fair and it really can throw off and ruin a focus strategy and because these strategies can lead to things like 10 12 22 Point swings it can matter a lot if you're counting on Victory in this area if you're counting on removing some fleets and not doing damage to your own or you just need some of these attacks to go well or at least go well enough for you to get an extra piece or two in your reserves or control a planet or open up a place to build out a uh City onto the board you might be left in the wings and because of how swingy these points are being left in the wings on a dice roll feels really bad moving on down we have the thing that one of our players said that they were frustrated by is the fact that raids on the board
can't be prented or stopped there's not a lot of mitigation when it comes to the dice rolls I mean this is a attack first game a lead with your heavy hand a bring your sword to the Afterparty style board game and yeah you can respawn ships quickly you can get cities out there pretty fast and you're never completely out of the game but I watched as one player just swept through and more or less took one of the other players off the board in just a series of quick turns and that wasn't great and there was almost nothing they could do to mitigate it I mean they had their cards stolen and their resources were gone and all they had left was a little Hand of cards and a few puny ships on the board and they're trying to come back from nothing that is also the player that said they felt hopeful and felt like there was a lot of opportunity to explore various different scoring Pathways and it was also the the player that scored five points in our four-player game so you take it as you will I mean everyone I guess is entitled to their opinion but I think they were knocked out I think they were kneecapped pretty early and I don't think there was a lot they could do to prevent that because it happened so early in the game and it happened so quickly number three balanced by the players I've already hit on this quite a bit so I'm not going to harp on it too much more but arcs like a lot of leader games games and Cole worly games is a game that is focused on players setting the
initiative players knowing how cards score and what powerful combinations are and understanding the asymmetry between how players are shifting across the board and reading the room enough that they self-balance the game as they play cuz if I let them get too far ahead of me or we let them get too far ahead of us suddenly we're not in contention for victory anymore and I think in a game like root where Victory Point scoring is slow it's a progressive thing it doesn't happen at the end of a big chapter but instead it's one or two points every round you continue stepping up that Fortress it works pretty well cuz you learn the table you get a sense of the room and you learn how to pull people down or shift them or they get a little bit too far ahead and you start just punching them in the face until they ultimately lose and someone else wins CU you focused all your energy on attacking the Vagabond as you should every time but here in arcs like we only had three scoring rounds between when both games started and both games ended and so it's not a slow Progressive scoring system it's a big cataclysmic and sometimes detrimental scoring system and I don't know if shifting these Victory Point tracks up would make that better I don't know if scoring a little bit more often are having smaller Point scales but some asymmetry in the way that we actually collect and score which might be introduced with a leader cards will change that equation all I know is that it felt like it went
and both games felt the same in that regard it didn't seem it didn't seem like the balance that players at the table needed to introduce into the game was easy to understand and more so easy to achieve moving on down to number four it's complex in a really simple way arcs is confusing we had a lot of little tiny nuanced rules questions I mean have a list of about 15 rules that I think we missed through the course of our first two games and we had to double check in the rule book sometimes look up on BGG and other people have been asking questions around these but these aren't complex rules these are just odd open-ended things that exist like how and when do you Resort your tokens on your board yeah there's an answer for that but it wasn't obvious when we were playing it or if you're stealing from another player Can you steal one of the resources and throw it away because you don't have room on your own board to collect more but you also have the ability to take from them well it seems that there's maybe an answer that you can do that and maybe an answer that you can't we don't have that question resolved yet the trick taking is simple right you just play a card of a higher order or take one or two actions per round and yet the sequencing necessary is really complex you need to able to look at three or four cards and
have a sense of what's here at the table and possibly even be memorizing what's already been played out onto the game board in order to do as good as possible it's odd in that regard there's not a lot of actions to take there's not a lot of resources you can grab and yet with the mixture of cards that you introduce and the variable ways that you are able to drive the engine and score the way that every car has three four or five different things it could be used for and different times in which it should be used or would be preferable to have used it arcs gets really really complicated really really quickly and finally my two biggest complaints some of you are going to completely disagree with one of these uh the lack of lore I like the little bit of flavor text that we have in root I like the little top-of-the-line Pips about who we are and why we're fighting and every time I play rout I Venture into that story the Eerie Dynasty the mighty controllers of the forest this one great nation that's reduced to a single vestage a single Nest up on the high elm tree the Marquee the cat that's spreading over and chopping down and creating infrastructure the corvid conspiracy that's sneaking silently through the forests hiding and poofing back and forth jumping into the Eerie nests and sometimes leaving a little present for them to discover I love the way that
through subtle art gameplay and lore leader games established and built a world for me to explore arcs at this point after two games and I'm a lore first gamer so you'd think I'd have a narrative story to tell I have no narrative story from either of my game plays yeah I recognized some cute creatures and I read their names as I drafted them but I don't know who my faction is and I don't really know what we did and there's no strong difference between my motivations on the board or in any other players's motivations on the board the Ambition track doesn't inherently tell me or introduce to me what it is I'm doing I I get it I'm taking people cap captive to I don't know be a tyrant I'm attacking Nations to be a warlord but none of it imbued me in the game none of it enriched the game experience the mechanics engine was the thing I was focused on that's fine but with the beautiful artwork and the uh narrative opportunity that leader games has with a lot of their storytelling I do feel right now in base game arcs the lore and the narrative is falling flat for me and I wish it wasn't and the second other criticism that I have that again some of you might not agree with is the fact that memorization in this game is arguably an important part of it it's a trick-taking game where players are going to be revealing cards as they play them and the more information you have yeah there's always going to be some that aren't in Psycho but the more
information you have the better you're going to be able to read and take actions in your own hand and I'm not a trick-taking gamer with my ADHD and dyslexia combination working memory is not something I have a lot of so if I'm focused on what my next few actions will be I don't have extra memory slots to remember that a five Red's been played and a three blue and I have the four blue but I haven't seen the six so there's a likelihood that some other player has it or it's in the deck pile and the thinner the cards get the the more you have to balance I I can remember a few of them and I tried to pay attention but memorization in this game is going to be a thing that either makes or breaks the in-depth game experience for many players if you are focused and remembering what people have put out on the table you're just going to do better and if you're not focused and not remembering what people have put out on on the table you're going to miss out and the game recommends having two separate stacks of cards a face down stack and a face up stack for competitive play and it might slow down the game progress a little bit but it'll give you a little bit more information as the game moves forward and I totally hear them but at the end of the day I still have to remember what might be in that face down stack or what I put into that face down stack I still have to actively remember what other players have played cuz I can't just pick up the deck of cards and start cycling through them it's a puzzle side that some people are really going to adapt to and they're going to
easily integrate in with and enjoy a lot and other people are not going to find that fun at all so that's where we are that is my first impressions of arcs I know this is a long video but I I wanted to sit and talk about it I had a lot of things to go through I have a lot of thoughts about this game I am not sure where this will land for me I I think I agree with my game group at the moment 7 7.5 is where it currently ranks but it's a very mixed ranking system I think this could go up if mixing in a symmetry and having a group of well-informed five or six plays deep Gamers at the table if that self-regulates self balances this game could easily get up to an eight or a nine on the RoR scale and at the same time the base game if I'm five or six games deep and still working through the same general puzzle and playing with the same set of cards and never really introducing a symmetry cu the players around the table just haven't learned it or haven't played it enough because I'm always introducing it to New Gamers at my house I think the base game actually might drop down to like a five and a half or a six it might be good fun okay an experience to say the least but not a game that I'm readily grabbing off the shelf I think the most likely place where this ends up is that big box expansion based story
campaign that allows the adventure of arcs to come to the Forefront and makes it so you don't mind and you're not bothered with some of the intricacies of learning the game for the first time this has not been the most fun game I've played for the first time I mean my first impressions of this the first few plays that I've had have left me curious they've left me wanting they've left me excited to come back but I didn't end going wow that was beautiful or amazing or mindblowing I left going oh all right well that's an interesting Rule and I'd like to try to play again so I could get it more right or so that I could utilize it more effectively and so I can discover more content there you have it let me know what are your initial thoughts on arcs did you make it to this point in the video and are you excited about the other content we have coming down the line like I already said I'll have at least three if not more game plays coming out I have people coming to visit and I'm scheduling them I have uh the Arata rule book that I'm going to go through I'm going to be doing the 10 rules you might miss like we often do is here I'm going to be breaking down the two-player rules of the game and some strategy and tips and tricks that I've experienced in that course of play I have the 10 things we wish we would have known before playing and a strategy guide on the horizon along with hopefully a how to play and a quick start guide and all the other faction breakdowns and nonsense that you could
include I'm enjoying this game I'm excited to dive into it and even if it doesn't stick around I'm going to have a darn good time exploring creating and putting out some content for you all to consume whatever the case though whatever you do remember to do the important thing don't don't don't do that whatever it is you just thought of that's not that's not the important do the other the opposite of of that we'll see you next time bye