Hadrian's Wall | Game Review
Transcript
thank you hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson Beyond Solitaire and today I'm going to be reviewing Hadrian's Wall this is a chunky Roland rights released by Renegade games alright so I'm gonna give a very quick overview of Hadrian's well the main thing I want to tell you is that it's a lot less scary than it looks the the bark is a lot worse than it's fine basically what's going to happen is that over the course of six rounds so you've got six little gear markers up here you are going to do everything that you possibly can with the resources human and stone that you generate and basically what will happen is that every round you're going to flip one of these cards to figure out what resources you're going to have you're going to draw cards from your deck in order to choose a scoring condition and some additional resources as well as shapes for scouting so you're going to use your cards to kind of direct your game and your strategy and then also take some extra resources and then the solo game there's also a neutral deck that you draw cards from to let you interact with it as if it was another player basically there are situations in the game where you're allowed to trade with your neighbors or use your neighbor's scouting shapes on their cards in order to do what you need to do on your paper so if you want to see all that in action I'm actually going to have a how to play video out shortly but the main thing to note is that there's a six year structure and that you're using these cards to help determine the resources you have to work
with then you're going to deploy those resources in order to do a number of activities that are on these two sheets basically over here you have wall and resource type stuff going on so basically you can do mining build up your wall guard build up parts of your wall build up your fort and add granaries that allow you to extend how far you're actually able to build your form because everything is kind of gated based on how far you've taken the foundation of your fort so you can then build protections onto the top of it and essentially in order to do anything in the game you pay the resource that's listed and then when you check off certain boxes you check the resources that are in the box and then take them immediately so you're essentially taking these turns where you spend one kind of resource and then you're hopefully chaining to keep gaining things and getting things until you're having these massive turns especially in the later years of the game as you work on your wall there are also some opportunities to boost your resource production get extra citizens get extra Builders and even build roads that give you points so if you invest in these sorts of things early then you're going to get dividends throughout the game in the form of extra resources or even extra points in order to make progress in the game down here is where your main point scoring tracks are so you can kind of get a sense of how you're doing but basically there are four different point types plus calculation for the points that come off of your cards and you're aiming to do as
well as possible Peak solo score is 70 and then we can talk about what happens once you can hit that consistently there's also a negative scoring condition which is disdain basically every year the picks will try to come invade and if you didn't protect against them then you're going to get into trouble but I'm going to talk about that in just a moment over here you have places to put your civilians so basically you can invest with Traders performers priests apparatories or patricians and this opens up extra buildings and actions that are useful throughout the game so the Traders let you build precincts for resource production and points you can trade goods and that to get you points down here in the theater you can put on performances or mess around with Gladiators priests allow you to build Gardens and temples that give you something to do with your meeples and also generate points and as well as advancements along these tracks the apparatory isn't lets you build baths which lets you bribe your way at us in disdain which you might need depending on how you do in a courthouse that lets you basically kind of exchange one type of resource for another and then down here with the patricians you can take the Diplomat action in order to get some points and also block against the picks and then over here scouting where you can basically use these tetris-like shapes on the cards to fill out this little grid here and pick up some extra resources and one thing that you should note as you play and something that'll be really clear in my how-to video is that as you move along these tracks uh there are different colored flags and basically what that means is that you've unlocked the ability to build certain things so for example you can't build a small Precinct until your three spots on
the way along this track and there are other kinds of limitations you can't just do everything all at once so part of the game is deciding where to invest and how soon in order to open up the way to make progress later and then once you've spent all of your resources and done all of your little chain reactions at the end of the year you're going to go up against the picks so one thing that you can choose to invest in if you are crossing out these Shield symbols are your cohorts you have left right and Central and basically you're going to draw a certain number of cards depending on the year and difficulty level you've chosen and they're going to show you what direction the picks are coming from so if you draw four cards you draw four of these and then you see how many of the attacks you successfully managed to block if you block them all then you get a certain number of Valor points based on the gray flag over here um if you fail to block the ball you're going to pick up some disdain which you Circle off down here and which can lead to some negative points that are pretty nasty if you let it get out of control so even though it looks like there's a whole lot going on this game is kind of like a giant slot machine of working on your wall working on your buildings trying to get points and then trying to build things that will keep that chain running long longer and longer every year every turn and again I'm going to post a how to solo video for this so you'll be able to actually see the game in action as I play but for now let's have some final thoughts all right so now for some final thoughts overall I'm gonna say I really really really like Hadrian's Wall I absolutely love games where you're trying to squeeze the most possible out of every turn and you know get every Advantage every point every
