Goa Review - Chairman of the Board
Transcript
hey everybody today i'm taking a look at goa which is a board game designed by rudiger dawn back in 2004. this one accommodates two to four players and takes around 90 minutes to play so goa has really been a grail game for me i've been after this one for a long long time because it is long out of print unfortunately i'm a big fan of really good dorm games and i'm a big fan of games of this era so this is one of those traditional euros um with an auction element to it you've got a bit of engine building and you've even got a dash of push your luck but before i get into go up i just want to give a shout out to kianda dot co uk who sponsored the show so if you live in the uk and you regularly buy board games be sure to check them out okay so a game of go is going to look somewhat like this where you have this main board here we've got the money down the side in different denominations you've got these colony tiles at the top here this is four different colonies and if you manage to colonize all of them you're going to get a lot more points and if you only colonize a few and you've got your colonists here you've got these bonus action cards you've got these ship titles um ship cards sorry and you've also got these extra cards here um which are quite powerful and you can claim throughout the game and we'll go into those in a little bit later and the main feature on the board here is this big grid of these tiles and these are all variable and they're going to get mixed up from game to game so each time you're going to get a very different experience and these are going to be what you're going to acquire throughout the game to give you benefits bonuses plantations etc to get your little economy going so each player is going to have their individual setup as well where you've got these two
different sheets the first of which is going to be your kind of action board here where the more you invest in these things you're going to get more powerful actions so you've kind of got six basic actions you've got five on the board here but one of those actions is to upgrade um and we'll talk about how that works mechanically shortly and of course the objective of this game is to get as many victory points as you can and you're gonna do that by um upgrading these um different features these different segments of your board as much as you can because as you as you can see here from this numbers down the side the more you do that you can potentially get 10 points for each one that you do um additionally you've got this little board here as well which which maps your um the colonies that you've actually managed to claim and also the plantations that you can get throughout the game you can only have four active at any time each player is also going to have a number of markers here equal to the number of people in the game plus one additionally there are some kind of communal supplies here so you've got um all the different spices and stuff that you can play with and i've just set up these here just because i'm only using one player's piece but i'll be using those for example shortly but let's get into how the game actually plays okay so each game of go is going to be divided into two halves so you've got the a half and the b half the b half the uh the new slightly stronger tiles come into play and into this house is going to be divided into four rounds and each of those rounds is going to be divided into three phases so ultimately you've got eight rounds um but each of those rounds is going to consist of three different things you need to do so the first thing you're going to do is the
first player is going to choose where to put this first player token and that's going to show where the track is going to start in terms of which tiles are going to be auctioned for so let's just say the yellow player is the first player and they choose to put the first player marker here and then they'll put their number one token on top of it to show this is gonna be the first token that's gonna be auction four and because that is always going to be the case the first player market is always gonna go on the edge of the board or in future rounds in any empty spot and that means whoever wins it next turn is gonna be the first player in the following turn but also going to take a bonus action card which can be very strong to have and then it's going to go to the next player so let's just say the blue players next they are going to choose any adjacent tile to it either orthogonal or diagonal um to show which tower is going to be auctioned next so let's just say the blue player goes here because he thinks that's going to be a good tile to have and then the next player let's say goes here so the green play wants this nutmeg plantation and then the red player will place their 4 token and they can they can go here or here because they can't share a spot with anybody else so they've got the settlement tile all this extra action style so let's just say they want this one here because those actions are really worth having and then the yellow player because they've been first they also get to place an additional token so they'll place their number five here for example now of course if there are fewer players in the game there'll be less of these tokens out there so in a four player game there'll be five tokens three player game there'll be four tokens and a two play again there'll be three tokens of course because the first player gets to place two so once all the initial tokens are
placed onto the board you're gonna go into the auction phase where you're gonna start with number one here so then it's gonna you know kind of a once-off auction in a round-robin fashion so starting with the players token here the player to the left of them is going to start with an opening bid and or they could choose to pass of course so let's just say the uh the blue player chose to bid two and then the the green player bids three the replay might pass um and then it's going to go back to the yellow player so that's going to be everybody's bids in so we've got a big bid a final bid of three and that means that the yellow player can either accept that three bid and basically forfeit the first player marker to the person who bit the most um or they can choose to play pay one less money than the highest bid so you're always in a bit of a power position when you are the player who's got that particular tile under control so again this yellow player can either accept the three bid from the red player or they can play one fewer as in paying two money to the bank in order to keep hold of this first player marker and get a bonus action card so let's just say um the yellow player wants to keep hold of this first player marker therefore they could play two money to the bank like so discarding it and they'll keep hold of that one and take a bonus action card for their supply which again can become in very strong use um a bit later and then you're going to go on to the next towel here so you've got the blue two here again it's going to start off in a once-off round-robin fashion um and whoever wins the bid is going to either pay the player who's got the token on it
