Skip to main content
Loading video...

Woodcraft - Board Game Review - Pinocchio's Demon Workshop

Transcript 24:08

thank you hi everybody I'm Luke Hector and this is the broken meeple you're watching a board game YouTube channel where I talk about games give my honest opinions regardless of whether people want to hear them or not we'll get on with this review in just a second but first I need to say a quick word from the sponsor as a fellow gamer you'll understand this is unacceptable the solution head down to my new sponsor kiander.com Kinder stocks many of the hot new releases as well as some old hidden gems free delivery on ultra's over 30 pound further discounts on bulk purchases and even five percent of your spending refunded bacteria's points to be used for further discounts down the line if you use the referral Link in the description below and sign up for a new account you'll get five percent discounts on your first order over 60 pounds so let's make gaps in your collection a thing of the past get down to kinder and start saving today thank you for listening and enjoy the rest of the video get on with it so today we're taking a look at Woodcraft this is from Ross Arnold and Vladimir suhi and I've been told that that's the phonetic pronunciation of his name so if I'm butchering it blame the viewers but this is from delicious games who are better known also for Prager kaboot regime underwater cities uh Messina 1347 or whatever the tagline was you know these types of games and they've all been pretty popular among Euro Gamers certainly from my perspective I thought Messina was kind of mehn it's a right above average I liked Prager fine I don't love it but I like it and I really really like underwater cities it was on my top 100 so that's definitely my favorite of delicious games in terms of Vladimir suhi it's a little bit more hit

and miss I don't like his older stuff but I like his newer stuff a bit more and underwater cities and Pulsar 2849 from check game editions are on my shelf and in my top 100 so these are games I really enjoy so I was certainly Keen to check in on Woodcraft because the idea of playing wood cutters seems quite appealing so what you were doing in this game is you have a bunch of action tiles on your board which correspond to buying wood selling it getting helpers getting orders Etc and what essentially happens is on your action board you'll take a tile it may give you a bonus depending what quadrant it's in and you'll shift it and you'll move it all the way to the end of the next quadrant as far as it can go this might also have you spinning this saw wheel in the middle which unlocks potential bonuses for tiles that have been left there for a fair while and so what you were doing with these tiles as a result is you're managing your Workshop so with your Workshop you have places to put helper cards you have ways to upgrade your workshop with more saw blades and splicers and things like that gather tools but mainly you are gathering these dice which represent the different type of wood that you need to fulfill orders which are represented by these little cards each card will have you know Dice and bits at the bottom that it requires to fulfill the order like in this case you get to build a little chest of drawers for a four yellow or two green a saw blade and a bit of glue um I'm sure it requires a bit more work to do that and that but fair enough but it'll give you a reward at the side which will typically be hazelnut victory points or blueberries which is the currency to buy stuff but with your

Workshop you're able to do some various dice manipulations so with a dice for example a saw blade can chop dice into different Pips so a six Brown could be chopped into a four and a two or five and a one or with saw blades you could make it like a six could be chopped into six ones if you really want if you the materials but saw blades can cut the dice down glue allows you to glue dice together so I can say well I need a six Brown well I've only got a two and a four well fine I've glued them together and make it into a six and splicers allow you to manipulate the pit values up so with these aspects of your Workshop you're trying to fulfill the orders and of course at the end of the game most victory points of course now one thing to say about Woodcraft from the get-go is that this is um tight and I mean tight I mean I'm asphyxiating myself with my own belt buckle tight you only get 13 actions in this game in a four player game you get 14 and a two or three player solo game that's it that is not a lot of actions and the game box says 80 to 120 Minutes it's quite a bandwidth there but yeah you are that's not too that's not inaccurate actually I mean your first game is going to take you a while so you're probably looking at more two and a half hours with a four player game until you're used to the game and obviously this is not an including the setup and takedown or the teach but yeah once you're comfortable with the game and you don't need to learn the rules I'm confident you could get a four player game done in two hours and solo games can be particularly quick but more on that later so you might think well okay 13 actions for that long