extra resource and you know playing Hadrian's Wall is kind of like a pinball machine where you fill in one slot and then it gets you something in another part of the sheet it'll get you another resource and then you can use that to build something else and then that building gives you a point and then getting a point get you another worker and so basically all that together creates this really satisfying experience for me that I personally just really enjoy uh the game looks a lot heavier than it actually is um it had like a three point something weight on BGG when I looked earlier today and I was honestly surprised by that um it looks heavy but I would say that in reality it just isn't it's uh actually a very manageable game uh with some caveats that I am about to give you that said uh this game actually made me better solo than multiplayer uh it uh it's very very non-interactive there's like interaction where you look at your neighbor's cards and it's actually a little bit spicier in Solo because you have to draw extra picked cards to make up for using those neighbor cards but you're not really going to interact much with each other's play space in a game of Hadrian's Wall and because you want to sit there and think through your entire turn this actually may be a game that's better to play by yourself because then you don't have to wait for other people or kind of panic because other people are waiting for you you can take your sweet time and your game can evolve as it is meant to um also because it was so non-interactive we were just seeing their coloring on our little pieces of paper um somebody in my game group walked by who've been playing another game like looked at us for a second and said y'all it looks like you're taking the SAT which I mean I was the kind of student
kind of liked the SAT so no um I uh I will say it's a really satisfying game but it requires a lot of concentration you have to sit there and really look at the sheets and like enjoy doing that kind of accounting in order for the game to be satisfying that said it really did it for me it gets my engine going I was very happy with it um the other thing that I will say about this game is that it is very difficult for the mistake prone like I make mistakes and um it's really easy to miss stuff on here like you know you it's very easy to try to build a building that you know you actually didn't Advance the civilian track enough to create or open up yet um it's very easy to accidentally go beyond the lines in your uh Fort area because you did an advance your Greenery far enough and you just kind of missed it because you were working on the mines in the forest um there are just a lot of like little easy accounting errors to make because there's so much going on and you have to be really really on top of this game and really focusing on it and even then you're still gonna mess up so that's okay as long as it's okay with you but if you get crazy when you make mistakes um or you know you really struggle with like an asterisk next to your score because you you made a mistake that you couldn't take back um then this game May frustrate you quite a bit I did notice too like in a multiplayer game because even if your teach is pretty good and other people seem to
know how to play if if you have new players who are extra mistake prone because you're all taking your turn simultaneously and you're so focused on your own work um then it's really easy to miss mistakes that others are making as well which can throw off a multiplayer game it's less the case in Solo I mean the times that I mess up what I will typically do is I'll essentially just pay myself back I'll treat it like a loan and maybe pay it back with interest so like forego you know the workers or resources I would have needed and sacrifice like one more but I mean everybody will come up with their own solutions for this but overall I mean I would say that Hadrian's Wall is maybe it's my favorite what one right or flip and Phil right now I really really like it and um it has its challenges but for me uh this is this is really the ideal in the sense that you're kind of bouncing all over the place and like really really pushing yourself to do better and better and better um in ways this game gives me some of the same feelings as Fleet dice which is another rolling right that I truly adore uh but I like it better so even though it's chunky and it doesn't quite fulfill like the simple pull it out play it premise of most role and writer flip and fill games um this one really does it for me because I find the puzzle of doing it so satisfying and I like having different options for things to pursue I like kind of letting my um my cards for my deck guide me on that as I'm choosing scoring conditions and overall that's really nice and uh now that I'm starting to score a little bit higher I now will actually be able to do the solo campaign so in the rule book there's just solo
scores like if you score between us and this year you're a melees dude just a soldier or like oh you can be the prefectus you know you're the best um and that's cool and you know for a while I've been kind of in that 60 scoring range trying to get to where I can consistently hit 70. I think I may be about to make another breakthrough with it and uh in which case I'll be ready to start the campaign so there's also a solo campaign for this game that I'll link in the show notes uh where you're is basically going through Forts and you have different like restrictions on your play and different challenges as you go from Fort to Fort so this game also like once you get to where you consistently score high it gives you a little bit more to do with it after that so it just pretty much keeps giving um I've considered it quite worth my time I really like it and uh yeah I mean My My overall review as a game is is very positive I actually want to make a video that's a follow-up for historicity purposes in the future so be on the lookout for that but the one thing I do want to talk about um is the presence of the purple Maples which are called servants the rule book is honest about the fact that they are slaves early on in the rule book but then you just keep calling them servants throughout and I kind of feel like like are we really going to just be like yeah they were there and we acknowledged their suffering and then like continue to ignore it while having a really good time the rest of the game that was something that really gave me a hard time um if you watch my playthrough video you'll notice that I can't decide what to call the purple meeples because I don't allow my students in my Latin classes to call a Sarah wuss which is the word for slave a servant I think
it's really important to acknowledge fully historically what you are doing and I do feel just uneasy uneasy that I'm playing a game that has slaves in it that I'm acquiring and then using for various purposes um that obviously has not stopped me from enjoying the game played the game many times I don't intend to stop but it does give me just that little ick factor and it gives it to me every time because I think that when you take a game's theme seriously you know you owe it to the historical setting and to yourself to be real about what it is that you're doing and you know that constant like kind of cold reminder of how gross Roman society really was um you know is present for me when I play this and you know there will be people who are like whatever it's just colored meeples and it's fine and whatever uh but that's not how I feel and if that's not how you feel either then you should be warned that that is probably my biggest barrier to playing this game actually I feel really awkward because I don't feel comfortable calling a slave a servant and I feel very uncomfortable saying oh you got another slave meeple because that doesn't feel great either so you know what you do about that historically um there's there's a lot of ways that we could approach that I guess I might talk about that another video but um yeah that's that's my biggest like issue with the game as a game I think it's delightful very easy to make mistakes lots of accounting but super satisfying and I don't see this one leaving my collection anytime soon so uh that's had dreams wall thank you so much for watching please like subscribe comment
uh please do support me on patreon if you're feeling generous and most of all happy gaming foreign