Skip to main content
Loading video...

Cascadia Review | The Beauty of Randomness

Transcript 18:57

hello and welcome back to all you can board my name is carlo and today i'm going to be reviewing cascadia so this is a first time design by randy flynn with illustrations by beth sobel and this is co-published by flat out games and aeg so this is an excellent game that just got released last year 2021 and it's kind of a tough game for me to review because the first few times i played it i really enjoyed it but i couldn't really put my finger on why i mean you know it has some very simple rules and i knew right away was a game i was going to like but there was something about it that just felt near perfect and i struggled for a while to pinpoint what it was until recently after a few more plays and i realized it's because the level of randomness in this game is so well executed and i think that's truly the standout aspect of it that kind of flew under the radar for me a little bit at first i'm going to talk about a few other things during the review but i'm going to be focusing mostly on the aspect of randomness and how that makes this game so good because it makes every turn every choice that you make difficult and it truly does matter so before we get into that though i'm going to tell you kind of a basic overview of how the game plays in case you're not too familiar with cascadia so in this game each player starts with one of these three-sided hexagonal tiles they're called a starting habitat tiles basically and on your turn you basically have four options on the main board there's going to be four more of these habitat tiles that are just single ones some of them have you know one type of land others might have two or three different types of land on them uh and then you have these habitat or these uh wildlife tokens on your turn you're

basically picking a set or a pair so either this tile and token this thailand token etc you're taking them adding the tile to your little personal terrain area and then placing the wildlife token on one of the hexes that has that animal showing so as well as the land types some of these will have one two or three different types of animals there's five different ones in the game so let's say i take this tile and this token you add the tile somewhere doesn't matter there's no placement restrictions unlike in other tiling games like carcassonne where all the sides have to line up you can put this wherever you want as long as it's adjacent to a previous tile of yours and then you're going to add the wildlife token to one of the habitats spots that can basically hold that animal then you're going to take a new tile and token from the bag and add them to the display and then the next person's going to go you're just going to go around the table doing that every player is going to get 20 turns and then at the end of the game you're going to count points and see who wins so the points are scored mostly from these wildlife scoring cards there's one for each type of animal and in the box there's i think four different ones for each animal type so every time you play you can mix and match with different ones um each animal usually has some type of theme or type of kind of way that you're generally trying to score but each card kind of gives you some different ways uh for example you know this elk card says scores per straight line of elk so if you have you know one elk or two or three or four depending if it's in a straight line you get this number of points you know red tailed hawks uh need to be not next to any other hawk so you just want to have them spaced out and you can see you can

get a maximum of 26 points if you have eight or more so they all have these different kind of scoring conditions they're going to point you in different directions so that's where the majority of your points are going to come from you're also going to get one point for every nature token you have left at the end of the game you gain those by placing um an animal token or wildlife token on what's called a keystone tile so a keystone tile is something like this where it just has the single land type and single animal and if you place that animal on it you'll see it has that little leaf symbol on there and that means you take a nature token which you can use later to kind of uh play around with your options a little bit which i'll get back to in a bit uh and then the final thing is like i said even though you don't have the restrictions of where you place your tiles you do want to be lining up your habitats as much as possible because at the end of the game for each of the five habitat types you're gonna score points uh one point per tile for your largest grouping of adjacent tiles so let's say i had six tiles that made up this forest that would be six points so do that for each category and then you're also going to compare with the other players to see who has the largest size um habitat type of each of the types and each player is going to who has that majority is going to score a number of points based on player count so that's that's pretty much all the rules right there a couple other subtle things like what you use your nature tokens for so on your turn uh you can trade in a nature token to basically take any combination of a wildlife or a habitat tile and wildlife tokens you can take something you know from here and one that doesn't match up with it and then you just replace them from the bag you can also spend a nature token to wipe any number of these tiles from the

board and replace them with one new ones from the bag so they basically give you some options to kind of help you know play around with that randomness a little bit and give you some new options on your turn i will mention quickly that there is a solo mode for this game as well and if you're playing solo uh you basically just you there isn't an ai player or anything like that it's just after you take tiles the tiles will shift down you'll remove certain ones from the board and then you'll add more so you kind of have a little more control over what's going on and it's sort of just automated so it's just a 20 turn game um where you're just cycling tiles and tokens out of the market a bit quicker at the end of your turn okay so now let's talk about all the aspects of randomness that come into play and i might even overlook sun here because there's a lot of different ways it comes into play that aren't maybe necessarily obvious right off the bat so the first one is your starting uh habitat tile so there's only five of them in the game but you know so there's a bit of variety there's not too much but right off the bat you're going to get a random tile so you don't have any choice over what you start with then there's going to be the random distribution of the habitat tiles and wildlife tokens so not only are you usually going to see different ones but they'll be in different combinations as well so you can't just say from the start without even looking at those oh this game i'm going to do this you got to wait to see what actually comes out on the board then there's the randomness of which cards are using and again these are ones where you can just you know the the rule book has some suggestions as to you know play with this combination or play with this combination so it's not always going to be random but i find that over time if you're going to be more experienced with the game you're probably just going to shuffle them up and pick one out of each category and randomly complete those so right off the bat just in terms of the starting setup of the game what your your starting tile

is random the choices that you have in the middle of a random and what your main scoring conditions are going to get you points for a lot of the time are going to be random as well the other thing i'll mention is if you're playing with uh four players you use all the tiles but anything less than four players and you randomly remove a certain number of the tiles and leave them back in the box so that you can't you know if somehow you were you know had memorized all the tiles you had some idea of which tiles had come out and what types of land you know were more or less common throughout the game um you know in a four-player game sure they're all going to come out by the end uh but if you're playing with two or three players or even the solo mode you're going to be removing a chunk of the tiles so again that adds a bit of that randomness to not knowing what's been removed and what's still left and the other thing is as you go throughout the game you're never going to get through this whole bag of wildlife tokens so some games you might get a lot of one type or might not see much of another type so there's a lot of these unknowns that you're kind of juggling on every turn and there's all kinds of new information that's going to be you know especially with the higher player count as it comes back around you know the game statement what's available to you will change quite a bit from turn to turn the other thing i want to mention is because you know at the start of the game that you have 20 turns um there's going to be a point near the end where you know let's say you're 14 15 16 turns in and you might have completed some of these scoring objectives and by that i mean you know some of these ones that have like a maximum like again for the hawks you know you have eight of them for a max of 26 points so you might have a few turns left and you might think okay well now i don't really want to get any more hawks but there are there's other categories where you can start a new sort of set so let's say you got

your elks let's say you already scored four elks for 13 points for that straight line somewhere well you know if you have four or five turns left are you going to start another straight line of elk so you know if there's one elk tile out there and you can place it on your board if you end up with just the one elk that's only going to get you two points so you have to sort of hedge your bets on okay what new you know i've already maxed out on my hawks i've completed this thing of elks i've you know maxed out on my salmon where am i going to try and get points and again you're playing with that randomness of how many turns do i have left what's on the board and you're trying to come up with a plan as to okay based on the likelihood of what's still out there how likely am i to accomplish something if i start a new goal should i be trying to just grab points elsewhere should i be trying to you know focus more on my my wild or my habitat types to maximize and get the majorities for those so there's a lot of this unknown still left near the end and i really like the game arc that that creates by not only the combination of scoring conditions but just the randomness of the tiles and everything in the order that that all uh comes up in and another thing i want to focus on here real quick is the nature tokens so i like it when games uh kind of hide the scoring so to speak um games where everything is you can just calculate and say well if i go here it's this many points if i go here it's this many points then it's just sort of a matter of time eventually you're going to figure out what gets you the most points and you're probably going to go with that option and one of the things i love about this is these nature tokens at first this seemed like such a subtle inconsequential thing to me the first time i played the game i didn't think much of them and other games that you know flat out are associated with whether whether it's the the main flat out crew of molly

johnson sean stanwich and robert melvin whether they're designing the games or they're working on the development side of things they often have these types of ways to mitigate the randomness from the kind of draw options in the middle and what i like about the way these nature tokens are implemented is because it's worth a point at the end of the game let's say there was a way that you know you just had a a stack of spare tiles you could pick from to just say oh if i'm trading in the nature token i'm just going to place this thing that i want to place if you had more control over it the nature tokens wouldn't be as interesting and the choices wouldn't be as difficult because you know that by sacrificing it to use it you're losing a point but if you could just right away say oh well i'll use this nature token and i can get four points if i do this with it or i can get this many points if i do this with it or i can get this many points then it would just be okay if i'm gonna get three points but lose one the net gain is two and it would just be kind of a no-brainer but because the options with the nature token i mean one of the ways you can use them is to take a combination of a tile and a token but even then that might you know you don't know how many points that's going to end up giving you at the end of the game unless it's maybe your final turn and you already know that the game's going to end right away but otherwise again it's this kind of hedging your bets like yes it might get me two points now but also if i were to save this nature token for a future turn could i get more points for it later and the other thing is because you can use it to which actually happens fairly commonly is to just wipe a certain number of tokens from the board you're trading in the token for an opportunity or almost for an opportunity to have more opportunity there's no guarantees this could end up backfiring on you so

it's always an interesting choice on first of all whether to use the nature token because you don't know what it's going to do for you short term as well as long term but also how to use it so i really like the way these are implemented because the rules of how to use them are so simple but again throughout the game as you have these nature tokens in your supply it's this very limited resource because again you only get them from going placing a wildlife token on one of these keystone habitat tiles so even if you have you know three or four throughout the game i don't think i've ever seen anyone holding more than four or five at a time you know you might be having this limited supply and you're trying to think okay i have seven turns left and i've got two nature tokens is this the right time to use it is there gonna be a more you know is my back gonna be up against the wall more later where i have a better opportunity to use it and kind of mitigate that randomness and get rid of that in a way that you know gives me better options so now let's talk about how player count affects randomness and just player count in the game in general so i mentioned you before when you're playing this game that every player is going to get 20 turns so if you're playing solo the entire game is 20 turns because you're just cycling out extra tiles and stuff from the market but you're still just playing your 20 turns you're not handling an ai player if you play with two players of course each player getting 20 turns so 40. upwards of if you play a four player game and there's a total of 80 turns you're only getting 20 of those so you're you know a quarter of the time you're playing and the other three chords of the time or other players turns so from turn to turn as you go and then three other players go what's available to you in the market is gonna change a lot more you can't on your turn say well if i take this then maybe on my next turn i'll take this pair or i'll take that you can't really

plan ahead on anything so with more players there's definitely more randomness and you have less control over what's going on on the board whereas on the you know let's say two player side of things if you take something you have a good idea of what's still going to be out there on your turn you might have you know might be able to kind of guess as to what your opponent's going to take but you have more control over that in a two-player game the other thing is you know with three or four players competing with multiple players over different land types for majorities and depending which tiles come up and all that kind of stuff there's just going to be a lot less out of your control so for those who have maybe mentioned that the game was either you know too much randomness they felt like they were frustrated by the luck of the draw kind of thing maybe you were playing with three or four players and maybe you'll enjoy the game most if you play it solo or with two on the other side of the spectrum if you felt like you were you know getting too good at the game or you felt too easy or you wanted more you wanted it to feel more tactical where every turn felt a little bit tougher to make those choices then you might want to play more on the higher end with three or four players just keep in mind that that will lead to a little more downtime and i will say similar as i mentioned when i reviewed calico which is also a collaboration between aeg and flat out games uh is that i think the game probably works best at two players maybe with three as well the solo mode is also really good that solo to 3 is all very very close and how how well the game plays i would say adding a fourth player just you know again it slows it down without adding a whole lot more uh intrigue or excitement to the game i think adding a you know playing with two or three instead of solo definitely has a lot of positives adding a fourth player so the game still works well because it's a fairly quick playing game even with four you can teach and play this in under an hour uh so no

matter what the player count is i think it's great but i think it's probably best at two or three and i just find it interesting how the difference of randomness applies depending on the player count that you're playing at now normally at this point of review even when i'm reviewing games that i really like i try to be as critical as possible i try and point out you know yeah this could be better this could be better kind of thing cascadia is a really really tough game to criticize i mean my biggest complaint is probably what i mentioned is just that i have very little incentive to want to play the game at four players just because it adds that amount of down time so i mean maybe i wish the game could scale slightly better with four players but really i'm kind of just kind of just reaching for anything to criticize here because the game is so well polished and this is kind of one of the hallmarks of anything that you see this flat out games uh logo on is their games always feel like they're very well developed all the kind of you know any potential fluff any fiddliness in the rules any anything extra that doesn't belong feels like it's been kind of ruthlessly cut out of the game to make it the most simplified kind of clean smooth playing most polished experience possible and it's something i really appreciate that i think flat out uh really nails on all of their games whether it's you know point salad calico cascadia whatever the case may be and i think that's a big reason why it is where it is on the board game geek rankings again this game just came out last year as of now it is currently number 123 on the all-time boring geek rankings with an average rating of 8.1 and that's after only 6 000 ratings so for those who don't check if you go ahead and look at all the games that are ahead of cascadia or go look through a

bunch of them you'll see that most of those games have a lower average than 8.1 and usually have a lot more ratings than just 6 000 and the way the bgg rankings work it often at you know if a game needs a certain number of rankings the more ratings it has the higher it's going to move up on the list so it's only a matter of time before this game cracks the top 100 could crack the top 50 could even go higher like i really do think this is sort of a modern day classic this is a game that i think will still be played and talked about among the better tiling games at least a decade from now probably more um it's one of the rare games where you see a game that has a weight rating on bgg below a 2.0 crack the top 100. you know the top 100 tends to gravitate towards those heavier games the kind of classic argument is that uh you know people who have been in the hobby the longest and are the head you know playing the heaviest games are more likely to be on board game geek reviewing games and ranking games compared to you know maybe a more casual game who tends to enjoy lighter games kind of things so this is why you see so many games like you know glue maven terraforming mars spirit island brass birmingham you know all these kinds of games war of the ring near the top of the list very heavy games there's only a few games like azul and that kind of thing that actually cracked the top 100 with simple rules and typically those tend to be games that are very approachable for you know newer or more experienced gamers or people who prefer like gamers but still have enough kind of meat on the bones enough satisfaction for people who are used to playing heavy strategy games longer games and anywhere you look you know people who tend to gravitate towards those heavier

games who are trying cascadia tend to really enjoy it and i think it's one of those true like truly unique games that has that kind of perfect crossover between the appeal to kind of the lightest of gamers and the heaviest of gamers um that they can play with their own groups and they can also kind of cross paths and play this game together and still enjoy it um it's yeah it's ranked already as the number one abstract game on board game ahead of azul it's the number 12 ranked family game there's a reason why this game is just shooting up the list all over the place um and i think it's got that addictive kind of one more try kind of feel the same way that when you play a role and write game and at the end you always feel like i could have done better you know like the gunshot clever games or whatever those kind of games where you every time you finish you think i could have been more efficient i could have done better i want to play again to do that and the reason why that happens in cascadia is because of the randomness because if you just had a stack of tiles in your own possession and you could choose when to put them out there at the beginning you would just make a plan based on the scoring cards and you'd have a lot of control over what you're doing and if you got an awesome score because you saw your plan to fruition then what's the point of coming back to the game right the randomness is what gives you that little bit of frustration and keeps everything just outside of your grasp and makes you want to keep coming back to see if you can find the best ways to mitigate that randomness find the best timing to you know veer off the course a little bit or when to use that nature token or in which way and which scoring conditions to go for when you know based on what has or hasn't come out on the board there's just a lot to consider on every single turn and the game always surprises me with that every time i play it i think okay this time the decisions

are going to be easier i'm kind of a cascadia veteran now and i sit there looking over my moves my options and it always feels like the decisions are tough everyone i've shown this game to has loved it i highly recommend cascadia absolutely one of the best releases of 2021 one of the best highland games out there and it's all thanks to the absolutely basically perfectly executed aspect of randomness in this game so that's all i've got to say about cascadia i hope you enjoyed this review if you liked it please consider liking the video subscribe to the channel if you haven't yet um pop on over to our discord channel we've got a bursting community there over 200 people already just chatting about games all the time but otherwise thank you so much for watching and i'll see you next time

Progress saved