or of course if the person who's actually controlling that tile wants to wants to clean that tile for themselves they can play one money less than the highest bid so it's a really strange auction where you have to be very careful up where you want to tinker your auction or your bid to um because you're always going to bear in mind that you're all the person controlling the entire can always play one less and which can be quite significant so once all those tiles have been claimed of course the board is going to get emptier and emptier but we'll talk about the significance of all the tiles in a little bit because it's not going to make much sense without knowing the next part of the game which is where you go into your personal actions and use things on your action board here so in each turn or after you've done the orchestra face you're going to have the opportunity in a round robin fashion to take three separate actions or potentially more by discarding these action cards and you're gonna have six different options on what you can do so the first of which is to take a boat card and that's gonna you're gonna take a number of card equal to the spot here so if i had upgraded to this spot here i could take three boat cards with a single action but at the moment i'm only taking one so that's a very simple action and that applies to these three here actually they're all very simple this one here lets you take one of the spices or potentially more spices depending on your number there but you need to have plantations in order to accommodate them and the next one is to take one of these action cards and you can draw this many and you can keep this many in your hand so the further you upgrade
the more you can draw and the more you can keep in your hand and again we'll go through those later because these are quite strong and definitely a big part of the game and the other action here is to colonize one of these different colonies here on the board so you've got killon cochin madras and calicut and they all have different values on them so you can see here on your separate player board you've got kilon which is the easiest one to colonize because it only takes six corners to do so but calicut is quite difficult because it costs 12. and that's where this part of the game is going to come in and this is going to be basically a permanent number of colonists that you have available at any time so you don't actually spend these or gain these when you take this action there's just a passive ability that you have and when you take that colonized action that you have to claim which one you want to um coordinates first let's just say i wanted to um colonize keilon i could first off as a base value i'd start with any of these let's just say i started with a base value of two um i i would have a starting value too then i'll flip over two of these cards uh because these are kind of multi-used cards here and add this value here so other than we're up to four and then we are up to five so it's not going to be quite enough to colonize because if you remember we needed six to colonize it but that is where these cards come into play where you can boost that value to hopefully get you past that threshold and claim that colony and when you do that you can pick up one of these tiles add it to your little colony board here like so and take any resources on them so that either takes one of these um one of these resources or one of these
resources put it on that one spot and as i said earlier the more of these you get at the end of the game works on a sliding scale bonus so if you get all of them i think you get 10 points if you only get one you get one point and so on so you really want to be making sure that you get as many of those colonies done as possible and the final action you can take is to actually upgrade the different elements here in the first place so as you can see here i might need one of these resources in order to slide this one to this spot here and therefore it makes me more efficient in future rounds and as you can see here once you get everything on a certain row then you can get these bonus action cards which comes into play because normally as i said you only get three actions per per phase but you can actually end up taking more of them um depending on if you have these bonus action cards which again can be very useful but you can only ever store one back from round to round so you need to make sure you use them or potentially lose them and of course if you get to the highest areas here then you can actually get these bonus action cards as well which can come into big use and the more you upgrade things the more expensive it's going to be but of course that's going to be the big part of your end game scoring now once everybody's taken their actions from the previous round you're going to start again with the player who won the first player marker in the last round and they're going to start from a new spot so other than an empty space or on one of these border spaces and you're going to go again and repeat that process so let's talk about what some of the tiles actually do and what you're actually trying to bid for so you've got towels like this where you can take a whole bunch of resources instantly like
these ships here and something i should have said is when you upgrade your playboard not only do you have to spend the resources you have to spend a ship for each resources you spend as well so ships are very useful to have and you've got the plantations which of course are good for storing those resources so you don't have to waste them you've got these ones here like you get a colonists each round so these really do build up if you acquire that tile early in more colonies here you've got this kind of a wild plantation here which are really useful uh you've got this one's here we can either take ships or colonists this one here makes all your level one plantations like this one here worth three points at the end of the game rather than just the usual one now you've got a whole bunch of colonists there you've got this one here where you can discard six of any goods to get five victory points at the end you've got these expedition cards here uh you've got the ones that we claimed earlier like again more colonists some more boats more plantations double actions which are great one of each so you've got like a boat an action and a colonists and so on so the first round is pretty simple but we'll talk about what the second round does uh right now so i've set up some phase b tiles here just to show you how the game escalates so you've got these tiles that come into play which gives you straight up victory points which are not insignificant because every point you get in this game is massive it's not a terribly high scoring game so this is a really good tile to have you've got bigger plantations here so you've got these three sized ones which give you a great capacity to store things back got this espionage one here which is great because if you're really lagging behind on one of these different tracks but your opponent isn't let's say for
