Bonfire Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm talking about bonfire which at the time of this recording is the latest game by my favorite designer or one of my favorite designers stefan feld the game accommodates one to four players and plays in about 90 minutes the idea of the game is pretty out there it's pretty wacky and wild um i think we're supposed to be these um these gnomes trying to um entice these spirits to come back and like these bonfires i don't know it's pretty out there and it doesn't make much sense but um this is probably one of my most anticipated games of the year because um not only phil being one of my favorite designers um this one is um kind of a step heavier than some of the more recent stuff that phel's been bringing out um you know games like the castles of tuscany um carpe diem et cetera they're kind of on the lighter end of the scale but this one is a bit more of a throwback to some of his earlier titles which are a bit more complex and have a bit more going on um so i'll try and explain how the game plays um and some of the kind of ideas dramatically might not make sense um because the game is pretty choppy um you know a lot of it doesn't doesn't really fit together in a thematic fashion which is probably why the game has this such an out there theme um but basically you are trying to get as many points as you can throughout the game by doing lots of different things such as completing quests and therefore lighting these bonfires you're trying to create paths trying to create portals from those paths into the bonfires um trying to lead spirits back down
these paths um and so on so there's lots of things you can do but um yeah ultimately it's going to be a bit of a point fest a bit of a point salad kind of game there's also some kind of common objectives out there as well which everybody can kind of fight towards um so the there's kind of two kind of sections of the game you've got your own kind of unique player boards uh which are quite interesting there's quite a lot going on in them and it's kind of your user interface on how the game is going to play out and also you've also got the um the main board which all the players are using which has a bunch of islands on them um also has this really cool great bonfire where you can kind of take loads of resources and stuff and it also has this council as well which where you complete your missions you're going to send some of your little gnomes off um to get a little rewards and stuff and it's also going to trigger the end of the game um depending on the player account um basically the more uh you know the more players there are the more missions you're going to need to complete amongst all the players to trigger the end of the game um the main board is also going to hold some of the cards that you can accumulate throughout the game which gives you kind of bonus powers or kind of instant scoring methods as well so uh mechanically the game boils down into three kind of encompassing actions um the main one action is to take one of your fate tiles which are kind of these um kind of three kind of a row of three actions basically and you're going to put them on your play board on this kind of grid and get the corresponding action tokens which you're going to use to take your actions throughout the game this grid is quite an interesting part
of the game because as the game goes on you're going to get more of these fake tokens and as you line up these um actions kind of orthogonally you can get more and more actions um as you go on um so it's got this real kind of puzzling aspect to it when you kind of focus your strategy on a certain thing you can get more of those tokens and you also get rewarded for covering certain um areas on that board or certain squares by getting gold or um or wild action tokens so i mean gold is kind of like a wild resource in the game so you know before you even start you've kind of got this um external puzzle that you need to work out i'm in order to do what you want to do which is always great because um games like trajan bring me that kind of feeling where you know you have to navigate your own user interface before you even get going in the game and that's just that extra layer of complexity really get you know it really um you know intrigues me um the i think it's easy to explain the other simple action which is to basically complete one of your bonfires and when you have a certain mission criteria completed you can flip it over and send one of your one of your gnomes off to the high council which can give you um instant rewards or points and so on um and finally and you've got your kind of main action taking um action where you're going to cash in your different tokens to take the corresponding action and those actions can be either traveling around the map from islands to islands traveling down them the different water paths and you know if you use one axis you can go down one path you use two you can go down two pass and if you use three you can go anywhere and the reason you want to go anywhere or to these different islands is because
that's where you are going to pick up your new missions which are going to basically give you at the bulk of your points at the end of the game the missions come in three different kind of difficulties you've got your basic blue ones you've got the kind of you know mediocre red ones and you've got the um more complex or more difficult to achieve yellow ones and obviously the points are going to correspond to that as well so you know the yellow missions are going to give you more points than the blue ones but obviously going to be more difficult to actually um to to complete and those missions could be things such as having a certain type of spirit on your board or having a certain amount of cards or a certain amount of um type of missions um also maybe having um taking some actions from the same islands and stuff so you've got all those different criteria you've got to try and um complete to get these missions done additionally when you sail you can kind of piggyback off the action to take one of the other actions which is picking up these spirits and putting them on your board and that's kind of another ties into another action you can take also taking the missions as well because when you take a mission you need to actually cash in a token um and if you have already taken a mission from that island you have to cash in more tokens so um you know just focusing on one area is going to be um you know it might be quite a bit more expensive um in terms of taking your action tokens up um additionally from taking these are cashing in those action tokens you also have to cash in resources um and those resources i think
