Valheim - Board Game Review - The Forest Is Moving
Transcript
Oh, and it is lovely. Just beautiful. You know, you are quite a decorator. It's amazing what you've done with such a modest budget. I like that boulder. That is a nice boulder.
Hi everyone. I'm the broken mele. Win or lose, I'm going to be honest with you. Sorry, I'm a bit late with this one, but this is Mood Publishing's Valheim, the board game that I'm finally going to review. This is its deluxe edition form, and I will talk about some of the editions in the deluxe edition. It's mostly cosmetic, but for suffice to say, yes, there is a retail version of this one with a smaller box and that, and the retail edition is perfectly fine in terms of its components. You know, you're upgrading things to, you know, some wooden components and a sort of big prop-up house that you can build and stuff like that, but for the most part, like, it's just cosmetic. The retail version is still perfectly good, perfectly fine. If you are not interested in paying the extra money for component upgrades, then by all means just get the normal version. But I've got this big one. And just as a little bit of context, Valheim is another one of those PC games I've sunk a lot of hours in. So Deep Rock Galactic was their first one, one that gave a 10.
It's like a benchmark for a video game adaptation board game. And Valheim is another one I've sunk a lot of hours in. I mean, Deep Rock Galactic's probably taken a good 500 plus hours of my life easily. I'm I'm sure it's more than that. And Valheim, I don't know how many hours it's taken up. I'm sure I'll put a screenshot up, but yeah, it's taken up a fair whack as well. And funny enough, me and friends on Sunday evenings are going through it again in a kind of uh high difficulty run through. So, you know, we we enjoy playing this. So, I played the PC game. It's basically a survival game where you're dropped into the middle of an open world procedurally generated and you have to build structures, gather resources, kill wildlife, you know, kill monsters and, you know, get the meat, get the furs, get the leather, you know, smelt ores, all the typical survival game stuff that you see, except you do it effectively with your person in kind of third person view. It looks very pretty despite being typically a kind of sort of not quite pixelated graphics.
We're not talking Stardw Valley type thing, but certainly not like the most grandiose of 3Dness here. And it's just a very addictive game. I do recommend people try it if they can, whether solo or preferably in a multiplayer group. You get a multiplayer group of yourself going with it, it's great fun. So, obviously adapting it to a board game piqued my interest, but also worried me slightly because Valheim is a very long-term game. You play it over a course of many months, you know, or years even. You know, you build up your big base and then you move on to other biomes and then you build up another base and then you go to a different biome and you fight bosses and you know, this stuff takes time to put that into a board game that you can finish in one session. Is that actually possible to do? Deep Rock Galactic is a scenario-based game. You go in, get the get the mind stones, get the gemstones, kill the bugs, get out. You know, you can be done with a game of that on the PC in like 25 minutes or so. This takes a bit longer. Can you make it into a board game? Well, let's see.
You have my undivided attention.
Right, we got plenty to cover and somewhat to this game. It's brewing up a bit of a storm out there, so it's kind of fitting for the weather, but this is a scenario-based game. So, you are basically dropped into this world. It's open world in the normal game. Here, you have a pre-map setup with hex's as per the scenario. And the idea is is that you must venture forth, kill monsters, gather resources, build various bits of furniture in your house, and eventually be ready to summon the main boss. So that could be, you know, Ephicia, the sort of big sort of lightning deer basically, or it could be Bone Mass, this giant slab of ooze, poison, and undeadness, you know, who's a bit of a pain in the actual game. But, uh, you know, basically, you've got one of four different bosses to try. You've got a scenario book here with 14 different scenarios. Some of them just require you to kill a kind of like a mini boss, shall we say, like a troll or an abomination, but others will have you go up against the various boss characters, and the maps will be laid out sometimes with different islands so that you have to sail across from different ones, or it will be one big area that you venture out and go see. They will be made up of different biomes. So you have like the meadows, you've got dark forest, you've got swamps, you've got mountains, and each one progressively has more dangers, better resources, and you know, progresses you throughout the game. So if you're fighting a fikia, for example, you're mostly going to be based in the meadows, just like in a PC game. If you're going to be fighting Bone Mash, you're going to eventually be going into the swamps, that kind of thing. Players take control of an unnamed character effectively with their board, and they will be able to place item slots, have
stamina and health, and have uh slots for consumables. But what they'll essentially do at the start of the game is that they will have two skills chosen at random that they slot in. And these I need to take a better example there will give them ways that they can level up their character and give them unique abilities by performing certain actions in the game. So for example, explorer end my turn on a tile not adjacent to the house. If I do that three times, I get extra speed for the game. You also end up with one of Odin's blessings which effectively allows you to pay stamina to do something like heal, reroll, or die. you know, some small effect that can be useful, but of course cost your stamina to do so.
The spirit is willing, but the flesh is spongy and bruised.
You'll perform three actions on your turn, and there's quite a few that you can pick from. Typically, you'll move around the landscape, move to a different hex, flip it over, and it may spawn little monsters for you to fight. It might have ways that you can gather specific resources like wood. It might even have a treasure chest guarded by a skeleton or something. You'll move and if you encounter the monsters, you will effectively fight them in dice combat where your choice of weapon will determine your type of dice that you use. You're rolling hits. They are also rolling dice against you. Again, they will roll hits, maybe have defenses or special abilities like poison, for example. And if you've got armor, you might even be able to roll some defense dice on top. When you fight enemies, you might even be able to call in allies who are nearby. They can rush in for a stamina cost and assist you with the battle. Being outnumbered is not a good thing in Valheim. And when you start the game, you are weak as hell. I mean, you're basically just punching people.
And in like in the PC game, that's not the most recommended thing to do. And in here, they make it doubly so. But you can move around and instead gather resources. So this one here lets you roll a die, a green die to gather wood. Roll how many hands that you can grab. Get the resources. And these resources represented in cool little wooden pieces. Where am I trying to find them? Here they are. Wood could include, say, you know, animal fur or it could include wood. These will go onto your house and you use these as a different action to build bits of furniture. So, what are these furniture pieces? Well, these furniturees could involve a nice little table, a bed, you know, a rug, a crafting table, a beehive, you know, even a little boat to go sailing across the ocean. You all these little things that you build build in the PC game that can give you maybe like health regeneration, stamina regeneration, let you cook more meals. Cook. Yeah, you can cook. You can flip over a card from this deck and cook carrots and honey glazed chicken and bore meat and necktail. You know, all the classics you know from the game. You can craft. So, you can craft axes, spoons, yes, spoons, spears, bows, you know, different types of armor, helmets, shields, wolf hide, chest plates, you know, all the things that you remember from the game, providing you've got the materials as a group to spend. Anytime you get resources, they go back to your house. You don't have to f them around, and you work as a co-op in a group.
Look at me. I'm Dr. Zidberg, homeowner. After you've taken your free actions, there is an event deck for the respective boss that you're fighting. You flip over the top deck and it will do something fairly nasty. The creatures will move around or some weather effect will happen or you'll have a choice of do you want to do this? If so, you get a reward, but there's a negative to go with it. It might even spawn a raid. A raid is basically where over the course of the next few turns, enemies will build up on a hex nearby base. And once you get to a certain timer marker, they'll basically be unleashed on your base and you'll need to fend them off or risk your furniture getting smashed to pieces. This happens in the PC game and I got to say, pretty impressive. Managed to do it here. But the event deck is also a timer for the game itself. If this runs out and you haven't summoned the boss, game over, you lose. What you're trying to do is summon the boss as early as possible. But you want to be prepared for the boss because if you summon him early then he'll have less health as a result of the amount of cards left in this deck. The problem is if you go into the boss too early then you haven't got the weapons or the armor to be able to stand up to the brutal like you know ferocity of the boss as he comes and pounds your ass basically. And the idea is once you summon the boss you convert the top of the board into this little mini arena here. So here we've got the health track for bone mass for example. It tells you what defense and dice they roll. It's big undead mass.