example i had the uh only one upgrade on the ship here but my opponents they had five then i can actually leech off their efforts and take that five out one time so that's a really good thing to kind of fast track on one of the um things you're lagging behind on i got these more versatile ones here you've got ones here that give you an expedition card each round which is really strong this vice king one here is great because it gives you a free upgrade on your furthest behind track and this resupply one that brings in this um this element here to either take any of the resources of your choice equal to what you flipped over and you've got more points here you've got a swap tile which means when you take this one you can swap it for one left on the board to give you that extra flexibility and you've got one here that actually lets you swap a towel or swap this tile for one that's been actually not brought into play in the first place because not every tile is going to show up game after game so before we move on i just wanted to show a few of these expedition cars to show what they're capable of so you can see this one here you can end up just selling spices from your plantations and colonies in order to get straight up money and of course money being a big factor in this game this one here lets you pay money to get the upgrades on your player board rather than playing the spice value so this is a really good way to fast track that if you've got that extra coin in your pocket this one here that means when you upgrade you don't have to pay either spices or ships depending on which version you have that so you get a bit of a discount there this one here means when you colonize instead of just flipping two cards you get to flip three at this one here of course just gives you your basic intake of resources so these are all really useful to have and
additionally if you don't want to play the cards for the action themselves you can actually store them back in your hand bearing in mind the symbol you have here and the more symbols you have of the same type gives you more points based on a sliding scale so another way to get extra points into your pocket so that pretty much shows all the mechanisms and how the game plays let's talk about some thoughts here so first off mechanisms um rudiger dawn is great at what he does and i love the the kind of mix of the action grid here with that auction system so you actually have that kind of point-to-point movement mechanism mixed with what's going to be coming up for auction i've never seen that done before and it's a really good blend of mechanisms that i like quite a lot and it can actually play a big part in how the following round is going to play out because you know you might want to start here as a first player i'm knowing for a fact that one of these other auction tiles have to come up next because you can only ever go adjacent to where you existingly are but the person who places that token is going to be in the kind of power position because they're going to be the one who can acquire that tile for cheaper so not only do you have to focus on which tile you want to claim for yourself because you're going to get a better deal for taking it but also that you're laying the foundation for somebody else to be there so i really do like the way that works and i love the flow of money as well because you can't just win every auction because you're going to be paying or line in the pockets of other players but at the same time you're going to run out of money yourself so it does have a really nice cash flow in this game where sometimes you might even just place a one of your
markers on a particular tile that you know somebody else wants so that will give you a nice big cash injection to keep you going throughout the game and pay for your future bid so i love this grid system it's fantastic it works so so well and it can really um you know really does kind of throw the auction mechanism on its head and can add a new direction to that genre additionally i do like the fact that this isn't just a straight up you know throw your bid in style auction is a one a one-off auction everybody gets to throw their one bit in and then that final player and we'll get to either undercut it by one or choose the pass and that works really well for this style of game i think if it was a straight up you know bid what you want style auction again and again until someone runs out of money then i think that could bog the game down quite a bit and it wouldn't quite feel right if this one this one you really do have to leverage that bit just right so that you can afford it but also you're not giving you the person who's tall that is or person who's controlling that title that really good strong advantage to get that for a really good deal additionally these player boards work so so well so this is pretty much your hub on everything you want to do in the game and i love it when games kind of force you to do everything but you haven't got enough time to do everything and that is one of the main things i took away from goa is how time can really run away from you and you only get eight again eight rounds in the game to get everything done and get as many points as you can and you can't upgrade everything and you know that's why these different action cards can come really um you know play a big part in getting more done and get more bang for your buck which makes again not taking that first
player market even more kind of inviting to do so but yeah i love the fact you have to balance everything so carefully you know you want to have your ships because you need your ships and spices in order to upgrade anything in the first place which is going to be a massive way you're going to get points you need the spices because you need to upgrade everything but you need the storage from the plantations in order to get those spices in the first place of course you need money because you need to keep buying future tiles to keep yourself getting stronger and stronger but maybe you can get by on other tiles you've collected beforehand because you might get an incoming other ways and of course you want to colonize because colonizing gives you way more storage full different spices and will give you a big point swing if you manage to get them all so yeah a lot of good things going on here and i love the way you have to spin all those plates even the colony action which plays a big part in you know a game like this normally when you got a game this calculated and this kind of involved a deep i don't really like pushy like mechanisms in them but this one actually works so so well because you can actually you know invest in getting a base layer or base level of these colonies so you've got a really nice strong platform to start with in the first place you can collect the cards to try and ensure that you get that victory but that pushy like element just adds a little bit more fun into the game and doesn't actually work against it and if you fail you still get compensated by taking a call on your card which could help you in future rounds so yeah it just works well for me and i didn't think it would but it actually does so yeah very happy with how this game works mechanically you know i wouldn't really expect anything less from a designer like rudiger dawn the time investment for goa is pretty much on the money for me this is a 90