that's not a lot of time per action and no it's not I kind of wish there was more actions but that tightness does mean that you are playing a big efficiency puzzle here you've got to get your engine working it's Gotta Be foolproof otherwise you're just not going to do well on the victory points and the income phases that happen during the game happen every fourth income phase well slightly different in a four player game so you're constantly trying to squeeze everything in in such a short space of time and your first few actions aren't even gonna be that lucrative you know your first few actions might be pretty basic your engine will never really kick off until about halfway through the game at which point it snowballs a little bit that you can do more on your turns but it does take a little while of game to get there you know I want the engine to kind of kick start a little bit sooner uh or not like have the game half over by the time it gets into full motion but yeah you're kind of spending the first few actions just getting little bits together and then later on you're like blimey we've already used up 40 of the game and I've barely done anything what am I supposed to do now it it definitely tight and if that's your type of game you're certainly going to get that feel here for me I don't mind things being tight just not stupidly tight and this one I think's bordering that line of just being a little bit stupidly tight now the rules themselves pretty straightforward actually I was crying impressed overall there are a few edge cases that you are going to need to check the rulebook for and there is a nice restaurant sheet for all the helpers and the various contracts and that so you can easily just pull that to

the side no reference a per player a little Annoying although you do have a basic kind of summary of your turn on the boards that's not too bad but you have to rely on the back of the rule book for the icons and a few rules reminders but the list of rules reminders is so vast that you're not going to be glancing at that on a regular basis it really should have been a bit more condensed but the rules themselves I found to be fairly straightforward there's a lot of pictorial examples particularly how the action wheel works because let's face it you need to understand this like bread and butter before you teach the game otherwise it's going to be fiddly but even that's not particularly complicated I mean you move the tile you move it into the X quadrant go as far as you can spin the wheel if you go past the arrow and if the arrow has to cross a tile you can't do it because it's blocked that's pretty much all you need to know about it really but everything else including the actions and the free actions you get are all explained pretty well although there were a few edge cases where I did have to try and look things up and I couldn't quite find the answer that easily and um yeah there is a major rule that you must not forget which is not explained on like the tile or the reference age when you plant a tree you get a free saw action with that dye you use bear that in mind it is vital to balancing the pots because if you forget that rule the pots are going to be completely a complete waste of time for you and you need to know that rule exists but unfortunately you'll only know it exists because you've read it in the book not because it's printed anywhere else in the game but overall yeah it's not a particularly difficult game to get into I would dare say one of the easier games

to get into then for most of Vladimir suey's designs component quality not too bad I mean the tiles are fine everything's a a decent little card it's tokens for blueberries the dice are the basic d6s you've seen in games of old so it's not nothing particularly Stellar the art works good it certainly fits the setting although are we playing in a weird demonic setting where like puppets are making toys out of their own kind because I don't know about you but the artwork for these characters especially on the helper cards they look like puppets they look like they're made out of wood and so the amount of fun that we had in our games bantering over what kind of demonic Dark Twisted world this is it's pretty impressive and the book doesn't even explain what the setting is it just keeps going on about how great wood crafting is and like you are where woodcrafters isn't wood great doesn't it smell lovely it doesn't mention a thing about the fact that blueberries are currency and this wood is Magic and you can grow wood and the fact that the people look like they're wooden puppets I mean I am literally controlling various demonic possessed forms of Pinocchio that have all just suddenly recently become real boys generally quite easy to understand subject to that plant pot one I mentioned a minute ago but generally you should be able to read most of the iconography in this game and understand what they all do and if you don't the icon list is right there and this list which you'll probably will refer to a couple of times at least during the game does explain every single Helper and contract so you shouldn't end up with

too many cases of confusion hello hello anybody home so a lot rides on this action wheel so is the action wheel good yes thankfully this even though it feels like it was airlifted straight out of progress is the best aspect of the game I enjoy this system seven action tiles fairly easy actions and the idea of manipulating them to go around this board and pick the opportunities for when little bonuses are there I mean it may be great oh yeah I could really do with an order right now but then you look at another Tower and you go oh that hasn't been touched for a while if I do that I get four blue breezes a bonus I get a free die of my choice and a reputation because it's sitting on that spot oh I can't let you have it that's just too many bonuses and so you've got that tight decision of do I go for the one I was intending to go for or do I go for the one that's got all the juicy little bonuses with it that aspect is really cool and definitely my favorite part but here's an aspect I do have problems with and this is something I've discussed with a lot of people including Ross Arnold the designer himself lovely chap but the cards themselves four cards go along the top four on the bottom for the orders and the helpers respectively two cycle every income phase bear in mind that's only going to happen during the game three times another Wise It's a case of when somebody buys something another one will come out now the player scaling is a bit off because if you play only Solo or two players these cards do not cycle at all barely it's like it doesn't cycle anywhere near quick enough so if the cards aren't out that you want you're kind of screwed but then let's

say you play four players okay people are buying those cards more often the problem is that's been bought so often that chances are you'll miss out on the card you want easily enough but it's not so much just that the problem I have is that when you're playing this game there's usually some various routes that you can go down it's like right I'm gonna go heavy on the workshop I'm going to go heavy on the helpers I'm going to go get a bunch of tools which are stupid powerful if you can get a bunch of them out but whichever route you pick you're hoping that you can get the orders and the various things that work with that so let's say I start off early and get a bunch of tools okay great I should probably get a bunch more tools and I'm going to go down that route because there's a public contract for it the problem is a lot of your game is dictated by the order cards that come out these cause a lot of Sweeney moments of like convenient happenstance for various players so I might have a situation where a bunch of orders came out that all had tools as a reward oh fantastic right I'm gonna get started on the tools I've made a nice start fantastic you then get the next four out and none of them have tools oh okay powers do I get tools I can get to that bit on the track and that's it oh all right well I'll give it a bit of time maybe four more will come out okay four more come out and you end up with nothing and even if they do come out of the deck later remember this is a 13 Action game you don't have time to wait for the good stuff to come out you're stuck with what you have which does make this a game that you can't really strategize but the problem is is that for the person who does go down a route

who does get the cards that they need they are going to win the game flat out stat it's just gonna happen and I've had games like that where I've somebody has gone for reputation that's like okay I've started off with a bit of reputation fine and then the reputation dries up and suddenly the fact that they've done a bunch of orders is meaningless because they don't get any points for the reputation bar because they can't get enough of it to level up but then somebody who went for tools suddenly ends up with all the order cards that give tools you know a bunch of other things that will give tools and suddenly it's like oh right I've filled up my entire attic and look at this acceleration I've got and I'm gonna win with 130 odd points you're not even breaking a hundred it causes a lot of those little swings and that is a little Annoying and it does hurt my enjoyment of the game quite a bit because I'm feeling like the game is playing me at that point like I'm not choosing a path to Victory and following that path I'm reacting solely to four cards that come out on the display I feel like you need to double that number particularly in a four player game you need eight cards on view to see what's there so that if somebody is choosing a particular path something should be there that's available to them but four is just very very restrictive so you might argue with okay you've got to make good use of what you have there but again as I said if somebody gets what they need they're gonna do better than somebody else who just picks up something half decent from what's there and I just feel that there just needed to be a little bit more option available now I've not tried a house rule where I double the display like that although might be something I

try in the future but as the way it's designed it's only four cards only four orders only four helpers and you know even the helpers have the same problem you know somebody might just happen to get a help or a pop out out of nowhere that gives them two reputation for buying it oh great so I just went through this entire two turn phase of right I need to sell that die to get this brown six and then I need to upgrade my workshop which then allows me to chop this die to several Browns and because I've got the glue token from there I can put all together on a make this order that gets me to repping a little bit of money ah good that felt good two rounds but I got that order done that's two reputation great somebody then like on another turn a helper comes out of the deck and it gives two reputations Straight Like That on I mean you just got the same award I did for a convenient card popping out of the deck and I had to go through two rounds worth of Hell In order to get to that point it there's a lot of weird cards in here that just seem a little bit too good for their own for their own good but also it's just that you know these these cause some swingy moments and I would just like maybe a little bit more control over that and I reckon maybe extending the display would do that will it cause a little bit of extra analysis paralysis yes and certainly this game does lend itself to a fair bit of analysis paralysis but for me I just need that choice because as much as I enjoy a lot of aspects of this game that part really does great there's not a lot of player interaction either honestly I mean if you're playing some more players or you're really doing it at any time because you don't manipulate anybody else's Workshop all you do is race to a

couple of reputation tiles on this board and you uh grab a order before someone else does that literally it there's you know apart from manipulating his action board again in you could do it with a random card flip and it would have the same aspect as a multiplayer game in fact you can do that because somewhere around here there are Solo cards uh they're in a deck somewhere I don't know but all you basically have is a 10 card deck that flips over a card and you move tiles or gain reputation for a dummy player based on the card it chases down public Tom tracks and it moves tiles around that's literally all the solo mode is which is why I'm not doing a separate video it's beat your own score it's the exact same game with a couple of minor tweaks and honestly I would have originally said oh yeah that's much better because I shaved the time length down to like 60 minutes tops I mean you can get for a solo game of this pretty quickly if you know what you're doing but there's a bigger problem with the solo mode remember the cycling of cards it just doesn't happen enough with less players and in Solo mode in particular it pretty much never happens you know the card deck is skewed with all the different aspects there might be like a couple in there that change order cards and that's it so you go through a 10 card deck by the time you've got through 10 cards you've only got four rounds of the game left so it's only going to rinse repeaters so much so you are stuck with most of the same orders and cards other than the refresh from the level one Dexter level two decks you're stuck with the same stuff for most of the game

is a massive problem with the lumber yard in that respect this part down here where you've got Dyson storage that you can buy the AI player pretty much never buys from there so if you've got a situation like I had last game where I could really do with some good yellows but the only thing there is two ones for the entire game what am I supposed to do right it's really hard for me to get yellows I'm screwed

what am I supposed to do oh you know it's going to take too much effort to get stuff and Gloom together and all that when it would be a lot easier if it just happened to be a six in there that I could grab you know or you know a different number and one and the solo mode is kind of killed in that respect it's quick it's simple and you get to enjoy the puzzle aspect but because you are basically dictated in even more by the cards it ruins the fun but one aspect that I do want to talk about is these public contracts you start off with a couple of hazelnut orders that allow you to get these public contracts and they are pretty much what you think they are you they give you they give you like an objective and your score points based on them several of them will be out during the game and I am telling you right now get both of them you end up with two hazelnut orders and you can get two of these you need to focus on two of these and get them stacked because the points you earn from these are quite sick each one can cap out at somewhere around the 18 point mark other than a couple of lower Point ones that don't require much effort but it's not too difficult to get 18 points in one of them and you should be able to get most of the points in another if you've just gone for that all game and so the points that I have seen people just accelerate like crazy like I've got a bunch of bonuses or game I've done a decent amount of orders I got some rep you know what I feel like I've had a good game and the scores are relatively tight and then because I decided to take one contract not two I took the five blueberry five-point method on the cut on the hazelnut order I lose outright

because somebody else has done two cards I've done one five points pales to 16 18. you need to do two of these but one aspect I really hate with this really really hate is the fact that they are first come first serve this is a game where turn order doesn't matter except that you have to grab these in the same round as someone else otherwise they're gone you don't get them and so somebody who goes last ends up sniping one that you don't realize ice and you've got no way to react to it it's just gone and you're talking 18 points let's say that you both play the hazelnut order at the same time but the other player just happens to be one turn ahead of you and so manages to get their hazelnut order done in advance they Nick the one that needs six helpers you spent most of your game getting five six helpers and you've lost 18 points it cripples you out of the entire game oh yes I hate this in fact to be honest I'm house rolling this from now on I'm householding it you don't take the card it's not gone out of the game simply you do the hazelnut order you get to put your Cube on one of these and you get to claim it so it still forces you to do the order but it doesn't put in this unnecessary punishing aspect where just because you were returned late you lose out on the entire game that two punishing in the game that's already pretty tight and restrictive I'm house ruling that stat so Woodcraft overall is an enjoyable experience I've liked it and there are certain aspects I really like in it I mean the artwork is demonic and creepy

but it's still quite good it's simple to get into for a Vladimir suit he gave it's not too like you know bogged down with rules even though you do have a couple of edge cases that you must bear in mind because they're not on the reference aid but for the most part you should be able to get into this game and after some practice get a four player done in about two and a bit hours with the setup you know two and a half maybe but you could get for a solo game really quick two or three players you could get done in much less it's you know it's a relatively speedy and elegant game for what generally tends to come out of delicious games and the action will love it as well I think the tiles move moving on this and the bonuses and the little opportunities you get is really cool and everybody I've played it with has agreed that this is the best aspect of the game even if it's basically just a clone of progress to put reg neighbors and tweaks but I do have problems with what I've said before I do think that the fact that your game is kind of dictated by the orders that come out is very limiting I don't like the fact that it is only 13 or 14 actions because I just find that too tight you know it's very restrictive you know especially when the first four to seven actions are not gonna get you a tundra in a game it doesn't really kick into high gear until halfway through the game at which point you've then only got about six seven actions to play with you know I would like it to maybe just be more actions or just have the engine kick into gear a little bit quicker but just the idea that oh yeah if I get a bunch of tools I'll do really well if only the cards will come out that gave me some tools you know oh I I've got a bunch of orders

done why do no orders come out that give me a lot of reputation and all right I've got a bunch of dice in my storage here and the next card that comes out is oh it wants all brown well I've got a bunch of green and yellows here there's good stories but nope the one I need just happens to need brown and I just find that really limiting and punishing add in a few little annoyances like the public contracts being first come first served that's stupid stupid but I can household that easily enough you know those things do get in the way and certainly for solo players this isn't really going to be a thing for you because the cars just don't cycle quick enough even though a solo play is going to be really really quick and pretty straightforward so Woodcraft is cool I have to compare it to a few games I've done recently in terms of rating and I was gonna give it only a six but I think it's good enough and there's enough positive elements to it especially compared to some of the other Euro games I played lately I'm going to give it a decent seven out of 10. it's getting a seal of endorsement I've enjoyed my time with it is it going to be a keeper I don't know I'm going to try it with a couple of house rules I'm going to extend that flop display I'm certainly going to house rule this aspect and I'll see how the game plays after that and if that improves the score for me I'll hang on to the game and be really glad of it but if it doesn't then I don't know if it will necessarily be a keeper but I've enjoyed it it's good I can recommend it I think some people are not going to be too bothered by how limiting tight it is that might be the game they're gunning for in which case by all means grab this because you're going to get your exactly what you desire but I would argue that the point about the Flop being very

limiting is still a bit of an issue in this game you know regardless of whether you want it to be super tight or not but I'm gonna say seven out of ten still like it it's good but a few things just cut it down from being a great game which it could easily have been so that's it for me on this episode of the broken meeple I'll see you on the next video I do until next time you can thumb up the video share it on social media or subscribe to the channel or the patreon to help me out with more review copies and trust me Essen was expensive but until next time you can check out more content on the channel including the video review I've done for oh Swan that was a bit of a biggie but also my top 100 has concluded you can check out the final segment of it now so take care and remember as always regardless of what you're doing with demonic crazy Pinocchio puppets it's still only a game bye for now

Progress saved