You have a special help card as to what the different enemy dice values mean. And they'll have special effects like this one. You know, they turn around. Toxic swipe arena cards. They have their own like battle cards for fighting in the arena which might let the let's say Eigure might kick you with its hind legs or lightning zap you. You know, the the Elder might strangle you with some vines. You know, they got their unique quirks in combat. But what happens is that you are transferred to this little mini boss arena thing here. You have bone mass or the enemy sitting in the middle. And basically there'll be a facing requirement. So which way they're facing is important for what they do but what you can do against them. And on your turn you'll be able to move around the boss while also attacking it from different points of view. And there's different effects on the arena board and you have to obviously contend with the boss's attacks and its own arena specific attacks where it might, you know, bow mass might slap you in the face, but then also might poison you at the same time. If you can get the boss down to zero health, you win. If not, you lose. And if players die, it's not necessarily the end of the game. I mean, it is if you're in the arena battle, but in the main game, there is an opportunity to come back with your tombstone effectively, which is kind of like a kind of like a resurrect, much like in the PC game. You die, your stuff is kind of on the tombstone, you go back and get it, but at least you're still able to continue with the game. It's not one of those situations where if one person dies, everybody loses. Now, it's not quite that restricted. For the most part, that is the game. You have multiple scenarios that you can play.
There's even rules in the book to build your own scenario and tailor the difficulty how you see fit. But that's kind of the crux of the game. Start off, go out, get the resources, craft your gear, craft your furniture, kill monsters, and then eventually once you're ready to summon the boss, summon it and go kick his ass.
[screaming] So, from a good standpoint, let's talk about the production quality. Now, as I mentioned, this is the deluxe version that I'm reviewing here, but the retail version is still good. You get cardboard components rather than some wooden components, but everything still looks good. You've still got good tile hex's. The artwork is very nice, very bright and colorful, and comes straight from the game effectively. I mean, it's not completely ripped from the game because obviously the game is kind of a little bit more I don't know what the phrase is to use. It's blocky. It's almost kind of like a Minecraft style thing. Um, but the idea with this is that obviously it's proper artwork. So, it's a little bit more cleaned up here, but you'll recognize the creatures. You'll recognize the grey dwarfs and the the trolls, the the fen ring, the bone mass, and motor and all these ones. And it basically goes up to motor, so the fourth boss in the game. There's nothing here for the fifth boss, the goblin boss, or anything further than that. I suspect they'll save that for expansion content, but yeah, four is good enough for now. But with the Doug said, you know, you get nice insert trays. You know, they're fairly, you know, they're not the strongest thing in the world, but they will do the job nicely of holding your components. It's a little unclear where to file some of this stuff, and the rule book doesn't really help you in this regard. But basically, just come up with a system of your own, and you should be fine for the most part. You might even have some spare slots available that you didn't necessarily have before, but at least the cards and the tiles are easy enough to sort. And as well as like the different board game pieces, there is normally a board where you position all
this stuff on. I just can't fit it on the table right now, but it's basically just a board with a river, a big lake on it, the ocean, and you just put the tiles on it and connect this to the end. It's, you know, it's nice, but it's not essential. It's just there. But the production quality in general is pretty good. I like the miniatures. You know, they look like the game. They're decent quality. They got decent amount of detail on them as well. Well, I think if anybody's a painting fan, they're going to have a field day with some of these. You know, the cards are good stock. I don't feel like I really need to sleeve these. You know, they can. And to be fair, the insert is not the best with sleeve cards, I've noticed. So, probably you just don't want to sleeve this game. I wouldn't worry too much. And you've got cardboard tokens. So, I I think it's a decent production all round with one exception. And it's not a big deal. Sorry, Vicure. Don't zap me. It's not a big deal, but it is a problem. It's a gimmick. And as gimmicks go, it's pretty bad. It's the house. The house, some of it's fallen off. There's a lot of pieces here for crying out loud. Um, the house gets stored basically on the top of one of the uh tops of the trays here. And that's a that's not the best way to store anything. Just a flimsy little top of a tray here. But this house is a gimmick and it's not worth assembling because you've got to assemble this every game. So, it's not pre-built in the box, even in a box that big, you know. So, that's already a pain in the butt. But the other problem is that it's not essentially clear how to assemble it. Yes, they give you a guide how to do it, but even when you're looking at the guide, you're like, "Wait, that bit goes in there. That bit goes in there. That's
a bit fiddly." It's a fiddly thing to put together, but on top of that, it's entirely useless because it doesn't do anything to add to the game. It just gives you a 3D structure that you put here for your house. The problem is is that from depending what angle you're looking at or even if you've just got stuff inside it, it obscures your tokens and your furniture and stuff. So, you have to sort of peer inside the house to see what you've got. It I get that they were trying to make this a little bit more deluxe. But honestly, as deluxe things go, just forget it. You know, you're really only getting the deluxe for component upgrades, you know, insert and stuff like that. But, you know, possibly like for the miniatures as well, but do not get it for the house cuz the house is just annoying.