i think there's six different kinds one of those being wild whenever you take a mission need to cash in a certain type of resource corresponding to the island and also one corresponding to your player board which kind of rotates as the game goes on so as you can tell there's a lot of interlocking systems here all of which need to be weighed up um some of the actions are a bit more simple such as taking a path tile when you take these path tiles you just add them onto your player board which creates a path where the spirits can walk down and can kind of give you more points if um you know if you focus on doing so um you can also focus on taking these portals as well um these portals give you i think they give you two points each at the end of the game but they also give you um the ability to move your spirits through the path into where the bonfires are and to get you more end game points um which can be quite a significant way of getting points but it's quite difficult to achieve because moving the spirits down the paths cost quite a few actions especially if you want to get right to the end and additionally they can't kind of share paths so you have to kind of move one at a time um and so on so there is a bit to weigh up there as well additionally some of the portals have only fit certain spots on your player board so having a particular type of portal is important and that relates to the another action you can take which is the bonfire action or the great bonfire action where you've got this kind of a wheel of resources and you are moving around trying to you can pick up different resources you can pick up different um are these
uh portals and you can also pick up um i think little bonuses such as um action tokens for example um so yeah there's a lot going on um you know the the mitigation is quite good because normally with a bonfire you can if you take cash in one token you can move one space if you're cashing two tokens you can move up to two spaces in a clockwise fashion and but if you cash in three tokens you can move it anywhere and the same goes for the boat and stuff so you've got a bit of flexibility there and i think the final action you can take is to take um to take these gnome cards and you've got basically you've got um i think it's like expert cards and you've got elder cards as well and the elder cards are quite simple they're going to be the same every game and they are going to give you points based on certain criteria you have so you might say take a point for every path path tile you have or take a point for every token you have um and the thing about this is you know it might seem pretty basic but because there's only one available of each type it's kind of a pushy like chicken kind of mechanism because you you know if someone takes that tile you you completely can't take it all that card you can't take it anymore so you need to make sure that you're doing it before everybody else does um but you don't want to push it too far to get you know to get loads of points because someone will snatch it before you so kind of running away with a certain type of strategy is a good way to get the most out of these um out of these elder cards and by catching your opponent off guard um the the expertise cards are a bit more interesting because they give you loads of really cool powers you can do
which kind of you know trump a lot of the base game rules such as um you know when you travel you can travel one faster or you can move the bonfire and additional space um you know you could you don't have to move one of your um one of your spirits at a time you know they can share paths for example so there's loads of kind of game breaking powers which are quite interesting to be fair and um you know if you especially if you get them early in the game you can kind of tailor your um your strategy to piggyback off the expertise cards you've picked up to take one of those cards not only do you have to cash in the the card tokens but you also have to cash in a number of resources um corresponding to that card as well so resources are a bit of a you know a bit of a thing to worry about in terms of getting the um not only getting the missions you want but also getting the cards you want as well and that pretty much determines the the main actions you're going to take and um and so on and as i said once you've got a certain amount of missions completed you are going to trigger the end of the game which just kind of a five round countdown um and at any point in one of those rounds you can kind of forfeit the rest of your goals and take that many points equal to the amount of rounds left you have um also at the end of the game you get points corresponding to um the the type of bonfire you've lit you know depending on how easy it is you know that red blue or yellow mission if that corresponds to the type of path you've laid then you are going to get an additional two points i believe um so yeah there's a lot of things to weigh up a lot of things to think about
um having that flow of resources the flow of missions or the absolute action tiles you need to take um you're somewhat limited to the um to the actions you could take because of the puzzle um and you know anytime you can get rid of action tiles in order to take a new fake tile and because you can only ever place a new fake towel when you've got one um one action left and that can kind of give you a whole new you know injection of actions to take um so yeah as you can probably tell it's a game you kind of have to play for yourself to experience but it is meaty it has that proper feld feel to it i mean the interlocking systems and um you know a wide array of strategies to go down so yeah in terms of meaningful decisions there is a boatload in this one while still not being overly paralyzed because you are limited to the tokens you have at any time um and if you want to kind of you know be a bit more free with that you're going to basically throw away a whole a lot of your tokens and um you know keep putting new fake tiles down which isn't going to be very efficient to be honest so yeah meaningful decision-wise this game is a feast for the census loads to do loads to explore and everything matters which is great um the balance of the game as well seems really good i mean mostly you're going to get a lot of your points from the from the bonfires you're lighting by completing those missions however you know it's not uh an insignificant amount to focus on getting those um you know getting those portals down getting the spirits onto those um onto those bonfires which is which is quite a good amount of points to be had
and so on so there is a lot of different things you can focus on but mainly bearing in mind getting those missions done um so i do really like that mechanically i think once you've got your head around the kind of three encompassing actions it's pretty simple all the actions themselves are pretty intuitive and also they're pretty snappy as well i mean there's no really long laborious actions to take they're all pretty snappy and there's not kind of a lot of waiting for your opponent or your opponent's waiting for you to do all the housekeeping and stuff in order to complete your actions so while there's still loads going on i think it's still pretty um you know it takes along quickly and the ap in the game isn't actually too bad i'm considering um time investment i think the game um is just about right i mean the turns do whip by quite quickly um and obviously because the endgame criteria is triggered by how many people have been sent to the um to the high council then some games could be longer than others because if one game everybody's focused on those more difficult yellow missions then it's going to be a bit longer but if someone's kind of blitzing through those um through those cheaper blue missions then it's going to be a bit quicker replayability is is really good because there is a ton of these mission tiles that go in with this game um all those different complexities so yeah every game is going to be quite different in that respect um additionally um all the different action cards