minute game which is pretty much my sweet spot for a game like this i certainly don't feel this came out stays as welcome for a second and it does tick along extremely nicely you don't really find yourself losing interest when it's another player's turn because to be honest most of the game you are always invested in what's going on you know what's going to come up next how much you're going to spend are you going to get money for doing so can you afford to do things what resources do you need to hold back and how are you going to spend your three action points you know are you going to investigate more action so you can do that so you're pretty much always in the game on this one you're not going to lose interest once another player's turn because you're going to be so invested in what you're doing and that maybe that extra a little bit of time that you get to mull over your decision is actually going to be a useful thing the player interaction is pretty damn fantastic as you'd expect with euros from this era you know whenever you have an auction there's always going to be some kind of passive player interaction but this one because the money flows from player to player it makes it that more interesting because you know somebody might be sat on a tile that you really want but you got to be cautious that you know if you spend too much money on it then they're you're gonna give them such a strong position for the following tiles but at the same time if you bid too low then they're probably gonna get an absolute steal because they actually get paid one lower than that as well so yeah all the interaction here is just embedded in the game it doesn't feel like it's multiplayer solitaire because again this grid is going to play a big part being first player is so significant because you're really going to have a strong say in which which tiles are going to come up that round so yeah everything is contested over
and um that level of tension and that scarcity of the resources that you want on that tile that you want does shine through so strongly and i love that so let's talk about aesthetics and production so first off this is really kind of synonymous with the era and this game is going back 18 years now at least at the time of this recording um and this these kind of games really do kind of just warm my heart i love the way this game looks and it's got that real throwback euro feel all the cards very simple in what they do there's not a surplus of materials here just very muted very toned back and just fits the kind of game this one is not much confusion in terms of what the different towels do and even the rule book itself really does um lay things out crystal clear so you can quickly clean things up if you do have a little bit of confusion about what the tiles do um the resources themselves are the wooden spices and they should have stickers on them but i've been a bit lazy and not stuck them on yet but yeah these are all good the player balls themselves they are pretty much paper thin which is a bit disappointing but i suppose at the time production wasn't such a big thing as it is now i think the sense of progression in this game is fantastic i can i mentioned before that the time really does feel like it gets away from you in this game eight turns to get everything done and you can't do it but that is really where the attention shines through it makes the game come alive and it ramps up into crescendo towards the end as these bonus actions become more and more valuable and you know you find yourself at the end people are fighting at the beginning of the game people are fighting over money but at this end of the game people are
fighting over actions because they just need that extra action to get that resource that they might want in order to upgrade their playable to get into that next bracket of points yeah i really do love the pacing of this game it does feel just right just so delicately balanced sometimes in terms of how many rounds this one takes what you can do on your turns etcetera so yeah i think this game is just so well played tested and so well-rounded in terms of the game length the actions you can take and the actual points output you can get at the end just brilliantly done the scalability of goa is actually quite a funny one because normally auction games do not work well at two players they are the odd exception of that but this one i would happily play at two players it'll become a lot more kind of cerebral in the opportunity that you leave the other person in terms of the tiles that come up and it'll become a little bit more tighter and you'll be a lot more conscious on what you want your opponent to have or not have so yeah in terms of the scalability i think this game is pretty fantastic so final thoughts on goa so as i said this was really a grail game for me expectations sky high and i'm so happy to see this game delivered and more i think this game is brilliantly executed i pretty much love everything about it you know this is really my jam of game i love auctions i love pushy luck i love this kind of light engine building this all just comes together so harmoniously and this feels like a real classic to me and this is certainly is going to stay in my collection for a long long time to come really proud owner of this game i think if you can come across this one and you do like this era of tight
succinct games then you are going to love it because you know this is a great designer with an amazing pedigree and this is probably one of his best designs that i've played um and it's criminal this is not in print anymore because this one should be still in print still in circulation for all the players who like this kind of game to enjoy because it is an absolute gem of a game that i love i love how you have to do everything in this game there's not enough time to do everything you need the spices you need the money you need the boats you need these expedition cars you want to colonize and you can't do it all but just prioritizing things is where the money is at so love the back and forth love the auction mechanism love that kind of point-to-point movement just no complaints whatsoever and this is going to be a a proud earner of a shield or an elite shield so my highest commendation for goa and i've got no hesitancy to give it that thank you so much for checking out this video if you found it useful or at least somewhat entertaining then please hit like and consider subscribing if you haven't done so already additionally if you wish to support the show because i am a woman operation and i don't get any support from publishers then please consider backing on patreon at patreon.com forward slash chairman of the board where you can back for as little as two pounds per month thank you so much i'll see you next time