Making it bigger doesn't make it clearer. Deep Rock Galactic was very good for its simplicity. Like it was just a simple concept and the rules were pretty straightforward. Although granted, I do admit Deep Rock Galactic needed the second edition of its rule book to get like perfect. This one's a better rule book out of the gate, but it's still by no means perfect. But overall, this is a fairly simple game to learn. And I know it looks like there's a bit a lot of pages here, but that's because the font is very big. There's a lot of pictorial examples and this one has a lot of like, you know, references for all the creatures, all the tokens and all the biomes and everything. So, you know, it's a very comprehensive rule book with an icon guide on the back and, you know, and even player raids besides. I wish that maybe there was a player aid for a couple of other parts of the game.
It's not perfect, but, you know, it's it's doing a good enough job. But, the game is fairly straightforward. You know, if someone's teaching you this game, you're going to get it easily. It's not a hard game at all. There's no complex actions. There's nothing that's hard to grasp. You know, the idea of go out, get resources, craft. I mean, we've all done that stuff before, so it's familiar to people. Dice combat's very simple. So is crafting. So is cooking. So is, you know, the event deck.
Super easy, fairly an inconvenience.
It's has all the references in here, and it does make it rather a big book. I think it might have been better if they'd simply kind of cut half of it and put it as its own reference book and just kept this as the normal rules. You know, then you wouldn't have such a big rule book that you're having to, you know, pass around all over the place. And the final little blemish against it is that it's not the best at edge cases. Edge cases and FAQs are going to pop up for this game, and BGG has a fair few of them already. But as much as you will easily be able to play the game fine and you won't have any problem with the main rules, it is still a straightforward game, there are still edge cases that this rule book struggles to help you with and you're either going to have to just come up with your own little rule for it or ask the designers or ask around on BG. So yeah, not perfect. I mean, Deep Rock Galactic wasn't perfect with its rule book either. So this is something that probably maybe Move Publishing needs to work on, I think, as a publisher, you know, because you know, Deep Rock wasn't perfect. This one's not perfect with it. So, you know, I I put it in the good section because overall it's straightforward. But yeah, there is that little blemish. Bear that in mind.
And I think Moods needs to start working on this front.
He's out of line, but he's right.
The theme of the original game is represented well here. Now, you do have the problem that you can't really take a game that is like, you know, many months and years of play and condense it into a board game and not have some abstractness thrown in. but it does do a decent enough job. Each scenario almost feels like maybe like an extended night playthrough. And there are rules in the game to play this in campaign mode. You effectively play four games in a row. You go through all the four different bosses and you can save little bits of furniture and that from your previous base and bring them over to the next one. But for the most part, I'm not desperate to play this in campaign mode. I actually think the game is better just played as a simple scenario. But everything else that you do in the game does feel like what you do from Valheim, you are building the same bits of furniture. I mean beehives and stuff, you know, every time you get a beehive in Valheim, it's fantastic cuz honey is such a useful ingredient. You, you know, you build up your base, you fill it with beds, you fill it with crafting tables and stuff. And you know, that stuff brings back the theme. If you're if you've never played Valheim in your life, you're probably going to lose a little bit of that Easter egg factor here, but you know, you're still going to get a decent smooth like survival game anyway. And there is definitely that co-op feel. Each of you is moving around the map. You're working together.
You can jump across the like the field effectively. You know, if you're close enough to somebody who gets caught up in a battle, it's like, "All right, I'm going to come and help you. Like, let's kill them together. You all work together for the arena battle at the end." So, there's no like one player lone ranger thing. You're going to need to work together because if you don't, you're not going to be able to get to the whole summoning thing before this deck runs out. You know, the timer is relatively tight in this game. You've got a decent amount of variety with what you can craft. You know, you've got axes and knives, pickaxes and bows and clubs and swords and all sorts of things here. And you can even buy certain special armor from Howor the Trader. So, crystal battle axe, a bone tower shield, stag breaker. Everybody remembers that one. Troll hide cape. So, there's a few little interesting bits and bobs that you can use to, you know, tailor up what it is you're going to make. But, there's only so much time. You've only got so much material. So, you are going to have to work FOR IT.
WHAT ABOUT YOU GUYS? WE AIN'T FOUND
With the subject of theme, I mentioned raids before. I'm very impressed they managed to represent those in the game. In the PC game, now and again when you're hanging around your base, it will basically say raid, like, you know, a figureure is angry or something. And basically, a wave of enemies come at your base trying to destroy it. And it's a pretty cool function in the game because it means that you can't venture too far from your base, especially if somebody's been left behind, because you might have to come back and sort out the raid. It's the danger of exploring too far out and leaving your base unattended. Well, in this case, it would have to be attended by one or two people because if there's only one person defending the base from an entire raid, that could be problematic. I didn't think they were going to be able to represent that here, but they managed to and it works quite well. You draw the card from the event deck and then it basically over the next three player turns builds up enemies in the nearby hex. So it will build up a grrey, another grrey or grrey and a grey dwarf, whatever. And it will build them up and then when the timer runs out, they all rush your base and you basically engage in a normal combat but with multiple enemies. So you've got a few turns to prep, get back to your base, maybe craft some other items to help you. And it does feel like a raid from the game.
It's a shame it only really happens once during each scenario because it only has one card in the deck. But I guess you wouldn't be able to do that many raids in a game where you've only got like a small deck of event cards and a timer. You know, the game can't carry on forever. But I'm just pleased that they actually managed to represent that. You know, I it was a more tricky aspect of the game to bring to the tabletop and it works well. It adds kind of like a little nice little bit of narrative as you're going through. You know, you're trying to get resources and you're killing the little monsters. Ah, the raid. All right, guys. Get back now. You know, it it brings that little commodery and it's just it sounds like a small thing, but for someone like me who wants this game to adapt the video game and be respectful to its IP, I'm glad that it does go out of its way to do that. You know, this is definitely paying homage to the theme. It's not just using it for the sake of using it. No, it actually is trying to be Valheim. I like the little arena battle setup as well with with this. So, you know, it's not like one of those ones like Vagrant song or like the uh what was the other one? That big one?
Oath sworn. We're not talking phenomenally huge boss battlers like that. It's kind of like scaled down mini version. Essentially, the boss will be in the middle and it will rotate round, you know, based on what you roll, but you've got it. It can do many hits against you. It will have its own unique deck of attacks and each of you is effectively sort of running circles around it trying to hit it in its back rather than be in its front arc, etc. But the map has different like limitations like if you go into certain areas you can't use fire costs more stamina you can only use range weapons that kind of thing and you know just makes for a nice little like ending to the game like you've been doing this stuff already and then then suddenly the game play changes slightly and puts you into this little boss battler. It can feel punishing. I mean you know you're dealing damage to the monster but then it's also pummeling you back. Although it depends how well you prepared.
Sometimes you might steamroll the final boss because your weapons are just that good or your rolls were just that good. And you are going to have to accept that this is a game of dice and sometimes the dice will love you and sometimes they'll hose you. Yeah, you're not playing this as a full Euro experience. But then let's face it, did you do that with Deep Rock Galactic? So, same thing applies here. This is a fanatic survival game, not a Euro game. But yeah, I like this little arena setup. You know, they could have maybe like added a couple of extra differences. You know, there's not a huge amount of differentiation between the four bosses, but there's a little bit. There's enough. And it's just a nice little ending. It's not like, oh, we spent ages doing the actual game, and now we've got to spend ages on this. Now, the game actually will probably only take you about 90 minutes, 2 hours tops to play through a full scenario.
Really, it's not going to take that long to get through the deck, do your free actions, and do the little mini boss battle. It's still a fairly quick example of this type of game. And normally these type of games can be made to take quite a long time to finish, particularly if it was a full civilization style game or like a big epic survival game. This one is scaled down to be less epic, but as a result, shorter, quicker, and smoother. See, there's two sides to every sport.
I especially like that this game has a pretty decent tutorial system. You essentially play through this big sort of 55 card deck and it takes you through the main mechanics of the game. Not every mechanic. It's not really going to explain raids in here and certainly I did mention those edge case problems and not going to be in here as well, but this will teach you essentially the bulk of how to play this game pretty well by just simply following the directions on the card as you flip them over. There are some problems with this though. It's not perfect. Firstly, one of the cards actually does have a legit mistake on the card. I believe it is card number 25. It tells you to spend um your last action to craft a fire table and then tells you what resources to remove except the resources on the actual player summary are different from what's on the tutorial. Now, the player summary is the one that's correct, but yeah, your tutorial having an error is not a good thing. Okay? And also, there are just a couple of bits in here that are not worded the best. You know, there's a one or two combats, you know, particularly with multiple enemies that feel like the wording could have been a little bit better, but you can get through it. you can figure it out and it makes the tutorial maybe just a little bit clunky in places, but for the most part it will do a decent job of teaching you the game. I'm just glad that they threw this in, you know, and it does, you know, you know, let's say, call it B+, you know, a B+ job of teaching you the game because a lot of these games will not bother with a tutorial. You know, games like Frost Punk, for example. Frost Punk's a awesome game and I love it, but it probably could have
used a tutorial deck like this to go through the game rather than throwing it in with a really complex and hard scenario, you know? So, it was definitely worthy of it inclusion, but yeah, maybe just a run through like a blind play test I feel like would have spotted one or two of those little issues and it could have been easily fixed. Now, no game is perfect and this one is definitely not perfect. There are some flaws that do need to be considered here. The replay value has been called into question by people and I can see where they're coming from. You do have a lot of scenarios in this book. I mean, you've got what was it 14 scenarios and they do vary in terms of the map layout and which boss you're facing and stuff like that. And you can even make your own. So, you can basically balance the difficulty by saying right, you know, how big's the world, how many islands, how many biomes, what normal or veteran creatures, few many objectives, that kind of thing. And so you have got a decent amount of variety in the box. I'm not saying that there's no replay value.
But one thing about these scenarios which Deep Rock has an advantage on is that they do feel kind of sy in how they operate. You know, Deep Rock Galactic scenarios, particularly with the added expansions, are definitely more varied. You know, just a simple go and collect a few gems is very different from the one that has you collect those big arquarks and stick them in the middle. It's also very different from escorting a drill dozer. It's incredibly different from building the Morite pipelines that you do. You know, two of those are in an expansion, but like I say, with those different scenarios in there, they do feel different. I mean, attacking the dreadnaugh, for example, that's very different than doing a normal mission. Here, though, regardless of which boss you're facing, it doesn't necessarily translate into anything phenomenally different. You know, you might change up what type of weapons you make because instead of making wood, you're making iron, but at the end of the day, you're still making a spear. It's just a funkier looking spear. You know, it's more just the boss you face at the end is going to be slightly different in how it attacks you and its arena rules, but what you're doing in the game of go out, get resources, and bring them back and craft stuff and furniture is not drastically different. You know, you might vary things up. Like one game you end up building a bunch of beehives. you know, the next game you end up, you know, saying, you know what, I'm going to build a fire table and all our weapons are going to be on fire, you know, and that helps. It certainly does against the Elder, but you know, it's not going to dramatically feel that different from game to game. You're more just setting the map and the type of foe that you're facing and the type of
biomes that you're in rather than changing the full-on scope of the game you're playing. So, that is it's a flaw and I do see where people are coming from, but that's not to say that this game is devoid of replay value. It's definitely here and if you're willing to make your own scenarios, you can kind of do what you like. But yeah, it's not it I can't say that they're not sort of partially correct on that front.
I'm going to allow this.
The customization of your main characters is also a little bit lacking in this. You know, yes, you can give them what weapons you desire and what sort of consumables and that, but the skills are designed at random. So you could just say, "All right, I'm going to pick them this game." But normally they're done at random. But some of them are easier than others to achieve. And this is kind of the only thing that differentiate your character. Basically, two skills and a little bonus that you can spam with stamina if you happen to have any stamina, which is not always a common thing. So that's the only way that your characters are differentiated. You know, you it's yes, you might say, "All right, I've got a sword, I've got a spear, but that's not a massive difference really. Even in the PC game, if my colleague over there has got a sword and I've got a spear, that just defines the way we attack things, it doesn't really fundamentally change the character we've got. Maybe if you're an archer and you're going for stealth rather than like full-on armor and getting into the front lines with a hammer, then yeah, there's a difference.
But that sort of thing doesn't translate to the board game. That's more the PC game. Here, all you've got are these two skills, and they're not the most varied, and some are harder than others, and sometimes you might even think, well, they're not even that worth doing. I mean, it's nice to have extra speed, but then there are others where it's like, oh, I can potentially re-roll a dieice if I have a certain token to spend. Well, getting those tokens in the first place is not easy. And so, the power feels a little bit situational compared to others. You know, there are definitely some that I think are better by far than others included. Now, sometimes those ones are hard. You have to do them more times to trigger them. Would it have been nice if they were triggered from the get-go? Like rather than having to actually work to activate your skill, can I not just start with a skill? Just a little bit more customization with the characters, I think, would have been welcomed here.
It's not like it's not terrible, but it's a little bit of a shame. It just would have been nice to have gone through some kind of customization, but to be fair, a PC game doesn't give you a ton of it either. So, I can't like fault it too much for that. But, I don't know. It's just a little bit like maybe just a little bit extra, but I say it's not it's not bad, but yeah, it just could be better. I hate this game. The only other nitpick I can think of is that when you have a lot of people on a hex, it can get a little bit cumbersome. You know, three different spots on a hex, the hex's are decent size, but could have been bigger. And when you've got like a troll and multiple railings, and you know, you're two or three people on the same hex, it can get a little bit clustered and it makes it a little bit hard to track. Not to mention that for some reason they only gave you one copy of each monster card. So when you're tracking what monsters you're fighting and how much damage they've done, it's a little bit fiddly having to put cubes around the individual models and such when they could have easily just printed more copies of the same monster card so you could lay all three of them out in front of you if you were fighting three enemies and then you just put the cubes on the card. That would have been a lot better. But for some reason they did it like this and it's just it can occasionally lead to some fiddly battles. But it's not a massive deal.
I've seen plenty of miniature games fall shy of this problem, but come on guys, you know it's a problem when you see it around. This is something we should be trying to solve.
I missed the part where that's my problem.
The difficulty curve is also a small nitpick to mention. The difficulty is generally fine. If you're playing it multiplayer, usually when I'm playing this solo, I will control two characters. The tutorial wants you to play all four at once, which is a bit cumbersome, but it's a tutorial and chances are you're hopefully playing this with other people. But two, three, or four player is probably the best way to play this in terms of how many characters are in the game. You can play it true solo. Just have one dwarf and that's it. No other changes. The problem is that one dwarf on their own or one character, I say they're not dwarfs. I'm thinking of Deep Rock, but you know, one character on their own is pretty tricky. You know, it's difficult to get all the stuff you need and be able to survive against all the monsters with just one health pool worth of stuff. It's definitely playing on hard mode. If I'm playing solo, I will control two characters and I think that works pretty well. Three and four again works pretty well. You can cover more spaces, but obviously you go through the event deck a bit quicker. But raids by yourself, ow, they kind of hurt a bit. You know, multiplayer does favor the raids there.
So, yeah, you can play this true solo, and I I kind of wish maybe that the rules were set up so that they could scale for true solo a bit better, but in this case, I think it's more that if you're going to play this by yourself, control a couple of characters. It's not hard, but your experience will definitely be better. So Valheim overall does a decent job of representing the PC game it's based on and I'm glad that they've been faithful to the IP and certainly if you are a fan of the game like me it's going to elevate your experience of this. If you are not a fan of Valheim then you're not really going to get much from this and if you know nothing about Valheim then your experience will still be good. It just might be slightly diminished. I can certainly admit to the fact that there is an element of, you know, nostalgia here, but not like tons. You know, if the game was horrible, I'm not going to defend it just because it's faithful.
But this game is a pretty decent smooth survival co-op game. You know, the rules are not complicated. You can get into this game pretty quickly. You can even finish a game of this pretty quickly. You know, less than two hours, you should be done with a four player game of this. That's pretty good going for something like this. But the dice combat is fairly easy. The, you know, the crafting and the cooking and all the stuff you can buy in that. Again, straightforward. You know, all the stuff's on your player aid for what things cost and what certain effects are and that. So, the bulk of the game is pretty smooth. That being said, the game does trip up on itself every now and again with some, you know, issues with, you know, wording on some of the tutorial cards. The rule book not being very good with edge cases, you know, that is a bit of an issue. And the rule book just maybe being a bit long for what it is. I mean, like maybe they could have just cut it in half and had a reference book and a rules book. That would have been better. But the rules themselves are generally pretty decent in here. But yeah, you do have that issue that you're going to be asking a bit of FAQ now and again. And Deep Rock also fell victim to this, but I think this one falls victim to it a bit more than Deep Rock did, but then Deep Rock did eventually fix it with a second edition of the rule book. This one doesn't necessarily need a second edition of the rule book, but maybe it is when, you know, if they do future prints of this, they're going to need to print out like an FAQ sheet or something, you know, to handle those edge cases, cuz not everybody wants to go on BG to find out this stuff. Um, I wish there was maybe a little bit more customization on your characters rather than just two skill tiles that you may or may not do. And even though there is a decent amount of replay value in the game from the scenarios that it's giving
you, there is room for expansion. You know, more mechanics from Valheim can be put in here. And the scenarios aren't drastically different from each other. You know, you might have to go sailing in one and not in the other, but at the end of the day, you still go out, get resources, kill monsters, and eventually fight the big bad. It's just slightly tweaked as to what the big bad does and what the event cards have. It doesn't dramatically change the game, unlike the Deep Rock Galactic scenarios, which can fundamentally change how the game plays. So, there is that little element of issue there. So, this is a decent, faithful adaptation of Alheim and it's definitely one of the better ones I've seen. I have seen some god-awful adaptations of video game IPs. And I'm glad that Mood Mood Publishing are doing a good job of being faithful and bringing these popular IPs to the table.
But this one isn't as good as what Deep Rock was. Deep Rock was definitely a much better game. And I think the nature of what that game is, a 25inut scenario co-op shooter game, just suited the tabletop better for that one. Here, the tabletop is decent for it, but Valheim is a much more long-term style game, and it's a little bit harder to translate it well to the tabletop. And they've done a pretty good job here. Like I say, it's it's one that I really enjoy, and I want to hang on to this game. I'm going to give it an eight out of 10 overall. I think I think it's great. I think it is a great game, but those trip ups, the issues with maybe some of the replay value, you know, some of the tutorial wording, the edge cases in the rule book in this deluxe form, you know, the components are nice and the insert's nice, but that house is absolute garbage. You know, little lacking on customization. You know, there's little bits here and there that it does trip up on, and that takes it out of the distinction range category, but I think it's still worthy of an eight. I enjoy it. I want to play this when I can. Um, you can play the solo. It's going to be tricky to play solo. I mean, the difficulty is definitely, uh, shall we say, better in, you know, better in multiplayer than it is in solo, but, you know, you have that option available.
So, solo or co-op, there's plenty of ways for you to tailor your experience of this. It's a pretty great game, just not as good as what Deep Rock was.
Second place, THAT'S A FANCY WORD FOR LOSING.
SO, that's it for me on this episode of the Broken Me. If you like what you see, then thumb it up on YouTube and Board Game Geek or wherever else you see it online, Facebook, Instagram, the works. And of course, let me know your thoughts down below. What do you think of this Valheim board game? And what do you think of the Valheim PC game? You know, let me know your stories. Tell some funny stories about what's happened to you on the game or something. It'll be interesting to read. Until next time, remember, it's only a game. And I'll see you on the next Broken People video. Take care.