there you know there's a lot to explore and a lot of different things to um to try out um interaction-wise i think is actually pretty good for you for a euro um there is some quite good interaction not only because everybody's kind of sailing around trying to get the uh the missions they want and you know there's only a limited amount of them um and you want to be the bit there to get the ones first um but also there's competition over getting the cards that you want you know the elder cards and the expertise cards but also there is um there's some common objectives on the board as well and those common objectives are things you're kind of naturally going to complete as the game goes on you know such as having all your spirits on your board having you know all six um action cards down or or cards down and basically the first person to trigger one of those or to complete one of those is going to have a neutral gnome that they can put onto the high council and that's really important because normally you can only have one of certain type of color on each of those kind of council seats um to get a certain benefit but if you get the neutral ones you can take that benefit again which can be very powerful such as you know moving your spirit all the way along the path to the end which would normally be quite a quite a burden to do so or sailing anywhere on the map or taking gold which is your wild resources and stuff so yeah it's very important to um to focus on those neutral objectives as well as your own ones so yeah interaction wise very good um aesthetically as well i think um i i actually really like the way the game looks it's as i said the theme is way out there it doesn't make much sense it's very
you know it it's just to fit the kind of the square peg in a square hole really um but the the theme works the way the game looks works well i really do like it has a really cool color palette really kind of interesting to be honest it looks different it looks um you know like it's fantasy but it's a different kind of like fairy tale style fantasy and the gnomes and stuff are weird the artwork's good i mean i do really really like this some artist actually i think is it lauhausen i forget his name but i think he did the um artwork for oracle adelphi as well and which i really like it's got a kind of uh a cool euro style feel to it but still being attractive um and classy as well so i really do like the way the game looks um and i just like the general feel of it and i said despite the wild theme it actually works quite well um if you know if you if you get your head around it um and set up and head down time as well there's a bit of fiddliness to the setup you know picking all the portals out putting all the missions out and stuff um and also setting up your playboard as well but not too bad i mean the game more than compensates for the setup um progression-wise as well i really do like the way the game ramps up because they're not only do the missions get tighter and tighter the um you know you're you're trying to line up a lot of things on your player board you know with the not in the bonfires you're lighting but with the path as well you're trying to get all the portals in you're trying to move up your um your spirits and all these things are you can't you know you can't do them all having everything done is quite um
unachievable in this game and and you need that tension to be a really good euro for my in my opinion and this game does that well and dig it wrong you can get a lot done in this game but you need to play well to do so um and also rely on other people playing at the same pace as you because um the the end game criteria is is quite different and um you know it throws a bit of a you know a bit of a spanner in the works in terms of the pacing of the game scalability as well really good i mean the fewer the players the fewer the missions go on the board so you know there's still going to be that tension there and also i said the the endgame trigger is is based on fewer names being sent to the council um so you know it's very proportionate depending on the player count um and comparison-wise i mean while this game does feel like a classic felden game it still feels extremely fresh um extremely new and interesting um but it still has those fell tropes you know as i said the the feld the trajan like um you know player board you know instead of using mancala you've got this kind of really interesting like almost like a uh you know a tile placement kind of game you've got the all the different things you've got to think about you know there's it feels very held in but it feels like a a new interesting failure that isn't retiring or regurgitating old ideas but it still has that failed feel so i really do like that but yeah as you can tell um overall i really really love this game i think it is fantastic it is more than lived up to my hype of the game you know i was excited for it because you know i want those heavier failed
games and not the kind of entry level ones and this one is right up there with the best of them for me um i love everything about it i think it is just great and i'm happy to play this again and again and again and again and it is more than definitely going in my collection for the long haul two months i think this is probably the best felled game i've played since um the oracle of delphi which is um you know quite a few years old now so um yeah the best fell released since then i have and that's i think that's high praise because i like all failed games but i happen to like more some more than others and this one is right up there for me so yeah really happy that he's still bringing out fantastic games and it's got me excited for for more ideas he's got because the man is a genius he makes great games that are just perfect for me um yeah this is a great one if you like all those classic failed games you know you like your um you know your trajans and your burgundy's and your delphi's and stuff like that you're gonna like this one is fantastic um give it a go um i think as a game you probably have to pay for yourself to um to understand quite how it all fits together because i said it is quite um quite an obtuse game um it's quite nebulous in terms of how how it you know how it works but it works very well and it is a lot of fun interesting and just just great so uh that concludes my review of bonfire um this gets my elite shield so this is the top
or the highest and you know a claim i can give to the game and um more than well deserved because i love it so um and i'd also be very surprised if this game doesn't end up in my top three of the year um in terms of 2020 releases um you know maybe even a number one i don't know i'd have to think about that and also also there's still some quite good games to come out or big anticipated releases to come out but yeah that concludes my review of bonfire um if you have enjoyed it please hit like and subscribe to my channel check out my other videos too you can also follow me on instagram and back me on patreon um i'll leave the links below for those uh for everyone else i'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye