Wispwood - Board Game Review - A New Hope For A Tired Genre
Transcript
Hi everyone, I'm Luke Hector and this is the Broken Mele, a show where I devote my time to ranting and raving about board games. But there's usually more ranting than there is raving. Well, here we've got a new title from Czech Game Editions. This is a new designer, I believe, Reed Ambrose, and it's a tile laying game. 45 minutes, one to four players, so solo mode included. And honestly, I didn't actually know a lot about this going into it, other than the fact that the cover looks gorgeous. I mean, the the artwork in this kind of reminds me of the AI games that I've talked about before on on some of my listen, an older like platforming game. And seriously, if you get a chance to play it, play it. It's really worth it. But the artwork definitely looks colorful and lovely. So, it's got a nice striking cover, but Tile Lane is not exactly a genre that's um uncommon, shall we say? Yeah, Tile Lane is so common that it's getting to the point where I don't know what new thing you can possibly do to the genre. Granted, there are good ones that come out. I did Timbertown a little while ago from Alleycat Games, gave it a high rating, and I still have a couple of tile layers on my shelf. factor. Yeah, Alice's Garden is still over here on the shelf, which I gave an I think a nine out of 10 to, which is, you know, as barebones, you know, it's fairly bare bones um tile laying game, but it does the job for a decent player count, well produced, quick filler length, you know, it's it ticks a lot of boxes. So, this one is one that has managed to get a good rating out of me. So, of course, when new ones come out, what exactly can you
do? It's going to have to work very hard to wow me and bring something new. Otherwise, it would just be any like any other tile lane game that exists. So, Wiswood, what can you offer?
Wingers, Dingus, listen up.
So, before the game starts, you are going to pick a scoring objective for each of the wisps and for trees. So, this is just a selection of five here, but there are five for every single type. This will be public knowledge, and this will determine how each of them will score. And so what you start off with is a cat tile which you will place in your 4x4 grid to begin with and you can build out how you need to as long as you respect the wishes of the 4x4 grid. And then you have a board here with all the available whisk tiles on at the moment. What you do is that you pick one of them and you choose a shape from either side. They have all the different sort of polyomino shapes we've seen in all Tetris games. And whichever one you pick, you take the whisk tile as well as as many face down tiles as necessary to complete the shape. Now, green uh wisp hats in particular have to be placed at a certain place next to the cat. So, let's just say row and column in this case. I might decide I'm going to build the L shape and I'm going to create it like this. So, I'm going to have it surround the cat. And so, this is a typical turn sequence. Now, this does not refresh until you get to a point where they're all exactly the same and the player can choose to bin them and refresh or that you run out of whis tiles and they just automatically refresh. But otherwise, what you see there is what you get, including the polyo shapes that can go with it. Your cat has a ability which if you flip it over and have it hiding in its tree, which is just so damn adorable, it's unreal. Um, you get to pick any polyomino shape on the board or you can bin the entire lot and refresh, you So, it's an ability that you can do, but the
only way to refresh it is by taking a tree turn, which is that you ignore everything on this board and you simply take one, two, or three face down tiles and put them in your grid. As long as you build next to something you've already built, that's legal. Not a problem. Each turn carries out in this fashion until somebody builds up their 4x4 grid. So, let's just say I've got a few tiles here and I'm uh let's just, you know, taking random tile cuz I want to showcase. Here we go. So that's a 4x4 grid tile here. Now here's the cool little twist bit. In between rounds, firstly you score up what you've got there. So based on this criteria, you score up how your forest looks. Then you remove you get to move your cat to a different tile. So this cat should have been sitting on a tree at the start. Sorry. This cat can move to a different tree tile. So it's like uh maybe I want to put it over here now. Okay. Then all the tree tiles get removed from your grid without touching the wisps involved. So these just go back to be selected elsewhere. So now you have some wisp tiles that are fixed in position. You now do the second round which you carry on from where you left off. This doesn't even refresh or anything, nor does your cat ability, but now you're building up to a 5x5 grid.
And in round three, you'll do the same thing but for a 6x6 grid, except that the wisp tiles that you have stay where they were. So now I've got these whist tiles permanently set in place and I have to build by shapes around them. So where you position your wis tiles is going to matter a great deal between rounds because it could restrict your placement in future rounds. You play through three rounds in this fashion and then at the very end you know you've scored up all three times. Naturally the scores will get bigger as you go through because your tiles will stick around from previous times and of course the one with the most
of course. So let's get the obvious thing out of the way. This game looks gorgeous. Oh my god. Wow. I mentioned the artwork earlier, but it really does look nice and it's it's not even like in yourrface artwork as well. It's it's kind of it's weird. It It's beautiful yet conservative because it's a nighttime forest look. So, the back of the tiles have got, you know, cool like pictures of nighttime trees on it, which is all well and good, but the wisp tiles basically have like kind of like the outline of trees in the background. And then the wisp itself is just super bright, super colorful. like you can easily tell which is pink, which is orange, which is blue. And even if you're slightly color blind, they are very distinguished pictures. So color blindness should not be an issue here, but it makes it stand out. It's like if you imagine that you were in a nighttime forest and you saw these brightly colored wisps everywhere, you know, you can imagine how that looks. It's personified here greatly. And because there's so many of these tiles, and this isn't even all of them, they're just it's just nice having this kind of artwork. It's, you know, well, it the the artwork is just gorgeous. Like I say, it even production wise, you mean these are good, sturdy tiles. You know, they're the right thickness that they need to be. I love the fact that this adorable little cat is dual layered. So, the idea is is that you you fold it over. It's it's CG's usual like little double-sided sticky tape thing, but on one side it's the cat and on the other side it's the cat hiding in a tree to say you've used the ability. I think that's just cute and adorable. So, anybody like me who's a cat fan is going to like gravitate to that. Um, they even throw in a guide here, which on the back is to do with solo scoring. We'll go
into that later. But on the other side, you can use it as a guide for measuring out your 4x4, 5x5, whatever grid. That's a nice little touch cuz a lot of games don't do that. They might have the player board already have the grid in place. But ones that don't have a board usually miss this part out, and it's like, it's nice that they actually thought about this. So, you know, if spatial awareness is not your forte, you can use this as a cool guide. And even I use it now and again when I got to think, oh, hang on a minute. Ah, left not left myself enough space. You know, it's just nice that they thought of that. It's a nice little addition. But that's essentially most of the components. And of course, you've got a very nice board here. The cards, they're good card stock. You don't need to sleeve these. You only pick one out of each during the game. That's all good. Although, five of each one is a nice amount of variety. I mean, there's a lot of different ways that these things will score. And all sorts of combinations these cards are going to make the game play out a little bit differently. And in the future, all they do is just maybe bring out a promo pack every now and again and just give us more objective cards if you want to add to the variety in that sense. But it's a very quick setup. I mean, all you've got to do is just put the tiles face down, set up the board, choose a card of each, and you're good to go. You know, very nice and quick. The game play itself is not the most interactive game in the world. It's you're definitely building up your own sort of puzzle on your board, but you do have to consider the opponents a little bit because you can see what everybody's gathering in terms of the wisps. So you know that somebody's really going for the green, somebody's going for the oranges and the board doesn't auto refresh every turn. So there is a little bit more of a care for other players because if I've you know if I've got a
situation here where let's say I've got uh you know let's say I've got this I've got two pumpkins here and a witch hat. Well if I choose the witch hat there it next person is left with just pumpkins. Now a do they want pumpkin hats? Maybe that's not a factor, but because it's now all the same symbol, the next person could refresh the entire board and have lots of choice. So, I might think, well, perhaps I should, do I want a pumpkin hat? I was like, well, I could do. I mean, I could put it here in this corner. It would get me some more points that way. Or do I desperately want the witch's hat? But I might decide, you know what? I'll take the pumpkin. All right, I can put it there. I'll build this shape. Here we go. There's another one. I want them on diagonals with each other. That's all good. And now the opponent can't refresh the display without a cat ability because they've got two different symbols. So you are at least maybe not necessarily thinking about every player in the game like in a four-player one, but in a two-player or even three player, you know, you're definitely thinking about the person who's after you and considering what they can do. You know, in my last game, I definitely made a a deal of that where the one to the left of me was constantly trying to grab the witches hats, you know, and trying to get sets of free.
So, when I see they've got five, I'm more inclined to think, well, can I use a witch's hat? I don't want to give you a sick witch's hat. You know, I better make that as part of my decision. Yes. Okay. Not the most interactive game in the world, but it's something. It's It means that it's not entirely a multiplayer solitaire game. The game does take about 45 minutes as it says on the box. I mean, an hour absolute max, and that's if you've got slow players. But, yeah, we are talking 45 minutes or so to get a game in. Maybe even quicker if you do this with two. Um really the longest part of the game um in terms of like ah this bit takes a little while is probably the scoring phase. You score up three times and you've got to go through each of the five different cards as well as say who got their grid done first for some bonus points. And in the early game it doesn't take much to count it but in the later game it might take a little bit longer and obviously with four players you got to do it four times over. So you do take a little bit of a break in between rounds to sort out scoring but it's not quite as crazy as some other games have done it. And the scoring conditions are not particularly complex either. I mean they, you know, rows, columns, pairs, groups, diagonals, least of, most of, you know, all those classic little tropes you've seen is kind of what you see on here. I'd certainly say that these are easier to score than say some of the stuff in Timbertown was. Although there are one or two in here that I have seen where I'm like, uh, that'd be quite fidd fiddly. I've got to see which group is connected to this group or whatever.
It's like there's one or two that are a little bit crazy. But, you know, one or two in a pack of 25 is nothing, you know, too bad in that front. Uh, it's just a very simple, smooth affair. But the thing I really love about this is that whole transition between rounds. Cuz most of these games, if they are getting you to build up a grid, will just have you build up the grid and then that's the end of the game. Or you build up the grid and then scrap everything, start a fresh new grid. But most of the time it's just one grid, one game, that's it. The fact that this one has multiple rounds and doesn't refresh itself, you know, other than taking out the tree tiles is the unique selling point for this game. I said at the start, how's this going to stand out from the pack? There may be other games with tile lane where this sort of thing happens. To my mind though, I can't think of them off the top of my head.
I'm sure somebody will say in the comments if they can, but the fact that I've got to think about it is enough to make this game stand out. And it's just a good fun part because it makes this one more finy despite the fact that it's got very simple rules. I mean, the rule book is written perfectly well. No ambiguity. Two pages for the solo mode, rules summary, and useful terms on the back of the book, which is all you need. I mean, this one doesn't really need a reference aid. The back of the book is perfectly fine. And you can see these cards, you know, at any point. So, you know, for something that's got a very smooth and simple rule set, the fact that there's actually a really good thinky element and a decent amount of depth for dealing with the fact that your whis stay in place is such a cool new feature for a tile laying game because, you know, if I take these three out already, I've got to think, well, now I've got these whis stuck here, these stuck here. So, what shapes can I like kind of, you know, weave in and out of those? I could do like an S spin down there or an L shape. you know, where am I going to put my cat before the next round starts? That has an impact, particularly with the greens, that the placement of these is highly dependent on what your cat is. Sorry, where your cat is. So, that's going to have an impact as well. But also, because some of these will build up over time. I mean, you know, here, count, you know, count pumpkins not on a diagonal with another pumpkin. Okay, so this would probably suck. I'd have probably had it there instead. But the points get bigger. So, I've got two like that. Nine points. Four. Four of them. I'll get 22.
six of them are 39. You know, they do compound upon each other. But obviously now that your whis are stuck here, as you build up in subsequent rounds, you have to consider the stuff you've done before as well as the new stuff. You don't get to go, "Well, I didn't put those in the best of positions, but it's all right. Well, scrap it now, and now I start a fresh." No, your mistakes or your good placements from earlier are going to haunt you in the future rounds. And there have been times where I thought, God, yeah, if I'd actually spaced these out a little bit more in the past, I might have actually had an easier time trying to deal with these. And sometimes, like, you know, this one, one point for each tree in your largest group of trees. I've created some weird little loops or something. One game I Yeah, one game I created this weird ring loop of trees. It was still the same group, but that was because I had a bunch of my wisps all tightly, tight together in the middle, and I was building around them. So suddenly I had to create that kind of sequence to make more most of that scoring objective.
It's just a cool little twist. I can't think of other tile lane games that do this. And you know for something in a very tired, shall we say genre to bring out a unique point that gives this game a lot of depth is a solid plus point for it. It does add a lot to the enjoyment. You can play this solo as well. I mean it's a two-page solo book. Basically, the back of these guides has uh four levels of difficulty for a solo mode. And the solo mode's actually quite nice if you want a quicky little puzzle. You play the game as normal. You select five objectives and you play your turns as normal. But the way it works for the solo is essentially one of these wisp tiles will be replaced by the ghost cat as it is. You know, the ghost cat will come on here and you have these firefly tokens which basically you you know each round you'll put so many at random and they've got movement values on the back.
The idea is is that the ghost cat will look one, two, or three spaces typically. You know, I think it's one, two, or three. I can't remember if there's a four in there, but you know, it will look so many spaces around the ring and it will select the tile that will score it the most points. How many points does it score? Well, you randomly choose that at the start of the game where you assign one of these wisps to each of the score values. So, you know, for example, in one particular game, it's going to go very much for the hearts because each one is worth eight points. I mean, this is a a second level difficulty one. And so when you're looking at the board and considering, right, well, you know, you you'll know, you can see how many ones and twos and threes there are in a deck. You've got some knowledge, but you don't know how many of them have come out in a round. You'll look at the board and think, well, uh, there's only two spaces ahead of the cat, and it will pick an eight-point tile, so maybe I should take that particular tile. Okay, can I use the tile? Yes. Do I like the shape? Not overly, but do I bank that it's going to draw a one, in which case it won't look at the tile. It won't pick it. or do I just let it have it or have I got to find some way to work around it? You know, there's a few extra little choices that you got to make. But that's it.
That's all the piloting you have to do. You just flip a token and it picks a tile. It's not going to build its own grid. You haven't got to deal with if it has this, do this or anything. It's just flip a Firefly token, looks ahead, takes the tile, put it next to the scoring thing on here, and this is how many points it will score at the end of the game. You've got to beat it with all the objectives. So, this game is fun to play solo as well as multiplayer. Um, adding too many players probably just adds more time to the game. I mean, four players doesn't really add anything extra over three and that so on, but and there's no two-player variant. You know, two player plays out the same. So really player count only really affects the choosing of the tiles, you know, like how often this thing's going to refresh and that, but it makes it quite strategic in a two-player game because obviously this is only going to refresh so often in two players, whereas in four it will probably refresh more often, but then at least it means you've got more choices ahead of you. It's just a lot of good stuff going for this, you know. Is it one that I would want to play over and over again? Probably not. I mean, this genre has kind of done what it needs to do, and the scoring phases can take a little long at times. You know, there is that aspect, but it really does a good job of standing out in the crowd of a very used up genre. You know, it's like rolling rights have this problem. How do you make a rolling right stand out when there's so many of them out there? Same goes for this and probably area control games. Tile lane games have been done to death. We have done Tetris Polyomino games to death. and it's getting tired.
But this one, the fact that you create the shape out of tiles rather than just taking Tetris pieces, the fact that the whis stay from round to round and affect future rounds. It's it's enough to give this one its own stamp, its own like USB, its own. This is, you know, let's get a bunch of tile laying games, right? This one's kind of covering that. This one's covering this. Oh, yeah. And Whiswood, that's covering this unique bit. And, you know, that's an impressive feat in itself. at the gorgeous artwork and production quality. And this one is an unexpected hidden gem for me this year. I am giving this one a coveted nine out of 10 excellence rating. This is a distinction level game. I'm almost I was almost tempted to think, is it worthy of a 10? I don't know. But the scoring can take a little while at times and in four players, you know, you've got more turns and the game might just take slightly longer in that respect.
And there's only so much interaction, but there's a little bit. So, I'm maybe not quite 10 out of 10. Although, to be fair, I'm not entirely sure if there are any tile laying games that warrant a 10 out of 10 for me, but this is a high nine. This is just a really, really good tile laying game that ticks the boxes for what it needs to do, and finds a way to stand out, looks the part, plays the part, can even be played solo. It's just a really, really excellent tile lane game. So, kudos. You won me over.
Boom, So, that's it for me on this episode of the Broken People. If you like what you see, then please thumb it up on YouTube and thumb up on Borg Geek when it goes live on the page. Check out the rest of my review content. There's been plenty going around, lots of little reviews, a couple of big ones as well, and of course, plenty more to come. Thank you CG for the review copy. Thank you to the Patreons who help me uh keep this channel supported. Consider joining if you want to help me get all the fees paid, all the subscriptions paid, and of course, get more copies of games to review on your behalf. And until next time, remember, regardless of whether you adore this little kitty hiding the little tree, it's still only a game. So, bye for now.